Article 370 : Myths and Facts - J Sai Deepak -
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 02. 2020
- ARTICLE 370 - MYTHS AND FACTS
This dialogue functions to clear the myths associated with Article 370 with substantiated pieces of evidence. J Sai Deepak, the speaker, is an engineer-turned-litigator practicing as an arguing counsel before the Supreme Court of India and the High Court of Delhi. He is notable for his work on the court case pertaining to the entry of women to Sabrimala.
Much misconception has been formed over Article 370. In this video, J Sai Deepak answers a series of questions on Article 370 to put an end to the confusion, starting with - whether Article 370 has been abrogated or amended?
The other questions he answers in this video are:
*What are the consequences of the implementation of Article 370 at National and International levels?
*What is the reason behind the removal of Article 35a?
*Is this entire dispute an International or domestic issue?
*Post the amendment of Article 370, what are the options left with Pakistan to deal with the Kashmir issue?
*What are the possible options, which SC can take concerning the petition filed challenging the action of Union Government regarding Article 370?
By the end of this video, J Sai Deepak does three things:
1) Debunks the myths about Article 370
2) Makes it evident that the alteration of Article 370 was required
3) Proves that the removal of Article 35a was vital
For related Indic Talks and Indic Courses, see
Website - www.cisindus.org/
Facebook - / cisindusuniversity
Twitter - / cis_indus
Indic Talks : www.cisindus.org/videos/
Indic Courses : www.cisindus.org/courses/
Indic Varta : www.cisindus.org/indic-varta/
One day I would like to see Mr. Sai to be chief justice of India. He is a qualified personality from all angles. Thank you for bringing such an excellent interview. Keep bringing more.
For that to happen...passage of NJAC act or something of that sort seems to be crucial.
@@Thepatriotpodcast24 not necessarily. If collegium feels that he is fit
@@naveenparashar1984 have u listen jsd speaking in a law college on flawed collegium system n judicial ovverreach wherein he used the phrase "aristocracy of handful of unelected tyrants
@@naveenparashar1984 Mahatma Modi can make him if he wants.
Agreed
Please apeal govt to free hindu temples so they take-up their good works to promote ved art culture tradition rituals sculpture dance research education for all round development
we need Sai Deepak Ji as our Prime Minister. Chanakya re-born. Sharp, precise and a clear Rashtra Vaadi. Jai Hind.
J saie deepak is the brand Ambester of constitution & indian civilization 🙏, hat's off you sir👒, keep it up sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
How intelligent Nehru being PM of one of the largest countries with a fairly large n capable army was to take the kashmir issue to UN 😂....its just the amendment to 370, nearly half of the kashmir which we show in our map is still not ours... Lot more needs to be done to reclaim the entire territory which rightly belongs to Bharat!
Nehru and intelligence are violently opposed to each other.There has not been a fool like him in human history till this day.
How can anyone call Nehru intelligent!? Where is the proof of his wisdom? He helped divide India into Pakistan. Added to this, Nehru moved the Problem of Kashmir to The UNO. He was an uneducated, arrogant, self-centered Prime Minister of India who was not ELECTED but SELECTED BY M.K Gandhi. In fact, the Elected PM was Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel!. BUT, Mohan Das Karamchand Gandhi PERSONALLY favored Nehru as the first PM of India.
Please, read up Indian History Books written by Late Prof. Vishvanath Iyer, Late Prof.Veera Raghavachari and Panikkar written between 1950-1960.
The Indian History Books, published in late 60's 0nwards is fake and tilted to suit the fancy of the then Rulers.
Fantastic analysis. The mainstream media analysis about this topic is devoid of any logic or facts.
Excellent succint analysis!!
What a great combination. Sri Neeraj ji and Sri Sai Deepak ji - great to see people who stand for truth and intellectual knowledge Sharing and building strong cases for common public people who support Dharmic Bharatiya way of life. Thank you for both of your contributions and great support and sustained works.
Dharmic bhartiya way of life led india to b ruled by many powers is this another from inside or from outside.
Clarity of thought and crystalline articulation are the hallmark of this discussion 🤩. Excellent 👍.
He is totally biased and is clear about that there is no democracy in india if there is anything that is pakistan. Bro u r again colonised by ur own capitalist u r no more free india like US china .
Look bro time will decide his thought okk.
Great people in lndia . Cheers ! Three cheers to this man from south !!
Whenever I have doubt on anything related to constitution I listen to him. Al my doubts are cleared . Thank you!!!
Excellent analysis by Sai Depak. Wish he keep working on national interests of India. Thank you dear Sai Deepak
Brilliant mind ! Proud of you . Hindus need more Sai Drepaks ! God bless u
omg omg omg!!!!!! Both Neeraj sir And Deepak sir are my favourite😍
J Sai Deepak is a good advocate. He should work for abrogation of Hindu Charitable & Endowment Act, instead of fighting cases for individual temples Source of problem is this enactment.
Love and Respect J.Sai Deepak sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏❤️❤️🕉🕉
If CLARITY had a human form..
Best articulation of 370 article.....bravo mr. Sai Deepak
J.Sai Deepakji's analytical acumen is great,
🙏🙏🙏
Played the video as soon as i read J Sai Deepaj in the caption
He should be made permanent visiting faculty member of NALSAR .
Very lucidly explanation of article 370. Great clarity and thinking.
Very lucidly explained
Love listening his Answers 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sai Deepak thammudu you are rocking jai Bharat Jai Hind God bless you 🇮🇳🌷👏👏👌🎉😍👍
Punish Media for making its own conclusions ... They are forgetting there roles by making there own news ... they are supposed to inform what's happening in the world.
After this clip, I saw the light at the end of Tunnel No 370. 3 cheers, Shri Sai Deepak.
Dear Sir keep the spirit of fighting for justice all along. Very lucidly presented
Such a Beautiful and Inspiring presentation. !!
You are a gift for Indian society
Thank you🙏🙏🙏🙏...sir . We need your service to create awareness to understand the current situation of our Mother Land..Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳👳🇮🇳👳 .
The sad part is that the Congress party still extols the misdoings of both Gandhi and Nehru even at the cost of the interest of the nation.
Excellent explanation! My doubt is what was the need for J&K to have a separate constitution in 1956 if its own provisions said that it shall remain an integral part of the Union of India?
Practically speaking, Modiji didn’t exist in. 1956 to do what he did now!!!
Legally speaking J&K like all other pocketed kingdoms, has written agreements to join but it remained unfinished work. Hence it was technically a country within country, but already lost 90% of choices to be a separate country.
Ideally if POK didn’t exist, it would have been concluded then and there.
Even now, we can’t be fully proud! We formalized only the part that’s within India. 60% still exists as POK!
Beauty of Indian democracy is, despite it is magnanimous power, with practically no one siding with Pakistan, India went through proper constitutional obligations, and smartly used 370 and 35 for Kashmir, Jammu and Ladakh, as weapons to kill the effectiveness of 370 and 35!!!
Just like vaccination introduce imitated infections to avoid the virus in future, 370 was modified and used to make 370 ineffective!!! 😀😀😀
💐💐💐 Jai Hind!!! 💐💐💐
I saw you in some video with Rajuv malhotra.
Pls shriman hindi dubbed bhi release kare taki jyada se jyada logo tak aapki or humari baat pahuch paye jai hind
Very enlightening
Super Sai Deepak ji🙏🙏
Appreciate Mr Sai Deepak , using his intelligence and oratory skills for greater goodness of Mother Nation
J Sai Deepak ji and Neeraj ji KO Naman 🙏 .Brilliant Discourse between the two greats . Legal acumen of Sai ji is astounding and therefore his Analysis.
Wow, such knowledge. And such a good articulation.
Dhanyavadh
Deepak seems a man to be listened when for the first time I hear him
Clear cut analysis..... good job !!!!
good to see both experts in same video!
One-day I would like to see him as the PM. He must grow organically as Minister of Law, Home, Defence, Day. PM and then the himself.
SaiDeepak is our future PM. Sai us spontaneous, while Tejaswi strict goes by a rehearsed Script. Anything out of syllabus, Tejaswi will look like a School boy owned, but Sai Deepak learned to the core.
I love my sai very much. Our india should have thousands of sai. One day he become a powerful CJ. My heartiest wishes for him. God bless. Long live my love SAI.
Excellent explanation Sai Deepak thammudu congratulations jai hind 🇮🇳🌷👌👏👏👏👍👌🌷
very good discussion
Good video thanks from London.
Sai deepak ❤
Excellent explanation sir..thank you for enlightening us..
Extraordinary
Such a genius
Nest subramanyam swamiji.......👌👍
He should be our Chief Justice of Supreme Court.Superb logic,brilliant mind,thoroughly knowledgable
Pretty clear analysis by Sri J Sai Deepak ... 🙏😇🙏
Sai Deepak appears less than 50yrs age,, being an engineer graduate(asI read some where in one comment)how could he master Laws, constitution, history& be a practicing advocate in lands highest court SUPREME COURT!!!!!🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔how could he be so young still!!!!!! an extea ordinary genius!🤔🤔🤔!!!!!!!!
Great analysis, mr sai Deepak. 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Article 370 (1) still remains on the statute Book. Using this, a President who always works on the instructions of Central Government, in future can change this article and restore original position. In my opinion, article 370 should be entirely removed.
Golden words
Congratulations to all indians kashmiri for getting freedom from 370
📙💯
Super
I am a fan !!!
17:07 that’s the real issue, you change the whole agreement by changing the words or the meaning of the words yourself. It’s like they told Kashmiris that if you become part of India we will give you Hospitals, schools, jobs etc. and then after they join India and agreement is made, India replaces the words “Hospital”, “schools”, and “jobs” with “oppression”, “death”, and “grave”.
Without even referring to the other party of the agreement.
Jabardast
How much logic and facts are present in the discussion. That's why I left watching TV channels.
Need to put forth concept of CoK along with PoK in general discussion aswell
What a big surprise😘😘👍👍 There was no sign of Neeraj Atri Sir in the thumbnail or the Title. When the video started and listened the voice of Neeraj sir my mind... Ye awaj to... Then my head went up and Oh god ! I always wanted ghese both together and they are now. But I want a long discussion about govt control over hindu temples, missionaries, Islamic extremists, Darul Islam etc on Neeraj Sir show.
👌🙏✊
👌👌👌👌
Yes please u should also come to the discussion in media of North...
👍👍👍👍👍👍
Subramanian Swami Verision 2.0 🔥✔️
Really interesting and informative. What could have been a solved decades ago by debuting some one as erudite and belligerent as late c.p.ramaswamy iyer to negotiate,and showing acumen to drive the enemies altogether and by not taking it to the UN,we could have saved so many lives.
Dose UN resolution still active or not ? Please give more information on it
two dharmic intellectual deshsevak, of course the discussion is bound to be enlightening.
An excellent explanation of the issues. It was the genocide of a Kashmiri Pandits that led to the exodus. So it is important to refer to the events that took place then as the Hindu genocide wherein they Muslims gave the Hindus three options - Convert, Leave or Die.
Whatsapp se kam padha karo
Why did Nehru implement temporary Article 370 & 35A in J&K in the first place?
Article 370 is not the only thing wrong. Kashmir for Kashmiris, Maharashtra for Mahrashtrians, the Dravidian model ensuring that "others" do not come to Dravidasthan, and so on and so forth. From Day 1, if anyone talked of Secession , it should have been treason. If anyone talked of anything regional, denying the right of the people of the land to move freely within the country, as guaranteed in the Bill of Rights of the Magna Carta, should have been enforced. Nehru did not do that. As such given that Nehru had endorsed Article 370 and his great grandson is openly talking about repealing that abolition, should be considered as treason.
can rohingyas' and uighurs' citizenships be cancelled ... those people should now be deported and they have no right to indian citizenship
Ban all media which creates or instigates anger
Haan Art. 370 ke baad ek bhi millitant nhi niklaa Kashmir se... Koi bhi attack nahi hua... Khushi hi Khushi ki lehreen dhaud rahi hain jar jagaah... Employment tou all time high hai... Aur mazze ki baat ye hai ki.. 35A ke provisions abhi bi applied hain in form of domicile...
Jab tak aakhri muslim India rahega tab tak aatankwaad rahega. How to eliminate them is the question
Please give good good protection and freedom to speak
I used the stones to destroy the stones
He is not an interview man.
we can extract most of the knowledge from him if he is set free for the whole stages.
At 9:24 interlocutor said amendment of Article 370 'created a noise at the international level' - the concerns raised by the international community were not about the act of amendment itself but about the severity of security measures that were imposed in the state (curfews, cutting of internet services etc) subsequent to the amendment.
And why was that done? They were afraid, they knew it is not acceptable to Kashmiris.
@@SkepticalScribe3940 Why was it done? Most definitely to prevent Pakistan sponsored Islamic terrorists from spreading propaganda against the Government of India- organizing civil unrest and violent demonstrations in the wake of the abrogation of Article 370. That's why!
As to 'it being not acceptable to Kashmiris' sure it would not be acceptable the sessionist elements of the State. But when one invokes Kashmiris one cannot cherry pick Muslim Kashmiris or the secessionist elements in the State; one must also consider the 3-5 million or so Kashmiri Hindus based in Jammu and elsewhere in India and the world, who are also have an equal stake in the State.
One cannot blithely ignore the fact that (A) the State of Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India (those who are not reconciled to this fact are free to leave and migrate to Pakistan en masse) (B) Article 370 was designed to be a temporary measure and was meant to be repealed sooner or later. Secessionists never accepted that so why would it be acceptable to them?
ladies and gentlemen you are listening to library
If j sai deepak at place of fools like dhruv rathee , the country have different intelligent public.
Dhruvv rathee just throw random statement by staying away from own country for paid sponsorships...he never use resources for doing better review or doing anything good for people leaving in India....his only target is too spread false allegations on modi government and of course making money by spreading negativity ....
pappuji supporters are barking here🤣😂
Sai have you ever read the book by name the bend in the Ganges. Written in approximately in 1922, by miher sen
I'm not a commentator in the matter if politics and constitution. As a spectator and arms force personal deployed in the valley at that period, I've experienced the various consequences upon amendment of art. 370 and 35a. Almost every aware Kashmiri believe that it is abrogated totally and this instance has deliberately reduce devil stone pelting at security agencies. The whole active terrorist section and SANGBAZ gang goes into hibernation for a specific period, at that period in certain LAC speculation fire was decreased. Honestly it's an impact on political correctness in the valley, terrorist activities and some anti social and governmental tactics. Definitely it is a bold and justified steps in favor of our nation as well as citizen of India. Many leaders and opportunists take advantage of the inappropriate act, whereas people living in adjacent to LAC are totally unaware and they had nothing to do with them. Ultimately it was an instrument to the exploit benefits from government by few opportunists which was designed and crafted exclusively for the notorious cult.
I'm happy for my fellow men that now on they are less pron to face stones and the same way boys and girls get an opportunity to get away from non lethal pallet injury.
Jai Hind jai Bharat
Kanhaiya kumaar and sai deepak are the people who give me confidence about India's political future.
Kanhaiya kumar???😂😂🤣🤣which weed do u smoke bro??
Kanhaiya is a rogue. Please don’t ever compare him with J Sai Deepak.
You are mentally challenged person....
GoI is anyways bringing domicile rule making it ineffective for us to buy land or work in J&K.
Haha...sab election le liye thaa... Nothing has changed no the ground..
Yesterday at Arth festival it seemed to me like you were debating with Owaisi rather Swamiji debating with him. 🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍
Sai ripped Owaisi apart on the question "Do you use any Indian theological concept as an Indian Muslim?" Owaisi was nonplussed, huffed and puffed but was not able to come up with an answer. We know that Kutchi, Lohana, Sindhi and Gujrati Muslims believe in Hindu Goddesses (Kali) and some follow the Hindu laws (adoption, inheritance), but we know that Owaisi is a Wahabi Sunni who only follow Arabic Sharia law.
What will be the status of rohingyas who were given permanent status in jammu region before 5th aug 2019 ? Will ty lose PR status & go back?
Very early we Indian jump to conclusion without fully assessing all aspects of the personality. There are many intellectuals in legal field have over all knowledge but they are neither public personality and nor have time to debate issues.
Why govt doesn't make him chief justice of India
Sir all the lawyer read the same constitutional rights,then why misinterpreted
Political benifits, I guess
Article 370 was 100% amended in legal terms - which is as good as an annulment, repeal or abrogation. The Govt of India was able to use its powers under article 370(1) to amend article 367, and then use a Presidential Order to amend 370 in totality.
All provisions of Article 370 were replaced by the text "All provisions of this Constitution, as amended from time to time, without any modifications or exceptions, shall apply to the State of Jammu and Kashmir notwithstanding anything contrary contained in article 152 or article 308 or any other article of this Constitution or any other provision of the Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir or any law, document, judgement, ordinance, order, by-law, rule, regulation, notification, custom or usage having the force of law in the territory of India, or any other instrument, treaty or agreement as envisaged under article 363 or otherwise"
Sai Deepak should become another Harish salve
Guys, stop fantasizing him. Respect his will, and become a fighter against adharma like him. Not an armchair activist on SM but like him maybe on the legal side, or maybe an engineer, doctor, artist, historian/scholar etc..Fight with civility with laser focus like him otherwise see Dharmics disappear from Bharat in next 100 yrs. Develop this level of articulation & erudition. This is what will save bharat & not just voting for a political party 🙄
Totally agree with u!