How did the Vikings Discover North America?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 07. 2018
  • Signup for your FREE trial to The Great Courses Plus here: ow.ly/SrTS30kFTkD
    Disclaimer: The Great Courses Plus is currently available to watch through a web browser to almost anyone in the world and optimized for the US, UK and Australian market. The Great Courses Plus is currently working to both optimize the product globally and accept credit card payments globally.
    Patreon: / historywithhilbert
    Music Used:
    Sneaky Snitch - Kevin MacLeod
    The North - Kevin MacLeod
    Rites - Kevin MacLeod
    Þonne Hēo Besīehþ on Mīnum Ēagan - Cefin Beorn
    Lost Frontier - Kevin MacLeod
    "Lost Frontier” - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    Master of the Feast - Kevin MacLeod
    Twitter: / historywhilbert
    Facebook: / historywhilbert
    Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! historywithhilbert@gmail.com

Komentáře • 668

  • @okami9634
    @okami9634 Před 3 lety +93

    I live in Newfoundland (Vinland). There's a place on the west coast called L'Anse aux meadows, which is a preserved Viking settlement and museum. In the summer, it's full of actors dressed in armor, hammering away at the forge, cooking stew, and knitting clothes

  • @elisthortraustason7645
    @elisthortraustason7645 Před 5 lety +63

    I love that someone is finally making videos about vikings in North America. It truly is an underrepresented subject and I wish more people knew of it. You have been doing tremendously good and educational work on this channel! Greetings from Iceland

    • @marneus
      @marneus Před 2 lety

      They should do videos about the Big Foot, keeping with the myth theme.

    • @williamflamholtz5762
      @williamflamholtz5762 Před 2 lety +5

      @@marneus there's nothing mythical about the Norse landing on North America

    • @marneus
      @marneus Před 2 lety

      @@williamflamholtz5762 It's 100 % mythical and based on lies and Germanism. The rune stone was a 70's fake, they have never found human remains in the supposed norse settlements which were actually Basque fisheries. Norse landing is a Nazi lie.

  • @HistoryHouseProductions
    @HistoryHouseProductions Před 5 lety +159

    Norway in EU4 is just lost colonial potential.

    • @nathanboudreau7661
      @nathanboudreau7661 Před 5 lety +10

      History House Productions I tried a colonial game as them a couple of weeks ago but England just kept stealing all my shit

    • @nachteldantes4990
      @nachteldantes4990 Před 5 lety +4

      Morocco is the hidden Gem in colonizing

    • @unacittabizzarraechiassosa4143
      @unacittabizzarraechiassosa4143 Před 5 lety +1

      Japan is where it's at.

    • @unchartedsteppes7138
      @unchartedsteppes7138 Před 5 lety +1

      Nathan you are supposed to conquer Scotland and get an alliance with France (preferably from support independence) to box around england.

    • @gorge2786
      @gorge2786 Před 5 lety

      Una città bizzarra e chiassosa Northumbria my man

  • @user-bi9kj1oh1f
    @user-bi9kj1oh1f Před 5 lety +160

    Fun fact: the first settlers in Iceland were Irish monks.

    • @zoetropo1
      @zoetropo1 Před 5 lety +6

      Testimonium Ignis: Source, please?

    • @user-bi9kj1oh1f
      @user-bi9kj1oh1f Před 5 lety +11

      Zoe Porphyrogenita
      "At that time, Iceland had woods growing between the mountains and the shore. Christians were here then, whom Scandinavians [Norðmenn] call Papar, but then they left, because they did not want to be here alongside heathen people. They left Irish books, bells and croziers, from which one can tell that they were Irishmen"
      en.wikisource.org/wiki/Translation:Íslendingabók
      theconversation.com/viking-beaters-scots-and-irish-may-have-settled-iceland-a-century-before-norsemen-42280
      Here you go

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +21

      Testimonium Ignis If you’re interested:
      czcams.com/video/MZ5Y97NnFQo/video.html

    • @magnusorn7313
      @magnusorn7313 Před 4 lety

      @@user-bi9kj1oh1f or maybe they where second after some other group we dont even know where there yet?

    • @urieluriel715
      @urieluriel715 Před 4 lety +1

      Magnús Örn, Nope, first. There's no trace of any group before them.

  • @tombaugh5286
    @tombaugh5286 Před 5 lety +5

    I LOVE this channel. Always well researched and well made. Thanks!

  • @freshmarex3538
    @freshmarex3538 Před 5 lety +14

    Love the music You use in your videos.

  • @crowsbaneful
    @crowsbaneful Před 5 lety +7

    Thanks for the timing of this video, it's in perfect time with my sulking for not being able to have seen the Draken which is doing a tour currently.

  • @Skittletoff
    @Skittletoff Před 5 lety +8

    Great video Hilbert, you're #1

  • @steffen_of_frisia6789
    @steffen_of_frisia6789 Před 5 lety +9

    Nice video. Always interesting to hear about the history of the norse!

  • @aarn4v
    @aarn4v Před 4 lety +2

    I can't believe I can find such good quality educational content on CZcams that is so underrated!

  • @leornendeealdenglisc
    @leornendeealdenglisc Před 5 lety +3

    Glorious as always, mate! :D

  • @nachteldantes4990
    @nachteldantes4990 Před 5 lety +3

    Nice video Hilly boy, I really enjoyed it!

  • @williamcooke5627
    @williamcooke5627 Před 5 lety +30

    Very goood, as usual, Hilbert! And that was the most listenable commercial I've ever heard on CZcams.

  • @braedengriffiths4249
    @braedengriffiths4249 Před 5 lety +12

    Thanks a billion for this video man! I remember chatting with you in the comments ages ago. Newfoundland proud and strong! If you need any info on this subject, I’d be happy to divulge. Keep up the amazing work as usual!

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +2

      Braeden Griffiths Thank you so much for your continued support man!

    • @braedengriffiths4249
      @braedengriffiths4249 Před 5 lety +2

      History With Hilbert Ya shed light onto hidden, but important events in history! It’d be impossible not to support ya!
      By the way, look up what we call “bakeapples” they’re a type of berry that grows in harsh arctic/tundra climates and they’re widely believed to be the berries the Vikings used to brew their alcohol when they landed here. Possibly the reason why it’s called Vinland.
      As well, you’ve stumbled onto a plethora of potential history. The region was very important in the seven years war, both world wars and more (Trying to stay modest about my homeland without getting too excited hahaha.)
      Cheers me buddy! Here’s to many more videos of yours to come.
      Braeden.

    • @briangarrow448
      @briangarrow448 Před 5 lety +2

      I remember being at a travel industry convention 30 years ago in Miami, Florida and our tour bus got hijacked by a couple of drunken tourism bureau representatives from Newfoundland. That was quite the night of bar hopping in Miami Beach with a 100 well lubricated tourism and cruise line employees and those 2 guys from your province leading us in debauchery and singing some of their favorite drinking songs. A night that the conventioneers and Miami Beach Police will wryly remember and go do in history. Maybe Hilbert can do a segment on that escapade.

  • @gripen-swe
    @gripen-swe Před 5 lety +2

    Very good and informative video. Keep it up! I love that you pronounce the names correct! :)

  • @theblackprince1346
    @theblackprince1346 Před 5 lety +33

    Hooray more history with Hilbert!

  • @Phrenotopia
    @Phrenotopia Před 5 lety +22

    Well done! Great to see this penciled out in more detail than so many other videos....
    Including my own. :-/

  • @silentwitness7132
    @silentwitness7132 Před 5 lety +3

    Ik hoopte al dat je ooit hier over een video zou maken. Hartelijk bedankt!

  • @KnowHistory
    @KnowHistory Před 5 lety +8

    Great video! I am working on a video about the history of Norway I'll get this video tagged in the description!
    Keep up the good work!

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +2

      Thank you - can you send me a link when it's done, I'd like to give it a watch!

    • @KnowHistory
      @KnowHistory Před 5 lety +1

      Sure! I followed you on twitter, I'll send it when It is posted!

  • @taesu8
    @taesu8 Před 5 lety +43

    One thing that perplex me is that shouldn't Native Americans infected by Norse?

    • @12345678900987659101
      @12345678900987659101 Před 5 lety +33

      taesu8 It's possible due to northern European climate at the time and a less concentrated population contributed to lack of disease, or that there was little contact between the two groups.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +45

      That’s a very good point actually because these Europeans had already been living with cattle for thousands of years so would have had immunities the Native Americans did not.

    • @PastPresented
      @PastPresented Před 5 lety +6

      We wouldn't necessarily know if they were infected, because their relations with the Norse explorers were so antagonistic. In the case of post-Columbian explorers, there was much more social interaction with Native Americans, so they actually got to hear stories of terrible diseases (inflicted, as they saw it, by God, to punish wrongdoing) in communities they had recently visited.

    • @perfectallycromulent
      @perfectallycromulent Před 5 lety +7

      The Dorset pre-Inuit culture that inhabited the northeastern arctic regions of North America died out between 1000-1500. They were replaced by the Thule culture, who appear to have no relationship to the Dorset. It is possible that the Dorset culture was affected by diseases introduced by the Norse. It's also possible that they couldn't adapt to changing weather patterns - this is what is believed to have happened to the Norse, who were also replaced by the Thule culture after they disappeared from Greenland. Or it could be a combination of disease and poor adaptability, not a whole lot is known. But there is a candidate for a native culture that disappeared due to Norse-introduced disease.

    • @Moepowerplant
      @Moepowerplant Před 5 lety

      If I remember right the later explorers had actual diseased men with them (not sure which group it is), while Eriksson's party didn't appear to be sick.

  • @Condobius
    @Condobius Před 5 lety +8

    Another great video! Would love to see a video on Brian Borùma and Clontarf, or a new video on the Gauls. Your Gaulish Cultural analysis was excellent and a new video on that topic would be pretty cool.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +6

      I recently wrote a dissertation of a kind on Brian Borù and the Battle of Clontarf so I should really make a video about it at some point

    • @Condobius
      @Condobius Před 5 lety +1

      History With Hilbert Interesting, was it for an academic purpose or just for fun? I’m sure it’d be an interesting read. Irish history is a niche interest of mine, particularly from the Dark Ages until the Norman Conquest

  • @ronaldderooij1774
    @ronaldderooij1774 Před 5 lety +11

    The Vikings lived in Newfoundland for a few years. The exact location is now known since shortly (10 years?) according to archeologists.

    • @meginna8354
      @meginna8354 Před 5 lety

      Ronald de Rooij where?

    • @magnusorn7313
      @magnusorn7313 Před 4 lety

      some new study suggests L'Anse aux Meadows had activity in it for about 2 centuries but this would likely only have been occasional seasonal loggers

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před 4 lety

      The Norse site at L'Anse Aux Meadows has been known since 1960.

    • @canadianmmaguy7511
      @canadianmmaguy7511 Před 3 lety

      They lived in newfoundland until the little ice age when they were forced to migrate into the hudson and south to Maine and the maritime provinces.

    • @vanjimbo
      @vanjimbo Před 3 lety +1

      No they did not! Don't invent history that never happened!
      Vikings only ever were in northeast Canada!

  • @capehawk7048
    @capehawk7048 Před 5 lety +3

    Very nice vid

  • @basedcaulfield4547
    @basedcaulfield4547 Před 5 lety +24

    TL;DR: they sailed across the ocean.

  • @christopherellis2663
    @christopherellis2663 Před 5 lety +10

    Very interesting stuff, the Grœnlandinga and Vinland Sagas I read, years ago, the archeological evidence is firm.

  • @froyingur945
    @froyingur945 Před 5 lety +8

    Been waiting for this

  • @robertg305
    @robertg305 Před 4 lety +2

    Highly Glorious!

  • @dragongod6972
    @dragongod6972 Před 3 lety +5

    I searched this because I wanted to know if Vinland Saga was real

  • @civishamburgum1234
    @civishamburgum1234 Před 5 lety +2

    After you Werke talking about men goong West, all I heared, was the Song: "Go West"

  • @0ld_Scratch
    @0ld_Scratch Před 5 lety +4

    will you do something on Hanno the Navigator?
    also very good video, I have a soft spot for the history of exploration and seafaring!

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety

      I should look into it actually. If you find it interesting I would honestly recommend the History's Greatest Voyages of Exploration on the Great Courses Plus (I'm sure you can finish it in a month which is the free trial period as well ;) )

  • @CIA-M
    @CIA-M Před 5 lety +45

    Can you make a video about the vikings in the Netherlands? Not just about dorestad but also the plundering of Tiel and the siege of Nijmegen and castle doornenburg? Would be quite an interesting video I think :)

  • @stefanatliorvaldsson3563

    great video

  • @maryanndeweerd2570
    @maryanndeweerd2570 Před 5 lety +1

    Thankyou ❤

  • @aramhalamech4204
    @aramhalamech4204 Před 5 lety +6

    nice, a new video.

  • @nathanaelsallhageriksson1719

    About time......
    :-)

  • @user-op2wq6lv4v
    @user-op2wq6lv4v Před 8 měsíci

    I love learning about ships

  • @sonyad4765
    @sonyad4765 Před 2 lety +1

    Great video! There's a place in New Hampshire USA that is called Mystery Hill. It is rumored to have been occupied by the Vikings.

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před rokem

      The Mystery Hill site is one of those places that every nutball assigns it as a location for whatever ancient cultural group interests them. Of course there is zero evidence to support the wild claims.
      A fun place to visit, just don't take it as a serious ancient pre-Columbian Old World peoples' occupation site.

  • @leifforrest
    @leifforrest Před 5 lety +6

    Thank you for pronouncing Leif correctly! It's commonly mispronounced in the US, and it drives me crazy. Good Job!

  • @itsaguinness
    @itsaguinness Před 2 lety

    this reminded me that Playmobile has viking sets. I made a lil bald Ragnar with big beard and a cross

  • @nicjansen230
    @nicjansen230 Před 5 lety

    the shield of entwined spinners at 3:25 :P

  • @martinan22
    @martinan22 Před 5 lety +1

    You could make a video about the several population collapses on Iceland. They lost like a third of their population several times.

  • @thyscott6603
    @thyscott6603 Před 2 lety

    There are berries in Fennoscandia that are called Vinbär, literally Wine berry. They are very sour, there are white red and black ones, black being the least sour of them. We used to put them in all kinds of food mostly porridge in the morning. IKEA even sells Vinbärssylt, which is the marmelade of the "wine berry". It might be that the Americas had such too at the time, so Vinland is fitting well. Also can be made into juice like Marli Vital.
    It might be confusing but don't mixup Vindruvor with Vinbär, the first one being Grapes.

  • @AO968
    @AO968 Před 5 lety +2

    This is interesting, and quite detailed, but where did you get that flag of Greenland at 6:23 from? It doesn't resemble the one they're using today, and I can't find any point in time where such a flag was used.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety

      Thank you, the flag is a creation of the modern Greenlandic flag but then in a Nordic Cross rather than the rising sun form it's in today

    • @AO968
      @AO968 Před 5 lety

      History With Hilbert That's an interesting concept. Maybe you should propose this design to the Greenlanders, to make it consistent with all the other Scandinavian countries' flags.

  • @robinsinpost
    @robinsinpost Před 5 lety +18

    Have you made a video of the viking impact on Holland(I say Holland and not the Netherlands but I mean the whole country)? Even if it may be was called Friesland then. I don't know.
    If not can you make one.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +9

      Robinsinpost Maybe a series on how the Vikings affected each country they came to?

    • @kathryngeeslin9509
      @kathryngeeslin9509 Před 5 lety +2

      History With Hilbert. That would be great.

    • @lordofbees9067
      @lordofbees9067 Před 5 lety

      make a video about vikings in antartida,
      you dont have hisotry your ancestors were just beastfull trolls like nowadays, so you invent all your hisotry. the rela hstory that is scientific and is in ancioent books doesnt matter.

  • @bepsi6204
    @bepsi6204 Před 5 lety +10

    Can you make a video about Vikings in Ireland + 20th century Greenland and Iceland

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety

      I think a couple of people have been asking for videos on the effect of Vikings on certain countries

    • @lordofbees9067
      @lordofbees9067 Před 5 lety

      VIKINGS BEVER HAD BEEN IN AMERICAS, IT WOULD BE TOO MUCH FOR THEMMM. VIKINGS CANT DO NYTHING JUST ASSAULT AND STEAL OTHERS.
      THE NAVIGATION WAS JUST NEAR THE COAST, AND SOMETIMES A LITTLE FURTHER TO ENGALND, THEY COULD SEE SIGNALS OF THAT ISLAND ON CLER DAYS.
      HAVE A LIFE STUDY REAL HISOTRY.
      PORTUGUESES AND THEIR PHOENICIANS ANCESTORS WERE THE NAVIGATORS.

  • @calamusgladiofortior2814
    @calamusgladiofortior2814 Před 5 lety +13

    Great video, Hilbert. Just a small nitpicky note from a Canadian: Newfoundland is pronounced NEWF-en-land, not NEW-found-land. Newfoundlanders are affectionately known as Newfies. I look forward to seeing more on this topic. Cheers.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +4

      Thanks for the tip and your support :)

    • @Bjowolf2
      @Bjowolf2 Před rokem

      Is there any reason for this difference?
      Was it pronounced as the word "found" at some stage? 🤔

    • @slake9727
      @slake9727 Před měsícem

      ​@Bjowolf2 it's just the local pronunciation.

  • @hydrogenone6866
    @hydrogenone6866 Před 5 lety +4

    It would be interesting if a permanent settlement on Vineland had happened.

  • @ofallmyintention9496
    @ofallmyintention9496 Před 5 lety

    Do you (or, does the narrator, if a different person) work with or have any affiliation with any other channel? Your voice sounds very familiar...is that Jabzy?

  • @gamingwithkai9626
    @gamingwithkai9626 Před 3 lety +1

    I just needed help with school but thanks

  • @savioblanc
    @savioblanc Před 5 lety +3

    I think it's so weird to think of Catholic Vikings residing in Greenland in the 1100s, along with a Bishop residing over these communities

  • @Ivo--
    @Ivo-- Před 5 lety +3

    Fun fact: Bluetooth technology was named after Harald Bluetooth and the logo are his initials.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +2

      The reason they chose him as well is because of his councils so it was like a way to connect with his nobility just as Bluetooth technology connects devices.

  • @USAACbrat
    @USAACbrat Před 2 lety

    Are there any stories of how Hudson Bay was explored? Can't imagine a Viking passing by what looks like a big bay and good anchorage.

    • @fastertove
      @fastertove Před 2 lety

      Lack of evidence.

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před rokem

      Who knows. They may have ventured there very briefly but suspect they would have avoided it in the longer run. The bay has dangerous sailing conditions and there was the risk of being trapped in the Bay if they missed getting out through the Hudson Strait before the return of ice. No real reason to go there after maybe one look around. No resources there that they didn't already have access to in abundance around the shores of the Labrador Sea and Baffin Bay.

  • @ThatShitGood
    @ThatShitGood Před 2 lety +2

    It's mindblowing how influencial scandinavia is in the world history, I'm persian and these people left some good blueprints of their genetics in northern part of iran, specially in gilan, gorgan and mazandaran.

  • @cennethadameveson3715
    @cennethadameveson3715 Před 5 lety +9

    Any thoughts on videos of the eastward exploration of the Norsemen/vikings?

  • @meginna8354
    @meginna8354 Před 5 lety +10

    Some things to note for you, as i feel like you've left a lot out: The three Norse sources that document the expeditions to America are Eiriks-Saga rauða, Grænlendinga-Saga and Eyrbyggja-Saga(Eyrbyggja speaks very little of it). I can link you with good translations.
    you forgot to mention Leifr's brother Þorvaldr, who has the first ever encounter with Native Americans, he stumbled upon 8 Natives and killed 7 of them, 1 of them escaped. Þorvaldr is later killed by an arrow from Natives.
    The name for the entire American continent was Skrælingjaland.
    Leifr only went to America with around 20 people, Þorfinnr Karlsefni(my 25X G-granddad) lead the voyage to America from Iceland with around 65-140 people. Þorfinnur is also the father of the first Norse child born in America, Snorri Þorfinnsson(circa 1004).
    Þornfinnr captures two Native American boys and took them to Iceland and taught them to speak Old Norse, once the boys learned Old Norse they told some interesting things about N-America. The boys' tribe apparently lived in holes, they called their mother Vethildi and their father Óvægi. They sayd that two kings ruled the natives, and their names were Avaldamon and Avaldidida. there were no houses, there men only laid in caves or holes. They said that there was a land across their land, where men lived/built who were in white clothing and carried poles, with white cloth attachments and yelled loudly (bit weird written, i translated directly from Old Norse).
    Also, Eyrbyggja-saga says that an ex Jomsviking by the name of Björn Ásbrandsson became the leader of a Native American tribe, there have been speculations by Icelandic scholars if it was in Mexico based on where the location and culture is described, but likely nothing will be proven.
    I can't even mention all the things right now but that's a couple.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +2

      megin na I’m going to be talking about the other Erickson siblings in a later video but thank you for the information 😉

    • @meginna8354
      @meginna8354 Před 5 lety +1

      History With Hilbert If you want me to link you English translations of these sagas and name the chapters with interesting point, just ask, i'd be happy to help.

    • @ChronosCatharsis
      @ChronosCatharsis Před 5 lety

      I would love the links :)

    • @lordofbees9067
      @lordofbees9067 Před 5 lety +1

      VIKINGS WERE NEVER IN AMERICA, THERE ISNT A SINGLE PROVE.and will never be, they never been there.
      you knopw how vikings rechead england and ireland? portuguese ancestors (phoenicians) from lisbon, told them, they were making commerce with them.

    • @lordofbees9067
      @lordofbees9067 Před 5 lety

      "but likely nothing will be proven. "
      ---of course not, your trying to built an hisotry on lies.
      Vikings were in ireland and engalnd, maybe those tales are about it ... but if you dont know your history thas your problem.

  • @mattihp
    @mattihp Před 4 lety +1

    THANK YOU for saying Leif and not Leaf which seems to be popular among anglos...

    • @quidam_surprise
      @quidam_surprise Před 3 lety +1

      It seems like folks are irredeemable by nature 😔

  • @Skelstoolbox
    @Skelstoolbox Před 4 lety

    Many feel they went much further south.. They describe a river location that some historians believe to be New Brunswick. Some think they made it as far as the Hudson river in New York and others as far south as Florida or even the Gulf of Mexico.. I think at least the Carolinas, looking for areas free of scraelings..

    • @vanjimbo
      @vanjimbo Před 3 lety

      "Feel" isn't History! Vikings only ever were in northeast Canada!

  • @trygvematthiessen1673
    @trygvematthiessen1673 Před 4 měsíci

    12:07 I`m quite certain that the name or noun Vinland derives from the old Norse noun «vin» which means «meadow « or «plain field»…..

  • @akinahavana
    @akinahavana Před 3 lety +1

    In vikings final season they used this story!

  • @mikepowell2776
    @mikepowell2776 Před 3 lety +2

    Small point: Iceland is in the Atlantic Ocean, not the North Sea.

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před rokem

      True. To be more specific: Iceland is bounded by the Greenland Sea on the north, the Norwegian Sea on the east, the Atlantic Ocean on the south and southwest, and the Denmark Strait to the north northwest.

  • @flllopakk
    @flllopakk Před 5 lety +1

    Fun Fact: Tyrker at that age was meaning turkish- and particularly referred to the hungarian as well that era and the other eastern nomadic tribes whom they were in contact with.

    • @meginna8354
      @meginna8354 Před 5 lety

      The saga says about Tyrkir "Hann talaði þá fyrst lengi á þýzku" which means "he then spoke to them for long in German" , so he was in all likelihood a German slave.

  • @user-dr1bj1bq2e
    @user-dr1bj1bq2e Před 5 lety

    Is it possible they went up the river saguenay ....their is this small island who would been perfect for a camp

    • @canadianmmaguy7511
      @canadianmmaguy7511 Před 3 lety

      Yes.
      They were the white bearded people to the west who had iron. Sagueney was an important trading post

  • @CraisenGaming
    @CraisenGaming Před 5 lety

    Please do a follow up

  • @lordbrakeson
    @lordbrakeson Před 5 lety +9

    Being a Newfoundlander I’m a firm believer that we are Vinland. Lmao.

    • @dg-hughes
      @dg-hughes Před 4 lety +1

      Do you guys use the magic grapes to make Screech? (I'm from PEI)

    • @devashish_
      @devashish_ Před 3 lety

      Being a weeb and Having watched Vinland Saga, Im a firm believer that Vinland exists too. Same belief, different reasons. Lmao.

    • @canadianmmaguy7511
      @canadianmmaguy7511 Před 3 lety +1

      @@dg-hughes also from PEI. Small world

    • @slake9727
      @slake9727 Před měsícem

      Vinland is at Lanse aux Meadows on the most northern tip on the Northern Peninsula in Newfoundland. That's just a proven fact

  • @user-cn5pm7zg1u
    @user-cn5pm7zg1u Před 5 lety +10

    YESSSS FINALLY!!!!!

  • @aqidon
    @aqidon Před 5 lety +1

    Hilbert why do you write eirik the correct way then proced to write leif erikson when it should be eirikson? As my name is Eirik i always get a bit anoyed when people write or say erik instead. Even in norway this is a problem as we have both Erik and Eirik.

  • @lifefordummies
    @lifefordummies Před 3 lety

    Hello from Newfoundland! Great Video

  • @thessalonikiosmusv
    @thessalonikiosmusv Před 5 lety

    May I know font you used in this video?

  • @johnkilmartin5101
    @johnkilmartin5101 Před 5 lety +9

    If the Norse had landed on what is now Newfoundland it seems very odd that the plethora of cod is not mentioned as Cabot and those who followed after him were amazed by it. They talk about the schools being so thick they impeded the ship's progress. I would think that would be much more impressive than finding wild blueberries.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +8

      That's a point although they do make special mention of the salmon as big as men's arms in "Vinland," although if you plot salmon spawning grounds and places where berries grow they don't have any intersections on Newfoundland so it couldn't be the Vinland described by the saga and is likely more to the south.

    • @GoodmansGhost
      @GoodmansGhost Před 5 lety +2

      Or things just changed in 500 years =P

    • @johnkilmartin5101
      @johnkilmartin5101 Před 5 lety +2

      GoodmansGhost If you compare the cod to the other two super abundant species pushed to extinction by their over harvest by Europeans, the plains bison and passenger pigeon both are eruption species and were destroyed in less than a century. The cod stocks on the other hand were exploited for around four hundred years before anyone noticed a decline and another sixty before the government put a moratorium on the commercial harvest.
      That being said the Beothuk alone of indigenous peoples of Canada never formed a relationship with Europeans. This suggests at least in my mind that their first contact was very negative. They are one of only three people groups to be pushed to extinction after contact in what is now Canada. The other two are from south western BC just in from the coast and the remaining group were the Iroquoian speaking tribes aligned with neither the Iroquois confederacy or the Huron and were destroyed by the warfare between the two.

    • @meginna8354
      @meginna8354 Před 5 lety +1

      Vinland likely is located near the Miramichi river, based on how the saga describes the location.

    • @CK-mi8uz
      @CK-mi8uz Před 5 lety +2

      they obviously did land on Newfoundland has we have settlements here from them. I highly doubt cod was ever that thick, people brag and inflate the truth to make their exploration sound more impressive.

  • @pqbdwmnu
    @pqbdwmnu Před 5 lety

    Magic

  • @tropickid4547
    @tropickid4547 Před 3 lety +2

    Damn this is how eviors skeleton made it to North America

  • @stephfahey1101
    @stephfahey1101 Před 5 lety

    didn't the Celts also explore west prior to the Vikings or around the same time? I live in Canada and I remember watching a documentary a few years back about how Archeologists found Celtic Artifacts on the east side of Newfoundland.

  • @mikeeverhart831
    @mikeeverhart831 Před 3 lety +2

    How do you discover something when people are already there?

    • @takigan
      @takigan Před 3 lety +1

      If a whole society is unaware of the existence of an entire landmass, would that not be "discovering" it, at least in the frame of reference for those who weren't aware of it?
      You're criticizing the frame of reference that most schools in North America assume....that America was sitting here and "humanity" discovered it, without consideration for the fact that it wasn't as much a discovering by the whole of humanity (afterall, quite a huge chunk of humanity was already living there) but rather two vast cultures of people who formerly weren't aware of each other that eventually made contact.
      But that isn't the title of the video. He's not talking about greater humanity discovering an unknown landmass as a means of establishing some delusional origin story. He's talking about one small group of people (Vikings) discovering a chunk of land they weren't aware of before. It's no different than a Polynesian culture discovering a new island they weren't aware of while exploring massive chunks of the Pacific...whether those islands were already inhabited or not.

  • @TheManofLawlessness
    @TheManofLawlessness Před 4 lety +2

    When you’re told Christopher Columbus discovered America lmaoooo

  • @ringtail2925
    @ringtail2925 Před 2 lety

    I'm confuses what year in particular did they sail to North American Canada?

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před rokem

      The Newfoundland settlement appears to have been established about 1021, according the the latest research. It only lasted a few years. The Norse settlements in Greenland started in the 980s.

  • @paulatradies1942
    @paulatradies1942 Před 2 lety

    By sailing a boat, next question, lol

  • @Rommheim1
    @Rommheim1 Před 5 lety +1

    The coast of Labrador is not incredibly wooded, quite the opposite.

    • @satyr1349
      @satyr1349 Před 5 lety +2

      Possibly cut down a lot of the forest since back then.

    • @lordofbees9067
      @lordofbees9067 Před 5 lety

      VIKINGS NEVER BEEN IN AMERICA, ITS ALL LIES.
      THEY WANT TO BUILD THEIR OWN HISTORY.BASED ON LIES.

    • @magnusorn7313
      @magnusorn7313 Před 4 lety +1

      @@lordofbees9067 how did they get to iceland then?
      why is there a building on greenland that is mentioned in the sagas?
      what about the actual physical remains we have from their trade from greenland?
      what about the incredibly accurate geographic descriptions of north america down to the behavior of tides at st georges bay and the lake leading to barachois pond and the detailing of the fish you could can catch there?

  • @CRindler15
    @CRindler15 Před 5 lety

    What flag is that shown at 12:27?

    • @xanv8051
      @xanv8051 Před 7 měsíci

      Maybe it's the American faction that created this fantasy

  • @Rizztana
    @Rizztana Před 4 lety

    9:49 except baffin island isnt part of mainland north America... it's an island...

  • @HistoryTime
    @HistoryTime Před 5 lety +53

    North America was actually colonised by Mercians first, back during the Eighth Century. Though they soon came to miss the dreary weather of the English Midlands so gave up and went home. Though the place-name evidence still remains today. -->America --> Murica --> Mercia -

    • @huntersterling8623
      @huntersterling8623 Před 5 lety +21

      By Odin's beard i can't believe you commented that

    • @zoetropo1
      @zoetropo1 Před 5 lety +6

      Mercia? No. America is named after ;) Armorica, the Iron Age coastlands of Gaul, because the Armoricans founded Boston. (The last two parts are true.)

    • @12345678900987659101
      @12345678900987659101 Před 5 lety +8

      History Time America got its name by a cartographer who gave the Americas their name, naming them after an Italian explorer named Amerigo.

    • @huntersterling8623
      @huntersterling8623 Před 5 lety +3

      flyingkoopa45 WRONG AMERICA IS NAMED AFTER THE NORSE WORD MIRKLAND WHICH WAS SHORTENED TO MURICA

    • @HistoryTime
      @HistoryTime Před 5 lety +1

      Gott Mit Uns 😉

  • @GoodmansGhost
    @GoodmansGhost Před 5 lety +1

    Pretty sure mark in Markland means ground, not forest.

    • @paulingvar
      @paulingvar Před 5 lety

      Originally the word meant "border area", later " bordering forest". My Viking grammer says it meant forest in this case, "land of forest". Which makes sense if you want to describe the look.
      On the other hand I have a personal belief that Vinland does not refer to wine , but to a word meaning "grass". I Think the story about grapes is made up later by confusing the the word. The three names thus meaning (land of ..); flat stones, forests and grass is logical to me

    • @pisaks6782
      @pisaks6782 Před 4 lety

      "Landland"

  • @galaxyearth60
    @galaxyearth60 Před 2 lety +10

    You can't "Discover" a land where people are already living!

    • @bosertheropode5443
      @bosertheropode5443 Před 2 lety +4

      Yes you can, at least from our european perspective

    • @lt.kettch4652
      @lt.kettch4652 Před 2 lety +2

      ..bursts into some random persons house, I’ve discovered what god has given me.
      …but I already live here
      ….it’s ok, I’m European
      ?

    • @bosertheropode5443
      @bosertheropode5443 Před 2 lety +4

      @@lt.kettch4652 The europeans didnt knew america, they discovered it from their perspective, even tho the natives lived there for more then 20.000 years.

    • @spammergenerico5679
      @spammergenerico5679 Před 2 lety

      @@bosertheropode5443 10.000 years. Humans where on America allready 20.000 years ago, yes. But those where not the same humans that came 10.000 years later

    • @shainshartershwate7421
      @shainshartershwate7421 Před 2 lety +1

      You absolutely can.

  • @fenggula7890
    @fenggula7890 Před rokem +1

    My azz out here, learning history, because of Vinland Saga

  • @yrjkeenwa6584
    @yrjkeenwa6584 Před 3 lety +1

    Straight up Vinland saga lol

  • @karenarmstrong8141
    @karenarmstrong8141 Před 5 lety

    these days you cant get a video without it being sponsored by great courses plus or skill share

  •  Před 5 lety

    Hey, that flag! I made such a flag somewhere, it wasn't real, was it?

  • @hyperhedgehog7
    @hyperhedgehog7 Před 5 lety +1

    8:52

  • @michaelmoore4043
    @michaelmoore4043 Před 5 lety +20

    Dutch ships😏

  • @sanderskovly7641
    @sanderskovly7641 Před 5 lety +3

    Hilbert, where are you from?

    • @martijn9568
      @martijn9568 Před 5 lety +1

      On the channelbanner on the right you see a flag of a dutch province

    • @sanderskovly7641
      @sanderskovly7641 Před 5 lety +1

      Yeah, now I remember all the dutch memes he used to have. Just wondered, because since he nailed the norse pronounciation, he couldn't be from an anglo speaking country...(sad, but after my experience true)

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +1

      I'm a bit of Dutch, Frisian and living in Northumberland in the North of England ;)

    • @sanderskovly7641
      @sanderskovly7641 Před 5 lety

      So you are part anglian, partly anglian and live in the "mothercountry" of the anglo-speaking world. Anyway, just wanted to congrat you with the spelling. Most foreigneirs pronounce the names utterly wrong. But I understood that you had taken a course in norse?

    • @MartieD
      @MartieD Před 5 lety

      Sander Skovly Foreigners to Iceland or who are you referring to as "foreigners"? Modern Scandinavians pronouce these names very differently from Icelanders.

  • @illuminatea6868
    @illuminatea6868 Před 5 lety +7

    8:53 the ad ends

  • @Killzoneguy117
    @Killzoneguy117 Před 3 lety +2

    What amazes me is that the Vikings only stopped at Newfoundland. I get that they were in unfamiliar territory, but it seems so strange to me that they never made it into the Gulf of St. Lawrence or Nova Scotia given their territorial proximity to Vinland. Part of me likes to believe that Viking explorers perhaps made it at least to Nova Scotia, though of course I have no evidence whatsoever to back that claim.

    • @madhatter9569
      @madhatter9569 Před 3 lety

      They didnt stop at Newfoundland lol. If you believe that you're closed minded. They explored a good majority of what is modern day Canada and USA.

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před 3 lety

      @@madhatter9569 It is likely the Norse explored the Gulf of St Lawrence and thus parts of what in Canada today are the Provinces of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, and parts of Quebec. They did not explore "a good majority of what is modern day Canada and USA."

    • @madhatter9569
      @madhatter9569 Před 3 lety

      @@EdinburghFive There's been viking artifacts found all over the USA. A Norse penny found in maine. A viking helmet found in Pennsylvania. The Vikings made it to the mainland.

    • @EdinburghFive
      @EdinburghFive Před 3 lety +1

      @@madhatter9569 The fact remains there have not been "viking artifacts found all over the USA." . The Norwegian silver coin found in Maine, although an actual Viking period coin, it is questionable as to whether it is a legitimate artifact from the archaeological site. Also, the presence of a single artifact does not prove the Vikings were trading as far south into what is now the USA. At best the coin may be an item that was taken in trade with a more northern group of indigenous people. It then was traded on through a trade network by various Indigenous groups until it arrived in Maine.
      I think there is no question the Vikings "made it to the mainland" but this was much farther north in the Gulf of St. Lawrence region.
      As for a Viking helmet found in Pennsylvania, it doesn't exist.

    • @ThatIcelandicDude
      @ThatIcelandicDude Před 3 lety

      On New foundland site we found butternutts which is proof the settlers there went at least as far south as New Brunswick.

  • @matthewmann8969
    @matthewmann8969 Před 5 lety

    By being brave enough to

  • @rockelino
    @rockelino Před 2 lety +1

    Who's here after watching Vikings: Valhalla?

  • @louayGamer
    @louayGamer Před 5 lety +1

    skip to 8:50

  • @Tager253
    @Tager253 Před 3 lety

    thats wild

  • @misseli1
    @misseli1 Před 5 lety

    "For fewer than two kidneys..."

  • @garthwatene9428
    @garthwatene9428 Před 5 lety

    how do you discover a country when there is already someone there or does discovery only apply to europeans?

    • @paulingvar
      @paulingvar Před 5 lety

      If you find something unknown to you or your society "discover" is not wrong, but maybe rediscover would be better?

    • @savioblanc
      @savioblanc Před 5 lety

      It depends on who is narrating.
      Since it was primarily Europeans going around the world and discovering new lands to them, it would be discovering.
      They then told other peoples about these new lands.
      So for example, the Chinese were told about North n South America by the European missionaries and merchants.
      No one in the Old World, whether they be African, Arab, Turk, Indian or Asiatic was aware of the region of North and South America until the Europeans rediscovered these lands and then were told of these lands.

  • @charlesplayzeverything4386

    The reason how the vikings discovered america is they use a boat. But pretty cool video! Am complaining with a guy that the viking discovery of america didnt affect the world. then i talk back by saying "its becuz of the time. its 11th century when the vikings discovered america so there not much country when its on 11th century" But cool video!

  • @graysonballard1106
    @graysonballard1106 Před 4 lety

    I’m 30% Scandinavian

  • @mzda610
    @mzda610 Před 2 lety

    Eric the Viking boss discovered green land