Super Mario 3D All-Stars | Crazy or Lazy? (An Extensive Review)
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 12. 2020
- Danerade talks about Mario games for what seems like an eternity.
JOIN THE DISCORD!: / discord
Thank you to all the animators who formulated the intro and end credits!
To appease the original artists, the opening animated Mario gag with Yoshi comes from this video: • Something About Super ...
Storyboard for intro: • Christmas Intro Beta a...
All Music Used (In Order of Appearance):
Carol of the Bells (Piano) • Carol of the Bells (Ch...
Toy Time Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Big Bang! (Mario and Luigi Paper Jam)
Title Theme (Super Mario 64)
Main Theme (Super Mario 64)
Snow Mountain (Super Mario 64)
Dire Dire Docks (Super Mario 64)
Lethal Lava Land (Super Mario 64)
Cave Dungeon (Super Mario 64)
Slider (Super Mario 64)
Throwback Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy 2)
Stage Boss (Super Mario 64)
Ultimate Bowser (Super Mario 64)
Bowser's Road (Super Mario 64)
Staff Roll (Super Mario 64)
Red Streamer (Paper Mario the Origami King)
Welcome to Isle Delphino (Super Mario Sunshine)
Delphino Airstrip (Super Mario Galaxy)
Proto Piranha (Super Mario Sunshine)
Select Data (Super Mario Sunshine)
Isle Delphino (Super Mario Sunshine)
How to Use FLUDD (Super Mario Sunshine)
Phantamanta (Super Mario Sunshine)
Bianco Hills (Super Mario Sunshine)
Ricco Harbor (Super Mario Sunshine)
Gelato Beach (Super Mario Sunshine)
Pina Park (Super Mario Sunshine)
Boss Battle (Super Mario Sunshine)
Meet Bowser Jr. (Super Mario Sunshine)
Sirena Beach (Super Mario Sunshine)
Noki Bay (Super Mario Sunshine)
Noki Depths (Super Mario Sunshine)
Hotel Delphino (Super Mario Sunshine)
Pianta Village (Super Mario Sunshine)
Secret Course (Super Mario Sunshine)
Corona Mountain (Super Mario Sunshine)
Bowser (Super Mario Sunshine)
Epilogue (Super Mario Sunshine)
Staff Credits (Super Mario Sunshine)
Vellumental Area Battle (Paper Mario the Origami King)
Egg Planet (Super Mario Galaxy)
The Star Festival (Super Mario Galaxy)
Attack of the Airships (Super Mario Galaxy)
Space Junk Road (Super Mario Galaxy)
Rosalina in Observatory 1 (Super Mario Galaxy)
Waltz of the Boos (Super Mario Galaxy)
Buoy Base Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Gusty Garden Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Aquatic Race (Super Mario Galaxy)
Beach Bowl Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Dusty Dune Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Ice Mountain (Super Mario Galaxy)
Cloudy Court Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy 2)
King Bowser (Super Mario Galaxy)
Daybreak- A New Dawn (Super Mario Galaxy)
Super Mario Galaxy (Super Mario Galaxy)
Russian Dance Trepak (The Nutcracker)
Steam Gardens (Super Mario Odyssey)
New Donk City Cafe (Super Mario Odyssey)
Bonneton (Super Mario Odyssey)
The Grand Finale (Mario and Luigi Bowser's Inside Story)
Deck the Halls (Piano) • Deck the Halls (Christ...
Thank you all for an amazing year, here is for more to come in 2021. - Hry
Thank you all for waiting so long! This was a huge project that I had a blast making. And to answer the question, Crazy or Lazy? That's up for you to decide. You know my opinions on each game, but you are the final verdict. I will see you all in 2021 =). Take care.
Edit: Also I realize that my version of the box art isn't perfect, or even better in some cases (because I was talking at the literal speed of light) I couldn't fully explain that the point was to illustrate that I could create something so similar in under an hour. Just wanted to clarify some confusion.
That’s a nice conclusion to leave to the viewers, pretty nice breakdown. While I don’t agree with every point, I enjoyed the video quite a lot! Keep up the great work and hope you keep at it!
I like the boss transition from Paper jam.
I know this is off topic but can show us a behind the scenes of how you edit and research your topics and how long you take to do it? That’d be really cool
U should review PvZ2 China it’s so much more unique and fun then our version of the game.(that’s if u can access it)
wdym origami girl ded
Are we really gonna trust Bowser to give his opinion about Mario?
The same guy who disowned his own son twice in the same video.
Thats sus
@@Edsomthing YOU VENTED!
Jess sus
And that is the description for the Bowser's Fury mode.
@@Edsomthing yeah Jess sus ngl
My favorite part is that dane is doing a modern reveiw of a game from the 90's
He did that mainly because people consider all of this games the best games of All Time not the most important games of all time
@@someonethatisntfunny1622 Yeah, Mario 64 is shockingly bad from a mechanical point of view.
Reveiw
Favorite part of my life
I feel like 3D All Stars was a lazy way to do it, however, I appreciate the game's existence and allowing newer players to experience these games. The biggest problem I have with it is it missing Galaxy 2. Sure, I have more, smaller annoyances, like the menuing and box art, the limited time for digital, etc, but the fact that we could have had all the previous 3D Mario games all on the same platform would be amazing, and a great selling point for the Switch, however, the point cant be made as well without Galaxy 2. It's close to being fantastic, but if the devs had taken the time to put the extra oomph in, it would be, and they didnt.
Dont forhet the, reselling us the same exact game, like mario ed world, just because bowsers fury is here too doesnt mean their selling us a port
@@calespeight9087 well, the WiiU didn't sell well, and the games should still be able to be enjoyed, so I feel its a little more justified for 3D World. At least they are giving us a clear enhanced version of it, with Bowser's Fury, faster movement, etc. With 3D All Stars, it really feels like just a port.
My secondary issue is not including SM64's DS remake(?). It makes perfect sense, and the Wii U already got it.
Cale Speight i just don't get Mario ports adding in a minigame and calling it a remake, seems like an excuse to not add anything to the main game. Though, I might be soured by Mario&luigi 's extra content being lackluster in general.
@@lukebytes5366 I suppose adding side games or mini games to the main quest adds replay-ability, with the shining example being Bowser's Fury.
fun fact about the development of Mario galaxy 1 and 2.
Miyamoto believes Video games don’t need to have stories, all that matters is if the game is fun to play. Which is why most Mario games don’t have much of a story. Where as Koizumi believes that a story enhances a game. Koizumi studied film and had a big grasp on Galaxy 1 which is why it had such a cinematic and “epic” opening story. Miyamoto had a bigger grasp on the sequel, Mario galaxy 2. Which in return had way better levels then the first game, but had a very weak story. Watching both openings back to back makes it very apparent. Koizumi also had a big hand in Mario odyssey, which also has a very cinematic story.
This comment makes me happy cause I always skip the dialogue in any Mario game... except sunshine unironically
Yeah bowser has more of a presence in oddessy and the opening mwa
Kinda wild how 2 people can have the complete opposite of an opinion yet both right
I agree with Koizumi. Miyamoto needs to understand that that’s one of many reasons why their games get called lazy (NOT BORING). Yes, Miyamoto has a point and the games are fun imo, but I feel like a story just adds extra OOMPH that is absent in a lot of Nintendo-ESPECIALLY Mario-games.
Ahem timestamps I guess
Intro- 0:00
Mario 64- 2:00
Sunshine- 12:17
Galaxy- 31:05
The collection (the part where he gives his thoughts on the collection as a whole)- 42:21
Imma pray to you now
I will start a war for you.
You have all of my respect
As someone who played Sunshine and galaxy when I was like 9, I love being able to play them 7 years later on a new consol to experience them again. Turns out they're alot easier then younger me thought.
fun fact: in sm64 if you go into tick tock clock when the clock is at 12 then the stage is frozen
opposite goes to 6, it speeds up
Why does this only have 3000 views! This should get WAY more than that!
It's what i have been waiting for. No pre maked opinions because he already played it.
Ok
-- CZcams
@@supportsciencistgaming4761 lmao
18,802
Your wish has been granted
Sunshine is definitely the best Mario game for me. I didn’t grow up with it and still love it the most.
its like sonic 06
so bad its good
@@shadegaming2038 ooh, gottem
@@shadegaming2038 but it isn't even bad in the first place, it's genuinely great
I think this collection could have also been better if it had Super Mario 64 DS, the supreme version of the game. The models are better, they added tons of characters, they remodeled a lot of models limited by the hardware, and added more enemies.
I actually grew up with 64 DS. No clue if it’s the supreme version, since both have their ups and downs. Still, 64 DS was a fantastic remake of the original.
This is a really nice video! It’s nice to hear from someone who started with a Wii U since I’m someone who grew up with a Wii for a few years before getting the Wii U myself. I personally think that Eyerock is a good boss, but he’s the only good one in Mario 64. And overall I’d be more willing to excuse the lazier aspects of this collection if they included Mario Galaxy 2 because it’s my personal favorite 3D Mario. Galaxy 1 may have better presentation, but Galaxy 2 has better design, a higher difficulty, more creative ideas, and Yoshi just adds so much to the gameplay to the point that I would take 2 over 1 any day.
Really, speaking of the Wii, you could play all of these games there, with 64 being $10, Galaxy being $20, and Sunshine being... Probably $20 considering Player's Choice. Galaxy 2 could also be picked up for the Wii for $20, which would've made a collection of the 4 games $70. Instead, we get just 3 of them for $60, a $50 value.
Galaxy was my favorite game as a kid, I'm so glad they added it to all star
"Special thanks to Viddy's Vids" Woah, that was really funny to see for some reason. I've watched the review in a single go and I've got to say, it's been very well made. For most of the times I felt like I had things that bothered me about the games but everyone else wouldn't really acknowledge them. So it was nice to see that you share some thoughts here and there with me.
Keep the videos coming!
I would have put you but until you let me voice Uzbekistan in one of your videos it won’t happen quite yet ;). Thanks for the feedback!
Sorry for the late response. That’s a specific country that I wouldn’t really think much of but I guess that’s what’s funny about it. I’ll be sure to let you know if I ever need that country in particular. I thought you’d be more leaning towards Czechoslovakia though
@@KoralTea Never feel obligated, but I’ll never say no to Czechoslovakia.
Wow, I've never seen this much effort and care into a video like this before from your channel. You're improving a lot and a lot with your videos. Fantastic job
Just wanna say thanks for commissioning me on animating Bowser and showing it at the end credits!
Also, great video! Couldn't imagine how long this took to make with all the research and edit
Now you have *got* to play Galaxy 2. It is so good, and in my opinion definitely lives up to its predecessor.
Finally someone that doesnt rate super mario 64 a 10/10 ah feels good
I’ve got a question I’ve been wondering for a while, Mr. Ade; are you inspired by Scott The Woz at all? I see a lot of his same style in these videos, and I like it.
Great video! I really enjoyed the structure and flow.
Ay just wanted to say this was a great video. Games were analyzed fairly with points that were clear and to the point most of the time. Editing was solid. Some humor thrown in. Can't wait to see more from you in the future.
Found you from your PVZ Brutal mode vids, stayed for your reviews.
Your Luigi's Mansion video was also amazing, and what made me stay subscribed. Glad I did.
I absolutely enjoy watching you go into immaculate detail with these video games with the beautiful, hard to master, dry sarcastic but absolutely hilarious humor type. You somehow make a, in hine sight, boring video game review turn into something beautiful, easy to understand and entertaining video. Your channel definitely needs more recognition with how much effort you put into your work. Good job good sir.
Danerade: "the punishment shouldn't be so severe"
Me a child who's barely beaten donkey kong country and barely beat the final bowser : "I'ma have to not agree with you on that"
King you dropped this 👑.
These commentary videos are great, please keep making video, they are entertaining and charming
"God forbid if we kill in a mario game"
I haven't finished paper mario origami king
*BUT*
cool vid! I can't wait to play this game for christmas!
Fun fact: the reason bowser sounds like a cat is because to save money they used stock animal sounds, including (but not limited to) A cougar’s growl.
who'se gonna tell him that all the game's in the collection are emulated lol
Except Galaxy which is an actual port
Yea I love ur videos, I’m doing a marathon of all your videos, u have talent
Nice work!
30:05 I've always ADORED mario sunshine yet after watching this I had the sudden realisation that it does kinda lack in compare to other gamecube titles which I've somehow never even thought about before
Fun video. I played 64 and sunshine for the first time with the switch collection and felt the opposite of you. I found 64 to be extremely frustrating and slippery, and the camera of course is infuriating. On the other hand, despite some jank, I had a lot of fun with sunshine and found it's theming very charming.
Yeah I'll never get why 64 is said to be so good. It's fine but the worst 3d mario game by far
“We can’t kill in a Mario game”
Bobby: am a joke to you?
grammar intensifies
Seevehn that was a quote from the video
Wait until thousand year door hits you like a truck
@@someguy496
We didn't see his wife's death. A visual presentation is more heart breaking than reading a line of text.
@@buzzytrombone4353 You see what it did to him. It broke my heart, thats for sure
You are really put a huge amount of work in you're video don't stop ples😃
Super mario sunshine predicted among us
When the impos
When the imposter is sus
props to you for beating all three of them, i beat galaxy, maybe half of 64 before giving up, and got 2 shrines in sunshine because i didn't know where to go. guess i know now and i can go back to it. the second shrine was weirdly hard due to the controls lol
“i grew up on this” Holyshit im getting old, but i am happy to see a new pair of eyes look at these old games…
Mario Sunshine could’ve been the best game in franchise with a little tweaks.
Good video love to see a younger persons take on games I grew up with. Something important to keep in mind when going back to play these original titles is that they were well before the archetypes of games were so set in stone and well known. These were also the days of seeing things truly done for the first time, which is not something someone who grew up with post 2010 titles will experience very often, or ever. Peaches castle and the game as a whole, for instance, was (is) absolutely mind bogglingly impressive for someone who came from Super Mario Bros, Super Mario Bros 3, and Super Mario World. I literally can’t fathom how difficult it must be for someone to be impressed by these things when they never experienced a world without millions of polished, cheap, and available on demand titles.
A great example of this disparity is your assertion that you’re bumped out of levels to “pad out game time.” This game was made in an era where most games, start to finish (if you do a perfect run) were quite short, and an era where losing actually meant something. Like in the original Mario you literally go back to the beginning of the game when you lose, compared to just hitting continue in modern Mario. Why? Because you were actually “punished” for losing, and so you can eventually gain the satisfaction of conquering the whole game in one run. This was also well before the era of consumers expecting/wanting games to be very lengthy, so the motivation of trying to lengthen the game doesn’t really make sense. The real answer is, in 1996, when you died in a video game - it meant something, they make you do the level again. Completely bog standard. Modern video games feel like playing retro titles with save states, they’re so forgiving it’s insane.
Yo Dane, I’m on the younger side too (20) and I’ve never played most of these Mario games. Mario 3D world was my absolute favorite as a teen lol. I’ve replayed it more times than I can remember. This was a great review for someone who’s never actually played Mario 64 or sunshine. It’s really brave of you too criticize and honestly review such beloved titles. So many people can’t look back on their favorite games with a critical light. Great review (s)!
That clearly just needed something to get through the year, and they figured fans _might_ get excited over a remaster.
Mario Galaxy's lore building is spectacular and beautiful
i wanna be included in the next shameless discord plugin
When I got the game I had just finished Mario Galaxy a few months before on my old wii. I mostly wanted this for sunshine because I wanted sunshine really badly but couldn’t get a GameCube. It’s a really great game and I also tried our Mario 64 and I need like 10 more stars to finish it
Love your content 💪🏻🦔
The hilarious hypocrisy of Danerade (Bowser) disowning Jr., when his voice is even more ridiculous by comparison is gold.
i love how the intro title knocks him to the floor very funny
danerade: pinna park
subtitles: peanut park
Make more vids like this they’re really entertaining. 10/10
I've only played Galaxy and played 64 through the Wii U's virtual console so being able to play sunshine for the first time was great
Nintendo knew it was lazy, So they made it a limited edition so they can increase sales Because of FOMO (Fear of missing out)
Might as well flip off your customers
When Jr calls Peach his mama, I kinda wish she said something like "oh no...not another one..."
Toy time galaxy was my favorite galaxy when I was young! I still love it
I recently got 3DAS and I love it (and by “it” I mean “Sunshine and Galaxy”). Despite having a Wii and easy access to the PC port of 64 (with tons of QoL mods), it’s neat being able to play these games on the go officially, as well as officially having them in widescreen and 1080p. My preferred way to play Sunshine now is actually the 3DAS version with a GameCube controller and adapter.
I also like how they kept the charm of the demo videos on Galaxy.
However, this port leaves a LOT to be desired and I don’t think there was any excuse for its issues, and Nintendo ABSOLUTELY needs to do better in the future.
Mario galaxy 1 and 2 were legit my childhood. Also 3D world was what I had when I was a little older so now I wanna buy a switch purely to get 3D world
Still have my 2008 save on my wii. I played this game for a ridiculous amount of time as a kid.
Mom can we get Scott the Woz?
We have Scott the Woz at home
Scott the Woz at home:
(This video was great, the humour was right up my alley and the editing was amazing! 10/10)
Jeez man, i remember when u first made the PvZ 3 vid, and u had so much less subs. I don’t remember the exact number, but I remember before u got so many subs
Oh, so I'm NOT the only person that hasn't played those games prior to getting 3D All-Stars.
"He also sounds like a cat for some reason."
Lol you're not wrong, his voice clips are literally taken from a tiger, besides his laughing.
Hi, I’m Water, nice Video, Danerade! Merry christmaS,
4:23, rip so long gay bowser
I love the fact that too this day Amazon still has some of the European version left in stock
Very good Dane😎
Dunno why this has so little views compared to the pvz content. Glad to see you change up your content, please don't pressure yourself to be "The PvZ" guy because this is pretty great!
This channel is an underrated gem holy shit, I've been binging your videos all day. I can't wait to see you blow up!!
this game showed a lot of potential, i got it and said "i can just play these games on my Wii u... whats the point" Also, the games are emulated versions... Pretty lazy if you ask me. I think a better idea would to remake these games in Odyssey's engine, because in my opinion, it forces nintendo to think out of the box (making sm64 stages to fit with Odyssey)
its not lazy to emulate the games they don't need to be ported from the ground up and would probably not work that well and even if it did some people want to play the original game
@TrainerblueTube yeah ik
huh, super mario sunshine is the first 3d platformer i played (on the switch in only 15) but i enjoy it a lot, i haven't beat it yet cause im trying to 100% before i beat bowser but it's been a blast, i have had to use tutorials for a few levels, but honestly some of the bugs in the game actually kinda help the experience, like fruit storage, incredibly easy and incredibly useful, I find the flood a worthwhile addition due to the complexity it adds to normal standard mario platforming. And stating the game is unfair does seem a bit unreasonable since you can skip a lot of difficult stages, the game will make you go trough some but you can skip a lot of em. But what you said about the blue coins is true it just feels like padding, it makes it really difficult to 100% the game and i've always hated collectable fetching, it's a reason why i've never reached the true ending of batman arkham knight, there's just so many riddler quest. so yeah it is flawed but i'd say it's worth a play
1:17 i remember playing mario 64 on the wii u virtual console, but apart from that, i feel you
Honestly I'd rather emulate older games on the Wii or Wii u than the switch, which sucks
if you dont like emulation why does the luigis mansion gameplay have a windows mouse pointer? just curious is all
Before watching this, according to the cutting room floor, the upscaled mario sunshine textures were found in a folder called ''Lazy_Texture_Replace'' or something like that. Just saying...
At 11:32 my first thought was “wait Luigi’s mansion 3 had a soundtrack?”
My opinion about the collection is close to you but for seomone that before only play mario 64 ds and galaxy I would love that mario 64 ds was in the collection and with the bug and the game being unfair I didnt finish sunshine great video
Mario 64 DS review? (I really loved the game tbh)
Great video, but at 31:14 I would not consider the idea that Super Mario Galaxy is the best of the 3 games unanimous. Many fans would consider Mario 64 to be the best of this collection because of its legacy and open world. Still an amazing game though.
first of all dang that was a nice video, second of all how old are you because im 15 and i would struggle to make a video this good ( also you said you grew up with the wiiU which is crazy cus i feel young but i grew up with the wii)
20:09 those are Alolan forms of the enemies!
Watch as on March 31st as they released super Mario 3D all stars DELUX with Mario Galaxy 2 and Mario 3D Land added to it
When playing sunshine, I got stuck ON a shine. Couldn't move, couldn't collect it
10:58 - Pretty simple explanation for that actually.
That's _literally_ the sound they used for him back then.
They just took 1 of the "mountain lion" sounds from a sound library then pitched it up.
( If you're curious, you can find more info here: czcams.com/video/zvlt5L51prI/video.html )
Quick question where did you get your game cube from
1:24 this entire collection is emulation
Honestly the hugest mistake is not including Galaxy 2 or 64DS which would've made this a steal. Honestly if you just ported DS, Sunshine, Galaxy, and Galaxy 2 without improving framerate or anything, I would've bought this. Sadly, we got none of that and now I'm sad and don't regret not buying this.
Sonic Origins is dying of laughter right now.
OH MY GOD SO MANY REFERENCES
Really diggin the Scott the Woz clip used to describe the viewers here. Someone knows who our CZcams lord and savior is
Sunshine is so fun to play because of the controls, they are just a blast to mess around with. But the switch version had very awkward water controls which are inferior. I Shari appreciate it being actually challenging, with a couple minor exceptions which ARE unfair
I had never played sunshine, and the last time I had played 64 was at my grandmother's house, it was my uncle's but because he was stationed in Alaska at that time, the N64, Genisis, and NES were all hooked up there, but I mainly played the 64, so I had some memories of 64, but mainly Mario Kart 64, I played that thing more than Mario Kart Wii. (I am 16 at the time of typing this), so I agree, this is more of a first playing, (Galaxy 2 should have been included)
Fun fact: the international version of the game called "King Boo" in Sunshine was actually called "Boss Boo" in Japan. So, this design of "King Boo" was designed with a different character in mind.
I personally don't really like Super Mario Galaxy and prefer 64 and Sunshine, but I'm glad you got to experience these games despite how clunky most of them were. I still have those games myself, only reason I got them on the Switch was so I could take them on the go with me.
I like the Bowser's inside story transitions
I thought I was the only one who hadn’t played these games prior!
I didn't grow up with nintendo.
I didn't care about the N64 as a kid.
I was mainly into PlayStation's legend of dragoon and Crash bandicoot more then a plumber that jumps.
But as I got older my friends keep telling me how "Deep" and "Exciting" and "Mature" the Nintendo games are.
And I replied with a "Holly shit they looked like Baby games when I was a kid was I purhaps wrong?"
I grabbed a controller and played Pokemon for the first time and... "Wow... This is worse then I thought.. why can't I have my pokemon follow me around?"
"Play Pokemon black!" "Can your pokemon follow you cause they should in the year 2010s?" "Um no..." "Then it's garbage next game"
Ok next game is legend of Zelda breath of the wild "Oh this opening is similar to Fallout 3 I love Fallout 3..... Where is everything?" "Well it's mostly open spac-" "Genshin impact didn't cost me 60 and it has better graphics and more characters then this next"
Metroid this game looks like Halo I like Halo "So why not buy it?" "Why should I the other 2 games sucked"
Animal crossing "this looks stupid"
Smash bros "I hate fighting games"
Mario 3D all stars "Forget it-" "Oh wait there's a time limit!" ".... You're kidding me...."
*One gameplay session latter*
"Okay... The first game sucked galaxy made me nauseous but.... Sunshine was actually pretty fun"
"God forbid If we kill in a mario game..." ahem oragami king! Bobby
For me, this collection is just Mario Galaxy.
I played Mario Galaxy 2 really long ago and wanted to play the original.
I remember that time when I was playing 3D all stars and as soon as I got to the Sting Ray I got 1 million (not really a million probably like idk 9) Game overs to the jaw because sometimes because of the fact that when you squirt water on the stingray tends to duplicate if you squirted an inch of water means that most of those game overs were because of the fact that I was getting bodied like the stingrays were playing tennis with Mario’s corpse as the ball
--------------------------------
Comment 2: I can relate to the secret stages of sunshine being like Satin asking Mario Maker 2 to make probably the most hardest stage series in the game because the hotel secret stage made me not touch the game for like seven whole months.
(PS: I don’t know if it was actually seven whole months since I played the game I just know I haven’t played the game in a couple months not a year but a couple months)
Same I've never played these thats why it's the first game(s) I've ever pre ordered
Dude, you are literally the best youtuber