Mandate 2024, Ep 2: BJP’s ‘parivaarvaad’ paradox, and the dynasties holding its fort
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2024
- In one election after another, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has wooed large chunks of the Indian electorate with the idea that the dynastic rule of his “corrupt” political rivals has come to an end under his government.
But the new BJP under him isn’t without dynasties. From leaders such as Jitin Prasad, Anurag Thakur, Piyush Goyal, Bansuri Swaraj and Rita Bahuguna Joshi, to erstwhile royal Jyotiraditya Scindia - who helped the party topple the Kamal Nath government and bring the BJP back to power in Madhya Pradesh.
Scindia, meanwhile, is again in the fray from Guna, where Sreenivasan Jain met his son Mahanaaryaman, a fourth generation Scindia, in the interior villages of the Madhya Pradesh constituency. He went from one village to another, asking for votes, possibly preparing for his entry into the world of politics.
But Scindia Junior denies allegations of ‘parivaarvaad’, saying that him being part of Scindia’s campaign is not a political debut. “This is me supporting my father.” He insists that his only inheritance has been a devotion to public service, and all that he is focussing on is his company. “When sons join businesses, that’s not dynastic politics.”
The BJP, meanwhile, offers a convoluted defence.
Asked about BJP allies from political dynasties, including Ajith Pawar and Jayant Chaudhary, a BJP leader says, “Raja Ram, to defeat Ravana, do you know whose help he took? I will not give you a bigger example than this. To destroy Ravana we need Vibhishan. The goal is what is important.”
Asked about the party’s decision to field leaders like Jyotiraditya Scindia, another insists that “this is not about family”. “Dynasty is when you are launched. Maharaja Scindia does a lot of hard work. He goes to affected people, people who are suffering, he goes to their house.”
But in the remote parts of Guna, development is skewed and locals say the Maharaja last visited them when he was part of the Congress. Even then, faith in the dynasty seems to be unwavering.
A local who points to issues such as uninterrupted power supply and joblessness says he will still vote for the BJP leader. “See we believe in him, that he will find solutions to our problems.”
On the campaign trail, it seems evident that dynasty may help overcome some discontent of the kind that’s seen in Guna. And parivaarvaad across party lines is here to stay for long.
--------------------------------------------------
#LokSabhaElections2024 | You choose who forms the government. You also choose who you trust to help you make an informed decision. Help us empower you.
Pick a project you want and power @newslaundry and @thenewsminute's election coverage.
www.newslaundry.com/2024-elec...
Support our work. Become a TNM Member: www.thenewsminute.com/subscri...
Thank you for exposing the hypocrisy that is being practised by all these parties.
Rahul Gandhi ji has a clear vision for youth employment. Save the constitution vote for Congress
@@Dr.Pranav_Lohiya10 years of andere is electoral bond
Yes
Rahul baba is a Pakistani feet licker
70 sal chat liya ab to chhodo 😅😅
@@natvarsinhzala9078 , 10 saal se modi ki pod chata phir tumko berojgar bana diya aab toh chodo😂
@@Dr.Pranav_Lohiya look who is talking,
Way to go, Srinivasan Jain. I'm glad you are back
this time he seems to be biased in his coverage. Like he has been fielded by the opposition to highlight BJP's weaknesses but still Srinivasan Jain is definitely class apart. That core NDTV group like him Rajdeep Sardesai Ritika Baruah Ankita Chatterjee and of course Ravish Kumar and others were definitely journalists. Even if they were biased they asked real questions and reported on real issues. Journalists today ask set questions and do scripted interviews and try to influence people's opinion rather than report news.
I am so happy to see Sreenivasan Jain again on facts Vs reality.
True journalism
Srinivasan Jain !!!! We really miss you ..A Gentleman who always report nothing but the truth ..thank you sir for your revelation ..may your channel prosper & best of luck
Guys like Jain resurfacing is really a good sign, appreciate Srinivasan Jain for his brave report.
Excellent job by Srinivasan Jain as usual ❤❤❤
Thank you Srinivasan Jain. The world still goes around and we dont lose hope because some people like you still exist. Never lose your integrity please.
Little Scindia 28 not so little but damn what a luxury life and look at us who make these people rich by choosing them as our leaders and they keep us as middle class as we were.
*RAHUL GANDHI IS OUR HERO - NARENDRA MODI A BIG ZERO*
😂
Correct bro❤
No doubt 💯
I love this journalist, he has got some balls to walk around these bjp goons
😂😂😂😂 Old fag irrelevant reporter setting in to Sun 😅😅..... India 🇮🇳 moved long back from these commie stooge who has nothing substantial and meaningful to add... Nothing constructive.. Indian 👳♀️ 🇮🇳 journalists are biggest jokers 🃏 😂😂😂😂 😂😂😂😂 Old fag irrelevant reporter setting in to Sun 😅😅..... India 🇮🇳 moved long back from these commie stooge who has nothing substantial and meaningful to add... Nothing constructive.. Indian 👳♀️ 🇮🇳 journalists are biggest jokers 🃏 😂😂😂😂 😂😂😂😂 Old fag irrelevant reporter setting in to Sun 😅😅..... India 🇮🇳 moved long back from these commie stooge who has nothing substantial and meaningful to add... Nothing constructive.. Indian 👳♀️ 🇮🇳 journalists are biggest jokers 🃏 😂😂😂😂
He sees only leftward .😂
@@AjayKumar-re2zp you can go get your right wing ass screwed somewhere else
@@AjayKumar-re2zpgo cry 😂
Sri Sreenivasan jain , happy to see you after very long time. Our good wishes.
I appreciate your thoughtfull courageous comments about BJP , exposing them. Great work for the nation.
Vote responsibly vote for change
I feel sad on that poor man who believes them
it's depressing
Honestly, I was afraid when he was asking to the Sangh supporters eye-opening questions, thinking whether supporters would turn aggressive towards the reporter and do harm to him.
That is the difference between Congress bhakts and BJP supporters. 😢
@@AjayKumar-re2zpthis is election time otherwise BJP/RSS bhakt reaction like their masters modi-shaw.
@@AjayKumar-re2zp there is no difference between chamelions and bjp supporters🤣🤣
@@AjayKumar-re2zp we all know who are extremists
Andha bhaktha open your eyes @@AjayKumar-re2zp
Looking at the villages in the footage, i womder what they have been developing for generations 🧐
Many thanks for making these brilliant reports … parivaarwad in our country is rampant across the political spectrum, business both big and small, and professions like advocates. Scindias and similar erstwhile Raja families who were rulers for centuries under British patronage and are now in politics are probably the most glaring and glamorous examples. As your video showed, we as people too are still mixed up about our democratic and feudal instincts
In dynastic parties only sons and daughters are chosen to lead the party.,this is the basic difference between dynastic parties and others.
Srinivasan Jain all the best, we like your reporting from the days of ND tv
Welcome Vasu to the NL team. Please stay a regular in the independent media "parivar"
Please provide English subtitles
You missed TN's PMK, a BJP ally, lead by father-son duo, which has fielded son's wife in this election.
Rahul Gandhi ❤
Srinivasan ji...the journalists like u r doing the commendable job when it is really a toughest with lot of troubles but salute to u other honest & dedicated journalists with principal stand
As long as people are illiterate in terms of actually not sure of what they really want or in need, democracy will continue to remain an utter misnomer.
Thnx Mr Srini for coming back . For Television 📺 news from our age ur were one of an Icon like Mr Karan Thapar n Ms Bharka .
Ahh what a series ! It is the true depiction of journalism!
Shreenivas Jain was elite journalist in Congress regime and never questioned such issues during Congress rule.
So happy to see you Vasuji proud of you🎉🎉🎉
Great work
Journalism 👍
Great ground reporting by Srinivasan.. used to love his election coverage on NDTV .. saw the same spark here ..it is unfortunate that despite the dire state people are in many places, they still choose to vote for same people over decades. How come then there is an incentive to perform ?
I am from mpm
Digvijay singh, scindhia , pachauri, bd sharma
These are curse on mp politics. Expert on manipulation
Truthful depiction on hypocrisy of dynastic politics. Presented in a very entertaining way with excellent graphics ❤
How does this journalist walk around with those heavy balls?
He is Aljazeera journalist. So no one would touch him. It may lead another issue . It belongs to the Qatari govt . So his ball is strong
@@Rose-Jackie kuch bhi it cell lies.
@@Rose-Jackiebro graduate from andhbakt WhatsApp university with top sanatan diploma on how to make people others enemy
Good presentation
BJP was boasting that they will never indulge in any corruption and punish those who are corrupt. But it is (ELECTROL bond) evident that BJP is the WORLD LEADER / CHAMPION of CORRUPTION & Modi is the CAPTAIN OF THE TEAM.
Sreenivasan Jain does a good job in journalism
Very good information Sir
Please put subtitles. Can’t understand what the others are saying
Scindia use to say that he will throw mama shivraj singh
Now he says he ll throw out cong leader
Good to see you back Sreeni!
vajpayee ji advice to modi on unemployment
if we must wage war, we have to do it on unemployment, disease, poverty, and backwardness.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Srinivasan sir is the best journalist and he is very honest and brave
You must be joking ,he happened to be a run down Rahul supporter
Sreenivas’ ground reporting has been consistently stellar over the years. Super glad to see him in action again.
👍 Good job
Scindia son is a noob 😂😂
Modi is PM.
Is it because of his sacrifice,talent , administrative skills , reliability,leadership qualities ,integrity ,ect which are essentials to be a leader.
Must watch video
In the last century, Gandhi / Nehru's family contributed more than any other family in India. The family icon had given his palatial house in Allahabad to be used by the Congress party as its office to fight the Britishers during our struggle for Independence. His Son Pandit Nehru spent nine years in Jail fighting for our Independence. Then, as PM, he set up modern India's foundations: our constitution, democracy, steel plants, IITs, IAMS, space and atomic research centres, canals and dams, etc. The list is endless. His Daughter defeated our Arch enemy on the battlefield, took 90,000 Pakistani soldiers as prisoners, and broke Pakistan into two, creating Bangladesh. She gave her life as PM of India fighting terrorism. Her son Rajiv Gandhi started the telecom revolution in India, which has made India a superpower in IT and facilitated digital India. He also sacrificed his life-fighting terrorism. His wife, Sonia Gandhi, did not accept to become PM of India, which was offered on a platter and Made a top economist in the world, Manmohan Singh, the PM of India in the national interest. Today his son Rahul Gandhi after doing the Bharat Jodo Yatra of 3500 Km, is opening a " Mohabat Kee Dukan."He is supporting the oppressed. Naya Yatra has covered 6000 km to determine what India wants, as reflected in the Congress Manifesto.
In the Last 32 years, nobody from this Parwar has occupied any profit-making position in the government. We should have more Parwars like Gandhi Parwar and less of Sang Parwar.
Just by giving his house doesn’t mean anything when you have looted the whole Country
@@Jack-lr5ol: I suggest you read the entire comment.
Good job ....🎉🎉🎉
indeed look at the paradox. Scindia Maharaj versus the people living in utter poverty right in his constituency. At least Shivraj Singh Chauhan was better. He did something as CM for the people of MP.
Thanks
Thanks!
Brave reporter....
People are not realising what they are going to loose for themselves and the Nation.
Meaningful reporting, Keep it up and all the best wishes.
Sir aap ne to chamchon ki bolti band kerdi😂
I think time has come we common public must uproot these false Royal families running their Political business 😢
❤❤❤
👍👍
A huge respect for Madavrao Scindia, a figure in congress but disasters happened to him , one of the disaster is now on the video- I hope someone talk about the neglected problems of poor and suffering people of a old dynasty or kingdom called Guna, India 🇮🇳
Newsminute Call for all citizens to picket election commission offices around the country on a particular date demanding 100% counting of paper ballots . The eci has the power to do so. Supreme court order not required
While INDI alliance is only parivar, BJP has few dynastic members as well. But it is way lesser than INDI alliance partners
If little bit poison mixed with milk then also it will be hazards to the health...
Not matters about quantity ..
@@karunakarang5545 In politics we always chose the lesser evil. That is the point.
@@himadrib4743shinde, ajit powar, naidu, paswan, scindia purandeswari, ravneet singh bittu, milind theora, edurappa sons, dewa gowda sons, grand sons, suvendu adikari, prema khandu, reeta bagukuna joshi, piyush goel, tamilasai soundarajan, namasivayam, dushyant singh, jaseant singh son, rajnath singh son, rbn singh, naveen jindal, amrinder singh, suniljakur,anurag takur, jiden prasad, all are orphans not dynasties.
@@D.ThirumalaikumarKumar If others don’t have problem why will BJP have?
@@himadrib4743 then why modi barking this issues in poll speeches?
Modi what about Rafael Ayushman Bharat Electoral Bonds capturing MLAs toppling govts.
Do not confuse family party with party workers of a party .
😂😂😂😂😂bjp has become so desperate to win that they do not realizes that they are making themselves a laughing subject
Exposed 🔥
Getting ground realities is a strong breather from the “ghutan” of the Godi media 👍
The word pariwadi doesn't hold any relevance as there are pariwadis in every party. This is just to distract the people not to vote for Congress and INDIA bloc.
👌👌👌👌👌👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
The rally looks lackluster , hardly any crowd . How is Maharaj going to win?
Thanks to Godi media for making people believe that the “intention” of PM is good.
BJP full of paarivaadi candidates
Elite group of journalist of past years are exposing the erstwhile loopholes of their regime by questioning the same things with present regime of BJP. Trying to confuse the issue of PARIVARVAD. In family owned parties too man matters not politicians of the party.
How come these guys vote after coming to work in South India and don't question these guys'multi generation rules.
Bharat General Electron
3rd Phase ...one MP unanimously Elected party BJP
4th Phase...2 MPS unanimously elected
Party BJP.
5th Phase...4 MPS unanimously Elected
Party BJP.????
6th phase...8 MPS unanimously Elected
Party BJP ????
7th Phase...16 MPS unanimously Elected
Party BJP. ????
As per above only BJP party eligible for Unanimously Electron anywhere in Bharat. ????
He studied in Yale . Ye sarkaari school sudhaarega ??
Haha you think ? They’re all here for their own power bro
Fact is- people are themselves responsible to elect PARIVARVADI, and they enjoy their lives by being minister, MP MLA etc and people themselves suffer. And Whole electoral political system is PARIVARVADI, same goes with businessmen, Media, Bollywood etc. Hoarding mindset and othering midset has destroyed society, which results in one teenage travels in car surrounding cars other is seeking simple college!
To bjp politician and its follower the same thing done by them is justifiable but not they do not justify the opposition of dynastic politics😂
I was wondering why the Prime Minister’s interpretation of Parivarvad party explained in parliament was not played in this show. Playing the clip would probably go against the narrative set in this episode
What is it? Don't you think that BJP allies like JDS, TDP, NCP etc take party decisions through their founder families?
There is a point there, but don’t think using this limiting definition other instances of parivaarwad mentioned in the report can be overlooked or papered over
Wah Wasooliwala Modaniji Wah, Ache din?
BJP crossesall standards of decency and amplifies isolated events.
BJP frequently reiterates its contempt for the constitution and indeed the rule of law that people of the country enjoy.
Hypocrisy ka bhi seema hota hae!
Congress Parivar Shifts to BJP. Common is Parivarvad. Both parties are Parivarvadi. RSS/BJP parivar or Congress parivar.
Rajiv
Canada
There is no bar on the highest position of power in BJP unlike the party that funds this "news dhobighat".
Modaniji the Liar, the hypocrite and the dictator!
He definitely is better than the Scumbag Raul
Only Modiji and Gabbar Singh are exceptions to dynastic loot! I mean the dynasty, not the loot! 😂
Congress mukt means that those who cannot be defeated electorally must be co opted into BJP either with incentives or through coercion or a mix of both.
Nobody joins BJP out of love.
Most of the politicians have have business or business interests, and protect their businesses they make ....
Dhruv Rathee single handedly did what the entire opposition couldn't do combined 🔥🔥🔥
Fools paradise. Is his reach to 140 crores. Ha ha ha 😂
@@anueenu1 Just because of him...NRIs are coming to India to vote for Congress and Muslim League
@@pkmuhammedhisan i don't know why you bjp bhakts are so triggered over indian union muslim league, the party that was founded in 1948 and its constitution drafted in 1950.
meanwhile hindu mahasabha and rss joined hands with the real muslim league to support partition of india. it was savarkar who in 1937 supported two nation theory before jinnah. they joined hands while congress opposed the partition.
iuml is popular in north kerala and parts of tamil nadu. if there are hindu parties, whats wrong with there being a muslim party?
got caught...also a smoker...very yuppy
16:07 😂
Im from south india
Need subtitles for better understanding...
Pls consider and resolve this.
Need badly
State of a royal family's constituency is pathetic 🙄 Need more strong regional partners to focus more on local issues...
Please Put English subtitles while
Speaking in Hindi......
How can u fight dis mentality of people, no wonder it takes generation.
What Srinivasan Jain should drive on the question of 'parivarvad' is the scuttling of talent it leads to. Is Rahul or Akhilesh or Tejaswi the best people possible to lead Congress or SP or RJD! That is what is weakening those parties in the long run.
Look at the state of JD(S) in Karnataka - they lost Siddharamaiha because they would not give him the top job (CM) because it is reserved for Gowda genetic line.
Jain should have framed questions better, and in this same piece gone to other non-BJP parties and asked them if the best talent in their will always always be from the founder/leading families.
Modi just talks about pariwarwad just for the heck of it. Without these family members, BJ P will not last.
Hypocrites
@news laundry in the name of independent journalism don't be biased. Parivarvad is there in many parties but you there is a difference like how many leaders are contesting from the same family at same time. The no. Of families in BJP Vs other parties.
17:27 then how is it wrong when a star kids begins his career behind the scenes assisting and learning the trade before launch? Yeh wahi log hai jo nepotism nepotism kar rahe they 4-5 saal.
Winnability is the primary concern, more than anything else. I would even say the caste angle has more to do with winnability than the caste itself.
Religion politics doesn't work in this country.