The Many I's

/ martinbutler
Understanding Gurdjieff's Concept of 'Many I's
In this video, Martin Butler explores the teachings of G.I. Gurdjieff, focusing on the concept of "many I's." Gurdjieff proposed that we are not a single, unified person, but rather a collection of different "I's" or identities that emerge based on our circumstances. Martin argues that this idea can be misleading; rather than having many I's, we have an infinite number of I's. Each moment and situation brings out a different aspect of ourselves, shaped by our psychological conditioning and external stimuli.
Butler emphasizes that the goal of Gurdjieff's work is not to subjugate these I's, as this would be an act of violence against oneself. Instead, he advocates for understanding our nature and the reasons behind our behaviors. This understanding can lead to the formation of a "permanent I" or the "I of understanding," which observes our actions and reactions with impartiality and calmness.
This video delves into the notion that we are automatons, reacting automatically to our environment, and challenges the idea of free will. Butler stresses that achieving a permanent I involves nonviolent self-observation and understanding, aligning with the idea that true progress in self-work is marked by the absence of internal conflict and violence.
Join Martin Butler as he provides insight into how to navigate the complexities of Gurdjieff's teachings, aiming for a deeper understanding of oneself without the pitfalls of misconceived notions and violent methods.