PLANES (2013) - Mover Ruins Movies
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 05. 2021
- Fighter Pilot Reacts to the "Dusty Gets Lost" scene in the Disney movie PLANES (2013). Looking for a military/espionage/terrorism thriller novel? Check out the SPECTRE SERIES. HTTPS://www.cwlemoine.com/books/
- Krátké a kreslené filmy
The fact that this film's comms are better than other actual military movies is hilarious to me
I suspect your comment will reach 1k+ likes before the end of the week.
@@thepsychicspoon5984 probably lmao
Probably because it is focused on planes that they really wanted to get it right, maybe lol its so amusing
@@skeletonwguitar4383 yeah probably, just didn't expect good comms in a kids movie, but just made a childhood movie that bit better tho!
I thought the same thing, lol.
I heard the Navy still uses this movie for training
I can see why
Yep, and we still use Top Gun as a drinking game.
@@Boeing_hitsquad Did you learn that from Dark5?
@@Boeing_hitsquad I was going to bring this up.
@@Boeing_hitsquad Dark Dock or was it Dark Skies just die a video about the O-1 landing on a carrier.
"Fighter pilot checks realism in a movie with sentient talking planes"
Yeah, I was like ?!?!?!
... is pleasantly surprised.
Yea but it had a lot more right than an actual military movie which is even more impressive
@@Alexkeys141 thats ironic
@@generalkenobi5173 Hello there! And yea it is lol
The jets in the movie were voiced by Val Kilmer and Anthony Edwards, look closer at their helmets and they're modeled after Iceman and Goose
I was damn near screaming at my phone hoping he would notice it 😂
good eye!
Also the jolly Rogers markings 🤤
OH MY HEART
You are correct. I totally caught that the first viewing.
When a show for 6 years olds has better comms than 90% of DCS players
LMAO
I feel personally attacked
Comms? I always thought it was just the voices in the head of my insane pilot.
my dude I don't get airforce counseling and pentagon money to play dcs
It’s a movie and more for like 11 year olds
Forget Top Gun, this movie is why people choose to be fighter pilots.
Also air racers
RENO
"3 hours of flight out of the cabin."
Can confirm, was true for me.
This movie is why kids choose to be fighter pilots.
When a movie about talking sentient planes has better elements of realism than top gun.
i mean top gun has more realism in physics you gotta give em that
The sequel where the crop duster turns racer joins a hotshot crew is better than most of the drivel coming out of Hollywood these days. Actually a pretty cool flying and firefighting movie.
@@ALRinaldi to be fair if you're gonna turn any kinda plane into a firefighting plane, the one designed to drop liquids at low speeds accurately is a decent enough choice.
A cool fact is that the two aircraft are voiced by the actors that play Goose and Iceman in Top Gun
Tears of the sun : "...this Sidewinder looks one inch thicker, than it should be!"
Planes : "LSO... that's real... I don't know that they're forklifts, but... I'll allow it..."
:-D
Actually the director of this movie KLAY HALL went to the USS Carl Vinson aircraft carrier specially to understand that how things actually work on the aircraft carrier that's why maximum of the comms and carrier scenes were correct.
America's Favorite Carrier.
Disney always put effort on details so it's great
But never thought they did the same in this movie
The original animation of Dusty, Ice, and Goose flying by the carrier had the jets on deck with wings extended. When it was pointed out to Exec Producer John Lassiter that all aircraft on deck would have their wings folded, he had the scene redone.
They might not get it right 100% of the time but heard other stories like this that when they make an effort to get something right they go to the source and learn it.
Also, “Victory” is the Jolly Rogers actual radio call sign ...
I caught that too was wondering if any real life Jolly Rogers would comment.
Damn so you’re telling me this children’s movie is more realistic that ace combat basically 😆 this is hilarious.
In fairness, ace combat makes zero effort to be realistic. Other than modeling the aircraft. But, yep!
@@TerryTerius true that. What Intrigued the most about the game series is the engineering of the super weapons. Especially from AC5. Also the storyline.
You can literally do a backflip in ace combat I don’t think it’s making an effort to be realistic
Bruh, Ace combat was never Made to be realistic, it's literally an arcade game
MISSILES EVERYWHERE
When a kid's film has better comms than most military movies.
Everyone is aviation calls it the boat, not just the aircrew. Ship's company hates it when we call it the boat.
I know right! It's always referred to as "the boat". Its pretty fun to see the boat donkeys get irritated at aviation guys. Its even more fun on a small boy.
Also, I believe bingo field is an actual term for an airfield where pilots can land if they're too low for a carrier landing. Damn, I'm impressed.
I was ship's company on Nimitz and called it the boat. Sometimes it was the ship, really depended on how drunk I was at the time of last call. LOL
Everyone in my dads squadron(VF-213) called it the Boat. I have always known it at The Boat. lol
@@Rummyson 213 was one of the other squadrons on the boat when I deployed. Except they were VFA-213 and flew hornets. I wish I could have seen the Tomcats
Pixar does have a history of really nailing details even when they don't have to. Another example a lot of people point out is the radio protocol during the flight sequence in The Incredibles. It's probaby one of the reasons for the great quality of Pixar movies.
Likewise the dental commentary by the fish in the fish tank
Check the detail on playing the guitar from Coco. The fingerwork is close to IRL guitar players.
thing is this isn't a pixar movie
@@Nugcon Not produced by Pixar, but they co-wrote it, meaning they had input into the script and dialogue.
I think this movie was just made by Disney
Pratt and Whitney PT6 engines for the win!! TURBOPROP BABY!!
Yes
Matt!!
Caution prop-wash
Well well, this is quite unexpected Mat.
I'm shocked that a movie for kids gets it right more than most big budget films. Hooray for Hollywood?
Disney likes details. 😎
Nah. Hurray for Pixar/Disney
The animators even understood the Jolly Rogers lineage. The “Jolly Wrenchers” squadron number is VF-17.
I’m surprised they didn’t do the VFA-103 seeing as they were super hornets
People often forget that the folks who made Planes are actually avgeeks and put a lot of effort to stick realism into the movie where they could (without sacrificing on action, cartoonishness, and being too abstract for general people). It's one of my favourite movies!
During Vietnam when they were evacuating everybody a local stole a Cessna with his family and kids and he put it down on a boat so anything could happen
Yeah, it was a South Vietnamese Army Major. I remember from a video that the Captain ordered a few of the Hueys on the deck thrown off so that there would be enough room for the Cessna to land in the high winds.
You watch the dark channels? They just did a video on this a few days ago. Crazy story. Don't think you could ask for a dad or husband to do more lol. Stealing an airplane and landing on an aircraft carrier to save your family. Quite possibly one of he greatest stories ever
@@joeg5414 yeah haha
@@joeg5414 ya that’s the vid I was referencing love those channels
@@joshuanishanthchristian5217 ya he risked court martial doing that
There was a South Vietnam officer who was allowed to land his cesna on a carrier when he was escaping with his family. The wanted him to do a water landing and them be rescued, but they let him land when they learned he had his wife and kids with him.
of course they care for women and children, men can go die in the ocean. A tale as old as Titanic
When he said "they don't allow civilians to land on carriers" the first thing I thought of was saigon
What sort of loopy land have I fallen into that allows a spin-off to a Pixar movies be more accurate than actual serious action movies?
This was too cute. "Runways are NOT supposed to move." I will watch this whenever I want to smile just for fun.🙃 Might even watch the whole movie. Thanks Mover.👍😉
I want Mover to appreciate Team America: World Police. See how his law enforcement experience compares.
America. F@$k yeah!
I think he should react to ace combat zero. Especially the final mission
@@starkparker16 best song in a movie, ever :P
YEEESSS!!!...
Is it not ironic that an animated movie seems more accurate then the real big budget movies out there . Hilarious.
So a movie about a sentient Cropduster is more accurate than most movies about Fighterpilots, or Jets... Well. :D
This video was just WHOLESOME for me. Watching an animated kids movie to be more accurate than traditional Hollywood ones, and Mover laughing over it is just Hilarious!
Fun fact, the engine sound of the antagonist Ripslinger is primarily the engine that Mike Patey has fitted in Scrappy (that engine mixed with one other that I can't remember at the moment)
OMG! A CZcams reacts to one of my videos! This never happened before! Also, C.W. Lemoine, hope you enjoyed the video.
You missed the two F-18's sporting Maverick and Iceman's helmet paint easter egg.
I thought it was Goose and Iceman. They are voiced by Anthony Edwards and Val Kilmer so if they were going to choose one of Mav and Goose it woulda been Goose.
@@KomradeDoge
Goose’s helmet logo was very similar to Maverick’s. Which makes sense as they’re in the same aircraft
I love how Mover started out like, "why am I even doing this?" and ended up, "well damn if that wasn't pretty accurate."
He flys low because he’s scared of heights.
That was way more accurate than you’d think! Well done 🇺🇸😎
How this guy commented 5 days ago?🤣
@@farizdinnie7084 because I know Mover 😎
"bingo field"
not sure if that's real jargon but he means diversion airfields
Isn’t “Bingo” alone the callout for out of fuel
@@killian9314 but the phrase kind of make senses....emergency diversion fields for planes that are bingo on fuel?
@@killian9314 I think it’s not out of fuel, but the point at which you only have enough fuel to get home
@@jrstoelting Thanks for the clarity
When a kids movie has got better comm then top gun. ("_")
I watched this with my son and whilst watching the extras they say about the producer or director being a real pilot and a few others on the team so they knew what all the talk should be and sound correct.. good film and the extras were worth the watch also! enjoyed your reaction Mover! :)
7:42....I love how for that brief second Mover's face was like: "Does not compute". Keep up the excellent work Mover! I am glad to see that you're willing to "play" with ANYTHING aviation and do it with just enough seriousness to be legit, but not so much that you destroy the image of the movie. My next request would be "Airplane" with Lloyd Bridges..since you were Commercial Airline Pilot for about five minutes! :)
It's funny when Disney/Pixar movies go out of their way to get the little things right despite the fact its a cartoon about talking planes. I remember Incredibles has a similar scene.
Humorous when an animated movie about talking planes has better call signs then "highly accurate" video games
Aaaaaaaaaand we've officially reached the end of the internet... LOL Good Job Mover!!
FWIW, the Producers presented several scenes at Oshkosh before the movie was released and they talked about their documentation process. They received solid reviews and feedback from all the pilots in attendance.
They actually played the whole movie at Oshkosh in 2013, I was at Oshkosh that year.
@@MaxSterling01 It was probably the same trip as mine, but while movies were being played at the Fly In Theater, I was busy editing photos.
Yeah, those are Super Hornets. The fixed wings and angled tail fins also give them away. They're from VFA-103 Jolly Rogers (what else!).
I owned the DVD and there was behind the scene footage of the directors and other people who worked on the movie actually got to go on the carrier for some insight if if remember correctly.
The director came from a family of aviators as well, so pretty sure he picked up some of the lingo along the way.
Side Note:
Those Hornet type planes are voiced by Anthony Edwards and Val Kilmer. Their helmets are even those that they wore in Top Gun.
The Disney move about a talking crop duster is more military accurate than most Hollywood films
I've always wondered if one day you would've done a reaction to Planes Mover, can't believe you actually did 😆, what an absolute legend! 😎
And here is the first episode of Mover Ruins Movies where Mover actually SAVES a movie, instead of ruining it.
In One scene of this film, the old Corsair plane talks about his first and last mission during WWII,when he was the leader of a young squadron that see an enemy Japanese ship and thinks "oh!let's attack it!it's a lone ship!". Ignoring the fact that the ship in question was the Cars version of the IJN Yamato,they them discover that the entire fleet of Japan was there. And you wonder what ships had Japan in the Cars version of WWII? that's right: only Yamatos
If in the real life both Yamato and Musashi (but more Yamato) were a serious problem for the US Navy,imagine a fleet of over 100 of them in the same angle of sea. Bold move for them to attack,with a bunch of Corsairs,that amount of firepower.
the yamato was a white elephant propaganda piece that Japan couldn't afford to even run and ended up docked most of its life until it blew itself up
@@rubberwoody "it blew itself up"
This sentence was wrong from the start,but this end bit definitely made you win the award "stupidest comment ever"
Learn history, pal
@@rubberwoodycongrats on knowing actually nothing about the pacific side of WW2
@@imnomoremaverick ok. It's crew blew it up and Japan didn't run it in many missions because it was too precious. Is that better ?
@@rubberwoody still wrong.
Its crew didn't blow the Yamato up,it was the plethora of bombs,rockets and torpedoes the USN launched at it during the Operation Ten-Go,you dork
It's like, basic WW2 history
C'mon mover, you know you love the M18 Dromader. Where else do you still get to fly acrobatics for a living?
7:11 ripping the tail off: if the tailwheel caught the deck, then yes. Catching a cable I'm not so sold the plane would rip in two.
Here locally they actually use an arrester made out of 1/2inch sampson weave nylon rope to allow the crop dusters to stop in an overshoot. Doesn't rip the tail off, but the pilot tends to eat the instruments. The local company that sprays the orchards use Dromaders, and the airframe is amazingly rugged, but a 120 gallon fuel cell and a short runway surrounded by trees doesn't allow for a go-around most times. The rope is all of about 3 inches off the dirt and the main gear just roll over it while the tail wheel catches the line. Each end of the rope is anchored with a 250lbs. concrete block. Not going to arrest a fighter for sure, and perhaps that's where you are going with that, but I'd imagine that the tail wheel probably wouldn't catch a 2inch arrester cable in the first place.
Aaaaaaand, now you can bash me with a nerd stamp.
Oh, and as far as speed. yeah, they are slow. They have an average flight speed of about 90KTS, and land around 70KTS. Not sure what that is as far as minimums or maximums in the jet world.
At the start of the video I thought Mover was about to tear this up a new one but I ended up being pleasantly surprised at the end. Hilarious that its got more realistic comms than a lot of serious military films.
21000ft and they're literally no more than 1000ft msl. lol! Keep up the good work, Sir.
I also work for RAAF, and happened to say "the boat" to some LCDRs and boy oh boy, were they mad
A civilian has landed on a carrier. During Vietnam a Cessna landed on the USS Midway
It was fun watching you get excited at the moments where the writers got coms correct. At first it seemed like you were writing the suggestion off as a joke, but then gradually got more respect for it. Great reaction! :)
The extras for the movie (in the Blu-Ray/DVD release or on Disney+) include a 15 minute film called "Klay's Flight Plan" featuring the director Klay Hall. John Lasseter is featured as the guy who came up with the idea. But they have Hall visiting the USS Carl Vinson, where he arrived on a C-2. A Hornet did a low-level flyby just for him.
They also showed production footage to the XO and others. They noted that the wings would always be folded on the deck of a carrier unless it was landing or taking off. Lasseter actually approved redoing that footage.
I don't really where I heard it (and it isn't in that documentary) but apparently they got the "We got you" from the LSOs on the Vinson and added that too.
Huh...Didnt see this coming or so. What a surprise that you're reacting to Planes.
Only reason I watched this because of: Anthony Edwards and Val Klimer making a cameo appearance there as F-18s.
Your tongue-in-cheek comments about the scene, well in Mover Ruins Movies" segments as a whole always has me laughing out loud, spitting food, drink, snot, Thanks Mover!
Absolutely fantastic movies, my favorite. They clearly made the effort to get the aviation lingo and other parts right. For pilots, specially GA light airplane pilots these movies are an utter delight! Great escapism during these dark global times. Thanks for a great reaction vid Mover!!
wasn't just the pilots that called it the boat, we all did, you might be out on liberty and tell your buddy, hey i gotta head back to the boat i have duty tomorrow, in formal conversations we called it a ship
I saw that movie in parts when my son was watching it and I really thought (as an armchair DCS pilot) this is really impressive.
Clay Hall, the director of Planes, actually went on an aircraft carrier during the production of the film. That’s where he got all the information on what happens in the comms and on the boat when aircraft land/take off on those carriers.
Yes those were super hornets with the VF-103 Jolly Wrenchs. Planes are Bravo and Echo Voice by Val Kilmer in Anthony Edwards. If you look closely at the helmets you’ll see that one is Iceman‘s helmet from top gun and the other one has Mavericks helmet from top gun. You should review Planes Fire and Rescue.
I love that VFA-103 is known as the Jolly Wrenchers
A play on the actual name
I laughed for longer than I'd like to admit at "Fly a heading..."
1:37 "FAA is _not_ gonna be happy about that."
😂🤣
Also, fun fact: _Nimitz_-class Aircraft Carrier USS _Dwight D. Flynsenhower_ (CVN-81)
(Yes, it's revealed on 5:23, but what I mean is that *a **_Nimitz_**-class have an 81st carrier which, IRL, goes for the **_Ford_**-class)*
You should watch the making of, they had advisors. Surprising since it is a cartoon. They were trying to get the sounds right too.
Would love to see Mover's take on Battlestar Galactica, specifically any episodes focused on the Viper pilots.
This movie is way more accurate and realistic than what I thought it would be, impressive.
Gotta start talking good com early enough, to avoid any bad habits. By the time kids grow up and are able to get their pilots license, their com should be spot on... lol
When I was a young croppy I briefly worked with Dusty, the guy was ALWAYS getting lost so it does not surprise me they had to intercept. Last I heard he was last seen flying straight up into a mothership with some nut job screaming “I’M BACK”.
You can never start too early with proper comms! Thjs looks like fun movie though!
We always called our ship "the boat".
Thy Boat
Fun fact, Val Kilmer (Iceman) and Anthony Edwards (Goose) voice the 2 F-18's midway through the movie.
Love it. So glad to see Mover breakdown a documentary on aviation. Thanks
One thing they got *right* in Top Gun: Maverick was Maverick mentioning them pulling the cables for the barricade, but he wouldn't be making that call.
Always happy to see mover in my notification box
Hehe, it was charming hearing you approve the comm in a kids movie. Another animated fighter scene you might enjoy is from the 1993 movie Patlabor 2. If you search 'Wyvern Intercept' the first result is ideal. Take care!
I emailed him about watching this, my favorite movie of all time
He already did it.
Even a former SWO like me knows the Brown Shoe Navy calls it "The Boat".
They had a Cessna fleeing S. Vietnam after we pulled out make an unscheduled landing on a carrier
"Mover tries to ruin a movie but the dialogue is too realistic"
the voices are anthony edwards (goose) and val kilmer (iceman)
Mover, a civilian aircraft has indeed in the past been landed on an aircraft carrier, during the evacuation of South Vietnam the captain of the USS midway ordered a number of Hueys thrown over board to make room for an O-1 bird dog to land. It had a south Vietnamese airforce major, his wife and 5 kids onboard (pretty impressive for a 2 seat plane.......)
Love the fact that a movie meant for kids is more realistic than most military themed movies.
The helmets are Goose and Iceman pretty cool
Edit: saw someone said they’re voiced by Anthony and Val. Explains it
Mover, this is good stuff! Good comms’ also sold me on this! My grandson loves planes and wants to be a pilot and he loves this movie, so you may have further inspired him!
Can’t stop laughing. My favourite one so far. Love the seriousness of this part.
Best representation of Superhornets in movies for years
FINALLY!! The review I've been waiting for!
Since you did this, you're now obligated to do Jay Jay the Jet Plane
5:20 I was waiting for Mover to point out the GQ alarm being accurate, but it's probably background noise for him by this point
Blue helmet is Val Kilmer, AKA Ice Man, and the red helmet is Anthony Greene aka Goose.
I love the fact that a kids movie has some of the best comms we have seen in this series 🤣
I appreciated how the forklifts were colored to mimic the jersey colors of the flight deck crew!
The Jet planes are voiced by Val Kilmer and Anthony Edwards.
Been waiting for someone to review this movie
Apparently the Hornets were played by Val Kilmer and Anthony Edwards so we got Goose and Iceman on his wing. Also I've made a LOT of rider calls over my career. I was really surprised by the comms in this movie. lol
6:18 they also landed A C130 for tests, no arrestor wire, and it also took off, no catapult. Video’s on CZcams
Its weird that Mover is more impressed with this movie and how its more accurate, than most movies he has ruined lol
One could also assume that his pitch ladder and whatever that Crosshair was doing before he switched to WH TFLIR which I don’t know how he has that in his HMD, but those two things being offset or skewed could mean his HMD is trash which makes a lot more sense
The director did more research than most big fighter jet movies
There were also trials landing U-2's on carriers.
This was a quick and fun one, but damn that was good and funny at the same time. Even got the realistic call outs, nice.
Anybody notice that the “Bogey is civilian…” line was said by what sounds like Jester from Top Gun.