While I'm very disappointed that this game won't get an english dub this time considering how amazing the voice acting was in the first one, this is still a definite buy for me. I loved the first one, genuinely one of the funniest games I've ever played, and I'm excited to see where they plan on taking the story this time. Thanks for the review!
@@JRPGgamerforlife I'm honestly really glad they didn't make a sequel to that route, since I absolutely hated it. Barely any of the male characters were still alive by the end. They even lampshade that it's basically just turning into a straight-up harem game. I'm much happier they started from scratch so we could get all the characters to make a return. I haven't finished the game yet, but so far it doesn't feel too much of a retread of the original storyline, and I'm enjoying it quite a lot. Though the new battle system definitely isn't as fun as the original one, so I'd still say I prefer the original overall.
This game is a day one pick up for me! I absolutely loved the 1st game in the series. Actually anything Idea Factory and compile heart put out is a day one purchase for me. I just love their games.
@@DieselJT what's your favorite game by them? Anything neptunia I love, but I've really been digging mugen souls lately. I only hope they eventually get more funding because if they had a Square Enix budget they could EASILY put class anything of the modern era
I will miss the english dub as it gave the last game alot of charm. Hell, I would buy an english dub track for this game if it came as DLC later, thats for sure....
Same here, who knows it may be like xenoblade chronicles in that you can download the Japanese language for free so maybe it’ll be the same but in this case for English.
I was kinda hyped since i loved fencer F and the remaster but i'm not into tactical rpg that much. Also i'm sad the english dub isnt there since i enjoyed their voices
The previous game in the series (wasn't the PS4 game an enhanced port of the PS3 one?) is the only Compile Heart game I have ever really enjoyed, and I loved it. So I've really been looking forward to this one, and I'm glad to hear that it turned out well.
@Seishin I always thought Advent Dark Force was an enhanced port as well. But the way it's worded in this review made it sound like the ps4 game was a sequel. So thank you for the confirmation. Thought I may have another game to catch up on for a minute there 😅
@@Neo-Abobo nope. It was an enhanced port that got several routes added in and new playable characters that weren't there before and a couple other stuff.
thanks this was an extremely thorough review that went into things that i needed to know much better than other reviews i've seen. i was on the edge of picking it up before, but i'm much more likely to buy it now. i did really like dark advent, but this got so many horrid (though vague) reviews, that i was not feeling good about it at all. until now. thanks.
I think I will give this game a chance in the future. I am not completely sold on the strategy aspect. I don't really like that top-down approach. I think the old game had it's charms because you could connect to the characters visually. With this new game the characters are squeezed down to chess pieces, loosing that "connection". As said, I am really not a big RTS fan (although I can enjoy it in games like Kings Bounty II), and that's what holding me back for now.
I would like to mention that having prior game knowledge helps a lot as most of the previous cast of villains show up in chapter 3 like everyone knows who the hell they are. I am quite sure anyone new to the series would get lost really easily. Secondly, the game does not explain why Sherman falters between light and dark so easily, as he's seen to shift between good and evil early on in the game. Also, Glace participates in every battle you have, she's there to amplify enemy forces and introduce some sort of difficulty. Just some notetaking points that I think should be said in reviews.
So i picked up fairy fencer a while back as my random JRPG to buy each year Really enjoyed it and now seeing it going the tactics route for this game Has me interested. This review has also pushed me towards checking it out eventually to
I know what you mean about the English dub. I actually like SRPGs so the battle system is fine, but developers need to get it in their heads that this isnt 2005 anymore when English dubs were garbage and people preferred Japanese dubs. That isnt the case anymore, and not dubbing a game these days is just being cheap and lazy.
disappointed by there being no English dub considering that the first game had dub voices 🤦♂️, the change in the battle system is also a big turn off for me so I will be waiting for a huge discount as I am not willing to buy for full price, sorry if I sound like a idiot or if it feels like I am trash talking the game, believe me I don’t want to I absolutely loved the first game, I just feel like this is a step backwards rather than forwards.
True love the game, but it's only been released on the PS3. Same with Drakengard and white knight chronicles. Also a port of chaos legion would be awesome.
Wait, this is a series? I definitely thought Fairy Fencer F: Advent Dark Force was a standalone. I’ve tried playing through it twice and couldn’t finish it either time.
worse, Advent Dark Force it's a remake of the original game that added a side story where you played as the villains this appears to be a sort of pseudo-sequel (as in a rewrite of the original plot that acknowledges this fact, kinda like SMTIVA or Fire Emblem 3 Hopes) the story already involved time traveling and parallel universes so I can see that being the case here as well
The first one is *way better* than this new game, so your question is a moot point for that reason. You are better off playing the first one *anyway* since it's a masterpiece.
Wait, isn't fairy fencer and fairy fencer f the same game? Just a remaster right? Looked it up, there is only "fairy fencer f" and an expanded port. They r not different games!!
Great to see more of this series, but damn... couldn't they have changed the character illustrations? I know Compile Hearts do things in a budget, but precisely that is a good way of changing things a bit without investing a ton of cash. PS: dang, I freaking hate Pippin.
I wonder how it works for non-fans, though -- back then, I gave FF Advent Dark Force a thumb down for being mostly a Neptunia reskin with rushed, short stories (at the time, I hadn't played RB1 and RB2 yet, only RB3 and VII)... Well, I guess more reviews can be uncovered with some bit of click shaping.
@@BrandonHeat243 I'm not a PC guy, so it comes down to Switch or PS5 for me. Generally I find the Switch more fun to play on, and the added bonus of being able to play handheld is certainly a plus, but if the PS5 has notably better performance or load-times I might be persuaded to get that version instead.
I played the game on switch and the game was ass (since it was literally copy pasted from neptunia) but Fang and Eryn are the best protagonist duo I've ever seen so I'm in as long as they retain their personalities
A western otaku. Short version of "weeaboo", which 4chan used to use as a word replacement filter for "wapanese". The word itself comes from a Perry Bible Fellowship comic.
Fairy Fencer ADF is a great game. Death's End Re;Quest part 1 is also good. Dragon Star: Varnir has a great story and music and artwork, although the gameplay isn't the best and it doesn't run very well on some PCs.
The lack of an English dub instantly made me lose interest. Especially since the first game and it's enhanced PS4 version had a great dub. Really getting sick of IF getting lazy with their localizations.
An SRPG for weebs... Not counting Disgaea, Fire Emblem, Langrisser, Hyperdevotion Noire, Devil Survivor, God Wars, Valkyria Chronicles, Super Robot Wars... Yeah do you have the slightest idea how little that narrows it down?
I was disappointed too. Normally I wouldn`t mind having no dub but Fairy Fencer F has a very good English voice cast (and a lot of voiced dialogue, too) so knowing that there is no dub leave me very sour to the point that I will wait for a sale.
I much prefer when japanese games have japanese only audio. Typically when they get dubbed, the rest of us who like to enjoy them subbed have to put up with "dubtitles".
The English dub in the ADF version of Fairy Fencer is perfect, and that game would be *much* worse without it, and *no doubt* this new one is missing tonnes of value for not having it too.
While I'm very disappointed that this game won't get an english dub this time considering how amazing the voice acting was in the first one, this is still a definite buy for me. I loved the first one, genuinely one of the funniest games I've ever played, and I'm excited to see where they plan on taking the story this time. Thanks for the review!
Aww man, the dub was half the reason I liked this game
I'm more dissapointed that this game isn't a sequel that continues off of the evil goddess route.
@@JRPGgamerforlife I'm honestly really glad they didn't make a sequel to that route, since I absolutely hated it. Barely any of the male characters were still alive by the end. They even lampshade that it's basically just turning into a straight-up harem game.
I'm much happier they started from scratch so we could get all the characters to make a return. I haven't finished the game yet, but so far it doesn't feel too much of a retread of the original storyline, and I'm enjoying it quite a lot. Though the new battle system definitely isn't as fun as the original one, so I'd still say I prefer the original overall.
This game is a day one pick up for me! I absolutely loved the 1st game in the series. Actually anything Idea Factory and compile heart put out is a day one purchase for me. I just love their games.
Yeah I seriously can't understand the hate for them, they aren't triple A but they have so much more heart in their games (no pun intended)
@@KaijuCouture agree 100 percent!!!!!
@@DieselJT what's your favorite game by them? Anything neptunia I love, but I've really been digging mugen souls lately. I only hope they eventually get more funding because if they had a Square Enix budget they could EASILY put class anything of the modern era
@@KaijuCoutureit’s almost like… they COMPILE their HEARTS to their games 😱
@@ausername8770 they always XSEED my expectations!
I will miss the english dub as it gave the last game alot of charm. Hell, I would buy an english dub track for this game if it came as DLC later, thats for sure....
Same here, who knows it may be like xenoblade chronicles in that you can download the Japanese language for free so maybe it’ll be the same but in this case for English.
wow your one of those useless people who are willing to just throw money at anything arent you ?
I was kinda hyped since i loved fencer F and the remaster but i'm not into tactical rpg that much.
Also i'm sad the english dub isnt there since i enjoyed their voices
The previous game in the series (wasn't the PS4 game an enhanced port of the PS3 one?) is the only Compile Heart game I have ever really enjoyed, and I loved it. So I've really been looking forward to this one, and I'm glad to hear that it turned out well.
yes. Advent Dark force was an enhanced version with several changes like different routes.
@Seishin I always thought Advent Dark Force was an enhanced port as well. But the way it's worded in this review made it sound like the ps4 game was a sequel. So thank you for the confirmation. Thought I may have another game to catch up on for a minute there 😅
@@Neo-Abobo nope. It was an enhanced port that got several routes added in and new playable characters that weren't there before and a couple other stuff.
thanks this was an extremely thorough review that went into things that i needed to know much better than other reviews i've seen. i was on the edge of picking it up before, but i'm much more likely to buy it now. i did really like dark advent, but this got so many horrid (though vague) reviews, that i was not feeling good about it at all. until now. thanks.
I think I will give this game a chance in the future. I am not completely sold on the strategy aspect. I don't really like that top-down approach. I think the old game had it's charms because you could connect to the characters visually. With this new game the characters are squeezed down to chess pieces, loosing that "connection". As said, I am really not a big RTS fan (although I can enjoy it in games like Kings Bounty II), and that's what holding me back for now.
it's not an RTS tho
It's an SRPG closer to FFTactics or Triangle Strategy, one of the best of its kind
I would like to mention that having prior game knowledge helps a lot as most of the previous cast of villains show up in chapter 3 like everyone knows who the hell they are. I am quite sure anyone new to the series would get lost really easily. Secondly, the game does not explain why Sherman falters between light and dark so easily, as he's seen to shift between good and evil early on in the game. Also, Glace participates in every battle you have, she's there to amplify enemy forces and introduce some sort of difficulty. Just some notetaking points that I think should be said in reviews.
So i picked up fairy fencer a while back as my random JRPG to buy each year
Really enjoyed it and now seeing it going the tactics route for this game
Has me interested. This review has also pushed me towards checking it out eventually to
I love Fairy Fencer! But this sequel has no english dub and not a fan of the battle system. I will just replay the previous game.
I know what you mean about the English dub. I actually like SRPGs so the battle system is fine, but developers need to get it in their heads that this isnt 2005 anymore when English dubs were garbage and people preferred Japanese dubs. That isnt the case anymore, and not dubbing a game these days is just being cheap and lazy.
I agree 100%!
disappointed by there being no English dub considering that the first game had dub voices 🤦♂️, the change in the battle system is also a big turn off for me so I will be waiting for a huge discount as I am not willing to buy for full price, sorry if I sound like a idiot or if it feels like I am trash talking the game, believe me I don’t want to I absolutely loved the first game, I just feel like this is a step backwards rather than forwards.
are there more than one route/ending like the previous game? I remember being able to awaken the evil God instead of the Goddess in Fairy Fencer F
Yes! But you don’t have to beat it 3 times lol
@@NoisyPixelNews Nice 😂👍
I bought the collector edition
I thought the first Fairy Fencer F: on the switch was fine.
I liked its sense of humor and music. But the draw distance was so terrible.
That was a port and not a very good one
How long did it take you to beat the game ?
1000 hours.
i'll get on ps5 love srpgs
Hope cross edge be released for switch
True love the game, but it's only been released on the PS3.
Same with Drakengard and white knight chronicles.
Also a port of chaos legion would be awesome.
@@Yusei255 u never know considering they released record of agarest war from ps3
Trinity universe too
Wait, this is a series? I definitely thought Fairy Fencer F: Advent Dark Force was a standalone. I’ve tried playing through it twice and couldn’t finish it either time.
worse, Advent Dark Force it's a remake of the original game that added a side story where you played as the villains
this appears to be a sort of pseudo-sequel (as in a rewrite of the original plot that acknowledges this fact, kinda like SMTIVA or Fire Emblem 3 Hopes)
the story already involved time traveling and parallel universes so I can see that being the case here as well
@@Sigismund697 that’s actually one of the most confusing things I’ve ever heard, lol
How important is it to play first one before this sequel?
Looks kinda important considering all the characters and the last game “final route” left off on a cliffhanger
The first one is *way better* than this new game, so your question is a moot point for that reason.
You are better off playing the first one *anyway* since it's a masterpiece.
just play the first one
What’s weird is when I saw the strategy aspects I was put off, but then I realized the standard combat is too terribly different.
Wait, isn't fairy fencer and fairy fencer f the same game? Just a remaster right?
Looked it up, there is only "fairy fencer f" and an expanded port. They r not different games!!
There is no such thing as "Fairy Fencer." That simply doesn't exist. All of the games have the F included in the title.
Great to see more of this series, but damn... couldn't they have changed the character illustrations? I know Compile Hearts do things in a budget, but precisely that is a good way of changing things a bit without investing a ton of cash.
PS: dang, I freaking hate Pippin.
I wonder how it works for non-fans, though -- back then, I gave FF Advent Dark Force a thumb down for being mostly a Neptunia reskin with rushed, short stories (at the time, I hadn't played RB1 and RB2 yet, only RB3 and VII)...
Well, I guess more reviews can be uncovered with some bit of click shaping.
Oh, and do you have a recommended platform to play this game one?
Presumably PS5 would have the best performance. Well, PC might run better but that's not coming for like another month.
@@BrandonHeat243 I'm not a PC guy, so it comes down to Switch or PS5 for me. Generally I find the Switch more fun to play on, and the added bonus of being able to play handheld is certainly a plus, but if the PS5 has notably better performance or load-times I might be persuaded to get that version instead.
The answer is *always* PC master race.
@@True_Christian PC is lame and overrated, sorry you had to find out this way.
so, is this game a reboot or reimaging of the older game or is it a new story?
Does anybody know if the PS4 version is able to be upgraded to the PS5 version?
Are there different idol songs?
No English dub = no buy.
I played the game on switch and the game was ass (since it was literally copy pasted from neptunia) but Fang and Eryn are the best protagonist duo I've ever seen so I'm in as long as they retain their personalities
Lagging on the switch. I play for 1 hour and for some reason, lost interest in continue to play it.
*sees title*
Do you have the slightest idea how little that narrows it down?
Whats a Weeb ?
You,you are a weeb
A western otaku. Short version of "weeaboo", which 4chan used to use as a word replacement filter for "wapanese". The word itself comes from a Perry Bible Fellowship comic.
Played this some time ago in Japanese.
I don't know why I keep giving Compile Heart a chance.
They haven't released a single good game.
We all fall into the trap
Fairy Fencer ADF is a great game. Death's End Re;Quest part 1 is also good.
Dragon Star: Varnir has a great story and music and artwork, although the gameplay isn't the best and it doesn't run very well on some PCs.
The lack of an English dub instantly made me lose interest. Especially since the first game and it's enhanced PS4 version had a great dub. Really getting sick of IF getting lazy with their localizations.
An SRPG for weebs...
Not counting Disgaea, Fire Emblem, Langrisser, Hyperdevotion Noire, Devil Survivor, God Wars, Valkyria Chronicles, Super Robot Wars...
Yeah do you have the slightest idea how little that narrows it down?
No dub, no buy. What a lazy release.
I was very bummed about no Dub. I'll get it on sale one day.
I was disappointed too. Normally I wouldn`t mind having no dub but Fairy Fencer F has a very good English voice cast (and a lot of voiced dialogue, too) so knowing that there is no dub leave me very sour to the point that I will wait for a sale.
Quality&accurate translation > dub
Imagine consuming anime stuff with non-JP dub. Do americans really? Uncultured casuals I swear
Agreed.
You lost me at 'weebs'. Come on, that word might as well be the definition of xenophobia.
What are you talking about?
@@NoisyPixelNews Really? I'm sure you can figure it out for yourself.
I much prefer when japanese games have japanese only audio. Typically when they get dubbed, the rest of us who like to enjoy them subbed have to put up with "dubtitles".
The English dub in the ADF version of Fairy Fencer is perfect, and that game would be *much* worse without it, and *no doubt* this new one is missing tonnes of value for not having it too.
I rather everyone have the most options available to enjoy the games the way they want. Sorry, sub fans aren’t the only ones that exist…