Bon Scott DIDN'T Write Anything On Back In Black Part Three
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 10. 2023
- #acdc #bonscott #backinblack
The third and final video in my series examining the “Bon Scott Wrote Back In Black” conspiracy. I dive into some of the more serious and substantial aspects of this rock ’n’ roll narrative: the timeline in which Bon, Brian and the Young Brothers had to compose songs for Back In Black; Bon’s productivity and overall state in his final days; producer Robert John “Mutt” Lange’s possible role as a music arranger and co-songwriter; Angus Young’s conflicting quotes regarding how much Bon wrote or didn’t write in preparation for the album; the question of motive and whether or not stealing Bon’s lyrics made any sense in 1980. Finally, I discuss the importance of Back In Black and how the conspiracy undermines the legacy of Bon Scott and the band…!!
#brianjohnson #angusyoung #malcolmyoung #robertjohnmuttlange #muttlange #acdcconspiracy #backinblacklyrics #defleppard #powerage #highwaytohell #forthoseabouttorock #bonscottwrotebackinblack - Hudba
Just back from Indio. They were so damn great at powertrip! Was watching Let There Be Rock in the weeks leading up to it and Saturday's show matched the intensity, the electricity. We were shaken. Like we had witnessed the embodiment of rock n' roll yet again (stating the obvious).
Love the analysis man, great vids!
Thanks for watching and for sharing your thoughts on their Powertrip show. So awesome you witnessed it. From the setlist and clips I've seen, it looked like an epic performance. AC⚡DC forever!!!🤘🏼
@@EddyCannistracicongratulations you have attracted captain crunch to your horrible videos 👍
@@Peter_Dixon I encourage free speech. 😉
Buddy!!!! These are so good!
The topic has been one I’ve read about and was interested in the past for sure but the level of your research is commendable.
Thanks so much! I'm glad you've been enjoying the videos! 👍🏼
The level of Eddys research is that of an 8 year old doing a school project.
@@Peter_Dixon Unlike the thoughtful and well-researched arguments you’ve been throwing my way, right?
The Back in Black Album had only two writers, Bon Scott & Steven Schweinfurth Only and no others.
Sorry who is Steven Schweinfurth ?
@@rupertstreet13
The Actual Ghostwriter of ACDC
Book in the works 💪
It's always an exciting day, when a new Eddy Cannistraci video drops! Keep 'em coming strong! 💥💥👍😁
Hell yeah!! Glad you enjoy 'em, brother. 😉👍🏼
Man your days must be pretty dismal if this tripe gets you excited.
@@Peter_Dixon Thanks for the comment Peter, see ya around! Ciao!
In all of this theres also one solid factor through this entire fictional conspiracy. Harry vanda and george young.
Lyrical minders you could say.
They along with mal and angus groomed both bon and brian for ac/dcs trademark sound.
Logically there will always be similarities between the two singers because they had the same direction imprinted on them by the same teachers ( for lack of a better word)
Exactly. Because my videos dealt with the writing of BIB, I focused more on Mutt Lange's role in helping the band shape their songs, but no doubt the Vanda and Young influence was forever a part of Angus and Mal's songwriting approach. Add to the fact that George was also their older brother who was a successful musician and songwriter, it's not a stretch at all to call him "a teacher". One fact I didn't learn until after making these videos was that the songs "Rock and Roll Singer" and "Soul Stripper" were both in the band's setlist BEFORE Bon joined. Consider the lyrics in those songs: definitely what fans would perceive as "Bon Scott-esque" (especially "Rock and Roll Singer"). This isn't to take away from Bon's lyrical contributions but he was obviously given a basic framework to work within and developed his style accordingly (explaining why he never wrote anything like his lyrics in AC/DC prior to AC/DC and why Brian could likewise adapt to the this lyrical framework).
The writing time is even more unbelievable. 30 + songs where Titled & Written inside 3 hours in UCLA PICU... Bon took a few for homework.
Digging the saga! Cheers
Thanks, Marshall. It's appreciated. 👍🏼
I sound like a broken record but again, excellent video. Loved your closing words that dealt with the Young Brothers impact on Bon Scott’s and Back in Black’s legacy and vice versa. Well said.
Thanks, Joseph. It's much appreciated. 😉👍🏼
You sound like a broken Kiss record actually.
Brian Johnson wrote only 5 songs over 5 albums with Geordie and then just shart out all those great lyrics on BIB no problemo lol. And then wrote mostly word salad nonsense on every album after. Bon wouldn't have written all those lyrics on the album but you can bet your ass that the basics of those tracks would have been penned by him. Certainly enough for a credit. There is a live performance of Up To My Neck In You that is basically word for word what ended up on Powerage performed live 4 months before they recorded the album so thinking he wasn't working on lyrics for songs way before they were recorded is absurd
Brian didn’t write a full sentence for AC/DC , his non disclosure agreement gave him writing credits till ‘88 to keep his mouth shut about BIB . Once that expired his new agreement meant no more writing credits , the Youngs knew by 1981 he had no writing skills .
Bon fan boys always bring up Johnson writing 5 songs with georide but conveniently over look Bon only wrote 1 song before acdc why is that. Because it doesn't fit your narrative
@@billjames1127 And is Bon's first album his best work? No it isn't is it. It's like he got better at it but Brian got worse, I wonder why that could be. It's almost like Brian might have had some uncredited help or something.
It took less than 3 hours for 30 + songs all the song where as they came out with no do overs , it gets even more unbelievable !!
Great video as usual Eddy!
Thanks, brother, as usual. 😉
AC/DC ,And Brian Johnson are the most down to earth and honest Blokes in Rock. So if anybody thinks he didn't Write the Lyrics to Back In Black just read his Books, all Written by him no Ghost Writers involved .Then you will see what a very smart Writer he is ,so I think he is Capable of Writing a few Lyrics
Agree totally. Just watch the countless interviews Brian and Angus gave over the years to see these guys were just as bright and quick-witted as Bon. No doubt they were capable of coming up with decent lyrics.
Not that Bon would care who gets credit for those lyrics. Bon knows who wrote them and that’s all that matters.
Well, he passed away before Brian and the Young Brothers wrote the lyrics, so sadly he doesn't know (unless, of course, you believe in the afterlife). Regardless I'm sure Bon would appreciate the album being a tribute to him.
Sometimes Songwriting goes like That to come up with an album Like Back in Black Very Quickly is Just Genius. That's the Young Brothers for you .And Brian Johnsons Lyrics are equal with Bon Scott mostly about Sex
Thanks for weighing-in and totally. Most of the classic rock albums from the 1960s, 1970s and early 1980s came together quickly. It's called lightning in a bottle and AC/DC had all kinds of lightning (with both Bon and Brian).⚡
You're a Long Way from the Truth... Book coming..
The conspiracy is the fact mostly titled and written by a 14-year-old in UCLA PICU MAY 22-23 1979 without parents consent... parents would have sued and stopped it all !!
Opening this horrible video is worth the laughter just to see your comments again Steve aka captain crunch 😂😂
Back in Black is a series of 10 albums, ACDC ONLY GOT ONE ALBUM BECAUSE BON DIED. Each song on Back in Black is it's own album !! I still have the other undone albums !!
The best part of this rubbish are the words "The Conclusion" in the title. (To which for the record, I call bullshit!)
Great counter argument. Proves you read the thumbnail image. 😉👍🏼
You don't think it's the conclusion?
Your key Date is May 22-23 1979....Look at it.
Is that your first time being institutionalized?
@Peter_Dixon Lol 😆 😂 🤣 😅
I had over 1.3 million in bills !!
They told me I'd never walk correctly again, no sports, no running & no military service , Bon Scott gave my life a boost of determination, not only was I the first survivor , I worked hard to learn to pee, walk, run, I made the baseball team, AND got into The US Navy , I earned an Honerable DD214 , Bon Scott saved my life.... now it's time to set the Record Straight.... Right now you can ask questions about the songs and learn the Truth or you can ignore what I say, criticize me & go on not knowing, it's fine with me, I think your smarter and read the book before you cast a judgment, I'm willing to meet with ACDC & JOAN JETT too... ask a few questions what possibly go wrong ??
Lol 😅
Don ´t even have to wait till the end of the clip ´cause I already know I´m gonna love Part III. Keep ´em coming, Eddie. C-ya! PS If I write the word BULLSHIT will that Fink dude start a conversation?
Thanks much and "Ha!" We'll have to wait and see... 😏
OJ is innocent.
I agree with you. The theory that Bon wrote the lyrics to the Back In Black album is nothing more than a conspiracy theory with no facts or proof to back it up, just hearsay from unreliable second hand sources. The timeline basically proves that it's extremely unlikely, pretty much impossible that Bon wrote the lyrics to the BIB album. There is a lot of cognitive dissidence coming from the conspiracy theory believers who believe that Bon wrote those lyrics and that's just sad and silly. And before anyone jumps to any conclusions about my agenda here, I'm a Bon man and a huge fan of Bon's, he's my music hero and imo the best lead singer in Rock history but he didn't write the lyrics to the BIB album. PERIOD!
Thanks for watching and for commenting. And likewise, Bon is one of my favorite singers and Powerage is my favorite album of all time. But that doesn't mean I'm going to take songwriting credit away from another one of my favorite singers without any proof. And, as I made clear in this video, the "Bon Wrote BIB" theory doesn't work with the timeline or the band's established songwriting process. But you can throw facts and reason at these "Bon Wrote BIB" folks for weeks and they'll never change their mind. They like believing this narrative and therefore will never stop believing it.
You are wrong.
Bon Scott's original notes are of me and Bon Together in UCLA PICU MAY 22-23 1979 that's when most of the Bsck in Black Album was written .
R/Steve GhostofACDC and Joan Jett.
At the time of bon's passing the lyrics and music was finished!
Yeah, even though it doesn't work at all with the the timeline, band's schedule or their established song writing process and there's absolutely no proof.
Malcolm said to bon we are about Ready for you, maybe next week.
Bon wrote lyrics all the time, therefore he had a not book!
@@jonashallberg2832 Amazing research on your part. Have a link to this Malcolm quote? And yeah, they were supposed to meet back with Bon after the 15th session -- that's never been in question. Actually they were supposed to meet up on the 18th but Bon didn't show up and instead he went out that night and tragically died. You should actually watch my videos and then leave a comment. 👍🏼
Malcolm said this in an interview (you can see it on youtube)
And bon was a very popular member in Australia and Europe.
We fans came to watch
Bon and angus.then later just Angus!
In my opinion you only need the 3 first albums
With Brian, flick of the switch being the Best!
@EddyCannistraci How the hell have you never seen that Malcolm clip?! This is the 5th time in your 3 videos that you've had to ask for a link lol. You couldn't be any less interested in looking for or at anything that doesn't run parallel with your ridiculous claims. Don't get me wrong, I loved you doing the voice work as Charlie Brown's teacher, but you could give an aspirin a headache.
I think Eddy is still recovering after being dealt a massive take down from Jesse Fink in the comments to his last video. I had such high hopes for you Eddy. You make a false claim. Simon Wright did not support Angus Young’s statement. Simon Wright said Angus Young played him a demo of Bon Scott playing drums to ‘Back in Black’. A single song. Not ‘some of the Back in Black songs’. There’s an important difference. Angus Young has never said Bon Scott played drums on ‘Back in Black’. Simon Wright contradicted him! Angus Young only ever said Bon Scott played drums on two songs, the names of which change depending on the interview, and they weren’t ‘Back in Black’.
"Massive take down from Jesse Fink"? Yeah, Jesse sure put the hurt to me by insulting me and repeating the same "evidence" from his book. It was truly humiliating. I can't imagine why he wouldn't want to debate me in a video since he owns my ass so severely in CZcams comments. 😜You people are seriously living in an alternate reality. So now you're saying -- because of Simon's single quote on something that happened decades ago -- that Bon only played drums on "Back In Black" and not a handful of songs that ended up on the album, huh? I guess it's just like I said in the video: Angus has been spinning things to make it sound like Bon did more than he did.😉
Alternative reality? The only alternative reality is the one you’re living in where you believe people give a damn what you think. Why would Jesse Fink give you any more of his attention than he has already? He comprehensively tore you apart. The only research you do is taken from his book, which is 1000x more convincing than anything you have said here. After four videos, you still haven’t made a case. You know the importance of Wright’s statement about Bon playing drums on ‘Back in Black’. Angus never said Bon Scott played drums for that song, the title for the album that is supposed to be a tribute to him. You just choose what you want to use to reinforce what has turned into a losing argument. Good luck. At this rate you’ll have a sponsorship with CZcams by 2075
@@Violasobriquet This message brought to you by the Fink 🤖 2075. For more shocking truths about Bon Scott and AC/DC buy the 10th Edition of Bon the Last Highway with a brand new preface explaining how the book helped to change the legal standard for hearsay and first hand accounts.
LOL
@@EddyCannistraci Ah yes, deflection - the gambit of the great.
Being someone so gifted in believing nonsense as you are, I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if you actually think that.
Fantastic talk. You’re a real philosopher.
Great stuff as always! Back In Black rules
Thanks, brother, and hell yeah! 🤘🏼