Neil deGrasse Tyson & Joe Rogan Discuss Bad Science in Movies
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
- How does Neil deGrasse Tyson respond to mean tweets? In this video, hear Neil talk about some of his hot takes on the science in movies, and how they were received. Find out what movies like Titanic and Star Wars: The Force Awakens got wrong.
Should you be afraid of your microwave? You'll also hear Neil talk about why you shouldn't worry about microwaves irradiating your food. Hear him break down the physical processes that occur inside the microwave.
Why doesn't Neil have any tattoos? You'll learn that too in this video, along with how the Space Shuttle changed the way we commute, the origins of the Air Force and more!
Get the NEW StarTalk book, 'To Infinity and Beyond: A Journey of Cosmic Discovery' on Amazon: amzn.to/3PL0NFn
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
FOLLOW or SUBSCRIBE to StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalk
Timestamps:
0:00 - How Neil Responds to Mean Tweets
0:55 - Star Wars: The Force Awakens
2:28 - Titanic
3:33 - Microwaves
4:31 - Misinformation & Critical Thinking
5:46 - Tattoos
6:43 - How the Space Shuttle Changed the Way We Commute
7:25 - "Godspeed" & Etymology
8:21 - Origins of the Air Force
8:49 - The Space Force
9:50 - War in Space
"I don't believe in anything that hasn't been credibly verified, I don't deny anything that hasn't been credibly debunked."
Like Carl Sagan said, "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence"👍😊
@@reginagrahn5852 i dont think this is always true. alot of people quote Carl Sagan as if hes then end all be all on evidence but idk. Truth is stranger than fiction.
That's why I'm an agnostic. The existence of a god or no god has never been proven ...
but some still believe in themselves & not in others,sadly.
Neo you are very smart
But have you ever tought to test how spirituality just trying to test with out logic
I love you Neil, but this wasn’t ‘Joe and Neil discuss’ this was Neil lectures Joe lmao
Well he clearly needs it so…
Let's see a debate between Neil and Howard Terrance! LETS GOO, LETS MAKE IT HAPPEN
Its always Neil lectures someone .....
This is why "The Expanse" is my all time favorite science fiction!
It doesn’t ruin the movie to have these discussions… it’s just good fun talking about it and what would actually happen.
Going to the back of the racks for this one.
They also didn't censor. A lot of StarTalk audience members are kids and Niel tries to keep it PG most of the time.
I'm not complaining. I don't like any form of censorship. I was just pointing it out.
I loved his last comment : "Demonstrate to me, on Earth, you know how not kill one or another )then I'll believe your space threaty) !!"
When people say they don't eat microwaved food, a lot of them might be afraid of the microwaves but there are also many who just do not like food especially produced for microwave cooking because of the ingredients.
Yeah but you can heat up any type of food, that has a bit of water in it, in a microwave. You dont need to buy "special food" made for microwaves.
@@iori1303 Microwave Dinners were and are still a thing. I recommend not eating them heated in a microwave or an oven they are rubbish lol
@@Max_Flashheart In most cases the only thing different is that they are ALL made with way to much salt. And no, they are not going to match home concocted or chef level meals, but are better than military MREs, so go cry somewhere else, Flashfart.
@@cosmicraysshotsintothelight Learn to cook and don't be rude.
I like seeing Dr. Tyson on Rogan. I have no longer a need to watch Rogan be gullible to whatever clown is sitting across from him, but at least NdT gives a dose of some reality to that audience.
I like seeing Tyson on Rogan also, but tell me, what was Joe's role in this video? Was it edited from another video on his channel?
@@ray_ray_7112 NDT has been on the Joe Rogan Experience numerous times.
Let's see a debate between Neil and Howard Terrance! LETS GOO, LETS MAKE IT HAPPEN
As opposed to the monkeys just stupid enough to believe they have it all figured out and NDT is not a pontificating asshat. What's the difference between God and NDT? God doesn't think he is NDT.
@@RonBaker456
NDT exists.
I love the statement about the space treaty at the end, however, I think the idea of the space treaty in part was to show that we can coexist somewhere, so maybe putting the cart before the horse, they said "Let's start with space, this new frontier."
Zeon Zum Deikun was a philosopher who developed Contolism: a philosophical synthesis of both Ereism (an extreme form of Environmentalism, positing that Earth is sacred, and mankind was always meant to leave it and live in space) and Sideism
Whack -a do rogan doesn't belong in the same room with Mr Tyson.
How can anyone not like Neil? He is like the most charming and pleasent person I've ever seen. I would probably be the happiest person on earth if I could call him a friend. Such an amazing person.
I have tattoos and I love what you said about tattoos. I have grown in thought about some tattoos and I just own that I was in a different space and I appreciate the growth and I have added more tattoos when I do grow in thought. I love the idea of seeing how I grew and having something to show where I’ve been and some things I never grew in thought about.
It’s a literal record of your growth and change… that being said.. no tattoos for me.
I happen to know that microwaves change the laws of probability . I have a soup bowl that has a handle similar to coffee cup. The handle should roughly be pointed towards the front about half the time when the door is opened, but 90% of the time it is pointed towards the back, annoying me profusely. The ONLY possible conclusion is that microwaves change the laws of probability. ;-)
Add 30 seconds and wait a half a turn longer, or write a program that lets you index your turntable. Now examine what the probability of you taking on that task is. Not too much chaos in there. I think it is pretty predictable. 🤪
I constantly reheat my coffee after it sits here right next to me cooling as I type stupid CZcams comments. So I zap every cup several times just so I can get one hot sip or two, before falling into another organized ASCII waterfall. Just knowing that you too examine this phenomena makes me want to revive my faster than light communications method. I mean the only thing that travels faster than light is the instantaneous and universal urge to yawn. Now if we can figure out how to add a message to that we can talk to yawning species on the other side of the Universe. Waiting between yawns might be the only bottleneck though.
To leave room in a tattoo for new information is beautiful additions to previously loved art. I don't understand your theory that no information now is worth tattooing, I think we can start somewhere and add more later.
I had always assumed that the "godspeed" send-off was wishing John Glenn the speed of the gods (as in Mercury).
I hope one of my hero Mr Tyson will be open to debate with Terrance Howard’s thinking on physics and the universe
I like what it's called now...the Ministry of Defense, to create technologies that cancel any attack would be ideal!
What a beautiful mind.
We take this for granted. ❤
I'm only venting! At this point in our technological advancement, shouldn't all of our devices be free of charge? We rely on them to survive in the modern world.
the fuck was up with that ivermectin bullshit? anyone ever gonna call that out? he listens to science except for that?
Yeah when it comes to cxvid and trans stuff he stopped being fully objective
hasnt that order been rescinded? saw a news item that the CDC had gone back on their word and rogan had been proven right about ivermectin
@@vitriolveio care to explain what exactly you are referring to? i know joe can go off the rails but i havent seen anything egregious on covid from him. i havent seen a lot of episodes tho.
@@TheNeo349 wow. prove it. you're doing a great job of convincing everyone of a stupid lie. pat on the back.
@@vitriolveioor maybe he is and ur just not as smart as u think you are…
Like what has he said about it that ISNT objective😂
Yup
What is the science the producer of Star Wars didn't want you to tweet?
It was the campfire vfx that is on the outside of a spaceship, in space. In the new acolyte show. Fire like that isnt possible in space, and the vfx was shit. I do better than that fpr funsies and it doesnt cost me millions of dollars, just use of Adobe lol.
5:20 put this in the sky and on t shirts!
I used to run a grocery store when scanners were new. One customer made us place paper bags over the scanners and key punch the UPC codes, because she KNEW the lasers removed all the vitamins and nutrients from the food........
Love NDT and Startalk.
Can’t stand Joe Rogan.
I feel exactly the opposite. He's a pontificating buffoon who loves the sound of his own voice. NDT not Rogan.
@@RonBaker456
lol. That’s great. And when will you be getting that GED?
They should talk about bad science on podcasts. joe has spread more than his fair share of that.
That would make sense especially for science 🤔
People want to see a debate between Neil deGrasse Tyson and Terrance Howard because they have publicly disagreed on several scientific topics in the past. Terrance Howard, has often disagreed with Neil deGrasse Tyson claims about mathematics and physics, which may have sparked interest in seeing them engage in a formal debate to settle their disagreements. Terrance Howard is known for his “Terryology” theory, which he claims to be a new mathematical principle that he has been developing since his childhood. He has made several claims about the theory in interviews and on social media, including that the square root of 2 is the same as 1 (not 2 as commonly believed) and that multiplication doesn't exist.
I had two teachers in high school that taught me to do the research. One was a history teacher. He made us learn how to use the library to research our papers. He knew who used the library to write the papers and who used the textbooks and the encyclopedia. If you used the library you got an A+ on the paper and those who did not got a C.
The other teacher was a Geometry teacher. On the first day of class, He gave us a problem. We had the year to solve the problem. If we solved the problem you would get an A for the year. The problem was to determine what 7 raised to the 1000 power equals. When the end of the year came around, the teacher asked if anyone has the answer to the problem. Nobody had it. I tried, I got to 7 raised to the 40 power or realized the number was huge and gave up trying to get the number. The primary computer at the time was a pencil and a piece of paper. Computer were just getting into the schools. I even tried it but I was not in the computer club and had to rely on their kindness. They tried but gave up. Somewhere I still have the paper tape with the program punched into it. The teacher said there was no answer, and the number went to infinity. He did say the last number was a seven. I raised my hand and said sir you are mistaken. The number is a finite number it has about 800 digits and the last number is something like 9,7,0 or 1. He asked how I knew it was a finite number? I said first you told us the last number was a 7, that denotes an end to the number. Second 10 raised to the 1000 power is a 1 with a thousand zeros behind it. Third 10 raised to the 1000th power is a larger than 7 raised to a 1000. Forth the last number of the 7 raised to a power starts to follow a sequence of n numbers. This sequence repeats some 250 times and stops with 3 numbers left over and that 3rd number is the last number which is a 7. He did not give me an A but he did raise my grade from a C to a B. I was the only one who did the work to try to answer the problem and to contest the teacher answer.
Ese vato de mma es súper inteligente. Y lo paseó. Sin compasión. Le regresó algo , pero le comprobó lo que le dijo al principio. No hay otra forma de poder más fuerte que la ciencia.
String theory... i think some of the "ancient languages" that people cant decifer are written music and they need to look from a different perspective.
4:30 I don’t know what he’s talking about because my plate is too hot to handle after sitting in the microwave for a few minutes
It still conducts heat from the food that's on it.
more irritating than anything is there were books on a fighter sized ship that just cored a star and subsequently destroyed that 'solar' system but uhhh yeah those books were official star wars before jar jar binks was even a bad idea in the making
Mathematics is used to Describe what was observed, or in derivative: propose what would happen in the situation where the Mathematics used to Describe the Function is Absolute.
Translation: Math describes it, it can not define what is not included.
So E=mc^2.
In the original derivative equation. If m= m0/ the square root of 1-(v^2/c^2). m is the mass of a moving object, M0 is the object at rest, v is velocity, c is the speed of light. This is a relationship.
If we reset the scale, so that a photon is one horse, so we can directly compare it to horsepower, and we are making a stable comparison. The Horse without a Load has no mass, and is not part of the equation itself, as we are calculating the reduction of velocity due to this load. The Horse is imaginary: it does not really exist in this equation. The Load of the Horse is anything greater than our 1 we have in this equation. Now when our imaginary Horse has no Load: it can stop time when it reaches its maximum velocity, which is distance over time, and when c is substituted to be a horse length or stride length, and maximum velocity of a Horse. This is the fault of the Mathematics not including greater forms of Representation. It defines the scales of interaction above a photon, as our other equation defines the load on a horse, but if we want to just race the horses: the entire thing falls apart if you don't include the track. Einstein did not have super-computers to include every star inputting energy, and pulling with gravity: into his equation.
The Black Hole is beyond The Thermodynamic range: it breaks every law of Thermodynamics. The overall gravitational potential of a Black Hole provides and energy that is greater than the limits present to cease with the photon. A Black Hole is a system of negentropy that increases in mass, all the energy is conserved in nuclear reaction, and the idea of the photon goes away as breaks down, as to be even be called heat or a photon any longer, the photon is not the limit to a scale of infinite and limitless breakdown, The Black Hole has a singularity that is well below your energy range of a photon, and a core that looks like just like the component under a photon, but it is comprised of Vacuum found present in Mass time, a negative Dimensional formation, that is the window for prophecy found greater than the negative domain of reach within your own negative cores of some of your sub-atomic particles providing intuition. You don't respect all the avenues of determined exploration that can provide evidence, or even find reason to research beyond the prescribed limits of someone else's imagination or their once technical inability to solve problems.
NDT is 1 in a million and we need another million like him!!!!
I would more impressed Joe Rogan wasn't the one complaining about people believing things without understanding them.
Gotcha Tyson! You are wrong. My microwave DOES heat my plate. It is my biggest pet peeve with the microwave. It always makes my plate or bowl too hot to touch and the food is no where near as hot.
Not all plates are suited for use in a microwave oven, or you just new to buy a new microwave
@@TotalyKenyan It is new and not a cheap one. Please name one type of plate that won't heat up in the microwave.
I feel smarter after listening to Neil.
I was curious to watch this, I’m a Mr Tyson fan. But this video had me a bit in eeehhhhh mode.
That fact that we kill each other here is the dumbest thing we do. We are all in this together, we laugh at the same people, cry for the same reasons etc.
Has something to do with the entrenched part of their sense of self mentioned in the video.
Interview Sophia stewart please
My twin adores the Apollo space program. She finds gaffes all the time and she's not Neil.
🚀🚀👾👾🚀
That is profound. Show me peace on earth. Then let's see.
My plates/bowls always get hot after microwaving.
Or your food gets hot then transfers heat to the plates/bowls?
@@ctakitimu a lot of times the plates/bowls are unreasonably hot. Unable to hold with bare hands.
Science idea
What if there where a scifi esque clony ship with a bio experiment cosmic data device that grows biology and interacts with other bio experiments to eventually make something like a star trek whale but even smarter and more communicative
NDT has standing and credibility in his field not unrelated fields.
Sorry to tell you this. BB-8 rolling in the desert and up sand dunes was not cgi, but a real remote control robot that did just fine.
Which had to be manually pushed by people in green suits and or had to be held in place with netting so it would slip and skid all over tue place. You are wrong, ignorant, and clearly haven't seen any behind the scenes footage of the movie.
If Starkiller base had captured all of a star's energy, shouldn't its mass have grown by an equal amount? Shouldn't it have become a star itself, or collapsed into a black hole or neutron star?
I'd say not if it converted all the mass of the star into energy.
Neil Degrass Tyson 💪🏽 💯. I would appreciate a pin 📍 please bro. 🙏🏼
How about an anti satellite weapon that’s a net and has a little compressed air engine, drag the nefarious satellite back to earth.
Why my microwave heats the plates when i use them?
That heat gets transferred from the food. A small piece of food on the plate and the plate is slightly warm. Full plate of food (especially when it's soup) and the plate gets very hot.
@@finn808 thank you for your answer
1:47 I tell ly kids to not get bothered by technicalities while watching movies. That way we can enjoy a movie regardless of it's interpretation of real life physics. The back to future car should have been more damaged as showm as you can't stop a moving vehicle at 88 mph in a 300 ft stretch...so forth. When did fiction had to stop being fiction?
Joe Rogan? Really?
Undereducated as they are, Rogan's fans still deserve some sort of valid information.
@@user-dh6bj2me5p This is an old episode anyway.
@@user-dh6bj2me5p spoken like a true burner
Not every rogan listener is that bad, you have to remember how insanely popular his podcast has been, depending on the guest I used to be a huge fan just for the two hour long conversations, plenty of people just have it as background noise aswell.
@@undercoverspy123 #NotEveryRoganListener
I'm still waiting for the inconvenience of life
⚓️
Cheers Joe Rogan and NDT.😎🇨🇦👋💯
Maybe the entry cost to join the club is high enough to at this point assure "space" to have peaceful usage only? But could change when some more militant oriented group decides they don't subscribe to it? They can afford ARs and clips right now.
Gotta love joe rogan and neil tyson pod
W neil degrasse tyson.
Your the best, keep gooing.
Lo hizo tapear. Quizá fue fuera de división.
Tattoos, yeah. Once almost gotta wedding ring tattooed on my finger. Now I'm divorced, so, yeah, close call....
Okay all forms of heat are in fact going to destroy some nutrients but that's all forms of heat you break down enzymes and amino acids when you do that
Also most of the food that goes into or comes out of a microwave is highly processed so eliminating microwave food would in fact have health benefits but they would not be occurring for the reasons the woman believes 😅
I appreciate your math and science stuff Neil, but you cannot jump from killing one planet to killing a thousand. From a narrative perspective it would make no sense. Maybe it’s explained that the death star is inefficient and cannot convert all of the stars power in to planet killing power. The thousand planet killer Death Star is a great idea for the next trilogy.
I must lead us to con+vert up=truth=light=love=peace=God
They're all coming with us this time! 5 years till possible collison. Let's fast forward this process!
Last one is best. Same logic apply to AI about helping humanity. What have you done to save it before AI, so we can believe you are creating AI for humanity?
On April 13, 2029, the space rock is scheduled to approach Earth, coming within 20,000 miles (32,000 kilometers) of our planet's surface. The event will mark the closest Earth flyby of an asteroid of this size that scientists managed to forewarn
Tyson must be lazy cause when Terrence Howard was ringing saying hey check this out
Tyson wasn’t answering 😂😂😂
Let's see a debate between Neil and Howard Terrance! LETS GOO, LETS MAKE IT HAPPEN
No let's not
You would be entertained by a debate between an astrophysicist and a washed-up actor who was last relevant 15+ years ago?
The updated Death Star could destroy 6 planets, maybe 1000 planets.. it’s just a statistic. I don’t get wild on statistics put out in movies. If you tell me we can destroy a planet for real I’d go wild. Oh wait.. we are destroying planet earth :/
I had a discussion with a, seemingly, reasonably intelligent young woman the other day. The young part, by the way, is incidental. The same thing would have happened with the people whom I graduated from high school in 1969. She had no idea what the United States government is or how it works. Can you imagine if the discussion was about the big bang or the speed of light and its peculiarities. She knows what she needs to know to work the front desk where I live and cares nothing on an any important level about other things. Although she my know about the love life of her favorite musical performers, etc. etc. etc...
😭 Neil we've NEVER asked you not to talk to someone before... but please for the love of all that is holy, and for all the love of science. 😭😢 please don't lower yourself to something like Joe Rogan again.
8:11 "High speed"
Godspeed is from "God speed you" on your journey, back when travel time was significantly determined by mishaps causing delays, such as a broken wagon wheel or an injured horse. It meant "Your trip takes less time if nothing goes wrong, may it be so."
Fleas.
Archangels Chamuel & Charity; peace template; love as freedom; loving relationships; twin flame union
The twitter user could now link this video as the most pompous he's even been... lol
What do you all have against Rogan?
A correction to ND Tyson comments. By education he is a scientist. However, and this is said with no malice and with respect, within the scientific community, he would not be referred to as a scientist. He is an educator but not a scientist. In order to be considered a scientist (within our social network) you must practice science as your work. You must be physically working on material or you must be producing none academic exclusive published work that has passed established peer review or has provided furtherance of knowledge (example bad theory, but new math). N ever heard of any actual work he has produced or attempted to publish. His astronomy work was exclusively for academic credential not project based. Further despite common belief he actual hand no practical hand in Pluto "gate" (lol). This can be a sore spot at times with some scientist about educators and academics. Since (sometimes perhaps accidentally) they represent themselves as provers of a product they did not produce. Educators and academics are reading, understanding and repeating the works of others. This is fine as it is their job, but understanding this is appreciated. He is however a talented personality.
How can it be bad science when its not actually telling you its real science in the movies. The term is Science Fiction with the key word being fiction. Fiction itself allows you to have any science you want because its FICTION! Lol
If you’ve sucked all of the energy out of a star do you then need to blow up the planet or won’t it just die anyway from not being part of a solar system.
The real reason he dont have tattoos because he thinks there hideous to
Rogan and Tyson don't mix!
Joe i need my Excalibur! My iron sword! Its in Atlantis, help me get there so i can become Gabriel and fight the darkness in hell and bring em all back! They can Be-ILL and call me!
You are sitting on top of a rocket, containing thousands of parts if not millions, that can blow up due to the slightest goof, all built by the cheapest bidder. You need Godspeed on your side.
How really cares about all this ,When I no longer get a hamburger for less than 9 bucks,Now thats a Death Starvation waiting to happen.
Smart man but I still dont eat microwave food and thats not about intelligence I think thats condescending, its about food heated up from the inside out is not what the human body would he consuming in nature therefore its unnatural therefore I dont use it, apart from which it doesnt feel properly cooked like an oven or stove meal heated the way nature naturally heats things fully from the outside to the core as opposed to zapping the centre. Also microwaves have only been around a few decades so the studies into their dangers are inconclusive since no ine has been using them long enough for any health effects to be seen. Just cos they havent found anything yet doesnt mean they never will. Asbestos was once used in everything...
10001001
I want to just sit with both and talk science, cultures , and Learning and how we can make that COOL again. 💜 you Joe News radio was my Favorite show back in the day.
Bro Rogan? Really?
I don't know what he's thinking. Maybe he doesn't know. J Rogan is a dumpster fire🔥. A E-car on empty....Joe's whole lineup is to feed into ignorants, or meth heads.
Bro chill
4:36 i literally just microwaved my waffles (my toaster is broken atm lol) and the plate was hotter them my waffles.. sorry Tyson but wrong lol
Microwave dry empty plate. And they do heat up because of water, like moisture from the waffles
@@TheAmethyz still makes no sense... hotter then the waffles?
contraction of 4 words, god be with you......
Another misleading title
1st startalk i'm choosing not to watch.
You already clicked on it. To late
@@dueunicycle3699 no it wasnt. click on. click off.
click on. click off.
wax on. wax off.
Joe Rogan aye…. Respect lost
About the microwave, -that's an irrevelant issue. And why do you guys like taking dumb statements from dumb people to build a discussion on!
The use, or none use of a microwaves? Should it matter if someone chooses not to incorporate a microwave to cook food in their own home or not? Isn't it a personal choice, like if someone chooses to take showers over taking baths🙄 or not use a gas stove, but instead chooses to use an electric stove? 🙄 its not a secret that microwaves do encourage, fast, unhealthy eating habits and encourage the purchasing of highly processed foods that are unhealthy with, or without a microwave. Premade meals loaded in sodium. It's not the microwave that's entirely harmful, but the long line of garbage food-like products they push in grocery stores for the microwave. How can you be unconcerned about these health issues, but be overly concerned about us taking the vaccine? 🙄
Social media influencers shouldn't worry about micromanaging every thought of followers, just as followers should not worry about micromanaging every thought of social media influencers.
If microwave companies aren't out defending their own product and educating about it Neil then who signed you up for microwave spokesman/superhero? 😂 You're the coolest, and I hate when I have to disagree with you, but don't you think sometimes you're a little too controlling with your viewers? Can someone make a personal choice without it being up for bashing by social media?🙄🤨 I'm just saying... The existence of s. media is unhealthy why aren't you bashing that?😑 😏
I am your guardian Archangel Samuel, the angel of love, light and peaceful relationships! Always will be! Love you!
Soooo basically you're Lucifer? 🤣😂
@@SheSweetLikSugarNSavage that's Samael
@@TheArchangelChamuel 👌 okay....I stand corrected then.
Neil, you do yourself a disservice associating with someone like Rogan...
100%
I enjoy StarTalk a lot but I can't support something that in anyway promotes Rogan or anything to do with him. I know this is a clip from an interview done quite some time ago but including it here on this channel encourages people to go watch or listen to the full interview. I genuinely hope that those responsible for this channel learn from this and discontinue any kind of support for Rogan or his content.
Why can't you support something that promotes Joe Rogan?
@@vlogsbyalejandro I don’t know if you are trolling or just unfamiliar with Rogan and his history. He is quite problematic and has been for quite some time.
Gingersheep, lol. You sound like such a cliché with that comment. People who actually watch Joe's podcast know it's just fine. Stop being a little dictator.
@@BrainWorm4president2024 its just fine because you agree and relate to the content. We aren't all you Brian!
I don't really like Tyson to be honest. But it's not even close to Joe Rogan.
Tyson got some clarity & things to back up the things that come out of his mouth, unlike Rogan.
Rogan just sucks.
I stop watching Rogan because he gives to much air to bs artists, liars and nut jobs but it pains me because I know sometimes he get respected, intelligent people on but until he increases that ratio and stops polluting society I will just try catch the good guests else where!