Kremlin's Propaganda Review: The West Started the War in Ukraine
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 09. 2023
- Welcome to Fake News: a special look at the bewildering, terrifying and often farcical world of Russian State Propaganda, now back with a new host, Valeria Ratnikova. This week, Russia shifts the blame for the instigation of the war in Ukraine onto the West, and propagandists continue to push the supposed threat of eastward NATO expansion.
If you want to support independent journalism in Russia and help combat state propaganda, follow this link to donate:
tvrain.tv/donate-en/
Follow us on twitter / tvrain_english
#fakenews #tvrain
Thank you TV Rain for all that you do. You give me hope that there are sensible people in Russia who can bring sanity back to the country.
About 20-30%, who are so far doing nothing, except for a handful of individuals, meaning the saboteurs and the freedom fighters. Don't hold your breath.
Thanks God this is a minority! The Russian Federation is and will be free, unlike the garbage and illiterate west full of riots, immigrants, crimes, rude people, Russophobia, aka neo-N4zism. #goPutin #goRussia
NATO didn't reach out to expand, eastern European countries sought to join. Putin didn't understand the nuance.
Putin hopes we don't understand the nuance...
PUTIN EVEN ASKED TOJOIN NATO ,AND CLINTON REFUSED
@@Dobacat Did the US annex mexican Crimea and Donbass?! If so, mexicans must find friends to help them face the imminent US invasion!!
@@Dobacatwhy not? But that would never happen due Mexico and their citizens doesn’t see the east as an ally.
Are they doing so? Are there enormous advantages to Mexico joining a military alliance with China? You see when you people ask these questions, you ask it with an imperialist mindset; to you it doesn’t matter what Mexico thinks, they are subjects, China can do what it wants because it has power, democracy bedamned. That’s not really how sovereign states work particularly one with Mexicos proud history.
Propaganda in Russia is similar to MAGA ideologies.
Fully intertwined!
Same people, same money!
Yes Trump modelled himself on his hero Putin!!
Touché
That’s why the Americans should never vote on Trump again!
Not surprising considering it was proven as a fact that Trump is in bed with Putin by several foreign secret agencies to your FBI. This is why Trump fired half the FBI at some point, because they were about to actually dropkick him out of the white house.
Mindboggling! When you get the breath of how they are spinning the "special military operation." 😂
They *have* to keep the spin going to remain in power.......
if you think the cookies are bad Don't try Putin's koolaid!
Tea or window? 🤣
Austria and Switzerland are much more surrended by Nato countries then russia, and they live perfectly well with it.
Austria and Switzerland are both complicit in Puters war of genocide !
You are such an ignorant fellow. You know nothing about geopolitics and natural resources distribution on earth. In the 90s Russia cooperated extensively with the west and what happened?. The west only used Russia and turned it as a fuel and gas station. Those were that lows in Russia's history. Its the dream of the west to break up Russia into several states just as they did to Yugoslavia and its real. Russia knows what its doing just as the west also knows what they are doing. These Russians demonizing their own country are the weakest links that are easily patronized by the west. They have no idea of what is going on.
Those nations should join NATO since they benefit from its existence.
@@JoeZorzinI am Swiss and you completely miss two things:
1. These 2 countries where „forced“ to it‘s neutral state and did not choose so singlehanded.
2. Switzerland is a direct democracy and people would never accept giving up neutrality even if „we“ could.
@@VINLAND_777neutrality is just letting others die for you
I will never look at cookies the same way again.
They believe their own lies!
New Pinnochios
Excellent video as always…it’s almost funny …yet sad…how easily fooled the average Russian can be!
Propaganda in a closed society (like NK)…can be devastating!
Грустно что тупость Запада приведёт к 3 ей мировой войне ! Видимо Западу плохо жилось что постоянно расширяли НАТО и приближали к Российским границам! Не думайте что всё закончится на Украине, мы вас так же демилитаризуем и денацифицируем как и Украину, ждите мы скоро придём!!!
Я смотрю на ваши передачи и смотрю ваши комментарии. Больные и несчастные украинцы у вас просто промыты мозги ненавистью к Русским. Вы не видите, что на самом деле происходит на Украине и в мире.
It's a mess . Also russians steal toilets and underwear and socks, and they smell bad .
Yes Russia is consumed with nazism and fascism and under Putin has become an orwellian neostalinist imperialist dystopia...
@@user-il6by6ft7q а ты видишь что на самом деле происходит на Украине, Русский. А особенно в мире :) Привет, брат, из солнечного Лиссабонска ♥️
🗽🇺🇸 Great reporting! 🇺🇦🇺🇸 Standing with Ukraine🧑🤝🧑👬👭👫🌻 🫂with much Love from Indiana, USA 🕊️ 🙏
The fact that Putin threatens nuclear war demonstrates how little he cares about his own family let alone anyone else.
Its just a game he would never use nuclear…
The rest of the idiots would not let him push any nuclear buttons.
It’s not that I don’t believe you, but still, could you provide the facts when Putin threatened nuclear war?
have you been living under a rock?@@Kuksha_51
@@Kuksha_51many times… he has used it as a warning to try to get the west to stop supporting Ukraine so he can do what he said he never would do!
Putin's new name...Pinnochio
Loved your coverage - it's so distressing to see interviews of Russian citizens on channels like 1420.
It does the heart good to see sane sensible Russians covering the insane war and Putin and his propagandists.
Best wishes for you and yours.
Russian justice system compromised into quislings, wtever respect there was is lost
Before the war, very few in the West ever thought about Russia. Only those that became addicted to its fossil fuels, weapons and bribes could give a sh*t. After this war is over, even fewer people around the world will think of Russia, because Russian leverage (worthless weapons, less dependence on its fuels, no Wagner) will be almost zero. And, yes, Russia should be broken up and neutered so it no longer poses a threat to its neighbours. It should lose its leadership standing at the UN and all other international bodies.
I'd agree that ideally Russia breaks up in the countries it was before the Soviet Union, but that's quite a big change, if they could just change government that would be a much smaller change without creating a lot of drama and uncertainty for the civilians who clearly dont have a clue what's actually going on in their government. Any step towards improvement would be good, it doesn't have to be the end of Russia.
To be pretty damn blunt, Germany still exists as well, they sure did a good job turning their country around, as much as i do believe that 'Russia shattering' would be good, i also feel like Russia should at least have the opportunity to make amends, it's obviously gonna be a long process and its going to cost Russia a bunch of money (for repairs), but it should be possible, we've forgiven countries for much worse.
That would be interesting and a bit scary at the same time with all their nukes.I doubt whether republics with surrender their nukes like Ukraine did.
Russia sould be punished for worldwide atrocities as Vietnam, Korea, Laos, Cambodia, Bosnia, Kosovo, Panama, Iraq, Yugoslavia, Afghanistan, Somalia, Sirya, Libya... Oh wait those were good invsions against ev*l people. Do remember they had growth of 1.8% while your paras*tic econmy is in free fall. Can you buy meat and egs? Can you find one street without homeles?
Agreed. Russia is a sham, wasting so many resources and land
@@suicidalbanananana Germany was utterly destroyed, militarily, before it turned itself around, Berlin overrun, their parliament burned to the ground. I don't think anyone in the West thinks this will happen to Russia. The war will likely destroy Russia economically, but the goal here is only to force the Russians out of Ukraine, which will also probably lead to the end of Putin's regime. Whether the Russian people decide to try to reform Russia or not after that will be up to them.
Thank you TV Rain and please stay safe!
Ah! That cookie monster secene had me in stiches! 🤣
Thank you for your work!
You are very beatiful, inside and out. Thank you for your truthful reporting and analyses of what is really going on with Kremlin propaganda.
I blame the popcorn industry. They just had to find a way to get us all gathered around our TVs, tablets& phones having a 🍿laugh🍿at the russian Federation. 🍿🍿🍿😂😂!
Slava Ukraini 💛🇺🇦💙💪🏻
Especially when their own illegal army was attacking THEM, and some of their legal armies tip top brass was in on it. It doesn't get funnier than that. Russia is a caricature of a nation.
Full of admiration for your good journalism. It is a pleasure watching your channel.
Thank you for a Russian’s perspective on this horrible Russian initiated conflict. I mourn every Russian life and every Ukranian life lost at the hands of Putin and the propaganda machine.
I'd like to be compassionate about Russian soldiers dying too, except I believe trustworthy media about all the rape and torture and Russian soldiers laughing.
'A U.N. report says Russian forces committed an array of war crimes, including summary executions, torture, rape and other acts of sexual violence against Ukrainian civilians.' What could be the 'other acts of sexual violence' aside from rape? Perhaps the rape of children?
Since when have you mourned every life lost?
If from 2022, then you are eight years late.
Since 2014, Russia has called for a peaceful resolution to the conflict.
Russia proposed the Minsk agreements, the implementation of which was guaranteed by Germany and France.
But as Angela Merkel later said, Ukraine did not intend to implement the Minsk agreements, but used this time to prepare its army for a new war.
Then Zelensky made a tour to the USA, Britain and EU countries, where he received guarantees of support, after which he refused to implement the Minsk agreements and began hostilities again.
@@Kuksha_51lol…where do get your info ,from all the stupidness coming from your way it’s probably russian state dictatorship TV there lunacy is more common then sanity.
How did Russia implement the Minsk agreements. Did they withdraw their forces from the territories? Did they carry out free and fair elections? Did they prevent ‘separatists’ from bombing or shelling Ukrainian held territory? Did they stop anti-Ukrainian propaganda?
We could go through the entire Minsk agreement and there is no part which Russia upheld.
The Minsk agreements were a Russian delaying tactic. Their forces had failed to take and hold large parts of eastern Ukraine twice. They used the time to attempt to rebuild their forces, consolidate power in Belarus and plan for a new invasion. They never negotiated in good faith, just like every international agreement they signed up to. The EU and the US were naive to believe the Minsk II was the end.
@@Kuksha_51 Take your shity lies to Russians who believe such bullshit. You show to the whole world how barbaric and stupid Russians are. Dont Russians have any honour?
Kerp the good work guys. Slava Ukrajini from Slovenian brother
So true Leaders start Wars !
Can’t believe we spend trillions on weapons when all I took was cookies? 😂😂😂
It expands so you can't attack them 😆, you're the problem lol. Pretty sure they kno that 😆
Thank you for clear information about the Russian invasion!
Living a lie never turns out well.
It was great!!
can i get the recipe of mrs nulands cookies of mass destruction?
victoria nuland's ''cookies'' spured on the revolution ,her cookies must be really good ! lmfao
You best not have any, you might end up overthrowing the government! 😂
The magic cookie theory explains everything. Yeah, that’s the ticket.
Until she played the clips and put Cookie Monster into the video, I thought I wasn’t hearing the word correctly and was just nodding my head pretending like I understood. Now I get the joke, but still fail to understand
When watching the protests i remember thinking it would not be long before the Russian army appeared. Those protests were too frightening for the Kremlin to ignore and also gave them something to build a narrative around.
See Putin's address to the NATO Russia Council in May 2002 in Rome. He was perfectly OK with NATO expansion, including the Baltic States.
Still impressed by the propaganda? Protests belong to democracies.
Fair to me your comments....fm Constanța, Romania with love
second best army in the world is now second best in Ukraine- how they explaine it to people?
Fantastic channel deserves to do very well!
NATO rejected Russias application. A military alliance needs an enemy after all
Good Job - Paulo From Brazil!
Apart from every thing you have said is correct , it is a pleasure to have it rolled out in chronological order to understand the magnitude of bullshit that comes out of Moscow. Thank you. regards Wally
@@Anti-Russia WTF are you talking about?
Exactly, but you can tell he or she is anti-Russian, by their moniker. :-/ Russians truly SUCK at propaganda...and fighting wars. @@gaoxiaen1
Brilliant ! Keep up the good honest work
Sadly, Russia is sounding more like North Korea and Iran.
Great presentation. Each of the points discussed, I have seen in other indepedndent sources.
What I now have to do is to collect and collate my notes under the headings to which they apply. Thank you very much for such a clearly presented collection of material.
Actually very pathetic how they believe this b.s.😈😡
Fantastic!!! Glad that tou guys are still out there to show us the real version of Russia.
"Z" is the Russian "Swastika"! Slava Ukraine!
Wow great job
I wouldn't mind one of those cookies.
Clear presentation but I had to see it 4 times before it was received by my brain.
The first 3 times I was to much derived by your beauty
The job of the Christian church is not as a privileged propagandist of foreign imperialism and extortion.
Quality.
It's huilo.😊 good work.
People get the government they deserve. Russia deserves their government. Nobody else on the planet deserves Russian government - it needs to be resisted at all costs - Ukraine is doing a wonderful, if lonely, job of it.
Thank you for an amazing video
This reminds me of the following story: it takes place in a madhouse. One of the inmates, a man who has lost his mind, wonders what could be behind the high surrounding walls. He takes a ladder and climbs to the top of the wall. He sees a lot of people, coming and going. He says to himself: "It really looks like there are a lots of people in there". That is what these Russian conspiracy theorists make me think of when they tell us that it was the West that attacked Russia. Delusional or liers. Or both. All options are bad.
What can you say about missile defense in the Czech Republic?
@@Kuksha_51lol…what missile defense?
@@crissdiamond1907American missile defense system which was deployed in the Czech Republic.
This is a threat for Russia.
The US has stated that this missile defense system will be used against Iran.
Russia proposed to jointly use the Gabala radar station, which is located in Azerbaijan, which borders Iran.
But the US refused.
Then Russia asked for written guarantees that the missile defense system in the Czech Republic would not be used against Russia.
But the US again refused.
That’s why I asked a question to a topic starter guy who states that the West does not threaten Russia in any way.
@@Kuksha_51 A defense system is a threat? Is your brain melting Ivan?
@@reddix435I'm not Ivan, I'm Kuksha.
This is easy to understand if you can read.
Yes, missile defense is a threat because it changes the balance of power.
That is why there have always been agreements between the United States and Russia on the deployment of missile defense.
Those must be very good cookies.
I loved the Cookie Monster:)Elmo
I was waiting for Cookie Monster! 😂😂😂
SHOW The world 🌎 and DISPLAY your power making peace and coexist with US.
Damn. Now I want those cookies. 😂😂
Carry on mister Putin❤❤❤❤❤❤
So excited for tv rain on CZcams:)
Much respect, Ms. Rastikova.
Sovolyov "....and London" but, wait until my son who has been a member of the "Alternative Party" scene departs, and returns home. At home he will recommence studying, so he can join the sons of most prominent citizens to avoid being drafted..
A change of power… yes, the head of the Azov battalion sat on the presidents seat with a machine gun. You can see this in a Vice documentary on Ukraine from 2017, still available on CZcams
At the 2:42 mark, I see an ad on Russian TV, for a product with English words on it:
"ICE SNACK SANDWICHES"
It’s interesting that the military guy at the start of the video was recording it on an iPhone. Anything wrong with a Russian manufactured smartphone?
Russia stop this horrible war
I heard that NATO also forced the cccp to invade Afghanistan in 79
Dear....the clowns in Russia get too much attention...........ignoring would be the best mean to silence them...
Thank you for a clear and amusing explanation of what a horrible thing my country (US) is doing to those saintly Russians via the foolish and unlucky (though sometimes Nazi) Ukrainians.
Blame the cookies, of course😀
The Victor doesn't need to rely on propaganda.
Thank you for showing this 🙏..i hope that some russians can get this in their Zombie state of mijn .. praying for ukraine 🇺🇦🙏🇺🇦 from Holland 💓💓
TV rain just expressed a different opinion than Putin's. This does not automatically make Putin's view wrong.
But Russia and the USA have a border anyway.
Фйк ньюз, это Дождь!
Russian people must act and send putin and his colleagues to Haag.
Here in Africa we no very well the west and America starts ths War
Like your informative channel! Please keep at it!😊👍
If only everyone who supports Putin’s war watched this and had some common sense.
Great channel!!👍🏻Keep the vids coming, they’re always informative and well presented👍🏻👍🏻
Excellent English, Valeria!👍
Oh - thank you for helping me to understand. I thought it was ruSSia who was the aggressor, but now I see the light.
Recommend they consult the Unionist party in Northern Ireland. They even blame cat farts on the Irish Republic....and all their supporters believe them 😅😅
I love this channel. ❤ Even though they admit that it’s fake news, I still watch it just to see all the dumb ideas that Banderas believe.
It was all Victoria Nulands fault. Handing out chocolate and sandwiches is the same as invading another country with a kalashnikov
I wrote that before tv Rain brought it up
Can you make a short of the cookie part please 😂😂
Russia is on a slow death. I give Russia 6 months of life before complete destraction 😂😂😂
Ironically, it isn't Russia itself that is the problem. It is the people running the show. The Russian people need to find a way to rid themselves of this stupidly pointless Leninist psyche, and find a way to a fresh start......
That's a pretty bold statement.
Not 6 years, but 6 months?
Destruction by April 2024?
Are you sure about this?
May they rot 👍🌞
russia has to be stopped or it will never end, great video
Yes, I mean real facts are so yesterday aren't they?
So according to pootin,Ukraine invaded themselves the parallells of pootin with hitler are becoming closer i would suggest that he is 2/3 hitler and 1/3 stalin in outlook and how he has behaved since his invasion of Ukraine.
Min. 3:30 - What kind of b... is she telling not mentioning the telefonleak of Victoria Nuland with US Diplomat in Kiev.
You also can read the transcript of BBC:
Nuland: I think Yats is the guy who's got the economic experience, the governing experience. He's the... what he needs is Klitsch and Tyahnybok on the outside. He needs to be talking to them four times a week, you know. I just think Klitsch going in... he's going to be at that level working for Yatseniuk, it's just not going to work.
Pyatt: Yeah, no, I think that's right. OK. Good. Do you want us to set up a call with him as the next step?
.....
Jonathan Marcus: An intriguing insight into the foreign policy process with work going on at a number of levels: Various officials attempting to marshal the Ukrainian opposition; efforts to get the UN to play an active role in bolstering a deal; and (as you can see below) the big guns waiting in the wings - US Vice-President Joe Biden clearly being lined up to give private words of encouragement at the appropriate moment.
Pyatt: Yeah I saw that.
Nuland: OK. He's now gotten both Serry and [UN Secretary General] Ban Ki-moon to agree that Serry could come in Monday or Tuesday. So that would be great, I think, to help glue this thing and to have the UN help glue it and, you know, Fuck the EU.
If the Russian people actually believe that, then they are scarier than I thought. However lucky for me I believe the Russian people are intelligent enough to know better.
20% are smart 20% are dumb as dogshit and miss the USSR that suited them best. The other 60% dont care or have been raised to think they cant change anything anyway. Unfortunately all the suffering is done by the lower 20% so nothing will change until it gets 1917 style bad.
Why haven’t you mentioned that the EU also didn’t want to sign the agreement with Yankovich? It wasn’t a one way street.
2008 год - попытка принятия Грузии в НАТО, итог - война и отторжение Абхазии и Южной Осетии, 2014 год - попытка принятия Украины в НАТО в результате военная операция и отторжение Крыма, в продолжение СВО
Judging by all the smiles Russians support the narrative.
Russian propaganda is funny as hell, very entertaining.
Watch some TVP if you don't. They always put clown noses on the Solvyov crowd, and in one case ran a laugh track, which was friggin hilarious. I was watching it in bed on the laptop and was trying not to make any noise, while shaking and laughing to tears, because my wife was asleep beside me, and she doesn't take very kindly to being awakened that way, not that I blame her. I have learned to NEVER watch Ze Frank's True Facts under those conditions. If you haven't seen it, go take a look, but not while your other half is asleep beside you. You have been warned. It is some of the funniest stuff on the internet. :-)
It's also dangerous....
It's not funny at all, because people actually believe it...
They don’t have to believe propaganda from their government, not in the 21st century with the internet & VPN servers to get around government censoring, they believe it because they want to, they want to think Russia is a powerful country with influence in the world and not the pariah state with a garbage military it truly is.
❤❤❤
stiil wodering how its going those battlamages what they training in russia?
saw one video and then dead silence
Liars are the cause of the deep depression in Russia.