India In Egypt : Aryans were reverse-migrating Indians | Dr. Tilak Ranjan Bera |
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 07. 2024
- About The Talk:
In this episode, Dr Bera will elaborate evidences available all over India which confirms the phenomenon of the ‘Reverse Migration’ of the Indian origin fraternities.
Dr Tilak Ranjan Bera (Books) : amzn.to/3PTSg3m
About The Speaker:
Dr Bera has explored Indian subcontinent to collect evidences to establish the antiquity of Indian civilization. He introduced quite a few 'never-thought-of ideas' to arrange Indian history. He was awarded Fulbright Fellowship and went to the Yale University.
Topics covered:
00:00 Power Statement
01:00 Speaker Introduction
02:12 Recap of previous episodes
08:14 Why reverse migration from Red Sea remained unnoticed?
09:50 Sea route used for reverse migration
10:30 What caused the reverse migration?
13:36 Origin of the Indian population
16:25 References from Rig Veda
21:47 The primary routes used for reverse migration
26:45 Goddesses of Bengal
30:57 Patriarchal period in India and Egypt
32:20 Genetic evidences of onward and reverse migration
33:07 Cultural, anthropological, and linguistic evidences
39:34 Three distinct indigenous communities
41:52 Interlock Double Triangle Symbol
44:15 Red Sea connectivity of Northeast India
47:42 Onward Migration Map
49:44 Origin of animal symbols
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @sangamtalks
Join our CZcams channel to get updated on new video releases:
Hindi : / sangamhindi
English : / sangamtalks
Tamil : / @sangamtamizh
Punjabi : / @sangampunjabi
Bhojpuri : / @sangamtalksbhojpuri
Marathi : / @sangammarathi
Malayalam : / @sangammalayalam
Shorts : / @sangamtalkstv
Bangla : / @sangambangla
For updates you may follow us on:
Facebook : / sangamtalks
Instagram : / sangamtalks
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter : / sangamtalks
Koo : www.kooapp.com/profile/sangam...
Website : www.sangamtalks.org
Donate : www.sangamtalks.org/donate
Pre Islamic, pre Christian and pre jewish cultures, gods, architecture and various artifacts clearly suggests the deep link between other cultures and core indian culture..
Only in BHARATA or jambu dwipa we could see a native black, pale yellow, fair and all kinds of facial race,color and structure...
I had been in Egypt for sometimes there I have read the ancient culture of Egypt and surprised to know the facts that Cows were worshiped there.
Golden calf was worshipped by Jews once. For that act the generation did not enter Palestine.
Even worshipped zebu
prophet abraham followers too worshipped cow to which he cursed them , 😂😂its mentioned in quran too the original jews were the dalits of Egypt who rebbeld against Egypt under leadership of prof abrham
@@user-lp9vz6lu3t Wtf, Where did dalits come in all this? No Jews weren't Dalits, Dalit is a fairly new term.
@@vaibhavyadav9912 i means dalit types Egypt too had caste system, and jews were the people living in outskirts of Egyptian Empire, abraham was like bhim baba ambedkar of jews in egypt
মহাশয়, আপনার কাজ দেখে অত্যন্ত প্রভাবিত হলাম!
প্রণাম নেবেন !
Piecing together the ancient history of India and in fact the world is a real jigsaw puzzle. Confounding legitimate search is the fact that much of the history was distorted and whitewashed by the colonial rulers. Hope very soon, all these pieces can be fitted together without any bias, and we can get the true picture, but what is already gradually emerging is of an highly interactive ancient world is truly fascinating.
Amazing research. Dr Bera👌❤❤
He is like the lighthouse of ancient Indian history
Dr Tilak Bera is outstanding..Is it possible to have a chart which include timeline, region, genetics data and deity ..so that we can see if every data is compatible over all the parameters...Another request to know more on Gangaridai civilization because it seems Indian Historians are not interested and they have separate agenda.
Please see the time line given by Rupa Bhati and Nilesh Oak, Indic Professor s.
Ganga Hridi is elaborately discussed in India in Egypt including the etymology of the name.
@@ganeshandurkar5912 Mr Nilesh Oaks books do give the timelines for Ramayana, Mahabharata and are clear about no migration in or out and again into Bharat. This Egyptian theory is not backed by DNA findings as reported in scientific literature. Hence my query in one of the comments. My sense is that one or two data points and that too language based and conjectural is stretching the theory too far. But am not an expert so I leave at that.
Very interesting..!!! sadly we dont have any of this information in our school history texts . Thanks Sir for such a detailed info 🙏
my sinsere pranam to dr tilak great research ,
Why not Conduct WORLD LEVEL DISCOURSE on Ancient BHARATVARSH/ARYAWART CIVILIZATION on war footing? May U Reach Global Hindu Organizations to Organise and Conduct!!!
Thrilling but too complex. It flies in the face of Occam Razor. Simpler to assume that Bharat civilization originated in Bharatavarsha and move out to Greece, Egypt etc. No need for several inter-continental shuttling unless there are solid evidences.
This is thrilling information. It makes sense and is very well explained. Many thanks to Dr. Bera and Sangam talks.
Even if you read cou-raan Mohammad had been fighting against Murti pujaks only, his mother was one if murti pujaks aka sanatani 😅
I hope Indians are listening to this
Kindly share links to episodes 1 & 2. Not finding it in YT search!
I am. I no expert on ancient history. But would like expert opinion on what Bera says here and how it squares up with the Findings of Deccan College Pune, Birbal Sahni institute of and Paleobotany Lucknow and their Papers debunking the Aryan Invasion Theory using DNA analysis ; and Nilesh Oaks triangulation of time periods of Ramayana, Mahabharata etc using Surya Siddhant; and Sushruta Sambhita on medicine, surgery. All papers I’ve read very neatly fit with scientific findings and analysis. Would like the same from Mr Bera.
'India in Egypt' is the 'first volume' (other volumes are under preparation) of your answer. Every researcher is approaching the subject of establishing the 'Antiquity of Indian Civilization' in his own way, collecting data from his subject of interest. I am exploring as much as possible of the Mediterranean region to collect evidences available at that end for my next book.
If people came from Africa, how is it africa did not become more civilised than india. Does it not mean that it was out of india that population dispersal happened and not out of Africa. In fact I read somewhere that Africans and Indians are closest in DNA and that 80 % of the world’s population has Indian DNA
The lion (Panthera leo) is a large cat of the genus Panthera native to Africa and India.
I Knew this but was silent as I didn’t want to change the course of events and now you ppl have revealed it , not sure what’s gonna happen now
Stop using Sanskrit words such as Aryan(Hindu in English)in a inferior context. Its a great transgression
🙏
Yes came across articles that the Earliest Vedic hymns have references
❤
👍👍
pls incorporate better graphics for making the subject more engaging
Amazing how history can be turned around to suit the narratives of the day.😅😅
Overwhelming and obviously very well done. Thank you sir for your Great Effort. Let's burn with the truth.
Yes this is right theory ...
.
Thank you
.
I must agree on this research..
.
The Sea Route
to and from Goa
....has to be understood
.
The Greeks did define a name for Goa
...Aparanta
.
I read..
.
Goa was also known to the Greeks by the name Chersonesus or Nelikinda (Periplus), Nekanidon (Pliny), Melinda or Tricadiba Insula (Ptolemy), Nincilda (Peutingerian tables), Sibo, and to the Arabs by the names Sindabur, Chintabur and Cintabor. Its origins run back into mythology.
.
.
The return from west ...mahrastra to oriya is identifiable....they have such similar words n sound similar.
Could you include proofs n evidence appropriately so that ur talk is NOT reduced to mere HOT TALK
..
This talk is only 0.1% of the contents of the book. This book 'India in Egypt' is all about an analysis of evidences present both in India and in the rest of the world.
🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
When was the first migration to Egypt?
2500 bce.
Early Kirata and R1b haplogroup (Pali speakers) migration took place towards the Mediterranean coast (so called Cradle of civilization) about 10,000 to 12,000 years before present. They entered North East Africa through the Horn - of - Africa as well as through Nile Delta. These two divisions united and established the Egyptian dynastic rule 3150 BC.
this will explain the ramayan war. Ram would have been the Sanskrit Aryan while ravana would have been indigenous or paltri given the high technology on both side and same divine references for weaponry and favor
Why is this not in a paper? Btw plural of 'evidence' is 'evidence'
It is in a book titled 'India in Egypt' which discusses a plethora of subjects which is good enough for one hundred papers. Entire series of event needs to be explained in a sequence in compiled form and cannot be discussed in isolation.
what is bengal costal
don't be bias
The color of clothes worn by dieties are no doubt chosen by the devotees. But how the colors of saree will reflect from which part of world Bhartiyas were reverse migrating??? Do you have any reference to substantiate your hypothesis? Like, I can give you one example Sir, in my place during Durga puja, you can see MAA Durga🙏 in different colors of Saree (green, yellow red, pink); this means what?? People at my place reverse migrated from where?????????????
And on more thing, when you talk 10,000 years back like events, then no INDIA existed; it is and was only BHARAT. Kindly call our country BHARAT; least when you dig deep into Vedic period and all. Thank you Sir!
Our present idol makers do not follow any such pre- script period language and thus they use any colour they feel like. Whereas in archaeological images like in Egypt and ancient Greece you find them strictly following this pre - script language of color code 3,000 to 4,000 years ago. Incidentally, Rig Veda often refers to such colors which is followed in this book.
Secondly, we are not sure whether this region was known as Bharat or by any other name 10,000 years ago. We do not know the geographical boundaries of Bharat and Mahabharat. Using any other name would invite further confusion. It is thus rational to use India to justify the region we are referring to.
Mittani, Hittite, asyria or asuria , mycenea, ancient Egypt all were established and built by ancient aryans(ancient Indians), but destroyed and assimilated by the mooris invaders from africa hence the reverse migration and the surviving ones moved to Caucasus region and further west
westerners often pronounce Indian names with English connotations and vowel sounds that does not correspond to Hindi or Sanskrit grammatical vowel sounds, for example mesopotamia had been probably pronounced mech(o)potamia, Gilgamesh had been probably pronounced Gilg(a)Mech, alphabet in brackets has silent pronunciation. Middle Eastern language and other western languages cannot refer any meaning of these ancient names
Indian civilization could pre-date Gondwana land super continent.🤔
some one plz throw this video on faces of romila thapar ,irfan habbib
Now I know why some relatives are having colored eyes, blond and red heads and at least as white as whitey white.🤔🙄😃😀😁😜
How about giving some evidences rather than just making statements
Entire book is full of ground evidences present both in India and Egypt to convincingly establish the ancient connectivity between Indian and Egyptian civilizations.
Sir, With due respect, can you please share what kind of references you have to prove that Pali-speaking Bhartiyas moved to a land which "according to you is 21st-century geographical region called Palestine"??? If you have this information in any form, PDF or hard copy book, research papers or maybe Bhartiya Vedic literature; kindly cite those in your future videos.
It is practically impossible to explain everything to everybodies satisfaction in one such one hour video. We are discussing only 1% of the contents of the book titled ' India in Egypt '. Finally, this is a completely new concept arranged on the basis of available archaeological, linguistic, genetic and cultural evidences. However, you have to keep in mind that we are making an attempt to arrange the events of the pre- recorded period and thus it is not available in script as yet.
you just too engrosed in this , now its time to talk about the unity and consolidating india as a whole and if there are some mistake better to mitigate and ractify them. produce parable instead of rif # priyar embrace priya love not haterd
Europe is Atlantic Asia the Sanskrit Hindu language has no body other than Bharat Aryavart. The European languages are Indian in origin.
How does all this solve today's problems?
Every knowledge is not to solve problems and still somewhere someone will be definitely benefited by this knowledge! You can't be aware of every problem on this earth😂 Just be humble to accept and respect knowledge and knowledgeable persons!
The research done is leading to interesring information however the interpretation lacks deep spiritual significance, knowledge, understanding and experience of the various dieties their vahanas and various symbolic attributes such as color. Also the interpretation of the form of the interlocked star symbol lacks the connection to its meaning purpose and significance in Tantra shastra. Without its connection to both spiritual sadhana and the experiential understanding of existential reality, it will only lead to a superficial interpretation and conclusion. It seems that the researched information has been hastily fitted into a narrative that strips it of its deeper meaning and subtler and higher perspectives and interpretations. A continuation of a practice of culture spanning thousands of years cannot merely be driven by gross level significance. It has to have deeper and subtler connections to spirit and energy and its knowledge and it is imperative that that must be present in the interpretation of any research/theory/scientific conclusion or connection of dots of information on Indian civilization its culture people and history.
Decade back .. I put forward the REVERSE MIGRATION into Bharat .. Akhanda Bharatha extended until Anatolial, todays Turkey/Syria !
Bengal Tiger 🐅 🐅 🐯 🐅 🐯 🐅 🐯 🐅 🐯 🐅
How did the slavics mongoloids and the Caucasians emerge?
India served as the Intermediate Host of modern humans following their out-of - Africa move and their arrival in India 65,000 years ago. Presence of aboriginal tribes in Andamans confirm their survival in India. Presence of Tribal population in India is unique and also establishes their survival in India. Post-glacial period genetic identities spread from India about 12,000 years ago along with their language and culture. They developed other physical features because of different environmental influences. Their genetic identity remained more or less same.
@tilakbera554 Thank you, Dr. Bera. Looking at the aboriginal population of Australia goes back to 65 thousand plus years. The carbon dating of the rock paintings go back that far and the other interesting thing is the relationship between the paintings in Sri Lanka and Australia are very similar. I am wondering if you would have the opportunity to shed a light on this as well.
Idea is better ..but no evidence. .... In india tribes. .ariyan. .. Sruthi smriti. .vedam ( only for brahmin ) bhudha... Jain.. Etc...
Stop saying "evidences"!!!!!!!! Plural of evidence is evidence!!!
When India is renamed Aryavart the delusion will be ended
The speaker has not overcome the British influence! Caste is neither Varna based on satva-rajas-tamo-gunas, nor birth-based jati, kula, gotra, varga, shakha, vamsha, sangha, etc ! Combining all of these under the European Casteism System of Low and High Castes and untouchables is introduced by the British!
None of the Sanskrit terms Varna and birth-based jati, kula, gotra, varga, shakha, vamsha, sangha, etc is a totem pole like the European Caste System introduced into Americas to India.
1. Elizabeth Wheeler Andrew, Katharine Caroline Bushnell , Henry Joseph Wilson , Josephine Elizabeth Grey Butler, The Queens Daughters in India,
2. Anjali Arondekar, On Sexuality and Colonial Archive in India,
3. Durba Mitra, Indian Sex Life, and the Cultural Control of Women.
4. Anjali Arondekar, For the Record: On Sexuality and the Colonial Archive in India,
5. Ratnabali Chatterjee, The Queen’s Daughters: Prostitutes as an Outcast group in Colonial India
6. Ratnabali Chatterje, The Indian Prostitute as a Colonial Subject Bengal 1864-1883
7. Carolyn Sleightholme, Guilty without Trial: Women in the Sex Trade in Calcutta
8. Sudhanshu Bhandari, Prostitution in Colonial India, Mainstream, Vol XLVIII, No 26, June 19, 2010
9. Philippa Levine and Susan Grayzel, Gender, Labour, War and Empire in Modern Britain: Essays on Modern Britain
10. Philippa Levine, Prostitution, Race and Politics: Policing Venereal Disease in the British Empire
11. Sudipta Sen, Lawless Subjects: Crime and Punishment in Early British-India
12. Elizabeth Kolsky, Colonial Justice in British India: White Violence and the Rule of Law
13. Sen, Distant Sovereignty: National Imperialism and the Origins of British-India
14. Sen, Empire of Free Trade: The East India Company and the Making of the Colonial Marketplace,
15. 165 MILLION HINDUS KILLED BY THE BRITISH IN 40 YEARS, researchgate
16. Kenneth Ballhatchet, Race, Sex and Class Under the Raj: imperial attitudes and policies and their critics, 1793-1905
17. Nicolas Dirk, Castes of Mind: Colonialism and the Making of Modern India
18. N Dirk, The Scandal of Empire: India and the Creation of Imperial Britain
19. SISTEMA DE CASTAS
20. Malhotra and Vishvanathan, Jati, Varna, Caste
21. Satish Sharma, Caste, Conversion, and Colonial Conspiracy
22. Pardip Kumar Kukreja Guruji Sundara Raj Anantha, Aykshya Simrhen Raj, Caste is Not Hindu, a historical narrative, Caste is a Construct of the Colonial Invaders
23. Harjinder Singh, Caste and its Histories in Colonial India: A reappraisal
24. Rosalind O'hanlon, Caste and its Histories in Colonial India: A reappraisal
25. Caste Among Non-Hindus in India
26. Chris Fuller, Theories of Caste and British Colonial Ethnography
27. Roderick Ferguson, Aberrations in Black.
28. Samanta Pinto, Indian Sex Life, Feminist Method and Bad Objects.
29. Jessica Hinchy, Governing Gender and Sexuality in Colonial India.
30. Elizabeth Kolsky, Colonial Justice in British India: White Violence and the Rule of Law.
31. Jyoti Puri, Sexual States.
32. In the Absence of Reliable Ghosts: Sexuality, Historiography, South Asia. Diffrences 25.3 (2015) 98-122.
33. Jyoti Puri, Woman, Body, Desire in Post-Colonial India: Narratives of Gender and Sexuality.
34. Gayatri Reddy, With Respect to Sex: Negotiating Hijra Identity in South India. Ashwini Tambe, Codes of Misconduct: Regulating Prostitution in Late Colonial Bombay.
35. Sita Ram Goel, HinduTemples What Happened to Them? (Islamic destruction of Hinduism)
All the above books should be included as a part of the history syllabus in schools in India.
Population genetics
Stop mutilating Sanskrit words by putting it in a inferior context.
Zero evidence, ridiculous comparison with Egypt and rest. This guy has no idea at all. Such people are an embarrassment.
There is no question over Aryan migration to India from Central Asia.... and Arayn-migration to Central Asia from Ural mountain range... of North polar region
The Drividian tribe came originally from out of East Africa. Thats why they are the black ones. Don't get it twisted?????
😂😂😂😂 weed
Dravidians and alike did came from unknown place. We only have hypothesis based on oral traditions that could be distorted by the last conqueror. For example, who remembers Mani !!!
Black, brown, yellow, white which ever is your skin colour, everyone's ancestors came out of Africa. Skin colour difference is due to Epigenetic modifications. Ancestors of the white man was ALSO BLACK!
Nonsense. The equatorial Indians were dark-skinned . Moreover every kind of skin color and tone having same DNA including south and north of india are proven that there is nothing differentiating ancient indians etc
You Buffoon even original British and Irish people were Dark skinned.
Not at all convincing. Both Pali and Sanskrit are IE languages. They must have a common homeland, not one in Egypt and the other in Europe. These two langauges cannot reverse migrate inro Bharat because they go against the Rig Vedic geographical evidence as established by Shrikant Talageri. Besides your interestng take on the animal symbols, you're wasting your time indulging in such useless research. Please read the works of Nicholas Kazanas, Premendra Priyadarshi, Shrikant Talageri, Michel Danino and Aleksandr Andreyevich Semenenko.
Lion is very much native to india unless the Gir lions and lions that roamed around delhi were brought here during reverse migration
Aryan invasion ye sab galat he.. Sanskrut language it's God' s language.. Bharat 🇮🇳 me hi paida huyi, yahi pe hi jada use huyi, yahi se bahar gayi..
Sahi kaha bhai
😂
Palestine is not pali-stan. Stop this BS. Yes, there was trade between India and Mesopotamia, Iran, Egypt, Abyssinia Rome, Greece etc. But that doesn’t mean Indians migrated there in droves. They might have been trader posts and settlements. Just like foreign traders had port settlements in India.
Even if you have a valid complaint, which deserves consideration, by speaking with disrespect, most cultured people will discount your opinion, considering it unworthy of consideration, because it is coming from an uncultured mood.
Dude we have dna evidence and zebu migration evidence please read it.
@@bhimakarma I didnt show any disrespect. I called his point BS, not him.
I found it wierd too. Pali isn't an ancient language, especially a 12k yr old language.
@@cyb-m
Check your dna
Indian civilisation was much younger than Egyptian and syria. Both are known as cradles of civilisation.
Dr Bera, you need to connect with Dr Madhusudan from UK; Hindu Knowledge Academy to understand Rik ved, Purush Sukta and other important scriptures---that data you can use in your research to combine with genetics, and migrations.
where your forefather where black and has frizzy hair 😂😂😂
👍👍