I Can't Believe People Think This Is Okay?! - Judging Your Sim Crashes
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 05. 2024
- Thanks to MOZA for sponsoring this video! Check out the brand new R3 Xbox bundle here: bit.ly/MOZAJB_R3
If you enjoy the video then please hit that like button!
Twitch - / jimmy_broadbent
Business Enquiries - jimmybroadbent@dotxtalent.com
Discord - / discord
Twitter - / jimmybroadbent
Facebook - / jimmerinobombino
Send me stuff! (if ya want)
Po Box 53
Unit 3
Burnt Barns Farm
Ninfield
TN339LZ - Hry
Remember if you blame the other people first it’s never your fault
That’s what I keep doing to my ex wife in the divorce hearing everytime she brings up my drinking
I made a video reviewing a lot of these same incidents (but in a less "family friendly" way than jimmer) and I found that I naturally assumed the person accusing someone was actually the one at fault
This is the ethos of pretty much every top split wanker in iRacing.
Also known as the Danica Patrick rule
Brooooooo. It's like bruv just. Because your louder doesn't mean you're right.. Then, you get banned because of cry baby
7:46 That would be Real Racing 3, which, despite the name, is EA’s least accurate attempt at a racing game
i used to play it and the physics were horrible
it would also be single player as in multiplayer everyone is in ghost cars so no contact can happen
@@eeeeee-ih6czit’s strange because real racing 2 was actually decent (nowhere near realistic but fun) and then they came out with 3.
Its not bad, i played it since release, but its typical pay to win gacha game.
@@eeeeee-ih6czyup
If this series has taught me one thing, it's that you must always resafe joinly
Always rember, resafe joinly
resafe joinly 4 life@@Cat5_
just like gold did
I'm glad people remember this (:
Never forget.
"You must always resafe joinly."
-Jangle Brungleborg, 2023
The guy on the inside (yellow stripe) at 16:50 was already spinning before he hit the guy on his right hand side. You can see the back end sliding sideways prior to the contact.
That's what I was thinking too
You can also see how far back the rear skidmarks lead to, just to the start of the apex whereas the contact was near the sausage kerbs
Same toughts, his rear was so out of control, it hits something on the way and still keeps going.
Same thought, racing incident
I noticed that too. I would say it´s yellow stripe´s fault then, looks like he went in a bit too hot.
Pretty good Mini impression, the screaming driver really added something
11:50 for me the brown car didn't do anything wrong, he's close to being back up to speed at the 2nd part of spoon and the blue car knows he's there... they just send it into the bend WAY too fast and loose it.
Ya, that was fine with me too. He was well on track by the time that guy got there. Just crappy timing and poor a reaction from the blue car.
If I were the blue car, I would just lift and go through the outside and hit the exit kerb and go on my race
@@user-lw4hz5hx5hseemed like he was going around the corner like the brown car wasn't there and reacted last minute to attempt to go around the outside.
I agree, the brown car tried to stay off the racing line until he got to the corner where he would then be at racing speed. The blue car just didn't see him until it was too late and then spun as a result.
I think the blue car panicked and didn't hit the brakes. Probably target fixated on the brown car and noticed by the time it was turning, and then didn't hit the brakes for fear of spinning.
Cant believe I made the video! Was the third incident (blue green Mr. Helmans Mustang) and thank you for the input Jimmer! Ill try to cut the track to avoid cars in the future, staying alive is more important than being in the right lol, PS: Afterwards, the other driver and i decided the kerbs were at fault cuz we def made no mistakes
Lmao it's senna logic "the wall moved" 😂😂❤❤
@coliimusic except in the senna case, the wall had actually moved a minute amount after another car had collided with it previously
@@edwardking9359I think it was 1mm
21:12 this is why punctuation matters. If you apply commas you get something much more legible: "Am I, the white car, or the car in front, the black one, in (should be at, but whatever) fault? We were battling for a podium"
15:50 Looks like the yellow car may have lost it before there was any net code / contact.
"I sentence you to becoming a member or team Quadrant" nice 🤣
A sentence even worse than being sent to Coventry
@Xiphactinus I don't know I actually like watching quadrant but I have been to Coventry so I can agree with that part
@@DoreidenKishi some bits are nice, especially Earlsdon and Kennilworth, but some parts could be better, I was joking about Quadrant, they're just obviously marketed for a younger audience, which I guess is fine.
MR. HELLMANS DID NOTHING WRONG. Yes, he was off the racing line and trying to get back on, but that was because he was trying to remain on track. Speckle-livery took the chicane too fast to leave space for Hellmans and ended up taking a line which left Hellmans no room to remain on track. Bad call, Jimmer- this one's on Speckles.
I would agree here, sparkles took the right hander too hot and couldn't leave room for hellmann's
Speckles also took too much kerb which threw him off line and caused him a bit of understeer, so it's 100% on him. Mr. Hellmans is innocent
this was exactly my thoughts on that incident. One of the few times I just completely disagreed with Jimmy.
Agreed, you can see at 5:39 where they are going. Mr. Hellmann's is pointing towards the inside of the next corner whereas Speckles is going completely off track if he doesn't brake mid-corner.
Yeah I’m confused about Jimmy’s take on that one. He also uses the “he’s ahead, it’s his corner” language that isn’t actually a thing
10:57 Resafe joinly nearly made a comeback
17:53
Hero car making the pass puts their front left wheel on the curb. This allows the rear of the car to rotate with less effort, which results in him spinning out a bit. I don't think this was netcode, I think that the passing car made a mistake at the apex and oversteered into the blue car.
I was gonna say, the yellow car seems to start rotating before knocking the blue car out of the corner.
also think it was passing car's fault
You can definitely see the rear end step out before contact is made when you watch in slow motion
At 16:05 I'm not used to F3 but does the black and yellow lose the rear or is that just how these cars turn because it seemed like it was going to spin regardless of contact
i think he overcooked it. on some setups, carrying too much speed and turning in anyway off throttle will spin you
Yeah good vid but Jimmy wrong for this one, he was was out of control when he got the apex and spun before the blue car made contact.
Yeah, it clearly looks like he lost it before contact was made and this isn't rally. That's on black and yellow for turning himself into a ninja star across the track and wiping out two others.
2:35 the resemblance of Hamilton Verstappen at cops corner is amazing, same color cars same inchident😂
I think the F3 one was on the POV car, it looks like they lost the rear end going in and that’s what hit the other car, they were on an okay line
i agree i saw that too
Last guy in the pink car here. Great feedback I appreciate it!
I will say you were right about it being low split mx5 series. The reason at the time I wasn’t full throttle was due to it being t1 of the race and I was being cautious about potential crashes and figured I’d try to lag behind a little. The situation makes more sense to me now though. I’ll be more careful! Thanks Jimmer!
Understandable. T1 is always always scary regardless of rank.
A better way to be cautious into T1 is to go full throttle, then brake slightly earlier than you think you need to, and if there's someone right behind you, not quite as hard as you normally would initially. By braking early, you avoid being surprised by someone ahead of you. And by rolling onto the brakes rather than going full brakes immediately, you give the person behind time to react if they were sleeping. These are both slight adjustments though. If you're braking so early that cars are flying by you, it's actually more dangerous rather than less.
It's nice that Jimmy said it's okay to use a racing line, I always felt bad about doing that
Dont feel bad. You can use the racing line and still learn stuff like braking points and how to take a corner. For me it's also a good indication of how much space I can leave for a car on the inside.
4:08 the car on the right hit the curb too which meant he couldn’t allow for space on his left. The pause after the right corner shows the car on the right was actually under rotated.
Yeah, left car was clearly ahead and left space, if you look at the line of the car on the right hand side hes going to cut the corner if he didnt hit the other car. Definitely not the left cars fault Jimmer.
These and the voiceover track videoes are my favorites :) Good way to relax after a long day.
Absolutely LOVE me some Judge Jimmy!
You should do this but with real life examples that are infamous for how controversial they ended up being
Im new here but whoever edits these is amazing. Enough to be funny but not over the top. Good stuff!
Lovin' this, it is really good content! Part of the upcoming "Jimmer's Simmers Guide to Online Racing" tome, available soon at a virtual bookstore near you...
You continue to make us proud Good Son, bon chance Mon Ami!
jimmy mate, i'm so happy with how far you've come, what a legend, great content!
Love your videos, is awesome watching you improve, learn and succeed. Looking forward to your eventual 1M subs!!
2:42 if we're talking iracing rules this is totally legal tow breaking and not blocking or making too many moves. i don't weave to break the tow anyway because it's just a waste of time but if you're trying to make it 3 more corners to the end of the race or something i can see it being a viable tactic to use
yeah jimmy is confusing rules, none of those moves are in reaction or defensive in nature.
Exactly right. I got triggered as soon as he started counting the moves. "only 1 move" is not a rule in iRacing. You can try to break the tow. In the clip, when the closing car gets close enough the leading car picks a defensive line early (non-reactionary) and stays there. 100% fine.
Hm maybe it's different in iracing. Irl you get a big slap.
@@Jimmy_Broadbentoh for sure, I'm only talking iRacing because that was the sim in question. I mean clearly I could school you on some IRL rules too, I've done a few laps of indoor go-karts ya know ;)
@@Jimmy_Broadbenti believe that. makes sense. it's definitely unnecessarily dangerous for almost no gain
The editing is always on point in these
14:02 I did not expect a Worf reference in a Jimmy Broadbent video today but I'm happy I caught it.
Gonna say Jimmy ya missed the fact at 20:41 that every car in this lobby had high ping, which likely means it's on the guy that got crashed who has the bad net connection. So while it didn't look like it was his fault, it was totally his fault. No one else saw his car in the same position as he thought he was.
Is this how the ping works in these games? The ping should usually be displayed from the individual player towards the server / host. So even if you have an awful ping, you should see that the ping of the others is actually good.
I really enjoy this series
2:45 It's a silly question to begin with, because they're complete opposites. When breaking the draft you move away from the car behind's line, when blocking you move into his line. There's not much of a grey area there.
Yep, certainly nothing wrong with what they did.
@@CaseTheCorvetteMan Huh, what? Moving 5 times on the straight is "nothing wrong"?
@@ArumesYT he was getting out of the way of the following car. Prove he wasn't.
@@CaseTheCorvetteMan So moving 5 times on the straight is "nothing wrong"? You ask me to prove something completely irrelevant, yet you can't answer a simple question. WHY he moves is completely beside the point. Moving more than once is not allowed, period. Fuckwit.
lol I reviewed these exact same clips in a video (much less family friendly than yours) so its interesting seeing your take on them as well
@21:09 Mans needed punctuation BADLY " Am I, the white car, or the car in front, the black one, in fault? We were battling for a podium".
22:45 not gonna lie, the grainy look of that replay makes it look pretty real
Thats actually the secret of hyper-realism: High quality textures and flawed "capture" (i.e. fake camera/eye processing), hence why the Unreal 5 shooter footage looked that convincing.
one thing i've learned is that not every sim racer has triple monitors. that ascari chicane incident @17:15 could've been the product of this. Middle car might of not been able to judge the car in his blind spot.
thats why you have look left and right buttons for those exact situations
i race in VR myself so i can just look and see, but if you dont have the ability to look then work with the information you have, in that situation id have been more cautious
Keep them coming Jimmeh! Makes my iracing dilemmas feel "normal"
couple things you didn't touch on i thought were interesting:
4:00 - this one's really unfortunate, *both* cars get launched and destabilised by the awful sausage kerbs here, and while the hellmann's car does make a mistake, they do leave room and the contact is initiated after the patterned car takes a perfectly normal line into plenty of space, dips onto the kerb slightly and gets launched. really hard to find fault here
15:39 - you mention earlier in the video that the best thing to do sometimes is just to concentrate on your own race, and this is a good example. three wide into ascari, very scary, so the multi-coloured 90s reebok car backs out, doesn't try to follow yellow stripe car through, watches three cars get wiped out in front, takes all three places with no damage. racing IQ!
At 7:45 the game is called Real Racing 3
Love your channel, you got me to go from AMS2 and ACC to iRacing and I love it.
11:18 - casually just showing japan 2014 rip
19:21 Thanks for making me miss Trials Evo Judge Jimmer. I forgot that I missed that game so much.
Also keep bringing the amazing videos! :)
Ahh, some of my favourite CZcams content, aside from PC hardware reviews, and sim hardware reviews. Good work, Jimmy!
this is my favorite series you have!
WOO we back with some sim racing stuards!!! Was just watching some old ones
21:04 someone buy this man a comma. I believe the intended phrasing would be "Am I, the white car, or the car in front, the black one, in fault? We were battling for a podium." Both phrases indicating color are parenthetical and can be completely ignored without changing the meaning, which would help immensely.
Amazed by his ability to ID almost any circuit so fast
I recommend using the Braking Line only. While the full racing line is nice for helping learn a track. The braking line only option gives you an immovable hard braking reference. It's much better than distance marker cards on the side of the track. Especially because I am likely to remove those cards or anything else on the side of the track not bolted down.
Love to see the love for the racing line.
Awesome breakdown 👌
Love this series but would also love to see you react and judge famous real life crashes, for example the Hamilton vs verstappen crashes in 21 and other racing series
This is really fascinating as someone coming from motorcycle racing, there is a lot of responsibility given to the driver in front to give space to a car behind them. Is that because of the extra situational awareness afforded by sim racing (ie the arrows, blind spot indicators etc)? or is that expected in real life car racing? On motorcycles the rider in front has the line and it's up to the bike behind to prevent a crash, there are no mirrors and looking behind you is very difficult, effectively impossible mid corner so there's no way to know someone is there until they're in front of you.
I love that Jimmy can lay down the law, while also giving very helpful advice on it!
I would say about the F3 cars at Bathurst T1 (21:12) that it was a pretty ambitious send and they went so tight to the inside that they looked pretty unlikely to make the corner without issue anyway, unless they were to almost stop. Especially if the CPU car is just doing the racing line regardless.
In order to finish first, first you have to finish. Love that!
21:16 the windows error sound and the pop up scared the shit out of me 😂
My fav drinking game to play is to take a shot every time Jimmy's editor makes a blown out audio gag.
The fun part is I never make it to the end of the video before passing out
Nice comment about having the line on not being a bad thing to learn the track.
The only track I dont use the line on, is Nürburgring Nordschleife as it is the only track I actually know my way around.
11:08 I was actually watching that GT race live and got to see your reaction in the chat!! That was absolutely a textbook HELMET move, took out the leader of the race 😵💫
Where can I find the clip of this HELMET?
Yes
my favourite series! yes!
seeing a 27 minute sim racing stewards video has made my day
Regarding the GTP re-entry issue, I'd put that on the passing car. While not ideal from the re-entering car, he held his line and clearly showed awareness of the car around him, while the other almost pretended he wasn't there. It reminds me of something Michael Schumacher talked about in an interview. The setup was suggesting his reflexes weren't exactly superhuman with a practical test of trying to catch a dropped pencil. He couldn't do it and said that wasn't where his skill was focused; it was about at any given moment, narrowing down the possible variables of the situation in order to anticipate the car's behavior. "Anticipate" was his keyword. While he was talking about car behavior, it also applies to the other cars around you. You need to know that the slow car ahead is either going to stay slow on the racing line, or move across it. The lead car never telegraphed that he was going to move across, so you can only anticipate that you need to go off on the dirty line, in a corner where balance is already difficult with a lot of load on the front. As Jimmy says, no matter what the circumstance, you have to bring the car home and things will get in the way until that happens.
To that end, I used to watch IMSA GTP racing in the 80s when you had basically Group C prototypes racing against sub 2 liter GTU saloons like first gen RX-7s and 911s with enormous power to weight and speed differentials between classes under the best of conditions; the 962s didn't just spin off or run up the back every time they passed one, which happened every few corners. They anticipated the slower cars and played the long game. So as for the video, IMO it's totally on the trailing car if you have 2-4 seconds to anticipate where the car ahead will be, a lifetime in cars at that speed.
"I sentence you to becoming a member of Team Quadrant" was not even remotely what I was expecting there.
The greatest series of all time
Love these stewarding video's!
He has a great way of communicating information. I'm sure some people have had a bad rider coach before.
You did well explaining your reasoning, Jimmy!
Watching this is a bit like watching a quiz show where you feel really clever for getting the questions right.
@19:51 pause and look in the lower left corner where the standinds widget is. between the name and the brand logo there is a ping meter. For Blood_OrchidEvo it is yellow, which is already not really good, but may be still somewhat ok. For all others it is plain red.
If you have a red ping meter and see almost every other one also red, you have a very bad connection to that server.
Please leave it as soon as possible, else you are going to ruin many races.
Indeed. All other players showing a ping in red, thus high, most likely means he is playing on a server he shouldn't be playing on.
Everything higher than 50 is a no go for me.
21:04 Jimmys attempts to read this title almost slew me for some reason.
For the Blocking vs Breaking draft, its actually really easy, Breaking draft is moving away from the car behind you blocking is moving towards it, if the car in front is just always moving away from the car behind, there's really no issue, see Indy 500 recent years. And Indycar will call blocking if they think you've impeded a run on you.
You briefly mentioned this, and I think the problem a lot of people have in sim racing is they commit so hard at every single thing. Yes there are times when you have no other options, but 90% of the time. You have time to slow down, and let what is happening in front of you happen, and carry on. You don’t HAVE to make the overtake, you don’t HAVE to defend every possible overtake coming your way. Racing is more about survivability than it is outright pace. Especially in endurance racing.
Oooh the clip of Sutil in Suzuka 2014 right before Bianchi's incident hit hard
5:32 I feel like the guy on the inside here may have caught a little to much curb as his car appears to pop wide of the curb rather quickly.
His nose is pointed directly at the curb of the exit of the chicane. He is trailing while side by side and pointed at the racing line when contact is made. He’s clearly on a line that doesn’t acknowledge the car next to him after taking too much of the curb and then slammed on the brakes to try to avoid contact.
100% trailing car is at fault.
And Jimmy literally says “the overtaking car is responsible for it being done correctly” in the next clip 😂
Lets go! A sim racing stewards video!!
The Live For Speed clip at 13:07 made me very happy.
I hear that ridge racer r4 music, always good.
EditorChan is just goated
Hi ... I was born into a racing family. My dad and uncles raced short track ovals in the Carolinas. I started racing in my late teens. First advice my dad gave me was the 'risk vs reward' speech. After years of 'on the track learning' (sometimes learning the hard way), I believe this was the best advice I received. I agree with you to take whatever is given to you early in the race ... just don't be an idiot about it (especially if you have to repair your own ca( ;-[ ).
The first one is on the black car. He wasnt making the corner while giving enough space. The only reason hye ended up with room on the right is that he was pushed that way in the collision
Jimmer, you are very much starting to look like a 90's boy band members older brother . Keep up the good work!
2 Mello really does have some sick beats to judge racing incidents to
This editing is fire XD
20:00 i would agree if the porche wasnt doing the corner in 3rd gear, like, the other racers cant expect the porche to slow down that much, for there to not be contact the people behind would have to STOP the car for a bit
You can't always assume everyone takes every line at full speed, like the Porsche for example took a really awkward line into T1 because the Lambo on the outside blocked the proper racing line. The Merc comes in from the outside and obviously carries much more speed but in Lap 1 Turn 1 Monza you have to expect that there's also someone on the inside who has to be slower than you
21:18 actually got me. I don't normally watch on desktop
I love these video so much
As far the Suzuka rejoin, I would have spun it around in the tarmac directly to the left front of the nose and then staddle the outer sandpit to corner exit. Specifically because in the spot, running the outer area lets you look over and judge the closing rate.
21:10 Godzilla had a stroke trying to read this heading
17:25 looks like inside guy was left just enough space but he spun and his back end sent big brain#2 out of the corner
25:40 Check your pedals' calibration and maybe add some deadband. He may be resting foot on brake.
In my humble opinion, I think you are correct on every decision. A first for one of these. Usually there's at least one I disagree with or can see the side of the one you say is a fault. I always enjoy these videos though. Nice one 👍 Jimmy. 😊
14:35 Incident at Daytona RC, guys like this think that because the pass they were attempting was clear and that they were ahead a tiny bit of momentum that YOU knew their intention and should have to just give them the position.
The truth= no shit you were trying to make a move that you had no real chance of making atm. Which is why I the leading car made sure to hold my line and allow you to 1. Back out of it and keep trying to make fair clean good passes later down the road, 2. Stay in it and end up wrecking yourself and looking stupid when the video get posted for the world to see.
Learn what racing is becore you start to sim race or even raxe real cars.
Are we sure the first clip wasn't just some dudes trying to reenact Silverstone 2021 in minis, even the colors matched.
yo jimmy saw you at Heathrow yesterday hope you had a good flight
3:45 They specifically are NOT allowed to weave if the car behind is within passing distance, usually 1 second. You are allowed 1 move to defend, and then are allowed to retake the racing line.
Honestly my favourite part of these videos are the random sentences handed out
I believe the two mini clips on assetto corsa are the same race, you can see in the blue car's mirror the black mini coming up for the next corner where the og clip happened.
Could be wrong, cba to go back and check lap/time/user
Gold car rejoining and the blue car spinning off on his own was 100% blues fault. He could see the gold car, it wasn't going to stop, drive off circuit or teleport to the pits before he had to pass it. So at that point it is no different to a multi class field overtake, or any slow car and his responsibility to do safely. No point complaining about his re-join as he isn't just going to vanish at this point.
I think in the last one the pink car is so obsessed with following the racing line slavishly which is why he's going so slowly. Still not technically his fault, but as you said needs to be more aware. And faster.
I noticed at 17:19 the gold f3 car just as he is turning he slides ever so slightly which makes his rear tire bump into the blue f3 so maybe that has a part in the incident?