Boltzmann Brain Paradox Explained in Simple Words
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 04. 2023
- A Boltzmann brain is not real, but what’s fascinating about it is that it thinks it’s real, and all the memories and experiences it has are real. But, of course, this brain is not real. But how would such a brain know that its memories are artificial and its existence is more like a hallucination? How would we know that we aren’t those artificial brains? This is the Boltzmann Brain paradox, the result of Ludwig Boltzmann’s many years of debate with other scientists on his interpretation of entropy.
In this video, we discuss the Boltzmann brain in simple terms and understand why we humans are real and not Boltzmann brains!
#BoltzmannBrainParadox #Thermodynamics #Entropy
References:
www.terpconnect.umd.edu/~brus...
www.academia.edu/49958718/The...
doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0802.0233
Original Article Link:
www.scienceabc.com/pure-scien...
If you wish to buy/license this video, please write to us at admin@scienceabc.com.
Voice Over Artist: John Staughton ( www.fiverr.com/jswildwood )
SUBSCRIBE to get more such science videos!
/ @scienceabc
Follow us on Twitter!
/ abc_science
Follow us on Facebook!
/ sciabc
Follow us on Instagram!
/ scienceabcofficial
Follow us on LinkedIn!
/ scienceabc
Follow our Website!
www.scienceabc.com - Věda a technologie
That’s a really difficult concept. Maybe it’s constantly happening in the universe and we would come back into a minute particle only to bang out big again! Spider-Man: I’m tired, I’ll fly away now! Humans: I’m tired, let’s go to bed! Love the animations! Keep it up!
that's deadpool
I remember renting the movie Dark City on VHS when it came out at the video store. After seeing how the advanced beings would freeze time and go around switching out the memories of humans and putting them in different positions to study humanity, I started to fantasize about this sort of idea. Blade Runner also touches on this topic with how they enter false memories into the replicants to make them believe they had childhoods.
There is a phenomenon that has nothing to do with this subject, but it popped up in my head.
When you want to create a random pattern, for example with tiles on you floor, you must carefully create it yourself. Because when you create them at random, they have the tendency to create something that seems a pattern.
I presume it has something to do with pareidolia
Next time I have a discussion with my wife, I just have to think that I may only be just a Boltz brain.
Very Deep, thanks
I don't know if those 'scientists' who calculated the chance of a 'Boltzman Brain' is 'infinitely higer' than that of a human brain have ever heard of a crazy theory called 'evolution'...
You might say that the chance of the first replicator was very low, but can it possibly be lower than a thinking mind complete with a raft of coherent memories.
It would be a brave 'scientist' who asserts this, methinks
Evolution needs a planet though.
@@pluto9000 ... And that planet itself might be a Boltzmann 'brain'!
Is there a difference in probability if the infinity is countable versus uncountable?
How you do research?
Nice😎
How would they be full of memories and why would they develop these. Plus how would these interact or is it just one brain
It is just one brain. All of it's memories have been created the moment the brain was created, only for it to last mere moments before disintegrating back in the vacuum of space
The memories are created by the positions of the particles.
So we gonna just ignore 5:01 and not question why that part was added? ☠️
Ik bro wth 💀
What do you mean with : artificial memories ?
But then it seems we all have boltzmann brains, some particles randomly formed atoms, molecules, proteins, dna, cells, multicellular beings. Thus our brains are ultimately formed randomly only, where all the required particles were at the right place at the right moment
But one problem that i don't understand is that if our brain is just something that appeared with "false" memories, how come that these memories are correct enough that we could understand physics and quantum mechanics of the real (what even is real at this point?) universe and come to the conclusion that this is possible? If the thoughts are random and fake, as one would think, how can we still study the physics of the real universe? This just gets my head too tangled.
if you are a boltzman brain then maybe you are the lucky one who was randomly given a 'scene' showing you what a boltzman brain is. your randomly given 'scenes' (i dont really think memories is a good term for this concept) just happen to make sense to you. you cant peer into anyone elses brain right? so how would we know what a different boltzman brain is seeing, could be a completely different universe where everything looks like a picasso painting and to that boltzman brain, it also all makes perfect sense to them. thats how i interpreted it, i hope it makes some sense.
Whats the probability of a brain judt developing? Like clean slate.
Wait , wait , wait, this sounds a lot like Descartes. Do these scientists give any credit to the philosopher?
I don't know, I think I'd b e a boltzmann brain for sure - but what about consciousness itself?
I mean the argument falls apart when you remember that for the electrochemical functions of memories and thoughts to work, that brain still needs the power of a cardiovascular system, a respiratory system, insulation in the form of skin, and chemicals in the form of breathable air to stay alive long enough for those thoughts and memories to come into existence at all.
Absolutely great point
"We know that the model of an infinitely long-existing universe is a bust". No, we don't know that!
Lütfen Türkçe alt yazı ekleyin..(Turkish )
Videoda Türkçe Altyazı mevcuttur. Bunları açılır menüden seçmeniz yeterlidir.
@@Scienceabc çok teşekkürler :)
my brain hurts
"These models should be thrown out"
I mean it's infinity. With infinity everything possible is a guarantee and will happen. It's the nature of infinity. Anybody who doesn't agree doesn't understand infinity. And this doesn't only apply to infinite multiverses like on TV. It also applies to infinite time. And yes folks, also infinite space. If the universe is infinite space, there are an infinite identical replicas of you reading this same comment right now. Also in the future are there more infinite yous and everyone else, reading this comment, and every other possible comment, and doing everything else once can do, infinity, every second infinity across space, and in the future across time. Plus and infinite number of slightly different yous with just one hair out of place in time and space.. Also an infinite number of yous with a different shirt reading infinite comments and everything else infinite number in space and in the future. Also an infinite number of you with your thumb in your butt, reading this... No joke, everything possible not only can, but is guaranteed to happen infinity. On the bright side, that girl you liked, or that person who died, in an infinite universe there is an infinite number of mostly identical earths somewhere out there where she isn't dead and you two got together and lived happily ever after and are immortal, young, and happy, infinitely..
How did you know where my thumb was?
aika paha
Художников с ЯтьТВ что ли наняли?
Нет, у нас нет.
@@Scienceabc Почему нет?
why did they make the criminal black at the end
Why was the only black person in the video the one getting arrested
right?
lol thats cj from gta
😅
According to this theory, you only have your own brain to blame for that?
Lmaaaoooo. Why not
Go outside that's when you will learn you and everyone around you exists and all your memories up to the present moment are true and real and you exist, Just leave your dark room for once, Please.