She never deserved anything bad that happened to her. She wasn't a bad person. All she ever did was love someone whom her father thought was disgusting. I was glad when he got his.
Well I’m not saying she deserves this but in the begging she did say that if bet and dot where her kids she would have drowned them in the bath tub she didn’t deserve this but she’s not the bestest person ever sorry if I’m offensive
@@mrbubzcrack6698 ok but she literally changed a new leaf after this was done to her….so she WASNT the best but became a better person, and died from it. Sooo don’t always look at the negative, look how Elsa turned out 💀
this was by far the sickest thing that happened if you really think about it... a father doing something like that to his child... but great addition to the show, it was such a cool episode.
I can't help but feel for Penny. Her whole life was changed in only a few short scenes. I swear to god is someone ever did that to me or anything like that I'm fucking making sure they didn't walk away alive.
This scene upset me so much, especially when he couldn’t wait to see the look on her face. That’s pure sadism. He’s an evil father. So glad Penny got her revenge!
No, you misunderstand. He wanted to get the mirror. He wanted HER to see what he had done to her face. He didn’t care she was already in physical agony he wanted the mental/psychological pain too.
Her dad laughs at her agony, Paul cries for it and blames himself even though it wasn't his fault. I'd rather be hideous and be with a man who cares about me, than be beautiful and be with someone who doesn't care. Besides, the hair will grow back
What really gets to me is that she barely even reacted when she went back to Paul. She didn’t even say anything or blame him, she just wanted to be with him. 🥺
And this is when you notice that talent really runs in family i mean she's a really a good actress like her mother (for those who don't know who is her mother is Meryl Streep )
Manara Michele I honestly don’t care how talented that women is. Meryl Streep is a rape apologist and a hypocrite. Her daughter is innocent in all this but I can’t stand that mother of hers.
Deffinitely one of the most fucked up scenes in the entire show. This shit stayed with me for days after I first saw this like god damn that is brutal.
t.He could have kicked her out and told her to never come back.A carnival is on a travelling circuit.She would be long gone.But the evil part was the joy he took in it.He could not wait for her to wake up and see herself
"A man like me needs to have astounding reputation so that people trust me." *proceeds to visibly mutilate his daughter* The lack of logic in favour of the shock factor in this show is astounding.
Vilkku in doing that he essentially disowned her. After she said she was going to be with Paul she did half the work but he completed it. Like he said, he was going to everything he could to make sure no one knew she was his. After he did that he removed any responsibility he had over her, and no one was going to find out he did it.
why would her being w/ Paul hurt her dad's image? and how did they manage to get her to agree to take a nap to tattoo her like that? how can you sleep through that?
Lack of logic? More Fridge Brilliance/Frigde Horror... Nobody would recognize her and even now, people who undergo similar procedures have their sanities often questioned by others, so it would be his word, the word of a respected man against the word of a freak, something society looks down on and of whom they would probably thinks that is insane. Nobody would believe if she said he was her father, on the contrary, she would be seen as a delusional liar, who abuse a poor man who suffered the mysterious disappearance of his daughter... Why do you think she didn't go the cops immediately after they had mutilated her?
What happened to her father was soooo satisfying. Bathed in boiling tar omg one of the most satisfying scenes for me alongside: Ivy's death in Cult Lana's escape in Asylum Dandy's death scene in Freakshow
watching this scene is captivating but it actually makes me sick at my stomach. It’s a similar feeling to the feeling I got when I watch the clerk or whatever lady get her head shaved in Wolf Of Wall Street
I watched everything. It is close to impossible to scare/traumatize me. But this scene was terrifying. This is AHS for me. The only other AHS scene which made me feel the same way was in Season 2 (Asylum) where the doctor processed the poor women…
I think the worst part about this is that the rest of her life she is going to be looked at as a freak, I would rather die than have something like this done to me...
1:50 Yay! It is my friend Skitch! He actually has given me 5 tattoos ... he tattooed his own face and practiced on himself before he worked on anyone else 💖 oh... and he is a really sweet guy.
I had a similar thing happen in one of my stories. I’ve been writing stories about my toy collection, and one of the stories going on is my old Maleficent dragon trying to depose my Anakin Skywalker figure, who is my favorite childhood toy, as the leader of the toys through brainwashing the other toys into believing that Jedi are evil and Anakin doesn’t deserve to lead because not only was he Darth Vader, but because _she_ was actually my favorite toy because I basically made her an evil version of me. Most of the toys don’t follow her, but there are a fringe group of the toys who do, which included a pull string Rick Sanchez doll. She forced him to join her, threatening to use her connections to destroy all of the Mortys in the world. After conversing with my Geoffrey the Giraffe plush, he realized that she couldn’t possibly do it, so he quit. Angered, Maleficent knocked him out and painted a three clawed scar on his right eye, while also painting his pupil grey, blinding him in that eye. “Think of it this way, you’re unique now.”, she said. “Instead of just being Rick from the show, you’re the Rick who stood up to Maleficent and lost.” After that, Rick joins Anakin’s side, and vows revenge on the dragon who disfigured him.
It’s cute though how she and that other guy complete one another - his whole body is covered in tattoos except for his face, whereas the only part of her body covered in tattoos is her face 😊
The logic in him is so stupid, she could literally say that his father did that to him and his reputation would be even worse, even if she couldn’t press charges or anything
@@SC-dm1ct - because in that day and age, at best she'd be laughed out of the police station, and at worst, arrested and locked up in an asylum. She'd be victim blamed. E.g. "Such a horrible thing he did to his daughter, but what choice did he have? She was a slut who was going to live in sin at a freak show. That poor, poor father..." etc, etc
@@justinwillingale2086 Well, there's always murder. Sorry, but you don't cross people like that and expect them to not murder you in horrible ways later. Especially not if they know where you sleep. Not saying people don't, just that 24 hours wouldn't have gone by before he was dead.
ClaraDash well the male cried because he loved her (im not sure I have not gotten that far in the show) and the female cried because of what happened to her
In mordern times she will go on to be am alternate beauty artist(model) or get laser therapy to remove those tatoos. Hope that makes you people sleep batter at night .
She never deserved anything bad that happened to her. She wasn't a bad person. All she ever did was love someone whom her father thought was disgusting. I was glad when he got his.
Well I’m not saying she deserves this but in the begging she did say that if bet and dot where her kids she would have drowned them in the bath tub she didn’t deserve this but she’s not the bestest person ever sorry if I’m offensive
She did deserve it! Everyone deserves what they get! I'd bust her lip if she talked back to me! I would've done worse to that homewrecker!
@@mrbubzcrack6698 ok but she literally changed a new leaf after this was done to her….so she WASNT the best but became a better person, and died from it. Sooo don’t always look at the negative, look how Elsa turned out 💀
@@unicornunicorn3249 man I’m so sorry bro o wrote that when I was like 13-14ish
@@mrbubzcrack6698no you’re not offensive. I think she learned a lot after loving Paul
this was by far the sickest thing that happened if you really think about it... a father doing something like that to his child... but great addition to the show, it was such a cool episode.
Evy Bakker this scene scared the piss and shit out of me 😨
I can't help but feel for Penny. Her whole life was changed in only a few short scenes. I swear to god is someone ever did that to me or anything like that I'm fucking making sure they didn't walk away alive.
Reality is scarier trust me.
It's so dark.
E Visser out of all that happend on ahs i found this the most horrific because its her father that did this
This scene upset me so much, especially when he couldn’t wait to see the look on her face. That’s pure sadism. He’s an evil father. So glad Penny got her revenge!
Me Too
No, you misunderstand. He wanted to get the mirror. He wanted HER to see what he had done to her face. He didn’t care she was already in physical agony he wanted the mental/psychological pain too.
@@healgoththat’s what they said?
She was so beautiful she never deserved any of that ...
Beautiful or not, NOBODY deserves that.
I feel so bad for Penny! She just wanted to be loved..
puppy101 happy She was loved. She just needed to find her people.
Her dad laughs at her agony, Paul cries for it and blames himself even though it wasn't his fault. I'd rather be hideous and be with a man who cares about me, than be beautiful and be with someone who doesn't care. Besides, the hair will grow back
What really gets to me is that she barely even reacted when she went back to Paul. She didn’t even say anything or blame him, she just wanted to be with him. 🥺
This scene was so sick
And this is when you notice that talent really runs in family i mean she's a really a good actress like her mother (for those who don't know who is her mother is Meryl Streep )
Manara Michele I honestly don’t care how talented that women is.
Meryl Streep is a rape apologist and a hypocrite.
Her daughter is innocent in all this but I can’t stand that mother of hers.
Spencer Bowden THANK YOU! I’m tired of not only rapists getting a pass for “talent” but also their allies. It’s sick.
Spencer Bowden who did she rape?
Felicia I believe you misheard me.
She is not a rapist she is a rape apologist.
As in she defends a guilty rapist.
Was just about to comment this!
I just can't imagine a father doing that to his own daughter
Cade Griffith it happens
Father's always honor kill their daughters in the third world country's.
Baby u should believe that humans are the worst creatures of God believe me
That evil savage!
@@nicholdsouza6482 Honor killings aren't reserved solely for 3rd world countries.
Deffinitely one of the most fucked up scenes in the entire show. This shit stayed with me for days after I first saw this like god damn that is brutal.
Same here
It actually made me sick to my stomach at the time and still a scene that sticks with me.
t.He could have kicked her out and told her to never come back.A carnival is on a travelling circuit.She would be long gone.But the evil part was the joy he took in it.He could not wait for her to wake up and see herself
Meryl Streep's daughter everyone
Andrew Blue... Yes she is!
Andrew Blue that's cool. I didn't know that
this was by far scariest moment on show horrifying
I just realized she played in coven as the witch who got fed up with the axe man and decided to get the coven to kill him. Cool.
I hate him so fucking much. She was beautiful. She does not deserve that.
This scene was so disturbing... Such an underrated season
"I think you mistake my pride for vanity."
Excellent writing.
At least the freaks have a heart and understand what's she's going through.
"A man like me needs to have astounding reputation so that people trust me."
*proceeds to visibly mutilate his daughter*
The lack of logic in favour of the shock factor in this show is astounding.
Vilkku in doing that he essentially disowned her. After she said she was going to be with Paul she did half the work but he completed it. Like he said, he was going to everything he could to make sure no one knew she was his. After he did that he removed any responsibility he had over her, and no one was going to find out he did it.
why would her being w/ Paul hurt her dad's image? and how did they manage to get her to agree to take a nap to tattoo her like that? how can you sleep through that?
oooh19 she might of fainted
Lack of logic? More Fridge Brilliance/Frigde Horror... Nobody would recognize her and even now, people who undergo similar procedures have their sanities often questioned by others, so it would be his word, the word of a respected man against the word of a freak, something society looks down on and of whom they would probably thinks that is insane. Nobody would believe if she said he was her father, on the contrary, she would be seen as a delusional liar, who abuse a poor man who suffered the mysterious disappearance of his daughter...
Why do you think she didn't go the cops immediately after they had mutilated her?
People are not always logical. I can see this happening
I will never complain about my father ever again.
Wow, father of the year.
She didn't deserve any of this ffs I'm so glad that she had a happy afterlife and got married to that guy she loved
What happened to her father was soooo satisfying. Bathed in boiling tar omg one of the most satisfying scenes for me alongside:
Ivy's death in Cult
Lana's escape in Asylum
Dandy's death scene in Freakshow
watching this scene is captivating but it actually makes me sick at my stomach. It’s a similar feeling to the feeling I got when I watch the clerk or whatever lady get her head shaved in Wolf Of Wall Street
I’m not surprised that Penny’s father is one of the most hated characters of AHS
This scene is sick
Can you please upload the scene when they get their vendetta on penny's father and put him in tad and feathers?
Izzy C it's already uploaded
Izzy C. Its uploaded. I just watched it😬😬😬
I hate him she should’ve cut off his penis, because a man that does that to his daughter has no balls.
one of the saddest things ive ever seen in my life. father deserves the worst fate imaginable
I was sobbing the first time I saw this
This dad makes me laugh😂it shows how crazy he is
Lee Tergesen proving his impeccable acting skills 👌
The father is a frigging monster.
This is litteraly my biggest fear
I watched everything. It is close to impossible to scare/traumatize me. But this scene was terrifying. This is AHS for me. The only other AHS scene which made me feel the same way was in Season 2 (Asylum) where the doctor processed the poor women…
I’m glad when he saw her he didn’t call her a freak called her hurtful things and just hugged her
THAT IS REALLY SCARY LOOKING!! CAN'T SLEEP NOW!!°^°
Paul is awesome
I think the worst part about this is that the rest of her life she is going to be looked at as a freak, I would rather die than have something like this done to me...
At least she has people who excepted her as family after her father kicked her out, and someone who still loves her even after what happened.
@@eon5428 *accepted , but yes i agree
Oz really did mess up Tobias Beecher's head!
Lol
a narcissist at it's finest. it's hard for one to see this as abuse in reality tbh ):
U goin to have to kill me to stop me
Wow giving him ideas
Great idea
This scene is very similar to the scene where Dr Arden mutilates Shelley... Both scenes make me sick...
I love this season so much
God damn that this season was so underrated. The writers created such evil. Only pray that people like this don’t walk this earth.
Holy shit! That's Tobias Beecher
I hate him but not as much as I hate Dandy Mott for killing innocent freaks, instead of admitting he went mad with power.
I was so glad when Penny got her revenge on her father by tarring and feathering him.
The way he was singing was hilarious, wish my father paid for free tattoo work.
This guy talks about being an electrician likes he's the friggin president, like damn dude you ain't that special
1:50 Yay! It is my friend Skitch! He actually has given me 5 tattoos ... he tattooed his own face and practiced on himself before he worked on anyone else 💖 oh... and he is a really sweet guy.
I had a similar thing happen in one of my stories. I’ve been writing stories about my toy collection, and one of the stories going on is my old Maleficent dragon trying to depose my Anakin Skywalker figure, who is my favorite childhood toy, as the leader of the toys through brainwashing the other toys into believing that Jedi are evil and Anakin doesn’t deserve to lead because not only was he Darth Vader, but because _she_ was actually my favorite toy because I basically made her an evil version of me. Most of the toys don’t follow her, but there are a fringe group of the toys who do, which included a pull string Rick Sanchez doll. She forced him to join her, threatening to use her connections to destroy all of the Mortys in the world. After conversing with my Geoffrey the Giraffe plush, he realized that she couldn’t possibly do it, so he quit. Angered, Maleficent knocked him out and painted a three clawed scar on his right eye, while also painting his pupil grey, blinding him in that eye. “Think of it this way, you’re unique now.”, she said. “Instead of just being Rick from the show, you’re the Rick who stood up to Maleficent and lost.”
After that, Rick joins Anakin’s side, and vows revenge on the dragon who disfigured him.
I swear to God this scene made so mad I started to scream ugh 😤😤😤
She was so beautiful I felt so bad for her
It’s cute though how she and that other guy complete one another - his whole body is covered in tattoos except for his face, whereas the only part of her body covered in tattoos is her face 😊
This genuinely terrified me
This part always made my stomach turn
this was so hard to watch ;;-;;
honestly if i was in her shoes I never would have went home period!
Well he is not getting the dad of the year award, that's for sure LOL!!!
they wanted to recreate shelly's "clipped wings" on dr ardens lab table reveal so bad
Great choice for Dad. Lee Tergesen is underrated.
To think there's people running around that would do this to themselves voluntarily...
Can you upload the scene where Paul and Penny are talking in her bedroom and then her dad walks in?
The logic in him is so stupid, she could literally say that his father did that to him and his reputation would be even worse, even if she couldn’t press charges or anything
Why couldn't she press charges?
@@SC-dm1ct - because in that day and age, at best she'd be laughed out of the police station, and at worst, arrested and locked up in an asylum. She'd be victim blamed. E.g. "Such a horrible thing he did to his daughter, but what choice did he have? She was a slut who was going to live in sin at a freak show. That poor, poor father..." etc, etc
@@SC-dm1ct it was the 40s
@@justinwillingale2086 Well, there's always murder. Sorry, but you don't cross people like that and expect them to not murder you in horrible ways later. Especially not if they know where you sleep. Not saying people don't, just that 24 hours wouldn't have gone by before he was dead.
@@SC-dm1ct what I mean is woman we’re property to men pretty much as it is mentioned in the show
Me alegra pensar que ese señor acabaría deforme el resto de sus días.
This scene and shelly being mutilated are the worst scenes in ahs
this scene always has me a little lost..so how do u go from standing having a conversation to all of sudden passed out and getting tattooed?
Sandra Yeung maybe they drugged her or knocked her out
LORI•IS•DOPE but was there no resistence?
Sandra Yeung I don’t know bb :(
It's her against two grown men. I doubt they had any trouble subduing and drugging her.
Ngl though it is a really fucked up thing happen to herI liked Paul’s reaction as he hugs her and cries
This is what happens when Tobias Beecher left OZ 😂😂
Did penny even try to fight back? Or did they like knock her out then do it?
He’s so sadistic it’s gross.
Happy Father's Day!
Parents can be so cruel
Happy Father's Day!!!!
Does anyone know what the name of this episode is
Test of strength
Grace Gummer wow
this traumatize me
Is the artist the same one who tatooed Paul.
the dad was Tobias in the series OZ (hbo) he has range but def a villain looks better on him
They had a happy ending at least albeit in death
Beecher!
Now see if she lived in the age of tattoo removal this could have been all reversed.
He gets what coming to him
Yep
Paul was do handsome!
click here to watch eve get revenge on her farther > czcams.com/video/iYp01unu_mI/video.html
There's always foundation 😂😂
oh uh wow
U go back for ur stuff w/ the cops & get out
why her cry in the minute 3:45 ?
sorry for my inglish i talk spanish
ClaraDash well the male cried because he loved her (im not sure I have not gotten that far in the show) and the female cried because of what happened to her
Porque el estuvò la razòn de que el padre de la chica queriò repudiar su hija
ok gracias
:)
Hola
Were you there again with HIM?
Ngl this is one of the worst things I’ve seen this show did penny was a good person and her father did something horrific to her
Is Penny the same girl as the contortionist at the beginning? This is confusing me
Whyyyy she was so freaking g beautiful😭😭😭😭😭😭. That is really messed up👿
Absolutely disgusting. Hoe can someone do that to someone else???
Damn oz really fucked up Tobias Beecher
Its just a prank bro!
1:40 he has cute eyes
In mordern times she will go on to be am alternate beauty artist(model) or get laser therapy to remove those tatoos. Hope that makes you people sleep batter at night .
Its tobias!!!!!!!!!!!
I know this is late but can’t she put makeup on or get the tattoos removed right
It takes place in the like the past before that was really a big thing you could do
I mean maybe now lol but back then it wasn’t probably gonna fly with primitive make up