THE TRUTH ABOUT CHILD WELFARE IN NORWAY ACCORDING TO THE MEDIA IN NORWAY | Mrs.Chatterjee Vs. Norway
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 02. 2023
- Links to the article: www.dagsavisen.no/nyheter/202...
Links 2: www.dagsavisen.no/nyheter/202...
Join the membership plan and connect with us for any guidance related to Norway.
namastefromnorway.com
Like, Comment & Share with your friends and family.
Thank you for watching my videos.
Let's be friends on Facebook
namastefromn...
Connect with me on LinkedIn
/ arvind-keprate-10a61244
Let's be friends on Twitter
/ fromnamaste
Let's be friends on Instagram
/ namastefromnorway
#mrschatterjeevsnorway #ChildWelfareNorway #norway
Our thoughts on Mrs.Chatterjee Vs. Norway after watching the movie czcams.com/video/HnsR0eVIQas/video.html
norway ki govt. ne pichle 10 saal m ko i jaanch nhi krwayi wlfare department ki, kahi sach toh nhi waha ke executive child kidnapping and corrouption m h ya nhi?
Dude....what do u think about Father's behavior...u didn't felt this till now cause u r good to ur child. But for father anger and domestic violence why mother should suffer.
I agreed bro medical system kuch slow hai also bohat struggle krna prta yaha but about childwelfare service sb country main asy he work krte hai.jab hm apna cntry chur k aty hain tu hm bht kch dosry cntry ka follow krna prta hai.mere families pchly 50 salon sy yahan hai asa kbe kch nh suna unka kehna asa ha r na he asa kch dykha hai .han if kch galat ho rha gar main koe neighbour ya skole ya barnhage main kch asa pata chly tu action lea jata hai.but not in Norge also i habe heared that about uk .wha b agr asa kch hu tu woh usk about step lyty hain
I personally feel truth abe be kahe chuppa hwa ha asal main kya hwa woh abe b samny nh aya
How you know the truth? Are in department? Official statements and paper are not only truth. If you have power, your mind will be the same.
I am not saying i know truth but i am saying that it is not often in Norge. perhaps her husband has violated her and they noticed them.
The women who suffered herself claimed movie is 100 % true and she has suffered and tortured way more than what is shown in the movie.
She claims.
Indians are dramatic 😂
@@ashvinveeraraghavan8450 she is a mother. I’ll believe a mother’s story about her own kids vs an organization that makes money by breaking families apart. Follow the money, then you’ll understand who cares what.
I saw few comments regarding the mother , saying she was violent, crazy, psychopath. No matter however she was atleast she fought for her kids unlike her ex husband ,who preferred to stay in Norway than to be with kids.
She was repeatedly evaluated by top psychiatrists in India and found to have no mental health issues.
Compared to india ..iwould stay in norway too
@@vincentnijjar4221 💀
@@vincentnijjar4221 Then get lost to Norway. Who is forcing you to stay in lndia.
@@vincentnijjar4221 +1 😸
I would never set my foot in Norway even for a visit. I live in Canada and it’s a free country ❤ and I’m at peace that my daughter will never be kidnapped from me.
Beware of pro- LGBTQ community, that forcefully convert their genders without even parents consent.
Canada is just as bad for this sort of thing .
Well if you don't abuse the child, all parents are fine
I'm live in Austria, and it does happen to many Indian families in Europe.
What could be the reason?
@@drakedrones most of the time its cultural difference
@@n.s8137 So it’s not about abuse?
May l know as to why do you prefer to live in a third rated country with such barbaric and draconian laws which has produced a monster like Hitler. Is it a little bit of money you earn extra over there.
@@parpettersson1905 No, if that was the case then Indian Americans wouldn't have risen to the top of the socioeconomic ladder. If that was the case, virtually all Jewish families in the United States would see skyrocketing rates of their children being handed over to the CPS.
So sorry , this happens in Norway every day all year round. Thanks for the movie Mrs chatterjee
It really hurts when Indian immigrants continue to defend Norways criminal Social services.
This was not an isolated incident to an Indian Family
1) After this case, they jailed parents of a young boy from Hyderabad. The father worked with TCS.
2) They took away two children in 2018 from Indian parents until our Embassy and Foreign Ministry intervened.
3) A mother already dealing with an autistic child, Barnevernet doesn't offer counselling. They just kidnap children. One of the psychiatrist who used to go on these supervised visits is now a convicted child offender. Are you aware of these facts?
4) In every custody battle, every father blames mother. The truth is he chose to stay back in a country which kidnapped his children. But, the mother came back and raised her children, one of whom is autistic. IMAGINE !
5) They kidnapped a Czech families four children, Czech President tried to intervene but Norway didn't release the kids. Even he called them kidnappers.
OMG. Norway now known as kidnaper
@@claymate5826 Not just Norway. Sweden and Denmark too. They are the same bastard feathers.
For #1 that was because the parents beat their child with a belt. This level of intellectual dishonesty is unbelievable.
@@elvinmarvel7643Yes they take child abuse seriously. Ehat horrible places.
@@ashvinveeraraghavan8450 - Read this lqtest news - NRI mother dies after Australian authorities take away her children in foster care. It is a major issue abroad but people like you are so crazy about foreign countries you dont know the whole story either
There are many documentaries by Australian as well as American parents who have had unfortunate experiences with the Child Protection services of Norway
This Child Protection service is terrorist organization that sells children to warlords in Somalia Angola and other militant groups they also sell them to prostitution as well as drug dealers. This is well known fact as this is organization that should be proclaimed terrorist organization
While you are asking your audience to remember that the father said that his wife was mentally unstable you too need to mention the following
1. The father suddenly took this stance 3 days before the verdict in the Norwegian court when he was planning to file for divorce. He was miraculously silent about his wife's alleged mental health issues till then
2. If she did have mental health issues why did he not treat it ?
3. The news articles of the time had quoted several senior indian government officers and ministers calling out the husband for converting the custody issue to a marital one .
3. The wife has been repeatedly assessed by top psychiatrists in government hospital in India and found to have no mental health issues as alleged by the husband and the Norwegian authorities. So it is fair to say that it is about cultural differences for Norwegian authorities and a very selfish sinister stance by the husband to use this unfortunate situation for his divorce case.
4. This wonderful father has not visited his kids even once for the past 10 years.
If these people can they will also blame Yoshoda to be a villian mother of Krishna to be strict with naughty Krishna.
I agree norway and most of europe is shit place for indians.
@@rucha3385 the op is wrong, during court proceedings it was found that the wife was abusive towards the husband and used to beat her child. I know to indian it may found normal but it's extremely wrong in developed civilised countries.
The father of the children was more concerned with money and lifestyle than his wife and children. Like many old fashioned Indian husbands he allowed his mother to constantly bully his wife.
You should refer to -
1) BBC program on Child Welfare service of Norway
2) They especially target unpolished immigrants, because they are easy to prey upon. They took a child away from a chinese mother because her mother came to look after the young child. So, they assumed she is not fit to raise the child.
3) Please look up at videos of mothers whose children are being kidnapped by Emergency Care Department directly from school.
4) They took away a child from a mother because he was one pound underweight
5) They never let the parents find out whereabouts of their grown up children, so, permanent seperation
Norway Child Protection Services break families for profit
But I thought BBC holds no credibility after the Modi documentary! 😂
Chal bhakt log hai idhar bhi..jaake india ka child wellbeing index rating dekh lo…zara kamathipura sonagachi …ko dekho…child labour…ka level Satyarthi aapka nobel prize winner hai usko pucho... Give us a break …aap amritkaal main dankapati ki jaijaikar karo…
@@ajaxjaiswal3442
Because your mentality of judging credibility is only what they think of modi.
What nonsense.
BBC is the third class news of India supporting terrorism and telling terrorist of 26/11 as people with guns
This European counties don't want our Indian children to follow our indian culture or religion.
@God Bless you that's so true.
That couldn't be further from th he truth. In Norway they DO expect people to follow their culture in some aspects.
Other aspects people should leave their culture in their own home countries. In ex. it is/was normal in India to give kids slap for misbehaving, it's no tolerance policy here, so you can't follow that aspect of your culture. In some countries it's normal to perform female genital mutilation. Google it, it's in their culture, but it will have your kids taken away, if you do it in Norway and say it is our culture. In some culture it's normal to marry upto four wives. That part of culture and religion, you just can't do in Norway, and say it's our culture. It's about respecting the law in the country your are in.
I can give one example about respect for the country you reside in. Swastika had great meaning for us, symbol means a lot to us, including me. We have Swastika all over the place, on our home. It's personal matter.
But...Swastika was for less than 100 yrs ago, used by Hitler. Lot of cruelty happened under the second world war. Swastika was the symbol Hitler used. Some of the people living then are still alive. Europe hasn't gotten over the second world war yet. Maybe in another hundred years or something, world will see.
Swastika is our symbol, our culture, give us happiness. Still you will not see, in general, indian Hindus living here, using it in public. Not as a tattoo, not in the chain around the neck or print on the clothes. You will never see it outside our temples, inside yes, but not outside. In this case it's not about the law, it's about respect for their sentiments. Swastika is our culture and part of our religion, but we don't portray it in public. Same goes for the things that are against the law in Norway. You can't blame everything on culture and cultural differences.
You have nothing to fear, if you just follow the law.
Just saying.
@God Bless you To be honest if you want to give your kid the best opportunities, Scandinavian countries are best. You don't need to believe me. I don't even know why people move to US, especially in these times.
Yes. We do pay a lot in tax. If there is one thing most Norwegians incl immigrants, doesn't complain about, is paying income tax. Because we get that back in form of welfare for everyone. Free education, mostly free health care. If I get sick, I don't need to worry about how I am going to afford the treatment. I don't need to worry about my kid not getting higher education, because our financial situation. Large donations and tuitions isn't needed for them to become something. If it was in India, even your maids son could become doctor without paying anything.
Just don't do anything that is illegal or prohibited. You have nothing to fear about.
Yes. That I do agree on. People in general are loving and nice, but getting close to someone or getting to know others is extremely difficult. Best way is through channels like sportsclub parents, your work colleagues, maybe your neighbors through your own kids playing. Through some party you attend, where you start an interesting conversation about something.
Direct connection can be difficult, but once you get to know them, through those channels, they are very kind and friendly.
My own friends, like real best friends, are all Norwegians and we have been friends for more than 30+ yrs, since our school days.
@God Bless you you should have, if you had the chance. I am not being biased for Norway. I am just saying, because that's true.
Just don't do anything illegal, and bring up your kids in safe and loving environment. Protection of the child is a really big thing.
its very easy to support or blame the countries system or Parents BUT THE FAMILY WHO WENT THROUGH SUCH A UNFORTUNATE EVENT CAN KNOW THE PAIN.
Yes♥️🇮🇳
czcams.com/video/is0Hq1OfHaE/video.html
There cannot be any justification for separating kids from their parents.. I absolutely agreed with your opinion that one shall left the country if not taking care of the children as per rules.. I am from Pakistan.. and i am under high stress since i watched this movie on Netflix
Well many parents are abusive to their children for those children this is good... But for parents who are not this is very bad.
Leave when you are able. Once something happens you won’t be able to reverse it. There are many other countries to live with kids with peace of mind. 🙏🏼
There can be justification for separation in some cases, eg if kids are sexually abused by the parents, or extremely violent and dangerous household.
The norwegian children protective services are rotten through their core. My sister was raped by a man, which we later found out worked for the children protective services. This all needs to turn around for the better. Hopefully the new movie will open eyes
This Child Protection service is terrorist organization that sells children to warlords in Somalia Angola and other militant groups they also sell them to prostitution as well as drug dealers. This is well known fact as this is organization that should be proclaimed terrorist organization
99 percent of Norwegians are all rotten, racist, cold hearted, mean, jealous, mentally unstable people. They are same race as their cousin Adolf H. He occupied them and his Nazis soldiers had good fun sleeping with Norwegian women during second world war there while the Norwegian men acted like hijras. The Nazis produced their children who are racists of today there. White devils.
Ofcourse nobody will accept their mistakes whether its child welfare or father.
It seems some people are been paid to spread good word about Norway, as if it heaven on earth.
Norwegians can't handle being criticized. And yes, they try everything they can to put themselves into a good light. Norwegian authorities lie about all this all the time.
The theory how barnevernet should work is extremely much different from the reality.
Norway has been sentenced many times for disrespecting the human rights of families and children, many more times as any other western European country.
Norwegians can't stand being criticised? Sounds very similar to Indians 🤪
Yes Specially European countries like Germany
“Time to put our tinfoil hats on”
Your comment gets German Shepherd attention...🐐🐕💩
I can understand u have been living in norway and ur experience has been good..And also many other ppl who have been living there might not have faced these issues..However,it has happened with someone and we cannot just brush it off saying that the parenting was bad and so on..The reasons given in the real case are also the same..feeding with hands,having kids sleep with parents,teeka nd also they tried to prove that the mother was mentally unstable..Its a clear case of racism,white elitism and not respecting cultural differences of another country..Europe has been rampant with racism even before and many examples can be found in media..On the other hand,this case the lawyers did everything to attack the mother..If u take someone’s children away in a foreign land,they will go insane and react,and then obviously it can be proved they r mentally unstable..So,its a grave injustice that has happened and cannot be ignored..The father doesn’t care about the kids anyway..He is still living in norway..And the mother fought tooth nd nail even after reaching india and finally has got the custody of the kids..There is nothing wrong in presenting the views from the mother’s side coz the mother is the victim here..Can u imagine if ur kids are taken away suddenly for no reason. and then u spent half of ur life doing rounds of court proceedings,lawyers and so on just to get ur own kids back..If anything,Norway government actually needs to apologise and compensate the mother for the trauma and the harassment that she has gone through..
The father hasn't visited the kids even once in the last 10 years. The chap was using this unfortunate case to get himself a divorce.
BTW the lady was repeatedly assessed by top psychiatrists in India and found to not have any mental health issues.
In India you can buy docs certificates by dime a dozen…bhaktgiri chodo…India ka child welbeing may record dekh lo…goohle hai naa …use karo
Ye movie dekne ke baad Russia ko norway ka bhi invaion karna chaye
Yess
What one side story? Giving lecture is easy but the pain only can be understand the mother who gone all through this. I salute that man, the father of children, still living in that country who have no common sense. Second thing a mother can't be wrong for her children. It's a common sense. It is totally inhuman behaviour. They called the mother that she is not mentally stable, actually the whole country of norway is mentally sick. How could someone make such type of law.
A mother can't be wrong? Such an ignorant statement ! We have parents in India who force their kids to break up with their partners because they can't accept an intercaste marriage. Most indian parents beat their kids up whenever kid throws a small tantrum. This just shows how most Indian parents lack patience in dealing with kids. I agree what happened to Sagarika is sad but we must understand that there are countless people who don't deseve to be parents and such kids better are taken away (particularly when parents are abusive or immature teenagers).
@@baghyasrib3476 So basically you want to say that parents can wrong to children but other will not? How could you justify the act to separate a breastfeeding child from the mother? Why you think Norway Government and child welfare authority could think better than a mother who suffered 9 months for children? Second thing after becoming young the things are different. I was not talking about that. This foolish law and thinking like this has completely ruined sagarika's life. who will compensate this?
@@baghyasrib3476 yeah parents can be wrong but managing two kids alone that too with violent husband is not easy ok. Ur talking about teenagers parents not about this case . Don’t deviate and when the kids are young they need their mothers always.
I have been living in the United States since 27 + years. Not too long ago, in the United States Indian parenting was looked from different lenses and perspectives. As time passed they saw the value in Indian parenting style and now Indian Americans come under one of the most successful community in the United States. USA has evolved to recognize family, cultural values and bonding with kids is needed for the country to become stronger. Recent survey shows 50% American kids over 18yr stay home ( first time ever in recent history of America) and divorce rate has gone significantly down in recent years. Percentage increases in Seniors living with children rather in assisted living.
Norvey would change it's views on how to raise children in coming few years because indian culture teaches to co- exist with other cultures. When 2nd generation kids like Ava, Nishtha and others shine in Norvey/ world making a difference in a Norwegian society. No one wins a gold medel in Olympics because they have best etiquette. It's just a matter of time that Norway will change and develop the abilities to see beyond their view.
I would like to add one point here. Norway should make mandatory cultural training courses to complete before any immigrants step into Norway. Then from day one evey immigrant wether a student or family person knows what's do's and don'ts..
@@sumaadiga9909 In a way, what you said is called normalization. I heard stories from other European countries about Indians who had hard time raising their kids. Families who raised their kids with great ethical values, making sure they ‘fit in’ well with those societies. They had to finally return back to India. But, many Indians don’t dare to speak about these problems. They comprise their dignity and self-respect over material gains. I won’t judge their decision as good or bad, but that is exactly what the truth is. Glad that people are making movies on such topics, to raise awareness.
@mandatory lol is it common sense u go to different country the culture is different and values?
@@vincentnijjar4221 No doubt only a Christian can be such a low life like you. Do you realize that Muslim and Hindu childern are taken away from their culture and religion into white Christian foster homes to be fed pork/ beef and other non halal food. Good way to convert people. All Christian children should be snatched from Christians in lndia and handed over to Muslim families.
Most teenagers live home cause of increased rental prices 😂 it’s too costly to live on your own now
You are so imaginative to understand the whole story by just seeing the trailer only. You are not only brilliant but also GREAT.i 😊
I have made up my mind never to step my food in Norway especially with my kids. They mean the world to me and will never in my wildest dreams even take a flight that stops over in Norway
Some data isn't correct EAM was SM Krishna as it was under UPA govt in 2011.It was a case of post partum depression & lack of spousal support in child bearing.1st child being autistic complicated the matter as the child didn't get enough time from parents. Also Norway child care facility is involved in litigation with EU human rights for children up bringing. It has lost 43 of 68 cases on child upbringing in EU human rights commission. I am not scared of Norway but I feel they have an attitude of 1 upmanship when it comes to lifestyle choices.
So sorry for , this happens in Norway every day all year Thanks for the movie Mrs chatterjee
BS
Hats off to the mother who faught for 3 yrs to get back her own children. She is really very courageous whose constant fi
ght involved the India Government to come in to the picture. She deserves respect and motivation to do very well in her future. Salute to her
Very first question I have on Norwegian child welfare is that if they have such stringent law in place then why there is high depression and suicide rate in their country. Kids should should be healthy mentally, right? Surely is not good enough to help child grow with healthy mind., and hence as adult they struggle to survive with stress n go into depression.
...and do you actually KNOW that there is higher depression and suicide rate in Norway, compared to other countries? facts, please! PS: according to World Health Organization, 1 in 5- yes, ONE IN FIVE, will develop some sort of psychological problem throughout their life which would require treatment by a professional. So- this is not a Norway problem or an India problem, it is a WORLD problem.
Norway has no higher suicide rate than any other western European country.
@@sandsbola This seems to be a popular myth that some (luckily not that many) people love to uphold. Cold climate-cold people, warm climate-warm people. As if it was that easy. I am glad there are rational thinkers in here, like you. Grüsse aus Oslo.
@@bjrnjensen7074 just like the strange myth it's always dark and cold in the North.
Hilsen fra Sverige!
@@sandsbola Haha... that is true-well, except for the summer, of course. When there is daylight 24/7. Fun fact; only 10% of Norway`s populatin (5,47 million) lives in the upper half of the country. Probably a good reason for that.
So many incident still going on..he will not tell about that bcz he is in Norway
can't imagine the pain of that mother . I feel like you are being paid for this video . separated from children for two years can be a devastating experience for a mother
Yes for the kids too
Educating the viewers is a great thing. After watching movie, I watched quite few videos on NDTV channel and it does supports what I saw in the movie. Norway may be good now but has done a catastrophic emotional damage especially to a mother. It's not acceptable. I am in favor as you mention on last part of the video separating kids from mother is not acceptable and ask them to leave the country and raise the kids on your own country. Furthermore, it supports the theory they are running human trafficking by taking away kids. Non-immigrant living in your country does not give rights to you to take away someones kids. You have right to kick them out (That is your right as a #norway country). After watching this movie, I will #boycottnorway products, services and would never visit the country. I will never support the country in anyway or spend a single penny on tourism.
Never!
Exactly.. I will never visit Norway.. such a shame for a country.. Norway 👎👎👎
No matter what taking the kids away without any warning does seems to me as a case of kidnapping. Why not bring the charges against their parents first, give them a chance to defend against those charges especially if their is no proven sign of physical or sexual violence. Let them defend and then take away their children. Because without prior notice taking away children is kidnapping , authority is supposed to give notice even before they take your car but no notice in case of kids. Its shameful and deceitful.
Very well explained!
This doesn't happen with everyone but at the same time, the movie is telling what happened with that mother only... Thats why it says Mrs ChatterjeeVsNorway
it happens to almost every immigrant family. U should know better
@@lishaheinson6654 Lol. Nope. What a ridiculous comment. There are no families in Europe who raise their own children? What nonsense.
I know many family/ friends living in abroad. I have never heard anything like this . We have also lived in USA/ Europe with kid , didn’t face anything like this. Fact is in India many child abuse cases/rape cases get ignored .
@@lishaheinson6654
Wth!!
This is NOT happening with every immigrant families. I am an immigrant, and lived in Norway for 40 yrs, and don't personally know even one family, Norwegian or immigrant, who has had their kids taken away. In 40 yrs of living!!!
Infact i have witnessed, as pediatric nurse, few cases where kids have been taken away. Due to Munchausen by proxy, physical abuse resulting in brain damage and death, injuries to kids body that doesn't fit the reason given. In my line of work.
So please.
I am NOT against this particular mother. I don't know the entire story. Maybe it was indeed just a misunderstanding, between parents and the system. Maybe the mother has told the story accurately. My problem is that there is no way to know the entire truth because it's only mothers side, with maybe a touch of Bollywood masala. I mean there has to be other things.
My own problem with this is that the reason given in this trailer doesn't make sense.
I mean Co-sleeping is NOT prohibited in Norway (it's not recommended due to safety precautions, but it's not prohibited. My own kid ended up in our bed, almost every night, until she was about 7-8 yrs old, despite having her own bed in her own room.
Feeding with hands is NOT prohibited. Unless it's being done forcefully, and not even giving the kid time to swollow, due to risk of choking. Hand feeding is NOT prohibited.
Wth, using tikka in public isn't against the law, I have personally done that multiple times, myself and my kids, and did not loose my kids. Even being on a playground, with multiple others families. There was one instance where a parent told me to check out my kid, since she thought I maybe hadn't seen that. She told me that, I think your kid fell, there is blood on the forehead. I told her that it was a religious tikka made with sindhoor and water. It maybe looked like blood from afar, but isn't. She said oh I see, and that was that. No family on the playground turned us in. Because tikka isn't prohibited.
Edit: yes, EVERY FAMILY risks loosing their kids if abuse is suspected. Immigrant or Norwegian. Doesn't matter.
@@swathi3682 you never heard but this has happened in real. Here they are saying the story of one mother and not saying Norway does that with everyone..
Instead of giving a vague reason like “we found other serious issues too” .. why don’t they specify the exact reasons for taking the kids away? Berneverent has the responsibility to mention clear reasons / incidents than this one line to take any one’s kids . If they really have other reasons why not say / price and make everybody shut up ? I am glad you didn’t have any such bad experience , but that doesn’t mean Berneverent were right in what they did with Mrs Sagarika. To me they seem like kidnappers. Why taking the kids away is the only solution ? Why can’t govt assign help and counseling to parents and get things better even if there is anything wrong . What the f is wrong with this institution ? And do they have any concern about the trauma kids might go through for their entire life to be changed in one single moment ?
Rani is fabulous actress and versatile 🥰🥰🥰
Also a similar case in Sweden when 4 young children are taken away from a family!!!!!
Did they give prior warnings?
This crime is ordered by terror organizations that sell these kids to drug dealers and warlords in Africa to be child soldiers as well as girls sold to prostitution
This is organized mafia
Thank you fr ur information. I realized no one should go to Germany. Nd I will never prefer Germany as an option to live.
Absolutely
Very nice and balanced view of the situation. I have so many friends outside India with children, and it is very important for parents to be sensitive about local child protection laws. What is normal in our country can not be the same in any other country. Thanks for this video!
That's doesn't mean , Norway authority will kidnap a breastfeeding child
Don't prove yourself smart here, without knowing the full story
So just forget your own culture to please their rules and regulations. It's alright if they are not ready to diversify their culture...yeah....that's why America is the best for immigrants.
Always informative ❤️.
The worst cultures and rules are here
Childrens are taken away by their mother just because she love them in her own way.....
Disgusting 🤢
Shame on Norway ...
What perks were you promised by the Norwegian establishment for this post?
One of the most beautiful movie..which melts our heart...mother is always be a mother nothing is more powerful than the word "MOTHER"..
Very informative video 🙌🙏
Hi.
Namaste from India Bhai.
Pls make a separate video on the parenting culture of Norway.
Why did the Norwegian authorities find children sleeping in same bed of parents or children being hand fed by parents as some irresponsible behaviour.
For us it is a bonding activity and they will have some different view on it.
We need to know their view also.
Movie may be showing only a mother's perspective since it is based on a novel written by the mother.
The whole experience would have been very traumatic for the mother, the father and the children especially since suddenly one fine day they are picked up and put in a foster care away from their parents.
If you could give some details on the Norwegian cultural point of view on this then the confusion, anxiety and negative feedback may reduce.
In any view.. abducting children and seperating them from a mother is cruel and insane . Stop supporting rascals just because you choose to stay in that country and lick their feet
Safe to say ki Rani Mukerji ko Norway ka visa ab kabhi nahi milne wala 😜
Bhaad mai jaaye Norway, kon jaaye, waha.. Very small cold country
Shimla se kaam chala lo
Just because someone didn't took your kid doesn't mean the baise doesn't exist . Not only this family many families in Norway have complained about the child service . Norway child service lost 14 cases in European Court of law .
I only speak Ukrainian. I am using google translator. Therefore, please excuse me if the translation is bad! I am from Western Ukraine. I am a nurse and I save lives. I live now in Germany. I need a lawyer to file, with other disabled citizens of Ukraine, a lawsuit against Norway. My husband, a Ukrainian (oil worker, human rights activist) became disabled as a result of his defense of the rights of other people (Norwegian and Russian media for 9 years). My husband fought corruption in the Russian oil giant, which was headed by the founder of the 6th Directorate of the FSB and the ex-Chancellor of Germany. My husband defended the rights of disabled people and Ukrainians in Norway against Russian-speaking citizens of this NATO country. The Norwegians took my disabled husband to Moscow AFTER: anti-war pickets of my husband in the Russian Federation, his defense of the rights of Ukrainians in Norway, the issuance of documents to my husband by the Norwegian Red Cross for his close relatives (Polish servicemen repressed by the Russians), sentencing his defender to prison (in married to a citizen of Finland for 25 years) in Belarus, who reported the crime of the Norwegians against the Ukrainians and was recognized as a Political prisoner. My husband and his lawyer warned the Norwegians about the coming war, but they did not believe him. The husband was kidnapped and the war began. And after the war began, the Norwegians do NOT admit their mistakes! Unlike the Swedes, the Norwegians DO NOT LIKE to admit their mistakes even when the Chechen refugees deported by the Norwegians were killed in the Russian Federation (Norwegian media).
We are wondering why in Norway, BEFORE the war in Ukraine, provided, at the expense of Norwegian taxpayers, asylum to citizens of the Russian Federation who have a second citizenship of Ukraine? For example, the Jehovah's Witnesses in Ukraine were not threatened at all! And the payment of the state fee for renunciation of Ukrainian citizenship, in order to acquire citizenship of the Russian Federation, NEVER led to the loss of Ukrainian citizenship. After the correspondence of the Ukrainian anti-corruption fighters with the Norwegian police about specific religious "refugees" who received asylum in Norway (the "refugees" had 2 citizenships), the deportation of disabled Ukrainians to the Russian Federation followed, BUT they had a family in Ukraine! Collective deportation, strictly prohibited by law, was subjected to those Ukrainians - fighters against corruption, who reported, BEFORE the war, about the facts of granting asylum to Russian citizens in Norway, as religious "refugees". These "refugees" had, among other things, a Ukrainian passport (and there was no war in Ukraine then, and Jehovah's Witnesses in Ukraine were very happy)))
Who will give the contacts of a lawyer, who will be able to recover material compensation from the Norwegians in favor of the Ukrainians (media). The reason: the use by the Norwegians of Ukrainians with disabilities of collective deportation prohibited by the Law, without a trial and an interpreter, with the non-admission to the defense of Ukrainians of their representative, who is recognized as a political prisoner (media). Family members of Ukrainians have not seen each other for more than 3 years. Ukrainians are ready to sign an agreement with a lawyer, according to which the lawyer will receive ANY part of the winnings he wants.
You live in Norway that's why you taking side of Norway. The director of the movie is not stupid and BBC AND many other news channels saying that child kidnapping in Normal in Norway and a profitable Business.
Becarefull with your children's. Who knows one day they will come and take your kids.
This is not worthy of your nationalist cause. Nationalism doesn't mean standing by your people when they're wrong.
@@luipe6708 where you found thay wrong
Han heere jade h na unke baccho me isliye churana chahte h
@@dss8983 Yes. If you give one children to foster home , then you will get lots of money and the foster home will get money from parents who adopted the child. Very huge profitable Business in Norway. They only target foreginer kids because they can't do anything.
@@india-7035 no foster home doesn't get any money from parents adopting the kid. The government pays money to parents fostering the kids from its own budget.
So that welfare person (article you shared) talked everything except the main reason of taking the child away from parents... Wow...
And we can see the credential of his statement when he said that Indian external minister Sushma Swaraj... Does he knows that during that case congress was in power...
And he wants that he didn't get connected by any team from the film.. well why to connect when they hide and avoid questions by saying that it's confidential clause so can't talk about it...if you can't give your side of story then don't cry that you haven't contacted by anyone...
Even in this article,he did not said the main reason of taking the child.
He has wrongly mentioned Sushma swaraj as external foreign minister of dat time but yes being a lady from opposition she put pressure on govt on dis matter..not only dis, she was the only lady in every case against Indian kid Vs norway who took initiative for kid release ..in 2016 such case occur and within 2 months time the kid was with parents..she done a commendable work with holding back to back pressure on Norway counterpart..
After watching the movie I am feeling very depressed yo to know that Norway did not even think that if a couple was not your citizens and children were born in India so how could they claim them as their own. It was okay to give them to adoption if mother was not fighting or they were orphans but it was not the case here. The country did not have the right to claim Indias citizen as their own. I am shocked that while they claimed that they were helping the kids, didn't they realise how a small boy was feeling because they separated him from his mother. A small baby got separated from her mother. Your country should be ashamed of this the trauma you all have caused to the kids by not standing up against your contrie's law. It doesn't matter how your people justify this but it has shown us that I am not going to bring my child or myself to your country never. If we want to live peacefully with our children then we should not go and live in Norway even for just traveling because this country can take your child away even if they are not a citizen of their country.
Hello, love your videos. Maybe this video has the audio panned on the left.
Bhai tu abhi bhi rosy picture hi de Raha hai
"Even if you are stuck on the Mars, Indian Embassy there will help you."- Sushma Swaraj 🇮🇳 ,foreign minister, india 🇮🇳💪🏽
I guess she died?
Rip
In foreign countries they do not public the case from there side. They do not give counter argument on public forum. Indian parents take benefit-twist fact suitable for them and gain sympathy from public. Then make diplomatic pressure to get kids back to abuse them again.
I am an Indian living in UK right now so I know how the system in foreign works. Everyone have the same human right.
You are so educated. Amazing ✨
They may be educated but they have sold their soul to the devil for a little bit of money. Any non educated person have more morality, ethics and soul than these people. So what is the use of such education.
My friend…Norway don’t want to many foreigners, by breaking up family dynamics they can control the foreign population of foreigners. I hope you can see through this nonsense.
As always, your videos are always informative and thanks for sharing the information which i believe is so helpful to get a clear understanding of the situation on the ground, more importantly stops spreading the fear in the society. Kudos to you guys.
That’s why I’m listening to this whole video... to get different perspectives...
Can understand that “Cultural Difference” was not only the cause but it was a part correct. Why?
Now in Germany a same case is going due to which #BoycottGermany got trending.
Secondly this movie is made from the reference of a book by Sagarika Chatterjee “A journey of a mother”
A mothers pain is beyond horizon. So do not justify
wrong
i live in sweden and im born here. this happens to almost every immigrant family in sweden, norway, denmark and germany. This is a dark secret and only we parents living here knows what this is. I am so thankful to Rani Mukherjee to highlighting this to rest of the world
I don't know what kind of anti-social / child-abusive families you know then. Because all the families I know who have children from 3 years up to 15 years which are many, I haven't heard that anywhere - not in Germany, not in Denmark, not in Austria or the likes. Probably just a fake account.
fake account from an India. This account has a playlist of all Hindi songs. Shameful that we Indians have time for this kind of cheating and want to put a curtain over everything bad about our culture.
@@BharatinGermany Hello brown sepoy,you haven't heard... there are 100s of videos and reports on this..and you are saying that you haven't heard... You hate india and indian that's ok( we can see in your videos) ...but what about European human rights statment on this Norway's child welfare....i hope atleast you believe in your so called best countries (European countries) stand
@@BharatinGermany ..or somebody who had-rightfully, because they were not capable of taking care of their kid-and tries to put the child care service in a very, very negative light-because they don`t want to accept that their child was taken, even if they had drug problems etc. Heard about such an incident.
@@bjrnjensen7074 Absolutely Bjoern. I believe the same. No system is perfect, of course. But just randomly hating the entire system which in fact saves thousands of children every year from abuse is ridiculous.
Thanks for sharing this message. It gave me a great uplift considering to move Norway, as after this trailer n reading about Barnevernet I developed some fears and agony and ur video has made me relaxed. Obviously, the film has portrayed the pain n agony the girl has went through being in a foreign country but there must also be some other side of the story.
Glad it was helpful!
See their interview in TimesNow with Arnab 11 years before
They said sleeping with parents, feeding with hands many other cultural differences
Even Indian minister said the same in the interview
So stop putting your own narrative
They even said mother has mental problems
In India they did multiple mental test by various psychiatrists
They said she is perfectly good
Those guy must have taken money from the Norway Authorities to wipe up the movie
That why he is whitewashing many interviews and incidents
Don't fall for views
Nothing other side of story brother. its a luck for those who did not fall in their investigation else they must have eye on every immigrant
@@NamastefromNorway you better don't have any kids otherwise all your hard work to please your master will comeback at you. 😅
@@DevaAsuras They already have a kid . And l really pity the child who just because a fight between the parents can be snatched from their mother and handed over to some random strange new parents. And they call themselves a country. Shame.
FUN FACT: A lot of cases Is ongoing at the ECtHR, and Norway (Barnevernet) lost a quite a few.
This Child Protection service is terrorist organization that sells children to warlords in Somalia Angola and other militant groups they also sell them to prostitution as well as drug dealers. This is well known fact as this is organization that should be proclaimed terrorist organization
Thanks for sharing sach comments abt Norway .each one should alert now
Bahut hi galat hua.baccha churana kahte Hain ise.baccho ke pita abhi bhi waha hain,desh wapas a Jana chiye tha,chahe kam paise mile. Ma to ma hoti hain,Kolkata mein do baccho ke sath rahti hain. Akeli pal Rahi Hain baccho ko . Inke pati itna par likh kr patni ka sath chor diya.kis kam ka education. Norway is mamle mein badnam hain.
Kuch badnam nahi ha ..usa jao...pata chal jayega
USA mein to suna nhi Aisa.
@@ratnasarkar720 ab bhi aisa kafi hai raise karna unhi ke hisab se sona tak padhta hai 7 bad
Apna desh hi accha hain.rukhi sukhi kha lenge PR Aisa desh nhi chahiye.
The children are doung very well in india,so proves she is a good mother.
I can not fathom the lengths some of these comments go to support parents who abuse and neglect their children because of "cultural differences", a child is not the property of the parents. It is a person deserving og rightful treatment and love. If you beat your child in Norway sorry then your children will get taken away to have a better life for themselves
Be careful; it is very difficult to adjust and live in out of India for an Indian.
I was just planning to do my masters in computers but after reading a lot about how Norway Govt will take Foreigners kids away from parents . the Barnevernet takes around 1,500 children away from their parents every year.
I'm not Indian, but German, which is a culture much closer related to the Norwegian than the Indian is.
But even then this created huge problems. What also the movie shows is that the vast majority of the Norwegians doesn't consider other cultures as equal in term of their value. They look down on almost everything that is different from Norwegian standard.
In our case they denied us to raise our children bilingual, which is stupid beyond all imagination.
And it doesn't take more than a misunderstood story of a 6 year old with much fantasy to get you into real trouble. The most people working for barnevernet are not really competent enough for their work, but still have enough power to destroy families and existences for ever.
The legal system is very much biased, at least on the level of the fylkesnemnda, which almost always stands on the side of barnevernet. Which isn't hard to understand as they both work for the same authority.
Even though we have never been accused officially, it became very unpleasant over the years. As a foreigner, you should never try to criticize a Norwegian, they will take revenge for that. And they know how to do that by using barnevernet against parents.
After some years we decided to move away from Norway to Sweden, which was the best decision we could make. People in Sweden are much nicer than the cold hearted Norwegians.
And it's better to live without fear, which wasn't possible for us in Norway anymore.
Most Europeans are extremely racist and have hidden supremacist ideologies. These are the people who colonized and enslaved Asia and Africa. Laws and institutions just reflect the state of civilization.
@@rohanch07 that's definitely true, as European I have to admit that. Hundreds of years of imperialism do not disappear from a society over night.
as a norwegian I must say that first of all I do not see down on other cultures, we have a standard and we recognize that other cultures have some advantages and other negative ways.
But I can't speak for all ... only me.
That said, when it comes about multi-lingual and children .. that sounds not correct... I'm sure you have experienced it but it sounds like very very strange because I know children here where I live that are atleast speaking 3 languages .. and that is from the kindergarden and out.
Because there are so many languages and like I have sit here at the library lissening how the children talk they speak and switch between all 3 languages like it was one.. and they understand eachother.
I remember when we where younger and I and my friend used to talk and when we where speaking about things that the kids where not to lissen to, we used to switch to english .. these days however the kids understand if not all but very much english and can both lissen and speak english and quite often Lithauanian or Russian, or even Thai.
That is my experience with children and other languages than Norwegian.... these children are often either having 1 or 2 parents of other nationalities, but also some of the norwegian children atleast speak english and norwegian from kindergarden and up.
@@arcticblue248 yes, you are right. And I have never heard that from anybody else. Because it's common sense that it's one of the biggest gifts you can give to your children to raise them bilingual.
I will never forget that woman from barnevernet standing in our doorway and she was dead serious about it. She said we must only speak Norwegian at home. I could hardly believe what I heard.
And they were talking down on us all the time. In all papers they wrote down a lower grade of education than we actually have, even if we mentioned that every time.
In my whole life I have never been treated more disrespectful than by these people. And that's not even the worst part of it.
@@sandsbola that sounds nazi like. Isn't that against EU rules to suppress languages like that. I know for a fact that this wouldn't go well in germany and italy.
I blame 100 percent to Norway Child Kidnapping Services.
Really good video. I was planning to talk about this too on a similar case which happened in Germany - I believe it is very easy to agitate the Indian population emotionally and that's of course, what these one sided stories and movies try to do - 'things are horrible abroad - jaisa bhi ho, apna desh sabsa badhiya' which is a very ignorant view on the entire thing.
I have friends and family with small children in their families and taking away somebody's child doesn't happen randomly or easily - the people work on children welfare cases also know that. (Nobody I know has their children taken away from Germany, Denmark or anywhere else I know people in Europe).
I only know one case from Germany about the child being taken away from their parents, I have also watched the interview of the parents and anybody who watches the interview with a completely rational mind would simply understand that not everything is being told there and everything is being given a dramatic look.
I am not a parent yet, so I don't know - but I also know that there are definitely people in the world (not talking about this case) where the parents didn't deserve to have that child, but somehow that notion alone - that parents can also have their own mortal faults - is completely disregarded in India.
The last dialogue in the trailer "Main achhi hu, ya buri hun pata nahi, but main Maa hun" Is a very bad dialogue. You are right, not everyone deserves to be a parent. A bad mother is bad. Just giving birth is not enough. I also live in Germany and I speak with friends and cousins in India who still believe hitting kids is perfectly normal, and hitting kids even once in Germany is a big legal offense. I was recently in India and I saw how my friends were force feeding their grown up kids. Instead we have never force fed our kids and they tell us when they are hungry and eat well on their own from 1-2 year old. So when Indians say Europeans should understand their culture, they should also learn the culture of the place where they are living. Also hitting kids is not a culture we have to be proud of.
@@gauravk_in you said it better than I did. I believe the same. Indians are very easily agitated emotionally. Well, that's simply bred into us with all the TV series and movies we grew up with. I just know if I had never moved abroad, I would never have gained the ability to see things factually - how they are, without getting overly defensive or emotionally charged on different opinions.
While separating husband had accused wife of assaulting him many times due to her psychological problems. He accepted CWS took this step based on her problems, it was not purely due to cultural differences. Check NDTV, India Today articles or news on this case. Wife had also accused husband of conspiracy. We need to know both the sides of the story. From one side we can never know complete story.
True, even i have felt the same about Germany’s case..I strongly feel that baby’s grandfather has done something. Now parents are trying to cover it up . I didn’t feel they were completely genuine while narrating the incident.
Haa tu to gyan dega hi.. Tu to dhanda kar raha hai na bHaRAt iN GerMAnY. Jitna migrate kare Indians Germany me utna tera dhanda chalega. Sahi khel raha beta.
Finally some sensible voice. Naturally the girl seemed from a town in India where identity of a person as a mother is above everything else. Moreover the girl/woman seemed to be very adamant about her rights as a mother with zero sensitivity towards where she is actually raising her kids. In another European city women, raised in India, noticed that no baby ever cries in public..pin drop silence in trains, train station , airport and cinema hall, markets. We felt this is very unnatural but we recognized this difference and tried to ensure babies maintain this 'locally prevalent' respect for silence. Would agree deporting the mother back to India would be the better option, in case few mothers are unable to follow local customs. But who knows maybe that is interfering with human rights of the father to work in the eyes of Norway govt.Norway govt and couple of other European govt have very good child welfare system. This helps children who are born in families with DV, alcoholism, single parent etc..We hope such systems are available in India, so that each Indian child can be given a peaceful environment to grow up. The amount of help European govt give handicap parents so that they can enjoy parenthood is really commendable.
We recent moved in Norway 😢
get ready
Only the left audio channel is in the video.
I thought my headphones went kaput 😅
Why are u presenting even? I mean is it even a thing to talk about? Like what are you trying to establish??? It is right to pull away a child from mother's lap, who is breastfeeding?????? Disgusting what u r trying to do everyday...
See their interview in TimesNow with Arnab 11 years before
They said sleeping with parents, feeding with hands many other cultural differences
Even Indian minister said the same in the interview
So stop putting your own narrative
They even said mother has mental problems
In India they did multiple mental test by various psychiatrists
They said she is perfectly good
Those guy must have taken money from the Norway Authorities to wipe up the movie
That why he is whitewashing many interviews and incidents
Don't fall for views
I have some questions to Mr. Tremendously.He say 'his authority not only found cultural differences '. I asked from him and his authority what different was found by the authority. We are known the events from mother side not from authority. Please clarify the whole event.
You want to know the Story from the criminal side, who Committed the crime🤣🤣🤣🤣
They don't share much information, in these cases. It's bad 👎
the guy interview you shared above was useless he still doesn't reveal any real reason for their actions in that interview but at least through that news channel I was able to find a dozen article which prove how dangerous Norwegian cps are. Someone had to abduct their child recently through crowd funded movement from cps to get him reunite with his mother in Poland.
Thank you so much for letting us know the truth. A very well balanced and well said clean on the point video. You really spoke so well and clear. 👌
This person is spreading propaganda here to be in good books of Norway authorities.
The actual truth is
czcams.com/video/is0Hq1OfHaE/video.html
It's is not balanced
Nothing balanced in this. He is very much in support of the still corrupt system in Norway, all because he wants to continue to live there
Well done Mrs Chatterjee for fighthing 3 long years for your children what a scam from the govermet in Norway. And Good Desicion that you left your Huspand. For him was his own citicens ship more important then the welfare of his children
If your rights as a parent is more important than your child’s well being there are better countries to live in - with less child protective laws. Northern Europe has the most developed child protective laws in the world.
To all people moving to Northern Europe - learn these laws forehand and how they work. And it’s not only immigrants that are affected, to most part it’s natives children that are taken care of - due to risk of physical or mental abuse.
Even if there is an issue snatching away children from their mother is not at all acceptable. Mother knows best for her children.one more thing Sagarika is separated from her husband not legally divorced yet. Pls refer to her interviews.
I m mother of 2kids....my tears are not stopping after saw this movie
Beard suit karti hai aapko arvind bhai 👍🏻. Namaste from Dehradun 🙏🏻😊
@namaste from Norway
Dear, you will not able feel because you have not suffered. Just feel for the mother. It's elegant west culture different than ours. Please do not put blanket on such issues by defending Norway stand.
India has no such parent evaluation department. If we did, we would put up a different argument. Many Norway white citizen parents too could be evaluated and not found ideal. Children in India are not seen as citizen needing state care or state protection. We all assume parents can never ever hurt their kids.
If there was discriminatory treatment because of skin color alone we need to alert the Indian government to take note.
I suggest we need to have parent screening departments in India too. Child is the future citizen of a country, if he is not raised as per ideal standards he or she becomes a burden to the state, apart from harming innocent others.
No one has right to questions Indian parents
Thank you so much for clearing all the doubts ….👍👍👍
बहुत सही कहा आपने कहा 🙏 थैंक यू।
Waaaaaah Ji Waaaaaah always so nice video Ji
When you get paid and pressurised from Norway Authorities to post positive perspective of Country. Keep going.
You already made 4 videos on this. Make 4 more .
Everyone now knows about Barnevernet. In fact there is a BBC documentary Norway's Silent Scandal.
Can happen to anyone, minister of external affair was not Susma Swaraj. He was Krishna. Unfortunately she has to go through this. They targeted her because he has ASD signs.
What i conclude from movie is that child is being punished by putting them in foster home's unfamiliar enviorment all of sudden where they dont even fully understand what is happening with them.agreed parents were cruel sometime according to norway unique government then punish the parents not the child, charge parents to hefty compansations, send them to some counselling or rehab or training center where they has to pass the exam or if they failed they had to reattempt other wise they will be deported back to their country...but tortouring the child by keeping them away from bilogical parents and then handover them to some unknown foster parents is very very inhuman and not acceptable in any way...😢
I stay here in Finland, a Nordic country like Norway,for last two years and having 3.5 year old son. Not faced or heard any similar kind of situation.
I also agree medical sucks here. We usually consume Vit D on every day basis especially in winter.
This happened 11 years ago
Please don’t make any bad thoughts Nordic countries like Norway, Finland etc. They are peace loving nations having no racism which countries like USA,UK, Australia used to have.
@@NOTHING-j2h bro your mind Overthinkings too much, can't take a neutral decision, this way World doesn't work
When I have said I have bad views about those Countries
Did we start the world war or did Germany...
they spread peace, that doesn't mean , they are good at everything...
@@NOTHING-j2h This movie is not against Norway, or Norwayan people
The story is against Norway system or That particular child welfare Organisation
I have a cat he is staying with us since 1.5 year and I couldn’t stay without him for a week cuz I consider him my own baby and that woman was separated from her children for 2 years thats sad. You have no idea what she must have gone through during that time. She is a mother she knows how to rise her children no institution can detect their rules on rising a child.
These white countries spend more on their pets then their parents
Everybody reading these comments, please look up at articles, videos of heart broken parents whose children these Child Protection Services kidnapped.
About the medical system same here in Netherlands, they say Indian doctor do poor diagnosis, they don't share proper details on scan and x-ray. You don't even get access to x-ray which is taken on you 😂 the system is designed to protect the system itself not us so medical system is closed or sometimes it gives a feeling that they are fraudulent? Or incompetent.
The movie states it is based on the book written by the mom. So there is no need to contact anyone else. Stavanger Barnevernet will not give any input to anyone, as they have always claimed confidentiality. I can assure you that the story matches what was reported in the news media of the day, hence can be considered fairly authentic. As someone who spent quite some time in Oslo, decades ago, my experiences have been quite different, mostly positive, but also quite a bit of racism, as it is a uniformly white society. I believe things changed quite a bit now, with the inflow of quite a few Sri Lankan Tamils in the 80s and 90s, followed by muslim refugees and others.
Thanks!
Whatever you want to say but it does not change the fact that Norway is trying to dictate people, how to treat their children and it does not happen in India.
Well that’s their culture and once u leave ur country and go there for better opportunities u have to follow the rules there lol😅..
Dnt judge the book by it’s cover listen to all and understand.
@@2mins.336 Yes why not, Norway should teach every migrant, how to raise their kids, so they wont interfere with their lives.
We are proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳💪🏽 citizen. & Sushma Swaraj was the greatest foreign minister in our country. She said " Even if you are stuck on the Mars, Indian Embassy there will help you. 🇮🇳💪🏽"
It was UPA Government at the time and Mrs Swaraj was NOT the EAM! Thodi bhakti kak Kiya kar....