Touching the Dog is Prohibited Due to Rabies & Hydrophobia but now...
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 12. 2018
- Touching the Dog is Prohibited Due to Rabies & Hydrophobia but now there is Vaccine for Curing it, so Why Haraam?
Question & Answer Session of Lecture "Is Islaam the Solution for the Problems of Humanity?"
I love muselimes and every religions but millions of people touch dogs sleep with them including me I have not suffered a single illness or stuff like that dogs are the most loyal creature which loves you more than you do please respect them and love them❤️❤️
True but they're small chances that it will infected you with disease, and worst, could kill you.. there was a case where a guy's legs got amputated due to the disease transmitted from his own dog..doctor said the chances are less to none but, there's still a chance..so better to avoid
There’s articles online of people catching diseases from dogs. I suggest you read some
I avoid idiots and i avoid religious people because i do not want to catch their mental illness.
@@SIRAJPRODUCTIONS there are a higher risk from getting disease from humans than dogs
@@human1754 yes, but most of them are harmless and you can avoid humans. If you have a dog you're choosing to spend time with it
Touching a dog is not forbidden under Maliki school of thought. This is not to contradict Dr Naik but simply to point out that there are differences in interpretation of Scripture and these valid differences are actually a mercy.
Dr. Zakir didn't explain about the touching of dogs in this video but he did explain in other video..he said that you can touch dog but only in their head because dog can't lick up to their head..and also when they're dry..this is to prevent the saliva which could contain bacteria from being transmitted to your skin..
Hanafi, too.
@@eleanorrigby226 According to Imam Maliki he says that fur or saliva of the dog is pure(and Abu Hanifa too)which is it's a different opinion with Imam Syafi'i's statement about the dog that he says both the fur and the saliva is impure.
There is not a question except that Dr. Zakir Naik comes with the best of solutions. We all should be grateful for having him in this Ummah
Yeah I seriously don't like dr. Zakir answer at all.
@@stephennoronha6261 way to be a good Islam ambassador. 😂😂 telling people they are stupid Muslims isn't the Islamic way of telling people you disagree.
@@stephennoronha6261 learn to be more respectful...
I just love him. He is a great gift of Allah for Muslims.
@@tajulkhan7688 you might want to reword thats brother. Gift FROM Allah.
His logic only applies if the dog is rabid ... most dogs these days aren’t
In my country,(Australia) rabies doesn't exist. It never reached this island. 100% dogs are free from rabies.
So why not? His explanation makes no sense.
Rabies doesn't just apply to dogs it applies to cats and other wild animals as well who are infected by the disease
@@familyguy8494 well in australia everyother animal could kil u so who cares. also the religion was design for middle east and muhamed time and has been that way for thousands of years
Most dogs* not all dogs and Islam has come for every person in the world whether he is a uneducated man and does not know about diseases that comes with dogs or whether he knows and has vaccine, the rule after all is one!
@@familyguy8494 Most dogs* not all dogs and Islam has come for every person in the world whether he is a uneducated man and does not know about diseases that comes with dogs or whether he knows and has vaccine, the rule after all is one!
It's funny how the answer makes the questions sound silly.
brother! dare to find the truth,may be you are not satisfied with this answer.but you have to know,whom you pointing.dare to know about your religion scripts about truth,its not necessary,you should follow your ancient or close people,may be they are wrong may be others,search for it na!dare to do,but make sure you are having authentic information!so check various sources and take the valid one.its a request for you,to help yourself!!!
@@mdforhaduddinpolash1562 owh.. this is just a copy paste of your reply to other comments.
@@ariscosollover73 yes,its above their you can see!not a big deal.you can understand my intention,i am not making money,and my intention is why we stopped thinking in the age of science!and following things emotionally,others can be right,why dont we think so!
@@mdforhaduddinpolash1562 I'm sorry.. I could not understand your frustration.
It's ok!may be frustration can be helpful for you in some way!
If Zakir Nalayak is a Dr, then most of us are super-humans....by the way, I have jumped 4 floors to rescue a baby and a 🐕, I didn't break my bones and thank God for that.
♥️♥️♥️
He's a medical doctor and by his logic he's saying would you intentionally jump 2 storey when there is no need? You claim to have jumped 4 storeys (bulls*it but we'll go with it) to save a baby and dog, if the baby and dog didn't require rescuing, would you still have jumped 4 storeys?
He was talking about dogs' saliva. An medical doctor from 3rd world country would give you the same advice. I have lost a relative because of a stray dog who came into contact with a child...do you idots realize what rabies is? It's certain death. Any sane person would tell you to not come into contact with a saliva of a stray dog. But you can touch and feed them. Prophet Muhammad said 1 person went to heaven just for feeding a dog.
as a muslim and a dog lover, I've been asking this for my whole life !!
I wanted a dog so bad that i had to secretly have a dog at work, i kept the puppy somewhere in the construction site. Fed him every morning, lunch time and before I'm leaving work. I love that dog so much and the only time i have to play with him was justt at my lunch break time. This is so sad, for me.
I'm having problem understanding the answer from this doctor. Not because of his accent, but it just doesn't make sense for me. Sorry.
Same 😢. how is the dog doing now?
@@Ameerkat one morning, i came to work early as usual to feed him, but he wasn't there. He is missing. I think, someone took him, because he was such a friendly, happy and gentle dog. And i heard someone was watching him since few days before he was missing.
I didn't put a leash on him as I feel like it's cruel bcoz he deserve freedom.
I don't know what breed he was, but he kinda looks like a rottweiler mixed with some other breed.
He was my baby boy :(
Ok, now I miss him, and sad.
@@noone-cb3jm sorry...it’s hard to lose an animal you love so much. I understand.
Love your kindness ♥️
So basically Dr. Zakir said is prevention is better than cure..true there are vaccines, but how sure are we that these vaccines can 100% prevent us from any diseases or bacteria transmitted from dogs? And you also need to remember that the rules of Islam are applied to all people, to all generations since Muhammad's SAW time..1) there are no vaccines back then, the vaccines were invented in modern time 2)not all people can afford to pay for their pet's vaccination..this is a matter of hygiene..you can keep them as a guard dog or hunting, but never keep them as an indoor dog..if you really want to care for the dog, you can feed them, touch their head only when it's dry but never keep them inside your house
Dogs are not parasites. Dogs have been useful throughout history for hunting, tracking, and companionship. You can train a dog to bring you your slippers. Taking them for a walk gives you incentive to exercise. Then there are seeing-eye dogs, therapy dogs, bomb/drug sniffing dogs. Dogs can be trained to pull a sled, assist blind people to find their way around, and provide crucial emotional support for countless people (look up the 1925 Nome serum run for why this is important). They can help you herd animals. If you have a dog and treat them well, they will literally fight to protect you. There's a reason they were one of the first animals humans domesticated.
That's not the problem tho. I'm pretty sure Islam teaches people to not share saliva with a dog in the same way you would with a human. So eating off the same plate and whatever. I'm not muslim and don't know much about Islam, but this is just what I think they meant.
@@NoCluYT Dogs are allowed to hunt for you with their mouth
Guy: Asks a question in a purely respectful and curious manner.
Other Guy: Humiliates the f*ck out of him and his curiosities.
I'm one of his followers and an animal lover too and from both aspects this answer is irrational n illogical from religious purpose..maybe he doesn't know this answer or there is conflict on this topic and he wants to avoid it.
His answer is true and you are wrong
Exactly because lots of animals get rabies, not just dogs. And dogs are vaccinated against rabies in the modern world. There is a difference between a wild dog and domesticated dog
@@user-km6fq3nk2m rabbits, foxes, raccoons, and other animals also get rabies, so the fear of dogs is not rational.
@@bamu8328 no dog has more danger (scientifically)then other animals
@@bamu8328 Bye
I want to use this logic to everything in life
Same dude
Could embracing Islam make someone violent and become a terrorist? Yes. So prevention is better than cure, don't embrace Islam. Are you using that logic in this part of life already?
wilson ganks Anything could make someone a terrorist. Mind telling me why the Pope started a crusade?
Ruizhi Pieter answer is simple. Religion!
@@wilsonganks Religion was only in second place as a reason. The real reason for the Crusades was the violent Islamic conquest over a period of about 500 years and the liberation of Jerusalem. This Islamic violence over centuries is the greatest genocide in human history, with about 300 million murdered "infidels". No one less than Muhammad was responsible for this.
I love my life when I see dr zakir's new video notification
@@matiullahhosseini8798 Masha'Allah
You love Zakir Nike?? Yaakk!
It is haram to watch/idolize Spiderman!!
You are living Primitive, Dude. :P
Rudy Chan Be respectful to strangers dude
Same
Why No videos in his channel please tell me
This channel should not have 1 million subscriber but 10000000000000000000 Trillion
@Smart Khan omg thank you.
Smart Khan shut up why are u hateing i see on Every coment what is wrong with u
For a trillion subscribers u gotta bring the suicide bombers and their 72 virgins back from jannah
Vinnith Rama Murti shut up 🐮🐮🐮🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩🥩 with ur shitty 🐘🐘🐘
بارك الله فيك يا شيخنا رزقك الله الصحة والعافية اللهم آمين
That doesn't make any sense, cats can also have rabies and their saliva contain germs and yet Muslims can have pet cats
Not much makes sense in religion.
Massively dated lies designed to control people through fear.
I was very eager for your new videos....nd finally... Alhamdulillah
If you were to own a dog, you would vaccinate the dog when it is a puppy and revaccinate the dog every few years when required just as we humans do in our lives.
I own a dog, my dog lives in the garden, he has a big house and the freedom to run. He is vaccinated to prevent HIM from getting multiple diseases... Every couple of years he has treatment to prevent him from getting parasites (worms) and recieves treatment to prevent fleas and ticks and other parasitic infestations.
I would love to say that he has a use (like a guard dog or a worker dog) but really it's not true - or maybe he does... He honestly supported me through very difficult times in my life.
I don't believe dogs should be living in the house as I am not sure why exactly, but angels do not enter the home... I believe this now as at one point in the past I used to let him sleep next to the back door and it was difficult to cleanse the house of the bad energies sobhanallah, I'm not sure why this is but I know it is.
After touching my dog I will wash my hands very well as I would if I was outside touching the ground, dirt or any other animal.
I keep a seperate outdoor jacket and clothes to wear when I am with him so that I don't put dirt or hair on my normal / home clothes.
I think the most important thing is to practice good hygiene in life, to wash hands after anything you touch that is dirty or potentially dirty. To keep home clothes seperate from outside clothes or clothes that you work in. (I don't like seeing people walking to the mosque wearing the clothes they will pray in - sometimes I see people walking down the street when it is raining, muddy and the dirt of the street and the people splashing at the abaya and it honestly makes me feel slightly sad. I feel like praying deserves a nice clean clothes seperate. Unless this is impossible. If you go to gym you will take a gym outfit to sweat in and then once you shower you return your clothes to go home or maybe you will go home and shower and return your clean home clothes.)
Anyway I would treat touching a dog as I would a monkey, a donkey, a rabbit, a hamster, a buffalo or any other animal.
I also take vaccines to prevent certain diseases such as TB... When I visit my home country. It is high risk and a lot of family member have suffered with TB... But this doesn't mean I will not visit my family but it does mean I will take precautions.
This is my opinions but Allah knows best!
Every creation has a purpose in this universe, thats how life cycle exists,
In holy Quran Allah say nothing bad about dogs.
Mansha Allah Alhamdullilaah this is the best way to give answer non-Muslims.
But now there are vacancies for dogs that prevent them from developing rabies in their spit
But no vaccine for these stupids to get rid of stupidity and terrorism
if I want to avoid getting sick, I rather avoid children. How can he compare petting a dog to jumping from second floor? He doesn't make any sense at all!
Linda i love you💓plz accept my love ❤️😢
He makes much sense than your comment.
@Videos is breeding with cousins also worth the risk? How is petting a dog a big health risk at all? Petting a dog releases hormones that are good for mental health, having dogs and other animals in your home lower the risk of your children devoloping allergies. So in those few cases where something bad happen you have to weight that agains to many benefits. All animal risk spreading sickness and hurt you, but other humans is way more likely to do both.
@Videos I'm was asking about cousin breeding which is allowed and very common in islam despite increasing the risk for sickness and mental disabilities of the offspring, thats why we in my country see higher likelyhood of disabilities among minorities that pratctise cousin marriges. I've never said anything about not breeding, so most of what you write doesn't even make any sense. When I said I'd rather avoid children I meant like I prefer to not sit on a bus when a school clas go on, than petting a dog. How you interpret that to thinking that I want to stop all human breeding is beyong me xD
Its strange that I don't see dog owners drop dead or get injuries everywere..After all its just as dangerous as jumping from the second floor. You say its no worht the risk, but clearly many people think otherwise. Rabies doesn't exist in my country btw, neither does Salmonella among our poultry because we take great pride in taking care of our animals and prevent sickness. Cats which you refer to as cleaner animal spread the worlds most common parasite toxoplasma btw
You're missing the point
Hahahahaahhahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah...
Brother makes a good point.
What's to laugh really?
See david wood destroyed zaik naik
What a answer sir.. Masha allha👍
Dogs have served humans for the last 30,000 years. There is no other animal with the loyalty and devotion to humans that dogs have. Their faithfulness and loyalty is an example even to humans. They save human lives in the military and police, they lay down their lives as search and rescue dogs, the make life bearable for countless blind and disabled people. We owe dogs an immense gratitude that we can never repay. It’s time to start treating them with compassion after all they have given us.
I have never met a Muslim who is more protective and loyal to friends and family than an obedient dog. I grew up in an Iranian family, raised by a single father who admired all creatures; I was raised to be kind to all of God's creatures, and to treat all with kindness, respect, and to show generosity.
If I see a dog injured on the side of the road, I will care for it and seek help. In caring for one of God's creations, I show that I cherish all God has created. This should be the focus of such conversations. We have dogs who can sniff out cancer, dogs who lead the blind and help the disabled, and dogs that protect children against other creatures like bears, cougars, and snakes. Why do we consider them haram when one could say they are instruments of fate, or a merciful hand?
I expect this to cause a great deal of hate, but I felt this needed to be said. I do not follow a single organised religion, but believe in the power of organised religion. I am not here to hate on any one religion, but to provoke thought and conversation. Please, keep hateful and negative comments to yourself. Thank you, friends.
Yes, for your answer he was referring to siliva of a dog, you could to touch dog
Then youre just surrounded by the wrong people
Islam doesn’t teach us hate any animals. Or abuse them. If we touch dogs, u just need to wash hands properly (samak)
If you think that Islam promotes hatred toward dogs,then you are misinformed...Islam teaches all good things..Islam teaches muslims to be good to all creatures including dogs and pigs..if a muslim feed a stray dog,thats considered a good deed and that person will be rewarded by Allah..Allah love a person who is kind to all creatures
But in Islam there are rules and regulations to follow in order to keep a dog
Please dont go around spreading false accusation about Islam..Islam is a peaceful and beautiful religion..you should learn about Islam first before saying anything..if you dont want to learn,its better to stay silent
That’s literally what Islam teaches, to respect all the creatures. there’s a credible Hadith about a prostitute giving water to a dog and entering paradise.
touching dog will not make you rabies or hydrobhiia
What a answer ma Shaa Allah
The problem with this guys is that he refuses to listen to reason and mocks people. Islam was handed down in the 7th century. Dogs are not haram to touch. The saliva issue was to protect against dogs with rabies. People used to have leprosy in biblical times but now we have the BCG vaccine and almost nobody has the illness. In the same way we are now able to cure sick dogs. We have a dog that lives with us. We couldn’t live without him due to the immense joy and entertainment he gives us. What an incredible animal Allah has created!! Humans and dogs have evolved to live with each other over thousands of years.
No proof to his argument
brother! dare to find the truth,may be you are not satisfied with this answer.but you have to know,whom you pointing.dare to know about your religion scripts about truth,its not necessary,you should follow your ancient or close people,may be they are wrong may be others,search for it na!dare to do,but make sure you are having authentic information!so check various sources and take the valid one.its a request for you,to help yourself!
@@mdforhaduddinpolash1562 rather then you making an argument, how about you showing me the proof?
@@immigrationlaw1984 imagine of the people who were leaving before the age of science!what should they supposed to do!and it was the best way,but still today may be have such problems at least i dont know!zakir were never wrong nor defeated but he can be wrong as human,you should think and worry about yourself,and ask who is walking in right way,you or the other person,dare to seach from religious scriptures which are surely authentic
@@mdforhaduddinpolash1562 proof please
@@immigrationlaw1984 which proof you talking before the age of science people were living!i told you i dont know!he didnt hear the question properly,cant you see?he always caring bag of answers watch his previous debates,answers!haters always tries to take pin drop,its very common !
Poor dogs. Even they are being discriminated against.
Brother Zakir, Assamualikum, as your peacetv banded in India &
Bangaldesh, Can It be possible to Offer and arrange online discussion
between such Concerned authorities who misconceived about you and Islam ?
I have had dogs and cats for many many years and I never had any problems
Good.. But it's just a prevention though
Of course.
If you vaccine and treat them in clean environment.
This man is mad
does that mean it can not easily become infected? NO, if one thing is permissible that means it should be a good thing and is so all over the world, poor country or rich country. Just because you are in a place where it/ you can be vaccinated doesnt mean the one in a undeveloped place can have it as a pet too, hence if it was permissible the one in that underdeveloped prt of the world would then keep it as a pet, if effected they would spread diseases in their village and else where and suffer greatly all because it was allowed and in vein because they thoughtit was cute thing to keep.
This isn't manmade laws or democracy, if something is not permissible it is like that whereever you go, whoever you are.
How can we keep as a pet something that can kill you with it's saliva. Think outside the box.
@@aborgeshonorato does that mean it can not easily become infected? NO, if one thing is permissible that means it should be a good thing and is so all over the world, poor country or rich country. Just because you are in a place where it/ you can be vaccinated doesnt mean the one in a undeveloped place can have it as a pet too, hence if it was permissible the one in that underdeveloped prt of the world would then keep it as a pet, if effected they would spread diseases in their village and else where and suffer greatly all because it was allowed and in vein because they thoughtit was cute thing to keep.
This isn't man-made laws or democracy, if something is not permissible it is like that wherever you go, whoever you are(exceptin certain circumstances).
How can we keep as a pet something that can kill you with it's saliva. Think outside the box instead of thinking others are mad.
It's like saying "I've been robbing all my life and never got shot". If stealing is wrong in one country it is wrong in every country, just because one country has a justice system(example vaccine here) doesnt mean it's ok to steel only in that country. Once you get into such crimes you'll most likely do it everywhere you go, and if you are in a pmace that doesn't have a criminal court then your finished(i.e no vaccine). What worse is, your robbing is not spreading to others (unless you kill everyone that you see once you leave the pleace crime, which is not likely what robbers do, except in a shoot-out.
If a person wants to live life according to how the Quran teaches one to live than I say that person is responsible for understanding what the Quran teaches. The Quran does not require a person to be highly intelligent to understand it. It's simplicity is what makes it so amazing. People that want to be considered important try to make the Quran seem difficult to comprehend in the way they create to seem difficult only in order to attempt to be a necessary component required to be utilized for the further understanding of the Quran. Basically we need the scholar's to translate because us normal folk to simple to get it right on our own. Lies. Only Allah can and will judge. If your heart is in the right place Allah will understand. And if Allah doesn't understand then his understanding is based off how he feels at that moment about what needs to be understood. So it doesn't matter anyway at that point. So don't worry . Interpret the Quran how u understand it. Do the work. Relying on someone doing the work for u and just excepting it's understanding is cheating and lazy. Allah can't except that . Your hearts not in the right place. So now u know. It's all on u . Your life is your life. Your understanding is your understanding. No excuses. Get your own understanding and point of view. You'll be surprised at how many others think like u and have the same understanding. But never judge anyone else. That's Allah's job. Why try to do Allah's work. . If you want to work so much do the job you're supposed to be doing, that's figuring out your own life and how to live it righteously. Now sure some can comprehend better than others however Allah will understand that . That's why he judges us based off our hearts. The only true part of us. So even then we not not worry about how much we can comprehend as long as we give it our all and it's with love. Now somebody tell me different. Somebody tell me some cult controlling nonsense to combat what I understand as my Truth.
I'm quite disappoint with the answer. Hoping for logical explanation instead of metaphor type of answer.
brother!! dare to find the truth,may be you are not satisfied with this answer.but you have to know,whom you pointing.dare to know about your religion about truth,its not necessary,you should follow your ancient or close people,may be they are wrong may be others,search for it na!dare to do,but make sure you are having authentic information!so check various sources and take the valid one.its a request for you,to help yourself!!!
Mate, he clearly say prevention better than cure. u should watch till finish. Tsk3
That's why you don't listen to this man. I mean look at his face. He is not hygienic himself too. Yucks
@Andri But why is it Haram?
Ameen. The vaccine is prevention. 🙄
And why would he even mention prostitution. It’s like he couldn’t think of a reasonable answer to he tried to embarrass the man about talking about prostitution.
It's not a big issue like u raise it he was just giving an example
Disgusting men
@@hamzarahman296 you are disgusting
I don't know why people follow zakir naik, terror preacher
He’s prob gone to see many prostitution in his times. He clearly know how to get rid of his stds 😂
Hahaha wOw what an example🤣 amazing
A point for debate. By your logic, If I may say there would be nothing one can do because everything one does carries risks. Would you stop walking because you may trip and fall? BTW, a vaccine is not a cure but prevention.
His presence of mind is just mind blowing. Ma sha Allah
i would consult him as a patient
That's like saying if ur kids get mumps or measles just have nothing to with them or get rid of them ... every thing is contagious in this world does mean you can't love !dovaccinations can help we live in a fallen cursed world nothing is pure until we all get to heaven why live in fear while we are here make the best of it and love is hard as you can
Don't worry dude. He is doing good for dogs because if he or these rude demons touch the dogs, those innocent sweethearts will get spoiled.
Question was probably not about humans getting treatment of rabies, but vaccination of dogs against rabies. So if a dog is properly vaccinated against most diseases by the vet doctor, which is a usual practice now a days, then what would be the reason to discourage keeping dogs as pets. Using Dr. Zakirs own example, i will jump from the 2nd floor if their is proper padding through mattresses on the floor.
According to the Qur'an it is obligatory to keep dogs.(surah kahf[18:18,22] )
@Mr Ahmee Dog is dog. Be it a hunting dog or another dog.
And you would think them awake, while they were asleep. And We turned them to the right and to the left, while their dog stretched his forelegs at the entrance. If you had looked at them, you would have turned from them in flight and been filled by them with terror.
And similarly, We awakened them that they might question one another. Said a speaker from among them, "How long have you remained [here]?" They said, "We have remained a day or part of a day." They said, "Your Lord is most knowing of how long you remained. So send one of you with this silver coin of yours to the city and let him look to which is the best of food and bring you provision from it and let him be cautious. And let no one be aware of you.
Indeed, if they come to know of you, they will stone you or return you to their religion. And never would you succeed, then - ever."
And similarly, We caused them to be found that they [who found them] would know that the promise of Allah is truth and that of the Hour there is no doubt. [That was] when they disputed among themselves about their affair and [then] said, "Construct over them a structure. Their Lord is most knowing about them." Said those who prevailed in the matter, "We will surely take [for ourselves] over them a masjid."
They will say there were three, the fourth of them being their dog; and they will say there were five, the sixth of them being their dog - guessing at the unseen; and they will say there were seven, and the eighth of them was their dog. Say, [O Muhammad], "My Lord is most knowing of their number. None knows them except a few. So do not argue about them except with an obvious argument and do not inquire about them among [the speculators] from anyone." Quran 18:18-22
Where in these verses did ALLAH say it is obligatory to keep a dog?! please keep your ignorance to yourself
@@hassanmuse5606 This Zakir Naik is such a liar..of he is saying that dogs were used for hunting , then the dog used to carry the hunted meat in his mouth..the Quran mentions nothing what he is saying ..God, Muslims my brothers please do not listen to this man
Loved the logic ! Amazing !
The problem with Dr Naik's answer is this: He assumed that the querry was whether it was okay to touch a RABID dog (emphasis on rabid). When in fact, the question was whether it was okay to touch any dog, in general. And another fallacy in his argument is this- He mentions "prevention is better than the cure". Following this premise, isn't vaccination the act of preventing rabies? Vaccination is a preemptive treatment designed to "prevent" an illness (by definition, as I understand it). Which means, his argument can be used to justify touching dogs.
Safety first in islam also...also.....thank u dr.shaheb.
I respect Dr. Zakir Nayek. But I'm not convinced with this answer..
You need some rest
His reply is simple, donot overuse your intellect to oppose simple things. The next thing you might say is 2+2 is not 4.
I never heard him saying ONE intelligent answer !!!
The answer is simple. It is prohibited in Islam. It can be of many reasons, zakir quoted one of them and explain it in detail that one of the reason may be dog’s saliva. So islam is a complete deen there must be more thousands of reasons of prohibition of touching dogs so keep it simple. Stay away from dogs as prevention is better than chre.
@@hamzaazam5981 Welcome in the 7th century!
Do you really believe the nonsense you are typing here?
What for heaven's sake does touching a dog have to do with RELIGION???
Muslims should better focus on their religion and the worship of their imaginary Allah instead of making normal people of the 21st century nonsensical prescriptions that reach until into their bedrooms!
UNBELIEVABLE !!!
The answer is "prevention is better than cure". Mashaallah.
I'm confused. What if it's just not a random dog we're touching but our own? We know he/she has all it's vaccines and update them frequently..
So ridiculous. Dogs r gods creation. We should touch them and love them
But god make the dog haram
@@naimharith1545 god didnt made dogs haram, mohammed made dogs haram because he didnt like dogs, so now the dogs are the victims of a mad men.
My dogs sleep in my bed every night. No illness has befallen me. 13 years now 👍
thats the real logic,
Most dogs* not all dogs and Islam has come for every person in the world whether he is a uneducated man and does not know about diseases that comes with dogs or whether he knows and has vaccine, the rule after all is one!
as long as how you treat and taking care your dog.. sure there is no illness has fallen in you
One of my friend's father is a drunken guy almost 20 Years. So that's will make Alchol is good😅?
@@amalroshan0567 dogs dont have any effect on humans, literally zero, rabies is a very low chance when the dog is vaccinated, but theres a 100% chance of being drunk when drinking alcohol, dogs bring so much positivity and joy in our lives.
Hahaha, Dr.Zakir is mistaken when the Questioner said vaccine against rabies he meant vaccine for dog which will eliminate the rabies germs within the dog but Dr.Zakir understood vaccine of rabbies for humans to cure it.........
Well well welllll.........
John Player how stupid you are .....zakir nair are most intellingent person ...how dare you ...you want to debat with zakir naik
I thought he said that he is a doctor too? What doctor?
@@robbykhen dude, there is a rabies vaccine for humans also. after a dog bite, ofc u will go to the doctor and take this vaccine.
there is for the dog as well as the humans, separate vaccines. so wt zakir naik is not mistaken!!
Saira ashrafali I didn't said that he make mistake, I just asked what doctor is he... and you didn't answer my question
@@robbykhen what exactly was ur question, u just mocked dr. zakir naik
and u did say he was mistaken!!
Fantastic explanation
Irony is that Winston Churchill once said "Islam in a man is like Rabies in a dog"..😂 😂
May Allah (swt) throw him into hellfire for all eternity for comparing it like that, but it is ironic tho lol.
Winston fuck can burn in hell
@SpyHunter 🎯 One of Mr. Churchill‘s numerous bullseyes!
@@imgoingtomars5378 Your dad can lol
@@Mocroskate same for you
ماشاء الله اللهم ثبتنا على طاعتك
I appreciate what you said and I trust you Dr. Zaker machallah god bless you 🙏
mashaAllah
Anjohn Kim امين يارب
Some people will fall for anything
@Let's learn everything all your religion is fear scared scared scaredtry to earn your way somewhere try coming on our side and being loved and accepted and not condemned Jesus was condemned and treated badly for loving people hatred and judgmental stuff is from Satan. The almighty God wants us to be in loving one another Jesus was here to show The Lost ones back then love there was very littlecan't you see that there was only fear and still today religions are ruled by fear and control they want to control your brain love is not wrong it is the right wayif you have a religion that it's okay to call names and be rude to others that religion is definitely leading you astray
All the prophecys are proved !!!!do some study before you judge ...I say that out of love not judge
Why are they talking about rabies? No dog I have ever seen has had rabies. Driving your car is more dangerous than owning a dog. Why start your car at all then and just avoid driving all together too? Why live life avoiding things?
Bro one of my friends died from a bite of dog back home Pakistan the dog had Rabies?? You have to understand alots of country’s don’t have the medicine to treat it..
My mind is blown when he said prevention is better than cure. 😶
Lol
how about keeping Fennec Fox? is it halal to keep?
He is a very wise man...He has support from Allah subhanahu wata a'ala.. mashaAllah
First of all you can clearly see when a dog has rabies. Which means you know which dog is okay to touch.
Secondly I think that touching dogs is fine but allowing them to lick you is a different story.
Also you can get hydrophobia from insects does that mean insects are also haram to touch as well?
You clearly lack knowledge of virology & bacteriology.
Besides Rabies - Hydrophobia these are " one of the reasons" not only one.
Grow some common sense. You got brain- at least try to remember that.
@@komlalebu8333 how about instead of being a disrespectful pric. You educate me on what other reasons there are. Because you are sounding just as ignorant as the Dr. Zakir.
@@komlalebu8333 cats too carry rabies virus but cats are Mohammad's favourites.
Oh shit! Now what shall you do?
@@debojeet1993 You clearly lack knowledge of virology & bacteriology.
Besides Rabies - Hydrophobia these are " one of the reasons" not only one.
Grow some common sense. You got brain- at least try to remember that.
@@komlalebu8333 hey hey bro! Don't be a tape recorder. You are simply copying and pasting comments.
And you are a judgemental delusional prick hands down.
You didn't answer my question and resorted to personal derogatory remarks which clearly says how insecure you are
Islam shows you THE BEST solutions. It's up to you if you follow it or not. Don't complain if you don't follow it tho.
The questioner was very kind💙 he loves the nature💙 The answer given by the sir might b right but said in very negative manner🙏 love must b there in the words which we speaks 🙏
“ A vaccine is a prevention not a cure so is there to prevent the dog from getting any disease” so if the dog has no disease how is the dog impure? The example he gave doesn’t apply to vaccines at all. I wonder where he got his degree of a doctor from. And I have touched multiple dogs a million times and I haven’t gotten any “disease”.
So why don't u question the person who asked the question he was also a doctor.....brother scientist prove that touching dog..lead to disease ...not simple touching ...simple touching nothing will happen...hugging ...when his salive is on ur body. Then u might get disease... Go behind the scientist not him....
May Allah keep u happier and successful brother
@@rafiqullahrafiq7193 m having dogs from last 16 years but no one get sick, ur nabi was affriad of dogs so..... most dishonest species will definatly wont like the most honest one.
@@vinayakchindarkar7326 not nabi, but God's commandment.. if u doubt, see the miracle of prophets..
@@elvishamilton9308 lauda
Excellent logical answer.👍😂
It is not logical but is just saying anything to support a book.
Many people around us keep dog as pet and there are very rarest of rare cases of disease otherwise everything is fine.People like you love his logic because from your childhood you are made to believe that a single book contains solution to everything and is true all the time and when you see somebody supporting your faiths he becomes your hero.
Now my questions if in future we develope some medicine or technology such that our body is not effected by any disease then what logic will you give for this whole argument of not touching dog.
Anurag Tiwari you stay away from it. Why are you watching these videos if you are not muslim? This video is for Muslims so stay away, we don’t wanna words fight with someone who doesn’t belong from our faith.
is it halal to work as a driver in pet shop?there you need to carry dog&dog food.
U can never exaust the Khalima of ALLAH. NOTHING has been ommited from the BOOK. if dogs are unclean, it would of been expressed in the Qur'aan.
Who made them unclean? Isn't it the creation of allah? Doesn't allah create them? So who made then dirty or unclean? Lol
i love his lectures but completely disagree on this issue. Dog's salvia for hunting purposes is okay (where the animal is intimately touching the food u will eat) but otherwise the dog is not allowed. Why was it mentioned in the quran in the surah of the cave?
Dogs were made for very important jobs here in this world! So think alittle! How can it be haram to touch a dog? I mean it s unsanitary but Not haram!
You can keep dog, in your garden or yard for your protection,
Some rich people, who can afford to employ human being, for their protection, they employ them as their security.
In both case the dog and human being are doing the same useful job. THERE IS NO NEED TO TOUCH THEM EITHER OF .
I HOPE I HAVE ANSWERED YOUR QUESTION.
Anwar Sacranie. I didnt have a question. But Thanks for Stating your reply n answer.
@Hassan Sheikh.
No you are contradicting your statements. You had asked question in your comment "How can it be haram to touch a dog?".
Don't you think this is a question?
Faizan Khan. Brother........ Nowhere in my Text i asked that question! Why would i ask? When i already know the answer. Please read n understand my message again......... No contradictions are happening. Nd Dr.Zakir Naik said in the beginning of his answer, that his answer is Not from the Quran!!!! That says it all! N again to clairify you. Dogs are Not Haram to Touch! Beacause if they were, then they would be Haraam to OWN! Do you understand Brother? Let me know if you dont. Thanks........
Yes we need to cleanse as per Islamic guidelines after touching dog. But touching is not wrong. We can touch any animal
Did Noah and his family live with dogs , male and female, in the Ark ?
I have a friend Imtiaz Ali a very devout Muslim and he sells expensive dog breeds as a business .He takes care of them a lot like bathing them feeding etc by using his hand literally touching them. And he is fit and fine with no sign of rabies or dog related infections. Is that haram?
So is it okay to touch or love humans who has fatal viral disease ? why only dogs? Please enlighten me !!
@@aaribkhan9458 remember! Dogs also created by Allah swt. His creation is filth ?? May Allah forgive you for what you just said.
@@aaribkhan9458 Verse 5:4 says "Lawful for you are all good things, and [the prey] that trained [hunting] dogs and falcons catch for you."
Do you realise you called it shaitan and filthy. Do is it means it is good to make use of the prey that trained filthy shaitan catches for you ?
@@aaribkhan9458 So the creation of Allah swt is a filth ? Allah knows everything and i believes in him and i love all of his creations.
@@aaribkhan9458 No Allah didn't say that!! Only the fabricated hadiths.dogs are mentioned in the Quran 3 times, not just once, 7:176,18:18, 18:22 . NO WHERE does God call the dogs dirty animals or give any indication that they should be avoided or treated the way many Muslims think they should. Actually the story of the people of the cave, in sura 18,, gives the indication. that we should appreciate.
The people of the cave, 3, 5 or 7 were mentioned in the Quran and every time God insists on letting us know that their dog was there with them. Their story can be as complete without the mention of the dog, but God did, Why ?
God is telling us these righteous people were in the cave with their dog, if it is not righteous to have dogs, God would not have told us that story in which the dog has to be remembered as being there. We have to know the quality of God, if we were to worship Him correctly. When God says something He means it, and when he does not, he means it as much. If God did not curse the dog and call it all kinds of name, it is because God wants us to know that He created that beautiful creature and He expected us to make all use and companinonship with that animal that accompanied these righteous people of the cave.
Fabricated hadiths contradict the Quran. Many of them narrated by Abu Hurayra. Abu Hurayra, whose name is translated as , father of the little cat, hated dogs and women and from his mouth came many hadiths that insulted women and cursed the dogs and make them undesirable animals that need to be avoided and in other hadiths killed.
These fabricted hadtihs were falsely attributed to the prophet Muhammed who cannot utter but the teachings of the Quran and would only be a living example of the Quran itself. The prophet Muhammed who lived by the Quran could not have done anything but agree with the Quran,not contradict it. God gave us a great criteria to judge His truth form the man-made fabrications.
[Quran 4:82] ....If it were from othr than God, they would have found in it numerous contradictions.
@@aaribkhan9458 there's no such thing as quranist. He's a muslim who submitted himself to god. And god told us how to pray and the quran is complete. How can you say that?!. Please research uncorrupted islam for details on google.
I don't feel satisfied though. If I love dogs then getting one vaccine for life, will be perfect. Thats worth it. But if what he means is that ill need to get a vaccine over and over, then I agree.
well that is allah
I have so many Muslim friends who have dogs ..and nothing ever happened to them..the dog has to be vaccinated and not humans ...
dogs aren't haram to touch. The Quran mentions that what a dog has captured for you as food (hunting) is halal to eat. Why is Allah saying this is halal if their saliva is "impure"?
Ever since I was a kid, 4 years old, I was chasing dogs. I'm 22 years old now a Muslim. Once I move out to my own home I will get a dog.
Why is it saying the channel is not available.
I didnt expect that answer lol. He got a perfect answer
Perfect? Using the same logic, embracing Islam may cause one to be terrorist and violent as well. So with his own answer, one should prevent and not embrace Islam.
@@wilsonganks what is ur point? I didnt get u
Nowadays dogs are vaccinated before adoption. So no disease can be spread from them. So his answer is soo silly
@@wilsonganks Hindus and Christians and people from other religion also does violent and bad acts... there are bad people in every religion but that doesn't necessarily represent the religion they are following... get educated brainwashed fool
@@arefinali8942 well guess what. If you wanna claim your religion is true and god is so great, make sure you can live up to that standard. Of course, the expectation would be different if you claim your religion has flaws and god is not all able. You gotta pick a side and stand by it. You don't get to say god is all able and then claim god cannot have the power to control his believers from doing bad. That is far from the definition of all able and almighty. And I do agree with you that other religion also does bad. Which is why all religion are unnecessary and guarantees nothing nor does it benefit anything in this world today.
My favorite notification❤❤
Can we keep dog for work purpose ?
Means can we keep dogs for security work ?
Instead of petting dog keep a poor person as a security guard with which you can benefit him and his family.
We surely are allowed to keep dogs for security etc. Remember the people of cave ( in Surah Kahaf) had dog as company.
Mashallah.... Alhamdulillah... Finally u r back again... M glad...May Allah Bless you with lot of rewards... Aameen
dogs is the companion of people since in the beginning ..
So wer was D dog wen Adam roamed the garden of Eden
I'm considering going back to school to become a physician. Where did the medical doctor study medicine? I want to strike that school from my list of options.
MashAllah nice logic
Great reply by dr zakir naik
Mashallah Islam is the solution for humanity
No Terrorists
i agree with the seccond line . but the first one , i am not satisfy with the zakir reply.
He answered the question without understanding it. The dogs vaccinated before a bite don't cause rabies! It's not a question of risk.
found someone sensible at last!
@@ck3289 look how you people scared of dr zakir naik -you people always tried to search for his mistakes but didn't found any mistakes.
Wow what a beautiful logical explanation ♥️
you r a special kind of supid
this is the first time that I find an answer from DR. Zaik not rational at all.
My bf is non muslim, he is willing to learn about Islam.. but, he keep asking why we as a muslim prohibited to pet a dog. He said that he have a dog since he was a kid and he is still doing fine and he don’t die or get rabies til now, what should I answer. Help 😞
This guy always manages to get the best laugh out of me lmao. I still can't tell if he is trolling on us or not.
@TheW0o0w everything he says. Lol
@@archimedesofsyracuse9268 sister dare to find the truth,may be you are not satisfied with this answer.but you have to know,whom you pointing.dare to know about your religion about truth,its not necessary,you should follow your ancient or close people,may be they are wrong may be others,search for it na!dare to do,but make sure you are having authentic information!so check various sources and take the valid one.its a request for you,to help yourself!!!
@@mdforhaduddinpolash1562 thank you for your unsolicited advice. I found the truth
@@archimedesofsyracuse9268 thank you for your unsolicited, gratuitous comment.
The fact that you follow him despite repeatedly disagreeing with him says enough. 😙
@@noamanm3523 who says I am following him LMFAO. I can say whatever I want, it's called freedom of speech 😘
This is a question concerned with fiqh, and Zakir Naik doesn't have much grasp of fiqh.
This Question is in context of Fiqh. But Zakir Naik has a Bad Habit to insert Science in Everything.
May Allah keep you safe. You always bring the truth about Islam.
Some people pet dogs for security. But instead they can keep a poor person as a security guard which is a better option by giving salary & assurance to poor person and his family.
See david wood destroyed zaik naik
@@nunomartins2209 And Ali Dawah and Mohammed Hejab raped David Wood.
beef=tapeworm
I am a very proud Muslim and I love it however I disagree with this man’s logic because simply based in the answer there was no logic.
He is replying with a complete straw man of an answer.
The guy is asking why is it haram now that we have a better understanding of the illness and cures for it and instead of looking at the situation from a helicopter view so that he may give a unbiased logical view he compares apples to oranges!
I don’t see the comparison of a person jumping off a building and a person owning a dog… one is a real life self harming act that will result in real life consequences both physical and mental. The other should be a religiously theoretical answer based of an understanding of scripture and logic
People over here expressing the love for dogs and questioning against islam , know that Islam doesn't need you , you need Islam if you wanna go against the teachings of our prophet and keep a dog INSIDE your home and are trying to find a logical explanation for it then woe to you , if Dr Zakir Naik is not able to give logical explanation for a hadees it doesn't mean Islam is not perfect , we trust the prophet without asking for logical explanation all the time, we hear and we obey
There was a report which suggested people who have dogs in their houses are prone to more diseases and illnesses. I hope some human in this chat shallow this hard fact.
source: www.sciencefocus.com/news/transmission-of-viruses-from-animals-to-humans-is-a-direct-result-of-our-actions/
cats too. Oh wait cats are beloved in Islam and Rasulullah (saw) loved them!
''Domesticated animals, including livestock and pets such as dogs and *cats* , have the highest number of shared viruses with humans, with eight times more zoonotic viruses compared to wild mammalian species, according to the study.''
From that link.
Let's not deceive people, coming from a muslim. Let's just be honest.
Lowkey the metaphor doesn't really answer the question
Mashallah
I love my dog as much as I love you. Cat Stevens sang this song, many years ago. Now he is a Muslim...?
Can anyone tell me a hadith which say touching dogs is haram?
I love dr Zakir naik
czcams.com/video/m7tenqQC7Zo/video.html
watch the video
Yah lols love lols
Good thing I have a dog
You are blessed
CHANNEL is back😅😅😅
Nice...