Jaguar F-Pace vs Land Rover Discovery Sport vs Ford Edge 2017 review | Head2Head
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 12. 2016
- It’s the battle of the SUVs in this latest Head2head video review, and we put three contrasting 4X4s against one another. The Jaguar F-Pace combines a sporty ride complete with modern engines and stylish looks, but an expensive price tag. The Land Rover Discovery Sport offers class leading off road capabilities and seven seats, but a less than inspiring infotainment system. Finally, the Ford Edge offers space galore as well as an extremely comfortable ride. So, which one do I think is best? Which SUV is the best value for money? Find out in this brand new Head2Head video review in 4k!
Subscribe to carwow on youtube -
czcams.com/users/Carwow?sub_c...
Read our full Jaguar F-Pace review -
www.carwow.co.uk/jaguar/f-pac...
Read our full Land Rover Discovery Sport review -
www.carwow.co.uk/land-rover/d...
Read our full Ford Edge review -
www.carwow.co.uk/ford/edge?ut...
Awkward haggling is a thing of the past with carwow. Choose your perfect car with our configurator tool and let the country’s best dealers compete over you. Compare the five best offers by price, location and dealer ratings and choose the one that’s right for you - no hassle, no haggling, just a great deal.
Visit our site to save money on your new car - www.carwow.co.uk/ - Auta a dopravní prostředky
All carwow savings correct at time of publishing. Head over to our deals page to find all the latest offers -
Ford Edge:
www.carwow.co.uk/Ford/Edge/deals?CZcams&Make-Ford-Model-Edge-Type-deal
Jaguar F-Pace:
www.carwow.co.uk/Jaguar/F-Pace/deals?CZcams&Make-Jaguar-Model-F-Pace-Type-deal
Land Rover Discovery Sport:
www.carwow.co.uk/Land-Rover/Discovery-Sport/deals?CZcams&Make-Land-Rover-Model-Discovery-Sport-Type-deal
carwow I
carwow - Please a mazda 6 2018 review!
4
Matt watson kindly answer this, is the disco sport reall reliable?
A4e4fgerthr t both ngnyyb hftynfxtxhfzrthhtzr5&'jdytnctyndtynydtynyftnctyndtynydtynyftnydntyfnytfhyftht6fhtf6h6th6tdh6d4h656htyntdytnfynfthnftnyftnydtndyydth6stst6jd6ht6tdhyhtdydhtyntdyntddnythndt ze4tn89tsbo8nxtgroixlthrgxt9nlrxhtrnlht8ngtrjl8tgrl8jgtsrl98jg5rs8jl9g5srj89lys5r98h5dgrl98hdthtl98ythdl89y5dr9l8nysl9n8dr5yhl895yrsh89lyr5dn9l85syth98ytr9n8ytdh9lt8tdythl89y6t98hdl6d5nyu9lhl8998xrth9ft8xhjp5zgen89l5syrn5syrh9p8shyr5p89jsy5r8p5sy4hp8y5nrulrtxgunlgrtx is 5xgrnulitgxrnuliunsgi5lrng5isrnuig5srniulg5xrilu5xgr9lrhuthl95rt95eh5e9hlu5sthlu95ysl9uh5st4h89ls45
The edge is the best for what it’s worth. I rented one for 2 weeks and did the pacific coast highway, wasn’t a disappointment. Spacious, comfortable, and a decent premium feel
I would choose the Jag
Seriously? Ford EDGE? Volvo XC60 would have been a better contender .
chakor viper Yet the XC60 is still better than the Edge ;)
MrBasinator because it's a 100% premium car. are we sure that ford edge is a real premium car?
Greetings from Gothenburg, Sweden. You should see the brand new XC60 (premiere in the spring of 2017), a beautiful car with a lovely technique. It will be such a huge hit. Promise!
The3dsGeek and
Have you driven one?
Been watching your videos since you've been on other channels that shall not be named! although it's the same style of videos the quality and presentation has consistently improved, it's really good to see. Congratulations, Matt.
Great video! Perhaps in the future, with cars that have been around for a while, you could comment on reliability. You're one of the best reviewers around, Mat and I think you guys sorted out the audio issues you had a while back. Keep up the good work!
I never thought of buying a jag till I saw the F-Pace and I drove it , what a beast , it is out of this world, and I tried the Macan it is like sitting in a box and the Mercedes GLE 43 AMG is not enjoyable to drive as the F-Pace , it is a stunning car from many points of views!
Still waiting for the Maserati Levante review though. Nice vid Mat! :)
Even as a massive Jag fan, they really need to up their interior game. Its really poor at the minute, especially when you look at the last gen XF :(
I think the problem Jag is having is that they have to keep their costs down to keep up with the rivalry with BMW, Audi and Mercedes. This means they have to cut back somewhere, and that somewhere, as with BMW, Audi and Mercedes, is the interior quality. Lots of cheap nasty plastics. I will however give Jag credit for trying to hide the cheap plastic, rather than just showing it like in the other cars.
So jags perform the worst AND have the worst interior. What do they have left?
Supcharged jag's perform perfectly well these days, just the interors which are a let down over the last year or so.
Ewacool good point you make there. I can imagine the big German companies have a R&D budget several times larger than Jag.
Jag really need to start selling in higher volumes to truly compete with a better budget.
Joshua L I wouldn't say jags perform well when the f type r is as fast as a carrera s......
I love Carwow, it's my favourite thing to do/watch during my free time!
Such a wonderful review! Thumbs up!
I think you should share more head2head videos. Thanks for everything.
Greetings from Turkey...
I am not usually a Ford lover, but out of these I like it best!
I have driven all 3 .. and ended up buying f pace.. Totally agree with the comparison.. absolutely fun to drive ...
hi, any chance you can review the larest jeep renegade? I would like your opinion if that's possible
Can you do an all wheel drive comparison? Quattro, 4matic and x drive?
excellent! keep up at comparing cars.
Hey Matt, can you please do a review on the new Mercedes GLC Coupé because I was looking forward to buy the vehicle but I don't know much about it.
Dope video as usual
What is the front and rear tyre size of the both Jaguar f-pace and f-pace SVR? plz reply
Good review. I have an Edge and love it. Stick to the lower end of the range, get a discount and with decent predicted residuals you have a car that is a good bit cheaper than the other two, the Germans and actually competes on price with top end X-Trails,3008,Altecta etc.
Nice Comparison. Appreciate.
i am curious how the ford edge vignale would do in this comparison with extrem quiet cockpit, the full windsor leather interior, adaptive dampers and the new synch 3 infotainment system :)
How about a review of the facelifted Mazda 3?
Hi carwow,
Are you planning on reviewing a Range Rover sport? (The 2017 10.2" sat navy pro system)
If you add all the feature available on Ford Edge(Titanium), is about 37.000 , and if you add the same options on the F-Pace is about 50.000, and on the LR in 44.000
Mat can you make a video of f pace vs range rover velar
could you do LS 460 review bro ?
We work at craft markets and the Jaguar isn't as capacious or practical in the back as the Ford or the Land Rover. The Ford wins there as its a true flat floor and much longer - the same size as the Mondeo estate. Audi Q5 and BMW X3 are really poor in this department.
Try an Ikea flat pack furniture test in future videos?? Or a how many labradors can you happily fit in the boot?
what's the background music?
First thank you for doing this it showed me a lot and put thing in its place. BUT When I had a Jag XF I looked at a F pace in the show room I wasn't impressed do a shop by the time you get all the add on extras to so called win this it would be close to £60,000 not £30,000 I know, I went and priced it up just for laughs . Now I am not in the market for the New price bracket but for the second hand. I am just changing a BMW X3 for a Ford Edge Titanium with extras . don't get me wrong I like the X3 it drives fast and grips the road but they don't have a front eclectic heated screen :) . and the sound system in the X3 was crap sorry to say . not looking at Range rover and everyone tells me they have loads of electrical problems . this may have changed but can not take a chance and they are going for a lot more cash. I am glad you thought the Ford Edge could compete in this line up.
Which car will have a higher driving position?
Is that an optional pop-out tow hitch, or are you just happy to see me?
If you are comparing the PCP lease cost of the Edge against the Jag and Landrover there is simply no comparison.
By the time that you have added all of the extras that the Ford Edge Vignale has as standard the cost for the Jag and Landrover is double.
I have ordered one (Oct 17) and the monthly cost for me is £250 as against nearly £500 for the other two.
The f pace looks like a range rover evoque at the back
plz keep comparing cars, this is more informative that a solo car review
Taking a Ford edge on test tomorrow, currently have a Kuga ST-Line. Already driven the Discovery Sport HSE Black (very impressed). Possibly taking a Jaguar F Pace out on Friday. Depreciation on the kuga is horrific, as are most cars, however the Land Rover Discovery seems to hold better value. We don't pay list prices so have generally good deals through the privilege scheme. Just a shame Jaguar only offer 10% at the moment..
Absolutely Euro cars ftw.
can you review a bentley continental gt ?
what am i missing out on 30some mpg for discovery sport? thought it was 25 mpg...
Can i please know which music/song is being used in the background..please
09:00 that's a really cool little shot
Please review the Maserati Levante
ALLAN BINU Watch reviews from DougDemouro.They're way better.No offense.
Thank you so much....
can u please do a review of the dacia duster 2017 in ur own special honest way
I'm thinking about getting a second-hand Discovery Sport (as recent as possible - probably 2016 or 2017). Everything about it seems pretty excellent.... but I'm put off by question marks over reliability. Should I be? Is second-hand asking for trouble, or would a 3 year-old car have had the teething problems sorted out, but not yet be getting old enough for the problems of old age?
did you do it? thinking about doing the same (2017 se) but have same doubts
I love Matt Watson, I followed you from carbuyer to carwow
These are, I suppose, variants of 'premium' mid size SUVs.... and there are so many of them. The Edge is such a big car not to be offering 7 seats (like the Toureg but much cheaper)...... Rather than any of these, WITH OPTIONS, most of the full size SUVs like The XC90, the new Discovery, Q7 etc WITHOUT OPTIONS seem much better at moving folk and towing. The XC90 holds its value and does everything well, without shouting about it.
The Discovery Sport can also upgrade to the 10.2 inch InControl Touch Pro infotainment system
Hm
Mat when do you get to review the new honda civic? the reason I ask is because am unsure about the 1.5l turbo engine it's got compare to there normal 1.8l engine
The Ford Edge is the winner in my book. Beside being gorgeous, people who will choose this product instead of the Jaguar or Land Rover won't be stuck at the dealership every 4 weeks to fix an electronic problem or a mechanical one. The reliability of the Edge is far superior compared to the Land Rover and the Jaguar.
Also, in America, you can get the Edge with a 2.7l twin-turbo V6 clocking at 315hp and 350 lb-ft of torque for less than £38000...
The Discovery Sport is the prettiest of the 3 according to my taste. If you want a sport car, buy a sport car, not a SUV. When you are in the market for an SUV is because you want to have room for the family, little bit of off-road capabilities, space, comfort and reliability. The Edge is the clear winner in the match if you consider the price and the previous criteria.
Skoda Kodiaq review please!
Regards from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Matt, you're the best
Matt REALLY wanted that the F-Pace won a Head2Head so he left the german cars at home and took a Ford Edge :p
+Selleswiet we've already done the German car. So didn't get them in again. FYI Audi Q5 would probably win this test.
F-Pace vs Porsche Macan vs Audi q5 would be a better comparison
carwow new Q5 looks disgusting on the outside tho
Selleswiet true he could at least tried getting a Lincoln suv into this comparison :p
carwow when the new xc60 will come out, i want to see a comparison between f-pace, q5 and the new brand volvo xc60 !!
Ready to take on those Waitrose car park speed bumps
I want to see a video of Mecan VS F Pace
What's super weird is I've experienced the LR touchscreen and it's not even close to being as useful and intuitive as the Sync 3. I noticed the way he was pointing at the screen. Mine won't do anything either as it seems to think I'm not making a deliberate choice. But after the Explorer Sync 2 and now Sync 3 I don't even notice it not responding. Do the others work with tech like Apple Carplay or Android Auto? Not sure, the comparo didn't express stuff like that. Rewatch the part where the digital systems are compared and it's not clear what in the world is going on as he quickly dismissed it without actually reviewing. Weird!
The Edge is larger in rear storage and overall seating space. I have been in the LR Disco Sport, it's kinda small for trips (Edge barely does for my full family) but I have no real idea of the F-Pace since I still haven't seen one where I live or rented on business trips.
Strange too, here in the states, the Brit cars are way more expensive. Do you find these things in base trim in the UK cause that's like a unicorn (or maybe a Porsche)?. For that money, I could get the Edge Sport which is a far better value. Ford is also about to get rid of that 6 speed which makes the engine seem weak. It's only a poor performer due to the gearing. I believe 9-speed is coming this year to give it some wings.
Something that seemed out of place was the front wheels spinning on the Edge and no rears turning. I looked again and it's just a FWD model in this video (any number of conditions such as tires are the culprit). I live in the world of snow and ice during Winter months and wouldn't buy an SUV or truck without AWD/4WD locking capability. I've not seen Fords perform worse than LR's when given generally equal powertrains. The reason I even got the Ford is that I had a very good experience with their reliability of the past two I've had in the last 6 years.
Really, it's a bit small but I think the E-Pace is the cool car to have if it's just for me.
hmm I think the f pace doesn't really suit to play in that segment. Looking at the body size of the f pace I think that beast is more likely to be the rival of merc ml which has transformed to gle
Weird pricing for the edge... in the us it's price is considerably cheaper than the f-pace and the discovery
Mika Mika Because in the US there's a lot of cheap entry level cars for all the poor people.
I don't think they don't even try to be competitive with this model in europe. They know it won't sell great anyway.
Mika Mika German cars are a lot cheaper here in Europe priced similarly to other vehicles, however yes the edge is priced a lot more then what you pay
Because in the US you have the Lincoln MKX to compete in the luxury car segment, in the UK Ford doesn't have a luxury brand.
It's the same in Europe, too. Would've been nice to see "price as tested", since the Ford already comes good equipped as standard, while the F-Pace does not (heck, it isn't even AWD as standard!).
I just configured the Edge Vignale. 62.800€, fully loaded. A similar equipped F-Pace (with 180hp instead of Fords 210hp) got me to 80.700€. To be honest: I really doubt that the Jag is worth that much more money. I mean, it costs one third more than the Ford!
Lol all this euro trash. Because of all the poor....... Most of the US poor live better than some European middle class. Ford was a base model S up against luxury cars. Wasn't a fair comparison. It's price mostly dictated by unfair tariffs plus that stupid vat you lot have to use to keep your governments fed.
Here's some feedback for you, Mat. At the end when you're announcing the winner, reveal each car in one shot so as not to give it away when you're still talking about the car in last place. Just something small but feedback all the same :)
Where is the new insignia?
Right, liked it, thumbed it up. I even forded that Ford joke, which in fact was not that bad.
But what about the new unsporty Discovery?
That one I'm curious about.
thank you matt i love your test reviews awesome (in a candaian accent and where the edge is built in ontario. go canie.)
I wish the UK had gotten a proper version of the Edge. I own a 2017 Ford Edge Sport with the 2.7 TT EcoBoost V6, and the Performance brake package.
I won’t say the car is perfect, but it could’ve been a much more worthy contender for this segment than the watered down version that the UK received.
Hola qué opináis del land Rover Discovery Sport como hacer off Road
Discovery and F Pace cost around 80k-90k where I live. Lucky you
Ford edge is the best value especially if you get the American engine and sync 3 system
F pace looks amazing especially in silver,that be my choice hands down 👌👍
Any time you're going to do the Volvo V90 RDesign T6 or the XC90 T8 Rdesign?? Those are beautiful !
Jay Kelz If you want to look at fancy cars go to a dealer maybe?
Sirion Hey, not a bad idea at all
Jay Kelz Because seriously, this channel is more about service and I don't think Volvo even has a lot of RDesign cars to send to reviewers. To be honest I have never seen a RDesign SUV yet, even at my local dealer.
Sirion Hey you may just be right man! I know he did an XC90 but was a '15. I know other reviewers have done it so I figured I'd ask. No harm done if he doesn't. I wanna get one and value his reviews so was just wondering
Sirion i have seen 3 xc90 rdesign.... they are fantastic
What engine was in this specific Ford edge was it the 2.0 eco, 2.7 eco or the 3.5 I would hope at least the 2.7 or 3.5. I really do believe that Ford edge sport should of been in here especially price point wise. It would be as much or less the the other 2 vehicles and give the a run for their money as well.
Says in the video around the 9:45 Mark that it's the 2.0 210bhp diesel 👍
How muck consume is 37 mpg in km ? I mean how much it consumes per 100 km ?
It should have been - F Pace vs Discovery Sport vs Porsche Macan
He said if you didn't want a German car.
rskbug Macan v Jag for sure but the Sport isn't really a competitor for the Macan. Evoque might be or one of the Merc GLs
The Macan would have pawned them all, and its German
Macan can’t offroad shit....
I think that you should also include a "as tested" price because that would give us better info on how comparable those cars really are.
+sic22l 40, 44 and 47k edge, F Pace, Disco
carwow My point is - it would be nice to see those numbers in the video.
PS. Land Rover went bonkers when specifying this press car.
The words 'Foregone' and "conclusion' come to mind!
I think the F-pace is a higher level car than the discovery and the Ford
Yeah it is ,its btw x5 and x3 and the class of the velar
land rover DISCOVERY sport is the best
4K's gone! :(
The Jaguar is the car of the moment!
...
Ok, its moment is over now, lets get back to the better competition from germany again.
Given the Jag and German brands excel in luxury and refined driving, I'd probably decide between them based on reliability. And it would be hard to beat the German's appalling record in that dept. even thou Jag and LR are pretty poorly built themselves.
It's just too expensive.
Actually the F Pace is quite good. I'm surprised he's comparing it with Ford Edge and Range Rover Discovery. I wanted to see how the F Pace S (not the base one he presented) would compare against BMW X5, Macan and the likes.
My Agony F-Pace is X3's competitor (for much more money).
It's just too expensive for all those cheap plastics inside.
Does the F Pace S come with "plastic"? I believe all the finishing of the interior is leather/wood/aluminum. Unless you want to buy the cheapest basic model which I think is a shame (I'd rather get a Cadillac XT5 instead if I'm going to get the cheapest model) I think if you're going with the F Pace you better fork enough to get all the good features/interiors.
I'd have the edge. Nicest all rounder
In the USA the food edge starts from $29,000 and the jaguar fpace starts from $42,000 !! They are in control competely differant leagues.
Tengo la duda pero entre
Jaguar E-Pace
Land Rover discovery Sport
Mercedes GLC
BMW X3
Ford EDGE
Sería bueno un top 10
La más rápida
La más económica
La más espaciosas
La más confortable
La más capaz en 4x4
Gracias muy buenas videos por favor más en español 👍🏼
Here in India F Pace is heck more expensive than the discovery sport. Actually the top model of discovery sport is cheaper than the base F Pace. Unjustified.
Anish Somawar Same in Australia, here the Ford Edge starts at 50k while the f-pace starts at 80k
We get discount on Ford/Jaguar/Land Rover models, the Discovery Sport HSE Black in 180 PS, would work out cheaper than our Kuga ST-Line (180PS) AWD. Jaguar only offer a lowly 10% discount so its a no go-er at the moment.
@@bearz6606 worse S Korean cars are still Well Overpriced in the UK. Import duty/ tariffs to blame..red tape for the sake of it?
Big does NOT equal most practical!
It's a tradeof for driveabilty in narrow streets and parking possibilities which in most european cities can be a challenge if you have a huge car.
why you complaining about ford back seats not reclining all the way, but not mentioning that about discovery? Discovery is even worst which is recorded on carwow discovery test.
Sync 3 in Ford Edge is great. The system works wonderfully. Sometimes you don't know what you are talking about...
I choose the Edge. 🙂
Same!
Lol
Solely on the infotainment front, almost every other reviewer _raves_ about the SYNC 3 system in the Edge.
Our car had Sync 2. Edges will get Sync 3 from late 2016 - our press car was obviously built before Sync 3 came in
I don't know that it's "obvious," this review says 2017 and you didn't say which version of Sync it has. Supposedly Sync 3 is a major improvement. Thanks, though. This is almost the perfect comparison video for me. I like Fords, although my next car is almost certain to be the F-Pace. The only hitch is that I can get a ridiculous deal on a Discovery Sport from a family member that sells Jags/Rovers but the F-Pace is too red hot to get such a large discount. Luckily the Discovery Sport has a LOT to love, so it'll be hard to go wrong.
Jaguar F-Pace please!!
Well, I found the video that made my uncle trade his discovery in for a jag.
Which one of these 3 is most reliable?
MS jaaaaaaag
This was filmed over a month ago
Please make a review for M2
+DarkAvocado MS done it ages ago. Please search our channel.
Why doesn't this edge have Sync 3? That's an obvious disadvantage and why wasn't Sync3 mentioned like the inControl Touch Pro of the Jaguar.
craig doss I've mentioned this to them before, only the first release had sync 2 and all Edges in Europe now have sync 3. Carwow don't care about their inaccurate reviews.
+IxD that press car had sync 2 - it's what Ford sent us to review. Maybe I should have reviewed something I didn't have with me. I can't comnent on sync 3 as I haven't tried it yet.
Cmon Matt! You know what Sync 3 is though right? One look at Ford website or talk with Ford would have told you that Sync 3 is on Mustang, Edge from late 2016. Fine to say Sync 2 is crap but at least comment that Sync 3 is here particularly as you mention poor infotainment as a big minus. From your Edge reviews most people wouldn't have a clue and think they'd be stuck with Sync 2 until model refresh / facelift which is simply not true!
In Canada, Ford Edge is C$20,000 cheaper than a Jaguar F-pace base model
2:25 Well, that type of bonnet is not invented by Land Rover. Something similar was seen on Sportage 2010, which is a year younger than Evoque.
nemanja milosevic well it not have been invented by Land Rover but it's been a staple of Land Rovers for years. Years longer than the Sportage.
craig doss lol :) well if you count the boxy ones before Evoque, than you can also count every other boxy car like Lada Niva and judge which is the oldest one, but we both know that those bonnets are hideous and no Land Rover before Evoque was even close to being pretty.
nemanja milosevic it isn't the oldest. The first Land Rover was 1940s
mikeymarmalade i said LIKE lada niva, which means a gazillion of old timer cars which all looked alike and there are many russian and american ones that had that bonnet way before land rover (which was out in 1947). ..but that argument is pointless, we are talking about the modern, good looking implementation of it and land rover is not first there either.
These are all great in their own ways. However, the Ford should not really be here (in this comparison). I know this is a UK review, but here in The States, the LR and Jag start at about 10k or higher than the Ford and are built to be premium SUVs, and the Ford is more of a mainstream affair. So the Ford will obviously be less refined and such since it is cheaper in actuality because its origins are not premium. However, I guess the Edge is a bit more expensive across the pond. If it were my money in the UK though, I would also vote F Pace.
in the middle east the f pace and discovery start at over double the price of the edge....
Nice
I don't think anyone here in America would've compared a Land Rover & Jaguar with a Ford. Plus, in the US Sync3 has been out a while and is way better than Sync2 and you all seem to have different day-time running lights than the US spec model.
F-pace is one good looking suv.
Why are they comparing the Ford Edge (a mainstream vehicle here in Canada) to luxury brands? They should be comparing it's luxury version, the Lincoln MKX.
I'll take that Edge or Jag!!