1.4 Turbocharger vs 1.5 Naturally Aspirated Engine - Kia Seltos & Hyundai Creta 2020 Petrol Engines
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 04. 2020
- The two Petrol Engines of Kia Seltos already gave a dilemma to Kia customers and now the story moves ahead with Hyundai Creta. I am comparing the two types of engines in these two vehicles to tell you what suits you the best.
The .1.4 Turbocharger had been an interesting pick for many people due to the BHP figures it shows on the paper, but only true car experts know the advantage of the 1.5 naturally aspirated engine.
A small capacity engine having a turbocharger is not always a true reliable engine for many people. Watch the detailed video to learn more about what factors make the naturally aspirated engine a better choice than the Turbocharger engine.
** This video is about: **
Hyundai Creta 1.4 Turbocharger Engine Anatomy
Hyundai Creta 1.5 Naturally Aspirated Engine Anatomy
Kia Seltos 1.4 Turbocharger Engine Anatomy
Kia Seltos 1.5 Naturally Aspirated Engine Anatomy
Turbocharger Engine vs Naturally Aspirated Engine
Disadvantages of a Turbocharger Engine
Small Turbocharger Engine Problems
This video is not about features of Kia Seltos vs Hyundai Creta 2020 BS6.
.
.
.
Lean more about these cars in my blog at nickzeek.wordpress.com/ and share your car/bike purchase requirements, for a quick guidance. You can also call me to discuss your next car/bike purchase for just Rs. 349 per call @ 9130483778 (to be paid via UPI during or after the call).
If you have any question about any Indian car, please feel free to mention it in the comment below or write to me via social media:
/ thenickzeek
/ thenickzeek
Credits:
Starring & Review By: Nick Zeek
(a.k.a. Nikhil Borkute)
Videography: Nick Zeek
Scripted & Edited By: Nick Zeek
...
Equipment Used:
Go Pro Action Cam: amzn.to/3o0792u
Go Pro Mount Kit: amzn.to/2XV2yUH
Go Pro Helmet Mount: amzn.to/3p5GO4g
Go Pro Protection: amzn.to/2M1xlMJ
Mivi BT Headphones: amzn.to/3sB81y1
iPhone Photography: amzn.to/3qziVm0 - Auta a dopravní prostředky
Turbocharger seems more exciting but for long term, there is nothing better than a naturally aspirated engine. 🤩
agree!
absolutely correct
What do you mean by long term. Shall I know?
Hi sir can u suggest me which version I have to choose creta turbo petrol or 1.5 petrol cvt ? I want to keep my car with me over 7 years. And my monthly kms around 1500kms. Please suggest me
@@pradeepchand2698 if u want to keel for 7 years then stay away from turbo engines.Turbo engines are less releable compare to smartstream
sirf 12 minutes mein itna achha aur koi nahin samjha sakta tha ye complex difference. Great video.
Truly awesome video. Thanks for sharing the amazing comparison. This is very crucial information.
Very nice video, thanks for sharing the info. 🤩
Brilliant comparison. Too much of knowledge shared in simple language. Thanks Nick.
Wow, such an intelligent video. Me and my husband loved the seltos and had booked it. Recently moved our booking to Creta due to the panoramic sunroof. Now we will move our booking from SX(O) 1.4 to SX(O) 1.5. Thanks for the guidance Nick.
Bhawana Mohane Creta 2020 sx o ivt is great model
Ivt transmission ? You should go and study how ivt work i am sure you will go for dct
Are you happy with your changed decision, or you feel that you should have bought 1.4 turbo. Thanks
great video.looking for this video only. very nicely explained.
Very nicely explained, thanks for your time n sharing knowledge
outstanding technical vdieo. Never heard this comparison before about these top selling cars' engines.
Great video. Very informative.
Very well explained thanks
My running requirements is less, mostly go out on fun and enthusiastic drives (no revving engine on high rpm but mostly on long drives on cruise) , do my car maintenance regularly and change my car after every 5 years to get best resale value with max km run like 50000 kms. This led me buy 1.4 turbo petrol Creta SXO and I Love it !!! For little part when i need to overtake and all, this car drives like a rocket ! However if I drive on cruise speeds I get easily 16 -17 kmpl. I love my 1.4 T petrol car but that's me.
Amazing. Well said! Thanks for sharing your experience.
I'm guessing it's an automatic
Zero star safety don’t bother Indians because we are superheroes
Absolutely phenomenal , i was right to book the sx 1.5 petrol as per my requirements , thanks sir 🙏🙏
Nice and informative video. Good job. 👌👍
I wanted to decide between creta top line ivt sx(o) variant and seltos top variant which has a dct transmission.. if there is such a video then pls let me know, I would highly appreciate 🙏
Much need video that I was looking for. To the point content. Good work
Very nice video, much needed
fabulous knowledge!
Thanks ..very informative
Thank you for this detailed video bhai ☺
Hello bro,
Really liked the description provided by you, i live at siliguri and our area is surrounded by hilly regions of darjeeling and sikkim, by hills i dont mean just normal hills, its steep, sharp bends, and narrow roads, i want to buy a automatic model, but am confused between creata CVT and Dct model, i.e turbo and naturally aspirated engines, can u pls suggest me a which one should i go for? I mean i want a vehicle which will be normally be crusing at normal indian road conditions mostly ( very high traffic) but for weekend rides i want to go to hill stations which are just 50 kms away from our place never drove a automatic vehicle so very confused will the the automatic vehicles climb these hills?
Get 1.5 CVT if long life is desired.❤️
Very good explain thx bro
Thanks for the information.
Could you help me with this: I booked ecosport AT which is 1.5L 3 cylinder petrol engine but I got to know that the new facelifted will come with a 1.2L turbo charged petrol engine....what would you recommend? should I wait for this 1.2L turbo petrol or continue with 1.5L NA engine. I wish to keep it for more than 5years.
1.5L Naturally Aspirated Petrol Engine will be more practical for 5 years ownership.
Thankyou man you help me to clear my doubt ..now i am more clear about my choice
Very good explanation 👍
Wow you made it so clear... Thank you...
Fantastic. Impressed. Thanks. Subscribed.
Awesome, thank you!
Nice and decent!! How about engine oil selection ,grades as per location , synthetic vs semi !!
Good explanation brother 🎖️👍👌
Very well explained.
Hii. Firstly I booked Nexon xza optional petrol variant but now cancel it due to amt transmission Is brezza 22 automatic is worth to buy?.
In Nexon I was getting turbo engine but in brezza 1.5 NA engine is available.
So in engine performance, power, long term use and built quality is brezza automatic worth to buy??
Plz suggest.
Avoid all, just try Nissan Kicks once.
Very informative video....
Excellent explanation
VERY GOOD INFORMATION FROM NICK...
Very informative .. but I came across this after booking fronx 1.0L turbo. My yearly driving does not exceed 8000kms, and I like to cruise within speed limits, mostly on highway/expressway .. reason for buying this was cuz of this 15yrs ban on petrol cars so had to buy a new one. I did not go for NA engine as fronx does not have much features in delta+ variant so I was left with turbo option. My main query is, this engine is good for long drive? Earlier I had swift and even on it's 14th year, I could drive it non stop for 438kms, thats when I reached home lol. So this 1.0L turbo can do the same without much wear and tear if driven sanely? Thanks in advance
Watch this: czcams.com/video/ZfrB8-ZjvWg/video.htmlsi=pvwh5UCVC49GLjdr
Wow this is the most needed video on internet today for creta & seltos 😇
Super explain👍🌠
Beautifully analysed & explained 👍
Happy to know this 😘 keep it up bro 🌹
Great review. Happy that I have booked the Creta 2020 sx o ivt.... will wait for your test drive review of Creta ivt
Congratulations. Good choice
Ivt vs dct go and study
Hi Nick. Very informative video. Is Verna 2020 1.5 Diesel better for long run compared to newly launched Vento 1.0 Tsi special edition. Somewhere I felt Verna petrol lacks the feeling of a good drive when I drove it. Is it that BS VI Diesel engines are also costly to maintain? Please suggest in my purchase of sedan car under 13 L for long run.
For best drive ability, you can surely opt for Vento. If you think you need to keep the car with you for over 6 years, then avoid cars with smaller turbocharged engines.
Maintenance of Diesel cars is always high, and even higher in BS6. Consider Skoda Rapid, that’s better than Vento & Verna.
@@NickZeek Thank you so much for your reply. I am considering to book Skoda Rapid. took a test drive also last week. It was very good. Just I hope it will last longer than 7-8 years as it is 1.0 turbo charged. Vento I felt lack of resposiveness from dealers and that may lead to bad service experience later too. Otherwise it was in my mind too. For me... Safety is utmost priority.
Nick Zeek Finally.. I have booked Yaris G opt manual 2020 after long car search and waiting. Also considering your advice for natural aspirated engine for long run. Yaris! What a beautiful car. And such a pleasant drive. I got 19 average in my test drive of manual. Interiors are so elegant..I loved them more than Verna 2020 or City. Verna 2020 music system seems out of fit on dashboard. Some of the people don’t even know about it. One of my friend saw it first time and said it looks like Civic. And also hassle free maintenance and services. I have personally experienced the professional and quality services of Toyota. If you complain once about anything to top management in India, they even cut salaries, suspend or threaten to cancel the dealership if customers are not listened to. The dealer himself says, our management listens to and believes customers even if customer is wrong. They do deliver quality and give no-nonsense products.
Akx Malik Hey, sorry for the late reply. Yes, Yaris is a good choice. Have you got it?
Nick Zeek hii yes I bought Yaris G opt.. It’s running great.. milage is too good.. 15-16 in city, 19-20 on highways easily.. both AC on
Sir I've booked carens diesel but now really confused between all three engine options ie 1.5na 1.4turbocharged and 1.5diesel, my usage is approx 500kms per month and will keep vehicle for 6 years. Most of the time my car will be in load of 4 passengers and sometimes 6. Pls suggest which engine option is best for me.
1.5 Petrol 🙌🤩
In sub 4m SUV category is there any good option for NA petrol apart from Brezza petrol?
Venue 1.2P (4 cylinders)
Sir please suggest kia carens prestige 1.5 NA petrol MT vs prestige plus 1.4 turbo IMT which I have to buy. My Monthly driving is 600km per month
1.5P
What would you suggest between Creta and Harrier. Annual running around 12k. Usage would be mostly city driving with few highway trips to hills.
Harrier! Always.
In City, it will give great road presence. In highway, it will give sheer driving pleasure. In hills, it will deliver hreat torque to climb with hill assist.
Creta is good only if you worry about congested drive & parking.
Hi nick I want to ask u one thing I have book Kia carrens 1.5 petrol engine plz tell me if all 7 seats are occupied according to the engine car dab ke to nahi chalega plz reply
Well, I am sorry but I haven’t reviewed Carens yet, and I’am also not recommending Kia/Hyundai cars for buyers at this time.
All the best to you!
Explained in very easy way.. no diplomacy to the point and crisp..👌👌
Thanks, stay tuned & keep supporting. More such videos coming up: czcams.com/play/PLi6kFZ6aslP5SG7vYeenWfn_jSseBPdsi.html
Man that forced induction has its own sexy sound.. And I love it. Like a jet taking off ...
Please advise on the long term reliability of Tata Nexon 3 cyl turbocharged petrol engine? Want to use atleast 8 years. Currently using VW Vento petrol 4 cyl for last 8 years without any issues.
If you want a mini suv vehicle for 8 years, buy one with a naturally aspirated engine. Hyundai Venue 1.2P is the only choice, or take 1.5P creta if budget allows.
Nexon is superb choice and can beat all others in every aspect, but it can be reliable for 8 years only if you are a decent driver.
I booked Kia Carens 1.5l prestige petrol engine version as that was under our affordability and was feeling bad until I came across this video, thanks mate 👍
What is the mileage you get in city? Any demerits of this car?
Plz advise the best 1500 CC NA & best 1200 CC NA petrol engine and divide into different segments
Venue 1.2P & Creta 1.5P.
really nice bro
Amazing 👍
Good topic!
Very nice video.... We were planning to buy Kia Carens
@Nick Zeek sir, is normally aspirated 1.5diesel engine available in kia sonet?
No, Seltos 1.5L Diesel is turbocharged.
@@NickZeek sir not seltos , in sonet i am asking. is it available
Very nice representation
Well done 👍
Very Good Video......
Bhai should I go for seltos gtx plus turbocharged petrol manual engine or Kia seltos gtx plus automatic diesel. my requirements are for long term usage for more than 13 years. plz plz plz plz reply 😭
If GTX+ is really really needed, take 1.4 Turbo rather than 1.5 Diesel. Else, follow my advice of 1.5 P HTX & upgrade with accessories. If Diesel is still a choice, Harrier is the best vehicle for 14 years usage.
Nice video
Well explained
I want to go for VW polo TSI, its turbo feels much refined and properly tuned as compared to others, what do you think?
Totally agree, Polo GT drives really well. Here are things you will need to take care of, if you buy a Polo Turbo: czcams.com/video/ZfrB8-ZjvWg/video.html
@@NickZeek Thanks great info brother, Sadly Polo discontinued DCT new one is a torque converter. Now MT seems better for enthusiasts.
Arry wwahh... Bhot acchy sir.. Bhot informative hai..
Waise mujhy technically kafi knowledge hai, but mujhy ye information maloom nai thi... Bass aap aise he technically videos banaty rho...
My conclusion.......
I will suerly go for turbocharged engines, coz i drive descentely... 🚗
"Turbo kick is the best kick"
Shukriya.. ☺
Glad to hear. Please also share this video with others.
Cheers!
very good video
Ab jaa ke mila kaam ka video. Thank you
😇👍🏻
Can u please do a review of 1.5 P manual...in city and highway...there are not too many detailed videos around. And thank you for the invaluable info.
Thanks 😊
Sure, I’ll try for a detailed video.
Thank you
Hello ,
Is there any issue in Innova crysta petrol?
I wanted to buy a innova crysta after lockdown and wanted to go for the petrol variant as i dont like diesel cars and mileage is not an issue for me
Kindly suggest which will be a better option for me?
Good choice. Innova Crysta is a brilliant vehicle in all aspects. Such a nice family MUV.
Petrol Vs Diesel:
While you may hate Diesel’s NVH levels, high cost of purchase & maintenance, it’s more torqy than the Petrol Engine, which means carrying more passengers and luggage in Diesel Variant is better than Petrol variant for Engine’s long life.
Petrol variant is good if you mostly drive in city and will less often go on long trips. High speeding in Petrol variant will be fun (drive safe), also the low NVH levels will give you driving pleasure.
I suggest you go for Petrol variant taking into account the above factors.
@@NickZeek Thanks for your valuable advice🤝🤝
Pleasure! Subscribe and stay tuned for more videos.
This is exactly what I needed to know last week, while deciding the new Creta's variant. I booked the 1.4 Turbo, now will switch to 1.5 petrol variant.
What is the mileage of petrol variant in city ?
@@ajitkumarsahoo898 15
Don’t buy naturally aspirated. I have creta sx petrol naturally aspirated .. engine is useless power delivery is like 1000cc car .. overtaking is like nightmare sometimes. My 2 year old bolero is more exiting to drive than new creta 😔
then what is the purpose of turbo engine if there is no fuel efficiency and no extra power generation. pl explain
Watch this also czcams.com/video/ZfrB8-ZjvWg/video.html
Perfect! You saved my 2 lacs, I was about to buy turbo creta. Keep up the good work.
Thanks 😊 please remember to send me delivery pics & videos. Phone# is in the description.
Make new video for bs6 for comparing both
Do you think Seltos GTX plus 1.4L TURBO manual a good pick bro? I'm confused
Yes, it will add fun to your life, just make sure you are more of a fun loving drive enthusiast & less of a practicality admirer. ✌️✨
@@NickZeek Practical as in, isn't this car for Family though?
My main priority is Family Comfort
Good technical details.What will be mileage for 1.5 litre petrol HTX seltos in city? would it be efficient enough?
Yes, mileage will be good in Seltos 1.5 Petrol manual HTX variant, and it will remain good for long term.
16kmpl +
@@NickZeek thanks
Hi sir. Can u suggest me which version I have to choose. Creta turbo petrol or 1.5 petrol ?. Note that I will keep my car with me over 7 years.thank you.
1.5 Petrol 💯
@@NickZeek thank you
Sir, I've booked Kia Carens prestige model 1.5 L naturally aspirated Engine in April, will get the delivery probably in October,
I had ertiga vdi from the last 10 years which I recently sold out and I drove it around 1 lac km only but 25% was in hills with my parents, wife and 3 kids....
I just wanted to ask you, WILL I GET THE BETTER ENGINE STRENGTH/PERFORMANCE FROM ERTIGA vdi or not, specially in HILLS with my FAMILY.
Please reply with your convenience.
Since it’s a naturally aspirated 4 cylinder engine, it can be relied upon. Always ensure to drive on aggresive rpms around the hills (means low gears), cuz it’s just a 1500 cc & it’s a BS6.
@@NickZeek FYI, I drove ertiga vxi 2014 model 2-3 times in hills as well with my family, but I didn't get any pick up related problem with it .
But I couldn't be satisfied with my own vdi diesel ertiga....
My question is.....will I get the better pickup etc on hills with my family from ertiga vdi and vxi than Carens ....please share your experience....I'd be thankful
I haven’t driven Carens 1.5L in hills (neither planning to), but I know the 1.5L engine of Kia-Hyundai. I know the drive dynamics & ECU of 1.5L Carens (driven in city open roads), hence I can say it will work well. HOWEVER, what seems good to me, may not be exciting or satisfactory to you… hence, don’t rely on my observations & opinion alone, take a test drive around inclined plains yourself and have some family members and friends along.
@@NickZeek
Thanks a lot and God bless you from all the way
Pleasure 😇🙌
I have booked Kia Carens 1.5 petrol
And i was confused about it’s performance.
So please suggest is this engine is sufficient for kia carens. As this engine option car is not available for test drive.
Moreover, I have not found any video on CZcams which can clear my thoughts, that how this engine will perform. Planning for 10 years with this engine.
Please suggest. 😊🙏
Avoid engines smaller than 2000cc that have turbocharger.
@@NickZeek so my decision is correct?
This 1.5 Kia’s natural aspirated is sufficient for this size car?
Excellent content Nick, Just few queries
1. Is 1.5L P engine underpowered or ok for new creta considering its kerb weight. Even earlier creta had 1.6L P.
2. While travelling uphill with five passengers, luggages and Ac on, which will deliver more power 1.4T or 1.5P or 1.5D
3. Pls suggest which engine of Creta or Seltos will give adequate power as well as comparatively lower maintenance & long life, 1.5D or 1.5P or 1.4T
1) 1.6P was the best Creta Engine and I own Creta SX+ 1.6 (very satisfied). New 1.5P Creta is yet to be tested by me. Allow me some time to test it. Remind me again after the lockdown revokes.
2) 1.5D, because it has more torque.
3) depends on the purpose of drive, if daily driving is for long distance and highways, then 1.5D, if daily driving is frequent in city in then 1.5P, if daily driving is not frequent and you are a decent driver with soft run, 1.4P.
For some reason, if you choose 1.5P, get Creta cuz that offers 1.5P in top end variant whereas Seltos’s 1.5 top end HTX, beyond that variant, it’s only Diesel and 1.4 Turbo.
Test my above opinion yourself in the Seltos & Creta, then decide.
Also please share this video.
@@NickZeek Thank you so much for your valuable suggestions. I will definitely share this video with my friends.
I am not that descent driver and would not be able take necessary precautions as required to maintain 1.4T engine.
I prefer 1.5L P of Creta but just have doubt regarding adequate power. Can you share your experience if any about 1.5L P of Seltos which also shares the same engine.
Sir urban crusier kaise car hai, aur uska engine please sir reply
It has a naturally aspirated Petrol inline 4 engine. Good to buy if long term usage is preferred.
Hii sir
Does jeep compass have naturally aspirated engine?
No
One guy who talked technical and not features. Thank you.
🙏😇
Please suggest has creta 1.5 ivt engine create lack of pull with five adult passengers
Editing video of Creta 1.5 Automatic. Wait for next few days.
@@NickZeek thanks a lot sir.....I am waiting u as ye suggestion is valuable for me.....I have to book my creta in October..but confused on above mentioned topic
Sir really confused between verna diesel S plus variant and SX petrol variant.
My run is hardly 1000 km per month and will keep the car for more than 10 years.
And one of the main priority is the reliability of the engine for long term.
Plz reply sir plz.
1.5 Petrol 🥇
Arey waah, kya mast details batai. Mujhe nahin chahiye turbo, chhote engine wala.
Tata Nexon Xm petrol or creta ex petrol m bahut confused hun konsi lun
Please suggest me
Badi gaadi chahiye to Creta, chhoti gaadi mein kaam chal sakta hai to Nexon. Dono gaadiyaan zabardast hain drive quality ke mamle mein. Nexon ka maintenance cost kam rahega.
Thanks for your valuable suggestion
Just want to understand than why in this case all premium brands use Turbo charged engines e.g Mercedes, BMW & Skoda etc .
Even Skoda Kushaq is announced with both engines turbo charged .
Do these companies don't under this theory & if yes than why are they launching only turbo charged . Kindly explain
For that, you’ll have to understand the other video as well: czcams.com/video/ZfrB8-ZjvWg/video.html
My drive Mostly on Highway but monthly running not more than 500 km
Is 1.5 p is good option
Yes 1.5P is Best for you.
Very nice video.. bought 1.5 litre manual top model because I like power in my hand so I did not buy IVT....
Watch this: czcams.com/video/Y_tydqZ87AQ/video.html
Thank you watched this video but mechanism of both engines are different and watched so many videos before buying this variant. Overall ivt will give you mild or minimum rubber band effect according to all of them....dct is best for performance.... and between these two is manual......I saw for petrol variants only....and got this conclusion.....
Very informative video and this helps choose wisely. Could you pls help me pick b/w 1.4 Turbo Petrol and 1.5 L NA Petrol engine in Kia Carens. Our priorities: long term use at least 10 - 15 Years (If no scrap rules are applied to petrol cars), we prefer reliability over performance and mileage, shouldn't cost a bomb during service, running around 100 Kms a month or even less and mainly highways. Please help me with a speedy response as the waiting is only going to increase if delayed. Thanks!
Sorry, but I haven’t reviewed Kia Carens yet and I have chosen not to support / review any Korean car from now.
However, as it’s my responsibility to answer your question, I’ll suggest you to pick a Naturally Aspirated Engine for long term usage.
@@NickZeek Thank you and I’ve changed variant ( 1.4 G Turbo to 1.5 G NA) this morning.
Good choice! Naturally Aspirated engine can be reliable for long term.
@@NickZeek but the waiting is sky high, 48 weeks 😥
@@jagdeep19yadav 48 months or 48 weeks??? 48 months is 4 years😅😅
My monthly running is less than 500km
Is 1.5P good option?
Yes, 1.5P is the best one for you.
How about seltos 1.5 diesel for long term use??
1.5D is my personal favourite, it’s surprisingly smooth & I love it. Buy it if your monthly run is minimum 1500kms.
I want to purchase a car which will last for 15 years. Budget is 12 lacs. Thinking over seltos hte 1.5 petrol. Will it be a good choice. Plz suggest...
Go for Creta 1.5P EX, you’ll get some extra features.
Bolero
Please Nick Zeek activate english subtitle ,please i want to listen to what you say , but i dont understand indian language :(.
Hey, glad to read. Ok, let me add subtitles soon. Meanwhile, you can watch this English video: czcams.com/video/m2qExaEwn0g/video.html
My usage - both city + highway ,weekend trips ,no office going daily usage ,needed good mileage ,comfort , reliability
Montly run about 200kms
Sometimes 600 kms
Which will you suggest ?
Creta 1.5p or venue/Nexon 1.5 diesel
Nexon 1.2 Petrol will be the best choice.
czcams.com/video/02dRoDMLhWc/video.html
@@NickZeek thank you Nick zeek
Information is nice but turbo engines doesnt give as much trouble in driving as you are saying, owners get used to torque curve and then it feels much much better to feel that torque surge everytime, around 100Nm more torque is a huge deal!
Yes, I agree, and this video doesn’t apply to all, yet some. 😇
Nice. No nonsense video. Sad to see so less views...
Thanks 😊
Please share everywhere in your network so that the information can be spread well.
@@NickZeek sure. Already shared over WA 😊
What engine type is S CROSS PETROL 1.5 L ??
Naturally aspirated :
www.autocarindia.com/car-news/maruti-suzuki-targets-new-buyer-set-with-petrol-s-cross-418222
Apni fzs bike ka colur btaiye ???
Black
very good topic, this video should have come 6 months ago