Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 03. 2024
- HW News' Managing Editor, Mr. Sujit Nair, converses with distinguished historian and writer, Dr. Ram Punyani, exploring the notion of Hindu Rashtra. Dr. Ram Punyani, who previously held positions as a professor of biomedical engineering and senior medical officer at the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, boasts a career spanning over four decades, commencing in 1973, with 27 years dedicated to service at IIT starting from 1977. #RamPunyani #HinduRashtra #Hindutva #Hindusim #BJP #RSS #VishwaHinduParishad #Elections #LokSabhaElections #Elections2024
"Opinions expressed in this interview are solely those of the participants involved and do not necessarily reflect the views of the channel or its affiliates."
Please bring some BJP and Right wing people for interview.
a lot of these old foggies..have been so conditioned by western/marx ka churan...and despise civilizational value systems...that made us developed...and attracted these same...western impoverished cultures!
a lot of t...hese old foggies..have been so co....nditioned by ....western/marx k..a churan...and despise civil...izational value systems...that made us developed...and attracted these s..ame...western impoverished cultures!
A very learned and knowledgeable mind.. dr. Punyani. Thanks for the lucid details.. and Sujit.. for arranging the dialogue. Hats off to you sirs.
Very insightful, Dr. Ram Punya.
Thank you.
Excellent analysis and explanation by Dr. Ram Punyani.
@HWNewsEnglish - I must appreciate Mr Sujit- excellent conversation by him & Dr Punyani. Mr. Sujit is class act & perfect Gentleman. No interference while Dr. Punyani talked & wanted explain in detail & articulate his explanations. Unlike many other channels particularly the godi media.
Respect that about you - Love these brilliant conversations. Its insightful. clears doubts & most of all lets us see & appreciate all perspectives. He explained it so well, Thank you Dr. Punyani
🤣
Hinduism very well explained by Dr Ram Punyani.
Religion should be private and personal choice left to the individual.The state should treat all religions equally.That is the whole essence ..
As long as imported religions are not growing this fast from 3 to 20 percent since independence by Dynasty rule.
Religion can't be private. Because they're part of defining our public morality, identity, community, history and future. This delusion that religion has to be private is created by secularism.
ALL RELIGIONS ARE NOT EQUAL
ONLY RELIGION'S BORN IN THIS LAND ARE EQUAL
I can explain. Looting money in the name of electoral bond is Hindu Rasthra
tujhe pata laga tera baap kaun hai?
😂
RIZEBAG LOGIC WHO BOWS DAILY BEFORE AN IMPORTED CROSS
Most of the rich Indians thrive on foreign food where most of the things are made of non veg products. Double standards by politicians whose children study in western countries .
What stupidity is that? 70% of present Indians are meat /fish eaters. Non-veg is a dirty word used and invented by Indians. (chek internet) Maybe Ram can give the history of that.
WHO TOLD YOU THIS?
WHAT A CHEW TEA
VEGETARIANISM IS SPREADING FAST IN WEST
Wow, studied indian history in 38 minutes with clarity better than from volumes of social studies textbooks from school.
Hahaha.. 😂 you will forget in next 5mins
Excellently explained for any lay man to understand easily.
Hats off
राष्ट्रीय एकता के लिए हिन्दुइज्म सदैव प्रयत्नशील रहा है। और अलगाववादी तत्वों के सदैव विरोध में रहा है।
Excellent information from Dr. Ram Punyaje
Wonderful Conversation. Thank you
Very powerful video gained so much knowledge !!
Samaan vichaarwaale Sabke saath sabka vikaas waale Akhand Bharat se Bharat First ka sankalp rakhnewaalom ka unbreakable samooh ko koti koti salute.
Excellent interview. Need of the hour. Helps those with a little open mind to tread the path of sanity. Mr. Sujit Nair, Thanks for bringing out this interview. Also in general I appreciate the quality of your journalism.
It's hindutva rashtra not hindu rashtra. It's Saffron Sharia..
you must enjoy the green and so your womenfolks.
Lol. That’s funny. All bigots have a feudal mindset and show the same tendencies while hating the other.
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Thanks for this fabulous presentation. Helped clarify so much.
Ram Punyani is a gem of a man. All of 70 years of progress is being undone by Gujuart. People and history will never forgive them. :(
Makes a lot of sense, respect for gandhi, nehru & ambedkar is high. Understanding their noble fight against inferior moral values and feudal power systems gave goosebumps.
You guys need to read up on history lol.Gandhi wanted casteism to continue.Savarkar wanted to abolish casteism.Yet one is the Father of the nation.
yep, gandi used to sleep with two naked women every night who were 1/3 or 1/4 of his age. gandi was mohamad of 20th century.
@@kunals8022correct 💯
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Superior values ...yup Islam
Sarrr
Im a ram puniyani fan...he is knowledgeable
great wisdom big man!!
😂
Very well explained.I hope we follow a beautiful way of life and nurture each other.
Amazing session when you stick with one topic
In south its good to remain as it is . We are not worried of north this is their choice. Better to get divided instead of blaming each other..
Wonder why all Andh Bhakt from north. North is very inscure n men are cowards so they feel better wen someone rule them with kick in ass .
Where as south is Intellect and West Bengal as well , ppl use brain and understand how things work.
You can move across the world with Indian passport but land remain with India, no more partition now get Rohingyas treatment 😮
@jaydev7155 No wonder so many Indians inside India wants china to start a war with India. They will join in, to break up India.
100% agree with that
We will not allow backward North to dictate to the South
That is clear
The quality of the audio is extremely bad!😢
Excellent explanation ❤
सावरकर मूव्ही देखके काँग्रेस खेमे मे आग लगी है क्या ,? 😂
हिन्दुइज्म में ही इनको साम्प्रदायिकता दिखाई देती है। 😅 राष्ट्रीयता नहीं दिखाई देती।
Bhai Bollywoodiya hindu ko mafiveer ki movie pasand aayegi😂 tum log Bollywood mein hi khush raho.
@@ShamshadAlam-ei4ne वाईसे भी तुझे नही समझने वाली मूव्ही बनी है.. तू गांघी की मूव्ही देखता होगा ना ?
Sujit am happy, you have made an effort to know our culture stuff of our nation at least now....to confirm more and more knowledgeable and learned people for your future arguements.
Sujit sir. Great.
Fantastic
Whatever Sir punani spoke is completely correct n the hard truth to these present blind followers n double standard n hypocritic Hindus.
Okay phernandes
Third rate converts
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Gai Raksha does not mean an explossion of wild cows creating a problem for farmers with this banjar pashu every where. They should be exported to other countries instead of banjarpashu problem in the Hindi speaking states.
Good interview
Fruitful discussion and informative for many
Thanks for this video.
BEST part about HW News: guests are actually allowed to speak 😄
The Freeing of Brahmins in the Bilkis Bano case and the special mention as 'Sanskaari Brahmins" by Gujarat High Court is a sample of how the law treats different Jatis when the shxt hits the fan. Even with the constitution, many Supreme Court judges favour the Hindus. So what will it be like when a Hindu Rashtra comes?
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Do u know abt k.u.f.r
Such a pleasure listening to Dr. Ram Punyani
Why and whom Hindu Rashtra is being conceptualized ? Will it improve our economy and make us a dominating force to recone with.
Wonderful explanation!
What he said about Hinduism can also be said of other religions too. Especially in relation to Pakistan.
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Do u know abt k. U.f.r
Aryans came...Aryans came...Aryans came...from where, how and what is the evidences???
HE IS VOMITING WHAT HIS CHURCH MASTERS VOMITED IN HIS MOUTH
ARYAN /DRAVIDIAN WAS A CHURCH CREATION TO DIVIDE HINDU'S FOR SOUL HARVESTING
Would be good to have the what? Why? Where? When? Who? How? In a text document shared after the session.as well...
Today's Hinduism is a umbrella under this there are major religions and minor religions. major religions are
1. Saivam - one who prays Sivan
2. Vainavam- one who prays Perumal in South and Vishnu in North
3. Kaumaram-in South worshipers of Lord Murugan
4. Ganapathiyam - in west worshipping Lord Ganesh
5. Sathism- in east worshipping of Devi
6. Souram - worshipping of Sun
7. Vedic - worshipping of Brahma and mostly Brahmins preeching Sanatanam, Manusmriti basis
8. Kuladeivam - worshipping ancestors almost all over India in all society
These are apart from Buddhism and Jainism
These are sects...
How beautiful our beloved country was before 2014! Vote wisely this year.
Yes, Pakistan was a beautiful country before 2014.
Why is the sound quality so bad?
Hindu rashtra is a utopian idea which might backfire to further balkanize the country if pursued for some more time. It has the capability to divide India into many fragments in future.
The only reason Bharat exists, and tolerates so many different faiths, cultures, is because of Hinduism and the Hindus majority.
We can see what happened wherever muslims were in the majority.
THERE WILL BE NO DIVISION
ONLY COMPLETING THE INCOMPLETE PARTITION FROM 1947 BY POPULATION TRANSFER
Dr Ram Punjabi is one the very respected professor of IIT Mumbai. My meeting with him is very vivid. One of the nice and wise gentleman.
DID YOU MEET HIM INSIDE CHURCH?
Hindutvadi soch hindu Rashtra..
Classic case of ( the wilfully ) blind leading the ( wilfully) blind...
🙏🙏👏👏👏👏
This discussion should be broadcast in Hindi so that the rural population can be made aware of the situation
😂
Where is it?
JNU student election results indicate BJP is loosing badly in the ensuing elections
THAT JNU HAS 4000 STUDENTS ONLY WHICH HAS MOST LEFTIST PEOPLE.. INDIA HAS 1.50 CR WHICH MOST ARE DESHBHAKT AND MODI BHAKT...
Very funny 😂 only 8000 students University
YEAH THAT'S WHY BJP HAS ALREADY SWEPT ARUNACHAL PRADESH EVEN BEFORE ELECTIONS HAVE TAKEN PLACE
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAH
Really really good explanation sir .
The vegetarian Hindi-Hindu-Hindutva basically represents the Hindi belt. In the South, Hindi is not acceptable. The Bengalis are non-vegetarian, but Hindus and have powerful cultural and literary traditions based on the Bengali language. They are very proud of them and will fight tooth and nail against the imposition of any alien value. So a serious clash is inevitable. Will India survive the imposition of Hindutva? The future does not look good.
See the bottom-line is that Republic of India is not going to have any state relegion in coming future and all this is merely a propoganda, yet I'm proud pious and stauch Hindu who subscribe to the idea of That thou art. Thank you 🙏
Hindu raashtra means ghulam of Modi and Amitsha. Nothing else
Chal फेकू
Chandranathu Basu coined the term Hindutva in 1890.
Rss stand as Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh
So rashtriya means national
Then our country or Afghanistan. Which one will have more value in the world among other countries?
The concept of Hindu Rashtra is not in our national interest Kashmir Punjab many parts of North East and many parts of South will not accept Hindu Rashtra Those wanting Hindu Rashtra are in there ignorance asking for a break up of this nation Some one commented Hindu Rashtra and Khalistan are two sides of the same coin What we need is a firm rejection of the idea of nation based on religion
Some people are blind. They never see the clear, present and imminent danger. All have the right to their views. It ends there.
And what is that danger? Have the courage to spell it out.
@@himmsingz when the danger strikes you will know. So be patient & courageous too.
@@universalhuman4417 You don’t have even a small amount of guts. Lol.
@@himmsingz DANGER IS SEMETIC TERRORISM
WE DON'T WANT ANY SEMETIC TERRORIST ON OUR HOLY LAND
People might be having different opinions according to personal understanding. In Hinduism there is no concepts of selectivity as see in all other cultures and religion. Total inclussiveness without divisions. We consider whole world one family including plants and animals. Family members might have different approach and path they are allowed to choose till aims and objectives aren't to harm themselves and other family members. After so many cultures and religion in the whole world it's impossible to make akhand Bharat again so at least Bharat culture needs to be channelised within Bharat. After partition on religious bases Bharat automatically becomes Hindu nation as other portions endorsed as Islamic nations. It was failure of past leadership non endorsements of Bharat as Hindu nation for own political interests and preferred upeasements. After nationalist leadership of modiji/yogiji public becomes awake and hopeful . Removal of article 370 foundations of Ram temples are practcal proof for inclination of presents bjp leaderships. So Hinduism is certainly beneficial for everyone. Selectivity is illusions and personal interests only.
Buddy it's Gandhi's Hinduism minus minority appeasement ( no support to Khilafat, proselatisation etc. )
No other way. Eventually this will be a corporate varna world. kali kalam ☹️
Why sound so bad
What is hindavi swaraj as propagated by the Chhatrapati then?
dna ka locha hai ram punyani ka.
Who is this man?
Lmao
Buddhism does have caste hierarchy
very bad sound
Vasudeva kudumbaka (The world is one family.). That is the operative part of Hindutwa.. All nations have boundaries. These boundaries engulf a specific common culture. Do not mistake it with religious nationalism of the Abrahamic religions. Here we have Hindus and Abrahamic religious followers. Modern democracies follow a universal franchise. Influencing individuals or collection of individuals is the basis is getting power. Hence religions and cast are tools to exploit.The confusion about the Indian nationhood is the aggressive vote bank tactics, to use the cast and religions, strategically , to get power to rule. Your explanations here are political understanding taught in academies. It is not based on the cultural evolution of Hindus. The people who lived south of the Himalayas were Hindus as accepted .. A simple mind can understand it. But a power hungry politically exploitive mind set of modern times cannot digest it. They do not get satisfied with the world is one family concept? . The Hindu concept of living a life is Dharma ,Ardha, Kama and Moksha. Simply putting it is that following dharma( right living) earns material satisfaction to full fill desires to culminate into self realisation and happiness.bIt is inclusive! The uncompromising condition is right living. !!! Here politics do not restrict itself to right living. 😢😢😢😢Hence the confusion on nationhood! . Right living for Hindus are practicing Bhakti( Supreme love for the God ) to gain knowledge and wisdom by studying Dharma puranas( Ramayana and Mahabharata with special attention to Bhagawat Geetha), full filling material desires and finally adopting to sanyas ,retired life. These ideas are puranic teachings. Here Hindu has space for other faiths.But other faiths are politically made to distrust it. ( Why do they see RSS, a service organisation as nasty?)Politics exploit this division. The people who lived south of the Himalayas though Hindus, were administered separately by the compulsions of dialect, geography and localised culture. Hence the kingdoms came to existence. These kingdoms were linked through broader Hindu culture envisaged in the Mahabharata . So ?? What are our cultural , religious and political boundaries.????? The cultural boundary is the largest! . The religious boundary is bias and exploitation . Finally , the political boundary is devoid of Dharma !! We can discuss till the cows come home.😅
Above gentleman has no courage to comment on other religion except Hindu
Ghandhi was against all types of killing or slaughtering. However, why he was specifically against cow slaughtering?. Grass / leaf are the food of many other animals. So, what is the difference between life(jeevan) of a cow and other animals?. What are the fundamentals of glorification of cow life?. Jeevan or life is implanted in every vegetable, seeds other than fruit's flesh. So eating seeds and vegetables is also one way of destroy of life(jeevan)?
THEN WHY WAS KHANGRESS FIGHTING ELECTIONS UNDER THE SYMBOL OF COW AND IT'S CHILD?
Ram not a avatar can you ask Sita
What has a iitian got to do with hindu rashtra
HE WILL GIVE GYAAN TO HINDU'S
WHILE APPEASING MUZLIM ON THE SIDE
Lies lies and lies which was spread by Dravisha creeps
What secular India means, support khilaf movement, support direct action day, support moplah riots, genocide of Kashmiri Hindus, privileges to minorities in educational institutions, scholarship, Hajj subsidy, wafq board grant, imam salary, personal law and many more based on religion,
Every thing you said was because of religious zealots, which was opposite of secularism. Just because your brand of religious zeal is different from those doesn't make secularism the villain
@@dineshbfaces Hindus getting any minorities privileges in any country across the world?
@@dineshbfacesand all happened against hindus and still you want secularism
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Hindu rastra==brahmin kshatriya baniya rastra thread raj == ,manuwadi raj == 10%brahminical peoples rastra==
In history their was no hindu. Hindu religion was made by
British. When british came in india there was christian and islam and other some people like aarya and dravida.The briliant british made hindu religion mixing aarya and dravida.
Namazi
What is hindu rashtra and Khalistan my?
Let every body chose for him self his illusions and dellusions/ religion . What the words that guest quote " love is religion " So it should be . Otherwise watch Western philosophies has done with the world ,specially in Middle east . I suspect that story to be repeated into India if state follows CIA !!!
Hindu Rastra is Raj Tantra ...where everyone is Praja not Nagarik
It is a terrible curse as said by Ambedkar who even left Hindu Dharma and rightly so
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Yes Islam izz good sarrr
@Amber-mt3nv he read Manusmirti only
@Amber-mt3nv I do not care ...give any tag u like..the truth is there is no Hindu dharm or Sanatan ..it is Brahman Dharma and everyone else is Sudra
“Reason to believe why Hindu rastra will be Rajtantra”
this Vision is not new not something current BJP or RSS has imagined. It is the founding father of RSS/Hindu Mahasava has conceved. Likes of Dr. Munje, Golwalkar and Savarkar.
It is not just a theory, they have written multiple books and article about it. None of which talks about a parliamentary democracy. And only democracy gives power to critisise the ruler no other forms of government does, only democracy gives freedom of expression by that very right today BJP neta and supporter says Godse Jindabad and Gandhi is british agent. Hence without it we are just Praja.
I will not make it lengthy by referencing many books. I will just point to a fact.
Dr. Munje went to Italy and met Musolini and stayed in then fascist state in March 1930. When he came back he advocated a fascist state in his daily paper Kesari . Like every week he wrote an article on how fascism is better and a Hindu state with one leader is the right way.
Next we do not have to go back that far. Let see the current state. BJP has not done anything that is not already written in the books. The purge of muslim was written after holocaust by Golwalkar praising Hitlers extermination of jew and asking Hindus to take inspiration.
Current PM is almost a king only thing pending is the last breath of democracy in SC and Liberal social media and opposition . Rest all Media , Institutions, all other courts are at his disposal. Who dare to expose him will get a whip from agency. He does as he please , anybody joins BJP is clean rest all deserves dungen.
Finaly after 2024 election 400+ seat Hindustra I have no reason not even 1% to believe that that last breath of democracy will not be gone. And yes we will have election and be a democracy just like Russia.
Mr.Sujit,You are from Kerala,land of literary are in high in number. Why don't you leave your caste name? Your channel is being followed by persons of different caste.
That is anti hindu.
776k subcribers.
776 views.
Pthetic.
learn propaganda from ravish.
check now....check even later...u just take a convenient snapshot and make your comments?
See it after 5 days.....all wont be live here man who will eventually see it
He is a brahmin who subjected all under privledged to hardships for more than 5000 yrs. Just dump him and move on.
First explain what is a communist ideology?? Because the majority of the top commies are living lives more lavishly than Adani and Ambani 😊. Plz explain communist ideology. Then I will explain what is a hindurashtra
No need to explain hindurastra! We understood!
After 2014 i seen people blindly hating BJP and RSS I my self was the part of it. But now I have realised their truth. The left media talks about Democracy in danger. Minorities in danger under BJP RSS rules without studying the ground reality. Now I know what real BJP RSS is. They are more connected to the ground the this left parties.I have seen RSS people work to uplift the society. Hindutva is all about uniting Hindus under one umbrella by slowly slowly removing cast barriers among them throw economic uplifting and urbanization. Congress has been in power for 70 years and what they did for so long was divide Hindus in basis of cast and consolidate muslim to win elections but BJP is uniting Hindus throw nationalism and hindutva and economic upliftment.i just wand to say in 2019 lok sabha i was 19 years old and it was my first time voting and I voted for Congress
but this time am more aware of things around me and this Time am gonna vote for BJP.
We need to go back in time when none of the aliens like the first alien got into kerela and the the rest of British Islamists who came into India for whatever reasons the then living was only one kind of people living with their own practices etc. The people living in this area was called Hindus the name originating river Sindhu. Then it was called Hindu Rashtra devoid of all aliens and alien practices.
Many sincere Hindus are not likely to accept the Hindutwa of Dr. Ram Punyani.
Shear wast of time by Sujit. There cannot be a hindu gods, idlsmic gods and christisn gods. There is a power unknown to any human from inception of universe till this day. There cant be three parents for one man kind, leave alone other smmal bit religions. So leave the church, masjids and temples and other worship places of all denominations to fanatics like the one talking. We can have peace. So religionless world must be our motto.
Real islam first
Such one sided view. Jai hind
Brother Nair ji,
Does it matter if you understand Hindu rashtra and then decide if you want it or not?
Any case , you are against anything Hindu and Nationalistic.
Then why bother ?
And you bring gentlemen like Punyani to support your view point.
Just leave Hindus alone !
good for every body !
Relax are you afraid to handle truth and facts . ...? Let us alone man. Go back when ready
Brother, being nationalist does not mean subscribing to a single religion and being thoroughly communal and practicing dictatorship in the name of that particular religion. just imagine , of today the western nation who has almost left the orthodox church suddenly decides to become practising Christians and decided that the Christians should only be first class citizens and rest all trash and should live only as per Christian values, and tortures kills Indians and other religious population just because they are NOT christians , your nri friends would have to return to India to save their lives.do you want that?
Buddhists vs muslims in srilanka and Myanmar
Jews vs muslims in isreal
Christains vs muslims in Europe
Hindus vs muslims in India
Iraq vs muslims in Iraq
Third class interview
Completely distorted discussion. Gandhi was a hardcore orthodox Hindu. There was no difference between Congis or Hindu mahasabha's ideology. Congress was a political wing of Hinduism before RSS, Jansangh, BJP etc emerged.
Definition of Hindu, Hindutva, are all getting distorted in these discussions. Crap...
Sujit Sir,
You will keep debating baseless dogma while Sangh Parivaar will play smart electoral politics and end up with far more seats than Congress and Allies.
People don't Vote for BJP for a 'Hindu' Rashtra. They VOTE FOR BJP TO ENSURE (IN THEIR MIND) HINDU POLITICAL SUPERAMACY IN PRESENT DAY INDIA.
So much for the Appeasement and Communal Politics dichotomy of Congress in post independence India.
India may split into 28*28 political entities. It doesn't matter to Commie spokespersons like Mr. PUNIYANI a bit. People of his ilk shall be posted in Eastern Ladakh and be the first 'shield' for our Nation against Chinese Bullets 😅