Dr. Phil: Man Accused of Murder Hears Polygraph Results
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 02. 2013
- Hear Kelly's polygraph results.
Read more: www.drphil.com/shows/show/1972
Dr. Phil tells compelling stories about real people. The Dr. Phil Show is an American daytime talk show and TV series with host and personality Dr. Phil McGraw, who offers advice from his experience as a psychologist. The show provides the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television. For over a decade, Dr. McGraw has used the show's platform to make psychology accessible to the general public by addressing important personal and social issues. Here on the Dr. Phil CZcams channel, you will find the best moments, highlights, and segments from the TV show. We upload new videos every day, so make sure you subscribe and ring the bell for all notifications, so you don't miss a single one.
Full episodes of the Dr. Phil Show premiere every weekday on CBS, with a new season premiering every fall in 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023. Each full episode contains an interview or multiple interviews with doctors, teens, families, parents, kids, and more. The executive producers are Phil McGraw and showrunner Oprah Winfrey of OWN. Dr. Phil is the top-rated daytime talk show attracting millions of viewers every day alongside other talk shows, including The Ellen Show with Ellen DeGeneres, The Dr. Oz Show, The Kelly Clarkson Show, and The Steve Wilkos Show. Dr. Phil makes regular appearances on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, Jimmy Kimmel Live, and The Late Late Show with James Corden. Dr. Phil has also done crossovers with 90 Day Fiancé and Inside Edition.
Do you want to be on the show? bit.ly/BeOnDrPhilShow
www.drphil.com
Facebook: / drphilshow
Twitter: / drphil
Instagram: / drphil
TikTok: / drphil
#DrPhil #PhilMcGraw #DrPhilShow - Zábava
The hair under his lip is killing me
It's the lower lip that's getting me....
Plot twists: it’s his teeth
Guilty of felony level facial hair.
It hides his BS lol
He's getting ready for prison life!
He looks like he’s trying to bully the polygraph guy with a glare.
That is exactly what he tried to do, bully the polygraph guy.
@@paulcolburn3855 yep he was like “ you’re next “
The polygraph examiner is an ex FBI agent so I don't think he felt too intimidated by him. Lol
S
1000%
He's extremely calm for someone who's "falsely" being accused of murder. If I didn't do it, the polygraph said otherwise I would not have such a calm tone
@Manifesting Leo Goddess cus he did it obvs
Yep.that's because he's a narcissist!!
When you are sociopath, you don't feel guilty
@@carriea8165 EXACTLY!
He was raging, not calm.
RIP Jack, you were one of the best at polygraphs, and you were honest and fair regardless of whether the person who you were examining was a pile of garbage like this dude
He died?!?!?:(
@@danaellis3861 yeah. He died in 2018
He was also very articulate.
Yeah pancreatic cancer
Noooooo.. I came hear to comment that he is so amazing.
That anger in his eyes was deadly
You can see him change, after the results and that look... Those ladies better not even end up alone with him
I’m afraid for the safety of those two women. He’s going to kill them.
Nah I think they can handle him.
Why go on dr Phil after getting away with murder
Confidence. Thinking he’s invincible. Cockiness in his ability to lie.
Or he's innocent
@@joogullae3456 either way he is free
@@ryanguercio7061 he’s in prison probably most people pursue court after polygraph results
@@joogullae3456 Stupid comment!
That thousand mile glare 😭
Looks like he did it 🥺
I've no education in this field, but I think what Tim Roth in Lie to me series (although (in my opinion) very often very unrealistic) said is true - when people lie, they often stare at you - to see, if you believe them.
Don't you mean Thousand Island Dressing?
He was immediately trying to intimidate anyone who would question him.
@@nicolexxxg HE DID....COMMON SENSE HERE!
" I did not have sexual relations with that woman"
“I find that answer vague and unconvincing”
Hahaha
If you don't vote for me you ain't black.
@@jaturungkabart5554😂
I thought the same thing!!
1:57 Best New Jersey/New York Accent ever
You’re a liahhh, you’re a liiiiahhhh
“Your a lawyer”
“Your a lion”
''You're a llama''
“you’re a loy-ya”
What a weird response to failing a polygraph "I find that hard to believe"instead of "I DIDNT DO IT!"
Yeah watching this show and polygraph results, people who are guilty always have interesting responses
1:58 He's a murderer and a lawyer? Wow
She is saying liar lol she has a thick accent not lawyer
@@courtneylynn4080 it’s a joke...
Ted Bundy
Killer combo
He could be innocent .
He broke his neck so fast to stare him down 😨
“No until your in jail”
Damn, the way she said that gave me chills.
You tell him!
*you're !
@@nobull9541 got there before me 👏👏
Yur @@nobull9541
This is the worst feeling to live with. Knowing someone has killed your family member and they are walking around free. My uncle pushed my mother out of a moving car in 1987 she was hit and ran over by a oncoming car. She was taken away in 32 body bags. I tried so hard to have my uncle held accountable for her death but Florida closed the case. I have forever had a hole in my heart that he was never held accountable for his baby sisters death.
I’m so sorry that happened. It devastates me that people that are guilty of murder get away with it all the time and nothing can be done legally if there is not enough evidence. A very good friend of mine was murdered in 2018 and the person convicted got off not Guilty. There were 4 witnesses to her murder and none of them have spoken or want to even though one of them was her “bestfriend”. Her murderer is still out there and it’s known who it is but not enough evidence. I can only hope karma comes back to people like that later in life.
@@PK-fp8ie Did you honestly just ask me what did my Uncle have to GAIN from killing my MOTHER? Other than the fact he was cut off at the bar, lied about punching her in the face, and the bloody hand print on the back left door as he pushed her out of the moving car? He lied and said he was driving because his girlfriend, the driver lost her license for DUI. He blamed it on the alcohol he consumed.
the human justice syetem may have failed you but our savior and judge he will repay ok
Personally, I've always subscribed to the idea that if it means enough to you, you should be willing to take justice into your own hands if the law fails you (which it usually does). If the idea of your mother's murder walking free eats you up that badly inside, and if enough time has passed and that feeling hasn't gone away, then maybe you should consider whether it's worth spending time in prison to avenge her death. After all, if you're going to live in torment for the rest of your life, then consider whether it's better to live in a prison of concrete and steel or one of guilt and powerlessness. But it may not be, and if you have other things to live for, then try and find some way to live with those feelings and just hope he dies horribly in some accident or something. It's a heavy decision, and not one to make lightly. To be clear, I am NOT advocating for you to do anything, I'm only presenting a perspective.
"I'm tired of being told I killed my wife."
It's not an anger detector test, Kelly.
Underrated comment
That facial hair proves he did it.
It’s all the evidence I need too.
Rest in Peace to the great Jack Trimarco.
He was great❤️
He is sadistic. They try to believe their own lies but body language tells u everything
I don’t know how people can go on the show and say it’s hard to believe when they knew they did it
She sounds like lois Griffen in real life
I was eating ice cream and was only listening , i 100% thought i'd clicked on a joke mash up with Family Guy and Doctor Phil lol ........ it sounds just like her
A man with a mustache like that is definitely guilty
1:59 “Yer a lawyah. Yer a lawyah”
He passed one and failed the other. Humans put way to much faith in technology. To the point where this women was probably saying “idc if you pass two tests we will keep taking tests until you fail.”
"I find it hard to believe" ... THAT'S YOUR REACTION?!
"You're a murderer and a lawyer"
" Yes I'm a murderer but don't you ever insult me by calling me a lawyer again!"
"Yoo're a LOYYY R"
1:31 the way he’s looking and lying reminds me of Walter white lying lmao
I definitely noticed the glare and made me think "I'm pretty sure he did it"
I would love to hear an update on this.
Same
Same
Same
Same
Same
The hair under his lips looks weird and gross.
Agreed😂
Vag
So were any murder charges ever brought against this man?
Polygraph's aren't admissible in most courts because they are often found to be unreliable - hence why Dr. Phil uses the word "deceptive" and not "guilty" or "lying".
@@trevscribbles However polygraphs can influence prosecutors and/or police to either pursue a case, or to shift to look for other suspects. Useful so police don't waste a lot of valuable time on the wrong suspect. Also they could be very helpful if used on key witnesses. They are mostly accurate once you rule out sociopathy/psychopathy, and the presence of any drugs that might affect the test. There are also tricks to "beat the box" but they can be checked for and eliminated. Like everything else the tech, as well as the psychology of deception, has improved over the years. They will be admissible at some point.
@@scottys1423 I could be wrong here, but I think they might be admissible in some American states already actually? (I'm Irish, and it's not used on this side of the pond anyway)
@@trevscribbles Don't think they are. Lie detector test are psuedoscience. Nothing they detect is uniquely tied to lying.
Look how he flicks his head toward the polygraph examiner when he hears the TRUTH....LOL!!
He was sure working that jaw when Dr. Phil questioned him. Body language says so much.
He looks like that kind of person.
His excuse for failing the polygraph was “I keep being accused of murder, so when he asked that question it got me upset.” Umm, the question was asked so that you could prove your innocence. It wasn’t an accusation. If you were innocent, it should have been a relief, not a stress to answer that question.
I miss Jack DeMarco. RIP 💝
He died!?!
@@BabyDoll-qd7fh yep
@@BabyDoll-qd7fh Cancer😭❤
True, he & his magic polygraph made PURE psedoscience seem credible.
He passed in 2017 😮
He passed one polygraph and failed one miserably? What does that say about the reliability of polygraphs?
Two different tests with two different results. Which one did the family believe? Of course.
Polygraphs are not admissible in court.
They are in Federal Courts...
Polygraphs are unreliable and inadmissible in court, why dose dr phil who has a speciality in court psychology have so much faith in polygraphs ?
But if he passed one and not another it just shows yet again how polygraph tests aren't accurate and why they can't be used as evidence
Wow you could feel the intensity in that episode. $hit just got real.
I really wish Phil would stop using polygraphs. It makes for entertaining tv but they are not admissible as evidence in court for a reason. Either way, I do think this guy did it though!
I like polygraphs...I especially loved Chris Watts' polygraph..what a POS🔥
Okay but my question is why do we take these results as accurate when they won't even hold up in a court of law, they won't use polygraph results in a case because they are too inconclusive.
+pp]pi5io5io5ooooiiioi6poiou45ppoi5ooooo5ip57p5pyi5iu56o5oo59o5oo5o5po68o5o66o
You're correct but it can be good enough to gain insight on if someone is telling the truth or not.
According to the video he took a polygraph test that he passed before. Don't know if he did it but the polygraph test doesn't hint at anything since he passed the previous one before
“Your a lawyer” liar* lmao did anyone notice that
It is written all over his face and his actions as clear as a sunny day in Florida!
Lol these closed captions got me chuckling away. You're a lawyer, you're a lawyer. Hmmm.. maybe he can represent himself!
I mean... if he didn’t kill his wife, wouldn’t naturally your response be “I loved her so much and I couldn’t ever do such a thing” then ball your eyes out? ... not “I.didn’t.kill.my.wife. And stare down
👁 👁 “
Just v he didn't say that don't mean nun lol
Luckily polygraphs are not allowed as evidence in the court of law.
Phew
The problem is polygraphs are not 100 percent accurate which is why they don't hold up in court.
That's the weirdest soul patch I've seen
Why.....Why would you take a polygraph test on national tv if you're lying 🤦♂️
He passed one, he failed one
Lie detector tests are not reliable, nor proof.
Because lie detector tests are so unreliable
He may or may not be guilty but polygraph tests are notoriously unreliable; that's why they're not admissible in court.
ik he was guitly when i saw his face before the results came in
Can I ask you where you bought your crystal ball? 🤦♀️
Aren’t polygraphs bs anyway
Not at all whatsoever
@@alliesinger297 they are if your calm you pass it so if you believe your own lie so good you will pass. If your nervous you WILL fail. Take it into account that some people get nervous.
Well if you're an anxiety case who suffer from essential tremors the test is likely to be wrong
I’ve taken three polygraph test in the army for training purposes. I wasn’t accused of anything it was only for training purposes. I told the entire truth all three polygraph tests. In the course of a month. I passed the first two and failed the third.
My understanding is that polygraphs just measure physiological reactions to questions/answers. I wonder if one could lie the entire time but pass by keeping their reactions in check. Like with test questions: "are you sitting down? or is the sky blue?"
Gary ridgeway passed a lie detector test because he was a lizard brain with zero emotions and no sweating or increased heart rate.
@@JSolar590 sure can
Please I want to watch the full episode. Which season and episode is this??????? 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
i wanna know why he still denies it. is it pure ignorance or is his memory faulty?
What was the follow up on this story?
Saying he found it hard to believe instead of there's no way and the instant rage proves to me he is guilty.
How would an innocent man react?
If you are accused of something with the gravity of murder, you hire an attorney, guilty or not, you should not be on tv
Which episode is this?
Is there an update on this case? Was he found guilty?
As unreliable as polograph has been proven to be, anyone would be stupid to take one whether innocent or guilty.
You could see how scared he looked when his results were revealed.
That wasn't him scared, he was furious at the examiner...
Still though, he should've been more scared about the fact that he got exposed as a murderer on public tv. Not so sure he should be angry about the fact that the test said he lied.
He would have been sooo loud with the “I told you so” if he would have passed!!!
By the time his results got revealed, he knew he wasn't gonna be able to lie his way out of going to jail.
Lie detector tests legally can’t be used to convict someone, I don’t think he’s going to jail
2:06 Look at the uncontrollable anger in his eyes from here on. He can't even hide it while on TV and almost gets out of the chair! Then look at his eyes at 2:12.
Only a psychopath would go on national TV to lie and think he's gonna get away with it. 😂
You are what you are, a lawyer
Jack has a tendency to say "to pass, he needed plus two or above, a fail is minus four or above". I really think he meant "minus four or BELOW," but always said "above".
My assumption was that he referred to the absolute values.
O J Simpson had a -20 on his poly! He lied thru his teeth!
Deborah Haney, you're not paying attention....
I agree. -15 is below -4, so I can see where you're coming from, although I can understand Jack's point of view as well.
@@kata4794 When the police brought in the Green River serial killer 20 something years earlier, he "passed" a polygraph.
Spy Aldrich Ames also "passed" numerous polygraphs.
People who have later been exonerated by DNA "failed" polygraphs.
Polygraphs can be inaccurate so idk
Exacly as I was thinking
'Yourra loyyah... yourra loyyah...'
Polygraphs are stupid it depends on if your nervous
True
Your a lawyer I told you your a lawyer your a lawyer
Polygraphs are an abomination
“ hey Killah!!”
On a online class and watching dr phil
Seeing this video after an hour long video essay explaining how completely unreliable and meaningless polygraph tests are is weird... I genuinely hope these are just paid actors and this isn’t a real case.
It’s ridiculous that some people think that they can cheat a polygraph test. He’s claiming that the test was wrong because it said that he was guilty, but if it had come back that he was innocent, he would’ve accepted the results.
Polygraph tests are BS. I don't know if he did it or not but that polygraph test doesn't prove anything. Heck according to the video he took a polygraph test before that he passed.
My Gosh!
This guy is guilty I can see it in his eyes.
The polygraph got me hyped up
The lady sounds like the girl from my cousin vinny, “ya are whatchya are yer a loiya”
You cannot judge something like that from a polygraph test lmao. Too many variables.
The tone of his voice and the way he speaks when defending himself says otherwise. No stuttering. Very clear and to the point. Didn’t add a load of bollox he just made it clear.
Repeated himself twice and no more.
Could just be used to lying at this point or he’s innocent eitherway from the sounds of it we will never know.
He was not found guilty as far as I know so there really isn't much evidence.
Like you said lie detector tests are not reliable.
He actually passed one but failed this one lol
When you are accused of murder, you’re not gonna be calm. Especially when failing a polygraph and having that announced on live television. The fact he was calm was actually odd.
Question though, what do we believe then if he passed 1 poly and failed another?
Nothing except the status quo. I don't believe he did it, but I also don't disbelieve it. This Test shows nothing even if there was just one. The fact that there is two just shows how unreliable and dumb these tests are.
Not defending him. I don’t know the back story or what was determined as cause of death. I assume he escaped conviction through effective legal defense or was not evidence to charge him or maybe no crime at all. But… guilt surrounding a death leaves a person questioning what they could have done to prevent it or what they did indirectly to cause it and enough blame upon themselves aside from murder that there’s still deception that skews a polygraph. Same is true if someone believes their own deception. It may provide indications of conscious deceptions but not conclusively. And this is why they are not always accepted in a trial. Guilty passes one and it’s favorable in the minds of a jury. innocent and fails one results in a false conviction. Because it’s not perfect, it can’t be trusted unequivocally to prosecute or defend. Not sure anyone should actually take one unless their legal representative is very certain it will be helpful. Denying one might look bad, but taking one on dr Phil and failing looks worse. Guilty or not pretty dumb move.
*john mulaney voice* "ooOh i bet he did kill his wife 👀👀"
I think Dr. Phil should stop presenting the polygraph results on his show and presenting polygraph tests as sound science. Why doesn't he get more criticisms for this?
You’re a lawyer. You’re a lawyer. Ya killed ha.
There is a reason polygraph tests aren’t considered reliable evidence in court
Not for nothing but polygraph tests don’t prove anything
Even his answer to how he felt about that was so off. I find that hard to believe?? Really??
1:58 "Ya ah wachu ah, yoa a lawya"
He had a Freudian slip at the end
What's up with that soul patch though...
Tell me lies tell me sweet little lies
1:58 so he also lied about the fact that he was a "Lawyer" so he's both a murderer and a Lawyer too
Are polygraphs ever correct?
yes, only very rarely are people able to successfully lie and get away with it. before the polygraph the tester puts mental stress on the person taking it so its more successful
No, they're easy to manipulate, and they're never 100% accurate no test is, polygraphs will never be sufficient evidence and aren't allowed in courts for reasons being that they aren't accurate, many things can factor into a person's body responses not just telling the truth or not, and in this video the man said the 1st one came back saying he's innocent but the 2nd one didn't and that's another reason, different results with different tests, I work in the field and they're super easy to pass, I've lied on so many.
@@leslieschultz6701 LMAO