Google Gemini vs Google Assistant - Which One Is Better? (Tested On The Pixel 8 Pro)
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- Google Gemini with AI vs The Original Google Assistant
In this video I will compare the smartest assistants from Google in 15 different categories to see if Google Gemini is worth ditching Google Assistant. Tested on the Google Pixel 8 Pro.
#googlegemini #googleasistant #madebygoogle #googlepixel
*Chapters*
0:00 - Intro
0:17 - Scoring System
0:29 - Clock Commands
1:13 - Controlling Phone
1:43 - Conversions
2:55 - Messaging
5:04 - Navigation
5:42 - Control Smart Devices
6:07 - Playing Music
6:17 - Reminders
7:14 - Notifications
7:41 - Chain Questions
9:02 - Random Commands
9:41 - AI Commands
13:00 - Identifying Objects
13:42 - Offline Support
13:57 - Final Conclusion
For Donations:
paypal.me/indepthtechreviews
75 Exclusive Wallpapers on Patreon (as low as $1):
www.patreon.com/posts/15-excl...
Related Videos Playlist:
• Virtual Assistants (Go...
Follow me on:
Facebook: / in-depth-tech-reviews-...
Twitter: / idtechreviews
Instagram: / indepthtechreviews
Amazon Affiliate Links:
Amazon US: amzn.to/3AOk4MB
Amazon UK: amzn.to/36uXJFM
Amazon UAE: amzn.to/3k9LLcv
Amazon Canada: amzn.to/3kg0aUy
Amazon Germany: amzn.to/3hZ4zbT - Věda a technologie
I hate that Gemini opens the app when it answers
This! Very annoying.
It's experimental beta , will get better
Gemini is useless in both desktop and phone. I use chatgpt for all questions I havr
Hopefully you sent them feedback instead of complaining
Well Gemini hates you also.
Gemini still needs some work with certain tasks. Will get better with updates for sure
I hope they integrate them together to avoid using two apps, I think they should add Gemini to Google Assistant not the other way
@@IDTRI like it better that Google Assistant is integrated with Gemini because Gemini will understand what we are wanting much better whereas Google Assistant frequently misunderstands what I'm asking
@@IDTR I thought Gemini is for chatting purposes only is that wrong?
@beyondevrything I think it is for both. I think google is trying to create a generative ai asstiantant.
@@IDTR or let gemini decide when to use google assistant for that exact or slightly different command
Google needs to make a tiny AI model that runs locally and can tell if a message should be answered with a LLM (Gemini) or the normal assistant (Google). this would really speed up most tasks.
100% Right now Google assistant with Gemini can't play music 🫠
They did, it's called gemini nano which powers the s24 series ai
@@dirtydirtsgt4751 nah that's different, it's another text to text conversation ai. What we need is a determining ai that chooses Google assistant or gemini
@@dirtydirtsgt4751 all phone processors have ai chip in them for years, thats just marketing bulls
how will they spy then
Worst of all that they removed a lot of features from Google Assistant and didn't add them to Gemini. It is a slow app because it works from the cloud.
THIS. like dude you could have easily made it so that, it could do basic stuff on your own device. but more advance stuff needs cloud
@@siliconhawk9293 I know, but there were things that Google Assistant did without an Internet connection... I also understand that the Pixel 8 brings a dedicated processor for AI, so because they don't use it.
because its in beta!!!!
@@tomchapman128 We will see how it evolves... and that it gives short answers without so much text
> and didn't add them to Gemini
your expectation here isn't correct. the goal of removing features was to remove some tech debt, unrelated to the llms.
> It is a slow app because it works from the cloud.
not true. if you were running a llm on your phone, it would be even **slower**. it's slow because a. the llm is so large b. the servers aren't fast and c. the gemini app doesn't stream the responses yet.
however i agree that the simplest intents can be recognized locally.
> I also understand that the Pixel 8 brings a dedicated processor for AI, so because they don't use it.
gemini nano has subpar quality compared to gemini pro.
Gemeni is not ready yet but surely it will be much more usable in the future
The future is going to be crazy. Imagine saying. "Hey, google, text my mom how to cook a chicken."
This is a beta version, far from a full version ready to be released. I'm guessing they're going to show it's true potential once they launch their new phones Pixel 9 on Android 15.
@@jimjason5146 or cook it yourself
@@carloareaserthey will integrate gemini to google assistant
@@jimjason5146 I won't be satisfied until I can say "google, make dinner, so that it is nice and warm by the time I come from work" (using current location, speed, traffic, addresses, oh and a kitchen).
Google surely needs to work on making Gemini better as an assistant.
But what a fantastic comparison!!! Loved it. ❤ Truly in depth.
This is Emad's 500th video. Thank you so much for always uploading videos about Android that are professional and easy to understand! Congrats on the huge accomplishment! 🎊❤️
Love the side by side. Thank you for the comparison!
Most helpful tech Channel!
Here you will find real and practical reviews, comparisons and tests!
Thanks a lot to the Author!
I don't get why they didn't just integrate Gemini to Google Assistant. What's the need for a whole separate app?
The thing about Gemini is that Gemini is more better at images and googling, while Google assistant is more better at simple tasks and daily voice commands, In addition with Gemini being under development so it is better to have a separate app, Just like Google and Google Chrome.
It's because, although very similar, their intended use cases are different from each other. Google Assistant focuses more on automating tasks for improved productivity (Home) and Gemini is more about original creative production (text, art) through ai, but I do agree they should marry the two
This is apparently your first experience with Google? They are kings at unnecessary redundancy and having more projects than they can handle.
@@BuzzingGoober Agreed. Google just starts projects, fiddles with them for a while and eventually terminates them completely. It's gotten old.
They're not compatible.
You will save us from these companies downgrading everything, you are the only hope
I just learned Gemini isn't officially released/ replaced google assistant so.. no problem
But still this guy does amazing reviews showing every possible detail
Exactly my friend bought s24 ultra. The main camera is worse than my s22 ultra (poor white balance and exposure and contrast).
It's 3x camera's edge detection is also worse than my s22 ultra. And the downgraded long range zoom .
@mlloser8318 yep , but its a newly launched phone, Samsung launched an update today let's see if anything get fixed with the first 2-3 updates and if they fix it at the end I guess it's fine since you have Time to keep the device for 7 years without issues..mostly..
( I mean all phones have some issues)
Gemini is in experimental beta and the app was released less than a month ago. You expect that to already be better than google assistant which has been out for 8 years?
@SmitePlayz_ oh i thought it was official, gotta fix the comment
samsung took away the 10x of s23u from s24u and gave it 5x tele + digital tho @@wheely4405
Wish your channel will Grow, you are the best Tech CZcamsr, very knowledgeable
Finally after 2 years found this channel ❤
Very interesting, thanks for taking the time to try all that!
Excellent work bro very enlightened
I stopped using Gemini as an assistant within two days of downloading it. It couldn't take commands quickly when I was driving. Moreover it's slow at everything. It's a great chat bot, but I agree Google assistant is the best
They should add Gemini to Google Assistant not the other way around
@@IDTR exactly. That's what I thought would happen. The problem at Google is the teams not working together
My sentiments exactly. As it is Gemini is like how Google assistant was back in 2016. I don't understand Google's destructive changes for everything that they have that's already successful.
Google assistant is the king and always will be the king
I was trying play music but Gemini just open the app and start to give me some options or some tutorials instead to just play the fcking playlist. That was annoying, and the another thing is annoying is I can't open the Gemini App without Gemini try to change GA, everytime I use Gemini at the end need change again to GA.
I hate that, I just want the use Gemini like a chatbot or something like that not my assistant. But I have no choice. It's all or nothing.
This is why I have subscribed to you ❤💯🔥
Incredible video. Really comprehensive and clearly brings out the strengths and shortcomings of both. Glad I found this. Gemini still has a long way to go. But I do see it surpass Google assistant some day as it learns and adapts
That was a crazy comparison. This just shows how far ahead GA is. But I love both. GA is more on everyday commands which it was built for over the years to do. Whereas Gemini is more on generative commands. It helped me the other day come up with different names for a letter. I wouldn't mind Google keeping the two but allowing our phones to distinguish which commands would be better for either assistant. Now that would be INSANE 😬😬
I think it's better for google to integrate Gemini into Google assistant, that way it would be way better.
Very useful review
Thanks
Fantastic video. Highly Informative
This was extremely useful Thank you.
Great comparison to knoW where the assitants are at, thanks :)
Your channel is one of a kind
Thanks for the information 👍🏾
I'm not sure why the functionality had to be reduced. Both apps still exist on your device. Gemini hands certain things off to assistant, so why does it not handoff the other things too? I'd get if this was a beta run but it's not. They're advertising to everyone that you switch within Google assistant.
For Gemini to be great, it needed to have all of the assistant functionality from the start. It's cool but most definitely not ready for primetime.
I think rather than a different app, Google should integrate Gemini into the Google assistant, which would be best of both worlds.
More creative tasks should be handled by Gemini and regular task should be handled by Google assistant.
I completely agree with you
i am sure they will, and they will think of a business model that can generate more revenue
Thank you for this video … i nearly tought to Switch to Pixel from iOS, after seeing Gemini on the Google IO
I think ill wait a little bit
انت مصري يعم😂😂
خدت بالي اول ما فتحت الفيديو من الاكسنت
بالتوفيق❤
Thank you for this video
Greetings from cali colombia 🇨🇴
Great comparison.
great comparison. thank you emad you're a perfectionist
Awesome comparison
im supposed to make my research papers but this is fascinating
Great comparison, really helpful! thanks alot
Gemini has potential, but its definitely got a long way to go
The ability to read and interact with the page is great!
I reached the same conclusion using both. Google Assistant still works perfectly with the smartphone's screen off to tell the time or weather forecast, and the Gemini needs the screen to be unlocked to respond. In addition to Google Assistant being much faster.
1000 views in under an hour. Good job brother. I've been with you for 6 months now and you're doing a great job man. Keep it up.
6:12 NF MENTIONED 🔥🔥🔥
Thanks once again for this amazing comparison 🙏🏿.
Gemini assistance app will help v.much for the person whose English language is the second language,while the is having a conversations with. It will boost up the English speech skills.
Its far from perfect, but I think its awesome. I can ask really complex questions, etc.
Gemini has been updated yesterday, now they added the misssing features, like reminders, also now it runs Python code in the same window a feature for developers
Why didn't they give make Google assistant get it's output from Gemini?
cause gemini is still in beta (as you can see). It's generally a lot slower. It would be too much of a change, without being better in all areas. It's good that they didn't replace google assistant with gemini just yet. To me it's unusable at the moment and just a gimmicky tool
You mentioned that Google Assistant can't directly write emails for you, and listed "help me write" within Gmail as Google Assistant's alternative feature. But this feature within Gmail is actually powered by Gemini, and you only get access to this when you pay for Gemini Advanced.
I tried Gemini for about a day but switched back to regular assistant due to the lack of alarm routines. That's something I use everyday.
New update stopwatch is working❤
Thanks for sharing I will try again
I wonder if it works because of Emad
When it comes to the time differences at 11:18, the times are determined by the device time, which looking on each phone is different. Possibly a time zone selected wrong.
"Run the stopwatch" will start a stopwatch in the background (assistant). I think the start is recognised as starting the app.
انا بحب اللهجة امصرية بتاعتك دي يا جدع والله ❤❤
I think Gemini only triggers the Google assistant extension when you give voice commands and that too only from home screen and not when you type or give voice commands when Gemini app is opened
Last I used it couldn't even tell me the time, the future is here!
Gemini is still not fully integrated for assistant functionalities , and in my own testing if you wan't to get consistent assistant features you must always start form home screen, otherwise it will prioritise generative text responses. a solution at the top of my head for now would be to use different wake up phrases like hey google for assistant focus with gemini boost or something, where hey gemini will always for generative AI
You completely forget about translate option in Google assistant. It really useful.
Saw this video regarding this doubt will I get the same translate option in Gemini or not.
Google assistant is much faster and much useful
Nope. It's Gemini is over hyped downgraded shit for now
I think maybe when you were using Google assistant the original to ask the question to send a voice message maybe that when it was still using the original assistant it would still use the original function to send properly the voice message that you want it, but maybe that when you asked the same question on Gemini it may have already cancel that function and so you cannot anymore send the voice message so it just sent a normal message.
Your English is very good 😃
You're not going crazy with the whole assistant features working before and not working now. I can vouch and agree that assistant has definitely somehow gotten dumber
Hope that Gemini will be way better than it is right now and what OG assistant currently is 💯
Does the Gemini app only work in the US? It keeps saying that it is not available without telling me the specific reason. It's strange to think this is US-only, because I can access it using a web browser.
In my opinion it's normal for Gemini to take more time to respond because Gemini might first figure out if the voice input is a command or a question for Gemini AI and then compute information based on the decision.
My assistant on the pixel 7 had no problems starting the stopwatch.
Google needs to get better with their software... Too many open projects results in mediocre performance.
Original Assistant for now
I'll continue to use Google assistant and keep gemeni as a link to the web app for generating emails, photos, etc...
the first time i used gemini, i asked it to set an alarm for the next morning, something i ALWAYS do with assistant, it said "got it, set" and then i checked 30 mins after my alarm, missing work, that it in fact did not set the alarm.
Solid video
Gemini is cool for generating images but outside of that, it's just not as fast and polished as Google Assistant so I switched back for now.
i think with the one with an equation, google read them all as individual, so that when you did 30/2, it only did 30/2 and not the rest
I just want to let you know that for some reason Gemini is much slower on your phone than on my phone. On my phone Gemini loads up just as fast as Google Assistant in almost every regard or circumstance. I'm uncertain why your Gemini is loading at a much slower pace. For example, when trying to load up locations or asking directions to the nearby pizza restaurants, Gemini loaded up everything in less than 5 seconds.
Yah, at times, I'd argue most times, we just need a simole and useful assistant. Not a complex AI
I have used Gemini for a month now, I find it less advances ok the voice recognition and less convenient to use either for the smart assistant features or the AI tools
one google assistant feature I personally use all times is the feature to translate everything on my screen to the system language, hell if there's text on screen that's not in one of my languages, and I bring up assistant, it just shows me a quick shortcut button for the translate command. gemini seems to simply be incapable of comprehending that command, and even when it does understand the command it has a terrible execution.
When it comes down to it, how many people will, actually, use things like creating a form letter on their phone? To me, AA does what most need better than Gemini.
I have the advanced in my phone i recommend you compare that one too. Mine doesn't talk though.
stop watch works perfectly fine on my pixel 3xl
How do you access gemini like an app other than just opening it on a browser?
One day Gemini activated itself and I was confused. I even check the Play store and it said I hadn't downloaded yet. I eventually switched back to Assistant since Gemini still lacks some features I use. If they make Gemini better or combine the two then it'll be a win but for now Google Assistant takes the slight edge.
in P8P Google assistant gave me correct answer for calculation but i have to tap the mic for every command. can u tell me how to enable cpntinous feature in google assistant
Gemini still new so lots to improve on
Gemini is fine. But I think Google needs to work more with it. For example, Gemini should not always use the default LLM while answering. With Assistant we don't do that type of thing. The best would be if they can combine some features from both Gemini and Google Assistant.
A big step for me. I like the comments, i like your presentation. Gonna sub and try Gemini. I never used an asst before. I really hope i have a good experience. Electronics usually gang up on me. 🙄
Yeah Gemini is just a baby so I'm looking forward to it growing to match its big sister Google Assistant.
4:35 was your fault. It asked you what was the new message and you responded with "send a voice message."
How come I can't change the output voice when using my Gemini AI?
Hi there,
Let me clear the confusion.
Gemini still passes system releted commands to Google Assistant as Gemini is not made for it.
Truly the in company fighting
at 2:30 I don't think it gave a wrong answer as much as the symantics weren't clear, I am cuirious to see what happens if you phrased it like "devide the result by two" or "devide that by 2"
Reminders to work on Gemini AI btw. Make sure you turn on Workspace
We must send Google an email to correct all these errors and add a direct translation feature for calls, such as the Samsung S24 Ultra.
lol was NF the relaxing music?
The main problem is that Gemini feels so much slower
Gemini ira mejorando y El asistente de google lo sacaran del mercado, asi que es bueno acostumbrarnos a Gemini.
This doesn't surprise me one bit. But I think it would be interesting to repeat the test in 12, and 24 months from now. It could be very different.
The mean problem with Gemini at the moment, It's tied into the OS the same way Google Assistant is. I see the potential of Gemini
Hope google integrates gemini into assistant; however, I think assistant days are numbered. Most of the points lost are just controlling the phone which they should be able to easily add once optimized. I mean, they do that now so they have all the codes for it so it may just take some time to build out some sort of HDK and migrate to new framework. If Google doesn't announce any new features to assistant this June/July and only talks about Gemini, RIP Google Assistant in 2 years.
the problem is when you open the Gemini app it sets itself as the default assistant.
so can't in a convenient way use the Google Assistant as the digital assistant and Gemini as an AI app
Yeah that sucks, but you can, set it up. Conveniently when you open Chrome go to Gemini's site. Then set the site as a home icon so you can go to it.
@@micahjohnson9184 Yeah that's a great workaround. Thanks for sharing!
What gemini app are you using? The one I have is only a chatbot like chatgpt on my oneplus. How do I get one like the one in the video?
It’s built in the new Samsung and xiaomi iirc
Google needs to add an extension to Google assistant to only use Gemini when needed... Ion like that with the Gemini app downloaded (pixel 6 here) I still can't use Google assistant & Gemini at the same time.