How to know if your dryfire is wrong
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 06. 2024
- Benstoeger.com
Benstoegerproshop.com for gear
PSTG.US for in person classes and digital coaching
Ben Stoeger books on Amazon: www.amazon.com/s?k=ben+stoege...
Podcast from pstg:
traininggrouplive-pstg.libsyn... - Sport
Great advice! Some SF instructors pointed me to your channel and I am glad they did!
Ben I need your help. I wrapped the resistance bands around my nuts but I’m still not seeing a sub second draw. Any thoughts on what I’m doing wrong?
You should have your boyfriend check the tension on your bands. You will be excited by the results
"Dryfire" are my favorite videos.
I used to think my dryfire was my issue, too, but over time, I realized my issue was my inability to assimilate the feedback I was getting from my dry fire. See I originally just thought dry firing all day every day would make me better. Then, eventually, one day, I listened to what my gun was trying to tell me.
This
I can't hear what my gun is saying. Will porting my gun make it louder?
I think a lot of people have a misconception of what dry fire will do for them when not consistently testing what they have been doing at home in their live fire. You can’t just put in the reps at home and not go to the range for 3 months then go and think you will see immediate improvement. That range day after those 3 months of reps was, in reality, was your first test of your dry fire, so if it was wrong you just wasted 3 months possibly building bad habits. I have learned that the best use of my time and ammo was work on some key things in dry fire for a bit then test that at the range with live fire. If that range day was successful then find the next thing to focus on that needs improvement. If it didn’t work, use that range day to figure out why, then tweak your dry fire and try again. But don’t simulate a “range day” at home over and over but never go to the range to test what you have been doing.
I tried months of dryfire, no range, and my mikes increased big time. I think you MAY be onto something!
Dryfire is an art form and extremely beneficial when done correctly / effectively. I do like Ben said, focus on a single skill at a time, sometimes combining two skills. I start slow to make sure the core technique is correct, then speed up, cutting the par time until I find my failure point then spend more time at that par time until comfortable, then cut the par time. The other important thing with dry fire is, you have to be honest with yourself! If you see the sight move as you press the trigger, embrace that error, don't think that's OK, try again until you know you get it right, then cut your par time. Be realistic, don't expect an 0.9s draw to 1st shot from concealment while you're struggling to make it in 1.5s, keep working. Lots of good dry fire resources out there, some guy Ben something, published a book "Dryfire Reloaded", I find very good. You're welcome Ben. Keep up the great vids. When are you expecting your Staccato?
Man, this channel is really concise and helps a lot. I really appreciate how much you seem to give a shit, thanks for that.
Absolutely solid advice. I find myself falling into dryfire ruts and this is the kind of thing I need to hear.
You really do the most to help him instead of just saying he should take a class. Noice!
Love to see subtle hints of the conscious/subconscious mind starting to creep into your videos. Steve was pretty much the only one talking about this at one stage, couple it with your ability to talk about the actual "doing" side of shooting and its a win win for everyone watching your videos.
People miss the 4 levels of incompetent competence a lot out of naivety, to add on to your very beneficial comment, so here’s a tip for the people
At the bottom of the pyramid we have
Unconscious incompetence, essentially ignorance to your drills or rhythms to what you need to
Do and know
Then above that we have unconscious competence, you know know what you need to know but still have to proactively think about it in order to employ it.
Next is subconscious competence, this is the level where the proper habits are there and start to become second nature. Lastly at the top of the pyramid we have awareness, this is where you know longer have to think about what you are doing but you have the ability to bring forth attention to something that needs attention. Think of tying your shoe, you can look wherever you want and tie your shoe but if you want to assure your shoe is now tied you can bring your attention to the shoe and confirm or change what you want with the knot.
This is great advice, I’ve been using dry fire reloaded and these extra clarifications really help.
Ben, I love your honesty.
Best video yet
Thanks!
That end comment is great😂
We all spend a lot of time trying to figure out how top shooters do what they do. This leads to a lot of drills done mechanically without a lot of understanding.
Your recent video on doubles is a perfect example. I have been working on doubles for a couple months, and I have been doing it completely wrong. I had the surface idea but didn’t have the deeper understanding of how to approach and evaluate the exercise.
My guess is most people fail to make progress more because of how they approach training than because of how much they train. Have you noticed any common traits among the shooters who have a high round count but persistently hang out on a mediocre plateau of skill?
A more in depth discussion on how to induce the same sort of mistakes that live rounds going off causes (i.e., in live fire) in dry fire would be helpful. Thanks.
Thanks for such good coaching. After you have done possibly 1,000s of reps of dryfire, is pulling the trigger on every rep of dry fire conditioning you to potentially automatically pull the trigger in a real-life situation. Is there some benefit to intersperse shoot reps with a no shoot rep?
Those mantis training systems are really worth the money
New here.
(Were you really on "The Simpsons"?! Reffering to your channel pic.)
I was referred to your channel by a firearms instructor at my local range. I took 5 classes recently, and the final 2 were for my concealed carry which was when the instructor gave us names of channels to check out. Yours was on the list.
Thanks for the information! I look forward to continually getting better.
Have you heard of praxis protocol by Mike Ochsner? I’ve been using his dry fire training and I would like to know your thoughts if you have any on it. Thank you for the videos Ben!
There is an app that helps with making the dry fire training more aggressive. It’s called dry practice drill. It has some par times for different drills and you can crest your own drills. It keeps you from doing the whole “go slow” mentality.
Yep! Love that app! My favorite dry fire app these days.
I can't find anything by the name "dry practice drill"
What is the exact name of the app?
@@EDP_every_day_pyro That’s a fair question! I can’t figure out what’s up, but when I search the App Store (iOS) I can’t find it anywhere. I saw it there as recently as last week, so that’s weird and I have no idea what’s up with that… 🤷🏽♂️
It’s just called dry practice drill, but I can’t find it in the App Store. Weird, cause it’s still on my phone and I can use it.
It’s only up on the Google Play Store. Must’ve been removed from the iOS App Store for some reason
Can you elaborate on keeping dryfire real through the lens of par times? For example: do you subscribe to the belief that dry par times should always be some fraction (say 80%) of targeted live times? Or is it better to start with a dry time that 1:1 matches an imperfect live time, with a focus on hammering out process fixes to address relevant issues at that speed - before seeing what breaks again at a more aggressive pace?
How wrong should dry fire be? Let's say I'm simulating a plate rack in dry fire. I set a par time that I can't easily accomplish. How many reps should I judge as correct? And would this be correct for only a single aspect of the rep, e.g., target focus, or for all aspects?
👍
👍🏻
Could be all mental. His mental mindset maybe falling apart when it gets real
Question: I am doing some steel challenge comps just for the purpose of "training" for uspsa. I dry fire 75% hands below belt 25% surrender position. This week I have switched to doing more reps in the surrender position but even after 3-4 hours of dry fire my surrender position is SIGNIFICANTLY slower, is this normal? If I try to speed up I get a poor grip and my logic is I would rather have a good grip then a fast draw with poor grip.
Drawing from wrists above shoulders will never be as fast as wrists below belt simply due to distance of the gun from your hands. Especially considering that scoop draw is possible from wrist below belt.
However, you can try alternating you hand positions in wrists above shoulder to improve the path to the gun. Some top level SCSA shooters will use a consistent index point like a hat for their starting hand position as well.
Surrender position is probably between 0.1 and 0.2 seconds slower. Not getting a good grip is lack of familiarity with the surrender position draw.
@@nathanjames7030 thanks
@@ggjuggosauri I'll try to find a good index point that is consistent
@@nathanjames7030 I would second this. That time differential maps for me, as well. Bane is right, at the end, too - no matter how fast your draw, if you don't take the needed time to come out of the holster with a good grip, the mistake propagates out along your whole stage or string of fire. Take the time it takes to get a perfect grip, and not a millisecond more. ;-)
🤯
I can dry fire till the cows come home with a timer or without, dime trick or not, punch the trigger or suprise break. Done it all over the years and rocky steady at home but with live fire it goes low left.
Oddly enough even tho it’s been a while since I did uspsa I did have the same problem when shooting a stage
It sounds like a mentality issue more than a practice issue. If your training is going out the window it's because your panicking. Work on that and you'll match training with reality.
Measure BPM and cortisol level in dry fire and in competition. Learning how to control the adrenal stress reaction is the first step.
Man what the f…
@@thedirtyb4stvrd Combat science.
It sounds like there is no substitute for live-fire, and that dry-firing will only get you so far. You cannot "fake" the recoil of the gun.
nonsensical conclusion
Finding the proper balance is an art. Live fire shooting can also hide some of your mistakes just like dryfire can. Enjoy the journey. 🙂
The thing is a massive percentage of problems/errors in shooting occur before the pistol recoils.
Dry fire, live fire and competition is an interconnected triangle that you have to continuously maintain in order to recognize strengths and weaknesses in each area. You'll have to learn which skills carry over from one area to another, and continuously work on the bottlenecks between them through HONEST self-assessment. "Don't criticize - analyze", as some dude said.
Realizing you're not as hot shit as you thought you were when going from dry fire to live fire, and worse yet, to competition, is part and parcel of the process, IMO.
@@Pedestrian777well said
ben - team israel or team palestine? be honest