History of the .45 ACP

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 683

  • @anihtgenga4096
    @anihtgenga4096 Před 5 lety +20

    I like the .45 ACP because a Big Dumb Bullet doesn't have to mushroom or do anything fancy when it impacts the target.

  • @sawtoothmunitions7307
    @sawtoothmunitions7307 Před 5 lety +310

    Nothing says America like a 45.

    • @marsrizzo2854
      @marsrizzo2854 Před 5 lety +8

      Sawtooth Munitions USA USA

    • @DrSimeonHill808
      @DrSimeonHill808 Před 5 lety +16

      45acp is good Big Hole more bleeding = energy +weight = stopping not a overpenatationer! Boom

    • @faisaldhariwal1510
      @faisaldhariwal1510 Před 5 lety +17

      Actually I must agree, as a British lover of all things USA, I love the 1911, the 45 Colt SAA, the Harley 45 and of course, 45rpm records- its a really important number

    • @chrismacdowell3381
      @chrismacdowell3381 Před 5 lety +3

      Sawtooth Munitions .45 likes. Sweet.

    • @DrSimeonHill808
      @DrSimeonHill808 Před 5 lety +3

      I love 45. +p aluminum supersonice $$ but crazy can custom make.

  • @frogdude21XXX
    @frogdude21XXX Před 4 lety +65

    I served in the 80's, and I was there for the transition to the M9. I was unimpressed with the performance of the 9mm, in FMJ form. A lot of folks say the newer bullet tech makes the 9 as good as the .45acp. What they fail to consider, is that that same technology is also being used in .45 ammo. I carry a .45acp pistol to this day, although I've transitioned to a Glock 21SF. I love the 1911, but a 9 round capacity seems inadequate in today's whiz-bang gizmo age. Both my Springfield 1911A1, and the Glock 21 have been 100% reliable in my hands, so that's not a factor in my decision. I would trust either piece with my life. It's just that with a factory Glock 21 mag holds 13+1, plus I carry two 17 rounders. so 48 rounds in three mags. it would take six 8 rd 1911 mags to have the same capacity. (Glock apologist 😂🤣✌🐸)

    • @liamkisbee8117
      @liamkisbee8117 Před 4 lety +9

      Bro. 1911 para ordenance for 45 acp also you can get double stack 1911 in 10mm. They even have 460 rowland turns a 1911 into a pocket howitzer. 460 rowland touches .44 magnum ballistics.
      1911 best hand gun ever made.

    • @chrisnorris9473
      @chrisnorris9473 Před 4 lety

      N45autohasmoreknokdownpowerthen9mm

    • @outtathehouse5293
      @outtathehouse5293 Před 4 lety +7

      when a 9mm HP fails it becomes a FMJ. When a 45acp fails its still a 45acp FMJ

    • @frogdude21XXX
      @frogdude21XXX Před 3 lety +1

      I wish, but WAY outta my price range!

    • @gameragodzilla
      @gameragodzilla Před 3 lety +7

      @@chrisnorris9473 There's actually a study called the Joint Agency Defensive Handgun Ballistics Test or something along those lines that tested various different types of rounds on a variety of different mediums. The conclusion was that .45ACP hollow points, on average, had a 50% larger permanent wound cavity than 9mm hollow points, and .45ACP hollow points also had the least degradation when going through barriers and the like (meaning it was the most reliable at expansion, too).
      So basically, three rounds of 9mm is equivalent to two rounds of .45ACP, with the .45ACP being more likely to expand, too. Therefore, a 13+1 round capacity .45 Glock 21 actually has more firepower than a 17+1 round capacity 9mm Glock 17. 14/2=7 while 18/3=6. Even a 10 round extended magazine on a .45 single stack 1911 is equivalent to a 15 round capacity 9mm. 10/2=5 while 15/3=5.
      And, of course, there's also the fact that even though the .45 is more reliable expanding than 9mm, in the event neither expand, the .45 still has a PWC that's 60% larger. So the axiom "a 9mm may expand but a .45 will never shrink" is also true.

  • @429supercj
    @429supercj Před 5 lety +77

    I love the .45 and I love history. This was a great little history lesson. Thank you.

    • @devontaenash1409
      @devontaenash1409 Před 3 lety +2

      I want to like your post but I want you to get .45 likes.

  • @bdr32965
    @bdr32965 Před 5 lety +54

    Let us give thanks to two great men, John Moses Browning for the .45 ACP and Jeff Cooper for 10mm

  • @lynheydt3304
    @lynheydt3304 Před 4 lety +3

    I like the way you explain the difference with a tennis racket and a sledgehammer. That pretty much sums it up.

  • @ninocatacutan2779
    @ninocatacutan2779 Před 3 lety +9

    Ive heard this story about the 45cal being created to knockdown the Moros in the southern Philippines and now that you’ve mentioned it, that story has been confirmed. Legend has it that they were actually using some spiritual powers to endure bullet wounds or even evade bullets in the first place. Your gun history series is very informative and enjoyable. Thank you and shoutout from the Philippines.

  • @garybivens3236
    @garybivens3236 Před 5 lety +80

    I have always loved the 45 and always called it a slow moving brick wall

  • @bhanna1975
    @bhanna1975 Před 5 lety +71

    I am & will always be a .45 ACP man, the 1911-A1 has been my cary gun for about 28 years

    • @michaelbyrneskiai
      @michaelbyrneskiai Před 5 lety +2

      I'm sure you are the baddest ass at the PTA and soccer mom gatherings

    • @timothyterrell1658
      @timothyterrell1658 Před 5 lety +1

      When chambered in the 1911 platform 40 cal is very much comparable to the 45 acp round as to energy and knock down ability. As current loading available.
      With a benefit of a little longer range.
      The usual line of pistols available for it, short barrels and lighter weight make it a poor performer. This is not a fault of the cartridge but rather a fault of the Gun design.

    • @blacktophemirt8526
      @blacktophemirt8526 Před 5 lety +1

      @TrustkillProductionz (i ask this out of curriosity not contradiction)why does it wear guns out? im new to pistols ive always been a rifle guy

    • @repetitivemotion
      @repetitivemotion Před 5 lety

      blacktop hemi R/T The pressure that a 40 cal generates is higher than 45 or 9 mm so it cycles the gun harder and creates more stress on the parts.

    • @repetitivemotion
      @repetitivemotion Před 5 lety +2

      Ben Hanna How do you hold your pants up?

  • @marsrizzo2854
    @marsrizzo2854 Před 5 lety +100

    My brother works as a trauma nurse on the Mexican border has daily gun shot victims.The two round they all pretty much die from are 45acp and 357 mag.

    • @LegallyArmedAmerica
      @LegallyArmedAmerica  Před 5 lety +19

      mars rizzo interesting!

    • @marsrizzo2854
      @marsrizzo2854 Před 5 lety +12

      He told me the sheriffs want to go back to there GP 100 in 357 mag get rid of the 40s

    • @michaelbyrneskiai
      @michaelbyrneskiai Před 5 lety +4

      The ones that get hit if they get hit.

    • @Nobody-xh5qe
      @Nobody-xh5qe Před 5 lety +8

      357 Sig is the way to go

    • @maximusjoseppi5904
      @maximusjoseppi5904 Před 5 lety +7

      @@Nobody-xh5qe ya, thats a good round. i prefer 45 super though.. just as powerful, doesnt require special guns, and puts a bigger hole. just throw it in you favorite .45 and rock on

  • @williameastman9498
    @williameastman9498 Před 5 lety +4

    Tennis racket vs sledge hammer = Best damn illustration of stopping power on CZcams!
    Some folks i.e. 9mm fanboys, like to argue that "stopping power" doesn't exist but if a 45 caliber bullet hits a target with more foot pounds of energy than a 9mm bullet then it logically will have a greater energy dump into the target, assuming of course both are well designed expanding hollow points.

  • @ernestpaul2484
    @ernestpaul2484 Před 4 lety +12

    There are several departments using the Glock 21 in .45. I had always been a fan of the .45 and a Wilson Combat Commander was my carry gun back in the 80's and 90's. The sheriff's department I was at as a deputy went from P89 Rugers to the Glock 21. It was one of the best out of the box POI and POA pistols I had ever fired.

  • @Moderator_user
    @Moderator_user Před 2 lety +5

    I recently bought a Glock 21 I will say it’s one of my favorite handguns wish I could’ve got into this handgun when I entered the gun world.

  • @eboydell1
    @eboydell1 Před 5 lety +2

    I am 65 yrs. old, and have collected and shot guns since I was 14 yrs. old. The 1911/.45 acp is my favorite gun and round. I have more 1911s than I like to admit. However, in the last two years, I have discovered the 10 mm. I remembered the media failure of the "Bren Ten" and little else. So I purchased a Colt 1911, Delta Elite in 10 mm, and was extremely happy with the results. However, as in all of my guns, I am not going to carry a nice pistol, and have sweat, and use just wear the finish off. To remedy this problem, I purchased a Springfield MDX 5.25 inch barrel in 10 mm. Now I have a finish which will not be effected by body sweat and daily use, but is 10 mm with a 15 round magazine. I highly recommend it. The 10 mm will stop all "doped up animals" in their tracks when they attempt to rob & kill you.

  • @williamthehuntsman
    @williamthehuntsman Před 2 lety +3

    I have always loved the .45acp. Don't get me wrong, i like anything that goes pew pew, but ever since shooting my great grandfather's 1911A1, I have just been in love with the caliber. I have carried a .45acp for about 4 years now in the G21 and I don't regret the purchase.

  • @jtd3d351
    @jtd3d351 Před 4 lety +50

    The 1911 is THE best looking pistol ever made in my eyes.

  • @tomhecht6068
    @tomhecht6068 Před 3 lety +4

    The hole made by a .45acp is 50% larger by area than a 9mm. Multiply that by the depth of the wound and that's a lot more lost tissue. If you use ball ammo to insure an exit wound you have a really devastating wound. Browning was a genius, I'm not going to second guess him.

  • @jagerdergroe8604
    @jagerdergroe8604 Před 5 lety +15

    45 ACP is my favorite cartridge, My first gun is going to be a 1911 in 45 ACP and I hope I'm able to buy it soon!

  • @knightshift8714
    @knightshift8714 Před 4 lety +3

    It might be just me but I've grown real fawn to the 40 , power of the 45 (with greater range) with capacity of a 9 (with much greater power hp/fmj doesn't matter) putting the 40 in a carbine your shooting 10mm velocities! (Magnum! Force!!) I hear people complain about recoil but I don't even feel the recoil anymore I think the 9 is snappier and the 45 hits my hand harder, the 40 is right in between (even price wise) and a good compromise imo. When I was a kid I felt the twisty/snappy recoil of 40 but with training and age I guess I've grown to it. Hell I feel my 380 mouse guns kick harder then 40s. But still no matter what hats off and much respect to the 45s as I feel it was the Cal that paved the way to just about everything... And shout outs to the cult 45s/357/38/3030/black powders as well... Respects! ✊😎

  • @fee_lo8346
    @fee_lo8346 Před 5 lety +24

    I like the 45 ACP hallow points for big shallow wounds. A nice HSTs that open up to .75 inches and penetrates about 14 inches... perfect for an apartment building or something or something like that... as long as you don’t miss 😳.

    • @pinslayer4579
      @pinslayer4579 Před 5 lety +5

      @Brad Roberts weird as it is the 9mm folks are ALWAYS bragging about the high capacity of their Tupperware tacital blocks........ya wouldn't think a good marksman would need 20 rounds..........

    • @anthonyioane4438
      @anthonyioane4438 Před 5 lety

      @@pinslayer4579 fudd.

    • @leelizardwilcox6271
      @leelizardwilcox6271 Před 5 lety

      @@pinslayer4579 ya would think those with a 45 acp could actually hit their target alas they cant they think the sound of a 45 will kill all attackers while they toss lead down rangfe and dont hit shit, must be why they made double stack 45 for people like you that cant hit shit.

    • @fredrickmillstead6397
      @fredrickmillstead6397 Před 4 lety +1

      RVN 69-70 carried a 1911a1 and still do to this day. Effective and intimidating.

  • @extremelyrightwingmexicani6948

    Good Ol' 230 grain hardball.

  • @mikewilliams8151
    @mikewilliams8151 Před 4 lety +4

    I still carry a 45 ACP for the last 35 years. Have 1911 made in 1913. Tried the plastic guns, to light. Love the iron for recoil control and use as defense club

  • @noelr2502
    @noelr2502 Před 5 lety +5

    Great video. I just got a S&W M&P 45 2.0 in FDE for my new carry gun. 45ACP has always given me a sense of security just from the historical performance. Yes 9mm has improved, but it still doesn't weigh 230 grains.

  • @OGsDangerShow
    @OGsDangerShow Před 5 lety +15

    BIG fan of the .45 for off duty carry. Or the 11mm for those of you in Canada, America’s hat.
    OG, the Taufledermaus Channel

  • @guardianminifarm8005
    @guardianminifarm8005 Před 5 lety +11

    Outstanding. We are watching these as a family. The old guy & children as young as 7. Teen children get to hear another voice with more info saying the same things. We sure appreciate this. Looking forward to new tech.
    My adult children chosing ccw has been an interesting journey. 9mm & 45acp. I am a 40, 45, 10 guy.

    • @LegallyArmedAmerica
      @LegallyArmedAmerica  Před 5 lety +1

      Guardian Minifarm thank you and your whole family! I wish you all the best and a great 2019!

  • @RegularGunGuy
    @RegularGunGuy Před 5 lety +89

    John Browning called it the Fist of the Lord!

  • @MarineReconinDe
    @MarineReconinDe Před 4 lety +3

    I enlisted in 1987. At the time, the 1911 was still in use but being phased out of being the standard issue sidearm. I shot both the Colt 1911 and the 9mm, the 9mm is trash. Jamming issues, slides breaking, no stopping power. Which is why my go to and my personal sidearm will always be a .45 ACP.

  • @P_Tree
    @P_Tree Před 3 lety +3

    My dad was a airborne ranger so I grew up on .45s and he always told me I only have to hit someone once with that .45 and they're going down and most likely wont make it. And that's what I was trained with so I know how to use it!

  • @hacksskillsmods8916
    @hacksskillsmods8916 Před 5 lety +10

    Happy New Year! Great video. I've shot a 1991 .45 for 20 years now, I bought my first .45 and never looked back. I have found the 1911 in .45 ACP to be accurate out to 100 yards, I've shot it in IPSC, trained with it for self defense and shot it long distance. I see no reason from a self defense stand point to have anything else. Mr Browning and Mr Cooper were both geniuses ahead of there time.

    • @WALTERBROADDUS
      @WALTERBROADDUS Před 5 lety +1

      Well, the cons..... dated, parts heavy, low capacity. Not adjustable for small or left hands. Unsafe, single action design for duty use. Needs tuning to work well. Today, there are simpler actions, lighter in weight with more capacity.

    • @devontaenash1409
      @devontaenash1409 Před 3 lety

      @@WALTERBROADDUS unsafe my ass . They had a cop that drop his m1911 and the broke off and it still didn't fire.

    • @WALTERBROADDUS
      @WALTERBROADDUS Před 3 lety

      @@devontaenash1409 A statistical data point of one gun. One time.

  • @johnhale9686
    @johnhale9686 Před 5 lety +21

    America has a love affair with the 45 ACP. At the time of the 45 ACP introduction it was pretty powerful. Time has moved on there has been improvements in bullets, powder as well as totally new cartridges have been created(375 mag, 40 S&W,10 mm, 44 mag ). actually the 45ACP is about as powerful as a 44 spl. All semi auto cartridges are compromised rounds to fit the grip.

    • @glenn1035
      @glenn1035 Před 5 lety +4

      John Hale
      Get Buffalo Bore +P 45ACP 230gr 950fps and drop a 22 pound Wolff recoil spring in your 1911 (be sure its a quality piece not $300 foreign sweat shop junk)

  • @matthewwilliams6596
    @matthewwilliams6596 Před 5 lety +35

    Whats wrong with testing rounds like that? Testing rounds is technically science and if the person donated their body to science then its all good. Just dont go dig up dead bodies.

    • @blacktophemirt8526
      @blacktophemirt8526 Před 5 lety +10

      death row inmates can be useful for once.im sure gassing is expensive

    • @anthonycoffey816
      @anthonycoffey816 Před 4 lety +6

      @@blacktophemirt8526 right? Plenty of rapists & child molesters out there that would do the job 😅

    • @cerberaodollam
      @cerberaodollam Před 3 lety

      I want my gsw anyway so... Volunteering

  • @gonzalez519
    @gonzalez519 Před 5 lety +7

    Fun Fact: The star in the Cuban flag 🇨🇺 was supposed to represent the 51st state of the United States of America.
    Yes, we Cubans were a state of the USA 🇺🇸 although for a very short period of time.
    After the United States seized Cuba from Spain during the Spanish-American War, the Stars and Stripes flew from January 1, 1899, until May 20, 1902, when the Cuban national flag was hoisted as a symbol of independence and sovereignty. It has been used ever since.
    Btw i was the 1K like on this video. 😅👍

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +1

    This is one of the best gun channels.

  • @odeituazon3967
    @odeituazon3967 Před 4 lety +2

    This is a proper history lesson about .45 ACP. 👍🙏

  • @HomemConservador
    @HomemConservador Před 5 lety +24

    Love your analogy: "tennis racket and sledgehammer"!!! I'm .45 guy... I trust my life in my G30S!

    • @michaelbyrneskiai
      @michaelbyrneskiai Před 5 lety

      When you don't put yourself in harm's way it doesn't matter what you trust your life to so get your old ass back on that porch you rocking chair operator.

    • @HomemConservador
      @HomemConservador Před 5 lety

      Michael Byrnes excuse me but do I know you, Mr? I have been in the Navy for 25 year... by your language you should be very brave behind a keyboard.

    • @michaelbyrneskiai
      @michaelbyrneskiai Před 5 lety

      @@HomemConservador lol Navy

    • @HomemConservador
      @HomemConservador Před 5 lety +2

      Michael Byrnes www.defesaaereanaval.com.br/piloto-brasileiro-de-super-lynx-voa-no-wildcat/
      Now go back to your hot milk and cookies, spoiled kid!

    • @plagedh3
      @plagedh3 Před 5 lety +2

      @@michaelbyrneskiai lol u got owned pretty bad bro

  • @danlarsen7572
    @danlarsen7572 Před 5 lety +28

    In my opinion the 45 is still King

    • @jonc2914
      @jonc2914 Před 5 lety

      Dan Larsen tokarev, game over

    • @33fastcar
      @33fastcar Před 4 lety +2

      Me too! The only time I don't have my 45acp on my side is when I have my 44mag there in its place. PERIOD! I can shoot my guns anytime I want. I just walk outside & shoot! Did I mention I live in the middle of our 7K acre ranch in Texas?
      I don't know how I managed in the big city for 35+ years? I did buy a shit ton of guns when living there. I like living in the same house my gun safe is kept. Not 60 miles away in the big city. I've always had the ranch house but I was waiting to retire before moving out in the sticks for good. I retired last August & I can't believe a whole year has passed! I've only bought 4 guns in the last year... I've been busy playing on the ranch! You should see my shooting range. There is a whole living room set in the firing position. No TV or radio to dampen the mood. Just LOTS of FREEDOM, ammo & things to shoot.

    • @TheRealZJE313
      @TheRealZJE313 Před 4 lety

      Yes especially if you have that new Winchester Ranger ammo. It's the new version of the black talons

  • @Tadicuslegion78
    @Tadicuslegion78 Před 5 lety +30

    I know I know, 9mm is king and all, superior engineering, capacity, better recoil blah blah blah. And yet I still choose to use .45 acp because it just works.

    • @jamesslick4790
      @jamesslick4790 Před 4 lety +7

      9mm is a fun round, and it's cheap (relatively) But bigger IS bigger. I don't CARE about long range (that's what rifles are for). For a handgun a close interpersonal engagement needs to be ended quick. Hard to argue with .45 ACP in that role. Save the 9 mike mike for the range. .357Mag in revolvers or .45ACP in an a pistol are for WORK.

    • @liamkisbee8117
      @liamkisbee8117 Před 4 lety +3

      A 45 acp can kill a man at 400 yards, 1911s can be modified to fire the 460 rowland which gives you .44 magnum ballistics in a 1911. Its a 110 year old war horse and still bosses modern pistols. Acurracy and reliability with a round the size of a musket ball.

    • @scottwest9299
      @scottwest9299 Před 4 lety

      James Slick , go check ammoseek. The 9mm has became more expensive than .45. It’s absolutely hilarious to see that argument killed. (Every time I share this some asshole 9mm wiener has a meltdown, so just be ready for it. )

    • @Revolverguy38
      @Revolverguy38 Před rokem +1

      @@jamesslick4790 I agree

    • @RobP-fd6lj
      @RobP-fd6lj Před rokem

      Shoot placement

  • @chuckfults9256
    @chuckfults9256 Před 5 lety +2

    I don't care what anyone says about ALL the other pistol caliber rounds out today BUT the 230 grain full metal jacket.45acp cartridge IS without a doubt the BEST stopping round out PERIOD! You can stop a 250lb Samoan dead in his tracks just satin! Long live John Moses Browning! His Fist of the Lord STILL WORKS even today!

    • @anthonyioane4438
      @anthonyioane4438 Před 5 lety

      Bullshit. 357 or 44 magnum or even proper 10mm ia superior in stopping power.

    • @chuckfults9256
      @chuckfults9256 Před 5 lety +1

      YEAH but, I'll take 20 cents a round .45acp any day WINNING!

    • @anthonyioane4438
      @anthonyioane4438 Před 5 lety +1

      @@chuckfults9256 Yeah that's bad if your using ball ammo for self defense XD. BUT WHATEVER works for you.

    • @chuckfults9256
      @chuckfults9256 Před 5 lety

      You get hit with a subsonic 230 grain chuck of metal, you are goin Down just sayin! Not bad for over a century old technology just sayin! You're just as dead!

    • @anthonyioane4438
      @anthonyioane4438 Před 5 lety

      @@chuckfults9256 You get hit with 124 or 115 grain or anything you are going to die if you are not in a vital organ.

  • @montanamountainmen6104
    @montanamountainmen6104 Před 5 lety +4

    The Army at the time still used horses. They wanted a modern day handgun of the same stopping power as the 45 Colt revolver. Seems the old timers were quite smart today we still use the 45 and are now dumping the 5.56 , because you know the old timers said it won't do as expected. Wallah, 50 odd years later they figured that out too, shoulda listened in the beginning.
    Pistols were never to be used as long range weapons , they were for contact distances of 50 yards or less. Why would you try to engage a adversary at 100 yards with a pistol when your primary firearm is a rifle.

    • @leelizardwilcox6271
      @leelizardwilcox6271 Před 5 lety

      were definitely not dumping a 556 anytime soon certainly not within the next several decades.

    • @montanamountainmen6104
      @montanamountainmen6104 Před 5 lety

      @@leelizardwilcox6271 Well I read the Army is changing calibers the 5.56 will no longer be the standard. It will be the 6.5 Grendel.

  • @thomasknight9896
    @thomasknight9896 Před 5 lety +2

    I carried the 1911 for 25+ years in the Army,three tours in VN as a combat medic. When I deployed to Saudi we were ordered to turn in our 1911s and draw the Berreta 9mm. Almost cried all the way to Saudi! The 9mm with modern loads and bullets is much better weapon,in 1990 in the Army we drew FMJ! Hated that.

  • @MTMILITIAMAN7.62
    @MTMILITIAMAN7.62 Před 4 lety +2

    The year the .45 ACP was dethroned wasn't 1985 but 1983, when the 10mm Auto came out. The 10mm Auto was developed in partnership with Retired Marine Col Jeff Cooper, who is often credited with modernizing combat handgunning, and was a huge fan of the .45 ACP and the 1911. He recognized the cartridge is not perfect, and stepped up to lend his experience with the .45 ACP in development of the 10mm Auto. Everything the .45 can do, the 10mm can do better.

    • @MidnightSvn
      @MidnightSvn Před rokem

      Col. Jeff Cooper ultimately abandoned 10mm citing, after extensive testing, 10mm "showed no advantage in performance to 45 acp under 60 yards" and followed his conclusion that handgun shootouts never even occur even close to 60 yards, but far closer, so he dismissed the very idea of 10mm as not realistic/practical.

    • @MTMILITIAMAN7.62
      @MTMILITIAMAN7.62 Před rokem

      @J A Well Cooper is demonstrably wrong on this. The FBI's own testing in 1987 showed the 10mm was conclussively superior to the other rounds tested, including the .45 ACP.
      And having seen multiple animals killed with .45, 10mm, and .357, I can assure you, the 10mm is better than both the others. My grandparents have rural property, where they have culled one or two deer a month for decades. Having taken hundreds of deer with all sorts of different cartridges, the 10mm is absolutely better than the .45 ACP. The .45 ACP doesn't have the ass to drive a heavy for caliber, high sectional density bullet deep into the vitals with enough remaining velocity to expand in the thoracic cavity. The 10mm does. The .45 does all its expansion within the first few inches of penetration, so by the time it reaches deep enough in the chest to reach large cardiovascular structures, it has settled down and produces a relatively narrow, uncomplicated wound. The 10mm still has enough velocity behind a 180 or 200 gr XTP for it to still be deforming much deeper in the chest, so not only is the total penetration greater, the depth of the active body of the permanent crush cavity where the bullet is expanding and deforming, and is actually ripping and tearing tissue, is about twice as deep as .45 ACP loads. The 10mm is much more effective at killing shit than the .45 ACP. Not just a little. A significant margin. The .357 Magnum comes close to the 10mm. The .45, not so much.

  • @OGsDangerShow
    @OGsDangerShow Před 5 lety +24

    An instructor of mine once posed the scenario; “you’re in a room and five Taliban are about to run in through the door. You can have any pistol with only five rounds, which do you choose?” 45 was the unanimous choice.

    • @stevemoore8646
      @stevemoore8646 Před 5 lety +4

      My 500 magnum

    • @timothyterrell1658
      @timothyterrell1658 Před 5 lety +3

      Simple choice 44 mag Da 4 inch barrel. Hollow points. If you can handle it. It is not very easy to use but very effective.

    • @timothyterrell1658
      @timothyterrell1658 Před 5 lety +3

      @@stevemoore8646 if you are able to control it. ,That will work just fine .Unfortunately most can't control the beast. The 45 is hard for many to control. It is not a good choice if you can't keep it under control.

    • @jacobmccandles1767
      @jacobmccandles1767 Před 5 lety +3

      The instructor rigger the question. Do you know of any 5-shot snubbies in .45 ACP? Me either.
      If I have to face 5 armed men, I'd better be able to get multiple hits on target, fast. I'd also better not be aiming for precise 5 for 5 hits...and I want all the ammo on board I can get!
      I'm a 9/40/10mm/45 fan, but I thing I'd like an FN 5-7 in this scenario.

    • @OGsDangerShow
      @OGsDangerShow Před 5 lety +3

      Jacob McCandles
      I think the point of the exercise was you only having five total rounds in a pistol. Your choice, 5 shot snubbie, 5 shot 9mm auto, 5 shot 45 auto etc. Not sure I’d bet my life on five rounds of needle-thin 5.7.

  • @TSideWes805
    @TSideWes805 Před 5 lety +2

    From blowing off Gangsters head in the Prohibition Era, to sawing down Japanese infantry units during WWII, this .45 ACP round has put to rest millions of humans.

  • @samanthabaker6033
    @samanthabaker6033 Před 5 lety +1

    The word he was looking for and could never say is kinetic energy.

  • @jalan8171
    @jalan8171 Před 4 lety +4

    Paul Harrell's 'meat target' tests eat your heart out given this Pre-WW1 routine of testing!

  • @jensenmiller6410
    @jensenmiller6410 Před 4 lety +4

    "I didn't know a man existed that couldn't be stopped by a slug from a .45"

  • @littlerougue
    @littlerougue Před 5 lety +5

    I agree the .45 is very manageable as far as recoil goes

  • @andrewwash8005
    @andrewwash8005 Před 4 lety +6

    My Dad was a medic (WWII, Korea, Vietnam). They trained by having a sheep or hog shot through the organs and then they had to treat the gunshot and preserve life. Going to war it is better to test on an animal then just have theory and end up in a combat zone.

  • @arlenebuaya6641
    @arlenebuaya6641 Před 5 lety +2

    Here in the Philippines .45 acp is the caliber of choice by most if not all motorcycle assassins...more effective evidently than the easily available 9mm(service caliber of PI military and LE officers).

  • @frankberst9849
    @frankberst9849 Před 5 lety +3

    The 45 ACP and 357 Magnum still reign supreme, no doubt about it. 40 S&W is also a very effective round, and the 10mm is downright vicious. However, if given the choice, l personally would never trust my life to a 9mm. Ever.

  • @Uberragen21
    @Uberragen21 Před 3 lety +2

    I absolutely love these history lesson videos. I'm a huge history buff, so there's that.
    Thank you for feeding my need!

  • @ADRay1999
    @ADRay1999 Před 5 lety +91

    My favorite Cartridge (.45 ACP)
    *THANK YOU JOHN MOSES BROWNING*
    🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
    Fun fact: the .45 acp cartridge was originally for the Browning/Colt Model 1905

    • @Average_olive_oil_enjoyer
      @Average_olive_oil_enjoyer Před 5 lety +10

      T W O W O R L D W A R S

    • @Schwarzvogel1
      @Schwarzvogel1 Před 5 lety +14

      @@Average_olive_oil_enjoyer The same can be said of 9x19mm, .303 British, 8x57mm, and when it comes to 7.92x54R... it's the oldest cartridge still in military use today. Still, what I really am grateful to Mr Browning for is the M1911 itself, Browning A5, and the M2 (although the first two are a lot easier for me to get my hands on than the latter, as I don't work for Uncle Sam).
      Pistols (and even rifles) don't win wars, but compared to contemporary designs, the M1911 was leaps and bounds ahead of most other autoloading designs available in the early 20th century. A fun fact: Rambo helped improved the design of the M1911. (A civilian named Marcellus Rambo, that is!)
      The funny thing about the most innovative and influential firearm designers in history is that virtually _none_ of them were infantrymen, and only one (Mikhail Kalashnikov) was actually a soldier, and he was a tanker. Only John Moses Browning was actually a gunsmith by trade. Eugene Stoner was an aerospace engineer; Hiram Maxim was a bicycle mechanic, etc. I guess that goes to show that you don't need to be a doorkicking, pipe-hitting Tier 1 operator to know something about guns! And in our age of tacticool beards, tattoos, shaved heads, and foul language, we shouldn't automatically discount the opinions of those who don't have military backgrounds when it comes to designing effective firearms.

    • @tonyrousseau473
      @tonyrousseau473 Před 5 lety +5

      @Brad Roberts I would not say it won the war or was carried by few, speaking of WWII the american solider & the garand won the war, however 1.9 Million M1911's were procured by the military during WWII, so I would not say they were few in numbers, so saying "it didn't win shit" when it was present & in use by many, makes you sound like an idiot who makes a three word post with the CAP'S LOCK ON!

    • @owenchismar1858
      @owenchismar1858 Před 5 lety +2

      The .45 ACP matches the velocity and energy, as well as the bullet weight of the .45 Scoffield (S&W) revolver cartridge. I don't know if John Browning was aware of that, or even knew it, when he designed the .45 ACP.

    • @MultiDryder
      @MultiDryder Před 5 lety

      Just curious with modern age and fact that 10mm is better why not 10mm

  • @FilthyAmerican
    @FilthyAmerican Před 4 lety +2

    Mort crew here you would be amazed at the testing still being done on cadavers.

  • @archiveseeker
    @archiveseeker Před 5 lety +19

    I have a Beretta 92FS, Springfield .40, and a Para 1911. The .45 is my favorite!

    • @joshuasmith6346
      @joshuasmith6346 Před 4 lety

      I have an hk usp 45 and Its beautiful

    • @cecilpotter1229
      @cecilpotter1229 Před 4 lety

      I have P 14 P 12 best shooting guns I have ever shot and I have shot every thing

    • @thatguy4087
      @thatguy4087 Před 4 lety

      You poor things have never shot a Glock. Lol

  • @JamesLee-sq2cx
    @JamesLee-sq2cx Před 5 lety +51

    Never travel without a.45 ACP
    ALTHOUGH THIS IS HORRIBLY REDUNDANT.
    I’m not leaving home without it.
    At home......Shotgun fan😉😘

    • @boondocker7964
      @boondocker7964 Před 5 lety +1

      See? You know what to have ready.

    • @zarinkai2927
      @zarinkai2927 Před 5 lety +2

      Have fun being deaf once you let off that canon indoors.

    • @sitdowndogbreath
      @sitdowndogbreath Před 5 lety +2

      @@zarinkai2927 I'm already hard of hearing so what's the damn difference

    • @anihtgenga4096
      @anihtgenga4096 Před 5 lety +1

      Just don't take it to Mexico. Not even a cartridge. Trust me.

    • @whitefx2
      @whitefx2 Před 5 lety

      Yup don't take ammo, not even a spend casing to Mexico

  • @freshfowler1398
    @freshfowler1398 Před 5 lety +19

    Ahhh...The good ole days!! Excellent stuff Paul!!👍🙏🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @jalan8171
    @jalan8171 Před 4 lety +1

    The argument of small caliber with high velocity vs. large caliber with lower velocity goes back before the Ackley - Keith debates of the 1930's. As the shooting skill level of recruits dropped considerably after the Vietnam War ( 'conflict', hell! for those that were sent over to south east asia, it was WAR), the Army and other services recognized that it required less training (particularly for the officers) to put a lower recoil handgun into the hands of relatively lesser gun experience soldiers. Also, since our allies (NATO) utilized the 9x19 as standard issue ammo, it made logistical sense for the switch to the 9mm Luger ammo.

  • @leedonald2336
    @leedonald2336 Před 5 lety +7

    I carry a glock 21 and love it and have many 1911s, love a .45 acp round

  • @Klocaine237
    @Klocaine237 Před 5 lety +16

    loving the channel. cant wait for the next one. keep them coming brother.

  • @k4vms
    @k4vms Před 5 lety +2

    Good presentation but, do some additional fact checking. .45 ACP 220 grain defense ammo in +P has a muzzle velocity of 990 FPS, a big chunk of jacketed hollow point lead moving very fast. Close to 9mm 147 grain chunk of jacketed hollow point in terms of FPS. .45 ACP when it comes to defensive calibers has the greatest Cenetic knock down power, 2nd in Cenetic energy next to the top end 10mm. Reguardless of the platform, i.e. 1911, Glock 21, Glock 30, etc. The .45ACP creates hydrostatic shock to the human body besides the devastating temporary and permanent wound cavities which is the destruction of tissue. Lookup the meaning of hydrostatic shock.
    My personal favorite platform is a 1911.

    • @leelizardwilcox6271
      @leelizardwilcox6271 Před 5 lety

      NO HANDGUN WILL EVER GENERATE ENOUGH ENERGY to KNOCK SOMEONE DOWN if it did the SHOOTER WOULD GET KNOCKED DOWN as well. for every action theres an equal and opposite reaction

    • @k4vms
      @k4vms Před 5 lety

      lol lol It does not literally knock them down, that's just a descriptive term. It has enough Cenetic energy to cause hydrostatic shock which will cause the body to start shutting down.
      Research hydrostatic shock. Wound cavities, shot placement(which may cause bleeding out) along with hydrostatic shock is knock down power

  • @byronomboy
    @byronomboy Před 3 lety +2

    I’m from the Philippines and glad Moro fighters were mentioned as the inspiration to the “Yankee Fist”.

  • @ShimomuraTakezoWong
    @ShimomuraTakezoWong Před 5 lety +8

    Can't agree more with you, always prefer .45ACP

  • @papotaino1516
    @papotaino1516 Před 4 lety +1

    Nothing better than my 1911 acp45 fell In love with it while in the USMC

  • @TheDroc1990
    @TheDroc1990 Před 5 lety +22

    Was waiting for this one!

  • @calvinlong1265
    @calvinlong1265 Před 4 lety +2

    Mass equals force times acceleration. . . It makes perfect sense to me that a 45 loaded with ball ammunition would be much more effective than a 38 long Colt loaded with FMJ's.

  • @MrExplorer1965
    @MrExplorer1965 Před 4 lety +2

    Slow and heavy always works.
    Read a story from a sniper that said his 7.62 bullets actually worked better on enemy combatants after it came out of super sonic speed and slowed down.
    Hell, until quality hollow points were designed for the 9mm luger, it was considered a horrible combat cartridge because it was going so fast at handgun ranges, that it just past through.....
    The 45 ACP has, and always will, work.

  • @tootired76
    @tootired76 Před 2 lety +1

    Everyone seems to forget that the .45 ACP is the best round for use with a suppressor! It doesn't go supersonic so there is no additional snap or noise!

  • @SlytigerSurvival
    @SlytigerSurvival Před 5 lety +4

    I like the .40 best, and 9mm. Penicillin was a great gift. My grandpa’s dad died from something a simple penicillin dose would fix. Polio vaccines were great too. Let’s hope someone can cure cancer.

  • @brandonsmancave554
    @brandonsmancave554 Před 4 lety +2

    Forsure learned something about my favorite caliber today 💪🏽 45ACP!

  • @wastool
    @wastool Před 5 lety +6

    9:16 There are still a lot of law enforcement agencies which still use 45acp as standard issue.

  • @classicgunstoday1972
    @classicgunstoday1972 Před 3 lety +2

    To this day, I still see peace officers in Texas, young and old, carrying the 1911 .45 ACP. From Texas Rangers trickling down to Sheriff deputies to Houston Police to small town police.
    Not everybody, of course, not even majority but quite a few. Not uncommon to see. Rangers loved it since it came out in 1911

  • @tanman7879
    @tanman7879 Před 5 lety +8

    Good stuff man. Loving your channel keep it up.

  • @shadowsfad3d
    @shadowsfad3d Před 5 lety +31

    .45 is a man stopper period. ..no need to say anything else.

    • @marco_marks
      @marco_marks Před 5 lety +2

      .45 is a pistol bullet with all the limitations of one see "Why one cop carries 147 bullets"

    • @michaelsmith9308
      @michaelsmith9308 Před 4 lety +2

      Im very comfortable carrying the 45 ACP in ALASKA against bears, in CA against mountain lions and bears, however, some of the bears are very big, make sure you have extra magazines and dont miss the head shots, because a bears claws with one hit alone and your FINISHED!

    • @joshnelson8611
      @joshnelson8611 Před 3 lety

      My pinky could be a man stopper

  • @k.r.v.4219
    @k.r.v.4219 Před 5 lety +1

    There are a lot of tall tales about why the .45 was developed for use in combat. But the most severe and somewhat troublesome came out of the Philippine Jungles and the enemy's desperate use of a terrible way of preparing their fighters. It was widely known the Moro fighters were prepared by having their torso wrapped in long belts of wet leather wrapped tightly, that when dried out would shrink to add protection, however, there was another part of this preparation that's never talked about. That was the practice of using natural plants with hallucinogenic properties, plus wrapping up of the genitals that together drove the fighters into a mad sort of pain-free state of mind over body. That allowed them to not be fazed or stopped by the .38 long cartridge, so the heavy projectile of the .45 ACP, along with the autoloading 1911 Colt Pistol was developed together to do the job of stopping them in an ins!

  • @Schwarzvogel1
    @Schwarzvogel1 Před 5 lety +3

    Happy New Year! One interesting thing about the history of the .45 ACP is the conflict that led to its development was a shameful period in American history. The U.S. should not have decided to emulate the Europeans and colonize the Philippines; quite a few people in the U.S. at the time thought it was a very un-American thing to do. Still, good things can come from bad times...
    I honestly believe though that a lot of adoration for the .45 ACP is largely due to the M1911, which is one of the finest autoloading pistols ever designed. If the round were associated with a pistol that did _not_ work well, I doubt that it would have endured for as long. There are many cartridges that were excellent ideas (e.g. .280 British, .276 Pederson) that never took off because the weapons they were associated with were never adopted for general usage.
    In short, I believe that the .45 ACP is an excellent cartridge, but I do think that it owes its much continued usage to the genius of John Moses Browning in producing what was essentially a near _perfect_ pistol.
    I must ask, though: after the tests, what did they do with all the meat? It seems like a waste to just throw it all away when they were done! I did recall reading somewhere that the Thompson-LaGarde tests actually proved the superiority of the bottlenecked .30 Luger cartridge in some ways (it was the only one on the first day that killed the cattle with one shot). However, the Army was adamant on having a .45-caliber cartridge, so they tinkered a bit with the operational procedures until they got what they wanted.
    That being said, most people on _either_ side of a firearm chambered in .45 ACP haven't complained about the caliber's effectiveness as a man-stopper.

  • @davidschlegel3919
    @davidschlegel3919 Před 5 lety +6

    Damn good video. Glad you’re on Patreon coz I started donating. Keep making great informative videos. Would love to see some history on the .380 round now that my hands aren’t as strong as they used to be and my M&P 380 is my carry weapon.

  • @33fastcar
    @33fastcar Před 4 lety +1

    My favorite side arm is my trusty Smith & Wesson M&P .45ACP.
    I love that pistol & caliber!
    I'm 53 & have collected many pistols over the years. My favorite is still the bad ass .45ACP.
    Automatic Colt Pistol.... ACP...

  • @mikewilliams8151
    @mikewilliams8151 Před 4 lety +1

    I have a 1911 made in 1913. Still shooting it and function is great. Will always carry .45 acp until no longer made

  • @ruggerREL
    @ruggerREL Před 4 lety +2

    5:00 “greatest gun ever made a single action army” ocelot

  •  Před 5 lety +19

    I love the 9x19mm, but I also respect de .45 acp. I can't say the same thing about the .40SW, the "Ducky Calliber", as I use to call it.

    • @MultiDryder
      @MultiDryder Před 5 lety +1

      Agreed and .45 I call .45aarp because I see it as for old people and .40 as .40 short and weak. That's why I'm a 10mm person, better than any of those calibers, more capacity and more modern

    • @timothyterrell1658
      @timothyterrell1658 Před 5 lety +5

      There is nothing wrong with the 40. Round . There is a problem with the guns they make for it. They put it in the guns designed for 9 mm. Which is to small for it.
      The 40 and the 10 mm are appropriate for 1911 sized gun platform. Yet Noone wants that.

    • @MultiDryder
      @MultiDryder Před 5 lety

      @@timothyterrell1658 not in 10mm there are alot of people buying m1911 in 10mm these days especially with how popular caliber is becoming

    • @bernieeod57
      @bernieeod57 Před 5 lety +2

      If you cannot or are not willing to master any of the major calibers, use a 9. Not just the ability to shoot it but to run it. If you cannot operate the slide of a major caliber (.40, .357 SIG, 10MM .45) Then use a 9, No matter how well you can shoot any of the majors

    •  Před 5 lety +1

      @Bernie EOD, I'm sorry but I disagree with you my friend. If the 40 calliber is great but the pistols to shoot ir are piece of shits, so the 40 calliber is a great shit.

  • @dumpstercratsforextinction3493

    At first I thought he was James Hetfield!! Until he started talking!!

  • @SasqueEnchiladaII
    @SasqueEnchiladaII Před 5 lety +2

    Very educational, Mr. Hetfield. Very cool.

  • @zionkid28
    @zionkid28 Před 5 lety +2

    Dude love this little caliber series can’t wait for the tests. Thanks for all you do bro

  • @cw7legionofpewrights596
    @cw7legionofpewrights596 Před 2 lety +1

    I love the 9mm luger and the 45acp. Both great cartridges for their purposes and one thing I like about the 45acp is fun to see holes on paper targets at 25 yards 😂😂

    • @iaidagger8278
      @iaidagger8278 Před rokem

      Both excellent calibres the 45 up to 25yds and up to 100yds tje 9mm!!!

  • @blankeny
    @blankeny Před 4 lety +1

    I love .45 and even own an SBR in .45, as well as four .45 pistols

  • @skinner321
    @skinner321 Před 5 lety +1

    That's the best testing short of "in field".

  • @mikec6892
    @mikec6892 Před 5 lety +12

    Very interesting video. Thanks for sharing.

  • @charlesdang2557
    @charlesdang2557 Před 4 lety

    No need to ask me to hang around for the rest of the series. You got me sold. Fascinating topics

  • @natenrey4601
    @natenrey4601 Před 4 lety +1

    Watching from the Philippines

  • @codyhollis3677
    @codyhollis3677 Před rokem +2

    WE NEED A NATIONAL HOLIDAY FOR JOHN BROWNING

  • @nmr6988
    @nmr6988 Před 5 lety +4

    Great episode. The history of the cartridge in all its forms and calibers is fascinating. I wish i could shoot .45 so my brothers would give me some respect!

    • @timothyterrell1658
      @timothyterrell1658 Před 5 lety +1

      Nancy you can with the right ammo and training.
      Without the training the 45 is a poor choice of hand guns. You have to shoot it to be able to use it. You can't just pick it up and be Anny Oakley. They tend to twist in your hands.

    • @jacobmccandles1767
      @jacobmccandles1767 Před 5 lety

      Timothy Terrell why? Because poor barrier penetration, heavy ammo, heavier guns, and low capacity somehow equal respect?

  • @americanpatriot6918
    @americanpatriot6918 Před 4 lety +3

    New to your channel, just found you today. I watched your 40sw video before this one. Great information! Great way of explaining things and great snip it's of historical information!!🤜🤛🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @billfast
    @billfast Před 5 lety +15

    The 1911 in .45 acp is my choice for a carry gun any day.

  • @rudyrod100
    @rudyrod100 Před 5 lety +2

    I still carry a full size 1911 daily.

  • @madogllewellyn
    @madogllewellyn Před 5 lety +2

    Laws of Physics..... What's more deadly a freight train (.45 ACP) or a car (9mm) ????? .45ACP is still King of pistol ammo.....

  • @jimhill4510
    @jimhill4510 Před 5 lety +1

    The .45 ACP means less rounds, but for military purposes ONLY, you are not going to be using a .45 for long distance shooting. The fact that you would be using it at all, means that the enemy has been able to overwhelm the fire power you are or are not using at the time and it will be close quarter firing.

  • @TheRonjhet
    @TheRonjhet Před 2 lety

    Simplest explanation but it just answers the debate…
    Great presentation, Paul!!!
    And thanks for the history

  • @waynelabeaud7945
    @waynelabeaud7945 Před 5 lety +5

    GREAT INFORMATIVE VIDEO...
    THANKS PAUL

  • @gravesclayton3604
    @gravesclayton3604 Před 4 lety +1

    I have not shot the 1911 .45 auto pistol. But, I have shot many .45 acp rounds with a 1917 Smith & Wesson .45 Revolver, using speed-load clips for the revolver cylinder. I will tell you that the .45 ACP round hits a target very hard with devastating effect at close range. Recoil from the 1917 S&W revolver is also profound: you know you have shot 12 rounds when you are through!

  • @sopmod556mm9
    @sopmod556mm9 Před 5 lety +4

    As always, another accurate and factual video! Happy New Year!