(Dune) Stilgar | Faith
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 03. 2024
- ***
"Lisan al-Gaib, show us the way!"
Javier Bardem is incredible as Stilgar.
Music:
ARKIVAL - Inevitable
Composer: Jessica Jarvis
Album: Rising Tides
Follow Arkival:
Website: arkivalmusic.com/
Instagram: / arkival.music
Soundcloud: / arkival
Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/7sp56...
Apple Music: / arkival
Deezer: www.deezer.com/us/artist/1611...
#dune #duneparttwo #lisanalgaib
Thank you for your support: xRav3n, Panos DKS, Kyrex, Aaron Carolan, CONCEPTS J.R.S, OM_CAVALO, Of Elements, Dara Casey, Pottetan, The Dark Cosmos, VarianceMotivation, MsCheerio
Support me on Patreon: / crusade588
Software: Adobe Premiere Pro
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favourite of fair use. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
The Mahdi is too humble to say he is the Mahdi. Even more reason to believe he is! As written!
As written 🤲🏽
Take the shoe and follow him.
Lisan Al ghaib!!!
funny enough i was the only one laughing in the theatre, really shows how powerful and blindness religion could do to a person
Which is the point. @@x3LightNinG
You know a movie is peak when even one of the side characters gets an AMV
An Animated Music Video? Nowadays people just call these Edits or Tributes.
@@ultrabigfella They were called Anime Music Videos to do them mostly being used for anime characters, now that term is used for any character
As it is written.
Not Thufir Hawat
We were making AMVs from that one scene of the Sardukaur.
"I dont care what you believe! I believe!"
this line sat with me for hours after i left
@@Gothicc_senpai Coming from a Religious background, it hit me like a train.
Best line of the movie imo, and I was honestly disappointed this montage didn't include it
Man did the Kamina motivational speech : "Don't believe in yourself ! Believe in the me that believes in you !"
Of course the inquisition would say this.
Paul: *sneeze*
Stilgar: LISAN-AL-GHAIB!!!
As its written!
Stilgar is a stand out for me in dune part 2. I watched the movie twice just to see his watery eyes when paul was reading the southern fremen minds.
Yeah, i watched it twice as well! Great masterpeace!
Fremen are prohibited from crying. From young ages they are flogged if they cry or, especially, if they leave their Siech without a still suit. Reason being as adults if they do such things the penalty is up to death. His watery eyes mean an incredible amount if you have read the books; even if you have not, great job noticing one of the best (and most subtly important parts) of the film. What an awesome story.
Stilgar was one of the worst parts of the 2nd film. :( Good acting, but they they made a 2D caricature out of him. Would have liked to see him portrayed more earnestly. Too many comedic lines for the sake of comedic lines
If he doesn't get an oscar we riot
oh that's wild, he was one of my favorite parts. I fucking love Stilgar and his role in the movie was so apparent as a stand-in for the fanaticism of the fremen, I think Javier did a beautiful job portraying that intensity@@lLemonadel
Stilgar is that warrior priest looking for an answer to a question that could save his people. A leader willing to do anything if it meant his people can be saved. I think in some ways he knows the cost of the coming of the Lisan al Gaib but he doesn’t care. His people will be safe and have a chance to fight back.
That’s all that matters. As it is written
Maktub
Well at the same time even though its a self-fulfilling prophecy propagated by the benegesserit.
Paul has shown he can and he did deliver. Not only liberating Arrakis but conquering it for the freeman.
I think Stilgar genuinely believed that Paul would liberate Arrakis and save his people. However, whether or not he actually believes in the prophecy like a religion or he just believes in Paul as a leader is up for debate.
Even though it’s a lie, the prophecy still came true.
As Written
@@Tgm_464Is it even a lie then?
@@Hypogean7this is what I have Been thinking about a ton! Technically it’s all a propagated story by the beneigeseret - whether they planned for that story to actually come true or not who knows. But ultimately Paul ended up becoming the Lisan-Al-Gaib so was it fake or was it real 😂
"In that instant, Paul saw how Stilgar had been transformed from the Fremen naib to a creature of the Lisan-al-Gaib, a receptacle for awe and obedience. It was a lessening of the man, and Paul felt the ghost-wind of the Jihad in it."
- (Herbert 762)
Paul turned Stilgar from a leader into a zealot and never forgave himself for it.
Yes. Besides all his genuine bravery, empathy and capability of caring, Paul has also clearly consciously and unconsciously manipulated the Fremens through his words and leveraging the Bene Gesserit prophecy. He tested water with this in his brief speech to Liet-Kynes in Part One, and did it to the fullest in Part Two. Stilgar can definitely be seen as a victim of his manipulation.
"In that instant, Paul saw how Stilgar had been transformed from the Fremen naib to a creature of the Lisan al-Gaib, a receptacle for awe and obedience. It was a lessening of the man, and Paul felt the ghost-wind of the jihad in it."
@@josephcrawley7622 i should re read the book. It was written
@@dustx I recommend audiobook for a re-read. I find the audiobook's tone compliments the movie's really well. It's like transforming a space soap opera into a re-telling of a desert tale.
I love the zeal in Javier's portrayal of Stilgar when Paul rallies them. It's sooo good
I got chills from that moment
Paul does anything.
Stilgar - Lisan al Ghaib!!!
I was laughing so hard at this at the end of the movie)))
But the movie is amazing...
As written!
Stilgar is one of my favorite characters in the film
Love your videos cant wait for a Dune 2 version!
As written 🤲🏽
I love how this is now in the process of being a meme, part of me wishes I saw the movie at this point but part of me is grateful I got to take it seriously too lol
Having read the books, what seemed like almost comedy moments hits quite differently. I remember everyone chuckling and me knowing how it ends, recalling a line from the books where Paul is thinking how he is losing Stilgar as a friend as he becomes a believer. Of course it makes less sense in the movies considering they compressed 4-5 years into 6-7 months but still an amazing performance.
Idk why but it was hilarious after the final fight, Stilgar's clearly holding his breath in suspense, up until bursts in relief and celebration.
That blindness in faith is the thing that Frank wants to warn us about.
I always LOL when people praise muaddib when frank wanted to warn us about messiahs
There is a reason people want to have faith in something, want to have something to fight for, its a key desire of every human, it is incredibly powerful, people want to believe. i know the ideology of the books and of Herbert, but i disagree with his nihilistic world view, the first dune book can be interpreted in many ways, and there is no right way to interpret it, its the reason Herbert wrote the second book.
@@kyzantia8884 exactly, he got pissed people didn't follow his message blindly. How ironic.
@@kyzantia8884 faith is a savior in desperate situations but also a blade that can finish you off when you're not expected. Yes faith is a must in life but not everything, i have faith in Buddhism (in Vietnam there are many types of Buddhism that would take ages to explain) but i don't believe in it so blindly like a lot of ppl in my country. That they can liquidate everything to contribute some shady ass association that takes the name of Buddhism to make them and their family wealthy.
It’s not that simple
The one character that really stood out in the midst of all these marvelous actors, was Javier Bardem as Stilgar. Just incredible. Made me a follower and a believer of the prophecy as well. I was truly sucked in his performance. Can't really describe it. Spectacular.....
Honestly, I was ready to shout and join the Holy War.
Believe this on earth there is place forming like this from illegal drugs. It could be contained and controlled but is up to real Angels and the real monsters who hurt my plans yesterday but interfering are demons forever more. I no longer talk to demons unless have to protect self and they could get scars from me and then easier for the Lord to see who they are. Emotional scars are what they get and even their animals could no longer exist. They are not even worthy to be Bantha fodder. Not even worthy to be fertilizer.
Stilgar more than made up for how awful Zendeya was as Chadi... terrible character & her Water-Fat face being totally miscast (like the fact that the in universe Freman insult for outworlders is perfect for her is demonstrative of just how badly she was miscast.)
@@nationalsocialism3504 dang how was she that bad 😭 I’ve read the books before and yes even though it might be a bit of a departure from the original character i still found her character entertaining throughout the movie. plus Zendaya is beautiful so idk what ur talking about.
@nj_purple9451 your brain has been ruined if you find her attractive above normal... but even then she has a "Water-Fat" face, the Fremen are a slender/gaunt people whose faces don't have chubby cheeks. It's literally one of their worst insults to use for outsiders... her goblina face of being all muddled doesn't really work even in comparison to other goblinas like Beyonce or Halle Berry who managed to still look like White women that just happened to be dipped in woodstain. They retained that high cheekbone & strong jawline beauty that somehow a bunch of chicks have decided to turn themselves into circus freaks trying to replicate with that buccal fat removal cosmetic surgery.
That's just the physical failure of Zendeya being cast in the role... the role is just awful and goes against what the movie is showing to the audience. Dune is already going down the same route as Starship Troopers where the mass audience is going to react positively to the beauty & belief when it's intended to be a mockery of that. Chadi was changed to be what we the audience reaction to what's happening in the story... when the reality is that the overwhelming majority of people are going to be with Stilgar. The audience isn't leaving the movie being upset about Paul being a "messiah" who is going to burn the galaxy in a Holy War... we are sad that we don't have a messiah to follow who we would burn the galaxy in a Holy War for.
Stilgar's story arc conducted by Javier's acting....was beautiful
And this was beautifully edited.
Thank you
Thank you so much!
I think we all need a Man like Stilgar in our lives, You maybe be the Messiah, but you'll never move mountains without some powerful follower in your corner.
Except Paul isn't a real messiah.
Man did the Kamina motivational speech : "Don't believe in yourself ! Believe in the me that believes in you !"
@@JBFJBFJBF Technically, he is. A bio-engineered one for fullfiling schemers interests maybe. But a messiah nontheless.
@@JBFJBFJBF Who liberated Arrakis? Who Rode the Greatest Worm on his first try? Who lead the Fremen to Conquer the Galaxy? Who Brought Water to transform Arrakis? Who Became the Prophesized Quizach sadaract? Who was the only man ever to survive the spice water and master the ways of the reverend mothers? At this point it doesnt matter if the bene gesserit just made it up, it became true anyway. MUAD'DIB leads the way.
Stilgar is the character who is having the most fun
well said
This probably wasn't the way it was in the books, but in the movie it seemed like Stilgar didn't really start out as a believer and remained a skeptic but only spread the faith anyways because it was a means to an end in helping gather support for fighting off the Harkonnen. However, over time he slowly started to believe his own lies until in the end when Paul began reading the minds of the Southern tribe, at which point he had become a full on zealot! It felt like a significant moment because by him fully embracing Paul as the Lisan al gaib, it makes you as the audience also fully believe he has become it, raising the stakes for the rest of the movie and accepting that Paul has become a whole new person after drinking the water of life. It is bittersweet also since at the same time Chani becomes the only one not disillusioned by this new Paul and she realizes she has lost her old friend/lover for good
It was kinda similar but in the books, Stilgar saw Paul as a friend but then came a believer
Stilgar was ALWAYS a believer since he was a Southern Fundamentalist who had moved up North to fight against the Harroken... he was surrounded by the Northern non-believers that he was leading his belief being one of the things that motivated them to follow him in the first place. Kinda like in Hacksaw Ridge how nobody wanted to do another attack on Hacksaw without Desmond Doss there with them... his belief was so true and so profound that the men around him might not believe in it like he does but they do believe that HE believes. It's Faith as a second operation effect... they might not really believe as an article of Faith but seeing someone real who does have that Faith is something that they can have Faith in.
Stilgar is nothing without his Faith irrelevant to Paul coming to actually fulfill the prophecy or not.
Weirdly Paul was actually the ideal governor for the planet. He learned their ways, was part of their culture and earned a spot in their own hierarchy. If he had an official mandate the spice would be flowing perfectly.
That's why the emperor was scared of the atreides, they werent assholes and were gaining enough power to rivil the imperial house
Javier and several other actors really made these films amazing. In this second film we find that Stilgar can have a sense of humor, and be deeply religious as well.
That shot of Stiglar's pure belief at 2:17 is one of the best shots in the movie. Bardem sells the shit out of it.
People sometimes underestimate the true power of Faith. It is one of the most beautiful and terrifying things humanity has ever seen.
Now, you see the beauty and horror 😂😂
quite funny as the core message of this movie ( and the book writer) is as a warning to be careful of blind worship lol
Stilgar was one of my favourite characters in the books, and now with the movies that feeling just got stronger. And also I can't help but tease and say Lisan al-Gaib when I see my girlfriend doing anything.
Is she truly Lisa al-Gaib?
LISAN AL GAIB!!!!!!!!
M a h d i...
If Stilgar dies in part 3 I'm going to be very upset. So far Leto and Duncan both died and they were my favourites in part 1
Dune has many surprises
Spoiler
Stilgar survives
And Duncan has some surprises (no he didn't survive)
Seems you have an appreciation for strong male leaders. These things can reveal a lot about us.
This isn't a dig either. It's just interesting. I cry whenever characters show courage, I wonder what that says about me ;)
@@sylverxyz Leto isn't a "strong" leader in the traditional sense, more of a compassionate one, or even a weak one as the emperor declares at the end of the movie. Duncan doesn't lead at all, he is merely a strong warrior.
@@DrDanQ92 Fair, perhaps honourable men would be a more accurate term?
Fantastic work! Stillgar is a great character and you did him justice here :)
Thank you so much mate! Gonna watch your Dune edits soon
Stilgar is probably my favourite character from the films, when we first meet him he's a leader, charismatic and funny at times. However over the course of Dune 2 we see him devolve into religious fanatic seeing the signs of Lisan al Gaib everywhere. The first time we see him in Dune 1 he stands toe to toe with Duke Leto, in the last scene of him in Dune 2 he's spitting, almost frothing whilst boarding the ships to attack the Great Houses and embark on a galactic Jihad.
This Stilgar Tribute is Amazing!!!
Thank you so much!
The Morpheus of Dune.
The moment Stilgar saw Muad'Dib ride the worm is the moment he became a blind follower. Loved the expressions
You might think Stilgar is kinda funny and goofy when he shouts "Lisan Al-Ghaib" every time Paul does anything, especially when it comes to their beliefs and faith. But, for me, it's kind of ironic how a leader can be such a 'mindless' follower when it comes to everything he believed and all of the doctrine he got when he grew up. Because I can literally see this in my country lately, especially around the presidential election in February. Some people believed that one of the candidates was somewhat like "Lisan Al-Ghaib"; and unlike Dune, it's not even the truth. They're using religion and faith for political benefits and a polarized mass.
I'm not against Stilgar tho, he's still one of my favorite characters in Dune. He's such a potrayal of an experienced and powerful leader/veteran.
But Trump is the God Emperor of mankind. It was written.
"And behold the Trump of God"
- bible.
You know youre looking at a brain broken amerifat when they find a way to talk about trump under any circumstances
Idk... I think stilgar is exactly the kind of person you're talking about. Course, that's in the books. Let's wait for the final part!
@@Unbid581 I'm really interested in reading the books. But English isn't my first language. Is it gonna be hard for someone like me?
@@Chris-jw8vm I don't know much about the US presidential election or politics. But is the Trump situation similar to the one I mentioned?
В полном восторге от второй части! Надеюсь, будет еще и третья ) Саундтрек просто бесподобный!
"As it was written"!!
Stilgar, the absolute legend
Beautiful! Amazing as always and such a great character!
Thank you so much!
You made a marvellous edit without even having access to the entire second part, which holds most of the scenes involving Stilgar. That's truly impressive. I would urge you to make another edit when the entire second part releases in high definition, I am sure you will do a phenomenal job and will enjoy it. Keep it up!
Edit: Excellent choice of music by the way.
Thank you so much for such words! I'm sure i'll make another one!
The cuts back to the thumper on the beat are so good
Javier Bardem is a Superb Actor, I can't think of anyone else to play this role, very talented Individual .
a man who remained devoted long enough to see his FAITH realized, I absolutely love the religious / character writing behind Stilgar and this edit perfectly highlights that!
“For You is Your Religion; For Me is My Religion.”
Best Picture of 2024
Dune part 2 is now in my top 10 movies of all.time
What an absolute art❤
Great tribute as always man it's good to see ya back doing film edits.
Thank you so much!
Denis-Timothee, say this line from the script
Timothy-Says line from script
Stilgar-AS IT WAS WRITTEN!
Stilgar's fanaticism is legitimately terrifying
Nicely done
Wow... amazing!
Best character
Great!
Hell yeah! That was a sick mashup.
*Stilgar* The biggest Glazer of the known universe.. 🗿
you have done it again brother crusade! As written!
Goated video brother, I loved each second of this video !
Thank you so much bro!
this is one of the channels that inspired me to start editing myself. Love your work.
Thank you so much for kind of words!
Stilgar representa el deseo de que nuestra fé sea (al fin) recompensada.
wow and a great edit 😀
AS WRITTEN!!!!
Stilgar is both a beautiful and tragic character. He had absolute faith that Paul was fated to be his people saviour. And in his faith he created his own messiah, he taught all that Paul needed to know to become Lisan al-Gaib. The faith in the prophecy made him both strong and weak, unwavering and fragile, it gave him and his people the will to resist the worst the Harkonen could trow at them, but made them vulnerable to the machinations of the Bene Gesserit. He represents true faith, both the strength that it gives and the fatal flaw that it breeds.
Stilgar a super serious character was the comic relief in the second movie and its gold
This is such an incredibly effective edit, well done!
Thank you so much!
Amazing edit ! Hope you will do more about Dune !
Thank you so much!
he is beginning to believe, said morpheus
Barden, Ferguson, Chalamay, Zendaya, Butler all the casting are incredible in Dune 2, each Role are intense
There are signs!
I guess this character became a mashup of two characters - Stilgar and Korba - and became this... well, simplified and different kind of Stilgar. I watched the movie in cinema as someone who read all the Dune books years ago and was prepared NOT to compare the two things (book and movie) but maaan this was different... So after 20 min I was just leting it go and enjoyed it as a Dune themed reinvented blockbuster. Because this is what it is. And for that, its a cool movie
Yes, I find movie/show adaptations always have to be enjoyed as a reinvention/spinoff of the original text.
Man did the Kamina motivational speech : "Don't believe in yourself ! Believe in the me that believes in you !"
Strong faith is truly following what you believe, ignorance is blindness in choosing your belief and sticking with it.
because you ignore other beliefs.
Once a wise and strong leader to a blinded fanatic going on a holy crusade that’s a real tragedy
Lisan al Gaib!
Lisannnnn!!!! He is to humble
Please make another one when the movie is out digitally! So many scenes could be used!!
He is my favorite character
this character grows and you and sticks with you. I remember in the book when someone said something and Paul asks Stilgar and Stilgar says something about how he has subjugated hundreds of planets and billions of people. Anyway, don't have time to find it, but before Paul speaks to the council, Stilgar tells Paul to speak in his place and to slay him to do that, but Paul says no general would ever handicap is top weapon, that would be foolish, or something to that effect.
What the hell are you trying to say bro
Great job brother! Especially with so little footage
Thank you so much bro!
Lisan al Ghaib!!!
The tragedy is that Paul loses a friend, a mentor, and a brother in arms who becomes a fanatical devotee.
Dessert Power
So amazing. Please do reverend mother Mohaim!
I love dunes lore
Maud dib 😩
W Glaze
Long live the fighters
Amin! ...Don't blame me I voted for Lasen el Gahib, Paul Usil Mau'dib aka the Preacher! Amin. May Shai halud be pleased and send our enemies to paradise.
As it is written
did you post a video called As Written which got taken down?
Did anyone else find Stilgar unintentionally funny?
Yes. And at the same time very serious. Just remember the scene of his facial expression when he was ready to give his life when Paul challenged everyone
where did you view the movie online? link?
enough Chani ! follow your old man
As Written!
stilgar is paul's biggest glazer
Lisan al-Gaib!
Looks like he escaped from the life of Brian.
Does anyone know the translation for "As written" in the fremen language? I want to say it in that language but cant remember how it sounds
stilgar believed :(
>Paul trips and embarrasses himself
Stilgar: "AS WRITTEN!"
*fundamentalists lose their minds*
Lost a Friend and gained a Fan :( dang
did you read the book?
Technically, Paul IS a Messiah... Thanks to him the Emperor falls, the Fremen become free and water returns to Dune. A self-fulfilled prophecy is still a prophecy. Stilgar has ALL the reasons to believe in Paul -even if he does not believe in himself- Lisan-al-Gaib, in spite of all.
That’s all that matters. As it is written!
"together we will bury the empire"
Muadib! Is the sam as Español!! On gladiator movie😂😂😅
How did you get HD footage of Dune 2?
The video uses currently available trailers and TV spots for Dune part 2
Faith is a double-edged sword: It can bring both hope and sorrow. However, I can't blame Stilgar considering how the Imperium treated the Fremen and how they kept Arrakis as a desert rather than make it into a green paradise.
“Where was it even written Stilgar? Do you have a book or scroll or something I can look at?”
“Here page 198, the Mahdi asks his good friend Stilgar to look at the book and then reads about the exact conversation they’re having at that moment.”
“…As written.”