Psychotherapist Reacts to BTS Persona, Shadow, & Ego
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 07. 2020
- Psychotherapist Reacts to BTS Persona, Shadow, & Ego with 41 year old Asian American mom friend.
[5:52] Intro: Persona
[12:57] Interlude: Shadow
[20:44] Outro: Ego
GUEST REACTOR:
1) Rhonda Richards-Smith
www.RhondaSmithLCSW.com
FB: / rhondatherelationshipe...
TW: / rhondasmithlcsw
LI: / rhondasmithlcsw
IG: / rhondasmithlcsw
My Socials:
mandarinmama.com
TW: / themandarinmama
IG: / themandarinmama
FB: / mandarinmama
BrAzn AZN:
braznazn.eventbrite.com
Noona ARMY Podcast:
• Noona ARMY Podcast
I'm a writer who stans BTS and loves them a totally normal amount. Check out my BTS think pieces:
BTS (방탄소년단) MAP OF THE SOUL: 7 ‘INTERLUDE: SHADOW’ COMEBACK TRAILER REVIEW
mandarinmama.com/bts-mots7-in...
Your Guide to Being a Middle-Aged BTS Fan
mandarinmama.com/middle-aged-...
Why BTS Winning a Billboard Music Award Matters
mandarinmama.com/bts-bbma-win...
The Grammys Snub BTS: ARMY’s Reaction Smacks of White Privilege
mandarinmama.com/grammy-snub-...
Read more about my think pieces about BTS at:
mandarinmama.com/bts
Subscribe to my channel for future videos:
/ @mandarinmama
-----------------------
Psychotherapist Reacts to BTS Persona, Shadow, & Ego
Intro: Persona: • BTS (방탄소년단) MAP OF THE...
Interlude: Shadow: • BTS (방탄소년단) MAP OF THE...
Outro: Ego: • BTS (방탄소년단) MAP OF THE...
------------------------
STREAM DAECHWITA AND AGUST D 2!!!! - Zábava
Sorry about the sound. This was filmed end of March, right when I was still figuring out how to do Zoom reactions. Now I have a process, but then, it was all new!
Well done. She needs mono, Agust D and Hope World
And Ego uses Afro beats
Was your friend able to see the subtitles?
Ac Cc she was - though they were really small on her phone. :)
Serendipity, Singularity and Epiphany next ;>
I wonder if anyone notices that
RM looks up at his persona
SUGA looks down at his shadow
Jhope looks straight at his reflection/ego.
I don't know if it's intentional but I think it's such a cool detail if it is.
Ooooooh that is super cool!!!
Wow well observed! I had not noticed. 💜⭐️
I'd actually be really surprised if that wasn't intentional; with BTS's mvs EVERYTHING has meaning :]
WOWWW hadn't noticed. Thanks for pointing that out!
I did not notice that when i first watched them🤯
People have criticized Hoseok for having such a positive attitude, calling him fake and that he’s just putting on a show. But I find it refreshing and admirable that he knows where to draw the line in what he feels he needs to show to the camera.
I think he's genuinely quirky (silly noises) and bright as the members also say that his real personality and his persona are much closer now. You can see even in run bts episiodes, jhope gets stuff Done. He's on the case and works hard with the right amount of messing about. 2nd leader :)
Thats what i have been thinking about a lot these days. You can be both. You can be nice and rude at the same time and a person shouldn’t be defined by either. Because i can be sincerely good to someone and be a bitch to someone lmao.
I used to not t like J Hope due to how over the top he was, it felt disingenuous but now I’ve realized he makes a conscious choice to be bright and that he’s is probably the most professional member. I now see him has. The one who was meant for this life, because he’s so aware of his presence as a performer and so in tune with his artistry.
J-Hope being sunshine is still him. Even though he and everyone has a persona, it doesn’t mean he isn’t himself or that isn’t a part of himself.. I don’t want people thinking he’s disingenuous just because he doesn’t show other sides of himself all the time. He and Jin are similar in that sense of love cheering people up and making people happy. Jin has said he doesn’t like showing a side of him that make people feel sad, which in turn makes him feel sad. Making people happy/smile makes him feel happy. Anyway, when J-Hope is in dance leader mode, he’s serious business :)
Yes! This exactly!
Jimin once complained that jhope should show him his other side when his struggling and not only the sunshine one.
also when he's drunk he became quiet
Didn't he admit that he made a conscious decision to be this bright happy person, full of hope, because he was so unsure and a little dark in the early days of training? I don't think he's faking or it's a show. But I think he has depths that only the members get to see, which is why they respect and listen to him and maybe even fear him a little. It's like how we get to see flirty cuddly Jimin but the members have indicated that he can be scary and we've even seen a little of that in vids of their early days. These are complicated people the way we all are but I think J-hope decided not to share that with us, which I can understand. Because, in my opinion, he's been thinking of the long game of not just being in BTS but having a solo independent career and fanbase. Of all of them, he's the one who's going to be out there as a performer for life and he's protecting that future. But we'll have to wait and see.
All of this really comes down to what he talked about on hopeworld. In regards to his identity, Piece of Peace really sums it up. While he wasn't very happy in the past, and while he still has his moments of not being happy, the knowledge that he is bringing happiness into other people's lives is the reason why he can maintain his own happiness. He's said before that being positive has helped him see more of the good sides of life and genuinely made himself more happy.
That’s one of the reasons I love BTS, they don’t put themselves into genre box like most artists do. Every album is different and we don’t know what will get from them, it’s like Christmas morning every comeback because we don’t know what sound we will get or style
Yes - they are so versatile!
I think part of it is also that he’s come to accept all the aspects of his persona. He said that he’s choosing to be a more positive person
Yes!! Great point!
nods, makes sense.
You know I’m a Hobi stan and you are honestly 100% correct when you said he’s very mysterious (I’ve just never realized it until now).
All the members have said he used to be pretty sad before debut and he himself has said that he notices how his Hobi persona bleeds into who Hoseok is. But he’s also said he wants a distinction between Hobi and Hoseok. But he very rarely shows us that part of himself.
The closest I feel we’ve ever gotten to seeing a part of Hobi outside of what he wants to show us (him being a symbol of hope and writing lyrics that talks about his aspirations, what he’s thankful for and being a beacon of hope to others) is in the track “blue side”
He literally says nothing beside “blue side” and it’s his shortest solo track but I feel like that’s as much as we’ve seen of him when he’s not happy, when he’s not hopeful, when he’s not J-hope. And we can see that even in live-streams he’ll refrain from answering questions that are too deep or anything he just doesn’t want us to know.
I wonder if he doesn’t think we’re interested to know that part of him, if he thinks we won’t like that part of him, or simply just wants to keep a part of him to himself and his friends/family
huh, interesting.
i remember there was once a question they were asked “how is your stage name different from your real self” and he said “well i’m supposed to be jung hoseok in my real life but at this point i’m jhope all the time” so i guess at this point he’s used to being j-hope so much that he’s kind of lost jung hoseok a little bit. i just hope he’s happy no matter what
It’s interesting that you talk about blue side because that song means a lot to me and I actually listen to it when I’m feeling sad and down. I use it to help me calm down and get to a stage of being content. It helps me get to a state where I’m not sad but I don’t have to try and make myself happy when i really don’t feel like it.
Aquarians are secretive in nature.
@@diamond_0613 I am an aquarius too
I think Jin is the most mysterious member of BTS, he has yet to reveal his family, has openly admitted that his persona is fake, etc. The members themselves have even said that the Jin that we see is not the Jin that they know. However, i can see why you believe J-Hope is mysterious. Great video, i love Rhonda's reaction!!!
I always thought that was interesting about jin. Like. I wonder what he's really like. Especially with him nearing 30.
Have always thought this too about Jin. Noticed it about Jhope a long time ago. He was actually my bias....why I got into BTS at all.. I saw him on American Hustle Life and he was so hardworking and charismatic. He had such leader energy and confidence so I was attracted to him. But as I got to following BTS and seeing them on shows, it became mor clear that he was going for the sunshine and sweetness jokester persona which I don't really like. I much prefer serious and focused Jhope. I still love him but now my bias is Suga. Suga is easy for me to read. He's expressive and similar to how I am as a person. I can also see why he and Jhope would work well together and be close. I honestly think that Jungkook is pretty mysterious too. He should be easy to read but he's not. How can you describe his personality? Fans seems t be conflicted. Some say he started too young and is possessive of his bandmates and immature. Some say he developed well. Of all of them, I worry about him the most. Best wishes!
I never saw interview when Jin said his persona was 'fake'. It just that he 'build' his persona. The member said that the current Jin is different than early Jin they know because he was a lot goofy now, while he was cold and charismatic before.
Honestly i think Jin was the most relatable for me. Because i always make a joke and make everyone laughing, everyone always say that i'm funny and bright. BUT i often cry.. almost every single night i cry, .. some little thing can make me hurt easily.. but nobody see that.
I'm good at hiding my feelings, and my "fake" side is a natural thing that just comes out of it. Persona is just active.
This is a bit late to reply but i just wanted to give my thought. I don't think jin's personality now is fake it's just that ppl can have different persona inside themselves. In his case i think he might have the quiet introvert persona but also have the more cheerful persona too it's just that he shows army the cheerful side more than his introvert side. But now he seems to be more open up a little with his struggle and share it with us. Actually a lot introvert that i have met except for myself are like that, they know when to have limit about what to share with ppl by having bounderies. Most of the time It's not that we tried to bottled up our feeling it's just tht we don't want to share it and keep it to ourselves and ppl that are really close only because sometime there part of ourselves that was meant to be just for us.
Actually I'd say that we know a lot about J-Hope.
He's from a loving family (his mother worked 3 jobs to help support him on his dream to become a dancer, and he's very close to his sister). His sister is very pretty, looks astonishingly like him, and is a rather successful fashion designer. He has a puppy called Mickey that he loves a lot. He has dealt with depression since before debut days, but he has found that the persona J-hope has helped him with this because it taught him how to focus on the positives in life. He gets great strength from the other members, and acts very affectionately towards them. Behind the scenes, he takes care of them and helps support them to the level where RM calls him the second leader of BTS.
He Adores. Dance. He says that he feels music in his body, which is why he loves to dance so much, and he expresses his emotions through dance quite often as well. Whether it's as a joke or out of excitement, J-hope leaps at a chance to move.
He is a little insecure about how he looks from people calling him ugly in the past, but like the other members has grown to embrace himself and his appearance. He takes great comfort in the fans, seeing them as a part of why he has been able to become J-hope. His old tagline of 'I'm your hope, I'm your angel, J-Hope' became 'I'm your hope, you're my hope, I'm J-hope' due to the support he got during their many tours.
He doesn't like making mistakes, which is one of the reasons why he focuses so hard on his dance.
He's very willing to take risks and try new things, even if it scares him. That's how he got into rap, he jumped into rap battles without any experience just to give it a go. Same goes for his music production.
Despite this, he is easily startled and scared, which always makes for some hilarious reactions in nearly any tense/scary scenario. A good example of this is the flinch game on James Corden, or the time he had to pose with a snake for some photos. Despite both of these things, he still gave it his best shot and committed to it.
He's known for having many hidden talents, leading to the members giving him the nickname of Golden Hyung, similar to JK's Golden Maknae. He doesn't really show off many of them, but every now and then he'll do something cool. The members say that he doesn't like making a big deal of it.
He's proud of his hometown of Gwangju, and has referenced the uprising that happened there quite a few times, as well as embraced his Jeolla dialect. He is still proud of his time in Neuron, his street dance team from pre-BTS days, again, referencing them often.
He loves fashion, especially bright and unique items. This usually makes him easy to pick out when he's in his casual wear. He also adores interesting bags and shoes for similar reasons.
He's more private than some of the members, but by no means does he keep anything to himself.
cool, ty for the info.
Thanks
I'm really glad that Yoongi talks about the topics he did in Shadow. In fact I'm proud of all of BTS for breaking those standards of being perfect idols and just being real with their fans on how they feel being at the top.
It must be such a great form of relief. Because they do this, they stay humble. They know their own flaws. That's such an amazing thing that you don't see very often.
I think I've only seen one or two other reactors understand/acknowledge how devastating Shadow's lyrics are... everyone else is just like, "man, that beat slaps!" or "that switch up though!" or think it's somehow just a flex song. :-( I cried after reading the lyrics the first time and a few times since... and my initial reaction was "can someone please check on Yoongi and give that man a long hug?!" LOL Maybe it just hits me harder since I am someone who has lived with the 'shadow' of depression/anxiety for 30 years and can relate to it on a certain level. Obviously not the fame/success part, but the knowledge that my brain chemistry will never let me feel completely happy and learning to accept it as a part of me.
Your analysis of J-Hope is SO spot on! I agree with you that he’s the most mysterious member, in that he’s the very private and holds the strongest boundaries. He’s also my bias! 😅 But I don’t simply like him for his “sunshine” persona; I actually really appreciate his discipline as an artist and how he protects his private life.
I feel like we know a decent amount about Jhope, Like he told us a lot about his childhood, and his family life growing up, and he's one of the few members that introduced us to his siblings. He has songs about the stuff he's gone through.
@@jordanjackson788 Yeah, I think it's a mix of open/mysterious, IMO Jin is more 'mysterious'. Though it depends in certain areas the more I think about it.
Thank you for introducing their mots era to a psychotherapist, it's interesting and fun hearing different approach about it. And I love your explanation too.
May all of you stay healthy, and happy :)
Thank you so much! Blessings to you, too!
idk why but I've never really listened to all 3songs back to back like this, they're usually mixed into whatever playlist I'm listening to. Really interesting, even though I know that their personalities always shine through in their music, the distinction in their personalities and how they see things is really highlighted when u listen to them back to back. I mean like I said I knew this idk why it's hitting me different today, idek if I'm making sense rn lolz
Yes! Totally makes sense. I always think of the three songs as a triptych meant to be listened together. (Though listening to the Persona album straight thru so much, I always expect to hear BWL right after Persona!)
I think because they do many genres is why they appeal to so many different age groups, plus their whole ethos speaks to all ages, which is also why we love them so much. 💜💜
Yes! All the genres!!
@@MandarinMama yeah, i love that about them. 💜
Ohh, i enjoyed watching this a lot :) for vocal line you could show your friend different stages - with Jimin Lie to Promise (self acceptance), with Tae Singularity to Inner Child and\or Winter bear \Scenery (finding your way), with Jin from Awake to Moon (popularity and talent), with JK Begin to My time (growing up). The only thing I'd suggest is provide the lyrics for better analysis, as we all know reading the subs when you're not used to can be quite overwhelming :)
Thx for the recs!!! I appreciate it!
I totally agree with what you said about j-hope. For me him and jin are the ones that we know very little and they make us feel like we do know but we actually don't hahaha is admirable tbh
Jhope ‘s other persona comes out when he is drunk..😆 just kidding 🙏
Haha i also love that side of him. He's just even more adorable 😂
Omg! Why are you doing this 😂 like I already laugh thinking about it
😂😂😂 I just imagined drunk Hobi
I am still in awe at how BTS music and mv appeal to different disciplines and genres. I love looking for videos related to BTS, especially reaction videos, and I am really amazed at how historians, professors, classical musicians, literature teachers, producers, and vocal coaches could find something about BTS songs and mvs that they could relate to and discuss and be impressed with it.
On the documentaries, JHope said that he is happy and thankful for this life. He himself doesn't know exactly who he is and is trying to figure it out. He is not acting nor faking. He is in the middle of journey to find who he really is, which is very normal and healthy.
Great reaction Virginia and Rhonda!💜 💜💜 Our boys seem to have captured another one.😀 I really enjoyed seeing the rappers through Rhonda's eyes. With the love and protectiveness that we feel for them I think that we can sometimes miss the other aspects of their personalities coming through. Once Rhonda asked if JHope was being tongue in cheek I SAW IT! Sunshine is so known for his joyousness that we get blinded to his other traits. Looking at Ego with this new perspective makes me like it even more. I so LOVE me a good wink and a nod. Thanks for giving us a reaction with a bit of a clinical mental aspect! It was an eye opener for me, at least. Keep up the wonderful work and great collaborations!💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Thank you so much! And yes! Once Rhonda pointed it out, I was like OF COURSE!
this is so informative reaction with miss Rhonda looking forward to watch her react to BTS song like whalien52,Love maze,Butterfly,tomorrow,21st cent gil, dead leaves, and alot more also each rapline members solo mixtape and vocals members too.
we cherish such meaningful reaction with people getting to know BTS. thank you so much
Thx for the recs!!
@@MandarinMama waiting for another BTS reaction miss Virginia im watching together with my kids.
I think the horse thing was just a joke that the members said in a teasing way. If you have siblings then you’ve probably had those moments were you tease each other, maybe something they said or did or how they looked that day reminded you of something else like an animal or an object or whatever it is, but it was trolls that took things out of hand and so the guys stopped doing it and also told “fans” who kept doing it and trolls to stop. Tae even addressed it on Weverse and made his displeasure very clear when some people posted “unappealing” photos on Weverse of the members. It’s also another reason they stopped rating members. Not so recently when Jungkook was asked to do it, he only put Jimin first, and left it at that
I had the volume up all the way, and then the Bighit intro came on and my eardrums exploded :^)
tbch- I was expecting a different type of commentary based on the title of the video and the intro like perhaps it would be a, loose, chat re Jungian Theory as it relates to BTS'works but I appreciated the content regardless. I loved that she clarified her feild right away- its the only reason I watched the while [edit:whole] vid! 😭 This was still so different- in that, your guest actually asked questions and seemed genuinely engaged in the conversation :) loved that! At any rate- thank you for sharing your love for the boys and a special thanks to your guest for being open to your efforts and passion 🥰. BORAHAE!! ARMYs always need folks like your guest 💜
Very entertaining and interesting, please do more. Always good to hear how people interpret the lyrics, styles and genres that B.T.S. go through.
One of the biggest appeals for me is the fact that you never know whats coming next! They have the most diverse and entertaining back catalogue as well as solo mix tapes and collaborations. In 7 years they have put out more meaningful content than almost anyone else ,even those who have been around significantly longer. Pick an album and find me a "filler" track because I cant find one, they seem to put everything into every single song and boy does it show.
J-Hope has really grown into such an attractive man. He has an incredible personality. Definitely our sunshine.
I absolutely enjoyed your video:)
and the fact that she didn't just observe all of the messages of each songs though it's her first time, she also went all into knowing their personalities and was so appreciative and supportive.
I luv her already T-T THANKS FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO.
You’re welcome! Thank you for watching!
Mandarin Mama ❤️❤️🥺
Wow that was so interesting to watch. Couldn’t really see the lyrics to keep up so I will now watch the videos again for the umpteenth time! jHope definitely understands the difference between his persona and self but accepts them as him. His upbeat character is him. His quiet side is also him. He actively entertains ARMY. He talks to the others a lot about pacing themselves and being professional...and he watches out for the others though often lets the younger guys do the hugs and comforting... but you can see he watches and notices how everyone is feeling. Though he says he feels the pressure of always staying ‘upbeat’ cos that’s now expected of him, in his lives this year I think he has let his guard down more. He’s been on screen dancing without talking, just being quiet and introspective. In his birthday live he talked about wanting to have someone to cherish..and about how he’s sensitive about love. This man Jung Hoseok has hidden depths. 💜
I don't think you even needed to the psychotherapy angle to get Ms. Rhonda hooked! I think she's an up and coming ARMY! Definitely do more videos with her!! I love my fellow ADULT BIPOC ARMY! Great video!
I am happy that she got it on Shadow. And I realized that whoever designated each song to each member is genius! RM open the cycle with a question, Persona, like he questioning all things around him. Then Suga following up with Shadow, like a topic he digs and know better. Then Ego with Jhope....a conclusion which open a gesture of 'hope'. Even the opening was Jhope emerge from 'shadow'. Its amazing. Really2 genius.
I love this reaction! Thank you for the awesome content!!!💜💜💜💜💜
You’re welcome!
Wow. I absolutely loved hearing her take on things! Loved loved loved. I’m looking forward to hearing more from her!!
Thank you so much!
Very excited for this video- I’m not where I can stream it but will save it to watch later!! So cool to have a psychotherapist respond!!
Yes! She’s sooooo smart!!
Thank you for reacting 😁 it's always nice and refreshing to see other people react to bts' song and also learn new things, their song holds so much meaning and emotion that it gets through you. 💜
Oooo I loved this a lot! I hope she can come back and do more reactions with you -- her perspective is fascinating!
Thank you so much! We have one more in the queue!
I wonder what she would think about JK's My Time? Btw, I love this idea! Loved hearing what Dr Richards-Smith had to say. Btw, there's a podcast called Speaking of Jung that have covered the Map of the Soul series by interviewing the author of Jung's Map of the Soul if you're interested!
Oooooh!! Thanks for the rec!
I’ve listened to that podcast! Very interesting and informative 🙂
I DEFINITELY wanna see more!🤩
Yay!! Thx!!
I love reactions where the art of their lyrics and the message the songs portrays is also part of the conversation. 💜 Thank you.
I would love to see more reactions from you two
Hey Mama, just a note: you can make your cc's a lil bigger. I could barely make them out and your guest was kind of squinting, LOL
Thanks for the suggestion!
@@MandarinMama My pleasure. I hope I'm not being to forward or acting like I'm telling you what to do; it's just I wear reading glasses ans I couldn't make them out at all.
Bridgette _McCaskill she was actually watching on a phone so she couldn’t see them well. But also, I didn’t know we could change the font size and it helps MY eyeballs so thank you!
I'd love to see more reactions with Rhonda!! You guys have some very deep and interesting conversations!
this is a very fun and cool video!! please make more
I can't believe i finished this 30 minutes video hahahahaha didn't noticed the length until i finished it. Hope you make more videos like this •3•
Lol! I totally understand if you end up watching videos on double speed - but thank you so much for watching the whole thing! That's quite a commitment!
More of you both please!
As much as I love your detailed introduction to Rhonda & her reactions to the mvs, absolutely loving the comment section. It's lit!
i loved her reaction and the whole video ! Hope I can watch more episodes of you introducing her more BTS songs with personal lyrics like reflection, the last , sea, tomorrow or something like love myself series
This was a lovely video!
I want more of these kinda reactions 😌
This is one of my favorite BTS reviews! Thank you. ☺️🌻
Wow, thank you!
I'm really enjoying this video. Thank you for both of you 😘. I want to see that she watches Blood Sweat and Tears.
Wow I’d definitely love to see both of your opinions on the rest of the members solo songs!
I loved this!!! such an interesting idea and as a psychology student it was really nice to watch it
I really liked this a lot. If you can do more, I'd love it a lot! Borahae 💜
Thank you so much!
I've been looking for something like this, a professional who reacts and comments on BTS MV's and music. Thank you so much!
You’re welcome!
I loved it! Please I wanna see more!🤩😍
Thank you so much!
I love it and I hope you show your friend Dr. Smith reaction to the vocal line.😊
Yes! We definitely watched one. Will see if she has time for more. :)
ms. rhonda is so beautiful. i'd love to see her more. 💜 intro persona's concept is more of wanting to understand who he is... is the persona taking over who he really is. interlude shadow is more of trying to run away from his "monsters" in the form of fame, media, even fans (mainly toxic ones) and in interlude shadow, the shadow tries to tell him that he's part of the SELF. and then ego is where it comes together... all parts of the SELF and being confident about it (including the persona and shadow). that's why outro is the... outro. these 3 songs are all connected. 💜 and each member expresses the 3 parts of self very concisely.
Clearest boundaries: Suga. Hands down! Thinking about it, Jin is my bias but I agree we know the least about his parent and personal life but I don't have a problem with them having a private life. I enjoy his singing, performances, his personality (funny and very generous/kind) and his relationship with the other members. Just because he's not so open with the juicy details, he still gives a lot for the Army.
Its their message, I always come back because of their message. It's empowering, it's eye-opening. To me they are Idols of Life. Thank you for sharing this, it made me feel warm and fuzzy inside, and I cried all over again :')
I love ms. Rhonda’s point of view with the videos.. thank you. 😊
Great one! Thank you for your time! Both of you! 💛💛💛💛🙏
wow i love this reaction video as always Miss. Virginia Duan MANDARIN MAMA gives us such great reactionsnbeyond what we expect and Someone knows how to asses a person. Thanks alot Miss Rhonda.
I am looking forward for alot of reactions from here miss Virginia also with your other Friend that reacted to Dimple.💜💜💜
Thank you so much!!!
The hardest part of me explaining about the whole BTS world to my friend is the struggle to hold myself from getting too emotional and bursting out tears.
i really appreciate this reaction and comments!!! thank you so much! 💜💜
I would love to see Rhonda again with other member's solo tracks.
Also, I wish there could be a whole series psychoanalyzing Hobi because I was just enjoying the crap outta you explaining him to Ms. Rhonda! Better tell her be careful. Once you start researching them its OVER...you're ARMY!
Loved it!
Thank you so much!
oh, now i need a vocal line reaction !!
BTW, love that you are presenting 3 songs and getting feedback from a psychotherapist's POV. Thank you for the reaction.
Thank you so much!
@@MandarinMama you look too young to be your age, love your hair color
That was interesting. This was my 1st listen to these 3 songs. I plan to listen to them om my own. I am not a fan of rap but i liked J-Hope's vibe. I am a former Peer Advocate and I work with my therapist weekly. I deal with anxiety and depression. I am a cancer survivor. I am trying to get her to listen to BTS and tell me what she thinks, lol. Suga talks about social anxiety and depression in his solo's which i think is cool. You know i never hot the impression that J-Hope was mysterious. He loves his family and is real close to them. He loves the band members. He wants to give us hope and give us positive energy that's a really hard thing to choose to be. He is a great dancer & rapper and singer. He is a light in the group that makes me feel good and warm. He is who he is to me. =0] P.S. My bias is Jimin!
Oh my gosh keep bringing her back we love herrrrrrr 😂💜
Her schedule permitting, I'd love to have her guest again! We have one more in the queue. :)
So excited for this.
I should be sleep but i's 4 am and I am here for it.
I'll re-edit my msg after this. Thank u for keeping up the efforts to introduce bts music to all types of ppl around u especially feedback from ppl from other professionals which I'm intrigue to get to know more. So, as from me all these 3 song spoke to me n I feel different vibe from all these 3 from mot albums. For persona, literally it's my most favourite song from namjoon besides his mixtape mono. Talk who the hell am I, confusion with perception surrounding influence n judging, reaffirm who rm is with all the avatar namjoon references mini namjoon along with all the robotic faceless ppl around. Society norm seeking ppl to either blend in or the choices n fear of stand out. All choices lead to different outcome n responsibility. Take it n responsible to own choice with faith n improvement accordingly without back out ur original decision n intention. Its tough thou. For interlude shadow, honestly it's so me. I deeply love this song when it came out either from how the lyric, melody or artiscally how the mv shot, it hit me so much. Shadow is part of who we r but how we aware the presence of it n how to minimise the influence it got on our mindset its very crucial. Shadow doesn't necessarily bad thing but we need to watch out the presence of unpleasant, negative worry n doubt then make good use of it to face challenges in right attitude. From shadow it somehow connect to me to the vibe of agust d 's daechwita vibe, I'm getting the vibe he's killing his old self but from i felt connecting to shadow he is killing his negative influence powering shadow, or the appropriate term would be break free of shadow consuming influences just like the last scene of bts's black swan art film. From the strunggle to disconnect from the shadow, turning into aware, manipulate shadow to move like him, to the level embracing good deeds of shadow, break free from negativity for good. That's how i felt from the mv n song itself complement to one another. Last but not least ego, j hope ll always be our sunshine j hope presenting the subject of ego in fun n festive moods in more cherish persentation. Listening only to the song, u couldn't imagine his lyric is so deep talking abt self finding subject, he shows the bright side of how things going to be. Just like his smile n bright persona, he project the issue of ego in light, festive beat with firm attitude behind heavy pressure of ego topic 👌💜👏👏if just like what ur friend's sharing that j hope is comfortable with boundaries n set to protect his personal side. I m glad n respect his decision as long as he is happy. What I worry is ll he got the perception that if he speak out n show out who he is, he become vulnerable n the possibility of having the fear of losing ppl 's love n care for him if ever he's not that sunshine bright j hope anymore. If he is happy for who he is, I'm happy for him n all army want is his happiness n not surpressing himself for the sake of bts best interest. Not everyone can be 24/7 positive n bright. Im ok if ever a mistake coming from j hope n im totally fine with it. The pressure to be excellent n improvement is good not to the level of pressuring him to be the suffocating perfectionist. I trust bts ll be all right with each other support n companion waking down this journey togather 💜 he doesn't like to relate to horse things but he choose horse like figure character of bt21 mang to embrace positive persona of horse itself not by how horse look
I liked the reaction, I want analysis on other members too)
Yes they are talking about the struggle between themselves like what they truly are inside and what others see like when they are on stage or before cameras so they want to know who they really are
A good watch, thank you guys.♥️
That was really interesting, I liked the way you perfectly described J-hope and I totally agree.
It was cool too see that woman interested into them 🤗 I hope she'll come back, I'd love to watch her reaction to 'Black swan', 'Spring day' and 'Fake love'.
I loved the video! If you do another one with zoom, maybe it would be nice to enlarge the subtitles on the videos in order for the other person to see them better :)
Thanks for the suggestion!
BTS have take me here to enjoy this great reaction and I really loved it!! ✨
BTS help themselves and others to listen our own heart of uman beings and spread love instead of hate.
In this years all of them grew up and l'm glad to see them shine in this world and in this life. I enjoying seeing people shine thanks to their music and messages. And in this video I saw a very warm and kind light, I really appreciate.
I'm really sorry if there are grammar mistakes in my comment.😅 I'm watching from Italy!!🇮🇹
Please film more videos showing your friends BTS songs, such as Whalien 52, The Truth Untold, 134310, Spring Day and other solos like Lie, My Time, and Singularity!! I really enjoyed your cooperative ideas and commentary 💜
Calypso R.-S. If you check out the BTS Playlist, it’s full of reactions with friends - many of them to the songs you mentioned. :) and Thank you for watching!
This is such a good idea!! Thanks so much for the reaction haha 💜
You’re welcome!
I love the Doctor. She is just so kind. She got it when our girl got a bit emotional and she just listened and responded in the way that she is getting it all. That was so beautiful.
I enjoyed listening to this reaction while at work! I wish there was a time for her to see Chicken Noodle soup!
I think the same thing. Hope is definitely the most mysterious. He has layers. He's like an open book but some of the pages are stuck together. Although this goes for every member, we can never truly know what goes in the mind of J-Hope. He seems to balance his personal and professional roles very well and is the epitome of Ego, the union of the Shadow and Persona.
Don't forget the whole time we (Army) comments on "Jay" vs. J-hope. When "Jay" whips out his forehead & is so much more confident. I think he hides even more of himself in Korea. He seems to soak up the positive compliments. Love your reactions ~
her feedback on Ego is so interesting!!
A great reaction, and really interesting too
Thank you so much!
I do love it when Namjoonie🐨💜 and Suga💜 open up and sing, rap talk about how they're feeling. But your right J-hope💜 is very mysterious. I would LOVE💜 to know more about him. I hope that one day when hes ready he can tell us more about himself whether its through music or whatever.
I loved this!!
Please do more reaction video with Ms. Rhonda. I like it 👍🏻👍🏻
Yeah Persona is based off of the book Carl Jung’s Map of the Soul, its the biggest reason I like BTS, the story telling component and the inspiration from literature and psychology all of it fusing together into their artistry. Especially RM’s song though is full of references throughout BTS’ career so its double the references.
i loved this!
Thx!
omg she is so beautiful!!!
I'm so glad I came across this video. I'm sick of fake reactors who use BTS videos for views and subs. Yours is really interesting, I checked your uploads and saw you did podcasts and introduce BTS to other people of all types. I can't wait to check those out. Thanks so much Unnie! This channel is a breath of fresh air. I'll recommend this channel to my ARMY friends. More powers!
If you ever have Ms Rhonda back for another reaction (especially since you said you want to show her more of suga/agust d), maybe you could bring up:
- yoongi said he's studying psychology because he wants to be able to help other people/fans who went through some similar things to him, and this attitude colours a lot of bts songs that bring comfort to the fans (this is probably influenced by rm as well I think)
- j-hope always starts his introduction by saying "I'm your hope, I'm j-hope" as a way to explain his public persona
I hope you'll show her The Last at some point too 💜
I think the next series of 3 should be Boy With Luv - Persona, Black Swan - Shadow and ON - Ego. Show her the group.
this was a great video. very interesting to see these reactions.
also the caption font seemed small. i felt like Miss Rhonda had difficulty in reading the lyrics.
Thx for the suggestion!
RM has actually mentioned that they changed the name recently and the BTS stands for beyond the scene now and they actually all write and produce music for their albums as well there own solo songs
the meaning changed only in the acronym. in korea is still the original
@@magaliscarsi yes I knew that... I should of explained better
Awesome!