PREFERRED (2ND EDITION): Kayenta Games-Integrating Upstairs Downstairs
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
- Detailed explanation of how to integrate the Upstairs, Downstairs expansion with Obsession, including:
1. Courtship Cards
2. Objective Cards
3. Board Extension
4. Improvement Tiles
5. Round Track
...and more.
I would just like to say that Dan, as a game designer and publisher goes way above and beyond any other games company in delivering the best experience and value for money for those purchasing his products. Many thanks Dan.
My pleasure!
I just got Upstairs Downstairs from a game store in Nashville for $24.99! I will be buying Wessex from you eventually! I just want to thank you for a great game and I love how you bring my childhood dream of living in England to life!
My pleasure!
Excellent video. I will receive my copy of Upstairs Downstairs today and this will be very helpful.
My pleasure!
Thank you for the video. I believe that most people will deduct most of this, even without the video or sheet. I think this video is a testament of how much you have cared for your backers and most of all, to deliver a quality product. And what a product it is! It's a great game, beautiful to look at, and that was clearly made with dedication and which really feels like a work of love. Thank you Dan, for allowing us to experience it and congratulations on a marvelous job.
Appreciate the honesty Dan! Love the these videos on each of the expansions and 2nd edition components and changes. You can see the thoughtfulness and passion that went into design and delivery of such an extraordinary and unique game. Can’t wait to play my complete game of Obsession with the Upstairs Downstairs expansion.
Thanks for this. My copy of the 2nd Edition with both expansions is due to arrive today. Appreciate the honesty and I wish more people would do this rather than just blame others or make excuses.
Thank you!
I flipped through a copy of Dune the other day (an original) that my son was reading. On the first page, the first line said: "In the week before their departure to Arrauis, when all the final scurrying about had reached a nearly unbearable frenzy, an old crone came to visit the mother of the boy, Paul."
Arrauis (it should be Arrakis)? Who proofreading a book misses a misspelling of the 1st occurrence of the main planet, the eight word of the book??
So I have company. :) But it just goes to show that complex projects have errors. The errors get ironed out over time (reprints), but it is amazing what the mind misses in certain circumstances.
Thanx Mr. Hallagan for this explanation video! Finally an unboxing video that has a purpose. It is actually so helpful you should have done it anyway even without the obmission. I watched this video minutes after I received my copy of everything in Germany! Eager to start playing!
Great to hear! I do think I would have done it anyway; I tend to never read directions when I get a game. I watch a playthrough, throw it on the table and play multiplayer solo, THEN I read. I better absorb the rules that way.
tHANK YOU VERY CLEAR AND EASY TO FOLLOW.
Thanks Dan. :-) I think I had eventually worked all of this out from piecing together stuff in the Rulebook, in Kickstarter material and Boardgamegeek forums, but it’s great to have your official explanation. I really appreciate and admire your thoroughness, attention to detail, and wonderful game! (I’m also halfway through the first of your books - what a Renaissance man you are!)
You're welcome! My next game needs to be something with a two page ruleset, like Hanabi!
Wait?! Books?! *off to Google*
This is still pretty complex. It would be good to have a separate video just on integrating with the 2nd ed base game, since a lot of people will be starting with that. Also, don't shy away from being opinionated! Have a recommended way to organize things (e.g., player boxes in base game). People will still do what works best for them.
Good advice. I think the PDF I am working on will give that sort of clarity. Thanks!
Dan Hallagan I’d suggest a player aid that has each of the wooden representative Meeples linked with the name of each. I’d do one with all on one sheet. Eg the picture of the wooden butler with it saying this is the Butler. Not having the game yet Im unsure if there is one. My impression is that the rules don’t have much icons in them.
@@stevegeorge7773 There are player aids for all the servants, one aid (with pictures) in the base game for the original servants and one aid (also with pictures) in the UD expansion.
Dan Hallagan great!
I’d also like to add that using the new, lower value monuments makes the standard solo game a little bit more challenging ;)
An excellent point!
Thanks for making this video, really helpful. Enjoy your break! Quick question for once you are back - for a 2P game would you still recommend integrating the 2nd copy of prestige 5 tiles with the base game, or are they meant exclusively for a 5+ player game? And doesn't the integration of extra tiles (like the additional 5P tiles or the promotional tiles) have an effect on objectives that require certain tiles to show up in the market?
Also, there are only replacement tiles for a subset of monuments. Do we leave the original monuments for which there is no low-VP replacement?
Yes, the new way that the market is managed takes all tiles. That will be my next video (in support of the setup video). There is very little impact on objective, except to make a few difficult groups a little easier, which I think is a good thing.
Hi Dan and thanks for this beautiful game! Still playing base game only as per your guidance but decided to integrate UD content compatible with base game hence I'm watching this video. Only thing I'm not sure about what to do is carriage house tile. Is it ok to just add it to the base game?
Thank you. Yes, the Carriage House tile can be integrated into the base game without any special rules. When you do add the Upstairs, Downstairs servants, the only new thing is that the hall boy can stand in for the footman on that tile.
Hi, another question please, about the level 5 tiles @28:22 (meant for 5-6 players) - I pretty much only play at 2p count, should I mix those into the base tiles? Setup of the Improvement tiles makes no separation based on player (only for Monuments). I am thinking yes, you can mix them all, but if in case both players already have bough a tile and 3rd come up in the Builder's Market, then that should be removed as nobody can buy again. Thoughts? Thanks
Yes, you can mix them. If duplicates appear, they stack. There is never 3 of a tile. There is either 1 copy or 2 copies of each tile.
The extra Barns and Servants' Halls are only for 1st edition base game owners and will not be used it you have the 2nd edition.
Hi, so the gentry cards you talk about @6:50 (not the promos, not the new family), can it simply be mixed with the cards from the case game, even if you are playing without the expansion? Thanks
Correct. They function just like any of the guests in the base game. Same rules, favours, etc. You would have to set aside the Howard family cards if not using the UD expansion.
So... I acquired the core set and all expansions including the promo tiles. I watched your storage video as well.
What’s the best way for me to play? I would like to play with the Upstairs Downstairs expansion.... I just don’t know anything about the monuments and such.
Can you contact me at hallagan@kayentapublishing.com? I can give you some guidance.
Email sent! Thanks so much!
Hi Dan, if we play with more than 3 player and we like to play with the "new" monuments (they are only 4), what should we do? Thanks
Just posted on BGG, but will repost here: The only restriction I would suggest is that you should never use the Garden Maze and the Sculpture Garden together (two ESTATE high VP monuments), which means that the most monuments you can have is 5 (the five high VP monuments that includes one of the two ESTATE ones). So 4, 5, and even 6 players (don't really recommend 6) would either get 5 high VP monuments or 4 low VP monuments, you choice. It is no issue that there are equal or less monuments than the number of players. Rarely do you actually see all the monuments anyway. As long as the players know how many and what type are in the bag so they can make plans, life is good.
@@kayentagamesdanhallagan856Thanks, Dan. Did not know that we could play with only 4 monuments with more than 3p. I think we should go back to the 'original' set 😉. Congratz for your game, it's brilliant. Cheers from Portugal
@@pintarfacil8064 Thank you!
We played a five-player base game last night and found we had to reshuffle in the discarded objective cards as there weren't enough to go around. Are there any new objectives in the Upstairs, Downstairs pack that are compatible with just the base game at higher player counts? I haven't added the new tiles to my set yet either, while my group gets to know the game.
Sorry for the delay! I was 'off the grid' in Glacier National Park. The instructions do mention the need to reshuffle in discarded objectives at higher player counts. There are only about 3 new ones (outside the servant ones) in the UD OC deck, so that by itself won't solve the problem. Was it a problem to reshuffle?
@@kayentagamesdanhallagan856 No worries, Dan. No, no trouble to reshuffle, just wasn't sure if there was a different way. Some players got back cards they'd already discarded, but that's life in Derbyshire.
I guess we'll just have to get Upstairs, Downstairs mixed in as soon as possible!
Upstairs Downstairs objective cards, so those combine with the existing 2nd objectives deck?
The two Objective Decks are independent. You use the original if not playing with the Upstairs, Downstairs servants, and you use the UD deck when playing with them.