As a serving submariner, within about 90 seconds i counted so many mistakes, i just had to keep watching just to see how many more i could find! Cheery little dit though!
@Scouse Submariner 1878 Let's start a list. 1. Cruising along near periscope depth blissfully ignorant of TWO torpedoes in the water. Those are some serious baffles that boat's got to not hear two torpedoes.
It could have a tough skin but still be buoyant thanks to a filling of maybe not cork (too compressible) but syntactic foam so it's not technically contradictory. But of course it's not made that way in reality and conning towers don't float.
I loved it . 6 years on Australian diesel boats I still have coffin dreams 35 years later. at least once a week. a great portrait of the submariners nightmares tjey have but never talk about
I was once a crew member of a submarine. I've also been in a DSRV, there is at most room for a dozen people in a DSRV. A hit by two torpedo's would certainly flood the engineroom causing the boat to go down by the stern not the bow. None of these people would survive.
A detonation that close to the hull would indeed cause a breech of the pressure hull. Likely killing everyone instantly Sonar should have picked up high speed screws aft...why no counter measures or attempts to evade. Not at all reasonable action by the crew No, I'm not a bubblehead but I've done considerable reading about submarine warfare
A nice, kinda spooky but heartwarming short film! Forget the imperfections and impossibilities. The story is about the strangeness and possibilities in miracles.✝️
Plot twist; Him returning to the surface was his final thoughts as the conning tower breaks off and cushes shortly after, landing elsewhere on the seabed.
Knowing nothing about submarines I was not hindered by noticing what was not operationally correct, but I enjoyed this flick a lot. I thought the ship crushing scene was excellent. The floating conning tower; well he had to survive somehow. Hats off to the little girl.
Excellent!!! I truly loved this movie! I thought it’s pacing was perfect. The tension built at an alarming rate! The ending totally got me too! Wow! I really cant say enough how much I loved this! Thank you for making this. I hope you continue to make more films. This was a wonderful surprise! Bravo! Well Done! Absolutely Awesome!
My take is the submariner knew he was going to die, so he imagined seeing the ghost girl and escaping his doom. In his last moments, instead of anticipating death, he comforted himself by visualizing the sun on the horizon one last time.
@@dhyde9207 i think he just met he could tell it was going to be a shit video which three fair that acting is horrible and nothing really made sense as far as continuity🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️ but it's pretty much what I expected before I watched it so I can't complain
With all due respect. Why is the sailor walking on the level if the sub is going down nose first at the angle shown from outside footage. An oversight maybe?
Reminds me of that old book called "The Shepherd" by Frederick Forsyth. Anyone read that one? A Royal Air Force fighter pilot is flying home from Germany on Christmas eve. His aircraft (a Dehaviland Vampire) experiences an electrical malfunction and loses its navigation instruments and radio. Now lost on a cold, dark, and foggy night, far above the clouds, running out of fuel, and panicking that he is about to die suddenly sees an old WWII fighter (a Mosquito I think) flying at his wingtip. The old plane escorts the lost pilot through the fog and down to the runway. Once safely on the ground he inquires as to who the fellow was that saved him as he wants to thank him, but discovers that he is a well-known airman who died a few years earlier in the war. Its quite a creepy yet stirring story. As a kid I read it many times and used to love the black and white paintings in the book.
The "life submarine" has already been launched, at this time you're just waiting to die as the water pressure rises higher and higher, you feel like you're in a soda can on the highway - and it's going to go suddenly. I can't think of much to do but pray at this point.
I got it as well, I just watched a video on U995 a German Uboat tour video, I wonder if that is why CZcams AI recommended this? All you need to do is tell the AI not to recommend videos like this and it should go away. lol
For those of you who find technical errors, just imagine this happens 50 years from now. It is scifi, isn't it? This is by far the best of these I have ever seen.
I think the point of this film is the ghost/hallucination of his daughter(?) pointing him towards a means to survival, and the parting shot of the submarine settling on the bottom amidst the shipwrecks from other eras is a nice touch. But what is the significance of the stone(?) horse on the ocean bed?
conning towers normally don't break off, the sub fractures rather then beer canning, and all air becomes super compressed to the toxicity level of oxygen poisoning. following that, the contents get "DIESELED" due to the air mass being compressed beyond tolerance and stuff goes whoof. but you'd be dead way before that happens. 500 meters isn't a working depth of most subs, since the sonar isn't exactly hitting much when your below the other guy. also RUSSIANS are spec'd for a max depth of the Akula class diving to depths of up to two thousand feet (609.6 Meters). each 10 meters (33 feet) of depth adds one atmosphere (1 bar, 14.7 psi, 101 kPa) of pressure on a hull per square inch (6.4516 CM squared), so 300 meters (1,000 feet), on a hull is withstanding thirty atmospheres (30 bar, 441 psi, 3,000 kPa) of water pressure for those area amounts. the United States SEAWOLF SSN: Attack Submarine, Nuclear-powered Class with it's exceedingly strong hulls are shown for a Test depth of 1,600 ft (490 m), that's TEST. not max depth, and the real limits for crush, or working depth are CLASSIFIED. but the russians and chinese hate those boats...because they also are some of the quietest things ever made for snooping about and standing ready to repel other subs, limited only by food on board for mission length.
While I pray we never find out the ACTUAL crush depth of ANY of our subs, I'm sure the actual crush depth is far in excess of 1600 ft. The Thresher had an official test depth of 1000 ft, unofficially 1300 ft at the time of the accident. However evidence shown she didn't fold until over 2400 ft down. Add 50 years worth of technological advances, and i wouldn't be surprised to learn that our newest classes of SSNs and SSBNs could survive into the 3000 ft range.
From something I watched the waiting would be the worst part; once it happens it's so quick you wouldn't feel anything; you'd be dead from the mix of superheated air; pressure and the explosion before your brain had time to feel it.
Ok the story is kinda cool and I liked it. I even clicked the thumbs up button. Now I am going to make fun of the technical mistakes because that to is fun. Lets see, going from memory and only watching the video once: 1) Active sonar when cruising. (A pet peeve of mine.) 2) Wrong volume of active sonar. Loud enough to give yourself away but not to actually echo locate anything at any useful range. 3) Actually all the sound from that boat seems to be all wrong from start to end. 4) Bow planes and fair water planes on the same boat. 5) Those torpedoes would have mangled that boat a whole lot more and probably just killed the crew outright. 6) What are those uniforms they are wearing? 7) That sub interior is in great shape for a ship that just got hit by 2 torpedoes. That boat should be saveable. Did the crew even try to blow the ballast? 8) How do you fit the crew of that thing into that DSRV. 9) That crew member wakes up and doesn't do anything like try to blow the ballast. 10) That computer is special. It, like, knows things. 11) Crush depth is not exact. It might be around 500 meters but you don't know exactly when. 12) That crew member gives up without doing anything and takes a seat between diesel engines. Well I guess that sub didn't have to be nuclear. 13) The hatch that closes when he enters the sail. Star Wars! 14) The sail is not going to float, and not that high if it does, and not that stable. I am going to be generous and say it will survive the implosion. Because ghosts. 15) Through out the whole thing, the interior of that sub is nice and flat and level. The exterior of that sub is in like a 90 degree dive. This isn't a mistake, you are just not supposed to know about this classified technology.
When the thresher imploded a couple hundred ft off the bottom at 4,000psi, it disintegrated the entire boat. Like an airplane crash. Our nuclear submarines used to have 2 inches of hy80. And at test depth they string a piano wire across the sub, and measure how much it sags in the middle. They do not look like the raisin surface between bulkheads like is shown in this video. That is called artistic license. And the bulkheads would do what if 2 inches of hy80 went in at supersonic speed. Nothing of the interior would be recognizable even the people. You would die so fast 1/1000th of a second you would feel no pain at all. You would be and then not. The Russian submarine off hiwalya failed at a very moderate depth so everything inside was still good including the people.
Are you talking about the K-129? That's the only russian sub I know of lost off Hawai'i. It was discovered at 5,500M or 18,000 Ft., not exactly shallow water. Its a fascinating story in itself. The CIA with the help of the Navy and Howard Hughes managed to engineer a giant "claw" to reach down and grab the K129 and bring it to the surface. They were partially successful, we know for a fact. Allegedly the sub broke while on it's ascent and we only recovered 40' of the now. There are rumors however, that we actually retrieved the whole thing, or that we went back a second time and got the rest. Fascinating story either way.
As the sub approaches crush depth and you hear the metal and parts creaking and getting squeezed, you hear the voice of Willy Wonka, though you cannot find him anywhere in the sub. And he is singing the infamous "Wonderous boat ride song", with some lyrics changed for the submarine: "There's no earthly way of knowing, Which direction we are going, There's no knowing how deep we're going, Or which way the submarine's going, Is it raining, is it storming, Is a hurricane a blowing, Not a speck of light is showing, So the danger must be glowing, Are the fires of hell are glowing? Is the Grizzly reaper mowing? (Creaking grows more and lasts more) YES! The danger must be growing! For the submarine keeps on diving! And it's certainly not showing, (Creaking and squeezing sounds grow even higher, as pipes start leaking out like crazy inside the sub) Any signs that it's ascending! WOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAOOOH! OH OH OH AH AH AH! (BOOOM! BOOM! BOOM BOOM!)
So what if it wasn't accurate? I still enjoyed it. Nice story plot. I mean, imagine being knocked out and coming to only to find yourself alone on an abandoned vessel. Think I would have tried to blow the main ballast to try surfacing, other than that, try launching weapons. LOL.
So you actually enjoyed is horrible acting and those stupid faces he made? Cuz this was clearly something that was probably thrown together at the last minute not something that was thawed out for years ahead of time or else it would have been better🤦♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
Good video don't pay attention to the negativity, you did a good job it gets the point across and then some. We have sat around with a few good hardcore friends and debated about whether you would want to be in a submarine when it is going down like the video or on a WWII Bomber when it is going down in flames and everyone of us chose the plane because in a plane at least you have a chance of survival cause you have more options on a plane than a sub. Thanks for the video we all enjoyed it. Oh and by the way Liked n' Subscribed Cheers
Moral of the story: Reincarnation, we leave all our old shells of a life to start new ones. What one thinks as the end, is only a new beginning on a new vessel.
Shortly after I came to & discovered I was left alone on a sinking sub that was going to inevitably implode…I would’ve ran myself head first into a bulkhead hopefully with enough force to knock me unconscious. This makes my top 10 worst ways to die list.
the hull wasn't breached from torpedo so a normal blow on MBT would have been enough. I've been in real flooding and we weren't thinking about leaving.
This story really has nothing to do with submarines. It’s about a strange man with strange fantasies of little girls in places nobody will find out about. It also shows we have spies in the military. How else would he know the conning tower detaches after implosion and you float to the top. Problem is now your under arrest for being a pedophile and they kill him in prison slowly. Story over
I really enjoyed this. Don't care to argue the technical or story details, or the acting. I like *all* of those things sufficient to say I enjoyed this a ton and will share it online, probably Reddit and elsewhere. Thanks!
I think all the real time served submariners commenting on the technical shortcomings in this feature need to accept it is just a bit of light hearted fantasy for land lubbers like me. I really enjoyed it.
Torpedo strike was in the stern. Flooding in the stern results in a stern-heavy descent with the bow pointing up, not like you see here. If you can't do an emergency blow the sub continues to crush depth "backwards", maybe vertically.
draco6543 also with two exploding torpedoes on the stern the damage would have been alot more severe. They would have lost more than just their starboard sternplane.
Well, if we're going to nitpick you also wouldn't see a random sub with a dsrv on piggyback, you wouldn't see a direct torpedo strike like that since it's less effective, the worst sub crew in the history of ever wouldn't abandon ship at such a shallow depth. I mean, this list goes on and on.
I have fallen from sky, Fallen to the bottom, I am the angel of sadness, Angel of lost hopes, Angel of lost dreams, I am the fallen angel, Fear me not, I am here for reason, That reason is to give you a second chance in life "Fallen Angel" Poem by Jc. Verro - with adaptation
Submariners should not watch fiction shows about submarines. So darn picky about crappy little details. 23 years in the boats and my wife refuses to watch any kind of submarine movie with me because I pick it apart. It's just a damn movie and I picked it apart but did not say anything until now.
Just a FWIW: It's essentially impossible to see the full length of a submarine (much less attacking torpedoes AND a submarine) underwater because maximum ocean visibility is usually a little over 100'. In absolutely perfect conditions you might get close to 150' but at that distance whatever you saw would be a blur. All the submarine movies - even and especially big budget ones - show these panoramic views of the entire submarine (or multiple submarines as in Hunt For Red October) and sometimes even backgrounds. Hey, I like it and it's fun, but just remember it's Hollywood and CGI.
no submarines have a attached dsrv all the time. dsrv is only deployed when dissub is announced and US sub forces arrive in time before all is lost at sea. All these events don't necessarily happen at all. So other options are used.
I can't help but think you jammy bastard 😂 I'm not submarine or military expert so I don't know what is not correct but it was full off tension and I really liked it
To all the people whining because it's not realistic, please be quiet. Nobody wants to hear your technical expertise. It's a great story, like a lot of sci-fi greats, and guess what-- they're not scientifically accurate either.
The suggestion was that he climbed inside a pressure vessel. The conning tower, if otherwise flooded, wouldn't be crushed. The pressure inside and out would be equal, aside from the inside of the pressure vessel. Why it all floated, though, is beyond my ken. Not only floated but bobbed around on the surface like a soap bubble.
For you simple minded, technically accurate, perfectionist critics: Some people read. Some watch movies mainly to see how many "errors" they can find. I guess it makes them feel "pretty smart". But wait⚠️, life isn't that simple. Miracles and especially the supernatural usually don't have an explanation and are downright weird. I tell you, I just loved this short film so much, I saw it 3 times! Oh, not to continue searching for unrealistic events so as to congratulate myself more but for it's theme. As a kid, I liked cartoons for their point -- not the nonsense. The heartwarming point in this was that the man lived after being forgotten and thanks to the little, precious girl spirit. There is a play titled: The Lass who loved a Sailor. Could not that apply in this case? (she saved his life)✝️
Even though this short movie has litterally a hundred or so technical research errors, it still gives me the goosebumps. Well done.
I was a kid in 1964 when the USS Thresher sank, and I thought of those men who suffered before they died. I was a sad day.
As a serving submariner, within about 90 seconds i counted so many mistakes, i just had to keep watching just to see how many more i could find! Cheery little dit though!
cheers dits :-)
I counted 4 man crew on a decent class sub. I'm no submariner but I'm pretty sure it takes more than that to crew her.
@Scouse Submariner 1878
Let's start a list.
1. Cruising along near periscope depth blissfully ignorant of TWO torpedoes in the water. Those are some serious baffles that boat's got to not hear two torpedoes.
@@RoderickGMacLeod On the other hand, What else can you do when Torpedoes are that close to you?
I don't think a Mystic Class DSRV Is going to hold a whole crew.
The conning tower must be made of cork. Amazing that the same structure is used to break through the ice in the Arctic.
It could have a tough skin but still be buoyant thanks to a filling of maybe not cork (too compressible) but syntactic foam so it's not technically contradictory. But of course it's not made that way in reality and conning towers don't float.
you don't know what in it that makes it buoyant
It’s not real it’s a film lol…..it’s would be first to crush actually
I loved it . 6 years on Australian diesel boats I still have coffin dreams 35 years later. at least once a week. a great portrait of the submariners nightmares tjey have but never talk about
this is a movie about a coffin dream not a SSTG traing film
I served aboard a fast attack submarine in the late 1970s and I often think about the hazards we went through. Thank you for your service brother.
I was once a crew member of a submarine. I've also been in a DSRV, there is at most room for a dozen people in a DSRV. A hit by two torpedo's would certainly flood the engineroom causing the boat to go down by the stern not the bow. None of these people would survive.
It's more sensitive than most would imagine?
Isn't there only one DSRV?
A detonation that close to the hull would indeed cause a breech of the pressure hull. Likely killing everyone instantly
Sonar should have picked up high speed screws aft...why no counter measures or attempts to evade. Not at all reasonable action by the crew
No, I'm not a bubblehead but I've done considerable reading about submarine warfare
The captain needs to be court martialed for not having his towed array out and for abandoning his crew.
And for not blowing all tanks to emergency surface since they weren't more than 50M when hit
@@allennelson3881 Just what I wanted to remark. ;)
@@allennelson3881 that would be if they they were working and didnt have to much water the ship already.
Though if the crew said they were all good, or he died on torpedo impact, the captain isnt going to risk all the crew to grab a body.
Where are the choppers and madmans?
God bless all our ocean explorers who havent returned.
They're still exploring.
RIP, I shall never join them
A nice, kinda spooky but heartwarming short film! Forget the imperfections and impossibilities. The story is about the strangeness and possibilities in miracles.✝️
Plot twist; Him returning to the surface was his final thoughts as the conning tower breaks off and cushes shortly after, landing elsewhere on the seabed.
Oh look, a touch of realism
Hera The otter similar to an occurrence at owl creek as stated by a commenter below
No, conning towers are engineers to breakout and slowly float to the surface as a last ditch escape pod. 😬😬😬😬😬🤔
As I was expecting. Big Ambrose Bierce fan.
@@John77Doe this is true for Russia lol
Knowing nothing about submarines I was not hindered by noticing what was not operationally correct, but I enjoyed this flick a lot. I thought the ship crushing scene was excellent. The floating conning tower; well he had to survive somehow. Hats off to the little girl.
Excellent!!! I truly loved this movie! I thought it’s pacing was perfect. The tension built at an alarming rate! The ending totally got me too! Wow! I really cant say enough how much I loved this! Thank you for making this. I hope you continue to make more films. This was a wonderful surprise! Bravo! Well Done! Absolutely Awesome!
My take is the submariner knew he was going to die, so he imagined seeing the ghost girl and escaping his doom. In his last moments, instead of anticipating death, he comforted himself by visualizing the sun on the horizon one last time.
Ambrose Bierce wrote a similar story about a hanging. "An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge".
This is a solid passion project. Not really technically sound, but the arc and the production more than made up for it
well sub.s should have these features, escape mini sub and escape pod
"Staring Mel James"..... he did indeed stare quite a bit, hence the title.
Don't tell me you actually watched this video? The moment I read that "staring" I knew it was not woth the touble.
@@voornaam3191 ... Pardon me. How much is a "touble" worth?
@@dhyde9207 i think he just met he could tell it was going to be a shit video which three fair that acting is horrible and nothing really made sense as far as continuity🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️ but it's pretty much what I expected before I watched it so I can't complain
Glad CZcams recommended this to me. Sometimes they get it right.
With all due respect. Why is the sailor walking on the level if the sub is going down nose first at the angle shown from outside footage. An oversight maybe?
Yea..one of many oversights🤦♂️
Hollywood
An interesting and entertaining storyline, well presented.
Thank you for taking the time to make, edit and publish this video.
Reminds me of that old book called "The Shepherd" by Frederick Forsyth. Anyone read that one? A Royal Air Force fighter pilot is flying home from Germany on Christmas eve. His aircraft (a Dehaviland Vampire) experiences an electrical malfunction and loses its navigation instruments and radio. Now lost on a cold, dark, and foggy night, far above the clouds, running out of fuel, and panicking that he is about to die suddenly sees an old WWII fighter (a Mosquito I think) flying at his wingtip. The old plane escorts the lost pilot through the fog and down to the runway. Once safely on the ground he inquires as to who the fellow was that saved him as he wants to thank him, but discovers that he is a well-known airman who died a few years earlier in the war. Its quite a creepy yet stirring story. As a kid I read it many times and used to love the black and white paintings in the book.
I listen to 'Fireside' Al Maitland read it every Christmas Eve night - or as close as they can get it on a M-F radio show - on 'As It Happens'!
The "life submarine" has already been launched, at this time you're just waiting to die as the water pressure rises higher and higher, you feel like you're in a soda can on the highway - and it's going to go suddenly. I can't think of much to do but pray at this point.
Interesting a thought provoking film. It had a lot of technical holes, but it was a nice effort. ETCS(SS) 1974-1995
Well here we go again a 7 years old video recommended in 2019
I got it as well, I just watched a video on U995 a German Uboat tour video, I wonder if that is why CZcams AI recommended this? All you need to do is tell the AI not to recommend videos like this and it should go away. lol
@@kitsouk1 I guess youtube AI assume too much
@@TheTeknus Judging by recommendations I am getting - CZcams has no AI.
@@TheHellishFrog Because CZcams has no I? You could develop your humour...
...and then he was captured by the enemy, interrogated, and eventually shot.
Great short movie. Kept my interest until the end. Well made. Thank you.
For those of you who find technical errors, just imagine this happens 50 years from now.
It is scifi, isn't it?
This is by far the best of these I have ever seen.
Finally explained to me what that part of a submarine was used for.
Not really realistic to be brutally honest.
I think the point of this film is the ghost/hallucination of his daughter(?) pointing him towards a means to survival, and the parting shot of the submarine settling on the bottom amidst the shipwrecks from other eras is a nice touch. But what is the significance of the stone(?) horse on the ocean bed?
The horse on the ocean bed shows you that the little girl died in a ship wreck herself
conning towers normally don't break off, the sub fractures rather then beer canning, and all air becomes super compressed to the toxicity level of oxygen poisoning. following that, the contents get "DIESELED" due to the air mass being compressed beyond tolerance and stuff goes whoof. but you'd be dead way before that happens. 500 meters isn't a working depth of most subs, since the sonar isn't exactly hitting much when your below the other guy. also RUSSIANS are spec'd for a max depth of the Akula class diving to depths of up to two thousand feet (609.6 Meters).
each 10 meters (33 feet) of depth adds one atmosphere (1 bar, 14.7 psi, 101 kPa) of pressure on a hull per square inch (6.4516 CM squared), so 300 meters (1,000 feet), on a hull is withstanding thirty atmospheres (30 bar, 441 psi, 3,000 kPa) of water pressure for those area amounts.
the United States SEAWOLF SSN: Attack Submarine, Nuclear-powered Class with it's exceedingly strong hulls are shown for a Test depth of 1,600 ft (490 m), that's TEST. not max depth, and the real limits for crush, or working depth are CLASSIFIED.
but the russians and chinese hate those boats...because they also are some of the quietest things ever made for snooping about and standing ready to repel other subs, limited only by food on board for mission length.
Thank you for the info sir :)
While I pray we never find out the ACTUAL crush depth of ANY of our subs, I'm sure the actual crush depth is far in excess of 1600 ft. The Thresher had an official test depth of 1000 ft, unofficially 1300 ft at the time of the accident. However evidence shown she didn't fold until over 2400 ft down. Add 50 years worth of technological advances, and i wouldn't be surprised to learn that our newest classes of SSNs and SSBNs could survive into the 3000 ft range.
From something I watched the waiting would be the worst part; once it happens it's so quick you wouldn't feel anything; you'd be dead from the mix of superheated air; pressure and the explosion before your brain had time to feel it.
Ok the story is kinda cool and I liked it. I even clicked the thumbs up button.
Now I am going to make fun of the technical mistakes because that to is fun. Lets see, going from memory and only watching the video once:
1) Active sonar when cruising. (A pet peeve of mine.)
2) Wrong volume of active sonar. Loud enough to give yourself away but not to actually echo locate anything at any useful range.
3) Actually all the sound from that boat seems to be all wrong from start to end.
4) Bow planes and fair water planes on the same boat.
5) Those torpedoes would have mangled that boat a whole lot more and probably just killed the crew outright.
6) What are those uniforms they are wearing?
7) That sub interior is in great shape for a ship that just got hit by 2 torpedoes. That boat should be saveable. Did the crew even try to blow the ballast?
8) How do you fit the crew of that thing into that DSRV.
9) That crew member wakes up and doesn't do anything like try to blow the ballast.
10) That computer is special. It, like, knows things.
11) Crush depth is not exact. It might be around 500 meters but you don't know exactly when.
12) That crew member gives up without doing anything and takes a seat between diesel engines. Well I guess that sub didn't have to be nuclear.
13) The hatch that closes when he enters the sail. Star Wars!
14) The sail is not going to float, and not that high if it does, and not that stable. I am going to be generous and say it will survive the implosion. Because ghosts.
15) Through out the whole thing, the interior of that sub is nice and flat and level. The exterior of that sub is in like a 90 degree dive. This isn't a mistake, you are just not supposed to know about this classified technology.
Forget the technical critics- this was cool.
Agreed. Looks like it was fun to make.
1027sterling 👍
When the thresher imploded a couple hundred ft off the bottom at 4,000psi, it disintegrated the entire boat. Like an airplane crash. Our nuclear submarines used to have 2 inches of hy80. And at test depth they string a piano wire across the sub, and measure how much it sags in the middle. They do not look like the raisin surface between bulkheads like is shown in this video. That is called artistic license. And the bulkheads would do what if 2 inches of hy80 went in at supersonic speed. Nothing of the interior would be recognizable even the people. You would die so fast 1/1000th of a second you would feel no pain at all. You would be and then not. The Russian submarine off hiwalya failed at a very moderate depth so everything inside was still good including the people.
Are you talking about the K-129? That's the only russian sub I know of lost off Hawai'i. It was discovered at 5,500M or 18,000 Ft., not exactly shallow water.
Its a fascinating story in itself. The CIA with the help of the Navy and Howard Hughes managed to engineer a giant "claw" to reach down and grab the K129 and bring it to the surface. They were partially successful, we know for a fact. Allegedly the sub broke while on it's ascent and we only recovered 40' of the now. There are rumors however, that we actually retrieved the whole thing, or that we went back a second time and got the rest.
Fascinating story either way.
As the sub approaches crush depth and you hear the metal and parts creaking and getting squeezed, you hear the voice of Willy Wonka, though you cannot find him anywhere in the sub. And he is singing the infamous "Wonderous boat ride song", with some lyrics changed for the submarine:
"There's no earthly way of knowing,
Which direction we are going,
There's no knowing how deep we're going,
Or which way the submarine's going,
Is it raining, is it storming,
Is a hurricane a blowing,
Not a speck of light is showing,
So the danger must be glowing,
Are the fires of hell are glowing?
Is the Grizzly reaper mowing?
(Creaking grows more and lasts more)
YES! The danger must be growing!
For the submarine keeps on diving!
And it's certainly not showing,
(Creaking and squeezing sounds grow even higher, as pipes start leaking out like crazy inside the sub)
Any signs that it's ascending!
WOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAOOOH! OH OH OH AH AH AH!
(BOOOM! BOOM! BOOM BOOM!)
If all movies were this short and exciting!
Usually the creepy girls come in 2's
As in The Shining
Dude this is true irl.
i love creepy girls as im a creepy boy
Maybe that should be a new design on all subs a Conning tower escape pod.
That's what some recent Russian subs have. Search Bing/Google Images with those words.
Anyone else get anxiety while watchin this shit lol. How terrifying just to imagine
When they say crush depth is at 500 meters they sure meant exactly 500 meters lol
@Guilherme Siffer Its out by quite a bit. Is 1640 feet.
@Guilherme Siffer 1 meter = roughly 3 ft
@@MrDomingo55 1,640.42 to be exact.
In that situation, I'd have rather remained unconscious.
Very Good. Thanks, once again.
So what if it wasn't accurate? I still enjoyed it. Nice story plot. I mean, imagine being knocked out and coming to only to find yourself alone on an abandoned vessel. Think I would have tried to blow the main ballast to try surfacing, other than that, try launching weapons. LOL.
So you actually enjoyed is horrible acting and those stupid faces he made? Cuz this was clearly something that was probably thrown together at the last minute not something that was thawed out for years ahead of time or else it would have been better🤦♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
Yea blow the ballast and then torpedo the crew for leaving u behind.
Yeah I would have blown the ballast tanks. At least that could buy some time to slow the decent. Otherwise, just wait.
Didn't we see that little girl with her sister in "The Shining"?
Excellent work on this video.
The second you wake up and realize your (assh---) "friends" have abandoned you when they had plenty of time !
Ultimate If you snooze you lose, apparently his crew mates didn't think to much of him just Took off and left him there Ahahahahahaahah!
The girl is just a spirit, he is already dead or unconscious when she appears. The surviving is a dream, he is dead since long ago...
Brilliant my dude....i thought the same
Crew members wearing orange coveralls. That’s how I feel underway. Lol
do you really need to write "lol"??? Why???
Lol lol lol lol lol lol
@@jasonhannah7483 fucking prick.
Lol
Good video don't pay attention to the negativity, you did a good job it gets the point across and then some. We have sat around with a few good hardcore friends and debated about whether you would want to be in a submarine when it is going down like the video or on a WWII Bomber when it is going down in flames and everyone of us chose the plane because in a plane at least you have a chance of survival cause you have more options on a plane than a sub. Thanks for the video we all enjoyed it. Oh and by the way Liked n' Subscribed Cheers
Bravo Zulu! Fantastic movie trailer based on the book by Joe Buff, noted author of submarine-themed books.
Moral of the story: Reincarnation, we leave all our old shells of a life to start new ones. What one thinks as the end, is only a new beginning on a new vessel.
Good story. Graphics were good, especially the implosion part.
Kind of like Das Boot meets Home Alone!
Exactly, or The Shining...
A nice little short film, but is anybody going to mention the sub going down at almost a 90 degree angle and the guy walking around in it like normal?
Shortly after I came to & discovered I was left alone on a sinking sub that was going to inevitably implode…I would’ve ran myself head first into a bulkhead hopefully with enough force to knock me unconscious. This makes my top 10 worst ways to die list.
Stay out the water yall
No =w=
Very good. I was almost expecting twilight zone type ending where he actually went down to bottom
Same here...Like "Incident At Owl Creek Bridge."
They couldn’t fit the entire crew in the DSRV, and most boats don’t have one!
Total fiction in every scenario in this short movie. However, some great tension and not a bad story.
the hull wasn't breached from torpedo so a normal blow on MBT would have been enough. I've been in real flooding and we weren't thinking about leaving.
Gene Murphy let me guess your the captain of a us nuclear sub lol
paul sturgess /Exile Sturg SC maybe just a diesel sub!
COMPUTER GAMES ARE NOT REAL LIFE
This story really has nothing to do with submarines. It’s about a strange man with strange fantasies of little girls in places nobody will find out about. It also shows we have spies in the military. How else would he know the conning tower detaches after implosion and you float to the top. Problem is now your under arrest for being a pedophile and they kill him in prison slowly. Story over
Your Bathtub doesn't count
Damn i would be in panic mode being all alone down there.
Good captain though. Did he not think of counting his brethren before leaving
A lot of sailors were lost when the torpedoes sank the boat.
really got that feeling you would hope never to get really good movie hit the spot thankyou
I would have gone to the mess hall, and eaten all of the cake and ice cream!
Love the horse at the end...the little girl; Marie Celeste?
Ignore all the smartarses, IT'S FICTION. Brilliant story, very well done.
Yep, completely umbelievable...
He managed to get on a terrific trim on the way down - no angle ?
I really enjoyed this. Don't care to argue the technical or story details, or the acting. I like *all* of those things sufficient to say I enjoyed this a ton and will share it online, probably Reddit and elsewhere. Thanks!
Your pretty hot USS Melanie! I wouldn't share you with anyone!
beautiful story of the legends of the seas👏👏👏👏
While in the control room why not open the emergency blow valves?
I actually really enjoyed that thank you
Sad and tragic the oceangate titan submarine and the 5 occupants didn't make it !!! Great film!
Would there be enough time to down a bottle of spirits? Great mini film real or not!
DSRV’s can hold about 25 crew! About 1/4 of the crew of a modern attack sub!
This was special sub this sub was manned by midgets
Like how the sub flew in
I think all the real time served submariners commenting on the technical shortcomings in this feature need to accept it is just a bit of light hearted fantasy for land lubbers like me. I really enjoyed it.
Torpedo strike was in the stern. Flooding in the stern results in a stern-heavy descent with the bow pointing up, not like you see here. If you can't do an emergency blow the sub continues to crush depth "backwards", maybe vertically.
Tom Tonkyro only A Movie ! Real Thing Far Worse !
draco6543 also with two exploding torpedoes on the stern the damage would have been alot more severe. They would have lost more than just their starboard sternplane.
Well, if we're going to nitpick you also wouldn't see a random sub with a dsrv on piggyback, you wouldn't see a direct torpedo strike like that since it's less effective, the worst sub crew in the history of ever wouldn't abandon ship at such a shallow depth.
I mean, this list goes on and on.
I have fallen from sky,
Fallen to the bottom,
I am the angel of sadness,
Angel of lost hopes,
Angel of lost dreams,
I am the fallen angel,
Fear me not,
I am here for reason,
That reason is to give you a second chance in life
"Fallen Angel" Poem by Jc. Verro - with adaptation
Submariners should not watch fiction shows about submarines. So darn picky about crappy little details. 23 years in the boats and my wife refuses to watch any kind of submarine movie with me because I pick it apart. It's just a damn movie and I picked it apart but did not say anything until now.
well said!!
And morons shouldn't make them unless they talk to us submariners, amiright?
@@consubandon You are right!
Well, I really enjoyed this.
What a great short movie! I love this.
Great video
Just a FWIW: It's essentially impossible to see the full length of a submarine (much less attacking torpedoes AND a submarine) underwater because maximum ocean visibility is usually a little over 100'. In absolutely perfect conditions you might get close to 150' but at that distance whatever you saw would be a blur. All the submarine movies - even and especially big budget ones - show these panoramic views of the entire submarine (or multiple submarines as in Hunt For Red October) and sometimes even backgrounds. Hey, I like it and it's fun, but just remember it's Hollywood and CGI.
Everybody remember where we parked.
no submarines have a attached dsrv all the time. dsrv is only deployed when dissub is announced and US sub forces arrive in time before all is lost at sea. All these events don't necessarily happen at all. So other options are used.
I like the final shot when the sub vanishes in the darkness of the depths same as the other ships on that graveyard
plot twist: the tower sinks soon after taking him with it
I liked the part with the submarine.
I can't help but think you jammy bastard 😂 I'm not submarine or military expert so I don't know what is not correct but it was full off tension and I really liked it
I really enjoyed that.Thanks.Nice work
I thought this was the Dust channel!
To all the people whining because it's not realistic, please be quiet. Nobody wants to hear your technical expertise. It's a great story, like a lot of sci-fi greats, and guess what-- they're not scientifically accurate either.
I agree!
It's akin to that guy from a soviet submarine who managed to escape in a capsule.
Well, that's 16 min of my life I'll never get back ...
Legend has it the sub is still sinking to the bottom
He didn’t even bother to save the little girl. What a bastard.
Very cool 👍
Brilliant
What happened to him at 7:00 ? Was the pressure weighing him down? Or was he giving up hope?
Giving up hope. The pressure was outside about to breach the Hull, it was normal inside
Why on earth would anyone think that the conical tower would rise to the surface? It would be crused as one of the first parts of the submarine
The "sail" is a flooded structure so its already a no go.
Full of air?
I don't think it's meant to be taken too seriously as he was directed there by a ghost.
Paul Gray
In this situation I would take directions from a big white rabbit holding a gold pocket watch.
The suggestion was that he climbed inside a pressure vessel. The conning tower, if otherwise flooded, wouldn't be crushed. The pressure inside and out would be equal, aside from the inside of the pressure vessel.
Why it all floated, though, is beyond my ken. Not only floated but bobbed around on the surface like a soap bubble.
For you simple minded, technically accurate, perfectionist critics: Some people read. Some watch movies mainly to see how many "errors" they can find. I guess it makes them feel "pretty smart". But wait⚠️, life isn't that simple. Miracles and especially the supernatural usually don't have an explanation and are downright weird. I tell you, I just loved this short film so much, I saw it 3 times! Oh, not to continue searching for unrealistic events so as to congratulate myself more but for it's theme. As a kid, I liked cartoons for their point -- not the nonsense. The heartwarming point in this was that the man lived after being forgotten and thanks to the little, precious girl spirit. There is a play titled: The Lass who loved a Sailor. Could not that apply in this case? (she saved his life)✝️
Spreading insults now are we? You make our religion seem degenerative…