Can I Copy Art Styles Better Than A.I.?
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 02. 2024
- A.I. is a hot topic, and it keeps getting hotter! In the time since I wrote this alone, we've seen Sora AI and Google Gemini making fresh waves - so the question is more pressing than ever: Can A.I. REALLY replace artists, and content creators on CZcams?
By getting one A.I. to come up with video ideas, then having another A.I. compete with a human artist to do the job - we will finally know the answer, once and for all!
Thanks to @danspex for that shoutout in the cold open! You can watch the whole video it came from here:
• 1K Subscriber Special ...
* * * * * *
Featuring the silky smooth vocal stylings of:
@Jake.Miller
@RT60
@DrakeDragsaw
Much obliged, fellers!
* * * * * *
My Super X-Girlfriend: / harrygoldartist
Basic Insta-inct: / harry.gold.artist - Komedie
I love the pure, unadulterated irony of an AI telling you to "get creative" with something
DHMIS moment
That pfp💀
@@sexygirlmax2019 i REFUSE to get creative unless it involves a human heart covered in gold glitter
Lets all agree
To never be creative again
@@sexygirlmax2019LETS GET CREATI-
I love how the AI "Sherlock Owl" is just unapologetically Rowlet in a detective outfit and nothing actually resembling a new Pokemon.
That's how I feel about everything that came after Gen1
I mean, they're unique, but now you're just introducing creatures that look like furniture and kitchen appliances lmao
@@minhuang8848yeah, I kinda want them to have a Pokemon that’s just purple sludge with eyes or a Pokemon that’s just a seal but the name has one letter replaced with e
@@minhuang8848 yeah i cant believe object mons only started existing in gen 2 and compose 80% of the pokedex. what were they thinking??
@@minhuang8848I just can’t believe how Exeggcute, Voltorb, Electrode, Seel, Dewgong, Muk, Grimer, Metapod, Pidgey, Pidgeotto, Pidgeot, Ekans, Krabby, Kingler, Goldeen and Tauros were definitely all introduced in Gold and Silver.
Modern Pokémon has a better ratio of ‘Just a thing’ to ‘Actual Design’ than Gen 1 did.
So you mean....kinda like current day Pokémon? If so, then you're not wrong. lmao
"Human Grit always beats Robot Magic" -Soldier from TF2
"If God wanted you to live, HE WOULDN"T HAVE CREATED ME!" Soldier to ai algorithems probably
“I will eat your ribs! I WILL EAT THEM UP!” -Soldier
Why is nobody talking about skibidi???
@@alambrito3377 Because that man comes from Half-Life, not TF2.
@@whiteroach3 kind of.
But mostly correct.
Also don’t worry,I don’t watch skibidi toilet
Ai doesn’t understand how art works it just gathers stuff from articles and wikis
ai cannot create art, because art is and will always be a human craft
@@fidgety48 especially animation, ai can’t understand how animation works it just puts abunch of moving frames and makes it look like if paint was frozen and melted and someone tried to clean it up with a McDonald’s napkin
@fidgety48 yeah thats why its art because its generated with the input of a human this it is art
Hello hello hello (l used to have a pfp of him but I changed it and someone just liked this but I don’t have him as my profile picture anymore so they have no idea why I said hello hello hello lol)
@@Ericshadowblade writing a sentence does not mean the image was made by a human, the ai tries to find out what you said and makes something up with the images in its database
My favorite little detail is that the AI keeps suggesting things that are already part of normal Pokémon design, like Living Objects or puns, in this "crazy" mashup.
Also, the second prompt literally suggesting you draw something completely invisible is just the cherry on top!
Hell, the first idea is literally Silvally. It's also a mixture of a fish, a bird of prey and a lion
also the fossil mixtures from Sword and Shield
@@asierx7047 That's what I was thinking!
@@asierx7047yea more like type: null but same shit lmao
Harry: "Give me a humorous Pokemon design idea."
AI: "The platypus is God's joke, why not steal that idea."
Isn't that basically GameFreak's original mission statement?
the many pokemon that are literally just dogs or cats or objects:
_I wasn’t expecting Skibidi toilet jokes from Harry, _*_I hate it and love it at the same time_*
Me personally, I fully hate that part and the reference AS A WHOLE
@@joelknowsgeographyandflags5578Bro is from Ohio rizz 💀💀💀
@@joelknowsgeographyandflags5578 I get your point, but I also find it hilarious due to its blatant sarcasm
@@real_liamonadeIt was so cleverly done so one can't get mad
I have NEVER laughed at a skibidi toilet joke before but this one got me laughing so hard.
It even took all the AI's bad ideas and made them good
7:13 Clearly you haven't seen enough old school CZcams Poop, where Mario saying "TOASTERS!" was considered peak comedy.
I suppose it is true that all toasters do indeed toast toast
Don’t forget Luigi’s “SPAGHETTI!” With that fact that spaghetti was an AI idea here.
@@TheHarryGoldShow "NO THEY DO NOT!! THEY TOAST *_BREAD_* DUMBA$$!!!"
(/ref for the people who need that specified)
10:58 alternative names : Hoodunit, deductowl, mentowl
Hoodunit is quite brilliant
I love Hoodunit
Head turner works too
I dont understand how this man can make jokes out of nowhere so smoothly. That skibidi toilet joke came straight out of left field and he didnt miss a beat
comedic timing is a hell of a thing i suppose lol
@@highdefinition450 And thankfully, something I just can't see AI replicating, all things considered!
A fun additional trait for a new Sonic OC would be wire legs, legs that are made entirely of wires, with nothing covering the wires that the legs are made up of.
i think he should just add a toaster to candycorn. clearly that would be hilarious
this is, to me, the actual use for AI as an artist: using it as insparations or ideas rather than trying to replace actual art.
real
most of the ideas he got weren't even good tho...
A bad idea is still better than no ideas, especially since it immediately becomes clearer what can be done to improve them.
Ai art is just a photobash of an existing artworks. What's the point of referencing a plagiarizing machine when you can come up with your own stuff?
@@awman698 ... I already get inspired by things other people draw. It's not like I'm tracing.
Personally, I would classify Weird AL's polkas as parodies since they still change existing songs in a comedic way.
True Alficionados like his totally original ones, like Hardware Store and Dare to be Stupid.
@@KairuHakubi My favorites are Genius in France and Jackson Park Express.
pastiche is the word used by himself, pretty apt too
And Even worse
@@Tree-Noceda That is one of my favorite albums of his.
What if Harry gold had a pokemon team?
Definitely a Meowscarada as the starter for the old timey showman vibe
Mr. Rime and make it shiny
@@Nikowo1610And a Galarian Weezing
empoleon
and a shuckle
Harry Gold's masterful artistry definitely earns him an art-themed Pokemon such as Smeargle or the Shroodle line, although since it's digital art you could also give him a Rotom Drawing Tablet as seen in the Pokemon Horizons anime IIRC
6:50 To quote Game Grumps: "Geez, walking chairs? what's he in a hurry for? to get sit on?!"
“Jeez! You open up a locked treasure chest to get a key.
Isn't that ass backwards?!”
What's this flashing bird flashing for? Is he the POLICE?
Yknow now that I give it thought, yeah, even the object pokemon have a purpose on why they look like that
What is this? Some kind of angel?! I don't want *RELIGION* in *MY* game!
always wanted to design an electric dog pokemon which i would name Barc. combing "bark" and "arc" and including elements of an arc welder and perhaps a junkyard dog.
I have no idea what an arc welder is, so I wondered what the B could be in the acronym, looked up what the rest of arc stands for, and spit out what I was eating-
@cosmicspacething3474 I have no idea what you're looking up, but there is no acronym. the arc I'm speaking of is an arc of electricity, and an arc welder can be either a machine that used electricity to weld metal together, or it can refer to the operator of that machine.
so the names combines Bark, the sound a dog makes, and Arc as in electricity, specifically Arc Welding
@@cosmicspacething3474 What did you find to make you react like that? Benevolent Animal Rescue Committee?
AI art right now seems to be perfectly constructed at first glance, only to completely fall apart once you try to study it lol it won't be replacing us anytime soon I hope. Also that's Humphrey Bogart when you ask him "Why the long face?"
I mean, that's only true for the AI art that you look at more closely and that actually has these issues. We all are heavily predisposed already (availability heuristic, confirmation/negative bias, compositional fallacy) and don't even notice that we're happily accepting an endless amount of examples that are more carefully composed, selected, or modified. Very similar to the VFX biases people love to chuck around, despite not knowing the first thing about how to even detect contemporary compositing and full VFX shots. Yeah, you can tell that the Rock is crusty in Scorpion King, but you don't really realize when things look great. Nobody bothers checking water in movies when we've been doing extensive replacement and simulation work since way before even Titanic, today more so than ever - all that folks ever think about is the negative examples because the positive ones are invisible. Same for anything AI generated in the future.
Also, and this is just food for thought: who is to say that this is necessarily bad? A huge part of many drawing and painting styles, especially with sketch-style illustrations, is to fake the details while actually being pretty sparse with nitty-gritty and greeble - look up the video "The Secret to Drawing Overwhelming Detail" by Stephen Travers Art, he perfectly highlights the illusions going on with that particular style. You could still go "well, that looks garbage looking closely"... but does it really matter? More often than not, that's secondary to just the overall feeling and vibe of a piece of art, plus it might be a stylistic decision in itself if used for dreamlike, seemingly coherent subject matter.
For now…
If u crop out the bad its almost impossible to tell, which is both bad and good
@@minhuang8848 tldr
@@Aswoop9000 put it in an LLM
19:45 Considering how useless the AI was for giving suggestions, massive kudos for being able to incorporate all those random features and still make it look official! (To the point I actually love the design)
24:20 ok that one caught me off guard, well played!
I had already seen the drawing and it did so too for me
Harry Gold is the only person I want my style stolen from.
Ah, thank you Mr. Gold for assuring us artists that AI will never replace our talents. Although, you did just prove my initial claim that you’ll eventually be the one to put us all out of a job…
You’re safe for now, but I’ll keep my eyes on you. Anyway, incredible video as always and thank you for the shout out in the beginning! Look forward to seeing more from you in the future.
For every 1 good artist there are 8000 bad ones and for every 1 decent ai bot there are 90 awful ones
Humans will always be better than A.I.
Considering ai needs human input and creativity to do its job yeah
Facts
......for now
@@Whimsykitwe are still going to be better than ai it's just that we lose our jobs because people don't wanna pay for people to make actual good and unique art
Not at chess
How can this man replicate styles so well?!
by doing what AI does. studying and copying.
talent
@@KairuHakubi Only thing, AI can't study because it's not conscious
@@samp.8099 a freakin goldfish can study, my dude.
@@KairuHakubia goldfish is infinitely more conscious than AI. AI doesn’t “think” or “know” ANYTHING.
Genuinely this video makes me feel better about my future as an artist. No ai could ever replicate the brilliance of Skibiddy
im gonna find you
furry
@@OttaSauroooo someone's mad that another person has hobbies
@@teletoge skibidi toilet is brainrot
I just love how you dunk on ai and flex your art skills at the same time
Your ability to take AI's rough, half-baked ideas fished out of the well from "the ring" and make them actually good looking is incredible! I aspire to have skills like that as an artist someday.
harry gold is such a goat that he can make horribly random ideas into actual banger designs
19:44 My suggestion would be to give the OC candy cane themed lightsabers. It would have the hook hilt sort of like Count Dooku's mixed with a candy cane. As for the lightsaber color, have the left hand hold the red lightsaber and the right hand hold the white lightsaber.
Easily one of the best art channels out there
I still cannot believe that you aren’t 1 million sub + CZcamsr, your content is absurdly high quality and even with your relatively slow video output they’re rewatchable enough that I could sit through the same 3 videos and be satisfied for a week!! Keep rolling Harry, I can’t wait to see what you’ll have for us next time!
I have been watching the same three videos on repeat I guess I proved myself right.
Apparently ChatGPT's concept of Albert Einstein as [a] Sonic the Hedgehog [character] is essentially Ivo "Dr. Eggman" Robotnik [Almost forgot to include the caricature; I'm guessing Humphrey Bogart?]
That's obviously Humphrey Bogart at the end.
I think one big concern with AI art is less that it's going to reach the level of quality as traditional artistry, and more so that companies without discretion are going to take whatever slop it produces that looks decent at a quick glance and roll with it anyhow just because it's free, and MOST people probably won't even look at it long enough to notice.
Why not both
Corporations won’t stop cutting corners and AI researchers won’t stop trying to improve their models
@@oberonpanopticon Both are most certainly the case here.
Those black and white thumbnail suggestions were conceptually decent.. and the best non-people AI art I've seen.
give the oc at 19:45 a scene kid phase and most its most tramatic experience being rickroled in the second grade.
I sure do love when a program grabs a million different images and violently mashes them all together into a soulless paste.
i adore how your interpretations of the ai programs are essentially megaman robot masters. thats awesome
Why shouldn't we use ai to replace the jobs nobody wants instead of artists
I got an ad for “Microsoft Copilot” an AI thing, They’re trying to keep you down, But you’re still the winner!
Harry gold color reveal when????
That happened in the Washington Football Team logo redesign video.
I love how unapologetically "you" you are, and your humor and sarcasm is beyond that of other youtubers I watch, bravo, a sub has been earned!
The Bidoof and Skiddy mashup name.. if you see this Harry you know what you've done
I regret nothing
Hi, pokemon fan here. I like object pokemon, the people that don't are just the granpas that only played the first (and maybe second) games. Also, fun fact: Vanilluxe is not an ice cream, it's an icicle with snow on top trying too disguise itself as an ice cream
12:43 Remoraid is a gun and Octillery is a tank. If you look at the beta designs they look even similiar to pistols and tanks
Yeah, the Object Pokemon strawman/complaint has always been a case of vocal bad takes.
Like, Chandelure looks sick AF, people who claim otherwise are plain wrong, and often those people also want to claim that Grimer evolving into Muck or 3 Diglets is more creative and well designed than something like Garbodor or Kelfkey, or even other kinds of super cool designs like Meowscarada.
Gen 1 actually kinda had a higher ratio of lazy designs than a lot of other generations TBH. And also has many of the worst cases of thing becomes bigger thing, thing based on object, and IRL animal [COUGH Seel]
So for a fun comment to this video and because I am awful at guessing famous people, I decided to use the assistance of AI to decipher the caricature.
Bing Copilot, despite having been given three different screenshots of Mr. Gold's caricature, continuously told me the face was too obscure to make any guesses, and then continued to tell me about famous people who have had famous caricatures made for them.
Google's Gemini admitted that the characteristics in a caricature are too exaggerated for it to be able to recognize who it might be, but at least was able to make three major observations of the man drawn. I prompted it further to at least guess who the man may be. These were its guesses:
1. Winston Churchill: This former British Prime Minister was known for his strong jawline and short, dark hair. He often wore suits and ties in photographs.
2. Jay Leno: This former late-night talk show host has a prominent chin and jawline, and his signature look often included short, dark hair and a suit and tie.
3. Clark Gable: This classic Hollywood actor was known for his strong jawline and short, dark hair. He frequently wore suits and ties in movies and photographs.
My guess was James Stewart which after looking at photos is definitely not the right answer... So instead I'll just steal the correct answer from the comments like AI art steals from the internet. It's Humphrey Bogart!
gonna sound like a little whiny butch for this, but there are some subtle differences between FoP and danny phantoms artsyles that would warrant choosing one over the other for a style swap.
phantom characters have all 5 digits in place of shovels for hands, adhere a little bit more to real human anatomy and offer more in the way of clothing detail.
Damn, huge missed opportunity to call the sherlock owl Owlimentary, tut tut...
Jokes aside, these designs are phenomenal as always, great work!
Thank you for the talk at the beginning about ai, and the acknowledgement that while people might not like to see content about it at all, you're very clear about what is/isn't derived from ai and are merely using it *for* the sake of drawing real art.
The main fear of artists: That they will be replaced by AI
The main fear of AI:
That they will be replaced by Harry Gold
Dog eat dog world
You are One of the best artist I’ve ever seen
I randomly found this on my recommended, and I'm super glad I did. I love the whole "old sitcom/news show" vibe of the video, and it's amazing how you're able to mimic so many art styles perfectly(something I would love to do)!
I'm definitely subscribing. I can't wait to see more of this!
Thanks so much, and welcome aboard - I hope I can keep you entertained!
Same way that it was for me, saw like, one of the regular episodes as well as the Mario one where each character was their old designs without being redesigned across tbe whole series,
Ended up subscribing and looking through like, the entire channel.
Great charm and creativity!
Humphrey Bogart, sad that I go to the “guess who” before I watch the main event.
considering it'd be easy to idly add a comment that doesn't contain the guess, and then have to delete it and start over because he won't accept edited answers... it's probably smart to start with the caricature actually.
Also good eye, I think you're right.
Always a joy to see a new video from you!
After a good half a semester of having to discuss the impact of AI on my life, this feels rather nice. Really, those things are at their best when used for entertainment purposes.
Also, I'd like to point out the... slam-dunking elongated Squirtle in the generated thumbnail at 25:30 - he certainly is a creature to behold.
And another reference to DHMIS in a Harry Gold video, I'll add that to the tally, haha.
tally? ha? as in Tally Hall? TALLY HALL REFERENCE IN HARRY GOLD CONFIRMED?
(just kidding lmao; I was trying to sound like an AI saying that, but explaining the joke kinda ruins it so I guess I'm just not funny)
Good to know artists will have at least another year of being better than AI
Here's hoping!
This is hilarious and also really impressive. I love that you show different examples and ideas for each pokemon, u put so much time into this🙏🙏🙏
I’VE BEEN WAITING ALL YEAR FOR THIS VIDEO WOOOOO
it's truly impressive how harry gold can replicate a art style.
I like how this guy proceeds to take a steamy shit on ai instead of just making another semi-generic "A.I is bad." Video.
AI will never replace hobbyist artists no matter how good it gets. It's fun to use though!
The editing, humor, and style of video feels very unique
Keep up the great work!
This is definitely one of your best videos yet! Always great to see a notification that you've uploaded a new masterpiece.
Your videos are comfort food thank you harry gold
Amazing work, Harry! Just gushing how well put together all this is; how many hours does it take to write,edit, draw, etc etc something like this?
Thanks! I really have no idea, I'm terrible at keeping track of that sort of thing... normally my videos take between one and two months all up though. (This one took three because it's longer than usual!)
Once again another fire video from harry goldman 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Love the lil robot designs you made for the AIs
I love Chatgpts voice lol
Bro drew Lincoln Loud in the Invader Zim style, he is immediately in my good graces.
The reason why the AI art for Sherlock Owl was so "good" was because it just ripped 99% of the art of Rowlet.
"The reason why Giger's art was so good was because he just ripped off 99% of historically depictions of death and despair"
Harry everytime you make a video I'm just so impressed by how good they are. Your videos are always so incredibly well put together, written and edited, they are hilarious, and stuffed with amazing art, which you make just to be shown for only a few seconds. Judging on your video's quality you seem like a channel with over 1 million subscribers, and it is absolutely criminal how you havent even reached 1K yet. I look forward to seeing your channel grow, you deserve it. God bless!
12:40 There is some continuity between these two. Remoraid is a gun, Octillery is a cannon and both are based on aquatic animals with suction cups.
Harry Gold. Im scared of you.
How can we be sure *you* aren't an AI?
Great video! You, sir, have proven that we should be more scared of you than the AI, lol. Quick question: How do you do that 90s TV grain effect on your version of Rocko's Modern Life SpongeBob
Brilliant video showcasing your talent and comedic wit as always, while at the same time still raising some very cogent critiques about the shortcomings of AI content generation programs. Despite being one of your longest videos, it's still very rich with content from beginning to end. Wonderful work.
but can you copy the ai's art style?
Glad your back Harry, i think your channel is about to blow up and im happy for you. Also is that Humphrey Bogart
I would LOVE an in depth video describing how you break down art styles and copy them, I know you’ve talked a good amount about them but I would be super happy if you made a full fleshed out video :)
Love your work as always Harry, you deserve even more success for all of your hard work you put into your videos :)
Watching you write to the ai like a person and then it completely misunderstanding your intent kinda summarises the whole situation perfectly. and I'm not even sure if its unintentional.
Great and entertaining, as always !
Love your content man
Yeeeaaah this is the "artist using GenAI" content I've been looking for! Keep up the good work mate
Hilarious video, Feelings of AI being a scary dominator of our yet to come future have been alleviated. Also, I believe that the ending portrait is Humphrey Bogart!
Amazing job with the drawings as always! Maybe if you keep drawing enough A.I will actually have inspiration for when someone gives it a prompt like characters in different art styles
gotta love how polite harry gold is to the ai
0:18 Rosalina DDLC
I know you can. This is gonna be a great video!
19:23 Along with the identity crisis, lets add on an extesential crisis on this wacky and zaney Sonic OC!
18:23 coincidentally, Smosh once did a bit where Ian was trying to draw Sonic, only to always get things wrong in his many attempts, with one attempt having Ian accidentally give him banana shoes. I believe it’s called Inappropriate Sonic.
All of that waiting paid off. Thank you Mr. Gold for another amazing video. Also I think that might be Humphrey Bogart.
I like these videos. I spent the whole time putting a typing on all your OC-mon. Also that's Humphrey Bogart.
This channel has such amazing style
The additional feature your sonic oc needs:
To be put down
Great work as always it is interesting how limited A.I. is in what it thinks is funny. Also that's Humphrey Bogart.
I'm not even a Pokémon fan, but that Pebbling design is absolutely adorable and now will probably stay in my mind for a good while
Its a wonderful life when harry gold post
It’s always a great day when the Harry Gold Show broadcasts!
Wheel of quirks legit sounds like a great concept. 18:28 though I am thinking of it being a character or creature
Incredibly brilliant artwork, but I just wanted to say I appreciate having the Bing Image Generator be a meat grinder
4:05 this cute creature should definitely be in palworld lol xD
Did not expect dan and jake to be here lol. Great video
"Flying fish-tailed lion-duck" sounds straight out of the TLA universe.