Magnus Carlsen Speaks | Maxim Dlugy's Chess Cheating Reviewed

Sdílet
Vložit
  • Äas pÅ™idán 4. 05. 2024
  • Magnus Carlsen gives an interview on September 21, 2022, and name drops Maxim Dlugy as Hans Niemann's mentor which is a huge flag to anyone who knows of GM Dlugy's cheating issues. Original interview on / chess24 and / magnuscarlsen
    👕 MERCH ► streamlabs.com/gmhikaru/merch
    â™Ÿï¸ LEARN CHESS & PLAY WITH ME â–º go.chess.com/hikaru
    🎠GIVE 💎 CHESS ► www.chess.com/membership/gift...
    🎬 CLIPS CHANNEL ► czcams.com/users/GMHikaruCli...
    ðŸŽžï¸ MORE GMHIKARU â–º czcams.com/users/moregmhikar...
    💜 TWITCH ► / gmhikaru
    💖 INSTAGRAM ► / gmhikaru
    🦠TWITTER ► / gmhikaru
    ✨ TIKTOK ► / hikarugm
    💛 DISCORD ► / discord
    💙 FACEBOOK ► / gmhikaru
    💚 SUPPORT ► streamlabs.com/gmhikaru
    🖤 SUPPORT MY ORG Misfits Gaming ► us-shop.misfitsgaming.gg/
    🤣 REDDIT ► / hikarunakamura
    â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”â”
    🎨 Thumbnail ► JojoChessNoob / jojochessnoob
    🎥 Edit and 🎨 Thumbnail ► Airton Alonso / tomeditor95
    👌Channel Management ► Team Hikaru
    📧 Business inquiries ► TeamHikaru@WMEAgency.com OR GMHikaruBiz@yahoo.com
    #gmhikaru #chess #
  • Hry

Komentáře • 714

  • @danolivier4899
    @danolivier4899 PÅ™ed rokem +40

    You totally misread Magnus, Hikaru. This is what genuine outrage looks like in Scandinavia.

  • @lrdkelvin
    @lrdkelvin PÅ™ed rokem +156

    i can't wait for the movie based on all this: the king's scambit

  • @vlnow
    @vlnow PÅ™ed rokem +34

    Interviewer is a 2900 in asking controversial questions without crossing any lines.

  • @Bhubnipz
    @Bhubnipz PÅ™ed rokem +222

    I’ve enjoyed every minute of this progression from “That’s the only thing I’m going to say on this matter†to “and this thickens the plot considerablyâ€

    • @yugiohfanatic1964
      @yugiohfanatic1964 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      yes because Hiraku likes the blin blin coins generated by this drama. Same with Botez sisters blin blin money gold diggerz

    • @NexenTriz
      @NexenTriz PÅ™ed rokem +8

      @@yugiohfanatic1964 Hm. So you would prefer if they never talked about it and act like nothing major happened.

    • @yugiohfanatic1964
      @yugiohfanatic1964 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@NexenTriz it's called coherence, something you can't understand

    • @NexenTriz
      @NexenTriz PÅ™ed rokem

      @@yugiohfanatic1964 Yeah perhaps I don't understand. Please explain it to me.

    • @StoneParanormal
      @StoneParanormal PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@NexenTriz views=money
      Multiple chess channels have popped into CZcams Popular section because of this drama
      They like the money.
      So they keep making drama videos.
      Do you get it?

  • @chopinfanclub6672
    @chopinfanclub6672 PÅ™ed rokem +575

    Interviewer did a good job pressing magnus into saying something by focusing on cheating as a whole and not on Hans which magnus clearly had the intention of not speaking.

    • @CarterMuller
      @CarterMuller PÅ™ed rokem +44

      To be honest, I don't believe that Magnus ended up saying anything more or less than he intended to beforehand

    • @PrivateJoker0119
      @PrivateJoker0119 PÅ™ed rokem +18

      Yeah I always thought Kaja is a fine host/interviewer

    • @calebwhiting8744
      @calebwhiting8744 PÅ™ed rokem +22

      Naw, I think Magnus said exactly what he intended to say. He was speaking in a rather bored voice like he was repeating bullet points he had rehearsed with his team many times. And he namedropped Dlugy at the very beginning, not after Kaja pushed him.

    • @SaraKochanny
      @SaraKochanny PÅ™ed rokem +2

      @@PrivateJoker0119 I agree, and she did a great job here

    • @SuperYtc1
      @SuperYtc1 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      @@SaraKochanny You do realise she gets the questions fed through an earpiece to her.. right?

  • @ispeeeaaakeeewhaaaleee
    @ispeeeaaakeeewhaaaleee PÅ™ed rokem +303

    Hikaru is the kind of guy who says he isn't a drama queen

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +12

      He is a false accuser.

    • @Jartran72
      @Jartran72 PÅ™ed rokem +27

      @@onlytruth5863 A guy who names himself "only trutj" would ofcourse pretend to know the truth, no matter how wrong he actually is.

    • @trevoroldham2195
      @trevoroldham2195 PÅ™ed rokem +3

      Seriously this guy is annoying af

    • @nth7273
      @nth7273 PÅ™ed rokem +3

      @@onlytruth5863 stop falsely accusing Hikaru. He never falsely accused anyone.

    • @Harshmelloo
      @Harshmelloo PÅ™ed rokem

      Bruh he gets views-money lol

  • @RajivSamaroo
    @RajivSamaroo PÅ™ed rokem +21

    It’s called the Carlsen gambit. You resign early in a majorly anticipated early game and throw all the other players off their mental prep and create a media controversy. While everyone’s up in arms, you calmly proceed to win the tournament.

    • @wchambers3849
      @wchambers3849 PÅ™ed rokem

      That was absolutely brilliant! 🤣

    • @RajivSamaroo
      @RajivSamaroo PÅ™ed rokem

      Statistically speaking you gonna lose at least one game, so do it against a strong player. They’ll feel they didn’t really beat you and they’ll be consumed with self doubt. it’ll totally mess with them and make them lose other matches.

  • @steelsteez6118
    @steelsteez6118 PÅ™ed rokem +88

    Thank you Hikaru, for not talking over Magnus when he talks and for pausing the video before inserting your comments. The proper way to do it.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      In the review of Prof Regan's analysis, he starts disputing the analysis before the professor has even opened his mouth. His chat are trying to teach him manners, or at least upset that his poor manners are reducing their enjoyment of hearing the evidence.

    • @FuriousTortoise
      @FuriousTortoise PÅ™ed rokem

      @@onlytruth5863 prof Regan likely built his program on Win98… two decades ago. Be honest… they’re likely weak against modern methods and AI chess. It’s knee jerk obvious Hikaru was pointing out the burden of proof was clearly not met. Hikaru’s interests if any GMs were involved (and who) are justified. I’d like more info as well because it came off like a prof pet project. The interviewer had no idea how to press him to speak with intellectual vigor and we didn’t see any modern demonstration… it was justified.

  • @hieab
    @hieab PÅ™ed rokem +267

    Magnus is not afraid of the Dlugy man

    • @skitzcunt4213
      @skitzcunt4213 PÅ™ed rokem

      i used to watch dlugy play blitz and bullet on icc back in the day

    • @theonexx762
      @theonexx762 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      Dlugy man (lvl 98) Swamp creature

    • @davidc5191
      @davidc5191 PÅ™ed rokem +9

      I beat Dlugy decades ago at a Manhattan Chess Club blitz tournament. Though he was a rising junior and of master rating at the time, nevertheless he blew a standard Philidor rook and pawn ending. His coach, Bill Lombardy, was watching the game and got very angry with Dlugy afterwards, and showed him the correct way to draw. I'm going to assume that's a lesson he hasn't forgotten.

    • @french2520
      @french2520 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@davidc5191 what's up old head

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +4

      Does Magnus think he is acting like a man? Does he think bringing up more circumstantial evidence and then saying "no comment" makes up for him taking a dump on the chessboard at St. Louis?

  • @izzyx1260
    @izzyx1260 PÅ™ed rokem +278

    "Do you think he's cheating?"
    Magnus: "Not gonna comment on that for now."
    "How do you feel about cheating in chess?"
    Magnus: "Not gonna go into it but it's bad."
    "So how about that guy you suspect is cheating?"
    Magnus: "I'll comment on that more after the tournament."
    "What are your thoughts on cheating?"
    Magnus: "...not good at all."
    "Any thoughts you would like to share about a certain player that's currently under suspicion of cheating?"
    Magnus: " ಠ_ಠ "

    • @hypercubemaster2729
      @hypercubemaster2729 PÅ™ed rokem +4

      @@astheworldburns3590 Nice Prejudice... shame on you.

    • @ianallen738
      @ianallen738 PÅ™ed rokem

      Did you just post your private number publically, hikaro?

    • @iluvatarchem
      @iluvatarchem PÅ™ed rokem +5

      @@hypercubemaster2729 wtf? I think you've missed an evolutionary step:
      Monkey----> human

    • @AnubhabLeo
      @AnubhabLeo PÅ™ed rokem

      Gold.

    • @Jartran72
      @Jartran72 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@iluvatarchem There were atleast 3 different steps between "monkey" and homo sapiens.

  • @shawncarter7188
    @shawncarter7188 PÅ™ed rokem +58

    I have to hand it to the interviewer... she asked relevant questions but they weren't "gotcha". They were respectable and gave Magnus a chance to answer in whichever way he wanted.

  • @lollycopter
    @lollycopter PÅ™ed rokem +118

    This interview just goes to show the value of journalists like Kaya Snare and is a good example of why it's not necessarily ideal to only have very strong chess players conducting interviews.

    • @vlnow
      @vlnow PÅ™ed rokem +10

      Yeah, she did a fantastic job of pulling comments out of Magnus.

    • @scientificatheist9381
      @scientificatheist9381 PÅ™ed rokem +3

      Chess grandmasters are bad at language and social skills

    • @somebodyhere3160
      @somebodyhere3160 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      yeah, when the interview is mostly about chess and is quite technical, then a strong chess player is a good choice, but otherwise, it isn’t ideal.

    • @driedpancake
      @driedpancake PÅ™ed rokem +1

      "Journalist" 🤣

    • @zah936
      @zah936 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@somebodyhere3160 no

  • @epmcgee
    @epmcgee PÅ™ed rokem +41

    Dlugy was also part of the end of Borislav Ivanov's career, after accusing Borislav of cheating. Dlugy later gave an interview with Chess Base that included him saying Ivanov was caught because he couldn't act like a strong chess player would, while playing chess of that level. Dlugy additionally said that if a 2600 rated player had the same type of machine they would only have to cheat about 4 times in a game, and nobody would think anything of it.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      Dlugy doesn't understand mathematical analysis then.

    • @winningtechnique1849
      @winningtechnique1849 PÅ™ed rokem +4

      Dlugy knows his stuff (evidently)

    • @raylopez99
      @raylopez99 PÅ™ed rokem

      interesting, though Borislav Ivanov had a device that can be easily detected by a metal detector. If Hans Niemann is cheating, it escaped both a metal detector and a thermal/RF probe that checks for devices in the ear canal. How is Neiman cheating? I'm sure the CIA would like to know, so they can outfit their agents with the same device.

    • @elg7365
      @elg7365 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@onlytruth5863 magnus said the same. We need about 3 to4 moves

    • @mattster-nw2xn
      @mattster-nw2xn PÅ™ed rokem

      "It's not the shoes."

  • @winningtechnique1849
    @winningtechnique1849 PÅ™ed rokem +38

    I don`t know why people complain Magnus is not saying anything conclusive. He is pretty conclusive as far as I am concerned as he is basically saying : "Well done to Dlugy for coming up with undetectable cheating gear"

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      Yes, unfortunately. If he could understand the evidence, then he probably wouldn't want to look that silly.

  • @gLu3r
    @gLu3r PÅ™ed rokem +144

    All this drama has gotten me into chess again. I haven't played chess since I was in high school thank you and Magnus and Hans.

  • @alieninsectbass
    @alieninsectbass PÅ™ed rokem +53

    7:59 That "yay" was PERFECTLY timed to celebrate Magnus's 2939 rating ;D

  • @snoozy04
    @snoozy04 PÅ™ed rokem +431

    Magnus Carlsen Speaks for itself

    • @GODofFM
      @GODofFM PÅ™ed rokem +9

      Himself

    • @will8840
      @will8840 PÅ™ed rokem +54

      @@GODofFM itself

    • @GODofFM
      @GODofFM PÅ™ed rokem +3

      @@will8840 you’re totally wrong

    • @James58Rams
      @James58Rams PÅ™ed rokem +45

      @@GODofFM your*^

    • @yty1941
      @yty1941 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      @@GODofFM 'it' can imply many things :)

  • @t81629
    @t81629 PÅ™ed rokem +37

    Magnus was so chill and love Hikaru's expressions

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      It may be that Magnus was as devious as Hikaru's expressions!

  • @landongibbs8678
    @landongibbs8678 PÅ™ed rokem +10

    We all act like we hate this drama so much but I think we all know that we want to see what happens next just as much as Hikaru does

  • @Koponenteemu
    @Koponenteemu PÅ™ed rokem +10

    Whoever makes Hikaru's thumbnails is doing a very good job!

  • @samhendriks2732
    @samhendriks2732 PÅ™ed rokem +25

    Hikaru, could you look into three games played between Warmerdam and Niemann? Warmerdam stated in an interview that Niemann’s play between their first two games (Grappa January 2021 and Guimarães 2021) increased dramatically in a game they played in Prague 2022. It would be awesome if you could analyse these three games and figure if the quality of play is out of the ordinary!

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      As well as the statistical analysis of the likelihood of him finding the moves. There is an analysis by a professor, you can look there. If you want the analysis of a streamer, it's likely to be what ever generates more views. Hikaru is a streamer first, he has stated this categorically.

  • @DJ_Penguin
    @DJ_Penguin PÅ™ed rokem +40

    I think magnus is just as calculating with his words as he is in chess. I think that's why this is so interesting. He's playing an irl chess game and trying to obfuscate his moves from Hans. If he doesn't come out and directly say how he thinks Hans is cheating, he can buy more time to gather evidence of it and possibly catch him red-handed. I will say knowing that his coach also cheated online is kind of damning imo. One person who cheated online is one thing, two people who cheated online is a whole other thing. Also for the hand fans out there just because he hasn't been caught recently, doesn't mean he isn't still cheating. It's incredibly hard to detect when it could only be one or two times a game.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      Magnus has said is is choosing his words careful so that he doesn't do anything illegal,. That what he is doing is unethical and unsportsmanlike is beyond question. There is difference between trying to not offend anyone, and trying to be as offensive as possible without breaking the law. It's the same as the difference between acting with integrity, and being purposely devious. That Hans has cheated in the Sinquefield Cup is out of the question as it stands, so Magnus is exercising masked libel in its purest form.

    • @DJ_Penguin
      @DJ_Penguin PÅ™ed rokem +4

      @@onlytruth5863 I don't see how refusing to play someone alone is unethical or unsportsmanlike. Especially when it's considered a loss when you resign. Any inference drawn from an early resignation is not Magnus' fault. If he hadn't had to play Hans in the generations cup, and resigned again, we would still be wondering if he even thought Hans was cheating.

    • @penultimania4295
      @penultimania4295 PÅ™ed rokem

      Most people are defending Hans purely because he's been witch hunted by the mob without any evidence, and would change their mind if someone actually provided any. The concept of innocent until proven guilty exists for a reason. Mob mentality and witch hunts can be a real threat to a person's life.

    • @GirlGeekLovesStampin
      @GirlGeekLovesStampin PÅ™ed rokem

      @@onlytruth5863 He could have handled this behind the scenes, and none of us would have known of any suspicion. Silence is better than insinuations.

  • @EarlSmith2469
    @EarlSmith2469 PÅ™ed rokem +4

    @02:30 She threw that "losing 3 points to hans" comment at him like a rock.

    • @godzillian3540
      @godzillian3540 PÅ™ed rokem

      More like bait on a hook

    • @EarlSmith2469
      @EarlSmith2469 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@godzillian3540 yeah not really. Magnus is way too smart for that trick.

  • @chessloverontwitch
    @chessloverontwitch PÅ™ed rokem +18

    I love Magnus's answer to "Is cheating a big problem in chess". He immediately empathized with other's who have experienced it more than he has. He is a true ambassador of the game and maybe the best we have ever had. I know he wants to help the chess world overcome this problem and the way he has handled the situation has certainly helped move the solution in the right direction I believe.

  • @paularized1
    @paularized1 PÅ™ed rokem +4

    I wish Magnus would have said he resigned after 1.5 moves because Hans played d4, c4 with engine precision.

  • @kompisworld
    @kompisworld PÅ™ed rokem +10

    I smell a lot of confidence from Magnus. Does not even seem worried. Looking forward to see him back it up.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      we all see different facets of the same object. Some people may equally see a devious disposition with commitment to try and get away with it.

    • @PurpleDragonSpike
      @PurpleDragonSpike PÅ™ed rokem +4

      @@onlytruth5863 get away with what?
      He was clearly on to something if Hans got rattled and instantly admitted to cheating multiple times... On a live interview... Don't you think?
      Or maybe just a lucky guess..... /S

    • @ytpanda398
      @ytpanda398 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@PurpleDragonSpike in fairness, magnus could just act confident with no evidence and remain that way. People would always infer suspicion about Hans, and magnus would not need to do anything

  • @chessbrilliance8783
    @chessbrilliance8783 PÅ™ed rokem +9

    Kaja is like "akinator" app.

  • @ih8stuff3
    @ih8stuff3 PÅ™ed rokem +81

    Maybe Magnus didn't think Hans cheated, maybe he disrespects him as a cheater in general.

    • @peristiloperis7789
      @peristiloperis7789 PÅ™ed rokem +45

      Magnus said once he hates playing against computers. Now imagine the feeling of playing against a guy who may be using an engine. And more than that, a guy who insults him after beating him . I'm sure Magnus despises Hans. He must have zero motivation to play against such a fake and disrespectful person.

    • @goorioles1976
      @goorioles1976 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      This is a good point. Something definitely happened during the SC that made him actually withdraw though.

    • @eschelar
      @eschelar PÅ™ed rokem +18

      If you watch Magnus's videos, you will often see him make comments about moves feeling unnatural or like an engine.
      This is a guy who spends a wild and crazy amount of time playing with people, books and engines. He's likely got a strong gut feeling for it, but he knows he can't prove it.
      Still, he's kind of the world's foremost expert on chess, so his intuition, while it may not be proof, is certainly not nothing. Even if it might be wrong.

    • @greenhat7618
      @greenhat7618 PÅ™ed rokem

      Then why did he play him in games before and suddenly decide not to? Doesn’t make sense

    • @peristiloperis7789
      @peristiloperis7789 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@eschelar I watched almost all Magnus videos and I can't remember him making that kind of comments.

  • @The_Invisible_Man
    @The_Invisible_Man PÅ™ed rokem +3

    Have to say Naka has evolved, his streams/videos are much better nowadays.

  • @joegillon746
    @joegillon746 PÅ™ed rokem +4

    Ask him if he has any ideas on how someone might cheat OTB. Get him to speak hypothetically.

  • @killpioo2
    @killpioo2 PÅ™ed rokem +39

    All of chess complaining about the lady doing her job, and asking the questions we're all thinking.

    • @Iead
      @Iead PÅ™ed rokem +1

      the questions asked were a bit repetitive so i can understand why people would be mad about the situation especially after magnus's coach not saying a word about the drama.. happy we know that he'll comment on it later but all we can do is wait

    • @Peakfreud
      @Peakfreud PÅ™ed rokem +6

      "All of Chess"?
      The over exaggeration for Dramatic effect , in a place already innudated with the over dramatic.
      ðŸ‘ðŸ‘ðŸ‘

    • @killpioo2
      @killpioo2 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@Peakfreud i meant to say all of chat. My bad, I think it was text to speech+sleepy.

  • @manumendelberg4974
    @manumendelberg4974 PÅ™ed rokem +18

    The reporter is a total og lmao

  • @l3igl2eaper
    @l3igl2eaper PÅ™ed rokem +1

    It would be relatively easy to prevent cheating OTB from people sending outside information. Play matches in a secure room that prevents external telecommunications.
    That would not prevent any cheating where the chess engine is physically on the person but it's a start.

    • @hirotakasugi4891
      @hirotakasugi4891 PÅ™ed rokem

      Exactly. People forget that 3D printing has come a long way to a point that someone can 3D print pewpew that doesnt trip metal detectors. It's even more easier to build an ear wig that is hard to see especially with people who have long hair.

  • @demzionmain
    @demzionmain PÅ™ed rokem +5

    Ya know you're early when his comments are almost empty.
    Looking forward on your take Hikaru

  • @leonarddickerson583
    @leonarddickerson583 PÅ™ed rokem +3

    Thanks, Hikaru. I was thinking that mentioning Dlugy--a reputable coach--was some sort of compliment until you revealed that Dlugy, himself, had once been thought to be a cheater. This means that Magnus is still accusing Hans of somehow cheating--though it is definitely unproven!

  • @adityavv96
    @adityavv96 PÅ™ed rokem +38

    She has balls to ask these questions straight up !

    • @jaconova
      @jaconova PÅ™ed rokem +7

      I was thinking they must be very good friends (or even banged) indeed. Only a woman could ask like that, that´s for sure...

    • @therealwelfin
      @therealwelfin PÅ™ed rokem +15

      @@jaconova lmao what 💀 if a guy asked those questions u think magnus would send assassins or something

    • @vincenzo6412
      @vincenzo6412 PÅ™ed rokem +10

      @@therealwelfin He would send his knights.

    • @defeatist3463
      @defeatist3463 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@jaconova tf lol

    • @MiguelTicona
      @MiguelTicona PÅ™ed rokem

      😂

  • @bacherfkinmcskiddlywop2491

    cant wait to watch this after work. thanks for the upload

  • @SeekAndDestroyTM
    @SeekAndDestroyTM PÅ™ed rokem

    I have never seen such a blatant presence of an executive producer as during the last 5 minutes where the EP talked through the interviewer's earpiece.

  • @SoB_626
    @SoB_626 PÅ™ed rokem +3

    In a way I like Hans' ambition and energy and I'd like him to be for real, but all I know about chess and life tells me otherwise. The way he crushes SGMs is just unbelievable. I mean watch how he demolished Hikaru in this game (/watch?v=NfClsJScfBw) and how he recently destroyed Aronian in 20 moves. If Magnus' rating is around 2850, Hans demonstrates an even higher rating than that by crushing the best GMs in this brilliant fashion.
    Remember how until recently everybody expected Alireza to be the next challenger and although he is truly a brilliant player, as he demonstrated since he was a kid, you can see how hard it is even for him to break through. Everybody knew about Alireza, Prag, Nihal, but Hans emergence was very sudden and unexpected.

    • @ncs9753
      @ncs9753 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      Yeah, and these super GMs who've played against computers before realize that Hans play like a computer. The issue is none of them figure out how did Hans cheated. Technology has become so advanced it might not be possible to catch a clever cheater.

  • @zackf3688
    @zackf3688 PÅ™ed rokem +2

    I wonder if other top GMs will start boycotting as well? Cc: Hikaru Nakamura.

  • @psycofire93
    @psycofire93 PÅ™ed rokem

    I'm sorry sir do you live here in Nashville and I had no idea? That Titans jersey caught my attn right away

  • @pizzapimp8128
    @pizzapimp8128 PÅ™ed rokem +12

    Wow. I did not know know Dlugy had been caught cheating.

    • @MetaKnight68
      @MetaKnight68 PÅ™ed rokem +5

      @@vanillaghetto He was acquitted of the embezzlement charge, not convicted.

    • @kinglear5952
      @kinglear5952 PÅ™ed rokem +2

      I remember it. Lots of titled players were complaining when he was playing.

  • @Bc31411
    @Bc31411 PÅ™ed rokem +110

    I don’t know if I started playing chess at the right time or wrong time with all this lol

    • @ghosthunter0950
      @ghosthunter0950 PÅ™ed rokem +19

      Just play for fun. It's always the right time for that.

    • @delitaheiral9184
      @delitaheiral9184 PÅ™ed rokem +3

      Drama is always present in any community so dont worry about it

    • @JulianMade
      @JulianMade PÅ™ed rokem +5

      Play in person rather than online, lol

    • @higherbeingX
      @higherbeingX PÅ™ed rokem +4

      Just play..this is the greatest brain game that's ever been r invented. The more you play the better you would become and the more complicated the patterns you see.

    • @abdalla6732
      @abdalla6732 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@JulianMade much easier to find players online

  • @LONGSLEEVERICKY
    @LONGSLEEVERICKY PÅ™ed rokem +2

    Would've been HILARIOUS if at 8:01 Magnus just responded with "I'll just let my chess speak for itself"

  • @jazelimbitislobodan
    @jazelimbitislobodan PÅ™ed rokem +3

    Watching them play is exhilarating, listening to them speak is an absolute agony.

  • @mauriciosuarez6631
    @mauriciosuarez6631 PÅ™ed rokem

    Does anybody here has the link to the Benjamin bok video of Dlugy Hikaru mentions?

  • @MegaStyleify
    @MegaStyleify PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Reporter asks question.
    Magnus: Um...

  • @Sympanet
    @Sympanet PÅ™ed rokem +1

    So they’re not posting videos of Hikaru playing chess on this channel anymore?

  • @jacobcook7
    @jacobcook7 PÅ™ed rokem +10

    Nice McNair throwback!

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      Hikaru is wearing the shirt, but he is a very poor sportsman!

  • @danielclv97
    @danielclv97 PÅ™ed rokem +4

    "Do you suspect that Hanz has cheated?"
    "I'm not gonna comment on that" - this is just like saying "yes, yes I do"

    • @peytonlucy5947
      @peytonlucy5947 PÅ™ed rokem

      Magnus thinks he is being cute and is following legal advice. He has already gone too far and directly saying that in his OPINION Neimann cheated would not change anything. He is giving the appearance of trying to smear someone without evidence. He should simply state that he has no direct evidence but FEELS that Neimann is cheating.

    • @danielclv97
      @danielclv97 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@peytonlucy5947 I'm not defending Magnis by any mean, but this is the result of free speach, it's not like Magnus its banning Hainz from playing in tournaments or something, he only put some of his elo points at stake. And that's why I don't think he can or should be sued.
      For me, I'm surprise competitive chess continue to exist at this level after the rise of better then human chess AI. Magnus and other GMs are what they define as "cheater" themselves, they use strong engines and use them to memories the best possible moves when preparing to play against an adversar. Moreover, those who win lots of tournaments like Magnus, can hire a whole team to do this for them, and they can just memories the best moves after. What difference is this from asking a live engine? I'm not saying they are not incredible good players who will obliterate casual players like me without a thought, but it looks like more and more competitive games transforms into some kind of luck game, and only a few that don't shows us the true power of the chess players after they go out of their preparation.

    • @ncs9753
      @ncs9753 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@peytonlucy5947 Multiple super GMs "feeling" that Niemann is cheating is sufficient proof really because how the fk do you even catch a clever cheater? Tech is so advanced. Even back in the day, no one can catch Ivanov red handed lol. Only the really stupid cheater will ever be caught.

  • @lordvoldemort1985
    @lordvoldemort1985 PÅ™ed rokem +4

    pls post the fabi interview reaction also

    • @joaocarlosdarosafagundes7482
      @joaocarlosdarosafagundes7482 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      Could you tell me where can I watch this? I've searched for Fabi's interview on CZcams and I found nothing.
      Edit: I did find it. It's in C-Squared Podcast. CZcams didn't show it to me when I searched for "Fabiano Caruana Interview", I had to write "Caruana Podcast". Curious, I thought it was smarter!

    • @lordvoldemort1985
      @lordvoldemort1985 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@joaocarlosdarosafagundes7482 yeah i just watched it. it was very interesting

    • @joaocarlosdarosafagundes7482
      @joaocarlosdarosafagundes7482 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      @@lordvoldemort1985 Yes, Caruana is both a very good thinker and speaker. Hearing him is always an enjoyment.

  • @kineahora8736
    @kineahora8736 PÅ™ed rokem +5

    Interviewer was fabulous, flashing her pretty smile, but persisting with the questions she knew were at the heart of what people wanted to hear answers to. Great job!

  • @Cage5
    @Cage5 PÅ™ed rokem

    From what I see the events and this interview is that Magnus is really unmotivated in playing chess. It's kind of sad seeing him like this. He's saying that chess makes him happy but I don't think it is the case anymore. I have said in other sites before that he will wait with his comments until the tournaments end. The fact that he behaves like that is because he really likes the rising young talents who one side relight the extinguished fire and motivation in him. That's why on the other side of the story, he wants to protect Niemann's rising reputation as long as he can.

  • @scottwarren4998
    @scottwarren4998 PÅ™ed rokem

    @GMHikaru I think Niemann has someone on another area controlling his mouse when Niemann plays. maybe niemann has a device for it, but it maybe isn't nedded one to cheat in his case..

  • @anotheruniverse5651
    @anotheruniverse5651 PÅ™ed rokem

    It misses Hikarus reaction at the end?

  • @LG-hf8ni
    @LG-hf8ni PÅ™ed rokem +8

    Chess content at 1:30 am German time let's goo

  • @gianfrancofini
    @gianfrancofini PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Where s the rest of the clip about caruanas podcast?

    • @GMHikaru
      @GMHikaru  PÅ™ed rokem +6

      Will publish it tomorrow morning. It's much longer. Thanks -- editor

  • @HPRshredder
    @HPRshredder PÅ™ed rokem +4

    Never a moment of silence in these lol

  • @jonadam4233
    @jonadam4233 PÅ™ed rokem +5

    I feel like whatever the outcome to this situation is, once it's out it will seem like it was obvious the whole time.

  • @jjhmr
    @jjhmr PÅ™ed rokem +6

    It's interesting that you think Magnus looks unfazed, as I pick up the opposite. He doesn't look his usual happy self.

  • @vigilantestylez
    @vigilantestylez PÅ™ed rokem +3

    Hans Niemann and Maxim Dlugy both agree. Stockfish speaks for itself.

  • @alexandravoropay7365
    @alexandravoropay7365 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    I used Leela (lc0) and I'm still not banned in spite of 2450+ blitz rating lol. So that DNA not working (I used 1-2 line of multiPV)

    • @ncs9753
      @ncs9753 PÅ™ed rokem +1

      It's easy to cheat and not get banned if you know what you're doing. Only the complete noobs who copy all the engine moves get banned. THey can't detect it if you only cheat in few crucial moves in a game.

  • @AGILISFPV
    @AGILISFPV PÅ™ed rokem

    What about the podcast with fabi?

  • @JH-en6ql
    @JH-en6ql PÅ™ed rokem

    Yeah, agree with Hikaru's comments that Magnus is confident. Also, keep in mind Magnus's hint that people support him more privately than publicly, which is a hint that the information he has makes those in his private circle supportive. In my opinion, despite his confidence and what we can interpret based on his comments, he really has nothing on Hans for OTB chess, and I wouldn't be surprised after the tournament if his additional statements lead to no more information re cheating in OTB chess.

  • @themoroccan101
    @themoroccan101 PÅ™ed rokem

    I am expecting a board game if they meet in the final

  • @styxzero1675
    @styxzero1675 PÅ™ed rokem +2

    That interviewer must have worked as an intelligence officer before, she knows how to get an answer out of peoples.

  • @CeltyYT
    @CeltyYT PÅ™ed rokem +10

    I want a "Let's talk" reply too :(

    • @ElijahLogozar
      @ElijahLogozar PÅ™ed rokem +1

      Let's talk. 🤣🤣🤣Just kidding

  • @carlosbonilla9159
    @carlosbonilla9159 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    And what about the real chess drama, where's the followup to Fabiano not playing the Stafford Gambit on Titled Tuesday?

    • @t39an8r
      @t39an8r PÅ™ed rokem

      Eric was devastated

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      I am confident Fabi will be crowned on "The Staffordshire Throne" in due course!

  • @VampyWorm
    @VampyWorm PÅ™ed rokem

    Her interviewing is really good though and wish more interviewers would do the same.

  • @666nevermore
    @666nevermore PÅ™ed rokem +1

    No it’s not the same questions over and over. One is your personal opinion on punishment for cheating, the other is an objective take on the matter. In the subjective question he can exposes his individual take on cheating in the other not. Interviewer aren’t stupid

  • @atedejong5620
    @atedejong5620 PÅ™ed rokem +7

    One point no one discuss is why did the Play Magnus Group (now a public company) in which Magnus is a minority shareholder, special advisor, ambassador and nr 1 player of their major tournaments - according to the Play Magnus Group website - invited Hans Niemann. As this tournament is organized by the Play Magnus Group. For sure everyone knew already that Hans Niemann had 2 incidents of cheating in his past (one at 12 and one at 16). And I assume Play Magnus Group had contracted Hans Niemann before the Sinquefield Cup where he beat Magnus after which Magnus withdrew from that tournament. Therefore you can only suggest that Magnus 'issue' with Hans Niemann came from the match in the Sinquefield Cup, not from what happened years back. Most likely the Play Magnus Group as listed company didnt want to cancel the contract with Hans Niemann or maybe they tried but not succeeded. Still dont know why this is not coming into the equation. Just wondering from that point of view.

    • @dreadbos
      @dreadbos PÅ™ed rokem +7

      Hans qualified for the tournament so they cant help it but invite him.

    • @atedejong5620
      @atedejong5620 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@dreadbos aah ok, didnt know it was qualification, not invitation. thanks.

    • @solaris70
      @solaris70 PÅ™ed rokem

      økAy thEn okay 🆗ðŸ‘

  • @kzztyant
    @kzztyant PÅ™ed rokem

    Is that Hikaru in an old school Titans jersey? What??

  • @kaidoChess
    @kaidoChess PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Wasn’t the game otb that he may have cheated?? How is that even possible jc??

  • @morgansmock800
    @morgansmock800 PÅ™ed rokem

    That was absolutely horrifying execution of an interview, everytime she asked a question I cringed

  • @dentalvideos6175
    @dentalvideos6175 PÅ™ed rokem

    Make the same interview questions` with Hikaru please

  • @ABAtrading
    @ABAtrading PÅ™ed rokem

    Nobody:
    Agad: And it was as of today that we had a completely new position between Hans and Magnus.

  • @phumgwatenagala6606
    @phumgwatenagala6606 PÅ™ed rokem +3

    Maybe Magnus just feels that he has cheated - maybe it’s his intuition (that he has used to be best in the world) - maybe he can’t prove it but he should be free to not play who he suspects, maybe he has been told to say nothing until some investigations happen…

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      He has repeatedly forced his agenda. If someone wants to remain silent, they do. When someone wants to make false claims and try to not be held culpable, they do what Magnus is doing.

  • @arryabudhiman5866
    @arryabudhiman5866 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Hikaru is happy to blow up this story..while it's also profitable for him..when many people are watching his channel...Hikaru is playing double standards..one side is criticizing the game when Magnus loses to Hans..the other side is getting the audience's benefit and showtime of the incident...what a shame

  • @Longtack55
    @Longtack55 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Cheating is unforgivable. It destroys victims' opportunities, and you cannot simply "make up" for it.

  • @virtualpilgrim8645
    @virtualpilgrim8645 PÅ™ed rokem

    9:11 The chat, on the left of the screen says, "Did Magnus take a bunch of Downers before the interview?" 9:39 "The king of chill."

    • @vlnow
      @vlnow PÅ™ed rokem +1

      I mean its wrong to generalise about an entite culture, but so many Norweigen dudes i have met have been super laid back and chilled out.

    • @virtualpilgrim8645
      @virtualpilgrim8645 PÅ™ed rokem

      @@vlnow "It's wrong to generalize about an entire culture." You just did. Frankly, it's not wrong but you think it is because you've been brainwashed. Generalization is how people organize their thoughts about reality. Stereotypes are also real. I give you permission.

  • @robertharald4622
    @robertharald4622 PÅ™ed rokem

    link in the description is broken?

  • @ARGAMING-oc1zv
    @ARGAMING-oc1zv PÅ™ed rokem

    Finally Hikaru cared about something.

  • @Drakshl
    @Drakshl PÅ™ed rokem

    The problem is cheating by having a signaling audience member would be far far too easy. Would be almost undetectable

  • @bonkyabeans
    @bonkyabeans PÅ™ed rokem

    "This is where the plot thickens conthiderably" - Hikaru

  • @moisesespino2021
    @moisesespino2021 PÅ™ed rokem

    great job this lady asking the questions in the right manner.... she actually asked him the same question from different points of view.... is she came up with those questions on her own.... shes very smart... .well done... Magnus actually chose his words like an End game... lol.... smart out of chess as well

  • @SuedeStonn
    @SuedeStonn PÅ™ed rokem

    Oh shit! lol, I never knew Dlugy got caught cheating in a tournament, I just posted a short while ago on the Caruana/Chirillo(sp) video that Dlugy was the guy that broke Borislav Ivanov and ended his chess career! 😅

  • @seinfan9
    @seinfan9 PÅ™ed rokem

    A Steve McNair jersey is not something I would have expected Hikaru would ever wear.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      He never needed to appear a good sportsman as much as he does at the moment.

  • @jasonuerkvitz3756
    @jasonuerkvitz3756 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Is there a difference between _The_ chess and chess? I'm asking for a friend who is a speech therapist.

  • @TheBruceKeller
    @TheBruceKeller PÅ™ed rokem

    Hikaru must be getting annoyed by the Niemann squad. Did that guy tell people in his discord to raid all the youtubes and streams about him or something?

  • @TheAussieRod
    @TheAussieRod PÅ™ed rokem

    What's all these CZcams in the middle of my ads?? Maybe Hikaru is slowly saying goodbye to some followers

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      He is not likely to be doing any of this to make friends, if that's what you were thinking.

  • @inactiveaccount4829
    @inactiveaccount4829 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    Magnus Carlsen's condition and demeanor when speaking on the question in regards to his life and how he's currently doing is slightly concerning.. I hope that this isn't too much pressure for him as a person and I hope that this drama hasn't put him in a position which will taint his reputation for the rest of his life. I hope this isn't the beginning of something deeper.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      His father seems like an honestly principled person who wants the best for Magnus. I expect when Magnus needs him, he will be wise in his counsel, and Magnus will, after the downfall, become much stronger than any chess player in history, not just in chess, but in character too. I hope that, and I think it's almost probable, but it's not guaranteed. It's up to him.

  • @nekonekic3948
    @nekonekic3948 PÅ™ed rokem

    When players calculating they blink more often, Hans doesnt blink that much .... Maybe a clue

  • @jmbbao
    @jmbbao PÅ™ed rokem

    I was eating Gruyere so after all this I am not knowing what kind of cheese to eat to not cheat

  • @vedantkoditkar5968
    @vedantkoditkar5968 PÅ™ed rokem +1

    I can understand loosing on the board to someone who cheated in past online would feel devastated considering you are still World Champion. If you've a proof they cheated then we can understand this stand unless it just unfair for Hans at this moment. Hope we will soon know the root cause.

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      If they did dehumanise Hans amongst themselves from when he was 12 years old until now, that's a long time. The hit to Magnus' ego and their group ego, would have been all the more devastating. It would explain why they have been so zealous.

    • @kazedcat
      @kazedcat PÅ™ed rokem

      @@onlytruth5863 So if a twelve year old torture and kill several people society will just let him go because his 12?

  • @sinbadw00t
    @sinbadw00t PÅ™ed rokem +1

    I honestly think Hans has his own Magnus BOT and he plays with it everyday its his favourite toy :)

  • @potzysk2
    @potzysk2 PÅ™ed rokem

    So far nobody has presented evidence that Dlugy is currently working with Hans, or that they have had any contact recently. Just that Hans attended Dlugy's academy some years ago.

    • @mark-od5ky
      @mark-od5ky PÅ™ed rokem

      That was Magnus saying indirectly that Hans was cheating like Dlugy did.

  • @ViridianIsland
    @ViridianIsland PÅ™ed rokem

    1:40 Skips the stuff the editor should have removed

  • @noahbirdrevolution
    @noahbirdrevolution PÅ™ed rokem

    The thumbnail forgot the tissues and lotion.

  • @brendanbrown3100
    @brendanbrown3100 PÅ™ed rokem

    Maxim is not short of a bob or two. A lot of chess streamers and 1 WC best lawyer up fast!

  • @goldentops7740
    @goldentops7740 PÅ™ed rokem +3

    to whoever slid in the nice haircut comment amongst the drama, we need more people like you

    • @onlytruth5863
      @onlytruth5863 PÅ™ed rokem

      yeah, your hair looks nice while you are taking a dump on the chessboard!