Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 05. 2024
- 👉Check out Geeks for Geeks Course- Coding for everyone:
bit.ly/thinkschoolthree90
👉Geeks for Geeks all courses:
bit.ly/thinkschoolthree90link
⭐️ Think School’s flagship Communication course with live doubt sessions:
thethinkschool.com/sp/communi...
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
Hi everybody,
It's been two years since Russia invaded Ukraine. And when this war started, many economists in the world predicted that the Russian economy would completely collapse!! Russia was not just in war with Ukraine, it was also battling against the United states and Europion union. So russia was practically fighting an economic war with 2 of the most powerful economies in the world!!But you know what? somehow, inspite of 17,000 sanctions, Russia's economy has not collapsed even after 2 years!!
And this is so shocking that, today, the IMF itself has revised its GDP forecast of Russia, from 1.5% to 2.6%! And, many economists say that there has been no change in the living standards of people in Russia at all!!
In fact, now it is one of the fastest-growing economies among the G7 countries!!!
The question is how did Russia manage to keep its economy afloat even after two years of war?
Why is their secret strategy that is keeping them intact inspite of going against the most powerful countries in the world??
Last and most importantly, what are the lessons that India needs to learn from the extraordinary endurance of Russia?
Our Best Indian Business Case Studies:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
✅Study Materials:
1. www.ft.com/content/d304a182-9...
2. english.elpais.com/internatio...
3. www.aljazeera.com/opinions/20...
#thinkschool #businesscasestudy #geopolitics #russia #europe #russiaukrainewar
👉Check out Geeks for Geeks Course- Coding for everyone:
bit.ly/thinkschoolthree90
👉Geeks for Geeks all courses:
bit.ly/thinkschoolthree90link
black paper video
No Dhruv Rather was harmed in this video. 😂 Dictator comment was the highlight. 😂
Sir after completing 6week of you communication master class I'm still afraiding to talk people, still I have nothing to say 😢
What about the hiring results?
Russia has VK and Yandex as alternative to what we are using to search and watch videos
while we Indians failed to develop our alternatives to those products
Our religion is just a scam, because we go outside and make other countries better
our Gov should stop using tax payers money and use abroad people money if they are stuck in some warzone to bring them home
and we are busy funding platforms who promote hate against India
Interesting analytics. As a Russian, let me make a couple of comments.
1. You named 1 million people who left Russia, but did not say where they went and how many returned. And statistics showed that they leave mainly to neighboring countries, they left only during the mobilization, more than half returned when the mobilization was over. It's hard to leave a country with the usual high standard of living from family and friends. Those Russians who have left are breaking away from culture and the country, and it is changing every day.
2. The working class in Russia cannot just leave everything and leave, firstly, many have loans and mortgages, secondly, most people work not at private but at state-owned enterprises with very good and stable salaries, as if hospitals, factories or the post office, they have nowhere and no need to run. They live the same way. Nothing has changed.
Read it strictly with a Russian accent
Strickly with a russian accent.😂
1 million is also less than 1%.... and leaving a country doesn't mean anything, 130 million chinese leave China every year.... think about that.... THINK ABOUT THAT....
Я смог😂
Portuguese guy here.
It's been very hard to get some news from Russia as you can figure out. But I'm always curious about all this things such as geopolitics, as well as knowing the "way of life" for the "common" citizen like I think I am at my country 😂
I genually have no second thoughts and it's all about knowledge and curiosity about the world I live in, not just my city or country.
Cheers and peace for everyone! 👍🏳️🇵🇹🇷🇺🏳️
this channel is western propaganda shill
19:37 Russia didn't ban transactions - sanctions did. I couldn't pay for my Spotify by the 1 of March of 2022
He was talking about transfering money into real estate outside the country
Так это не Россия забанила переводы, хотя бы думай прежде, чем пишешь
@@user-zd6sf8zo5y он это и сказал 🤦♂
@@yastyman он переписал комментарий
real question: how are you guys dealing with no spotify? what's the solution you've come up with? and how's the local music scene doing as a result?
20:30 В России килограмм картошки стоит 20-30 рублей, держу в курсе
держу в курсе, он привел в это в пример, да и цена картошки от сезона к сезону и регионов и сортов картофеля меняется
@@terrymcginnis7214 я зимой за 20 рублей покупал а пример у него довольно грубый получился
смотря какой регион
@@terrymcginnis7214 Всю зиму картошка в петербурге , как была 10 - 20 рублей , так и осталась . 10 это мелкая , 20 крупная .
@@terrymcginnis7214 A skolgo sortow est?
There are 3 types of economies: Market economies, Command economies and mixed economies. The Russian economy is a mixed economy. As a matter of fact, no economy can be a 100% market economy. The US economy, for example, is also a mixed economy.
100% market economy is a speedrun to Great Depression. Funny to see how some people declare that US, Russia or any other country is "not true market/capitalist" economies because there is not 100% market and state doing something regulatory :D
omg! Somebody had to say it
Thank you❤
Even a command economy is never a 100 controlled economy. But we still have to take russia a free market. We are the one to set standards and measurements to define things or else it would become confusing and baseless to talk about. Thats basic concept in class 12 economics.
@@saikatsaha4122 Are you joking or just ignorant? Free markets in true command economies such as the DPRK or the USSR are basically negligible but the same can't be said about government intervention in 'free market' economies such as the USA or even the EU. The USA and the EU are currently stopping their citizens and companies from doing business with Russia!!!
Russian economy only and exclusively relies on selling gas and oil. They are unable to produce tech and products, almost nothing. That's not a mixed economy, nor even any of the rest of economies you mention, but something very rudimentary.
First of all, let me say, Russia is an otarchy. A nation which has everything in natural resources.
hi you are only person who is saying something important in the comments
Did you mean oligarchy, because that means something different?
Today, I have identified the true logical fallacy that Ganeshprasad Sridharan is using to justify the wrongdoings of the Modi Government.
He doesn't believe India is becoming authoritarian; his jibe is proof of that.
Your logic is flawed, brother. First of all, you are waiting for India to stoop to the level of North Korea before calling it a true dictatorship.
Then, according to your logic, China and Russia, which are far better than North Korea, are the best examples of democracy.
I have a problem with how India compares itself economically. Instead of comparing with neighboring countries, such as Pakistan, in terms of GDP per capita, India should compare with countries that surpass us and strive to compete with them.
And now, this new argument by Ganeshprasad Sridharan that we are not like North Korea, at least.
Bro, it's okay if you want to support Modi, but don't try to halt the argument with such flawed logic.
If you can't see farmers being arrested for growing millet, then at least you can see the arrest of Kejriwal, the vilification of farmers as deshdrohi and terrorists, the buying of media by oligarchs, and the government's use of quid pro quo in electoral bonds. If you can't see this, then you are watching the wrong news channel, bro.
@@vivek.mhatre
"Autarky is the characteristic of self-sufficiency, usually applied to societies, communities, states, and their economic systems".
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autarky
Hello! Its autarky, not otarchy. Don't use words you don't understand, it make you look bad.
Autarky does not matter at all in a technological world with global trade connection. Russia cannot exploit its northern oil and gas resources without western tech.
No German Shepherd was not harmed in this video😂
What does this mean? Clueless. I saw many comments with same statement.
@@kaveenprabhushades actually they guys are talking about dhruv rathi who made a video few days ago claiming that that the democracy of india is in danger and on top of that even think school touched this topics that's why everyone is commenting....
Understood 😂😂😂😂
@@kaveenprabhushades They are talking about a youtuber called dhruv rati, who makes anti govt content, so people who don't support the govt see him as their father.
These youtubers are becoming godi media these days
another statement that 1000000 Russians left Russia in 2022 which is more or less true, but not mentioned that around 80% of them already returned back.
And millions of ukrainian citizesn joined too. Just population of Crimea alone added 600k.
Plus record numbers of migrant workers from former Soviet Union. There are no labor shortages. He didn't do proper research.
Now compare how many left Ukraine when the war broke out, especially the men. went from 50 mil down to around 37 mil in the span of 10 years from 2014. It might even be worse, they say 20 million are "displaced" also known as left the country.
@@josephthebig2889 It is worse. In 1991 Ukraine had 52M. Yea, after that soviet "genocide". In 2013 already 45M. And it is citizens, not people present in the country.
Crimea+Donbass = 6M left too, one way or another
So this war they started with ~38M.
And ~10M refugees in the first year. Mostly women, elders and children.
Men started to run mostly after Bakhmut meatgrinder. In my calculations, ~700k crossed the western borders illigaly.
So Ukraine is already half of what it was in the end of Soviet era. For full decommunaziation, and return to the level of feudal age we need to achieve 15M of 1917. A year or two and we will be there.
its interesting where they gone. Really many of them just moved temporarily to the nearest countries or countries with better climate to work remotely for russian companies or for local branches of russian companies.
When you started to compare Market economy (India) vs State Economy (NK) - there is no reason to hear anything further. Absolutely delusinal!
1 wrong doesn't make everything wrong. If you continue to listen he is 80% based.
@@SenatePalpatinetroller This 1 wrong is soooo massive - everything else is dwarfed and irrelevant
He's repeating standard US propaganda nonsense.
You are Right 👍🏽
17000 sanctions?? 😲😲😲... No country would hv survived such restrictions, particularly India
Sadly, we don't have oil reserves to survive such sanctions at all. China will easily survive because sanctions would be weak since the whole world is highly dependent on Chinese manufacturing
I think Iran also have face high number of sanctions and they survived too
I think India can survive the sanctions if you want to make the make in India project the reality then USA has to sanction India completely in all aspects
@@Mjv-fu6og they have oil and mineral
Countries with dictatorship survive sanctions 😅
No Dalub tatti was harmed in this video 😂😂😂
Teri aur Modi ki aukaat tere comment se dikh gai
@@HarmanHundal01 chal oye khalistani😂
@@Rahulsharma80558If you think Think School is neutral(once upon a time he was but now it's clear as day)then i am sorry nowadays he's meat riding bjp and making podcasts with them.
@@sammybosak10 Lol tell me a single incident where he is meat riding BJP 🤣🤣🤣 You guys rant freedom of speech freedom of speech, DICTATORSHIP and what not.. but when someone has an opposite opinion against your ideology you guys start bashing that person 🤣🤣 where is Think School's Freedom of speech now?🤣🤣
buy silver
There is some information which I would like to correct. 1. Industrial output grew not only in military industry, but in many other industries thanks to import replacement process, local businesses rushed to fill the gaps which occurred due to some foreign brands decision to leave Russia. 2. Labor shortage was a problem even before the war, but became bigger after the war started.
I'm from Russia. The conclusions that makes the guy are completely wrong. The state economy (planned economy) is much more stable compared to a market economy. We in Russia remember how Stalin's USSR fought with Hitler. Germany smelted twice as much steel, but produced fewer tanks than the USSR. The USSR was forced to send about 20-30 million adult men to war, while the country did not experience problems with food, because the planned economy ensured an even distribution of resources. The main advantage of the USSR was that it did not need to spend billions on the luxury of the rich - expensive houses, cars, personal planes, yachts. There were no rich people in the USSR.
Ну на счет не было проблем с едой это ты конечно зря. У меня бабушка как раз в военные годы была в эвакуации из Полтавы в Казахстан. Рассказывала с едой было все плохо, постоянно недоедали. Выжили конечно, но проблема объективно была.
Но вцелом с тезисом согласен, у Германии и суммарное население со всей осью, колониями и оккупированной частью Европы было больше. И затраты на военку превышали в 8 раз. И эффект неожиданности. И все рано превосходство в воздухе просто пролюбили на соревновании чья индустрия клепает быстрее. И даже когда остатки перекинули на танки, по ним тоже гонку проиграли.
@@iamaim2847 Да, согласен не жировали, но что и показательно. Из сельской местности забрали миллионы мужчин, а посевные проводились исправно на протяжении 5 лет войны. Очевидно, что это только благодаря механизации труда в сельском хозяйстве. Мало того что кормили себя, но еще и фронт.
И где теперь СССР, со своей стабильной плановой экономикой? Ах да он развалился за один день.
Cough**American Lend-Lease** Cough
The reason the USSR could devote more resources to produce more tanks than Nazi Germany was because America gave the USSR hundreds of thousands of trucks and hundreds of locomotives to make them more mobile. If the USSR would have had to devote industry to them, it would have had to build fewer tanks.
Russian soldiers marched into Germany chewing American spam, wearing American boots and on American Studebaker Trucks.
@@user-vp1uh4qc9f Плохие времена порождают сильных людей, сильные люди порождают хорошие времена, хорошие времена порождают слабых людей, слабые люди порождают плохие времена.
4:14 no german shepher was harmed in this video 😂😂
😅😅
Muslims coming to defend him in 1 2 3...
@@unknown.145gvgugbj According to them 60years of congress's rule is democracy (They forgot what indira gandhi did) and 10 years of BJP's rule is dictatorship. How ironic
india was a dictatorship?
@@unknown.145gvgugbjI’m katar Hindu but I’m with dhrue rathee ,
Bhad m jaye Modi
4:13 damn that was smooth....
Today, I have identified the true logical fallacy that Ganeshprasad Sridharan is using to justify the wrongdoings of the Modi Government.
He doesn't believe India is becoming authoritarian; his jibe is proof of that.
Your logic is flawed, brother. First of all, you are waiting for India to stoop to the level of North Korea before calling it a true dictatorship.
Then, according to your logic, China and Russia, which are far better than North Korea, are the best examples of democracy.
I have a problem with how India compares itself economically. Instead of comparing with neighboring countries, such as Pakistan, in terms of GDP per capita, India should compare with countries that surpass us and strive to compete with them.
And now, this new argument by Ganeshprasad Sridharan that we are not like North Korea, at least-bro, it's okay if you want to support Modi, but don't try to halt the argument with such flawed logic.
If you can't see farmers being arrested for growing millet, then at least you can see the arrest of Kejriwal, the vilification of farmers as deshdrohi and terrorists, the buying of media by oligarchs, and the government's use of quid pro quo in electoral bonds. If you can't see this, then you are watching the wrong news channel, bro.
It should be as some dog says.
@@ceaser7422Oye Chomu dhruv rathee never said india is under dictatorship he said india is slowly transitioning towards dictatorship if bJP keeps abusing their power.
Please use your critical thinking for once if you BJ party supporters(which i highly doubt) . You guys never watch full video and make your own decisions i am sure all the sheep here spamming "ahaha German shepherd destroyed" never say his entire video.
@sammybosak10 if you were an avid user of critical thinking yourself it's visible the core agenda Mr rathee pushes forward , he came on deshbhakt clearly stated vote for opposition meaning INDI alliance . You're telling me a party structure which isnt democratic at all( its just gandhis reigning) they will upheld democratic values ? . Also I would prefer having minsters like Ashwini Vaishnav than Lalu yadav (Railway ministers of their times )
@@sammybosak10 .
This shows one thing - You gotta have strong international friends you can trust :)
In India, you can transfer INR to foreign currency up to $8,000 with no problem. But if you go over that, you gotta pay 20% tax. So India's economy isn't as open as some might think.
Chinese can transfer 50000$ a year without tax 😂
@stc2828 There should be zero capital control. That's true free market.
@@stanley3290 its complicated. Fore example if India drop all the import taxes now, its local industry will get decimated and will never able to develop.
Russians can transfer 10,000 dollars a year
none are. theres limits everywhere. holding money in swiss bank also 20% tax
German shephard was not harmed in this video🤡
I am also writing this statement 😅😅😅😅😅
All i can see is Modi's make in India couldn't grab opportunity and again china is benefited by 7billion usd
Uske brainless people subscribers offended ho jayegan 😢😂
@@ajith887reason is that India does not have industry to full fill Russia's demand.
We have a very long way to go in terms of industrialization.
@@ajith887 basic Economic growth tools are getting implemented as per the market economy standards from the last 10 years in India. Before the phenomenon was either stagnant or nothing
"As some people say" at 4:11 - somebody just got owned
Arre!
You dont own anything, its the lord that makes and takes everything
Haha😂
actually evidence of invisible dictatorship
@@yash110496bro is tooo soft 😂
Got friends from Russia and they said that tho food prices exploded at the start, now it is even cheapier than before the war, the Russian government has also being investing a lot in infrastructure and heavy industry, so a lot of people now have good paying jobs
I can say that food prices have become very high.
Yes, they are trying to keep prices down for social bread, vegetable oil, cereals... but we have been shopping for two years and are surprised at the prices and the fact that 1000 rubles is not enough for two large packages (food for a week) as before. Now with 1000 rubles it’s easy to buy a few inexpensive standard products, which is upsetting. However, there are products on the shelves and it is not fatal. Perhaps this is a psychological moment of habit.
@4:14 to @4:18 That was smooth. 🔥
And thank you for such an informative video. 😊
No German shepherd harmed in this video 😂😂😂
He clearly mentioned with a question mark (the same logic that Indian media uses before tarnishing people's life) that are we moving towards dictatorship. He never said has become one yet.
If it continues, one day we won't be able to get back to normal like North Korea.
So yeah, either we watch that happen or do something about the potential threat now.
This is all what I believe the so-called German shepherd is trying to convey to its people. no matter what your breed is atleast Dogs are Loyal no matter where they go. I won't mind being called a loyal dog to my country.
Before being a bully to just everyone as we Indians do (ex North East Indians, how Rahul Gandhi is also made fun of, I mean there is a lot of fun we get for just making fun of anybody in this country and there is no ethics in it too) let me also mention, I'm not a Congress supporter. I don't want to live in a country and wait until I become affected later.
And when that happens, all of us who are laughing will have nothing to laugh about, we will be a laughing stock who failed to secure our own democracy.
@@mvpharsh who was roasted with that sentence...??🤔🤔
@@Nav2k5 Dhruv rathee
@@mvpharshhow,I don’t get it
4:14
Now 14 year old kids will get offended Iykyk... 😂😂
im 13yo and im ofdendnded saaaar
😂😂😂😂
@gknkrnkjgjugjrgjrng 😂
Now they will say Thik School "that's why education is important" 🤡🤡
@@ShawonGhoshdastidar thats why eudication important saaaaaar
4:13 No German shepherd was harmed in this video
😂😂😂😂😂bhai wo hath ka Nash katanga apna
@dhruv rathee
You have been propagandized!
@@sophosalpha u have been propagandazided liberalised
Bro ruined whole propoganda of German shepherd with a single line 😅😅😅
Who is German Shepherd ?
@@shishyathwa Dhruv Rathee‚ the patriot trying to save India's democracy from Germany😂😂
@@aadisinha2173 better than the patriot who eating their own country
If Russian can grow this much during a war time scenario, imagine how much would they grow without the war in Europe?
You could go read up on war economy and realize it is in fact the other way around. Growth is higher in war effort
Have you watched the video at all ? The point that @Flex2212 was explained in the video. It's somewhere towards the middle of the "Shadow Fleet" chapter.
Russia was not growing much before 2022 due to outflow of capital from Russia to the West.
The very thing that the sanctions shut off.
West shot itself in the foot.
Also, exports are just a fraction of Russia's economy. The assumption that Russia was "Nigeria with snow" dependent on exports was monumentally silly.
The economy would not have grown if not for sanctions that helped drive out competitors and cut off the cash flows of international traders. this triggered domestic demand from local producers. Military salaries provide an infusion of money into families and demand for goods.
But now, when many Russian factories have been rebuilt, when the population does not trust foreign corporations that have abandoned their obligations and have not returned prepaid money... oh. When the war is over there will be a new interesting act.
@@Conserpov Sanctions were also that "magic kick in the ass" Russian "elites" in offices ALWAYS seem to need. So many "Kulibins" in Russia, and "effective managers" always screw them over. Rigidity of thought and fear of responsibility. And greed of those in charge, thinking that they can keep running away to "comfortable" west. That's no longer the case. Too bad Putin isn't Stalin.
This man destroyed Mr. Rathee in Seconds... 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Don't respect him with mr😂😂😂
Umm can you guys enlighten me why he gets the hate ?😅 coz I seriously don't know 😅
Drink Beer 🍻
@@dhruvv_churi because he projects himself as neutral even though he has a particular agenda (enough people have exposed his hypocrisy )
@@abhyudayayadav6406 feed the people what they want, thats what its like to make your way into todays social media dominated world.
view equals to money.
You said 1 million Russian left their country in 2022 because of Ukraine-Russo war. But the interesting part is, in Germany alone more than 300K Russian ethic left Germany and went back to Russia (maybe they were afraid of anti-Russia sentiments). But what if it also happens across Western- and Eastern European countries and they goes back to Russia. the numbers would be more than 2 million.
A lot went to Kaliningrad, It's a special economic region of Russia, Only 6% tax and no VAT on imported goods and any other taxes. Also from the ones who left in 2022 are desperate to return because they have seen that even if wage is higher in west they still can buy way less basic goods than in Russia because of ridiculous taxes and other costs. Not talking about Iphones here.
Can you please site your source? Fast google check couldnt find any info about russians leaving Germany. Only found info about record russian immigration IN Germany in 2022 (34k+ people)
There is no evidence to support your claim that over 300,000 ethnic Russians left Germany and returned to Russia in 2022 due to anti-Russia sentiment. The available data indicates a significant and long-standing Russian population in Germany, but does not mention any large-scale exodus in the past year so where are you getting your information from because it's not publicly available.
Where did you found these numbers, I’m interested in reading them?
The most interesting aspect of that statistic is its lack of a basis in reality.
Russia prepared for this war post 2014 sanctions. He played game of chess with support from China since 2018.
yeah, putler is a great chess player. that why his 3 days SMO turned into a 3 days + 700 days SMO
@@IrrationalCharm It could have been 3 days had Russia used its power as NATO did in Iraq, killing thousands of innocent civilians. Russia is fighting the army, not the civilians, see the difference?.
@@IrrationalCharm how is counteroffensive hohol? Already in Crimea? oh, sorry, that was just Zelensky cocaine dream
@@innelator6941 yeah, using derogatory terms about ukranians. That means I am in the right side of history.
Fascist.
@@IrrationalCharm
No one has spoken in 3 days. If there is a refutation, show it. In fact, everything ended just in a week - Zelensky signed a neutrality agreement that American bases would never be on the territory of Ukraine, but Boris Johnson wanted the destruction of Ukrainians and the redistribution of the world towards Russia... OK
This video didn't mention some nuances about Russia economy, at first, Russia actually started exporting much more amount of products to such countries as China and India, but the problem is that countries has non-convertible currency, and payments for products, that Russia exports, are mostly made in that currency, which make the majority of profits locked in particular economy. So because of this, Russia is forced to import something or invest in their economies rather that convert revenue into rubles and boost what important for Russia. At second, despite Russia don't have fully state-owned economy, it actively increasing their share in overall GDP, by deprivatisation of companies, that was in state possesion when USSR exists, but transfered to private ownership when Soviet collapsed. Recently there was a situation, when stocks of some metallugry company was forcebly transfered to Russia from private owners, who even bought this stocks from others non-state parties, because goverment stated that privatisation process, that took over that 30 years ago, was made against state's will (wtf). At third, author didn't mentioned about migrant workers, who will replace those, who was conscripted or moved to work in military sector. So because of this Russian companies are more interested in migrant workers, and trying to gather more cheap labor in order to not increase salaries, and Russian goverment actively increasing theis work migrant's quotas in order to satisfy the request. And at final, Russia have a special "national prosperity reserve", that goverment actively use for covering excessive spending on military. So even if exporter's revenue are rising in dollar equvalent, it doesn't mean that they can actually use all of the money they earn. But of course, despite of all I said, Russian main exporters, who are all mostly state-owned companies, still managing to export their products in exchange for convertible currency, which they sell and spend into exsessive producing of rockets and weapons and nothing left for real people's prosperity.
no German shepherd was harmed in this video
There are millions of civilians and soldiers are dying because of the war. You don't have to raise your voice against war, but it is definitely not something to glorify.
@@krishnakamal49you got wrong context brother..... 😊
@@krishnakamal49 Just because German Shepard is being criticized doesn't means you will comment anything to oppose the comment.
@@krishnakamal49 Out of context comment bro. Check out the whole video, And u might require a bit high IQ to understand the reference.
Most WEIRD thing is: German shepherd has been exposed with FACTS about his purposely misinterpreted, misleading data by many CZcamsrs but still people are following him. How much dumb can one get??
Man….!! What a phenomenal detailed research and analysis 🙌🏻 thanks..🙏🏻
11:06 i'd push back on that because around 3 million Ukrainians, at the least have fled to Russia. So although they have mobilised and had people flee Russia, the amount of people who fled to Russia from Ukraine and still live in Donbas and the Annexed areas, actually gives Russia more people now, not less. And also most sources still count these people as "ukrainian population" even though they're actually in Russia or in Russian annexed areas, effectively working for Russia. For example the population of Donbas and Crimea, could be easily around 6-7 million.
Bro love how you logically break things down. How you present your chain of thoughts.
Keep up the good work bro. I will surely see you someday!
he reminds me of History Legends channel guy
Dude you deserve a national award and you are the most eligible one out of 90% who got their first...All the best❤
Secretly roast rathee. 😂😂😂
Did rathee say something about Russia Ukraine? I dont have the context
@@wannabedev2452 No
He is making videos that india is under dictatorship 😂😂
Thats why he took the jibe on him
Ganesh said INDIA IS NOT A DICTATORSHIP LIKE NORTH KOREA AS SOME PEOPLE SAY
@@Rahulsharma80558 ah ok thx
@@wannabedev2452they don't have any counter points to put forward to argue with dhruve points so they put in front a bigger fascist force and say look we are not like North kores everyone knows north Korea is fascist since long. By the way he said black paper will be out in April first week if he wants to put any counter to dhruve he could have made the video of black paper and criticised congress
@@fknrim83 there are like 15 videos debunking rathee point by point on the dictatorship video. Saying that there are no arguments against our German Shepard is very dumb.
Always learn something new from this channel. Keep up the good work, Ganesh!
You are 100% correct that India has to turbocharge its manufacturing capacity.
No dhruv rathee harmed in this video 😂😂
Today, I have identified the true logical fallacy that Ganeshprasad Sridharan is using to justify the wrongdoings of the Modi Government.
He doesn't believe India is becoming authoritarian; his jibe is proof of that.
Your logic is flawed, brother. First of all, you are waiting for India to stoop to the level of North Korea before calling it a true dictatorship.
Then, according to your logic, China and Russia, which are far better than North Korea, are the best examples of democracy.
I have a problem with how India compares itself economically. Instead of comparing with neighboring countries, such as Pakistan, in terms of GDP per capita, India should compare with countries that surpass us and strive to compete with them.
And now, this new argument by Ganeshprasad Sridharan that we are not like North Korea, at least-bro, it's okay if you want to support Modi, but don't try to halt the argument with such flawed logic.
If you can't see farmers being arrested for growing millet, then at least you can see the arrest of Kejriwal, the vilification of farmers as deshdrohi and terrorists, the buying of media by oligarchs, and the government's use of quid pro quo in electoral bonds. If you can't see this, then you are watching the wrong news channel, bro.
That sly dig at Dhruv was amazing 😂
Dhruv Who? 😂😅
LMAO🤣🤣
Man you don't get your payment from pr agency because spelling is incorrect
Dhruv Rathee
Most WEIRD thing is: German shepherd has been exposed with FACTS about his purposely misinterpreted, misleading data by many CZcamsrs but still people are following him. How much dumb can one get??
Market economies are dead and have been dead for a long time, even the us is a mix of state run economy and market
no german shepherd harmed in this video😂
4:16
Bro took a jibe at German shepherd
timestamp
@@baazinews1027 4:13
@@baazinews1027 Its the dictatorship part, where thinkshool mentioned if India were a dictatorship how it would have behaved to stop the protest and farmers producing wheat and rice and force them to produce millets.
Timestamp: 4:13
@@baazinews1027min 14
@@UTKARSHARJUN thanx
Bhai German Shepherd ka Mazak mat udaao, uska Baap Jail me hai. He is sad 😂
Bohut sad hai wo..haar jaga me ro raha hai..😂😂😂
I don't think the west really expected Russia's economy to collapse or crumble. I think they went light. They allowed plenty of extra time from when they announced sanctions- to when they were actually implemented so EU could buy plenty of Russian oil/gas before sanctions kicked in. Sanctions were soft because they didn't want to shock stock markets and collapse the world economy. Russia will slowly decline. That's why the ruble is down again and interest rate is 16%.
Sun Tzu in his book “The Art of War” rightly said - “There is no instance of a country having benefited from prolonged war” … think it also summarise what this video is trying to communicate. It would be very interesting to see how this pans out for Russia.
3:52 India is not a Market Economy . It is a Mixed Economy which is a combination of both State and Market Economy
that was before liberilasation
And so is China and Russia - only the proportions are different.... The best of both worlds, provided the center, the brains are nimble, fast and smart😊... Obviously, only big, independent and self-sufficient countries can afford it
Full market economies died a long time ago, europe and the us are restructuring their economies to mixed economies, capitalism died but for some reason this guy can’t see this
Aren't they all
@@machinefannatic99right
dhruv rathee:- kuku fm🤡
Think school :- Geek for geeks🗿
there two types of economy 1- ruled by state 2-ruled by market , but today russian economy is not ussr one and they had too much differences....same goes to north korea - it is simplification
and compare north korea economy with russian economy is stupid as hell... - it is more about prapaganda than scientific analysis
That subtle shot makes this video so wholesome. @4:14
We need more case study. Thank you Ganesh for your efforts.❤
German Sheppard bow bow, think school Wow Wow! Great content
Haha soo funny a godi influencer making passive aggressive statements on Dhruv
@@sammybosak10bruh learn your history before you compare India to russia... our country is more democratic than usa with its 2 party system.
@@surajs5913 You don't get jailed or threatened for speaking against ruling party the in USA
@@surajs5913 Mr. Oversmart don't you know the govt now literally has power to remove your posts or take action against you if the bj party thinks if your posts or content is mischievous or threatens integrity bs.
Very democratic indeed
@@sammybosak10 source?
I totaly agree with the closing remarks of being ready to grab opportunity....we have lost may until now but we shall prepare for everything next...
The secret of growth is trivially simple: total control over all institutions and the ability to write anything in reports for internal and external use, and of course an unlimited amount of oil, the price of which has been consistently high for more than three years.
If you don't think india is going to become dictatorship you are absolutely in right mindset continue supporting your "papa"
Looks like someone is salty enough because their 'papa' isn't getting enough support in the state 😂😂. In a dictatorship , government snatches power from people but here people are re-electing the government for a third term. Tell me how it is a 'dictatorship'??
Dictatorships is what ruled the world, democracy is just a word they use to calm you down 😂😂😂 the US is a dictatorship, the EU is a dictatorship in different forms
Supporting "papa" is better than supporting "pappu" andhnamaza🤣😂
Silent roasting 😂
Phenomenal analysis, hats off to the crew, kudos keep up the pace ❤
It is worth considering that production facilities are developing strongly in Russia and there is a large shortage of workers in the labor market. If the military industry starts to decline after the war, then workers will take up positions in the civilian sector. After the Second World War, there was nowhere to get a job in the USSR. Therefore, there was a sharp decline in the economy.
Hi sir. i just saw your video on national logistic policy and i just loved how you explain the concept in simple words and also brief on all major variables. And i hope that our government will take water scarcity problem even more seriously than logistics as the rising heat is rapidly drying up many lakes. I am looking forward to more videos related to decisions taken by our government and thank you so much for the efforts you put in making each videos❤❤
Brilliant analysis
THINKSCHOOL TEAM, KUDOS, YOU PEOPLE ARE DOING A GREAT JOB EDUCATING PEOPLE! KEEP IT UP!!
The “Shadow Fleet” study described in this video is already published back on 6th Dec 2023 from Bloomberg Originals under the video title as “The Shadow Fleet Fueling | Russia’s war”.
Great video !! Please share us how your process of video making is as well the presentation methods that you use .
4:16 Bro casually roasted dhruv rathee 😂
Ofc a godi influencer calling out dhruv rathee nothing new
Most WEIRD thing is: German shepherd has been exposed with FACTS about his purposely misinterpreted, misleading data by many CZcamsrs but still people are following him. How much dumb can one get??
Wow what a amazing video. Thank you for the clear explanations . From Australia
He misled the audience saying somebody called India a dictatorship nation whereas it wasn't mentioned anywhere in the noted video that the country is already under dictatorship. Again, in recent video, he put the title "Dictatorship in India Confirmed?" although there was nothing in the video about the freedom of people and fair election. This channel has been so helpful for the business point of view. Please don't wash your hands in the dirty river.
Bro, what’s your real problem? You wanted to see him prove India as dictator to make you feel better? You felt bad that he didn’t serve your objective? Or what?
@@contactdi8426 No. I felt that he was using the dictatorship topic unnecessarily. See the comments and you'll see how that thing triggered the people against a CZcamsr. I see ThinkSchool as a great business learning platform and don't want them to get involved in unnecessary trends.
@@kuberrana3356 If india were in a dictatorship then you won't be able to comment here, just see the case of russia, china, and ofc DPRK(north korea) they all banned youtube to avoid critisicm of their regime, they do use youtube but with VPN network.
@@mrxyz8366 who said india is in a dictatorship?
@@kuberrana3356 then what was mentioned in the thumbnail? and it was clearly mentioned in the title of the video without any "?" mark that there's a "Dictatorship" in India.
Putin has balls made of steel😅
Made of titanium 🌚
When Putin runs a country, the country automatically starts running the world 🗿🤣✌️
@@SANATANI_MEMER. ..correction, made from Putinium
Keep doing this types of videos bro...your case studies are unique❤❤..
The information doesn't stack up in the video in regards to oil/gas sales. 2023 has been a record low for Russia in terms of oil/gas revenue (compared to 2021) and Gazprom had huge loses in 2023 as well, compared to profits before. So its definitely no rose gardens in this regard.
That is what is shown to people like . Higher level people know the reality
The problem is that Russian not in a war with Ukraine. For all markers this is a just local conflict for russia. There is no full mobilisation, no war economic .
I learned new thing today 'Shadow fleet' a way to bypass sanctions in international waters. 👍🏻
Nobody is saying it’s already dictatorship. People like Dhruv rathee is talking about prevention of dictatorship.
With half baked facts from Wire and quint 😂😂😂😂
@@unknown.145gvgugbj P what can I say if you are biased and not open to the truth until you feel the pain directly and not of others
@@artysmart Yeah i felt the same way when amit shah was thrashed on fake charges when Congress was in power. And yeah who can forget how Modi ran for his life in 1975 dressed like a sikh. In 2002 too when congress did not send any force to supress riots and made him hitler ka chela.
Most WEIRD thing is: German shepherd has been exposed with FACTS about his purposely misinterpreted, misleading data by many CZcamsrs but still people are following him. How much dumb can one get??
@@FactsSpeakerrWhich CZcamsr
Im so happy I found this channel, very well presented thank you 😊
I think you are missing the fact that Russia produces a lot of stuff domestically, so similar to Japan, the exchange rate does not affect the local economy as much as you would imagine. If anything, a cheaper ruble is a boon for exports. If potatoes ever get more expensive, it is not because of the exchange rate, but due to simple market speculation by profiteers. One might say... free markets in action!
4:14 Ooofff sooo smooth , Smooth operatorrr !
The explanation is really great. That's why I love your videos.
Main lesson for India: Maintain and deepen economic relationship with PRC.
No one has said that India is becoming a dictatorship, but it may be on the path towards one.
Bro India is not dictatorship, it's going towards the path of dictatorship. Correct your source❤
How do you know? And what's this ," path of dictatorship"?
*Hello Team Think School. To my best knowledge, India has been getting crude from Russia at much lower prices & Russians agreed due to sanctions imposed. Then how come their margins improved or remained same. Please help understand correctly. Thank you*
It is discounted compare to international price ,but the discounted price is still higher than pre war prices thats why they are earning more profit
The bizarre part is those "heavily discounted almost for free" prices are still significantly HIGHER than what Russia used to sell it's resources (gas, oil, etc) to Europe for. Многоходовочка бля.
Short summary of the video
In the CZcams video "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker examines Russia's economic resilience despite two years of war with Ukraine and economic sanctions from the US and EU. Contrary to expectations, Russia's economy has grown, with a projected GDP growth of 2.6% this year. The speaker attributes this to Russia's market-run economy, which allows the market to control production, enabling Russia to adapt and grow in the face of international conflict. The speaker also highlights the differences between market-run and state-run economies, using the examples of India and North Korea, and discusses how Russia's military sector is experiencing a boom due to increased wages and oil and gas exports. Despite challenges such as inflation and a volatile currency, Russia's economy grew by 3.1% in 2023, while Ukraine's plunged. The speaker urges India to learn from Russia's experience and adopt market-run economies, avoid relying on war for economic growth, and focus on manufacturing to take advantage of export opportunities.
00:00:00 In this section of the CZcams video titled "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker discusses how Russia's economy has not collapsed despite two years of war with Ukraine and economic sanctions from the United States and European Union. Contrary to predictions, Russia's economy has grown, with a projected GDP growth of 2.6% this year. The speaker attributes Russia's economic resilience to its market-run economy, which allows the market to control production instead of the government. This approach allows Russia to adapt to changing circumstances and continue growing even in the face of international conflict. The speaker also highlights the importance of understanding the nature of a country's economy and the role of market forces in shaping economic outcomes.
00:05:00 In this section of the CZcams video titled "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker discusses the differences between a market-run economy like India and a state-run economy like North Korea. The speaker explains that in a state-run economy, businesses don't prosper due to inefficiency in resource management and a slow response to market trends. The speaker then shifts the focus to Russia, which was expected to collapse economically due to sanctions but instead turned out to be a market-driven economy. The Russian economy quickly found new suppliers to replace those lost due to sanctions, with China becoming a major import partner. Additionally, military spending has significantly contributed to Russia's economy, making up almost 6% of its GDP and creating over 3.5 million jobs.
00:10:00 In this section of the CZcams video titled "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker discusses how Russia's military sector is experiencing a boom due to increased wages, leading to a labor shortage in other industries and causing wages to rise across the economy. The speaker also explains that Russia's economy is not collapsing due to the sanctions against it because of its reliance on oil and gas exports, which have seen increased profit margins due to the price spikes in the global market. The speaker uses the example of oil, which accounted for a significant portion of Russia's exports before the war, and notes that even though the quantity of oil sold may have decreased, the revenue and profit margins have remained the same or increased due to the higher prices. The speaker concludes by mentioning that Russia has replaced some of its lost trade with the EU with increased trade with countries like India and China.
00:15:00 In this section of the CZcams video titled "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker discusses how Russia's economy has not collapsed despite EU countries spending $30 billion less on Russian oil in 2023. China has made up for this loss by increasing its oil purchases from Russia by 45%, and Russia has also been using a "shadow Fleet" to sell oil to European and Indian countries without abiding by sanctions. Russia has become China's biggest supplier of oil and India's second biggest, allowing Russia to make significant revenue. However, Russia's economy still faces challenges such as a volatile currency, the transfer of money out of the country, and the depreciation of the ruble with respect to the Yuan. Despite these issues, Russia's GDP grew by 3.1% in 2023, while Ukraine's plunged by 29% and 4.9%, leading some to question if Russia's economy is truly booming.
00:20:00 In this section of the CZcams video titled "Did Russia win the war against US & EU? Economic Case Study," the speaker discusses the economic challenges Russia is currently facing due to inflation and the depreciation of the Russian Ruble against the Chinese Yuan. The highest inflation rate in Russia was 17.8% in April 2022, and as the ruble depreciates, inflation in the country increases, leading to an increase in interest rates. The speaker also notes that the Russian economy is currently being kept afloat by the war and mineral economy, but the aftermath of past wars has shown that a war boost in the economy is often followed by an economic crisis. The speaker urges India to learn from Russia's experience and adopt market-run economies, avoid relying on war for economic growth, and focus on manufacturing to take advantage of export opportunities.
It is true that about 500k to 850k people (not a million) left Russia in order to avoid being part of the war. However, by annexing Donetsk, Lughansk, and Crimea, Russia gained a few million highly motivated and loyal people. Who does the counting for you? The Foreign Affairs magazine, or maybe the Wall Street Journal which claimed that the most common Russian weapon is the shovel?
love u and your video's research
Russia is like south indian movie hero that keep standing after got shot by manny bullets 🤣🤣🤣
To @ThinkSchool for the cheap shot at 4:11 and followers / commenters who use the term German. Shepherd … Dhruv Ratew never said it’s dictatorship … he said on the spectrum it is moving towards dictatorship . Also DR in his interview with Karan Thapar said a central govt minister approached him which he rejected . Since Think school did Nitin Gadkari interview which I liked very much , in the interest of transparency please disclose if you received any money for the interview and also if the Government edited the video before it was put on CZcams .
Well why did he reject the proposal for an interview? Isn't democracy about asking the right questions and having meaningful debates? Why did he pass up on the opportunity to ask questions to the right person who can be held liable if they don't have answers when DR is front runner in supporting press freedom and bringing back press conferences? And this comment does not mean I support BJP (NOTA for life) 'cause I acknowledge the current status of Indian TV news channels being biased but you have to appreciate the good steps of the government. The coin has two faces...
@@Aman-up9ud Thanks for the response. I think DR would have accepted the offer if the second condition on Government seeing and editing the final interview was not there. If they had agreed for a live interview that would have been a different matter. But BJP is good in headline and narrative management and they dont want to venture there. All their intervirews are scripted. Again I am not a Modi hater or anything....kudos to good things like Article 370 abbrogation or Balakot strike etc. But weaking institaions , misusing agencies , Governors going bersek , laws being guzzled though parliment , expanding scope of broadcasters to include youtubers....the writing is there ...Power corrupts absolute power corrupts absolutely....
@plazameranam Well doesn't that insinuates all the other youtubers who accepted the interviews agreed to not having a final say in what was going to be public via their channels?
I agree with all of your criticism towards the government. But calling it "Dictatorship" would imply that India was never a democracy in the first place 'cause more severe misuse of power can be observed post independence.
I will do you one better with a line from one of my favourite shows 'The Boys' :
"With great power comes the absolute certainty that you'll turn into a right c--t!"😁
@@Aman-up9ud I am not calling it dictarorship but on a scale of 1 to 10 ...i will give it 7. But i slightly disagree with your intreprretation of history....Yes there was more severe misuse of power (which i would have opposed if i was alive then and people did oppose) but its a mircale that Indian demcracy survived. Look at the history of countries that became independent Congo, Zimbabawae, Pakistan Bangaldesh etc there were so many coups and miltary rules ...Indian with its diversity managed elections and democrcay is a miracle in itself I would say. But we were able to do that becuase we had several leaders of high claire in both poltics (within and outside congress)and civil life. for instance Sam Manekshaw refused to invade before monsooon when Indira Gandhi insisted. Gandhi motivated people to withstand lathicharge and do fasting....look at the claiber of people we have now...people nowadays forget lathi charge cannot even post a comment becuase they are afraid of BJP troll army. Central ministers are subserveient and dont have an iota of an original idea (except Gadakari) ...modi dominates and eclsispes all ...the oposition is clueless running around like headless chicken....so my greasted fear is India may not be able to withstand another misuse of power....just becuase it survived and didnt become dictartorship in past does not give it perpetual immunty.... even a cat has JUST NINE lives....so lets not try our luck in this election and take cautious apporach...lets given him 300 seats but not 2/3 rd so that he can not change the consitution....(some semblance of check and balance) ....a few states so that Rajya sabha acts as speed breaker.....and then see.....but if we dont caution him now ...he will run amok...that i am sure...
who is DR to interview with Karan Thaper, he is no expert in any field, we can see the neutrality of druv rathee
You may be right about Russia in a post war world. However, from what I see, USA is having a similar problem right now. The dollar is rising, inflation is rising, they are dependent on the MIC to fuel their economic growth. Their infrastructure is falling apart, their society is collapsing. Africa is standing up to them and they are unable to do anything about it.
4:13 This makes u different from others
You don't support any party, you speak the truth and facts
Thanks
Dude, in Russia they don’t control the exchange rate. All that is being done is purchasing for reserves or instructions to sell foreign exchange earnings to exporters
The main lesson for India is the understanding that you should not keep your reserves in American securities so that they are not taken away from you later :)
Firstly ,i love your content but
Dhruv never said India is under dictatorship 😂😂
He said india is heading towards it🫠
I feel it's true
You are just hearing too much conspiracy theories brother. I live in a state which is run by an opposition party to the central government and here anarchy is reaching on a high level. The state is allowing all kind of dangerous groups to become powerful just to stop the reach of central ruling party in the state from gaining a foot hold without understanding the consequences of such measures.
does that mean we vote the opposition who did bigger crime than the ruling party. I agree that BJP is wrong in some aspects but dhruv rathee is promoting the opposition AAP and INC
they have did bigger crimes than what BJP did if your eyes are open. what cong did in 60years is democracy and what BJP did in 10 years is dictatorship?🤡🤡
how so arpit rungla?
Haven't you seen news channels ??
They are full of shit !!
I don't care about dhruv but he said the true
Hey. Who isn't ? Cheer up mate, we're all in the same boat ! Everyone's heading towards more authoritarian regimes. I guess that's what happens when world tension increases !
Not gonna lie your videos are great binge worthy content. I wait for you to upload new video
Dosen't seem to me that the survival and endurance of Russian economy had anything to do with being either a market or state run economy, Russia simply needed to find new buyers for its multiple products, regardless of who produces them, and it did. A purely market run economy is most likely to let regions and people sink if they've got nothing to offer as opposed to a state run economy where the priority is the well being of the country and all of its people
Appriciate your efforts and simple explanation.
4:30 bhai but sugarcane id important for sugar mafia and modi friend Adani is one of major sugarcane purchaser in india
You can link this
Even if adani is not involved, rice and sugarcane production can't stopped by the gov cause of the insane level of consumption, rice is the staple food for southern India and sugar consumption is extremely high all across India so gov can max give awareness it can't do anything else much tbh
Do you know who owns sugar factories in karnataka? Politicians across parties.
Thanks a lot!
Gave a great perspective 👌
Before this event in Ukraine, no one in the United States thought about Ukraine and did not help with money when it needed it, even Russia lent an amount for the Ukrainian economy that it did not repay, but when the war began, the United States began to take care of them as if it were their neighbor, The USA needs a country overseas, this is their new Vietnam, they could have helped before the war with money, but for some reason they help after the start of hostilities with weapons, strange help))))
China actually run a slight trade deficit against Russia due to its importing way more raw materials than before. Which is a good thing since the trade is mostly balanced. Meanwhile Russia can’t seem to import anything of value from India 😂
out of the three problems you discussed, the first two are valid 2 years ago and the third isnt a real problem because pre war inflation and post war recession will cancel out each other
No it won't it will cause something worse called stagflation if not handled properly
You don't understand economy at all.
@@mathieusimoneau3358 bro is ur statement directed at me or the og comment? If it's mine we can discuss
@@Chaos_rider_666 No the comment is for the op who can't make the difference between deflation and recession.
@@mathieusimoneau3358 I see....
Frozen INC
accounts, broken regional parties multiple times to the point of making them irrelevant, and arrested Kejriwal.
The only meaningful opposition parties left are in WB, Kerala, TN, and Andhra. Neither of those are going to expand nationally. WB will last only for another term, after that they'll arrest Mamata on some excuse before next election. As of now, they're not able to do that only because TMC has more powerful goons on the ground.
TN/Kerala are largely irrelevant on the national stage (which is sad, but true) and they keep trying to malign Kerala's image anyway.
Believe me or not this nation is United just because of
"CONSTITUTION OF INDIA" any fatal injury to this book will result in catastrophic consequences.. if they tried to change the basic structure of constitution I don't think any one will be able to stabilize this diversity rich country..
Чисто с точки зрения "А что было бы" видео интересное, но вся шутка в том что Европа довольно успешно побеждает сама себя
Fantastic Video. I regularly watch your videos. They are full of knowledge & analysis. May God Bless You my Friend. I will always pray for you. Brilliant Explanation & Absolutely Accurate Analysis. I wish you all the best. Thank You.👍👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸🪷🪷🪷🪷🪷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹💐💐💐💐💐🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂.