Shaq Was BRUTALLY Honest With JJ Redick…

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 1. 05. 2024
  • Today, Shaq and JJ share their takes on this season’s NBA Awards.
    Subscribe to The Big Podcast CZcams Channel to watch more episodes
    Full Episode: • DaBaby Opens Up About ...
    Follow us on all platforms : linktr.ee/bigpodcast
    #shaq #shaquilleoneal #bigpodcast #jjredick #basketball #mvp

Komentáře • 842

  • @Carlostothe24
    @Carlostothe24 Před 15 dny +1171

    Shaq saying only players should vote. Yah Give Perk and Arenas votes, thats a great idea 😂

    • @sobhansyed4482
      @sobhansyed4482 Před 15 dny +19

      I think perk does vote

    • @samfc23
      @samfc23 Před 15 dny +106

      perk voted for embiid over jokic lol

    • @ItsYuhBoyyyy
      @ItsYuhBoyyyy Před 15 dny +124

      @@sobhansyed4482and that’s a problem

    • @KRajah-lg6ix
      @KRajah-lg6ix Před 15 dny +20

      @@samfc23I wonder why?

    • @ichirosuzuki2252
      @ichirosuzuki2252 Před 14 dny +23

      @@samfc23 If not for Embiid's injury, he would have been the MVP imo, and I am a big Jokic guy that thought he should have threepeated

  • @IJudgeYou
    @IJudgeYou Před 14 dny +303

    only shaq can disagree with his own opinion while never admitting he was ever wrong

    • @stbsole
      @stbsole Před 11 dny +8

      That alone is a factor as to why he hasn’t been contacted for mvp vote

    • @christianluu2994
      @christianluu2994 Před 9 dny

      Hes most dominant thats why

  • @mobeanbilal1529
    @mobeanbilal1529 Před 15 dny +344

    "why'd you say Charlotte"🤣🤣

    • @pedrosotil3232
      @pedrosotil3232 Před 14 dny +37

      real ones know JJ is trying out to be a coach in Charlotte next season lmao

    • @jonathanchan1365
      @jonathanchan1365 Před 14 dny +2

      @@pedrosotil3232 what about lakers lol

    • @rayleigh8
      @rayleigh8 Před 14 dny

      This guy is a Jordan hater. Why is Jordan allowing this?. Does MJ no longer has any control on that team?.

    • @twojuanoh1437
      @twojuanoh1437 Před 14 dny +20

      @@rayleigh8 MJ sold the team fam

    • @phannypharts
      @phannypharts Před 14 dny +2

      Huge mistake if Charlotte sign him.

  • @Justjefe
    @Justjefe Před 14 dny +267

    I swear JJ in every basketball podcast 😂

    • @edfgc
      @edfgc Před 14 dny +12

      Is his job bro, its not surprising

    • @user-vy6gy6pw9m
      @user-vy6gy6pw9m Před 14 dny +1

      From some bizarre reason on a football podcast on the same day 😮

    • @marshall3278
      @marshall3278 Před 13 dny +5

      He is the literal worst; stood in the corner waiting for his defender to leave him open for a 3 his entire career...and now wantss to lecture us on X's and O's lol

    • @gabrielrojas5550
      @gabrielrojas5550 Před 13 dny +21

      @@marshall3278just say your a casual. There’s a science on getting open at the 3

    • @marshall3278
      @marshall3278 Před 13 dny +1

      @@gabrielrojas5550 There is also a science to making a PB&J but that doesn't mean that a 5-year old couldn't do it

  • @gennarocollidi1329
    @gennarocollidi1329 Před 14 dny +354

    “ Kobe should’ve had more” love how Shaq never forgets his boy

    • @kjaykingMVP
      @kjaykingMVP Před 14 dny

      LIKE FUCK DUNCAN 🤣🤣 lol na can’t do that to TIM 🦾

    • @ElevatorErnie1
      @ElevatorErnie1 Před 14 dny +12

      Except he doesn't deserve more

    • @tankeater
      @tankeater Před 14 dny +21

      ​@@ElevatorErnie1you're the ignorance we're referring to. 👍

    • @ElevatorErnie1
      @ElevatorErnie1 Před 14 dny +2

      @@tankeater what years did he deserve it, humor me

    • @tankeater
      @tankeater Před 14 dny +13

      @@ElevatorErnie1 second year Nash won in 06 and 07 when Dirk won... Now humor me and tell me how they're better those years over KOBE. You know, an individual award without talking about their teams. HUMOR ME, because I didn't make you laugh... But you sure will make me laugh.

  • @alvin081988
    @alvin081988 Před 15 dny +395

    Even Stephen A Smith who doesn't watch games has a power to vote for the awards

    • @paralleluniverse99
      @paralleluniverse99 Před 15 dny +67

      Shaq also doesn't watch games and is extremely limited in his basketball knowledge.

    • @TheSlithice
      @TheSlithice Před 15 dny +33

      @@paralleluniverse99 Shaq still understands the game way more than SAS tho.

    • @zeff717
      @zeff717 Před 15 dny +44

      ⁠@@paralleluniverse99The guy that played for 15 years has limited knowledge? I get he can be a clown sometimes but let's be serious

    • @Atribecalledsuccess
      @Atribecalledsuccess Před 15 dny

      Alvin doesn’t even get the nba in his country

    • @AllThingsKen
      @AllThingsKen Před 14 dny

      @@paralleluniverse99 bro even you dont believe this dumb sheet

  • @krinniv7898
    @krinniv7898 Před 14 dny +77

    "Earthlings" I just died 😂😂

    • @MistyKathrine
      @MistyKathrine Před 14 dny +5

      He took shots at Stephen Smith and Shannon Sharpe.

  • @MrSimonatra
    @MrSimonatra Před 14 dny +96

    People still not respecting Jokic's performance, it's insane.

    • @shredderhector9261
      @shredderhector9261 Před 13 dny +7

      Because people want to see amazing highlights. Joker is killing everyone but because he doesn’t dunk on people, it’s always considered a “quiet” game even when the dude gets 30-10-8. He reminds me of a new age Duncan. Just goes about his business, and his team wins.

    • @dedicatedjohn
      @dedicatedjohn Před 3 dny

      Not the case. Just ironic that a white man is dominating the league and gets all his deserved awards. “Now” it’s all about voting right lmao 🤦🏾‍♂️

  • @WindowLicker_-9
    @WindowLicker_-9 Před 15 dny +266

    Shaq is dead wrong. How many HOFers actually watch all the games? What if a voter doesn't watch Bucks games and doesn't know if Giannis is deserving or not?
    That's ludicrous. And don't act like former players don't make it their life's mission to hate on today's players. None of them can be trusted to be honest

    • @benhoward9572
      @benhoward9572 Před 14 dny

      This is exactly what is happening now with the media as voters. They don't watch small market teams and there are definitely media members that hate on specific teams and players

    • @SupaNatural28
      @SupaNatural28 Před 14 dny +4

      I'm pretty sure the people who have votes have a criteria they would have to follow to have that vote.

    • @4purs
      @4purs Před 14 dny +6

      @@SupaNatural28 they rly don’t

    • @SupaNatural28
      @SupaNatural28 Před 14 dny

      @4purs how you know? Cause they put in a criteria to where even to be eligible to win an award you have to play 65 games

    • @onlyfacts3178
      @onlyfacts3178 Před 14 dny

      @@SupaNatural28 its called agendas with their bosses.
      you know that all black voters put SGA over LUKA (C.broussard was the only one who voted for LUKA over SGA).

  • @zennihilator3724
    @zennihilator3724 Před 15 dny +190

    How can Shaq be the best ORL big man with only 4 seasons with the franchise? Nah, that's pure ego. Gotta give it to Dwight, he was there 8 years, leads the franchise in most stats, peaked as a 23/14 guy with DPOY defense, went to the Finals without anyone as good as Penny on his team...

    • @Parodyzrus
      @Parodyzrus Před 15 dny +48

      By Shaqs logic MJ is the greatest Washington wizard of all time 😂

    • @terancem6240
      @terancem6240 Před 15 dny +20

      Depends how you look at it. History and numbers, Dwight. Shaq looks at it as he's better than Dwight (facts) therefore he was the best big man orlando ever had. Both make sense.

    • @generalwipe3955
      @generalwipe3955 Před 15 dny +6

      @@Parodyzruslmao he might be

    • @dion4670
      @dion4670 Před 15 dny +9

      @@Parodyzrus Wizards team so trash since the beginning of time MJ with 1 leg might just be their best guy.

    • @murktee
      @murktee Před 15 dny +5

      MJ was the greatest wizard he averaged 30 lmao

  • @CCCoNeTiMe
    @CCCoNeTiMe Před 14 dny +27

    'SGA baddest boy in the league.' 🤣🤣🤣
    There in one sentence why all players should not vote.

  • @AidanXavier988
    @AidanXavier988 Před 14 dny +27

    JJ commands space for himself so well. I notice Shaq can dominate interviews at times (which is fair), but JJ recognizes it's a conversation and the back & forth is far more fruitful this way.

  • @DrewNoV87
    @DrewNoV87 Před 15 dny +66

    I think the key word in MVP isn't player, but value. How do you assign value to the best players in a league full of the greatest players. It's their contribution towards a winning environment. Steve Nash the years he won it, was not because he was the best player, but he was the focus of their team synergy. He made their engine run. So which individual player has the most effect on their team playing winning basketball.

    • @Jarlaxled-wg6wj
      @Jarlaxled-wg6wj Před 15 dny +3

      Shaq disagrees (doesn't matter your valid point).

    • @ichirosuzuki2252
      @ichirosuzuki2252 Před 14 dny +9

      Also it's easier to put up impressive numbers on a trash team. If you shine on a stacked team it's more impressive, or if you are COMPLTELY carrying a team you shine too

    • @str8nashtygaming466
      @str8nashtygaming466 Před 14 dny +4

      That's what the award should be. It should be what's the team's ceiling with player X and what's their floor without them. That's how you'd ascertain their "value".

    • @onlyfacts3178
      @onlyfacts3178 Před 14 dny

      @@str8nashtygaming466 NASH would go to the bench winning by 20 and they would go down to 2 points.
      A couple of days ago LUKA went to the bench with the game 15-10...all of a sudden the game turn into 24-10...KYRIE was on the floor and couldnt create anything.
      MAVS start losing by 33 points and KYRIE starts scoring.
      Next game KYRIE scoreless in the 1st quarter..later MAVS are winning by 20 and Thats when KYRIE scores 16 points.
      SO a lot of player have their stats on trash minutes.
      THATS why VALUE over replacement is a great stat to show who is really valuable or not.

    • @alvarojavier6274
      @alvarojavier6274 Před 14 dny

      @@onlyfacts3178exactly how it should be because players can’t control if the organization build a good roster around them. For me it’s more impressive and more valuable a player that brings the team from the 15th seed to the playoffs than a guy who makes a 3/4 seed a first spot team, both are superstars and really good players, but one is definitely more valuable. Since the MVP is a regular season award, we can’t take into account the playoffs hence we can’t consider if a player is so valuable to his team to make them win a championship

  • @rafiu7660
    @rafiu7660 Před 15 dny +80

    Cmon JJ, he knows it's Dwight for the Magic. He should be backing his teammate, Dwight was a monster in his Magic days. Shaq and Kobe literally ruined this guys reputation. How did Dwight not make the top 75 but Dame, CP3 and Melo did? I have nothing against those guys, but their accolades do not even come close to Dwight's and the main reason for Dwight not to get the recognition he deserves is because of the fact that Shaq always ridiculed him on national television and Kobe thought Dwight was lazy. Kobe also thought that Shaq was lazy but Shaq is still a top 3 centre ever. Is a shame seeing Dwight's old teammates also not speaking up for him, when Dwight always seems like a positive guy, was a monster defensively and covered a lot of his teammates mistakes singlehandedly, and literally carried that Magic team to the finals. Oh yeah, he also won a ring with the Lakers in which he was not riding the bench, but was a key player in some games too.

    • @HondoHoss77
      @HondoHoss77 Před 14 dny +8

      Fax. Dwight was generational. (Low key)

    • @skylertaylor7283
      @skylertaylor7283 Před 14 dny +5

      Lol did you really just try to throw in CP3 with Dame and Melo? CP3 is another stratosphere from those guys and Dwight

    • @dashontutt1969
      @dashontutt1969 Před 14 dny

      Dwight should definitely be top 75 but i feel like dame the only one out of the 3 you named that we can debate shouldn't have gotten in. But howard too 50 frfr

    • @AndresGomez-ct7qb
      @AndresGomez-ct7qb Před 14 dny

      @@HondoHoss77 Yeah, and that's while having one of the worst diets known to man. If only he had actually tried...

    • @lukakaps9548
      @lukakaps9548 Před 14 dny +4

      Dwight is not above CP3. And CP3 doesn't belong with Dame and Melo, he is significantly better than those guys.

  • @FMD023
    @FMD023 Před 12 dny +18

    I love that JJ is giving Timmy his flowers. As a spurs fan, it’s refreshing to see people finally recognizing Timmy and giving him his flowers in recent years. Timmy is the 🐐 PF.

    • @angelcanez4426
      @angelcanez4426 Před 11 dny +3

      I thought it was common knowledge that Tim Duncan's the greatest power forward of all time. The reason they probably forget about him is because there's no one else in the conversation at PF

    • @Benvyious
      @Benvyious Před 10 dny

      Kobe also deserved at least one maybe both of Steve’s MVPs. I agree Tim needed at least 1/2 more MVPs but voters had fatigue because spurs were one of the most consistent teams from 2000-2014 and I think that in itself undervalued Tim’s performance throughout his career.

    • @FMD023
      @FMD023 Před 9 dny

      @@angelcanez4426 No. he was under appreciated because at one point the spurs were considered “boring.” They won by playing great defense and slow basketball. It wasn’t until 2013 when coach pop opened up the offense and they started shooting lights out from the 3. Plus they played the heat so you had your LBJ haters and then spurs were the team to cheer on to stop LBJ. Spurs went from boring to a beautiful basketball.

    • @FMD023
      @FMD023 Před 9 dny +1

      @@Benvyious imo it’s because it was Kobe vs timmy. If you had a poll today who had the better career, most will vote Kobe just because they are biased. Fans want the more popular guy because by the numbers, Timmy’s career was wayyy better than Kobes. Only thing Kobe has over Kobe is that he repeated and Timmy never did. How can you consider Kobe’s career better against a guy who NEVER MISSED a playoff game in his career and made the spurs the winningest sports franchise during that stretch. It’s a popularity contest. Timmy finally got his flowers with the public when the spurs went against the heat. The offense opened up when they were deadly as a team from the 3 and their amazing passes. Remember back in 2013-2014, even their passes was ESPN highlights

    • @nicholascrespinel5854
      @nicholascrespinel5854 Před dnem

      Ya Timmy got lots of flowers and rings

  • @darkgate33
    @darkgate33 Před 14 dny +20

    “Over Wembanyana” it’s the Antetokounmpo all over again 😂😂

  • @ItwasnotLando
    @ItwasnotLando Před 14 dny +2

    Most VALUABLE player. I used to think the same way as Shaq, but it really is about who brings the most team success and who is best at making the players around them better.

  • @reneskyggebjerg2092
    @reneskyggebjerg2092 Před 14 dny +7

    "Earthlings" Love it.

  • @TheBeanBandito
    @TheBeanBandito Před 15 dny +19

    Bruh Dwight is the best Orlando magic big man ever wtf Shaq 😂😭

  • @ThatsJustJoshua
    @ThatsJustJoshua Před 14 dny

    Shaq’s explanation of in the playoff picture and having the backing stats for MVP is the best snapshot of what that player should be, contributing heavily to a contender and individually putting up the numbers to say they’re the guy

  • @Iceman-xe7jo
    @Iceman-xe7jo Před 15 dny +65

    Shaq is still pissed at losing to Steve Nash two years in a row 😂

    • @professororgasm
      @professororgasm Před 15 dny

      as he should be lol

    • @AllThingsKen
      @AllThingsKen Před 14 dny

      I would to when they give a white man my award

    • @mortystraphouse5077
      @mortystraphouse5077 Před 14 dny +3

      kobe got robbed of steve nash mvp not shaq. look it up. the yr kobe scored 81 his stats r insane MJ stats

    • @Iceman-xe7jo
      @Iceman-xe7jo Před 14 dny +7

      @@mortystraphouse5077 And Kobe’s team sucked

    • @jessemarkopoulos6116
      @jessemarkopoulos6116 Před 14 dny

      Except that when Nash won his second mvp Shaq didn’t get a single vote. Shaq is a moron

  • @Ironmaidenrules1
    @Ironmaidenrules1 Před 14 dny +4

    @7:10 Shaq throwing Greg Kite in there is hilarious 😂😂😂😂

  • @realtalkfbs
    @realtalkfbs Před 15 dny +16

    The problem is people have agendas. That's why MJ, Shaq and Bron missed out on being unanimous MVP's before Steph. It's always some asshole voting for the hometown guy.

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 11 dny

      LOL of those four guys Steph is the only one to be the one to have the most lasting most wide ranging impact on the game. Those other three are top players at their position in the history of the league but Steph is that AND changing the way the game is played.

    • @stevenclark5173
      @stevenclark5173 Před 5 dny

      @@bumshka21 No one's saying Steph didn't deserve it. The point is that those other 3 players also deserved to be unanimous.

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 4 dny

      @@stevenclark5173 lol all this is is recency bias what of bird and kg?

  • @UgoZg
    @UgoZg Před 14 dny +7

    Opinions are like assholes, everybody has one.

  • @kidwatson4240
    @kidwatson4240 Před 14 dny +4

    Shout out to Shaq for making sure people don’t forget Kobe Greatness.

  • @whogg0521
    @whogg0521 Před 15 dny +6

    Man, JJ is the truth.

  • @nemanjahxh9214
    @nemanjahxh9214 Před 12 dny

    i loved this conversation, jjr is really getting better at arguments with style and politeness, and shaq wasn't condescending. Real talk. love the idea of jj voting, definitely a lot need to be cut from that list

  • @garrettdurr7155
    @garrettdurr7155 Před 11 dny +1

    I agree with Shaq's point of view, the players greatness and what they do individually should matter the most. We do this in every other sport except the NBA for some reason.

  • @nicke1022
    @nicke1022 Před 14 dny +3

    As a life long spurs fan, our guys have been smugged so often from several awards. Duncan absolutely deserved a dpoy award

  • @ocorir
    @ocorir Před 14 dny +2

    I think coaches and/or executives should vote mvp. They’re literally the ones directly deciding value for their teams.

  • @comickicks5289
    @comickicks5289 Před 15 dny +22

    Love how Shaq always puts the respect on Kobe's name. These other Media people seem scared to name drop him now a days. Love JJ tho !

  • @SleepCove
    @SleepCove Před 14 dny +2

    The link for the full episode is another episode not this one.

  • @dreamweaver80
    @dreamweaver80 Před 14 dny +1

    I'm always shocked that Dr. J does not get more respect all time. And, ham also shocked he is not discussed as the most influential player in NBA history. I don't think people realize the reverence other players had for him and the greats that came after him had. Like MJ, Nique, Vince etc. would not have dreamed like they did and played that way without Dr. J. He is a legend and was a very underrated player all time.

  • @thehypocriticalcynic9182
    @thehypocriticalcynic9182 Před 11 dny +1

    They vet the voters:
    J.J. has a vote because he loves, "all-star-ball...
    Shaquille O'Neal does not have a vote because he likes basketball...

  • @moety2
    @moety2 Před 14 dny +2

    MVP can be tricky. Sometimes the best player doesn’t have to do as much on a good team as opposed to a good player or a bad team. Their numbers will be better because they have to do more. You put that player on a good team, his numbers go down because there are decent players to share the load.

    • @danielpenrodii2389
      @danielpenrodii2389 Před 14 dny

      In the case of Wemby vs Gobert, it’s actually simple. Imagine having 3-4 defensive stars around you making your life immeasurably easier versus a guy out there playing 1v5. That second dude should not have better defensive stats, since it’s that much easier for the opposing team to avoid one single guy. Yet…Wemby was better and did it all himself.

    • @moety2
      @moety2 Před 14 dny

      @@danielpenrodii2389 hence me saying it can be tricky and SOMETIMES not all the times. Have to use critical thinking and be objective because not all situations and circumstances are the same.

  • @Rivalry22
    @Rivalry22 Před 14 dny +13

    Wemby is DPOY.. shaq just said it's an individual award. I agree.

    • @sxyli
      @sxyli Před 14 dny +1

      rudy is the better defender wemby is block hungry he jumps everytime someone goes in the paint which is normal for a rookie or someone at the start of their nba career rudy is the more disciplined defender and the more skilled one for now at least

    • @Rivalry22
      @Rivalry22 Před 14 dny +1

      @@sxyli don't discredit the rookie bcoz he just got more blocks than rudy, how can you say he is a better defender yet wemby is better in all defensive stats than rudy? look at stocks and defensive rating when he's on the court.

    • @BallIsLife353332
      @BallIsLife353332 Před 14 dny

      Last time I checked wemby was still +1000 for dpoy as of the last month of regular season and that was mind blowing to me, said fuck it and threw a couple hundred on it in case they surprise us and name him

    • @Rivalry22
      @Rivalry22 Před 14 dny

      @@BallIsLife353332 yeah boi! let's gooo! 😂

    • @onlyfacts3178
      @onlyfacts3178 Před 14 dny

      how can you be the defensive player of the year if your team is one of the worst in defence?
      NO DPOY has ever missed the play-offs...
      MANUTE BOL leade the league in BLOCKS 5 per game as a ROOKIE (He made the play.offs and still didnt get the DPOY)

  • @VRKyurem
    @VRKyurem Před 14 dny +3

    Shaq forgets what his stance is halfway through expressing a thought

  • @bcs1793
    @bcs1793 Před 15 dny +31

    At some point the MVP stopped being the "Best Player in the League" award and became "Most Interesting Player in the League".

    • @hardwoodthought1213
      @hardwoodthought1213 Před 15 dny +21

      The MVP was never the best player. If it was, from 1970-2020, the only MVPs would have been Kareem, Magic, Bird, MJ, Hakeem, Shaq, Duncan and LeBron

    • @alexandrequillien4068
      @alexandrequillien4068 Před 14 dny +7

      It's the "who had the most impressive season" award. So the best player might not always have his best season.

    • @ThatsPety
      @ThatsPety Před 14 dny +5

      It's never been the Best Player award. If it was LeBron would have 8 awards. It used to be the "Whoever is the best player on the best team" award. But I kind of see what you're saying in the sense that narrative seems even more important than it was

    • @MistyKathrine
      @MistyKathrine Před 14 dny +1

      @@hardwoodthought1213 I think Malone still would have won it in 99.

    • @hardwoodthought1213
      @hardwoodthought1213 Před 14 dny

      @@MistyKathrine Nah. Duncan won a title and was even that season just marginally worse as a scorer (not saying career or anything just that season) whilst being the superior defender and passer.

  • @jamescorb904
    @jamescorb904 Před 14 dny +2

    Omfg I started dying laughing when Shaq brought Dwight up. I mean they both had great Magic careers. Shaq was good and more dominant but Dwight teams were good too

  • @aaronpeters6209
    @aaronpeters6209 Před 8 dny

    DPOY - Require a certain DRTG on/off requirement. Probably have similar - or related - requirements for other awards.
    .
    MVP - Like the playoffs requirement, great players should be able to their team past the play ins. Might also discourage tanking.
    ALL NBA - Don't think it makes sense to have ALL NBA teams & then ALL NBA defensive centric teams.
    Should just go by purely best offensive & defensive team awards. Allow for ALL NBA (all around team) to become a function of MVP standings.

  • @sganet_
    @sganet_ Před 14 dny +2

    When it comes to DPOY, yes you are disqualified if your team don’t make playoffs, especially if you lead the team in usage. Compared to the rest of the team, he’s technically most responsible with their lack of success year 1.
    And if we are looking at numbers, all advanced defensive numbers has Gobert way ahead of Wemby, there’s no way around that.
    Another thing people don’t talk about is offense for a defender, if you have a negative offensive rating, that should count against your net defensive contributions, in Wemby’s case, he’s a negative in OWS.

  • @KTF0
    @KTF0 Před 14 dny +1

    Former ​MVPs should get a vote on MVP

  • @kimstuart7989
    @kimstuart7989 Před 6 dny

    The keyword is value. Just because you're the best player doesn't mean you add value to a teams success. It may add value to the revenue of the team being box office, but that's irrespective of team success

  • @Stefan0v1
    @Stefan0v1 Před 14 dny

    For me it's much simpler than that..XD
    Do you guys know that stat that shows + - for your team with you on the field vs without you on the field?
    Some specific players are + 20 when they are in and - 10 when they are out..
    If that's not value, what is?

  • @DynastyFade
    @DynastyFade Před 13 dny

    I like the idea of former HOF and former players voting, but I think there needs to be some prerequisites first since the game changes so much over time. Everyone is prone to hyperbole, but a nice balance of former players/coaches/front office and media/analysts would be great to see. I wonder how the voting would look then.

  • @marcinolszewski2260
    @marcinolszewski2260 Před 15 dny +11

    By what criteria SGA is the baddest man in the league?

    • @domingow.17
      @domingow.17 Před 14 dny +8

      Basically, skin color lol. And this is coming from a non white person. I've noticed a bit of prejudice in a lot of nba media. The black Americans don't like players that play differently from the black American archetype

    • @occultsymbols
      @occultsymbols Před 14 dny +8

      Shaq is a very weird Luka hater. When Luka hit that step back game winner in the playoffs vs the clippers in his second season Shaq literally said he was not impressed by Luka and that he seen that before oh and btw Luka dropped a 40pt triple double that game as well. It’s clear as day that Shaq hates Luka. Idk why though

    • @joshb.1118
      @joshb.1118 Před 14 dny

      Way more points than Jokic (32 v 26). Similar advanced stats (though much higher relative to position), clutch points, more game takeovers. Jokic is a great player, but don't say there is isn't a very strong argument for SGA.

    • @kao1102-xk1lq
      @kao1102-xk1lq Před 14 dny

      @@occultsymbolsthis is just a blatant lie cos you’re emotional. I’m a Luka and Mavs fan and don’t see it like that. He doesn’t need to bow down and kiss Lukas feet everytime to prove to you that he likes him, he’s said he’s a great player multiple times and complimented him. Also outside of hoop Luka be hosting him in Slovenia

    • @domingow.17
      @domingow.17 Před 14 dny

      @@joshb.1118 way more isolation possessions than jokic. Why do ppl give iso scorers more credit than players who move the ball around to their teammates?

  • @lmt-adventures620
    @lmt-adventures620 Před 6 hodinami

    Here’s a fix: The NBA picks the criteria and send them to all voters (in writing) each year for them to follow.

  • @JohnMFlores
    @JohnMFlores Před 8 dny

    Shaq should organize a Players' MVP next year

  • @aspaceproductions
    @aspaceproductions Před 11 dny +1

    If team success doesnt matter then what does value even mean? What value does a player bring when their team is losing?

  • @hardwoodthought1213
    @hardwoodthought1213 Před 15 dny +20

    Players use to vote. They voted Kareem every year, even when he was missing the playoffs. What about the NFL top 100 list? It’s horrible every year, because players decide who is on it and in what order.
    There is nothing inherent that means an NBA player knows more than anyone else. Shaq alone is proof of this. The man didn’t understand what a PnR was. He just claimed you need heart to win 😂he claimed in 2011 that Brook Lopez was better than Dwight Howard 😂 he claimed Tim Duncan was ‘soft’ in 1999 and didn’t deserve to be listed as better than him. Duncan then swept him in the playoffs 😂 he claims Barkley isn’t qualified to talk basketball because he never won a title 😂 he flip-flops on his picks for greatest of all time so much, it’s almost impossible to keep up 😂 he was given a book on Nietzsche by Phil Jackson. His takeaway from the book? Nietzsche was so crazy he was a genius, and that’s what Dr O’Neal was. A crazy genius….
    That’s somehow better than someone from the media voting?

    • @Matthew-xl5bc
      @Matthew-xl5bc Před 14 dny

      NFL Top 100 is great. The players give other positions credit and not just glaze QBs.

    • @hardwoodthought1213
      @hardwoodthought1213 Před 14 dny +1

      @@Matthew-xl5bc Last year, the top 31 had 5 RBs and only 4 QBs. In 2023?
      Let’s say you argue well the list isn’t about value, it’s about best at a position. Why has Justin Tucker never even cracked the top 90 then?

    • @onlyfacts3178
      @onlyfacts3178 Před 14 dny

      YOU ARE WRONG...
      KAREEM was the clear MVP because he had more wins than the others (at that time missing the play-offs didnt mean you werent a TOP TEAM) it was by divisons..wich means you could have 50 wins and not make the play-offs while a team with 40 wins could make the play-offs if they were the TOP team in their divison.
      The rest you are correct..i cant trust someone voting who says ATLANTA is closer to the moon than CHICAGO just because he can see the moon from there and cant see CHICAGO...
      BUT MEDIA also is BAD...RACHEL said i dont watch WESTBROOK play but i see his stats thats why i am voting for him.
      AND you can go and check how many black voters put LUKA ahead of SGA...JUST 1..
      THE rest only vote for black players at 1st place...some dont even put JOKIC on the TOP...
      SOME MEDIA is clearly BIASED towards their TOWN and TEAM and if there is a TOP player from that TEAM they will always put him ahead.
      THATS why you saw SGA last season finishing 5th in the MVP without making the play-offs with just 2 more wins than MAVS LUKA who didnt play LUKA to TANK in the last games .
      LUKA had a lot more wins than losses.
      SGA had more losses than WINS.
      BUT media still goes for TEAM WINS instead of PLAYERS wins.
      EMBIID got 43 wins last season...SIXERS got 54...

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 11 dny

      @@onlyfacts3178 Luka has Kyrie SGA has great players but all of them combined have less years in the league than Irving

  • @JLCruise1
    @JLCruise1 Před 14 dny

    Living players in the 75 Greatest should get a vote. They know how to be the best.

  • @akashir5580
    @akashir5580 Před 13 dny

    Agree with Shaq on this one

  • @ajhd2005
    @ajhd2005 Před 14 dny

    I think if you've made the HOF you should get a vote. I'd definitely like to see coaches, players and ex-players get a heavier vote (particularly if they aren't allowed to vote for their teammates). And I think the media should have the same voting ability as the fans, maybe even after the players choose the top 10 maybe.

  • @Infamousjr719
    @Infamousjr719 Před 14 dny

    Who are you valuable to? The team!

  • @johnrvt
    @johnrvt Před 14 dny

    Love how Jj asks why Shaq mentions charlotte as Jj rumored for coach hire for them

  • @v1LL2n
    @v1LL2n Před 14 dny

    Break votes into categories. Fans, players (active only), media etc. and add weighted value to each category.

  • @bandito241
    @bandito241 Před 16 hodinami

    Can you imagine Shaq having the ability to vote if he only responded to that email that was sent 15 years ago 😂

  • @selfawarepotassium
    @selfawarepotassium Před 14 dny +2

    Shaq would probably vote Bol Bol for MVP. Awards will be even more ridiculous if you give every ex player a vote.

  • @thesajery
    @thesajery Před 14 dny

    Shaq shaking his head at the beginning LMAO. Also I'm with Shaq on this... win/loss ratio shouldn't matter, at all. BUT! I'm from OKC and I LOVE Shai. Luka stilla gets the nod from me, he's absolutely insane. SGA in a few years or even next, is a lock.

  • @cmoney1818
    @cmoney1818 Před 11 dny

    Realistically the best player on the best team usually gets the finals mvp im with shaq on the part its a individual award

  • @mattc5647
    @mattc5647 Před 12 dny +1

    More ex players should be involved, but someone like Shaq has made it clear he doesn't even watch games much.

  • @1yungez
    @1yungez Před 12 dny

    shaq more serious on here i like it

  • @jaybonny1954
    @jaybonny1954 Před 10 dny

    Shaq spitting flames

  • @adamsjohnathan57
    @adamsjohnathan57 Před 14 dny

    Current and former player (maybe) should vote. Media can do nominations.

  • @vigneshjayakrishnan1584

    It doesn't always happen but I 100% agree with Shaq's definition of MVP. Why should the most valuable player get more cred because their team lifts them up? The argument that the team with the better record HAS the better record because of that player is so subjective. Team sport. How do you quantify the individual contribution's to team success? That doesn't make sense.

  • @west1788
    @west1788 Před 7 dny

    Shaq speaking faxx about mvp

  • @drewwootten6770
    @drewwootten6770 Před 14 dny +1

    50 hofers 25 ex players 25 ex coaches and gmes? Maybe 25 of each? I think GMs and coaches offer great insight game-planning against certain guys.

  • @Menzeta
    @Menzeta Před 12 dny

    2:20 *Looks at Mike Tout on the Angels*

  • @maurice2245
    @maurice2245 Před 11 dny

    DYOP is an individual award,MVP is an award based on your impact on your teams success

  • @thomassryann8252
    @thomassryann8252 Před 11 dny

    MVP - shaq is right !! It’s a singular player award !!

  • @Ejohns1004
    @Ejohns1004 Před 11 dny

    Players, former players, coaches, former coaches, and GMs should get the majority of the weighted votes for NBA awards.
    The media's vote should be weighted like the fan vote in all-star.

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 11 dny

      LOL you remember when they tried this for all star and players mostly voted for themselves?
      maybe the media could vote to whom is selected and then the cohort you mentioned could vote to decide akin to the oscars
      but the media members are current with the game

  • @mandiletoni4963
    @mandiletoni4963 Před 14 dny +2

    Point is that Shaq is pulling for SGA cuz he afraid that people will start seeing Jokic as THE GOAT center after the 3 MVP .. you can tell he don’t watch games cuz the last 12-13 games SGA was injured/didn’t play for 7-8 games and the other 4-5 he played he wasn’t even the best player on his team.. either CHET or the peDo had better games and they got that nr-1 spot without him lol 😂

  • @pablosnackbar6417
    @pablosnackbar6417 Před 14 dny

    Current players. Like the old days. Simple.
    Being respected by your peers is the greatest honor.

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 11 dny

      Except that when they did this for all star the players voted for themselves

  • @CrumbsLamond
    @CrumbsLamond Před 9 dny

    Shaq will swear hes not sensitive one minute then have moments like 6:52 where he'll take it personally when someone disagrees with him

  • @TheDeven1000
    @TheDeven1000 Před 14 dny

    Shaq was about to kill that man if he said Dwight 😂😂😂 I think JJ knew it too 😂

  • @Killerboot369
    @Killerboot369 Před 14 dny

    He called them Earthlings lmao

  • @landon4278
    @landon4278 Před 8 dny

    HOFers voting is the worst idea. Case in point:
    Shaq: You should qualify for MVP if you make the playoffs.
    Also Shaq: Wemby should have gotten the DPOY.
    Shaq will do everything in his power to vote against Rudy just because he doesn't like the dude, he doesn't respect his game, and he doesn't like that he got paid. A lot of HOFers internalize the competition they have with current players and cannot even attempt to vote objectively as acknowledging someone got more MVPs than they did might move that player ahead on the list of all time greats.

  • @carlfriesen4888
    @carlfriesen4888 Před 14 dny

    I always thought MVP should go to the player whose team would drop the most in the standings if he wasn’t able to play that season. By definition he would be the most valuable player

  • @Tomtomme
    @Tomtomme Před 10 dny +1

    Luka not being MVP after monster season tells everything

  • @royhobbs5167
    @royhobbs5167 Před 13 dny +1

    You can’t leave important decisions to the guys that can barely read. I’m not joking either. A lot of these guys barely saw a college campus let alone class.

  • @Lapp802
    @Lapp802 Před 14 dny

    The reason i dont think only players should vote is because by voting for some players they might be making personal and biased decisions since they know the players currently playing

  • @steezymtb5876
    @steezymtb5876 Před 14 dny +1

    Come on JJ, Wembanyama is clearly the DPOY. His effect on the TEAM's defense when he's on the court is mind-boggling. Gobert has an easier job blocking shots, when the perimeter defenders actually put some pressure on the driving player. The highlights of people passing up easy looking shots out of fear of Victor should by itself the man is the single best defensive player in the league. He affects shots by just standing still. Other players have to actually do something.

  • @ryansemaan4070
    @ryansemaan4070 Před 14 dny +1

    they know JJ interviewing w charlotte

  • @GalacticAstroparticles

    The thing with these awards is that if you STRICTLY define the criteria, you can determine every award with an algorithm, based on the defined metrics.
    Arbitrariness leaves room for disagreements and preferences between voters, as well as room for narratives (which is one of the most important things in the entertainment of the sport).
    So the chaotic system (arbitrary criteria) actually makes this more interesting. 😅

    • @bumshka21
      @bumshka21 Před 11 dny

      You talk about it like the point of the NBA isn't entertainment. The league benefits from the subjectivity of an award because it drives conversation

  • @azrielnguyen9586
    @azrielnguyen9586 Před 14 dny

    JJ: "interesting..."
    Similar to Diddy circle, you're either in or you're out SHAQ. That's why I get to vote

  • @chrisbrooks6756
    @chrisbrooks6756 Před 12 dny

    Current head coaches, should be the voters for every award.

    • @jacoblee5796
      @jacoblee5796 Před 12 dny

      I think it should be a mix of head coaches, GM's and media.

  • @DreJr
    @DreJr Před 13 dny

    MVP can't be separated from team performance or significance of contribution to the team. If you do then who are you valuable to?

  • @RyanWong517
    @RyanWong517 Před 14 dny

    Maybe just add an "rising star award" for role player who has made the leap into star player.

  • @KengSuave
    @KengSuave Před 10 dny

    Jj reddish finna go coach charlotte you saw how he reacted when Shaq yelled that out

  • @2stepjoey
    @2stepjoey Před 14 dny

    Dwight was with the magic 8 seasons, to shaqs 4. Dwight had better stats with the magic. Shaq has the better overall career. Dwight was considered an important part of the one chip he got. Shaq was considered the key part of the chips he got.

  • @TribalKatz
    @TribalKatz Před 10 dny

    Back in the days, players were voted by their peers-aka the people that played against them.

  • @aleck6583
    @aleck6583 Před 12 dny +1

    I mean Shaq should start with actually watching the gamess before asking for a vote..

  • @chrism6880
    @chrism6880 Před 14 dny +1

    It's an individual award, but it's supposed to be most valuable. How much value are you adding to a team or the league if the team ends up a 7 seed?

    • @MistyKathrine
      @MistyKathrine Před 14 dny +2

      Reminds me that Steph Curry came in 3rd for MVP Voting in 2021 even though he didn't even make the playoffs. The idea that he deserved more votes than someone like Chris Paul that year was ridiculous.

  • @flychriss1194
    @flychriss1194 Před 13 dny

    If you're the best player in the league, your team should be making the playoffs outside of some crazy injuries. A great player in a team game helps their team win and leads that team. Your team wins because you're the best player.

  • @fabianm483
    @fabianm483 Před 14 dny

    I completely agree with everything Shaq said... how can people who have never stepped foot onto an NBA court on a team and not as a media personality be allowed to vote for awards that changes ppls lives... it should only be ex players and hof'ers ik it gets into the blurry line where theyre voting for players on teams theyve played for before. But i trust that so much more than RANDOMS ON TV WHO I HAVE NEVER SEEN DO ANYTHING on the court ever in their lives....

  • @stefangacev6414
    @stefangacev6414 Před 14 dny +5

    Maybe if you watched some fucking games Shaq you might get a vote

  • @23lacross
    @23lacross Před 14 dny +2

    Should’ve said to Shaq that Ernie doesn’t get a vote? And he would’ve shut up really quick.

    • @rohanshah7559
      @rohanshah7559 Před 14 dny +1

      That’s true, Shaq doesn’t have a lot of sense, but he’s got enough to not diss Ernie

  • @Aceonknives
    @Aceonknives Před 9 dny

    “Ur tge best big man in orlando majic history” ??? Shaq was best big man period!

  • @sin842
    @sin842 Před 14 dny

    MVP - An individual AWARD it isn't MVPLAYERS!

  • @jcreature11
    @jcreature11 Před 11 dny

    MVP should have zero to do with the team. It’s an individual award.