Someone Built an Apartment INSIDE a Bathroom…
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 06. 2023
- Would you live in NYC if it meant your entire apartment was less than 150 Square Feet? If so, this video is for you because these places are for rent right now.
Thanks to @CharlesMunroe for the tour / @charlesmunroe
Kernmode - Tigerblood Jewel // Assorted Berries - Dylan Sitts // Back in the Days - Mai Ligne // Ballin on a Budget - Matt Large // Bandana - Ballpoint
Need Music? Get Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
*Everything used to make this video*
[E-bike] lddy.no/1clto
[Camera] amzn.to/3VBWywO
[Mic] amzn.to/3ptHhz3
[Lens] amzn.to/3MZGmmF
[Handheld Tripod] amzn.to/3iUp3Ex
[Full Size Tripod] amzn.to/3cp2sty
[Lights] amzn.to/3izy3ic
Great news! If you make a purchase from any link above, my channel earns a small affiliate commission from the site.
I can barely afford $1850 for a three bedroom here in Florida and you telling me people paying $4000 for a damn piece of pie 😂
yup smh its ridiculous
That’s for a 3 bedroom?? Nj that’s for a crappy studio.
@@imarielmermaid yeah three bedroom house rental. It’s just crazy people pay more than that like you said for a crappy studio
Where at because I’m down in FL too and I’m not seeing that price but need to!!!
@@brownplans4748 well I been renting this spot for 3 years, it started at $1600. So yeah you’re right you ain’t finding that price. Still prices here better than NY for some small ass apartments
No telling how long that gas was on. You probably saved a lot of lives my friend.
We didn’t smell it when we walked in, so there must’ve been a draft from one of the windows
The oven was on the lowest setting. Thats why Cash said it was "warm" and they didn't smell any gas. So.....they didn't save any lives, but its still prudent to turn it off.
@@ae2948 Not true. Gas stoves emit deadly Carbon Monoxide even when functioning normally, that's why you are supposed to run a kitchen exhaust vent whether baking or cooking.
When an orifice is put in incorrectly or there is damage, then the toxic affects happen much faster.
@@wownewstome6123it’s time to ban all gas stoves. Health first!
@@sirwinslow7384 , Apartment should not be allowed to use gas stoves, it is very dangerous.
They had a protest in Boston against high rents. it's time NY and EVERY STATE do the same thing! RIDICULOUS
All rent control laws do is restrict supply and increase costs for other tenants. There are an estimated 60k apartments in NYC being held off the market because of rent control. And with the proposed expansion of rent control across the state and the new "Good Cause" eviction law being pushed, along with the active resistance to new market rate construction in the city, it's only going to get worse.
@@taylorlibby7642 it's not complicated, it's just that greed is in every fasid of American life. That's the only reason it's bad . Class dismissed.
@@danielcarlies5151 That's a pathectic class. Glad it was dismissed.
Greed should have limits, or the foundation of the city will break.
So agree..my niece had to leave the first job out of college she had there this year...no way...now she and we are so happy...you can not flourish as a beginner in this,,,even at a great level,,,only uber uber rich,,,this can not be.
I always thought that it was technically illegal (the best kind of illegal) for a NYC bedroom not to have a window. I was told it's part of the fire code.
It is!
Yup, you're right! There needs to be two means of egress (window & door) from a bedroom for fire safety.
Legally, that windowless room can be an office/ closet/ den but not a bedroom.
I thought so, too!
You can't call it a bedroom without a window in nyc. That's disingenuous at best, and the landlord should know about that. The multiple dwelling law clearly states what a bedroom is.
It's illegal (both building and fire code violation) to have a bedroom without a window.
It's a crap ton of illegal things going on with apartments in NYC.
Nyers r crazy. & Not in a good way if they gotta live like that. Like imagine getting excited by food. But there's a toilet beside it. What heartless person came up w/ that ish
Yes this so true. Had to have a window to be a legal bedroom.
$4000 grand for the first three is ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS!! PERIOD.
New York City can charge what it wants. Please get used to that fact.
@@yougottabekidding7476 facts
And the one for $3995 is a STEAL! 😂
I liked the 3300 one and the small studio but not for 3500
Four thousand dollars grand??? Kiiiinda redundant to use both the dollar sign, the three zeros, AND the word "grand", lol. 😂
I've gotten used to hearing about these nutty NYC rental prices, but I'm sorry - Did he say the apartments were $4000??? For closet bedrooms? That's insane. I don't care how supposedly nice the neighborhood is.
The prices on the others were just as outrageous. I just don't know how y'all do it.
That said - any Monday that starts off with a Cash/Charles video is going to be an a-okay day, in my book.
That’s about $48k a year just t rent a room. Crazy
They were all available...l\
Right 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🙌🏽🔥❤️….They are out their minds.
I couldn’t and won’t do it….
Lately, I've started to question my own sanity, LOL! 😭✌🗽
This is stupid charging $4,000 a month. These type of Apartments should be HUD based or sold for pennies at or at a very low price. There are a lot of veterans and people on SSI, SSDI or survivor benefits. People with chronic homelessness. A lot of people would take these especially if it was supportive housing. But the way things are done is stupidity at its finest. This is why people don't want to live in New York City......
A legal bedroom in NYC must have minimum dimensions of 8 feet on either side, including a minimum ceiling height of 8 feet and must be at least 80 square feet in size.
Furthermore, a legal bedroom must have at least two forms of egress, one of them being a window no smaller than 12 square feet.
For a bedroom to be considered legal, it must be possible to access a bathroom without having to pass through any other bedroom.
Window regulation for legal bedrooms in NYC is addressed in § 27-2058 of the NYC Administrative Code.
How could any of these realtor s legally show these apartment? They must be grandfathered in at some point in time, or separated for some reason. I can't see Charles and/or Cash doing anything against the law. But I wouldn't be able to sleep without a window in my room. Hard to conceive of anyone spending that kind of money and no window in the bedrooms?
I think you mean the window can not be smaller than 12 square inches...not feet. ;)
@@InsideKarensHead : A window of twelve square INCHES would only be 3 X 4 inches: Small enough for a hand, but not a whole body.
So some one should turn in the landlords of those apartments.
@@InsideKarensHead My cat couldn’t fit through a window that’s twelve square inches!
Cash: "There's no windows in here." Charles: "Hey, listen. You have a door." 🤣🤣🤣
Hey, don't knock cemeteries! At least you know your neighbors will be quiet.
Lol let’s hope so
I lived across the street from a huge Victorian cemetery in NC once and it was awesome. Very quiet neighborhood with huge trees and well maintained landscaping. And yes, the neighbors were quiet. ; )
and no new buildings will be build!
@@folkgirrl Wouldn't go that far. They'll definitely move the bodies if the land sells for development. They've done it before.
I lived near a cemetery for 10 years. Rent was very low and I had great neighbors. Nice and quiet. Very peaceful. I loved it.
“Common Area” in a 12 X 8 mini-apartment for almost $4,000 a month. Hysterical 😂
I rent a practical microflat in downtown L.A. for about $700, all utilities included. I've lived here for 12 years, new tenants pay $995-1050.
Am I supposed to feel like $4,000 is a deal, for living in a closet?!
Of course! Greetings from 🗽
Then WHY YOU & PPL CHOSE TO RENT IN DOWNTOWN?? When the apartment & land is tight & not much any space left.
PPL WANT RENT IN DOWNTOWN SO THEY CAN GO OUT FOR 3 minutes & have EVERYTHING, RESTAURANTS, MINI SUPERMARKETS, BANKS, BUS & TRAINS RIGHT NEXT IN THEIR APARTMENT!!
When 5 millions want stay in the place, but have only 1 millions apartment. THEN PPL WONDER WHY IT EXPENSIVE?? WONDER WHY THERE IS CROWN & NOT MUCH APARTMENT LEFT?
No, I’m not supposed high price raising & overpriced.
BUT PPL ALSO PLEASE USE THE BRAINS!!
Buy cars & rent far away from downtown!! Or rent outside of city & take more times to take bus/trains to going for study, working place.
Alots ppl spend 2 hour for 1 turn, everyday just from their house place to working place, that’s mean it take 4 hours EVERYDAY FOR 2 TURN JUST FROM THEIR HOUSE TO WORK PLACE!!
Then you can have less experience & more space as you want if you don’t want in downtown!! But it might very tired for everyday because it might take 3-4 hours just to get in place to place.
New York has always been this ridiculous. I remember 40 years ago the most common joke about living in New York was "A thousand dollars and no fuckin' bathroom?!" It's why in any show that shows people that are more middle/working class, they live with someone else. Hell, they even did that in Friends with Joey and Candler living together, and Rachel and Monica. Ross was a University Professor, so he lived on his own; and Phoebe inherited her grandmother's place. There is a reason why most of the firefighters that were killed in the Towers lived in New Jersey, not New York City. When living in New Jersey is cheaper, your city has a problem.
At least it used to be cheaper if you got a place in Brooklyn; but entitled hipster Millennials ruined that. Now you have to go to Queens, east Brooklyn or the Bronx to find decent rents, if even there. Yeah, New York sucks to live, unless you have money. It always has.
If the whole house is an “apartment” then, to my mind, it’s NOT an APARTMENT, it’s a house. You’re renting a HOUSE.
I, personally, love the thumbnail. Not really a bathroom...not really a kitchen. It's a BITCHEN.
So underrated my friend! 👌😂
There's prob an ahole out there like nah. I can downsize it some more. How about doing ur dishes in the toilet for $50 off
Yea talk about click bait.
@@ahhwe-any7434 that makes me think of Kramer on Seinfeld installing the garbage disposal in his tub to wash the salad while he showered.
Click bait!!!!
I'm surprised - these apartments have decent kitchens. I don't hate these apartments. Except for the prices. The prices are insane.
they are not up to code someone must report it to them
Cash.."its kinda dark in here man." Charles..."what you tryin to say?" 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Charles' worry over the stove was immaculate. Genuine concern. I felt that.
Cash: its kind of dark in here.
Charles: what you trying to say?
LMAO
😂
I actually enjoy seeing the small ones better for some reason. Love when you and Charles work together.
I really love watching the tiny apartments. It’s like a tiny home in a building. Always makes me smile. Thank you.
Cash: ' the view is breathtaking...' of a cemetery! 😅😅😅
I love these videos Cash the one thing that sets these apart from other NYC apartment videos is you show the surrounding neighbourhood where the apartment is. It really adds to the whole video! Hope you're keeping well and healthy. Big thumbs up 👍
Windowless room cannot be advertised or leased as a bedroom. NYS code.
It would be hard to afford these, (for me) without a significant other. The relationship may not last long because of the small space.
this channel reminds me of why i will never live in new york 😂
You gotta have that nyc mentality... most ppl can't handle. Nyc4life )
I felt exactly that way before I moved there for work. What I found was that it's an awesome place to be during certain times in your life, and if you're in the right career.
@@rickrolledtruth5834 its more on the side of, I would never spend that much to live there, 4k a month I can own a mansion in Texas... but I do visit new york and love it.
@@taylorlibby7642 it is a beautiful place, I love how you can pretty much walk or take the train everywhere. I make 200k a yr where I am. My rent is 1500$ a month for 1200sqft. Just makes more sense to me
@@FadiGamingRP I hear ya, back in the day Apts weren't fancy like this and basically you had to improvise yourself. It amazes me seeing them now. Back then it was expensive, in that time 1300-1800 and imagine no fancy stuff. Nyc will always have a place in my heart but I've moved on and I like silence now)
Cash, opening today was kicking it- love your tunes- Charles had positivity all around him today- your energy was spot on- editing is primo.
You are Climbing toward 600k ! Bravo!
Keep going!☮️👏👏👏👏
Cash and Charles!! 👍🏻 love these wonderfully snarky glimpses into NYC
Rent one of these so Cash can invest in some knee patches for his jeans 😂
Clog proof Toilet ? 🤔 My family would consider that statement a challenge. 🙄
I guarantee my son and grandson could clog that toilet. My son comes to my house everyday to take his daily dump 💩.because his wife won’t let him do it at their house anymore 🤣. I made him buy a sewer snake and if he clogs it or commits other sins in there, he knows where the scrub bucket is and he had better clean up after himself, or else ☠️. I won’t let my grandson use my bathrooms.
@@lisabaltzer4190 good lord it must be bad if he's banned at home!
Well... I'd like the number for the cleaning crew for the first four apartments. They did an EXCELLENT job! But they were all a big "NO"! How can you have a bedroom without a window? Is that legal? And then... have the nerve to charge $4K/month? That's insanity on steroids. I actually liked the studios ($3500/month and $3300/month) much better but that's waaay too much money to pay for those spaces. While the last one did have the requisite wine cooler, at $4K/month... "no". Too much money for that small place of a closet. Clearly today's showings were about the severe mental challenges that many Landlords face.
Missed you yesterday.
Hey you! Missed you yesterday with the stoner agent. I knew you'd like the wine fridge but yeah, they're all a big fat NO from me also. I think this is 1 of the few times that Charles has severely disappointed us. There's always next time for him to redeem himself!
Well, Cash said it was Charles' open house, so I'm sure Charles was going through the ringer running all over!
@@bonniepwtf Aw... thank you! You're so kind!
@@MamaCarola1 Thank you! You're so kind! I don't know... they (Cash & Charles) might be sending a message to the Landlords letting them know that these places are not going to rent at the price level that they want them to.
Charles is the best!!m
He ALWAYS brings the most unique & the best homes!!!
Vids with him are so much fun!!❤
"What do you think they're growing up in that apartment?"
Probably whatever that dude in Cash's last video was smoking...
Always appreciate a demo of the kick flusher lol, hope that oven wasn't left on by the last disgruntled renter...love the thumbnail best one yet, they actually have places like that in my city 😬
I was fooled by the thumbnail and the click bait title. Oh my.
Welcome to the channel. I stopped complaining about the click bait titles a couple of years ago, because I still watch sometimes even though I know better.
@@myoldvhstapes Thanks for the welcome but I'm not coming back. It's not just the click bait and the over-excited delivery, it's all those "renovated" apartments with the same cheap cabinets and appliances. Any charm the apartments might have had has been removed, and that is disappointing.
Know why they put fences around cemeteries?
People are dying to get in!
Cemetery: those in can’t get out and those out, don’t want in. 😂😂😂
I was waiting for the apartment INSIDE a bathroom but I must've missed it!
All apartments were over priced but that last one irked me the most one again a shady landlord puts up a fake wall cutting the living room half just to make a small bedroom to charge more money smdh no integrity what so ever in New York realistate
$4k a month for less than 300 sqft boggles the mind.
True...can't believe that there are people who pay that amount🤷♀
0:57 According to the U.K/E.U "Farm Animal Welfare Committee" the Minimum Space to transport per head of cattle is 17.22ft (1.6m2) And they Must have a Window or Slotted Vents! So Bigger than that Bedroom!!🇬🇧🤣And they want $4000 for That??😱
"The bedroom is 8' x 7'." 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Maybe the outrageous rents in NYC,is the reason so few residents have cars!
no parking
Awesome video, Cash! Charles, you are the man! Your listings are always interesting and certainly will serve New Yorkers well, sir. Bravo to both of you!
Another good day spent with Cash and Charles. Even though they were pretty small they were all livable except the studio. I am still shocked at the high rent for such small apts. enjoy your day.😊
Usually Charles has really nice apartments. Guess this was an off day bcuz I've never seen anything so small & overpriced from him. At least the kitchen areas were updated & there was a wine fridge & washer/dryer in 1 but.... just no. I thought that old school building was gonna be great but goes to show you, looks can be deceiving. At least Cash caught that someone had left the oven on in 1. I got the feeling when Charles jumped so fast he thought Cash had done something tho. I
Well... if nothing else they were all clean and presented well. But there was very, VERY, little that was redeeming of any of them. Not the exposed brick, the fake fireplace, nor the wine fridge. It's unbelievable that Landlords are charging these prices for fourth and fifth floor walkups. Or they believe that someone will take it without a bedroom window. I couldn't imagine a bedroom sans a window. CRIMINAL!
Agree. Overpriced boxes. Poor Charles repping some bad Apts. I like Charles!
Cash makes videos for Charles' listings that can benefit from advertising to rent out: the relatively large beautiful but PRICEY apartments and apparently their small, weird (and also pricey) counterparts.
Always amuses me how many people seem to watch this channel specifically so they can crow about how they'd never live in the city and that anyone who does choose to is crazy because you can get susch and such an amazing house for such and such a cheap price wherever they are. ; )
Me too! They say they live in a 5,000 square foot house on a hundred acres and only pay $1.95 a month for their mortgage. 😂😂😂😂
Lifelong NYC dweller moved out 2 years ago. Never slept so well. Feeling cool and calm. The city that never sleeps is not good on the human body or for the human mind/soul.
@@daleypudding6015 you is soft
@@daleypudding6015 I love the pulse and possibilities and enjoy the different experiences in cities. I love a beer at a cafe at night and a walk though the streets looking at buildings through the seasons. The proximity to everything, that i can bike all over. That's a small part of why i live in the heart of a capital city. You couldn't make me move to the countryside or suburbs. It's not my thing.
@@charismahornum-fries691 yeah I said that too when I was in my 20’s in NYC. Now I’m in my 40’s and can’t wait to escape NYC
Well, it was really only a matter of time before someone fit a studio into a NYC bathroom....
I enjoy your content so much, I have no intention of moving to NYC, I’m like 1,500 miles from there, but I like your energy and the other realtors you feature.
Feeling like a Rockstar this morning with this music, Cash 😅😅🤘🤘
Hey Cash, loved that music in the first appart!!😍
Depressing! Nothing should cost that much.😢
Apartment #1: If the "bedroom" has no windows, it's not a legal bedroom, though if you removed the door and used a curtain, it probably meets the requirements. The kitchen is amazingly large, and the place looks fine for a single, if also overpriced. Apartments #2 & 3: The same comments apply, but they have more space. Apartment #4: An old-time fancier building with laundry, but it's SMALL, with questionable wiring. Apartment #5 is also tight and has a hazardous microwave. Apartment #6 has a bedroom with window and laundry machines, making it the best of the set.
In the last apartment, the "bedroom" is not actually a bedroom since it must be at least 80sq ft. Then again, almost everything is illegal in nyc
@@Myraisins1 agree
@@omi_god of course not. The prices are outrageous. I would never pay those crazy rents. No way . I have a beautiful 3 bedroom 2 bathroom house with a huge fenced in yard, on one acre of land near a small private beach for $1800 a month mortgage and in another 8yrs we will own the house. We have a 3% apr 15yr loan . And we are an hour drive from NYC. Just how we like it.
@@JustanotherLiz That's wonderful! Whereabouts do you live?
Remember when Jimmy McMillan ran for NYS Governor against Cuomo for “The rent is too damn high!” Party? I remember seeing him in a car with a megaphone driving through my Brooklyn neighborhood.
Really enjoy your videos man just wish you could include the streets everything is located on for a better idea comparing prices
❤❤❤ Longtime watcher, first-time posting. I have to say that for every efficiency I see I feel a better solution would be to have a convertible or "let out" couch, rather than having them separate. I think it just looks neater. Love what you do, Cash!!❤❤❤
Great job with the tunes, added to everything that was going on. Title & picture will have "certain" folks blowing their daily gasket.😅😅😅 Great video, fun watch.
*Lives are saved by keeping bedroom doors closed while sleeping* (to avoid smoke inhalation in a fire), but with no window for fresh air, many people won't leave it closed. Like others stated, it's not to code for bedrooms to be windowless, since needed for EM exits.
Why don't people use day beds in 0 bedroom apartments. It would change the world they live in!
sometimes there is 2 people jammed into this tiny apts. AND a 'baby'
I love your videos , wish this one had the neighborhood tour
2:00 Charles looking visibly upset and concerned 😬
This is Gonna b so Cool CJ🔥🔥🔥👍n Happy Monday😀….
those stained glass windows are AWESOME!
Apply for affordable housing. NYC connect. Many brand new buildings in NYC. Apts come with washer and dryers in unit. Rents much cheaper. Everything brand new. It's a lottery but you might get selected apply for as many as possible. The rent is too high , food is too high. Cut cost where you can. Let's just be real with people, for real.
OMG!….this is disgusting!!!….the price not to mention a toilet in the kitchen🤮. I live in NYC and I’m tired of everyone acting like these tiny expensive apartments are a great deal, damn the location. NYC should be ashamed of themselves 🤦🏽♀️
$3-4000 bucks a month blows my mind for these places
Hi Cash! I can tell you take a lot of time editing your videos. They look really amazing!
Where's the place from the thumbnail?
It’s not even in the fucking video. CLICKBAIT!
Hey Cash, just to say, I really dig the sounds you put on your videos.
As a musician, I was wondering if you'd accept demos from people that just want a boost to get listened to?
Cheers mate
Title is hilarious 😂
And not click bait! 😂😂😂
@@pineapplejoy True 🥳
You’re hilarious!! I watch you every day just for a good, clean, laugh!
1:11 this looks like NYC stand up bedroom with shelves, bonus!
I'm a fan of that last apartment. Yes, it's small, but it's nicely renovated, and I like the exposed brick wall. I also like the separate bedroom. Nice separation.....and not a horrible price as opposed to others I've seen.
Not a bad set of apartments! I LOVE the apartments with the brick walls!!
Glad that I don't live in NYChave a great monday😅😅😅😅
I love this videos because they make me appreciate my one bedroom apartment off the Green Line in Oak Park, IL. Beautiful 1920s Arts and Crafts style building…for $1100 a month.
Love your videos but will never move to NY. Rent will make me crazy 🤪 😜 😩. Have a Blessing day 🙏🏻
4:34 KARAOKE TIME 🎶❤🔥
Why are people so desperate to live in Manhattan? I'm a NY native and would never put up with all the inconvenience.
Good grief! The RENTS!!! My mortgage is only $2500 and my house is a 2 year old, 6K sq ft modern farm house. I’ll take that any day over ridiculous rents for closets!
I looked up how much minimum wage was there and I'm surprised anyone can afford the prices of many of those apartments. 😳 I won't lie those, while those apartments are tiny...they're adorable.
Truly appreciate this video because we got a regular human being perspective regarding what happened, I don't know anything about the celebrity involved but I think his idea was solid about giving away items, but like other influencers he could have just picked maybe 50 at the most subscribers and give away items this way. Who knows maybe he got more subscribers after this incident happened.
Whenever I watch these videos,I always wait to see how many times he mentions, "You can put a table over there." 🤣
Last apartment definitely the winner funny stuff with you two great video
I’d worry less about the legality of a bedroom and more about the legality of these rents!!....ABSOLUTELY ABSURD!!!!
Love your tunes man 😊❤❤❤❤❤
This one cracked me up for some reason, well done 😂
2:01 WHOA... could thing none of you cracked a match... 🔥💣💥
Really surprised they are showing illegal apartments. As a realtor they should know bedrooms have to have a window.
He said “what you trying to say?” 😂
I watched a documentary on "apartments" in Singapore. You don't know what horrifying is until you see how poor people live there.
Cash: its kinda dark in here
Charles: whatchu trina say?
😂
For a long time, I was under the impression that my last studio was 398 sq ft, but looking at these places, I have a feeling it was maybe closer to 250 sq ft.... the bathroom had just a shower and no tub, which made it the most spacious part of that apartment!
0:47 "whatchu tryna say -___-" 😂
Well 1 out of 5 guys - not good! No window = no room! It's time that NYC made such rentals illegal! No in unit laundry. For that rent I'm not dragging my laundry into a basement or down some shady street! #5 is the only one that I liked. Of course I enjoyed the C&C road show guys. Thanks.
Excellent assessment of the apartments (seriously).
I used to live in Flushing for $1550 per month for a closet pretending to be a one bedroom. Now I live in a 900 square foot luxury apartment for $1800 per month by moving a few hours west of the city to Buffalo. Money goes much further here.
Sink sprayer! Good catch, Charles Munroe.
Makes me wonder why they have such dishwashers in the smallest of kitchens, wash once you've eaten/filled the sink and then you have some more cupboard space?
I like the nextlast apartment. However, especially the first 3 will be tough to rent. Who pays 4k for such a tiny place without a window in the bedroom?
That place by the cemetary is actually a nice place to live imo
Cash could you do a look about in Bensonhurst? That would be very interesting!
awesome job cash thumb up see you tomorrow
No window = not a bedroom. These landlords advertising this are just criminals.
I own a rental management company in Idaho. Those bedrooms are deathtraps. You need at least 2 decent points of egress (ways to get out in case of fire) and these “bedrooms” don’t have that. There is no way I would rent out a property with those unsafe and not up to code bedrooms. Is that even legal in NYC?
@@lisabaltzer4190 I believe it's only illegal to advertise it as a "bedroom". Same rules apply, there needs to be a window for it to be declared as such.