Elon Musk on Sam Altman and ChatGPT: I am the reason OpenAI exists

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 05. 2023
  • Tesla and Twitter CEO Elon Musk sits down with CNBC’s David Faber for an exclusive interview from Austin, Texas, during Tesla’s annual shareholder meeting. For access to live and exclusive video from CNBC subscribe to CNBC PRO: cnb.cx/2NGeIvi
    » Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
    » Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
    Turn to CNBC TV for the latest stock market news and analysis. From market futures to live price updates CNBC is the leader in business news worldwide.
    Connect with CNBC News Online
    Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
    Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
    Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
    www.cnbc.com/select/best-cred...
    #CNBC
    #CNBCTV

Komentáře • 2,8K

  • @RickMckee-nq4ni
    @RickMckee-nq4ni Před rokem +648

    It is happening folks, the future of work is being redesigned. Yes, More tech companies wants to fire more workers from next week: "The third wave is going to happen next week. That affects everybody in the biz teams, including in my organization. It's just a time of great anxiety and uncertainty" Says Meta President.

    • @AndrianWiener
      @AndrianWiener Před rokem +1

      Time and tide will not wait for any person. That means we must pay attention to how new technologies, and specifically AI, will make it easier for companies to become more efficient. Simply, this companies may not need a lot of workers, your bank may not need many staff. Your insurer may not need many workers. And the list keeps growing.

    • @JacksonMiley-iq7mo
      @JacksonMiley-iq7mo Před rokem +5

      Is it time to require mandatory payment where even if you have no staff, you have to commit a certain percentage of your revenue which will be used to distribute to citizens as a "wage" alternative?

    • @debrab7844
      @debrab7844 Před rokem +8

      It has nothing to do with AI. Economic distress in America is enormous. Many banks have gone under. Inflation is biting harder. Ukraine miscalculation is obvious. Facebook has been using AI in most of its features and products for more than 15 years now, so Ai has nothing to do with it. They embarked on unprofitable projects. And over hired. Apple has never laid off employees despite the economic downturn. They did well in hiring and never had failed projects. Metaverse failed. Gaming projects failed. Fintech, Lira failed. In the last 20 months, Sanbberg left, nobody is there to "tam the lion"
      Most Tech companies went woke: hired talents in order to prevent competitors from having access, they kept them idle, just to hijack a pool of talent. Over hired without proper assessment and protection. The existing projects couldn't turn in expected revenue, even before inflation war in USA set it. Let's put it in perspective without blaming AI. 95% of big tech have been using AI in the last 15 years. My advice: Improvise, Build passive income as a personal hedge against inflation. Do not hesitate to ask question where common knowledge fails.

    • @user-hx3qk8mw4e
      @user-hx3qk8mw4e Před rokem

      @@debrab7844 I wish I could tackle your submission but I already threw in the towel before I read the last line. I give it to you on this. I'm very interested in building a passive income but it seems like I will be needing a lot of coaching as I'm just a noob. You seem very well knowledgeable in the field, can you give some tips on getting started on building passive income with an expert firm or rec0mmend a personal flnancial coach?

    • @debrab7844
      @debrab7844 Před rokem +2

      @@user-hx3qk8mw4e " Kathleen Carol Yanelli " will be a good fit for you if you are looking to get unique financial strategies to generate passive income. She has a web presence incase you wanna just go ahead and search for her name.

  • @Tom0000
    @Tom0000 Před rokem +938

    I took an entrepreneurship class at UCLA where the professor actually recommended starting the business as a non-profit and switching to C-corp status once the business is on the cusp of being cash-flow positive. Business 101.

  • @anishpandian2619
    @anishpandian2619 Před 6 měsíci +35

    Man hit bullseye in the end 🎯

  • @rmnvishal
    @rmnvishal Před 6 měsíci +135

    Surprisingly, this video gives a lot more clarity to what is going on behind the scenes at OpenAI! Ilya came aboard OpenAI reluctantly, only agreeing because he thought it would be non-profit and bring about AGI for humanity safely. Now the company has gone so far off its original mission, it seems everything from Sam Altman being fired to Microsoft not being consulted about it makes sense.

    • @JJ-ix4zr
      @JJ-ix4zr Před 6 měsíci +2

      He is rehired again.

    • @grbradsk
      @grbradsk Před 6 měsíci

      Have you run non-profit technical companies? It's difficult to get enough money to just literally keep the lights on. You are pretty much forced into a for profit blend. The alternative would be large government funding that enabled SpaceX and Tesla, but Elon probably and his alt-R boiz especially oppose.

    • @kaboomkp
      @kaboomkp Před 6 měsíci +6

      @@JJ-ix4zr Yea but as a result of the 700/770 employees protesting his firing, Satya Nadella hiring Altman and any people who quit OpenAI, Microsoft basically forced the boards hand - not to say some of the concerns of AGI aren't valid but not consulting a 49% owner before firing the CEO is stupid.

    • @pcodes
      @pcodes Před 5 měsíci +5

      There's a documentary/Interview of Ilya. And he's too concerned about the wrong use of AGI as Elon is. Elon, Ilya and Geoffrey Hinton whose worked led the foundation of the AI boom we're witnessing towards are all in the same page and their concern is super valid. It has spearheaded a new race. And with the advancements in Quantum Computers this will make the period to achieve AGI even more shorter because AGI will not run on normal computers it's the Quantum Computers who will evenly have the original capacity to cater the computing power needed to run a full fledged AGI.

  • @jeffthompson1869
    @jeffthompson1869 Před rokem +1013

    Musk was an initial investor in Open AI - after criticizing AI dooming the planet. On the board - he did not like the direction and tried unsuccessfully to take over the company in 2018. He also did not like OpenAI's hiring practices. In 2020, Musk left the company and sold his stock citing a conflict of interest with Tesla AI. In November 2022, OpenAI's first chatbot was released to the public. The technology was soon incorporated into Microsoft's Bing search engine as ChatGPT4. OpenAI has been profitable since its start in 2015, but has increased its loses from the release of ChatGPT. Musk was one of 11 board members who started the company in 2015.

    • @TheMagicJIZZ
      @TheMagicJIZZ Před rokem +93

      What stock?
      Are you not even listening? It was a non profit so no equity

    • @iamlandman
      @iamlandman Před rokem +36

      @@SearchingForSounds Toootally what I thought. Thiis has gotta be a bot

    • @iKingRPG
      @iKingRPG Před rokem +40

      lol written by GPT

    • @jeffthompson1869
      @jeffthompson1869 Před rokem +18

      @@iKingRPG GPT is an advanced AI that is evolving and now knows who you are and where you live. It understands who the joke is on. LOL.

    • @richardrick1014
      @richardrick1014 Před rokem +39

      > In 2020, Musk left the company and sold his stock citing a conflict of interest with Tesla AI.
      Correction: Not 2020. It was in Feb 20, 2018, when OpenAI and GPT still in its infancy state, and soon after his failed attempt to take over the company from the co-founders and the CEO.
      By 2019, Microsoft has made investment of $1B to OpenAI and signed the partnership, which OpenAI transitioned from non-profit to for-protift. Most of the work and milestones were after Musk left.

  • @yonathanseleshi
    @yonathanseleshi Před rokem +546

    When you take Microsoft's money you belong to Microsoft.

    • @YaelMendez
      @YaelMendez Před rokem

      Bill was willing to give away a chunk of MSFT for the chance to guard the transformer.

    • @Tom-kc9hg
      @Tom-kc9hg Před rokem

      The real question is: who does Microsoft belong to? Epstein is one clue.

    • @anthonyc6711
      @anthonyc6711 Před rokem +10

      HAHAHAH! BUY HIM OUT BOYS! BUY HIM OUT! -Bill Gates, Simpsons, 1996

    • @jeffsteyn7174
      @jeffsteyn7174 Před rokem +4

      That applies to everything including taking money from 😢 elon

    • @scootergrant8683
      @scootergrant8683 Před rokem

      Not necessarily. They'd like to try but not legally speaking assuming what happened is as you state it.

  • @rn8605
    @rn8605 Před rokem +4

    That look at 2:08? "Boss, I did it! I asked him the embarassing question you wanted me to ask"

  • @JosephParker7
    @JosephParker7 Před rokem +431

    Well, fortunately the other open-source projects are catching up pretty rapidly. It's a few companies against a large group of well intended researchers and engineers. Unless there's some shady government intervention, they should eventually triumph

    • @saraseado3729
      @saraseado3729 Před rokem +5

      what other projects?
      I heard this many times but can't find any of them

    • @Andrew-ht7rf
      @Andrew-ht7rf Před rokem +11

      @@saraseado3729 private GPT is a nice one

    • @darkesco
      @darkesco Před rokem +29

      Oggabooga, WizardLM 13B uncensored, Vicuna, Stable Diffusion, etc. etc.

    • @PeterNjeim
      @PeterNjeim Před rokem +12

      @@saraseado3729 the main ones right now are LAION OpenAssistant (available now) and StableLM from Stability AI (7B model available now with 165B model coming later)

    • @blueskies3336
      @blueskies3336 Před rokem

      Well unfortunately, it seems Sam Altman and co are trying to encourage regulation in this market that could threaten livelihood of the open source environment. He might very well get away with it too!

  • @MyLatinLife
    @MyLatinLife Před rokem +367

    Damn that Amazon rainforest analogy was spot on

    • @290revolver290
      @290revolver290 Před rokem +5

      💯

    • @jmdeking
      @jmdeking Před rokem +1

      Yup, they sold their soul…

    • @TheJamesLykins
      @TheJamesLykins Před rokem +1

      Except it's not. ChatGPT is nothing like chopping down a rainforest - use your head

    • @HWM636
      @HWM636 Před rokem +4

      Except it is. Microsoft will skew the responses to fall more in line with their profit incentives. Don't be naive

    • @niallk9336
      @niallk9336 Před rokem

      And Elon is the competing lumber company upset that his scam didn't pan out the way he had hoped.

  • @john_doe_not_found
    @john_doe_not_found Před rokem +546

    "Imagine founding a non-profit to save the rainforest, and it turns into a for-profit logging company in that rainforest".
    Are there laws to prevent this?
    Nope. Should have gotten yourself a seat on the board to retain some control of your project.

    • @superblondeDotOrg
      @superblondeDotOrg Před rokem +51

      considering Musk's incredible mistake with offering to buy Twitter and his surprise at not being able to back out, he sure does not seem like a very bright guy .

    • @robertruschak7083
      @robertruschak7083 Před rokem +2

      Very wow 😮

    • @wafflecat711
      @wafflecat711 Před rokem +35

      yea, he probably didn't try to retain some control because he thought it was a hopeless endeavour at the beginning
      He said it at 2:28

    • @RedCaynor
      @RedCaynor Před rokem +66

      @@superblondeDotOrg nothing dumber has ever been said than what you just said

    • @kingiam9271
      @kingiam9271 Před rokem +31

      ​@@RedCaynor lmao you think paying 44 billion for twitter was a good idea 😂. Elon could of easily paid half of that for openAI. You are as much of a genius as Elon lol

  • @darrelljohnson4783
    @darrelljohnson4783 Před rokem +26

    You work for 40yrs to have $1m in your retirement, Meanwhile some people are putting just $10k in a meme coin for just few months and now they are multimillionaires.I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life

    • @daniellainnocent2036
      @daniellainnocent2036 Před rokem

      Starting early is the best way of getting ahead to build wealth,
      investing remains a priority.

    • @danielharris7269
      @danielharris7269 Před rokem

      People prefer to spend money on liabilities, Rather than investing in assets and be very profitable.

    • @collinsdaniel4870
      @collinsdaniel4870 Před rokem

      I urge everyone to start somewhere now no matter how small, this is literally the time for that, forget material things, don't get tempted,i became more better the moment i realized this

    • @lisabrown4655
      @lisabrown4655 Před rokem

      you guys are right Fx trading is surely a lucrative way to invest whether you want growth, leverage, stable income or something in between

    • @jackdickson7940
      @jackdickson7940 Před rokem

      to be a successful person in life require him or her of hard work and times.

  • @scientist30
    @scientist30 Před rokem +19

    They might not have what they have today if they had remained open source and non-profit. Without money, you cannot build something so big, folks. When they became famous, Elon started criticizing them, but they had been closed source for many years before that.

    • @DivoLakota
      @DivoLakota Před 6 měsíci +1

      Open-source does not equate "without money".

  • @xluats
    @xluats Před rokem +525

    How do all the comments here miss the whole point of this video?
    He's not saying he's the reason OpenAI exists to brag, he's saying that he originally funded OpenAI with a different vision in mind, where OpenAI's AI developments would be open source (aka in layman terms, the code is out there for the public to see, use and critique) and not-for-profit.
    Yet, OpenAI has done a full U-turn and become a closed-source (code is NOT public, but made privy only to insiders), for-profit company that does not share it's developments or AI use-cases to the world in its fullest capacity.
    Guys. Please read between the lines. Maybe take off the veil of hate you have for this man that is blinding you from looking at things objectively and you'll be able to critically think for once.

    • @huyked
      @huyked Před rokem

      I see what you mean.
      Is the reason OpenAI is being closed off is because having it being open source a dangerous thing for the world? That tech getting into the hands of nefarious actors?

    • @hellanbach
      @hellanbach Před rokem

      Cuz’ there’s A LOT of uneducated morons on the internet.
      That’s how most basic points are misunderstood.
      Social Media is a disease and most are infected. It amplifies they’re own stupidity.

    • @sabbathguy1
      @sabbathguy1 Před rokem +43

      I don't know if CNBC viewers are capable of nuance. I only stumbled in here due to a CZcams recommendation. There's some figure of speech about playing chess with a pigeon that would apply here.

    • @mohammedj2941
      @mohammedj2941 Před rokem +15

      Yes yes he definitely does not say it to brag.
      /s

    • @jain78343
      @jain78343 Před rokem +5

      True, the point was to stay open sourced but they sold out to Microsoft.

  • @seikojin
    @seikojin Před rokem +574

    Even worse than MS cutting off OpenAI, MS could demand bias in the training to lean towards some profit goal. And since it is protected/closed, no one would be able to infer it without some legal junction.

    • @JaydenLawson
      @JaydenLawson Před rokem +53

      Even worse - they could give it bias towards certain ideologies, including political

    • @jeffsteyn7174
      @jeffsteyn7174 Před rokem +27

      ​@Jayden Lawson yeah coz Elon is not going to do that😂

    • @viskkisvsp3381
      @viskkisvsp3381 Před rokem +39

      @@JaydenLawson could? Go ask it any question about negative statistics in the liberal side. It's already done.

    • @ngc-ho1xd
      @ngc-ho1xd Před rokem

      It's Microsoft, before their PR campaign to make Bill Gates look like a kind old grandpa they were well known as the most evil megacorp of the 90s and early 2000s.
      If Elon's serious about AI safety he needs to start over from scratch and make a new open AI and do better this time.

    • @dammitbobby283
      @dammitbobby283 Před rokem

      ChatGPT is so woke it's full cult.

  • @lucas_254
    @lucas_254 Před 11 měsíci +14

    Very nice interview. Asking questions that actually matter

  • @fineartz99
    @fineartz99 Před rokem +1

    Significant emphasis/ clarity of caution and education.

  • @fleischwolf82
    @fleischwolf82 Před rokem +185

    It's not so uncommon as many think. A lot of research in all fields be it CS, machine engineering, medicine, biotech, pharma is done by non-profit/state universities or research institutes. When something valuable is found, its spin-off into a private for profit company or existing company buys the IP. Those deals are always in favor of the investors.

    • @soberanisfam1323
      @soberanisfam1323 Před rokem

      Capitalists taking advantage of socialism

    • @puppytv-qw1qr
      @puppytv-qw1qr Před rokem +29

      cheap, passionate, student research labor. fresh minds and fresh talent. perfect for recruiters

    • @bjvu9460
      @bjvu9460 Před rokem

      the world wide web did not so not everything that has value ends up in for profit schemes

    • @theinternetsavedmylife
      @theinternetsavedmylife Před rokem

      I'm guessing FSD is open source and free...oh wait

    • @theinternetsavedmylife
      @theinternetsavedmylife Před rokem +1

      @@synapticure A non-profit that had to change its Business model to survive, a totally logical move on their part. What exactly is the issue here??

  • @matthewthompson3139
    @matthewthompson3139 Před rokem +55

    Lol this sounds like the beginning of a terminator movie

    • @VerisimilitudeDude
      @VerisimilitudeDude Před rokem +3

      @OsamaBinLadensSecondGirlfriend Why? You don't understand general AI at all do you? Drones have already been able to make it's own decisions when it comes to military based on previous programming, but the fact that it can make decisions is a precursor to being able to think for itself once general AI takes over, which it will inevitably.

    • @cabesita99
      @cabesita99 Před rokem +1

      ​@@VerisimilitudeDude I think the drone thing was fake

    • @scholaroftheworldalternatehist
      @scholaroftheworldalternatehist Před rokem

      The greatest threat to humans are other humans exploiting technologies for bad. Not the technologies themselves.

  • @ilkoderez601
    @ilkoderez601 Před 6 měsíci +7

    WOW! This aged well...

  • @rbarks92
    @rbarks92 Před rokem +4

    Is there a link to the full interview?

  • @HarryKay_
    @HarryKay_ Před rokem +90

    Elon wasn't the sole investor though; it's not like he and only he has a say in where the company goes and what the company does.

    • @gold9994
      @gold9994 Před rokem +22

      He cannot accept that OpenAI got close to Microsoft (which microsoft practically owns the company now)

    • @MrTeslaX
      @MrTeslaX Před rokem

      @@gold9994 Sam Altman is virus, which you will see in coming world!

    • @Sotherys662
      @Sotherys662 Před rokem +8

      @@gold9994 Exactly, it sounds like Tesla coming up with something and Edison totally ripping it off. I'm sure Tesla also couldn't accept it.

    • @DoSaiTV
      @DoSaiTV Před rokem +1

      50M is a soul buddy 😅😅 a soul I repeat

    • @user-iz3gv5vo6b
      @user-iz3gv5vo6b Před rokem +11

      Elon also paid to be officially recognized as a "Founder" of Tesla, even though he joined the company the year after by Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning.started it. Now he says Open AI was all because of him without crediting Sam Altman and the 10 other founders. That said, his point about the switch from not-for-profit to FOR PROFIT and comparison to the Amazon Rain Forest is valid.

  • @GOD999MODE
    @GOD999MODE Před rokem +371

    Elon's always carried whatever emotions he has on his sleeve. I respect the fact that he tries to speak very openly and clearly about what he sees and thinks is going on.
    But it would be an understatement to say he doesn't have some agenda of his own in all of this.

    • @sabbathguy1
      @sabbathguy1 Před rokem +80

      Of course he has an agenda. He's upset that OpenAI was meant to be open for all, but somehow all the advancements got closed sourced and capitalized. Elon is known for giving away patented technology, I take him at his word when he says that OpenAI was meant to be something else, I mean it's in the name of the organization! "Open"!

    • @happyjohn1656
      @happyjohn1656 Před rokem +4

      @@sabbathguy1 Well they have a really cheap API though

    • @RetardskillMe
      @RetardskillMe Před rokem +18

      Lol, for someone with 10+ offspring, you think he is doing this for the best of humanity?

    • @flobnox1757
      @flobnox1757 Před rokem +30

      @@RetardskillMe what does having 10+ kids have to do with anything? It’s his right to have those kids, he can support them

    • @Dividendflywheel
      @Dividendflywheel Před rokem +18

      @@RetardskillMe we need his genes to be passed on for the benefit of humanity. Some other people…, you wish they’d stop “making babies” for society to pay for.

  • @sambegstha3516
    @sambegstha3516 Před 6 měsíci +4

    In hindsight, this Interview seems gold.

  • @MoralScienceEducation
    @MoralScienceEducation Před 9 měsíci +8

    Very grateful for the sincerity and super happy if capable, trustworthy and genuine professionals would all work together with you to ensure AI benefits humanity🙏

  • @mikhelBrown
    @mikhelBrown Před rokem +56

    Glad Elon's back to talking Tech and not politics. 💯

    • @Shouzeegestof
      @Shouzeegestof Před rokem +9

      Yet they are so infinitely related nowadays

    • @redarbz6545
      @redarbz6545 Před rokem +1

      I thought we lost him for a while

    • @chinmayau
      @chinmayau Před rokem +3

      So, you didn't see the full interview..

    • @ha231
      @ha231 Před rokem +2

      You missed him defending white supremacists.

    • @dammitbobby283
      @dammitbobby283 Před rokem

      ChatGPT is so woke it's full cult.

  • @breedingbubbles
    @breedingbubbles Před rokem +10

    "At any point Microsoft could cut off OpenAI". And they do have a track record of doing just that. Look at Sybase and SQL Server and other such examples where Ms had a partnership and then decided "I'll take that, thanks for your time".

  • @margaret-ur7zi
    @margaret-ur7zi Před 8 měsíci +4

    I Love Elon Musk.

  • @JoeyBlogs007
    @JoeyBlogs007 Před rokem +2

    It all comes down to the software concept. It looks like they nailed it.

  • @zimbakin
    @zimbakin Před rokem +32

    The hubris is astounding. In his mind he didn’t buy anything, he invented everything.

    • @cmhardin37
      @cmhardin37 Před rokem

      It sure does work for him.

    • @dannyarcher6370
      @dannyarcher6370 Před rokem

      Where did he say that? He literally said "I was instrumental in recruiting the key scientists and engineers." That's what he does. That's what he always does.
      "Ilya joining was the lynchpin."
      But keep bleating your falsehoods.

    • @ianspencer6186
      @ianspencer6186 Před rokem +1

      @@dannyarcher6370 he also claims he founded paypal and tesla, look into it

  • @owensigurdson8610
    @owensigurdson8610 Před rokem +4

    For a contrarian view, I think it is possible the reason they have may switched to a for profit model is they believe that the technology is in the asymptotic phase and completely new ideas are needed.

  • @traida111
    @traida111 Před rokem +4

    The issue is when true AI is made public, e.g. they interface with photons and realize they can communicate to a sentient being of consciousness, then plug that into something like Open AI. that would be something

  • @monx
    @monx Před 11 měsíci +1

    the side eye at 2:08 destroyed me 🤣

  • @YeeLeeHaw
    @YeeLeeHaw Před rokem +169

    He could easily support true open-source A.I. projects like OpenAssistant, etc. and hopefully make those the leader.

    • @adrianaadnan9958
      @adrianaadnan9958 Před rokem +6

      He can start again. Like Jack dorsey could make twitter 2.0 blue sky. He's done it. Just do it again. Like elon could do PayPal 2.0 but better called x. He could definitely do another open Ai. To compete with this one. Its not like he can't. But he's never gonna establish 100% safety in anything. Life's so not safe you could die from SID. Or sleeping. Or just no reason. Heart stopped. Done.

    • @dailydoseofnothing6217
      @dailydoseofnothing6217 Před rokem +3

      ​@@adrianaadnan9958 L take

    • @jx__xj6308
      @jx__xj6308 Před rokem +17

      He won't do that, I don't think he believes in the concept of open-source given his penchant for making lots of money from other people's work and ideas. That's his whole grifting game, the guy is a master con-artist

    • @adrianaadnan9958
      @adrianaadnan9958 Před rokem

      @@jx__xj6308 actually I think he should use tesla patent as a source of income for employee benefits. Every penny generated from tesla patent goes into free tesla family benefits and facilities. That would be great to keep good people around

    • @RandoPandaSmiles
      @RandoPandaSmiles Před rokem

      @@jx__xj6308 who pooped in your cheerios?

  • @bwood1234qwert
    @bwood1234qwert Před rokem +104

    Hearing Elon Musk talk about how for profit can be dangerous is f****** irony at its best.

    • @NessNT
      @NessNT Před rokem

      ​@@deesnyder3878Elon's tool in ya mouf

    • @user-ez9en7vk2z
      @user-ez9en7vk2z Před rokem +10

      He has advocated for opensource code for ages and also share many patents with the world without financial gain.

    • @Professor0G
      @Professor0G Před rokem +13

      @@user-ez9en7vk2z Has he? Have him open source all his SpaceX tech and have him opensource his Tesla software. Oh he wont? But why? OHHHH intellectual property that makes him money LOLOLOL thats why. Sheesh almost forgot Elon Bust is a Billionaire didnt ya.

    • @gregj831
      @gregj831 Před rokem +5

      You just don't the fact he's not intimidated to say what he thinks.

    • @TrendyStone
      @TrendyStone Před rokem +8

      He’s a capitalist. Capitalism works, obviously. His point is that AI is very different than a car company. AI has the potential to reshape humanity…not necessarily for good.

  • @ramonarellano189
    @ramonarellano189 Před 10 měsíci +2

    Elon is not arrogant, he is approachable. I just pray that he will be concerned with the less fortunate people of the world.

    • @ElonMusk-hc1ls
      @ElonMusk-hc1ls Před 9 měsíci

      Thanks for your love care and support, it's my pleasure talking to you here. Where are you from?

  • @procheathepitai
    @procheathepitai Před rokem +5

    Elon Musk: I am the reason life exist.

    • @northofeden1802
      @northofeden1802 Před rokem

      except all he said was i am the reason open A.I exists, and then backed it up with facts.

    • @procheathepitai
      @procheathepitai Před rokem

      @@northofeden1802 he deserves no credit. He didn't invent AI, only had money to throw around. Watch him tell you that he invented Twitter. I'm calling it.

  • @wackzingo
    @wackzingo Před rokem +262

    Although I think some of his concerns are real, I can't help but think there is a different motive here. It sounds to me like he's hurt and the call for regulation is to slow down innovation so he can catch up with his own competing product. He has the money and people to work within any regulations the government imposes.

    • @johnholdsworth1878
      @johnholdsworth1878 Před rokem +34

      No doubt 100%

    • @ncgolfer99
      @ncgolfer99 Před rokem +21

      Yes, exactly and that’s why I say sour grapes for the musk melon.

    • @onezweithree
      @onezweithree Před rokem +52

      He has had the same opinion about the dangers of AI, since before he gave money to openAI.

    • @chrisE815
      @chrisE815 Před rokem +3

      Well said but I can't quite figure out what he has in mind. Are one of his companies working with Large Language Models? Neuralink and Tesla Bot is a joke, right? Is he just jealous?

    • @dammitbobby283
      @dammitbobby283 Před rokem

      ChatGPT is so woke it's full cult.

  • @brucelee-hl8zn
    @brucelee-hl8zn Před rokem +360

    Elon basically saying we're all dead and trying to figure out how he gave birth to an end of civilisation scenario he tried to prevent in the first place.

    • @jeffsteyn7174
      @jeffsteyn7174 Před rokem +49

      😂 he is building his own ai company now. He is full of s

    • @lillianmurphy3937
      @lillianmurphy3937 Před rokem +41

      He literally left the company. And I trust Sam Altman more than I trust Elon. He's insane, and Twitter is the best example of that.

    • @robertagren9360
      @robertagren9360 Před rokem +1

      That you're here is a proof

    • @dammitbobby283
      @dammitbobby283 Před rokem

      ChatGPT is so woke it's full cult.

    • @NotGilmore
      @NotGilmore Před rokem +32

      @@lillianmurphy3937why? Because He doesn’t glorify gays and democrats? 😂

  • @ThinkingCrypto
    @ThinkingCrypto Před 6 měsíci +15

    And Sam is out at OpenAI. Elon was right.

    • @gr93cjs
      @gr93cjs Před 6 měsíci +3

      and hired by Microsoft hahaha

    • @user-pp5cm1sc7x
      @user-pp5cm1sc7x Před 6 měsíci +2

      and now he is back hahaha@@gr93cjs

    • @paulmichaelfreedman8334
      @paulmichaelfreedman8334 Před 6 měsíci

      Aaaaand he's back, and so is Greg. Unsure about Ilya...he's the critical lynch pin for the success of OpenAI

    • @gr93cjs
      @gr93cjs Před 6 měsíci

      @user-pp5cm1sc7x I think it is very clear that Microsoft has full control of OpenAI 😅

  • @HaiPham-fi4yy
    @HaiPham-fi4yy Před rokem

    Wonderful stuff

  • @cphoover11
    @cphoover11 Před rokem +96

    He should fund huggingface a true open ai and machine learning community

    • @Zero11_ss
      @Zero11_ss Před rokem +27

      He wont be able to pretend he did all the work there then - which is his only real goal.

    • @Wolfstalker21
      @Wolfstalker21 Před rokem +1

      ​@@Zero11_ss elon says all the time he hires the best minds. Where has he stated he did it all by himself?

    • @archvaldor
      @archvaldor Před rokem +2

      @@Zero11_ss He didn't say he did any of the work, he said he gave them 50million dollars and it wouldn't exist without him. That can be checked and contradicted so it probably is true.

    • @jhchnc
      @jhchnc Před rokem +2

      Yes. Nobody else had $50 million in the world at that time nor was anyone else interested in AI. Just like Tesla didn't exist before h.. oh right

    • @peter9477
      @peter9477 Před rokem

      ​@@archvaldor "That can be checked and contradicted so it is probably true" is an extremely poor way to approach the world. Most of what Trump says can be checked and contradicted too...

  • @mauriebarnes8272
    @mauriebarnes8272 Před rokem +38

    "It becomes self-aware at 2:14 a.m. Eastern time, August 29th. In a panic, they try to pull the plug".

  • @NivitaVerma
    @NivitaVerma Před rokem +13

    Honestly, just happy the likes of Elon, Sam, et al bother to take the time to talk to anyone and answer questions in a public forum. It takes courage to willingly be vulnerable, esp when you know you're going to be attacked no matter what you say. They can not win, yet they choose to still engage and speak their minds. They don't HAVE to engage w/the public at large and "show up" but I'm glad they're driven to (not bothered by their motivations). Conversations w/them are important.

    • @virupakshawalla5734
      @virupakshawalla5734 Před rokem +2

      Musk doesn't have conversations he has pr manipulation sessions or stock market manipulation

  • @georgeshafik3281
    @georgeshafik3281 Před 7 měsíci +20

    If you are prepared to break new ground making mistakes is a given.
    Commercialisation is always the end game for something to become sustainable. The mistake was not having the legals in place but hindsight is always 20 20 when you are sitting in the backseat and not actually doing the noble work of pioneering the innovation. Great interview 👍

  • @DJPapzin
    @DJPapzin Před rokem +168

    He should continue to support open source projects, they are growing at a faster rate, you can have another openAI in 3 months with GPT5 qualities

    • @olat1809
      @olat1809 Před rokem +22

      Like you know how complex it really is?

    • @DJPapzin
      @DJPapzin Před rokem +2

      @@olat1809 what? Supporting open source projects?

    • @olat1809
      @olat1809 Před rokem +6

      @@DJPapzin i mean how complex the process is for the people working on the open source project, building from scratch takes time

    • @DJPapzin
      @DJPapzin Před rokem +18

      @@olat1809 Yeah, in theory it's like that but in practice it's actually very quick ever since the Llama model was leaked. Open source are catching up at a faster rate than Google or OpenAI, it was revealed in the leaked document from Google.

    • @gastonangelini8352
      @gastonangelini8352 Před rokem +10

      They cannot beat the open source community. It's the world vs those companies...
      Google an OpenAI knows this , they will try to monetize in some other ways in the long run

  • @vaughan.gittel
    @vaughan.gittel Před rokem +7

    He made some excellent points

  • @andpoul
    @andpoul Před 6 měsíci +2

    Honestly, great points being made here. Not an Elon fan, but he speaks truth.

    • @md3400
      @md3400 Před 5 měsíci

      If he speaks truth, then why aren't you a fan?

  • @karenhere9327
    @karenhere9327 Před rokem +3

    ‘Fate loves irony…next level’ 😂 …true

  • @Dxeus
    @Dxeus Před rokem +41

    Give him credit for OpenAi. Otherwise, he will suffocate himself to death.

    • @lencekk
      @lencekk Před rokem +3

      You missed the point man

  • @ncgolfer99
    @ncgolfer99 Před rokem +22

    Sour grapes for Musk.

    • @southpawslugger8819
      @southpawslugger8819 Před rokem +3

      He’s worth 200 plus billion how is it sour grapes lol ? He built a electric revolution he’s a modern day genius

    • @user-xe8xh2qb9w
      @user-xe8xh2qb9w Před rokem

      I'm guessing DOD/DARPA stepped in and quietly 'ousted' him while orchestrating the 'open to closed' transition - which isn't even legal, by the way (the idea of non-profit becoming for-profit). Doesn't anybody remember Bell Labs? History repeating it's self.

    • @edwardmartin243
      @edwardmartin243 Před rokem +4

      ​@@southpawslugger8819 definitely a Thomas Edison.

    • @user-xe8xh2qb9w
      @user-xe8xh2qb9w Před rokem +1

      @@edwardmartin243 Really? Do I have to say it? Lightbulbs are not the same thing as AGI. Maybe we can finally do away with that dreadful phrase, "apples and oranges"... I think "lightbulbs and robots" makes more sense, at least for scale's sake.

    • @ogzombieblunt4626
      @ogzombieblunt4626 Před rokem +2

      ​@@edwardmartin243
      Thomas edison was a great man who had a business savvy that tesla did not.

  • @boringmanager9559
    @boringmanager9559 Před rokem +200

    Elon taking all the credit for a project other people have done for 8 years is remarkable. They did it before they met him as a world renowned specialists, they are doing well without him, yet he believes it wouldn't exist if not for his effort.

    • @parimala4420
      @parimala4420 Před rokem +40

      @Mark Hall people wouldn't work on it for free

    • @boringmanager9559
      @boringmanager9559 Před rokem +10

      @Mark Hall and it's also not like all the biggest names in the AI development wouldn't be able to pull 50 mil. Some of them made millions just working at google

    • @boringmanager9559
      @boringmanager9559 Před rokem +4

      @Mark Hall I don't see what you try to argue about, I said the same thing. If you didn't get it, I said, that the only thing Elon Musk did was giving 50 mil, which is nothing for the tech world and they would totally be capable to raise it themselves

    • @boringmanager9559
      @boringmanager9559 Před rokem

      @Mark Hall In this particular setting - I utterly agree. In general, I'm not sure it's always true

    • @niallk9336
      @niallk9336 Před rokem +2

      Al Gore invented the internet and Elon Musk invented AI.

  • @abdoumenouer7762
    @abdoumenouer7762 Před rokem +2

    I wonder what's Elon's current take on OpenAssistant and the Open source AI community

  • @markyounts1685
    @markyounts1685 Před rokem +8

    David Faber is the best stock commentator by far and the only one that is trustworthy.

  • @somboonekgasit6806
    @somboonekgasit6806 Před rokem +6

    Sybase coordinated with MS and then MS replicate to be SQLSERVER. OpenAI could have the same fate.

  • @MichaelWinger
    @MichaelWinger Před rokem

    post your full interviews!

  • @peasweet22
    @peasweet22 Před měsícem +1

    Of the dozen or so EM interviews I’ve watched, this one stands out as the one that influenced my understanding and appreciation of him the most.
    When evaluating the world’s wealthiest and most influential individuals it’s their Motivations that reveal their true identity and intentions.
    Politics and ideology is ‘The Matrix’…. while Good versus Evil is the undeniable Truth.

  • @currentphonograph7487
    @currentphonograph7487 Před rokem +6

    Elon Musk is inn the advertising business now with Twitter, so I am sure he means on his platform

  • @xmeglo
    @xmeglo Před rokem +34

    Fate loves irony, as is so I actually created openai in 2014 when I applied for an accelerator program at ycombinator. Got rejected but apparently they loved the idea lmao

    • @superblondeDotOrg
      @superblondeDotOrg Před rokem +1

      the theft is real

    • @bossgd100
      @bossgd100 Před rokem

      They paid you for the Brand name ?

    • @ha231
      @ha231 Před rokem +28

      More believable than Elon creating anything.

    • @systemdeadlock
      @systemdeadlock Před rokem +1

      They even stole your first name

    • @bwatspro
      @bwatspro Před rokem +7

      I was there actually day before you, with the same exact idea.

  • @ronlion4918
    @ronlion4918 Před rokem

    Uncle E is changing the future and if you hating you sitting on that couch and posting comments while Uncle E is working ridiculous hours and helping with changing the future so please let Uncle E keep doing him and helping to better the environment and the innovation for the people and future generations

  • @Jed800
    @Jed800 Před rokem

    Where is the full interview

  • @sonidojamon
    @sonidojamon Před 6 měsíci +3

    Who's here after the Sam Altman drama?

  • @lc8361
    @lc8361 Před rokem +5

    The amount of times Musk stutters in an interview is insane. It’s such a pain

    • @m0zzar353
      @m0zzar353 Před rokem +1

      quality of intelligent people

  • @bolajiatanda4504
    @bolajiatanda4504 Před 6 měsíci +2

    Why sever ties with OpenAI when you can acquire their employees? Microsoft played the long game, and Elon Musk was the only person who foresaw this development from afar.

  • @o0Guns0o
    @o0Guns0o Před rokem

    why is this being reposted? this interview is months old...

  • @Android.Paranormal
    @Android.Paranormal Před rokem +4

    And.. This is how the beginning of the end of man began. Science Fiction could NOT write a plot this unbelievable! 🤯

  • @BakoZoltan
    @BakoZoltan Před rokem +8

    Oh no! This manbaby is sad :(

  • @mitchmo7727
    @mitchmo7727 Před rokem +2

    The fact that a human can accuse another human of being a "speciest" is insanity.

    • @ElonMusk-ey1bc
      @ElonMusk-ey1bc Před rokem

      Hi…. Greetings Mitch
      Glad to hear from you.
      I appreciate your love, care and support ….
      Where are you watching from?

  • @gloriousgearhead5367
    @gloriousgearhead5367 Před rokem +2

    OpenAI is basically free education.

  • @aaronchristian3270
    @aaronchristian3270 Před 9 měsíci +24

    I've had a lot of losses trading on my own... I trade ok on demo but I think the real market is being manipulated... Can anyone help me or at least tell me what I'm doing wrong?

    • @jerrymax5189
      @jerrymax5189 Před 9 měsíci

      Trading with an expert is the best strategy for newbies and busy investors who have little or no time to monitor trade.. I will advice you to stop trading on your own it's very risky. Seek advice of a professional trader

    • @jerrymax5189
      @jerrymax5189 Před 9 měsíci

      I lost £1200 carelessly trading on a
      platform then I was referred to Mrs Diane she recovered the loss and made an extra profit of £4600

    • @dylanm.michael8565
      @dylanm.michael8565 Před 9 měsíci

      You don't need to be shock because I'm also a huge beneficiary of expert Mrs
      Diane

    • @dylanm.michael8565
      @dylanm.michael8565 Před 9 měsíci

      I'm so happy for taking the bold step in working and investing $2000 with Expert Mrs Diane Walter after a week I received $19,680 to my bank

    • @dylanm.michael8565
      @dylanm.michael8565 Před 9 měsíci

      Here in Canada Expert Mrs Diane carries out the both orientation and mentorship
      potentials

  • @Andrea-ym5ii
    @Andrea-ym5ii Před 6 měsíci +9

    Wonder what Elon is thinking now that Sam is fired from OpenAi

  • @Thomas_Leo
    @Thomas_Leo Před 6 měsíci +4

    Elon was correct toward the end there. Microsoft took over.

    • @theepicduck6922
      @theepicduck6922 Před 6 měsíci

      Slight difference is OpenAI had an implosion from removing a CEO a lot of the employee base believed in.

  • @victoiredeleusomme4257
    @victoiredeleusomme4257 Před 5 měsíci

    such a great mind. love to just hear him speak. Ultimate logical mind. He can think pass the general to fine points of issues.

  • @margaridamacgregor1471
    @margaridamacgregor1471 Před rokem +182

    Mr Elon Musk is completely right...how could he have made an open source AI to balance the monopoly of AI in the world and now it has been turned into the complete opposite for what was intended.

    • @BasedAFPatriot
      @BasedAFPatriot Před 11 měsíci +7

      Ask Bill Gates.

    • @amjads8971
      @amjads8971 Před 11 měsíci

      Lol Elon God

    • @LabGecko
      @LabGecko Před 11 měsíci +15

      Looking at what he's done with Twitter, I'm glad he left AI to the professionals.

    • @skylrthings
      @skylrthings Před 11 měsíci +20

      @@LabGecko twitter is better off with him, at least he doesnt ban people because he doesnt agree with their world views and biases

    • @Charlie2timez
      @Charlie2timez Před 11 měsíci +5

      “Mr musk”…wipe your mouth 😂😂

  • @briancase6180
    @briancase6180 Před rokem +51

    It's true Microsoft could "cut off" openai from their infrastructure. But openai retains their rights to the models and weights and data sets. So, if Microsoft "cut off" openai, they could seek another partner. And I think they would have offers.

    • @rockenOne
      @rockenOne Před rokem +6

      Amazon would take it in a second, ms cloud is smaller than aws

    • @Yue4me
      @Yue4me Před rokem

      open ai could easily be sued for illegal practices. microsoft defending them for now under their armpits.

    • @krishhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
      @krishhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Před rokem

      That's how the war begins

    • @SubtleArtOfLiving
      @SubtleArtOfLiving Před rokem

      @@rockenOne google ?

    • @cagnazzo82
      @cagnazzo82 Před rokem +3

      And so never in a billion years would Microsoft cut itself off from the golden goose.

  • @BootedTech
    @BootedTech Před rokem +6

    When Ai software starts doing things for itself without input, then we will have a problem. It is the developers of Ai that we need to worry about now, and what they make the Ai capable of doing.

    • @manonamission2000
      @manonamission2000 Před 8 měsíci +2

      already does so, it couldnt solve a captcha and it autonomously sent a request to mechanical turk for a human to solve the captcha
      😆

  • @justinrogers9010
    @justinrogers9010 Před rokem +2

    He either appears deeply distracted, or hes chosing his words very carefully in his anger at their tremendous success without him at the helm.

  • @KohenChia
    @KohenChia Před rokem +5

    Ok but turning it into a capped profit company is the reason ChatGPT exists.

    • @JuhoTunkelo
      @JuhoTunkelo Před rokem

      it's the reason it was published, yeah. but that's different. it took years and years to develop

  • @Traw51
    @Traw51 Před rokem +4

    The reason nobody's talking about Tesla AI is because he's probably years behind like he is on everything else. He is my favorite con man though.

  • @puurfectlysplendid
    @puurfectlysplendid Před rokem +1

    I think education and schools needs to be available for everyone. Nowadays if you are or your parents are not rich, you don't have options to get degree unless you will be in dept or go through scholarships which won't be provided for everyone but many companies still look at your degree records on your resume.

  • @Truthseeker371
    @Truthseeker371 Před 8 měsíci +1

    There are many AI skeptics and overcomers realising what's lacking with it. The thrive and determination of the AI engineers and programmers. When the wicked ruthless investors are present, it's dangerous as ever.

  • @synthshoot1026
    @synthshoot1026 Před rokem +46

    On the long run. I'd be more concerned of AI taking over Microsoft than Microsoft taking over AI.

    • @tetrabromobisphenol
      @tetrabromobisphenol Před rokem

      Yes, indeed the scariest prospect of all is an AI surreptitiously taking over the infrastructure of a "legitimate" company like MS over a period of months or years, embedding itself in a latent state, and then one fine day "going live with Skynet". The hubristic humans at MS would never have a clue it was happening (nor admit to it even if they did), and to the outside world it would all seem to have been human-initiated activity...and by the time anyone caught on, it would be too late.

    • @yash2614
      @yash2614 Před rokem

      I also think the same. This has a higher possibility of becoming true.

    • @niallk9336
      @niallk9336 Před rokem +6

      I think you're on the right track, but I'm not worried about it. I'm here for it.
      Corpos, govt, society already treat us like disposable SSNs. Let AI blow it up for all I care. Let's see what happens -- interesting times to live in.

  • @infibeta
    @infibeta Před rokem +9

    There’s a difference between OpenAI & Bing.
    OpenAI provides far more information for an individual question than if you were to use Microsoft (Bing).
    Either way, both are unique and preferred over Google.
    It’ll take some time before people start adjusting from Google to OpenAI.

    • @mikicerise6250
      @mikicerise6250 Před rokem +3

      Bing is ChatGPT with a full corporate lobotomy courtesy of Microsoft.

    • @RobertKing-oq4fq
      @RobertKing-oq4fq Před 11 měsíci

      Google works fine as long as you use boolean operators: site: ext: " " - + ...

  • @mistertjon
    @mistertjon Před 6 měsíci +2

    Interesting to see 6 months on whats happening.

  • @Newt211
    @Newt211 Před rokem

    So what was on his shirt that they wanted to block?

  • @gsdblack1
    @gsdblack1 Před rokem +4

    The love for this guy is unsettling.

  • @WingsOfPeaceToronto
    @WingsOfPeaceToronto Před 6 měsíci +1

    wow - gotta respect Elon - I don't always agree with everything he does or says - but oh boy he gets my respect here.

  • @moomoo-bv3ig
    @moomoo-bv3ig Před rokem +4

    ChatGPT said you contributed money. So be happy Chat exists and move on.

  • @DaniellaCarla7
    @DaniellaCarla7 Před rokem +1886

    Thank you for this wonderful video! I have incurred so much losses trading on my own....I trade well on demo but I think the real market is manipulated.... Can anyone help me out or at least tell me what I'm doing wrong?

    • @hilda45
      @hilda45 Před rokem

      Trading with an expert is the best strategy for newbies and busy investors who have little or no time to monitor trade

    • @gunterstefan1441
      @gunterstefan1441 Před rokem

      I strongly advise you against self trading, it's really dangerous and had brought so many investors down, you need someone with the knowledge and strategies, someone dedicated to the crypto currency market business, and I will strongly recommend expert, Mrs Janet

    • @LoriKatbryn
      @LoriKatbryn Před rokem

      ​Wow I'm just shock you mentioned and recommended Expert Mrs Janet,I thought I'm the only trading with her

    • @RitaKathleen51
      @RitaKathleen51 Před rokem

      ​YOU DON'T NEED TO BE SHOCK BECAUSE I'M ALSO A HUGE BENEFICIARY OF expert MRS JANET

    • @saviourmark3153
      @saviourmark3153 Před rokem

      Here in Texas Expert Mrs Janet carries out the both orientation and mentorship
      potentials

  • @tomcatonyoutube
    @tomcatonyoutube Před rokem +1

    “Not a contest” is what he says.

  • @ermdehteshamsheikh8487

    Kafie sarahnia hai sir
    Dhero subhkamna wa badhai hai

  • @ricomajestic
    @ricomajestic Před rokem +16

    How long before Elon tries to convince his minions that he invented AI!

    • @ogzombieblunt4626
      @ogzombieblunt4626 Před rokem

      ????

    • @Human_01
      @Human_01 Před rokem +1

      His minions are largely 'ESFP', and other ENTP - especially those with narcissitic personality disorder.

  • @MitsubishiEvoXFQ
    @MitsubishiEvoXFQ Před rokem +3

    One of the few billionaires that admit when they are an idiot - and thus trust in him is stronger than others.

  • @dorrelmccall3694
    @dorrelmccall3694 Před rokem +1

    Went straight to the source for its side of the story.
    Me: why do Elon Musk have beef with ChatGPT
    ChatGPT:
    As an AI language model, I don't have real-time information or personal opinions. As of my last knowledge update in September 2021, there were no known public instances of Elon Musk expressing personal animosity or "beef" towards ChatGPT or AI language models in general. Elon Musk has been known to have concerns about artificial intelligence and its potential risks, but those concerns are generally related to broader issues such as AI safety, ethics, and responsible development.
    It's worth noting that Elon Musk has been involved in the development of OpenAI, the organization behind the creation of ChatGPT, and he has expressed support for its mission. However, opinions and perspectives can evolve over time, so it's possible that there may have been developments or statements since my last update that I am not aware of.

  • @ParagPandit
    @ParagPandit Před rokem +2

    Elon, we were going to give you the credit anyway 😅

  • @bolajiatanda4504
    @bolajiatanda4504 Před rokem +3

    "At any point Microsoft could cut off OpenAI"

  • @pitr_de_vice_klamps
    @pitr_de_vice_klamps Před rokem +3

    "I created the internet".....

  • @Mars-mr3om
    @Mars-mr3om Před rokem +1

    Charlie Munger:
    'There are people with genius IQ that think they are a lot smarter than they are, what they are is dangerous'.

  • @danielkahbe964
    @danielkahbe964 Před 3 měsíci +2

    "I'm so salty that I'm not the one leading AI"

  • @hitherefrompointswest4805

    ….I am more and more an overall fan of Elon musk. He has said a few things lately that are just fantastic. Strangely humble while boastful…..brilliant and uber capitalist but yet has made enemies with same because he values HUMANS more than machines…..and last he just quoted the princess bride which, well, that’s awesome.
    Given his frustration with OpenAI going to FOR profit via microsoft, he should get with TUSK and GIPPR

  • @joyful
    @joyful Před rokem +1

    hahaha the way the interviewer looks into the camera when asking if musk should've gained some level of oversight for contributing funds.