DIY Su-57 Felon with Ducted Fan or Pusher Prop : Which One is Better?
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 08. 2023
- I made this Sukhoi because I already made an F-22 Raptor plans, because I think it would be interesting if I made its rival too which is Sukhoi Su-57 Felon or in Russia known as T-50 PAK FA. This model is not design specifically for neither EDF or pusher prop, I just design the model airfame that can be built with 5-6mm foam board or depron or polyfoam, without any propulsion mounting design. You have to figure out yourself, but you can see on the build video how I install a single 70mm EDF on center between the two exhaust. For this setup I use FMS 12 blades 6S 70mm EDF, with 2.6 kg thrust with 80A ESC and 6S 2200mAh Lipo, I think it's more than enough than the weight itself. I also convert it from EDF to pusher prop using DXW 3536 1200kv brushless motor, 10 inch prop, 50A ESC and 3S 2200 mAh Lipo. Both perform well, while there's some problem in the beginning, you can see it on the build video on CZcams.
Download plans files :
paper-replika.com/index.php/r...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @juliusperdana
Specs :
1. Wingspan 1000mm / 39.37 inches
2. Flying weight : 1028 grams/ 36.3 oz
3. Wing loading :20.4 gram/dm2 - 6.7 oz/sq.ft.
4. Wing cube loading : 2.9
5. Wing Area : 50.35 dm2 / 780 sq.in.
6. CG : 8 cm / 5.39 inch from Wing Break
Electronics for test (pusher prop)
- DXW 3536 1200kv
- Prop 10x6 (2 blades)
- 50A ESC
- Battery Lipo 4S 2200mah
- 4 x 9 gram servos (micro servo)
Electronics for test (EDF)
- FMS 70mm 12 blades 6S EDF
- 80A Predator ESC
- Battery Lipo 3S 2200mah x2 (series connection)
- 4 x 9 gram servos (micro servo)
Transmitter
- Jumper T16 + BetaFPV Express LRS TX module
- 10 ch BetaFPV Express LRS RX - Jak na to + styl
You know what i like of your videos?, the fact that you show how hard could be sometimes the path from the maiden flight to the final plane configuration. Many channels show just how was build it and then flying flawlessly. So many beginners thought that scratchbuild and fly is very easy, when actually is not. Thanks a lot for this video!
hahaha thanks, on this video there are 7 flights with 6 crashes, actually it was 8 flights, all 7 ended up in crash lol. I assumed landing on water is not crashing lol
Setuju pernyataan anda bung👍
@@felixsrcworld5112 Terima kasih ! ☺
Great work, really good. But pls dont respect anithing russian, this terrorists state bombs civil people. This is a murderers aircraft. Not for defence. One day they can come to yours home too. Hope we will stand and win. Greetings from Ukraine!
@@JuliusPerdana Dont be too hard on yourself! those wasnt crashes, remember, Every landing where you walk out of the plane is a good landing, if the plane can still be used later then its a great landing so it was a great landing x6 ;D
Unbelievable how tough your model is - still flying after so many crashes. I should try building mine out of foam to be this survivable!
thank you, packing tapes hold it together, for me I'm surprised on how durable the plastic primer is, not any single chipping paint.
Am also so impressed that you use parcel tape. Could this become brittle with age? Like it dries out and crumbles?
@@richardkan8499 It depends on the brand. I have had some packing tapes go a little bit brittle with age, and others completely unaffected. Funnily enough, the worst for that is the fibreglass-strand-reinforced packing tape. The adhesive they use turns yellow and crystalline with UV exposure, and loses all its stickiness.
Hi, it's called a leading edge flap, it helps direct air over the wing during high angle of attack so the plane doesn't stall. Also very nice build!
but nice aircraft
nope, that's a levcon - leading edge vortex controller
It is not quite that. The Russians call them Levcons, and their objective to control the formation wing root vortices
Нет, мы не называем их «левкон».
Это отклоняемая кромка крыла.
now we can say that there are 12 SU 57s in this world which means, theres an entire squadron of them
Lol
@@JuliusPerdana indeed
Where did you get this numbers? 😂 Amount of jets is classified and unknown.
Before 2014 when Russia increased level of security, country produced by 100 different jets per year only for internal usage (and dozens for foreigners). It is public numbers. According to Soviet experience, it means in 2-3 times more produced secretly. So, at least 200 jets per year. From that times Russia increased amount of production. How do we know this? Factories nowadays working in 2 and some even 3 shifts (24/7 non stop). It means production increased in 2-3 times. So, now is produced at least 400 jets per year. New factory for Su-57 launched in 2019. So, according to basic logic, there are at least several dozens or more likely few hundreds of Su-57.
You reminded West which year ago told that Russia have cruise missiles only for 1-2 month of usage. Surprise, Russia already used more than West produced for last 20 years and still use almost each day. If you forgot, in Russia all military factories are state owned, country have all resources (from energy to metals) in unlimited amount, it means for Russia weapons de facto cost nothing. And production is limited only by amount of workers. Are you forgot how europeans failed back in 1940s when attacked Russia. They also was sure, in Russia no weapons. Surprise, Russia had and then produced more than entirely huge Europe.
@@juliap.5375 last time I heard there’s 12 of them because if crappy economy
@@Animboyexe их уже больше 200 штук su 57
Fantastic jet. You just keep going fair play bud.
Well done
Thanks 👍
Wish I could build like that. That's a gorgeous su 57!
I just knew that the prop version was going to be perfect 👌 Awesome built
Hi Julius, great job, my congratulations, the pitch problem is because the EDF's thrust is parallel to the flight line, if you look at the real plane the exhaust engines point upwards, note that for example in the F -15 also points upwards, the incidence of the EDF is: if the EDF is below the wing the exhaust points downwards, if the EDF is parallel or above the wing the exhaust points upwards, it is like the incidence of the engines in pusher planes, regards!
Great model sir. Built my own Su57 foamie using RCPowers plan but modified to run on twin motor tail pusher, suggest you rebuild yours using twin motor with differential thrust for a strong yaw authority.
What a great effort to keep working and achieve reasonably stable flight. Great model.
Это просто восхитительно ❤
🤣 восхитительное россиянское аналоГовнетное дерьмо (☝️пятого🤣 поколения), которое по качеству и функциям не дотягивает даже до третьего поколения. Это дерьмище даже испытания не прошло.
Согласен
Русский мем в тему!
nice build! everytime i maiden a new diy design its the same thing, finding the cg while also figuring out the thrust angle, its a good puzzle
Cool, thanks!
Well appreciated guys!❤
What an art !😮
Very nice build! And also trial and error is part of scratch builds. All the effort is worth it in the end. The learning experience is most valuable!
Love that u never give up..that would’ve drove me crazy …and nice build looks great with the landing gear..like the real thing.
Thanks 👍
Great video, interesting to watch the iterative design phases. Gotta be hard to wing it without thrust vectoring and flight control computer.
Keep up the good work!
Nice work again Julius I’ll tune in to it later
I'm building my own and it looks so good so far. This a really informative and enjoyable video. Keep up the amazing work
Awesome! Thank you!
The plane keeps diving down can mitigated with thrust vectoring. This can be done by adjusting the direction of the nozzle thrust. This is also the main reason why the real su57 is so manuvarable. If u can add more servos to change the thrust direction, the plane will be much more stable.
Мужики, я вам советую поспрашивать тех ребят, которые уже сделали модель такого самолёта, последний раз я видел, чтоб один русский конструктор, занимавшийся авиамоделированием, делал этот самолёт с применением 2 маленьких реактивных двигателей, он ещё трюки с самолётом выполнял, и он был в состоянии его поднять и посадить.
Mas Julius apa kabar? Saya lihat mas Julius semakin sukses dan besar. Saya dari Solo dan tahun 2012 silam pernah beli satu set alat papercraft dari website paper-replika. Kalau mas ingat saya juga beli mika bening satu gulung dengan panjang 1,5 meter yang pasti sangat ribet untuk dikirim. Melihat video mas Julius saya jadi ingin membuat papercraft lagi, tapi mungkin masih nanti karena tidak banyak waktu untuk hobi hehe. Sukses dan sehat selalu untuk mas Julius dan keluarga!
Nice build! Simple and effective. I like it.
Thanks! 👍
The moving part on the LERX is called lov cons, it serves as a aoa limiter.
Just beautiful my friend... Thanks you!
I think the droop flap is used to change the air going into the engine much like the moveable intake on the F-15.
Отличная модель! Слишком большой угол, отклоняемых плоскостей, из за этого, его мотает в воздухе. Нужно ставить ОВТ что бы управление был стабильнее
Again, you're the MacGyver of RC models. No joke.
At least it makes a great Boat ! I like how you don't 'give up' easily. Keep working the issues for an acceptable model. Take care, rh
What a great work u done there, liked and subscribed!
I’ve said it before, incredible tenacity. 👍👍👏👏
Thanks again!
I've be waiting for this video , with great spectation and desire
Hope you enjoyed it!
my man can put all of the massive rc plane brands out of business, of you could make this at a smaller scale and a pusher prop edf, all the amazon brands would want you.
Amazing Explanation. could you make a video specially on the engine/thruster that is used here please.
Semoga dilirik om sama PT.DI buat kerja sama pengembangan pesawat jet tempur buatan dalam negeri, talenta seperti om ini yg dibutuhkan bangsa Indonesia agar tidak harus beli ke negara lain
Congratulations from Brazil!!
What a nicest plane! You dud a very very good job!
Thanks a lot!
What a beautiful plane, and nicely built.
Crazy dedication 🎉
Hermano,tienes mucho talento, creas cosas con mucha imaginación. Saludos.
Cool. I made a project of a hotspot with a wingspan of 1.10m. my first motorization was a 64m edf with 12 pas and 2200 4s battery. I removed the turbine and put a 1700kv engine next to a 3530. It improved the flight by 60%. but it was low speed. I'm going to put a 3536 of 1200kv and a 7x4 apc propeller to see if it improves.
I suggest you increase the pitch on the prop to 6.
Brilliant work!
Many thanks!
~ One word for you Bro....".Brilliance " ~
Awesome Work !
For me the best war fighter and very beautiful 🎉
заглянем на минутку в историю создания су 57 начиная от су 27. проблема в том что его планер изначально нестабилен и очень сверхманевренный, для обеспечения стабилизации была создана программа для обеспечения нормальной управляемости за счёт управления плоскостями. без неё его будет мотать, так как он изначально был случайно, а затем специально создан таким. планер сам можно сделать, а вот чтобы он нормально летел это уже заморочки с управлением и программами
This guy is living my dream
really nice build the only bit which might confuse people is the foamboard is what flite test use which has paper on each side and depron is what you mostly use which doesn't have paper
Yes , I use foam. Board with the paper for his models , I find if I use the paper stuff rubbing it off prior to paint or decoration works out just as good I’ve made several of his now and might go to balsa on some of his builds as they do fly well
@@Jay-zc7iq yeah as I live in the UK most of the foam board isn't very good and hard to remove the paper so I can't really do it
@@everythingrc5652 a tip I use is to use a cloth or a very fine foam sanding block you can get most places wet it with a small bowl rub the paper and comes off nice leaving a very smooth and very good finish I use warm water too if I want to bend or shape stuff but works great
@@Jay-zc7iq alright thanks I've done it before but I'll try again. I use 5mm xps foam which is good but has lots of little holes in it which means tape won't stick to it so I can't do tight curves as I can't seem to find any better cheap stuff in the UK
If u engineered it well, wouldn't have to play around that much to find troubles. Respect for all the efforts
I wish I have more time, the issue was just the thrust angle
Finally...su57 dog fight with maverick.mantul bang jul.
That is quite Reliable, but I tell you something those wings in the front that drop down is so when it Pulls up it generates Vortex Lift.
Очень реалистичная моделька нашей сушки)
With a dual ducted fan it woul be really good since you could use the different thrust to steer the plane but the props work well it seems but quite unwieldy and in case of a crash it will be destroyed.
Excellent Work!
Thank you! Cheers!
Looks amazing. I'd love to see what original designs you could come up with.
I like scale model planes, so RC too. But I made 5 of them on this channel, you can look it up all my original design : Bango, Bango 2, Walet, Alapalap and Berkik 3
Love This Bro ❤❤
I was eagerly waiting for this built and my deprons are waiting too. 😅
I wouldn’t be surprised if this was better than the actual thing
GREAT VIDEO !!!
Thanks for the visit
yang di tunggu² akhirnya di up😁
Awesome bro❤❤❤❤❤
Wah ini luar biasa dgn SU- terkuat
julius a question where to buy the transmitter where you buy the 10 ch BetaFPV Express LRS RX
Excelente trabajo 👍
The moving part is the LERX at the front of the engine intake
Great Job, ihr macht aus nichts wahnsinns Flugmodelle! Respeckt vor dieser Leistung!
Thank you very much
You should give it a full thrust vectoring system to give you insane maneuvering and angle of attack like the real life aircraft
Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩💕💕💕
Akhirnya, terus semangat bang
All's well when it ends well...
That 3D printer Prop was cool hack
Good approximation for CG is on line of 33% wing area from the front.
Super cool!!
Olá julius, belo projeto!
Faz um projeto do stearman PT 17 em uma escala de 2 metros
MASTERPIECE!
Very impressive!
Thank you! Cheers!
Very nice video, was very entertaining all throughout. I noticed you also copied the yellow parts of the plane from the pak fa t50 prototype, very nice details
The problem is with the EDF, its doesn't do thrust vectoring, that's why its kinda hard to fly.
вау! потрясающая работа!
to your question: those are not canards. more likely droop flaps as you said. it doesnt behave like a canard either, it more likely bites the airflow
Thank you, and thanks for watching, appreciated
Can i use edf after two to three pusher prop planes for beginner
Fantastic
I love it ❤🥰😍🫶 I really love it 🥹🤩
Very nice bro man tap euy aslyna
kerenn bangett sihh masss, mau nyoba bikin buat display aja
Good video bro
Appreciate it
I loved!
Very nice build, well done bro.
Which material did you use to print the propeller? Is it reliable and safe?
I use PETG-CF, I only fly it 2 times so never know is it reliable or not.
Thanks for sharing your video sir .wich one of the ESC & battery to recommended for Edf 64mm.sir..,
I usually use 60A esc and 4s 2200 x2
Im going to build this out of Correx/Corro-Plas what an awesome plane like all of your projects Julius! So what is the better out of the two pusher propeller or edf? I look forward to seeing many more and hope you do an OV10 Bronco a Rockwell B1B Lancer and maybe a B58 Hustler which seems to be all the rage with a new kit i believe around atm 😎🤘👌👍
I will go 2 pusher for peace of mind
Wow.... Bikin sendiri om? Buset luar biasa
Can i use 3s 5200mAh battery with 40A ESC and T Motor as2814 1200kv brushless 3 in this model??
yes you can
I've built a delta wing plane out of foamboard too, and its best flight was 650 meters.. It's just way too hard to fly at this scale, even INAV can barely control it
Try putting the battery weight in the middle of the plane to level out the weight. The batteries are probably the cause of the nose/front to be heavy.
Lulu is so cute she reminds me of my own cat, bless her
thanks, Lulu is a boy
Cats make such good supervisors.
nice recovery
Thanks!
What foam material that you used for build this airplane? Can I use KT board to build it?
depron foam/ polyfoam/ XPS foam/ foam board/ dollar tree foam board
god job om
Hi Julius where can I buy twin edf? This could be cw and ccw right? Most of online store can't find twin edf or cw ccw.ot shows only 1 edf in their store
you don't need CW & CCW on EDF, all rotates the same directions, even in twin
Thanks for info my friend. You mean I can buy two ducted edf even not cw cw? It's ok to put them together on my project Boeing777.
Uau, parabéns pela inteligência!
Amazing as usual. You deserve that laser cuttting machine.... Very nice model!!!!
Thank you very much!