Tollense Valley | Europe's First Battle (Bronze Age History Documentary)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
  • The Battle of the Tollense Valley took place in Bronze Age Germany c.1250 BC. Was this Europe's first battle?
    Archeological discoveries in the Tollense Valley in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Northeast Germany suggest this was the site of a conflict in the 13th century BC. (Closest dates might be 1230 - 1240 BC) This was the European Middle Bronze Age.
    As well as weapons and other artefacts, thousands of bones representing at least 140 individuals have been found here and most are men of fighting age. Some bones show injuries received at the point of death.
    There might have been between 3000 and 7000 participants which if true is a truly enormous prehistoric battle.
    So was this a great pitched battle? An ambush? A series of small skirmishes?
    Despite all the evidence, piecing together exactly who these people were, how many there were, where they came from and what happened here… is not so simple.
    If you enjoy my videos please consider supporting the channel
    Patreon ➜ / dandavisauthor
    PayPal ➜ paypal.me/DanDavisAuthor
    Ko-fi ➜ ko-fi.com/dandavis
    My Books
    Godborn: Gods of Bronze 1 ➜ amzn.to/3nm2au1
    All my books on Amazon ➜ amzn.to/3xngwz5
    My Links
    Website dandavisauthor.com/
    Facebook: / dandavisauthor
    Twitter: / dandaviswrites
    Instagram: / dandavisauthor
    Video Sources
    Warriors and Weapons in Bronze Age Europe - Anthony Harding ➜ amzn.to/383sToE
    Warfare in Bronze Age Society - Christian Horn & Kristian Kristiansen ➜ amzn.to/3z6ZtBN
    Die Welt der Himmelsscheibe von Nebra - Harald Meller ➜ amzn.to/3ERYbh7
    An early Bronze Age causeway in the Tollense Valley - Jantzen (2014)
    Bronze Age tin rings from the Tollense valley - Krüger (2012)
    Low Prevalence of Lactase Persistence in Bronze Age Europe - Burger (2020)
    Flint arrowhead embedded in a human humerus from the Bronze Age site in the Tollense valley - Flohr (2015)
    Instrumental investigation of oxygen isotopes in human dental enamel from the Bronze Age battlefield site at Tollense - Price (2019)
    Perimortem Lesions on Human Bones from the Bronze Age Battlefield in the Tollense - Brinker (2018)
    A Bronze Age battlefield? Weapons and trauma in the Tollense Valley - Jantzen (2010)
    Tollense Battle Ancient DNA, they had hunter gatherer roots by Genos Historia ➜ • Tollense Battle Ancien...
    The above links include affiliate links which means we will earn a small commission from your purchases at no additional cost to you which is a way to support the channel.
    Note:
    There is DNA evidence that some of these people had high proportion of Western Hunter Gatherer DNA. I have a post about this on Patreon linked in the comments.
    Video Chapters
    00:00 Prepare for Battle
    02:32 The Tollense Valley Battlefield
    06:26 Bronze Age Europe
    08:18 Bronze Age Warrior Aristocracy
    10:01 Material Evidence
    13:14 Isotope Analysis
    14:08 DNA Evidence
    15:35 What Actually Happened?
    16:48 Alternative Theories

Komentáře • 1,3K

  • @DanDavisHistory
    @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +187

    Thanks for watching! Please hit "like" and share the video around - it helps me out SO much.
    And if you enjoy my videos please consider supporting the channel:
    Patreon ➜ www.patreon.com/dandavisauthor
    My books ➜ amzn.to/3xngwz5
    Check out this accompanying Patreon-exclusive post on the high hunter-gatherer ancestry in some of the Tollense Valley DNA samples: www.patreon.com/posts/hunter-gatherers-56604642

    • @ajithsidhu7183
      @ajithsidhu7183 Před 2 lety +8

      Please do one how did bronze age era people.train for war

    • @CaucAsianSasquatch
      @CaucAsianSasquatch Před 2 lety +3

      Hey brother, old subscriber with a new profile. I like how you work through the microcosm of the details. Not looking at a culture from outside, but from the singular individual perspective. It is refreshing.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +10

      @@ajithsidhu7183 yes I will do. You ask this on every video and I said yes last time! I will get to it eventually. There are things to say about how sporting events emerged from war training and also from funeral games.

    • @pasquinomarforio
      @pasquinomarforio Před 2 lety +4

      Great storytelling. Each one is better than the last. Thank you.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety

      @@pasquinomarforio thank you very much.

  • @MagnusItland
    @MagnusItland Před 2 lety +2978

    When I went to school some 50 years ago, the Bronze Age was portrayed as a Middle Eastern thing. Even the Mycenaeans were not mentioned except as a half-mythical past referenced by the Iron Age Greeks. I grew up believing Europeans were fur-clad reindeer hunters until the light of civilization spread from Egypt via Greece and Rome to finally reach Western Europe. Today we know that the real prehistory of Europe was far more complex and fascinating. Or at least some of us know, and hopefully with the help of your videos, some more people will get a glimpse of a world almost lost in the fog of time.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +169

      Thank you.

    • @jelkel25
      @jelkel25 Před 2 lety +164

      There was a religious complex (they think) uncovered in the Hebredees that was much bigger than what the local community would have needed so they're presuming it was some sort of ancient Vatican type place for a religion that is long forgotten. The "all roads lead to Rome" attitude in history and archaeology did not do northwest Europe any favours and has been ignored or treated with derision. I think there are worlds (as it were) yet to be found not unlike the Hittites and Fertile Crescent civilizations.

    • @dirksharp9876
      @dirksharp9876 Před 2 lety +10

      Well said.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +94

      Do you mean the Ness of Brodgar site? That is an amazing Neolithic centre - probably extremely influential in Britain and beyond. I talk about it a bit in the Neolithic Britain video.

    • @jelkel25
      @jelkel25 Před 2 lety +47

      @@DanDavisHistory That's the one, I'm given to believe it is easily accessible by boat which was the most efficient form of travel then so could have been used by multiple north European countries. Gets the old grey matter in motion!

  • @rachel_Cochran
    @rachel_Cochran Před 2 lety +620

    I watched a documentary about this site and never thought about it again.
    You have given it more life in 20 minutes than those attempting to make an entire documentary about it were able to.
    Thank you for your channel and keep up the amazing work!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +17

      Thank you, great to hear that.

    • @chubbymoth5810
      @chubbymoth5810 Před 2 lety +8

      I second this opinion. Great video where you really manage to bring to light how modern archaeology gives us clues to how much we can interpret this event. The introduction alone with a possible interpretation was gripping.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +5

      @@chubbymoth5810 thanks! I'm never sure about doing those kinds of intros because I expect they put some people. But I'm glad you enjoyed it.

    • @Sugar_Cuckoo
      @Sugar_Cuckoo Před 2 lety +1

      tv documentaries are often far less informative and interesting than a youtube video on the same topic, that is 5 times shorter

    • @shades2.183
      @shades2.183 Před 2 lety +3

      @@DanDavisHistory you forget to take some very interesting things into consideration, a very important fact. Bronze swords, axes and spears have been pulled out ofDanish borgs from that time period, and not just small amount but in large quantaties. To me that point toward that the victors came from the north. That also match with roman and other germani accounts, namely that the strongest tribes came from north.

  • @18Bees
    @18Bees Před 2 lety +210

    Definitely one of my pre battle thoughts would be “I’d rather die by the sword than be clubbed by that bloody Shillelagh!”

    • @philvanderlaan5942
      @philvanderlaan5942 Před 2 lety +18

      I’d rather live by the bow than die by the sword.

    • @18Bees
      @18Bees Před 2 lety +4

      @@philvanderlaan5942 the ancient sniper?

    • @philvanderlaan5942
      @philvanderlaan5942 Před 2 lety +10

      @@18Bees i just would be more comfortable 60-70 meters farther away from my enemy than he can reach especially since I would not want to be wearing 15-20kg of bronze hoplite armor in that swampy ground

    • @18Bees
      @18Bees Před 2 lety +7

      @@philvanderlaan5942 makes it difficult to breath when your face down in the swamp 😂😎

    • @philvanderlaan5942
      @philvanderlaan5942 Před 2 lety +9

      @@18Bees kinda my point! , the only death in the SCA that I am aware of was a guy in a rural Pennsylvania tournament ( war ) who fell down in one of those 13th century French crow beak helmets and drowned because he had nailed himself to the bottom of a mud puddle.

  • @constantinexi6489
    @constantinexi6489 Před 2 lety +246

    It’s the obscurity of it all that gets me, I can imagine chieftains on both sides promising immortal glory and eternal veneration for their men if they win.
    Now we don’t even know who they are

    • @65stang98
      @65stang98 Před 2 lety +24

      and it was like that for tens of thousands of years before we have written history. pretty insane to think about. when you look at castles whose ruins are basically just rubble after 2k years.

    • @jasonmain6398
      @jasonmain6398 Před 2 lety +20

      Maybe. Or maybe they're half remembered as old gods. Who knows

    • @USERZ123XD
      @USERZ123XD Před 2 lety +9

      The same stuff they promise young people to fight and die for someone else for millennia and people just keep falling for it over and over again and again.

    • @salamandress
      @salamandress Před 2 lety +3

      It's still exactly the same today. No one gives two fucks about dead soldiers. They're still pawns in a chess game run by warlords.

    • @Hugh_Morris
      @Hugh_Morris Před 2 lety +2

      @@jasonmain6398 plausible imo

  • @sitrilko
    @sitrilko Před 2 lety +166

    I like how you stress the things which we simply don't know.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +17

      Yeah there are so many possible interpretations and doing archeology takes a long time. It's difficult here too because so much is underwater. I hope they continue to get funding to do the work though.

    • @levitatingoctahedron922
      @levitatingoctahedron922 Před 2 lety +7

      one of the wisest realizations of socrates, and one of the most ignored

    • @tygrkhat4087
      @tygrkhat4087 Před 2 lety +4

      For every one thing we know about prehistory there are a hundred things we still have yet to learn, and a thousand that we will never know.

    • @jk7140
      @jk7140 Před 2 lety

      I liked that too. It's a much more trustworthy style of presentation so I left feeling like I got a solid education on the topic. Plus the mystery of it all is engaging in its own right.
      No matter what these people were like, safe to say they had a whole host of strange myths, superstitions, beliefs, rituals and habits that wouldn't make any sense without one of them explaining it. Doubt we'll ever get to a real understanding of something that far gone without a written record but it's very interesting to speculate.

    • @ohhi5237
      @ohhi5237 Před měsícem

      except for the clickbait title

  • @lesleeg9481
    @lesleeg9481 Před 2 lety +195

    This video is like a dream for me. I've been fascinated by Bronze Age trade routes for more than 20 years, and this is the most comprehensive explanation of routes and items traded that I've seen or heard of so far. I guess I have to check out the sources and read a few more books. Thanks for putting this together. Love it.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +12

      Thank you! Very happy to read that. I'll have to make more videos about these trade routes because it is fascinating, I agree. Cheers.

    • @michieldeprez4025
      @michieldeprez4025 Před 2 lety +4

      That’s a fascination of mine as well, the late bronze age really was extraordinairy interconnected

    • @OmmerSyssel
      @OmmerSyssel Před 2 lety +1

      During Bronze age Danish Gudme were directly connected with local authorities in Hungary, despite several thousands kilometres of distance.
      Metallurgy has proven similarities from excavations.

    • @Baranina123
      @Baranina123 Před 2 lety +1

      Leslee gill. Can you recommend some books or other source about this era?

  • @Wolfen443
    @Wolfen443 Před 2 lety +146

    Fascinating, it shows that Early Europe was a fluid, ever changing world back then even before recorded history was collected. It could make a nice TV series if more details were available.

    • @paulohagan3309
      @paulohagan3309 Před 2 lety +3

      As long as the final episode isn't a major disappointment ...

    • @arynmartin
      @arynmartin Před 2 lety +7

      The Nordic Bronze Age persisted for a continuous 1300 years, and survived the Bronze Age Collapse of the 13th century BC -- which witnessed the destruction of every major civilized center in the more "fluid" south with the space of 50 years -- for 700 years.
      It was in the context of that great collapse that the Tollense Battle took place in.
      It was likely a (motley) host moving up from the south looking to penetrate the wealthy (amber) and stable and more homogeneous Northlands.

    • @Wolfen443
      @Wolfen443 Před 2 lety +3

      @@paulohagan3309 , we do not know how it ended, that is the problem filming something like it.

    • @drewskij2175
      @drewskij2175 Před 2 lety

      @@paulohagan3309 oh I see what you did there. Lets hope it gets corrected this time around. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @paulohagan3309
      @paulohagan3309 Před 2 lety +1

      @@drewskij2175 Apparently there's a prequel coming ... something about dragons ... maybe in the last episode the ladies will spring forward with their magical fire extinguishers ...

  • @connorpollock6087
    @connorpollock6087 Před 2 lety +94

    I love that you are able to blend the uncertainty inherent in archaeology with storytelling. This video was very well done.

  • @plurplursen7172
    @plurplursen7172 Před 2 lety +204

    The battle at Alken Enge in Denmark was around the same time as this one. And it was also a well equipped army vs poor local farmers. A whole generation of local people died in that battle. They can see how many farming fields turned into thick forrest in the decades after the battle. And, we know nothing about the reasons for the battle either. Our local museum have the bones and weapons from the warriors on show.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +45

      That's great they have the artefacts in the local museum. That clash was in the Iron Age, sometime in the 1st century AD, over a thousand years after this. And the work there has helped inform some interpretations of the Tollense site. There are so many places in Denmark where the conditions help to preserve evidence. I hope that more battle sites are uncovered in future.

    • @plurplursen7172
      @plurplursen7172 Před 2 lety +17

      @@DanDavisHistory The theory is that because of the decline of the roman empire, there was a lot of unrest in Europe. The power vacuum created migrations. But it's a mystery I hope we one day can know about. It's incredible how little progress in warfare and tech there was, from the battle at Tollense to Alken 1000 years later.

    • @wijse
      @wijse Před 2 lety +12

      @@plurplursen7172 No mystery that Germanic tribes fought other Germanic tribes. When you worship war gods and practice human sacrifice then you need battles and sacrifices.

    • @zipperpillow
      @zipperpillow Před rokem +10

      @@wijse These people weren't speaking German. It wasn't even a language yet. They were simply being Killed by invading R1a horsemen, who entirely replaced them in this area.

    • @wijse
      @wijse Před rokem +12

      @@zipperpillow I wrote Germanic tribes, not german language and i did not write the comment as commentary to the video, but as a comment for what Plur Plursen wrote about roman empire and alken (Germanic iron age battle). Read my comment again and Plur Plursens comment.

  • @blazingangel623
    @blazingangel623 Před 2 lety +204

    Love these videos Dan! Having a professional author like yourself as a presenter of history goes a long way in adding a depth of narrative that truly makes history gripping. Looking forward to the next one!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Wonderful, thank you so much.

    • @18Bees
      @18Bees Před 2 lety

      Totally agree with you. BTW, I let you yellow jackets alone as you chew on my honeybees 🐝😎

    • @markuhler2664
      @markuhler2664 Před 2 lety

      Ramble on Wreck

    • @Zanenoth
      @Zanenoth Před 9 měsíci

      Professional historians do the best of job of telling history.

  • @richjordan6461
    @richjordan6461 Před rokem +8

    I was already impressed with the video but my approval skyrocketed when you went on and on about what we DON'T KNOW and MIGHT HAVE GOTTEN WRONG after telling us what we DO KNOW. That is rare to see and thus precious. I stand a new subscriber, and probably a Patreon shortly.

  • @AncientAmericas
    @AncientAmericas Před 2 lety +4

    Splendidly done! I was on the edge of my seat from start to finish!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Thanks very much! I'm a big fan of yours, that means a lot.

  • @audreydimmel6674
    @audreydimmel6674 Před 2 lety +74

    THIS. IS. FASCINATING. I've always been intrigued by ancient cultures, and I wonder often how many incredible stories they had to tell that just got lost to the flow of time. And wouldn't you know it, but I'm also writing fantasy and sci-fi! So yeah, I think I might have just stumbled across a new favorite channel. Thanks Dan! **proceeds to binge these videos with reckless abandon**

    • @Thor-Orion
      @Thor-Orion Před 7 měsíci +1

      Check this out;
      3:11 this flint arrowhead is descended from a tool making tradition known as Solutrean, there’s just absolutely no doubt about it. People don’t understand how difficult flint napping is, especially tiny arrowheads like this, someone HAS to teach you how to do it if you ever hope to get good enough to make something like this arrowhead, the larger knives are a bit easier to work with but the nicest ceremonial ones are an ancient tradition. I’m a little shocked it’s still being used anywhere this late in the Bronze Age, because for arrows flint is just… massively inferior to metals. You have to be so accurate to hit something that’ll get a kill with one shot, which is what you need for hunting more so than military use. This toolmaking tradition was used for over 20,000 years. This is super off topic from the video but you seem to be enthusiastic about the history of our people so I thought I’d give you a fun fact that he didn’t mention in the video.

  • @nicholaspikos7012
    @nicholaspikos7012 Před rokem +3

    I just had to subscribe. 2 video's in a row on my way to work. I usually watch 1 & then go for some quiet time. Bloody great historical imagination, well researched & at the same time humble. No academic elitism here. Love your work friend

  • @30035XD
    @30035XD Před 2 lety +54

    Mad respect to you Dan. You are a man to look up to. I am shocked one single individual can be so damn good at both scholarship, artistry and communication. Your name will live on, your ancestors are honoured and proud.
    I trully hope you are getting all the glory, gold, women and followers you deserve.
    Thanks for your immense contribution to the spread of knowledge among us lay folks. Your content is nothing short of a treasure. Also, your books are real page turners, I am addicted to it.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Thank you very much, delighted to hear it.

    • @30035XD
      @30035XD Před 2 lety

      @@DanDavisHistory it is from the heart Dave. Let me ask you something: do you have experience with martial arts or the military? The way you describe fighting and tactics is not common among the wider public. It is to me one of the highlights of your writing. Not because I enjoy gore but because I have a background in both and I struggle to suspend my disbelief in that regard. I can also tell from your Q&A video that you are no nerd yourself and I wondered if you have real life experience with the reality of combat.

    • @StalinLovsMsmZioglowfagz
      @StalinLovsMsmZioglowfagz Před rokem

      CZcams liege lord, lol.

  • @Badbrad5133
    @Badbrad5133 Před 2 lety +61

    There is a rich full history of man that occurred before our known history. I believe the rule of ten applies. Whatever you think ancient man did, times it by at least ten. Nice video.

  • @basilbrushbooshieboosh5302

    As always fantastic Dan. So much to think about in scenarios with this much heaped evidence.
    The truth of the matter can never be ascertained but only snippets glimpsed.

  • @galloe8933
    @galloe8933 Před 2 lety +14

    I think this channel needs more love, all around it's pretty excellent stuff.

  • @enumerado9
    @enumerado9 Před 9 měsíci +1

    It's so refreshing to see a youtube video marking the shortcomings of the information gathered and what is needed to have a better picture. Suscribed.

  • @kirkjones9639
    @kirkjones9639 Před 2 lety +3

    This answers video answers some of the questions I had. It brings on so many others as well. Thank you for another outstanding video.

  • @AdamCeladin
    @AdamCeladin Před 2 lety +66

    GREAT Video !!!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Thanks Adam.

    • @AdamCeladin
      @AdamCeladin Před 2 lety +2

      @@DanDavisHistory I gave you a sub looking forward for more videos Dan :)) Really amazing job

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Cheers mate, I hope you enjoy the other videos.

    • @Ziggiratt
      @Ziggiratt Před 2 lety

      @@AdamCeladin OMG ITS THE KNIFE THROWING DUDE! RESPECT TO BOTH OF YOU!

  • @xen4886
    @xen4886 Před 2 lety +28

    Great history delivery...thorough, interesting and humble. "Could be this....yet it could be that, these are the facts that we know." Thanks again, I enjoy your videos on some of the most difficult history to pin down.

  • @IFY0USEEKAY
    @IFY0USEEKAY Před 2 lety +8

    I didn't know what you sounded like before I found this channel but I gotta say, now I hear your voice when I read your books... Awesome vids, AND books!

  • @RemusKingOfRome
    @RemusKingOfRome Před 2 lety +12

    Excellent. All this history we've lost, none recorded for the ages.

  • @petloh1882
    @petloh1882 Před 2 lety +3

    Can’t have enough of your videos. Great work dude!

  • @ericcloud1023
    @ericcloud1023 Před 2 lety +1

    Another amazing video man please keep them coming the bronze age and Europe and Eurasia is such an under-researched and documented. But it is one of if not the most interesting to me and apparently everyone else here

  • @SharekGadd
    @SharekGadd Před 2 lety +1

    So well done! Thanks for making this!

  • @hrodvitnir6725
    @hrodvitnir6725 Před 2 lety +10

    Okay I literally had to pause the video to say: that intro was amazing! You have crazy story telling skills.

  • @lefterismagkoutas4430
    @lefterismagkoutas4430 Před 2 lety +3

    Awesome video in such an underrated topic!!! Keep up this awesome work!!!

  • @ariomannosyemo9090
    @ariomannosyemo9090 Před 2 lety +2

    Great video. You put so much time, effort, and consideration into these and it shows.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety

      Thank you, mate. I'm glad you enjoyed it. I appreciate your support.

  • @michaelterry3885
    @michaelterry3885 Před 2 lety +2

    Brilliant video Dan..
    This was a fascinating discovery, I wonder what else we will learn about this site and this battle......?
    Your a VERY creative individual, an admirable trait.. Love your storytelling... Helps put me in the proper space and time... Context is crucial..!✌ thanks again Dan...

  • @sterkar99
    @sterkar99 Před 2 lety +54

    Really love the narration in the beginning man it's obvious you're a novelist. You have a talent for storytelling

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +5

      Thank you very much.

    • @sterkar99
      @sterkar99 Před 2 lety +5

      @@DanDavisHistory Gonna look for your books. I've wanted to get back into books for a long time. Tried self-improvement, long story short not for me they cringed me. A well written novel based on one of my biggest interests in this period of time sounds like a really good idea

  • @Matt-ni8jh
    @Matt-ni8jh Před 2 lety +6

    Good as always Dan, you have a talent for narration!

  • @octodaddy4494
    @octodaddy4494 Před 2 lety +2

    Good video as always, the Tollense Valley battle is a very interesting topic.

  • @beberivera7011
    @beberivera7011 Před 2 lety +1

    This was amazing! Thank you so much for making this🥇

  • @TheEvertw
    @TheEvertw Před 2 lety +12

    The part that showed me what an incredible scholar you are, made me nearly forget the bit that showed you an awesome poet.

  • @18Bees
    @18Bees Před 2 lety +7

    Wooohoop had to comment before watching. So excited to have a Sunday (Pacific Northwest here) morning episode. Grabbing coffee and off to sit outside with my bees and listen to this one. Cheers.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      That sounds perfect. I hope you enjoy the video (and your coffee). Cheers.

    • @18Bees
      @18Bees Před 2 lety +1

      @@DanDavisHistory loved it. Tnx mate.

  • @Jamie-fl2im
    @Jamie-fl2im Před 2 lety +1

    Another great video Dan.

  • @yeraycatalangaspar195
    @yeraycatalangaspar195 Před 2 lety +10

    Loved this one, makes the imagination flee.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +2

      Thank you, good to know. I'm never sure about the "scene setting" stuff and don't want to put people off but some people ask for more of it.

  • @genoshistoria3487
    @genoshistoria3487 Před 2 lety +4

    Thanks for another great video on Bronze age warfare. I really enjoy these. I was wondering when you'd do a video on the Tollense battle, it really is such an amazing site.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Cheers mate, I appreciate it. I didn't want to do a video on it, I was going to focus on other stuff but under almost every video and post people were asking for it or asking about it. So I thought I better do it.

  • @jasoncastle4818
    @jasoncastle4818 Před 2 lety +1

    Excellent presentation!! The quality I've been searching for, where others fall short! Earned my sub!!!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety

      Thank you, welcome to the channel. I hope you enjoy the other videos.

  • @guydesnoyers8417
    @guydesnoyers8417 Před rokem +2

    Such a difference between someone who is trying to give perspective and understanding versus someone who wants to get rich talking.
    Well done Dan!

  • @symonjones43
    @symonjones43 Před 2 lety +3

    I really like the amount of nuance in this video and others of yours, its really points to your ethics as a researcher.

  • @1dayhabit
    @1dayhabit Před 2 lety +4

    I recently discovered your channel and I'm very impressed with the great range of resources that you bring together. Sometimes I get interested in an artifact or ancient tool or weapon and try to discover more about it but I don't get far in my research. You bring together great photos but also many layers of additional information and - most importantly - a great depth of context that is usually missing from written articles, photos and the like. Great work, Dan!

  • @demanager0412
    @demanager0412 Před 2 lety +1

    Im so hyped, I havent even watched the vid yet but everything about Tollense is just fascinating. Thx 4 the vid in advance, Im gonna enjoy it nonetheless.

  • @benghazi4216
    @benghazi4216 Před 2 lety +2

    I think I've rewatched the Alternative analysis chapter 10 times by now
    Very thought inspiring!

  • @FlimFlame
    @FlimFlame Před 2 lety +3

    This is fascinating, great content thanks, and good to see the detectorists get a well deserved mention, still looking for a mayoral chain

  • @jezusbloodie
    @jezusbloodie Před 2 lety +5

    I absolutely loved watching this. Such an amazing and mysterious site

  • @John-mf6ky
    @John-mf6ky Před 2 lety +2

    So glad i found this channel, I wish I did sooner though. Keep the videos coming man! ✌️

  • @stranger2Utube
    @stranger2Utube Před měsícem

    Fantastic job Dan! Subscribed! ❤

  • @laurahill9643
    @laurahill9643 Před 2 lety +20

    I love that you incorporate archaeological evidence into your fiction. I love that so much, that you make a plausible scenario out of a pile of scraps and then go on to explain it.

  • @mfbobyle6771
    @mfbobyle6771 Před 2 lety +3

    Good job!

  • @stevec7923
    @stevec7923 Před 2 lety +1

    Excellent presentation. Thank you.

  • @olwens1368
    @olwens1368 Před 2 lety +1

    An excellent intro to the subject, very informative, subscribed.

  • @edwardealdseaxe5253
    @edwardealdseaxe5253 Před 2 lety +20

    Fascinating stuff, who knows what we might be able to see from Tollense in the future!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +3

      Yeah it's such an exciting discovery and there's so much more to find out.

    • @edwardealdseaxe5253
      @edwardealdseaxe5253 Před 2 lety +6

      @@DanDavisHistory My own Y-DNA is downstream of I2a, fascinating to think some of my own distant ancestors participating here.

    • @Peter-ri9ie
      @Peter-ri9ie Před 2 lety

      @@edwardealdseaxe5253 from which company did you buy your test? Am thinking about doing it myself.

    • @edwardealdseaxe5253
      @edwardealdseaxe5253 Před 2 lety +3

      @@Peter-ri9ie I did 23andMe to get my Y-DNA, but there are other options if you just want to test for Y-DNA. Some commercial tests like AncestryDNA do not offer a sequenced Y Chromosome.

    • @Peter-ri9ie
      @Peter-ri9ie Před 2 lety +2

      @@edwardealdseaxe5253 🙏🏻

  • @riharikaa809
    @riharikaa809 Před 2 lety +9

    Excellent coverage , never heard of this battle and I have read a lot of ancient history. Thank you for enlightening myself. Keep up the good work.

  • @johncoyote6755
    @johncoyote6755 Před rokem +1

    Great video. Thank you for your work sir.

  • @olinayoung6287
    @olinayoung6287 Před 2 lety +1

    Cant wait to watch this!! Thanks so much 🍂🍁😊!!!

  • @universetraveler5826
    @universetraveler5826 Před rokem +9

    The Mycenaeans conquered Europe’s largest city at the time, Knossos in 1450 BC

    • @SithStudy
      @SithStudy Před rokem

      I think he meant the first known battle in temperate Europe

    • @peterthesneakybastar
      @peterthesneakybastar Před rokem

      @@SithStudyI doubt it. There’s not really a temperate climate in Europe. It’s a large spectrum. Also, why would anyone care about climate? They’re all Europeans

    • @stevenweaver3386
      @stevenweaver3386 Před 14 dny

      Knossos was Minoan, on Crete.

    • @universetraveler5826
      @universetraveler5826 Před 14 dny

      @@stevenweaver3386 All 3 of which are European

  • @amethyst5538
    @amethyst5538 Před 2 lety +7

    Just found your channel and I enjoy how you condense the information, yet maintaining the details. I have never heard of this specific area. I can't wait to check out your other videos.

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety

      Thanks very much, welcome to the channel. I hope you like the other videos too.

  • @tweedledumart4154
    @tweedledumart4154 Před 2 lety +1

    Great video. Thank you!

  • @FreedomToRoam86
    @FreedomToRoam86 Před 9 měsíci

    Very nicely done! I like the way you show the actual battlefield and posit how it could have happened in a nice narrative. But then you fill in the pleasant hypothesis with the info about the people and finds, and the questions that real historians and scientists should ask. Hope to see more like this!

  • @nordanina225
    @nordanina225 Před 2 lety +14

    even though I have heard about this event a number of times, your story made me feel that exciting feeling again that I felt the first time I heard about it! 👏

  • @AlbusBlanco
    @AlbusBlanco Před 2 lety +4

    Fascinating! I pass by the Tollense Valley (Tollensetal) every day on my way to work. Strange to know what happend there.

  • @FromaTwistedMind
    @FromaTwistedMind Před 2 lety +2

    Great video. Good insight & logic applied.

  • @brutusvonmanhammer
    @brutusvonmanhammer Před rokem +1

    Quickly becoming a top CZcams history channel for me

  • @keeperoftruth5951
    @keeperoftruth5951 Před 2 lety +3

    Another excellent video from an excellent author

  • @thefisherking78
    @thefisherking78 Před 2 lety +3

    Ever since I first read a little snippet about this site, I've been fascinated by all the possible interpretations.

  • @UkSapyy
    @UkSapyy Před rokem

    Thanks. Hope it goes towards a morning brew or whatever. The stories and history are great. Would you consider longer-form podcast-type stuff?

  • @petermcfarlane7978
    @petermcfarlane7978 Před 2 lety +1

    Superbly researched.Well done fella.

  • @holdenedwards8506
    @holdenedwards8506 Před 2 lety +3

    You’re officially my favorite CZcamsr now

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      Wow thanks. You liked this one.

    • @holdenedwards8506
      @holdenedwards8506 Před 2 lety +1

      @@DanDavisHistory I’ve loved all your videos! This is by far my favorite historical period and you do such a good job at explaining everything!

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety +1

      That's great to hear.

  • @custink22
    @custink22 Před 2 lety +5

    Dude, i really enjoyed that. We never really learned much about bronze age Europe in school. It was always Egypt and Greece.

  • @bialasova
    @bialasova Před rokem +1

    You've done a great documentary which displays in an eloquent and entartaining manner how much uncertainties history is about - and still how much information can be gathered with scientific method, as long as we are sincere about what the facts are, what are the guesses and what is mere speculation, as well as what research needs to be done, to know more.

  • @basfinnis
    @basfinnis Před 2 lety +2

    Very interesting and immersive. Thanks

  • @seanwhelan879
    @seanwhelan879 Před 2 lety +6

    Brilliant Dan , I thought your intro was the start of a movie. Thanks so much for the exciting history lesson , till next time Slán 🇮🇪 ,peace all

    • @DanDavisHistory
      @DanDavisHistory  Před 2 lety

      Thanks very much Sean. I never know how many people enjoy the scene setting stuff. Cheers.

  • @lloydklumpp5650
    @lloydklumpp5650 Před rokem +5

    Just came across this channel. Outstanding narrative, solid evidence based approach and broad, open minded delivery. Can’t wait to see more

  • @kimhewitt921
    @kimhewitt921 Před rokem

    Excellent stuff..thank you✌️

  • @diggingdwarf610
    @diggingdwarf610 Před 2 lety

    found you today and i must say i absolutly LOVE your voice and your videos already keep up the great work and hope to see more amazing videos in the future good luck and have a great day

  • @lottesrensen8004
    @lottesrensen8004 Před 2 lety +34

    At skanderborg in denmark they found a battlefield with I think 3000 butchered local men of all ages supposedly having met a much stronger maybe bigger army

  • @benh6455
    @benh6455 Před 2 lety +4

    You're the man, Dan

  • @danielanderson1363
    @danielanderson1363 Před 2 lety +1

    Great video!

  • @TheMoose126
    @TheMoose126 Před 2 lety +2

    You've earned yourself a Subscriber. Keep it up

  • @aleksanderwaldon992
    @aleksanderwaldon992 Před 2 lety +4

    I adore Your work, Dan! Keep going, keeping my thumbs up for You!

  • @tonymaurice4157
    @tonymaurice4157 Před 2 lety +8

    How does this channel not have a million subscribers!

  • @DamianoPetrucci
    @DamianoPetrucci Před 2 lety +1

    Very nice video. Well done

  • @heirwolf6929
    @heirwolf6929 Před 2 lety +4

    Interesting video. I especially appreciate the discussion at the end about all the different possibilities these finds could mean. All too often we only hear one or a few interpretations, making findings seem more simple and clear cut than they probably are.

  • @markuhler2664
    @markuhler2664 Před 2 lety +10

    Either this is an incredibly interesting topic that I've never found before, or your low-key presentation puts forward so well what we can discover & what we can't know (or at least with certainty). Or, most likely, both. Thank you.

  • @georgejcking
    @georgejcking Před 2 lety

    Excellent documentary!

  • @kevinmulcahy7991
    @kevinmulcahy7991 Před 2 lety +1

    Well done! Thank you. Very informative with well crafted mental imagery. Author! Author! :)

  • @philip2438
    @philip2438 Před 2 lety +7

    I love your videos man. they shine a light on a massive part of history that is frequently overlooked. keep it up!

  • @deadhorse1391
    @deadhorse1391 Před 2 lety +13

    A fascinating video…enjoyed it tremendously!
    I found it interesting to see how flint weapons were being used alongside bronze ones.

    • @01testigo
      @01testigo Před 2 lety +1

      obsidian weapons were being used alongside firearms during the Indian wars in the 19th century. It is fascinating to think about how long certain weapon types were used.

    • @zer0deaths862
      @zer0deaths862 Před 2 lety +1

      I often think it's more of a high demand kind of situation during battles when they needed to immediately supply soldiers with weapons, kinda like WW2 Sten and Grease guns, quick, easy and cheap to make.

  • @vikingbushcraft1911
    @vikingbushcraft1911 Před 2 lety +2

    Awesome video 👍👍

  • @weediestbroom
    @weediestbroom Před 2 lety +1

    I'm glad I found this channel. Fascinating stuff 👍

  • @heimdallr221
    @heimdallr221 Před 2 lety +5

    What comes to my mind are the troubles the bronze age people of Europe and wider Mediterranean suffered in this period. Dissolving of trade routed you mentioned, migrations of large groups of people and abandonment of settlements.
    It is not odd at all to immagine entire tribes and peoples from northern Europe migrating southwards in search of a new home and territory, very possible resulting in battles and skirmishes as this one.
    A great video once again Mr.Davis! Always a great time learning more about this very interesting and important period of history.

  • @perceivedvelocity9914
    @perceivedvelocity9914 Před 2 lety +5

    Great video. As a kid I loved Arnold Schwarzenegger's Conan the Barbarian movie. I know that it doesn't represent this period of time but.... To this day that's what I imagine in my head when I watch videos or read about this era of human history.

    • @markwaldron8954
      @markwaldron8954 Před 2 lety +1

      It's now been demonstrated via DNA evidence that millennia ago, Western Europe was dominated by people with black hair, brown skin, and blue eyes. Very much the way Robert E. Howard described Conan and his people the Cimmerians, though this fact wasn't known in Howard's own time. So ancient Europe was inhabited by people who looked like Conan.

  • @jcharlesbayliss
    @jcharlesbayliss Před 2 lety +1

    These films of yours really are exceptionally good.

  • @claudiocarrera9552
    @claudiocarrera9552 Před 2 lety +1

    Thank you so much, what great knowledge you have passed to us!!

  • @MauriceLeviejr
    @MauriceLeviejr Před rokem +4

    One of the ways you can gauge the violence of an era is the proportion of skeletons found with signs of violence versus those without. Another good gauge is the standardization of armaments found, both shape, composition, and relative age. The final gauge is the effectiveness of defensive armor, pieces of which are found around bodies that were never buried, this indicates an arms race and hence continuous warfare and a warrior caste

  • @metalman7791
    @metalman7791 Před 2 lety +5

    What a treat