The unexpected math behind Van Gogh's "Starry Night" - Natalya St. Clair

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 05. 2024
  • Check out our Patreon page: / teded
    View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/the-unexpec...
    Physicist Werner Heisenberg said, “When I meet God, I am going to ask him two questions: why relativity? And why turbulence? I really believe he will have an answer for the first.” As difficult as turbulence is to understand mathematically, we can use art to depict the way it looks. Natalya St. Clair illustrates how Van Gogh captured this deep mystery of movement, fluid and light in his work.
    Lesson by Natalya St. Clair, animation by Avi Ofer.

Komentáře • 1,8K

  • @thesilentnightingale2807
    @thesilentnightingale2807 Před 4 lety +3344

    For me 'Starry Night' looks like someone looking through tear-welled eyes

    • @leonardodavinci2230
      @leonardodavinci2230 Před 4 lety +97

      and maybe bad eyesight too

    • @patcolin2
      @patcolin2 Před 4 lety +111

      Maybe his eyes were filled with tears.

    • @shanmathi5747
      @shanmathi5747 Před 3 lety +76

      Yes once I wrote this for an art appraisal competition conducted by my English department
      And guess what
      I lost

    • @elm5433
      @elm5433 Před 3 lety +9

      @@shanmathi5747 What??? Tell me.......

    • @ajithkumar-jk1ne
      @ajithkumar-jk1ne Před 3 lety +2

      Exactly

  • @rainmiao9119
    @rainmiao9119 Před 5 lety +3800

    Van Gogh‘s mind was too beautiful for this world.

    • @drcommondrate12
      @drcommondrate12 Před 4 lety +11

      Rain Miao he was overrated tho

    • @shanaaa6009
      @shanaaa6009 Před 4 lety +32

      央礼 some “artsy” people made him overrated

    • @devilsadvocate7474
      @devilsadvocate7474 Před 4 lety +161

      @@drcommondrate12 nah he was barely recognized during the time he was alive

    • @terrry9709
      @terrry9709 Před 4 lety +53

      央礼 he is, and always will be an incredible artist though

    • @999titu
      @999titu Před 4 lety +2

      Precisy may be for us
      But maynot be for generations to come.

  • @AnnebelBuntOnline
    @AnnebelBuntOnline Před 7 lety +6821

    And in the end Van Gogh probably was like: ' oh lol this looks cool!'

    • @allardfreichmann3733
      @allardfreichmann3733 Před 7 lety +109

      A painting is never done.

    • @nusratqazi8138
      @nusratqazi8138 Před 6 lety +333

      He actually was disappointed after painting the starry night.

    • @saicharangarrepalli9590
      @saicharangarrepalli9590 Před 5 lety +130

      around Annebel He thought that painting was failure

    • @eriuphoenix
      @eriuphoenix Před 4 lety +50

      A lot of the paintings from that time period were very swirly. There was definitely something going on.

    • @999titu
      @999titu Před 4 lety +42

      He was dead in the end, posthumously appreciated
      It's a tragedy like Nietzsce and Poe.

  • @GojiraNoKyokai
    @GojiraNoKyokai Před 4 lety +2304

    “The greatness of a mind is determined by the depth of its suffering.”
    ― Hayao Miyazaki
    I wonder why society shames and ignores great artists when they are still alive and breathing, now it makes sense!

    • @recoveringsoul755
      @recoveringsoul755 Před 4 lety +25

      Well, some paints have toxic ingredients in them. Not sure if that might have contributed to the mental condition. Like Titanium white, has powdered metal in it. Probably not good to inhale. I wonder if he made his own paint colors or if they were sold somewhere?
      Or perhaps the sky looked different back then. The Scream painting was made after large volcanic activity. The sky had ash in it for a long time.

    • @CheshireCat01
      @CheshireCat01 Před 4 lety +30

      Great artists have a sensible and peculiar mind, that's why they often suffer from mental problems- because of the way they perceive things. The things that happen during their lives aren't the causes

    • @1..0w0..3
      @1..0w0..3 Před 4 lety +18

      @@CheshireCat01 *The things that happen in their lives, as well as the way they perceive it, they both play a huge role in determining their emotional state.*
      1. When you are an emotionally more sensitive person who is different than majority of people and you are born in a time period, when being different, regardless of being misunderstood, is not shunned by the society, it leads you to experience the peace of mind, merely because of being socially accepted.
      Regardless of whether you prioritize "blending in with the society's standards" or not, it does bring us happiness to have a lot of supporters.
      2. When you are an emotionally sensitive person who is different than the majority of the people around you and you are also born in a time period when difference of any kind isn't welcome, too many narrow minded people. Now people won't just "not accept" you the way you are, they won't just let you be at peace either. They'd try to change you, say you are emotionally stunted, say u aren't "normal" merely cuz they don't understand you, etc. Hence ruining your peace of mind.
      It surely does bring us pain when the society doesn't treat us normally merely because of not fitting in to their standards.
      The example 1 and 2, both involved emotionally sensitive people. They do not have a different way of perceiving things. But one has a more peaceful state of mind, because of not being bothered by the masses of people for not fitting in, which wasn't the case for the other one.
      *Only when someone practices stoicism or abstinence or something similar,* only then we can surely say that the events in their life, events caused due to where, when and who they are surrounded with, won't be a cause to their emotional issue.
      For example, monks from the ancient days to the monks in current generation. The core of their lifestyle focuses on not being strayed away by any materialistic things, one of the key things which leads to them having an extremely peaceful state of mind.
      -I'd proudly say how I'm on the path to eternal monkhood, but it isn't out of choice, hence I don't have peace 0^0-

    • @1..0w0..3
      @1..0w0..3 Před 4 lety +3

      So, being roasted since day 1 has some good benefits in the long run after all.... good, good.

    • @sampritipaul
      @sampritipaul Před 3 lety +4

      As they did to Sushant Singh Rajput

  • @lynettewood6328
    @lynettewood6328 Před 8 lety +462

    I'm an art teacher and painted his Starry Night in preparation for an art class for adults and was surprised to find out how difficult it was. But it mesmerized the students when they painted it. Everyone loved it and put their own interpretation on it. (as art should be)

    • @judithhermes9821
      @judithhermes9821 Před 2 lety +4

      As an art teacher you should know that the name of the painting is The Starry Night, not just Starry Night.

    • @spritals
      @spritals Před 2 lety +11

      What a brilliant class, I’m sure your students still get a lot out of that experience. You’ve inspired my to try it. Thanks, teach. :)

    • @austeyen5628
      @austeyen5628 Před rokem +19

      @@judithhermes9821 it doesnt matter

    • @judithhermes9821
      @judithhermes9821 Před rokem +2

      @@austeyen5628 It mattered to van Gogh. He named the painting The Starry Night. Who are you to change it? Who are you to dismiss his name?

    • @chrisjustchris8599
      @chrisjustchris8599 Před rokem +10

      @@judithhermes9821 i bet he doesnt care anymore

  • @dorothy-clarejacobs6365
    @dorothy-clarejacobs6365 Před 8 lety +3217

    I seriously doubt that Van Gogh took any of this into consideration when he painted "Starry Night." He merely looked at the starry sky and in his ill mind he saw its wonders and painted this most loved picture. I thank him for it.

    • @MelloCello7
      @MelloCello7 Před 8 lety +76

      Scientists in there questionable sanity behold the heavens and scribe what they see; there medium? Equations and theories, is there really that much of a difference?:o

    • @Kalernor
      @Kalernor Před 8 lety +247

      +Dorothy-Clare Jacobs NO way he took any of this into consideration, and that is the beauty, genius, and talent of Van Gogh. He was able to depict such a complex physical phenomenon to such a degree of accuracy through his unique perceptive eyes

    • @ZiggyZugzwang
      @ZiggyZugzwang Před 8 lety +29

      +Andy Austin I think it is called Absinthe :D. Drinking Absinthe is as close as it gets to seeing the world through van Goghs eyes. See for yourselves and watch the nightsky. But dont bring a knife to the party ;). (spoon should be fine)

    • @melozanob
      @melozanob Před 6 lety +53

      I think it wasn't intentional, but there definitely has to be something that connects this facts.
      Maybe he was able to see something else. Maybe he had a way of seeing his feelings. Who knows.

    • @sinansarikaya3662
      @sinansarikaya3662 Před 4 lety +68

      Well, yes it is broken down into mathematics and while the truth is undoubtedly that he he did not take these things into consideration, it has also to be noted that Van Gogh was very well aware of what he was drawing and not only has read but also profoundly studied the theories of art. Reducing Van Gogh to a thoughtless, ill minded drunkard does by no means do him and his works justice. But as it seems it is quite popular nowadays to reduce art to something that is no less than a spontaneous act and treat it as such.

  • @rimas1468
    @rimas1468 Před 6 lety +166

    'Starry Night' used to be my favourite painting when I was younger. But I can't remember why. Nowadays, when I look at the painting through old postcards friends and relatives have sent me, knowing of my love for the painting, I feel nothing. And that makes me feel unbelievably sad. It makes me feel more robotic than human.

    • @navdeeps3432
      @navdeeps3432 Před 4 lety +28

      Maybe you just need to see the original one more time

    • @pallabidutta968
      @pallabidutta968 Před 3 lety +8

      Maybe the rapport you share with your friends and relatives have changed over the years.

    • @dragonofepics7324
      @dragonofepics7324 Před 3 lety +17

      rimas14 I don’t think it looks as good small. Maybe you need to get a bigger version, or hold the postcards up to your face. Lots of things feel less powerful for me than when I was young. I feel like it’s because I’m not literally looking up at them anymore. When you look up at something instead of even with it, you feel a lot smaller and it feels a lot bigger. I think being bigger than when I was a kid is a part of it. Now I’m even with most the stuff I look at instead of being below it.

    • @Chirp-chirp
      @Chirp-chirp Před 3 lety +10

      I think because you've seen it one too many times. And your reaching so hard trying to love it that u end up not loving it. Also, it's very overrated in postcards and stuff.

    • @Apples765
      @Apples765 Před 2 lety +4

      Hey, try looking at " the cafe terrace at night "
      It always makes me feel so cozy and calm

  • @crixxxxxxxxx
    @crixxxxxxxxx Před 8 lety +3146

    I learned that scientists in Mexico wear sombreros and ponchos and those in Spain dress like flamenco dancers.

    • @ibrahinmenriquez3108
      @ibrahinmenriquez3108 Před 8 lety +108

      stereotypes? Where? hahaha

    • @amyreesor8128
      @amyreesor8128 Před 8 lety +5

      LOL

    • @alex91had
      @alex91had Před 8 lety +128

      +crixxxxxxxxx Russian mathematician at 2:08 should have a vodka in his left hand and an ak47 on his right hand ;p

    • @elifante
      @elifante Před 8 lety +53

      +crixxxxxxxxx And those of England suitcases, umbrellas and hats, though a monocle was missing there lol

    • @Melicioel7
      @Melicioel7 Před 8 lety +27

      +Elizabeth Ochoa But he does have a monocle! 3:11

  • @bellaportilla7
    @bellaportilla7 Před 9 lety +395

    "For my part I know nothing with any certainty, but the sight of the stars makes me dream."
    That's why he's one of my favourite artists - such an unassuming genius.

    • @Mgtr14
      @Mgtr14 Před 4 lety +1

      He admitted in that same sentence that he isn't very knowledgeable. Why do you still think he's a genius?

    • @srishtichaudhary3580
      @srishtichaudhary3580 Před 4 lety +16

      @@Mgtr14 only truly intelligent people can say that they don't know much.

    • @Mgtr14
      @Mgtr14 Před 4 lety +1

      @@srishtichaudhary3580 I'd say that it's always given that one's knowledge has it's limits. Van Gogh makes it sound like he doesn't know much at all.

    • @marlenna215
      @marlenna215 Před 4 lety +8

      I think a true genius knows that they don’t kno everything. Information is infinite

    • @poebz
      @poebz Před 4 lety +4

      @@Mgtr14 Then same can be said for Socrates. And you know what, you're completely right. I know everything, so I'm the most genius of all. Must be true, because I say so.

  • @KidsWithGuns1992
    @KidsWithGuns1992 Před 9 lety +293

    Hold on hold on hold on, I'm obviously a dumb ass cause I don't quite get it. This was essentially saying that "turbulence" is the way in which a certain kind of matter unpredictably/chaoticaly moves, or flows, and we have since been able to theorize an equation that estimates the structure in which turbulance moves or will move?
    And Vincent Van Gogh's starry night somehow visually represents very closely this equation?

  • @Segkee
    @Segkee Před 7 lety +794

    "The cracked mind lets in light the whole mind cannot see." - R.D. Laing

    • @1..0w0..3
      @1..0w0..3 Před 4 lety +5

      Once we see one too many memes related to the word "crack", quotes like that hit on a different level >x"D

    • @vinayseth1114
      @vinayseth1114 Před 4 lety +2

      That sounds like a horrible appropriation of Leonard Cohen's lyric.

    • @lynnpurse
      @lynnpurse Před 2 lety +2

      R.D. Laing was a psychiatrist who had a unique perspective on mental illness and most likely influenced Leonard Cohen, not the other way round.

  • @cinema.zipfile
    @cinema.zipfile Před 8 lety +287

    Vinny, you poor little man. You've suffered so much. May your soul rest in peace.

    • @karphin1
      @karphin1 Před 4 měsíci

      I agree, I feel so much for him, in his struggle. Went to Arles and saw some places he painted, also, went to the sanitarium, St. Paul de Mausole where he stayed after the ear incident. Looked out of the window in his room. Powerful moments for me. Am grateful to have been where he’d been.

  • @mkolnay
    @mkolnay Před 8 lety +426

    the sadness will last forever

    • @miranuzeri979
      @miranuzeri979 Před 8 lety +14

      indeed...

    • @jakubzajac8585
      @jakubzajac8585 Před 5 lety +5

      And then is the question, is it indeed worthy to be extraordinary?

    • @1..0w0..3
      @1..0w0..3 Před 4 lety +6

      @@jakubzajac8585 Being _extraordinary_ is better than being _ordinary._
      As being _alive_ with pain is still better than just _living._

    • @jakubzajac8585
      @jakubzajac8585 Před 4 lety +3

      Beautiful answer.@@1..0w0..3

  • @kristinacatherine5121
    @kristinacatherine5121 Před 7 lety +1782

    It's like C.S. Lewis wrote, "God whispers to us in our pleasures, speaks in our consciences, but shouts in our pains."

  • @ak.zilani2001
    @ak.zilani2001 Před 5 lety +152

    “Be clearly aware of the stars and infinity on high. Then life seems almost enchanted after all.”
    ― Vincent Van Gogh

  • @thecuriousnerd3396
    @thecuriousnerd3396 Před 8 lety +750

    when you first thought van gogh's "starry night" and "the scream" were just a painting. then you watch this. thinking maybe he went crazy because he is too smart.

    • @TheDictismiT
      @TheDictismiT Před 8 lety +69

      Van Gogh didnt paint The Scream lol

    • @gfddgbjtfdssxcvg
      @gfddgbjtfdssxcvg Před 8 lety +54

      I don't think it is really what one would call "smartness". I bet that he painted this pattern intuitively. Wouldn't be surprised at all if this pattern occurs in our own brains or at least can be "sensed" by our brains in an instinctive way. Maybe birds or fish need it when encountering such turbulence in the air or the water. Life came from fluids, life is full of fluids, and fluids are often turbulent.

    • @splootenist163
      @splootenist163 Před 6 lety +21

      Jacob Sode
      Edward Munch is the painter of "The scream" not Van Gogh. ;-;

    • @tinkervelz1811
      @tinkervelz1811 Před 5 lety +17

      he wasn't crazy he's ill. u just cant call someone crazy, no reservations. done. case closed.

    • @devinfahada4880
      @devinfahada4880 Před 4 lety +4

      He know things that he can't explained

  • @shuanggao3710
    @shuanggao3710 Před 9 lety +455

    There is no strict line between art and science. The line lies in psychology.

    • @shuanggao3710
      @shuanggao3710 Před 9 lety +7

      I have never known Van Gogh could be talented in this way!

    • @purvijain2306
      @purvijain2306 Před 5 lety +2

      Wow

    • @lyingeyes5579
      @lyingeyes5579 Před 4 lety +27

      Art is a combination of psychological strategies through the medium of use which is ultimately the technical science behind it to communicate a visual message, which is either personally interpreted or universally recognized (or both). Coming from an Art Degree student. Van Gogh legacy lives in all artists today when interpretating their work. You should always underline the personal and universally recognized meaning behind it.

    • @pallabidutta968
      @pallabidutta968 Před 3 lety +16

      Art is personal yet universal. Science is general and impersonal. Psychology is the objective take on the subjective states of our mind. Hopefully that made sense.

    • @Apples765
      @Apples765 Před 2 lety +1

      @@lyingeyes5579 👏👏

  • @willferrous8677
    @willferrous8677 Před 9 lety +320

    Now I understand what you tried to say to me. How you suffered for your sanity. How you tried to set them free. They would not listen, they did not know how. Perhaps they'll listen now.

    • @freesk8
      @freesk8 Před 9 lety +11

      Don McClean.

    • @xj-vn4eo
      @xj-vn4eo Před 5 lety +8

      And so I sing along.

    • @stevenethanlimanta1080
      @stevenethanlimanta1080 Před 5 lety +17

      Now i understand what you tried to say to me. And how you suffered for your sanity. And how you tried to set them free. They would not listen, their not listening still. Perhaps they never will

    • @onemercilessming1342
      @onemercilessming1342 Před 4 lety +3

      Will Ferrous--There is an art program that was used about 15 years ago in the district in which I taught (retired now). It brought together literature, art, music, poetry, vocabulary, and an art technique. Van Gogh's "Starry Night" was one of the units and Don McLean's song was featured in the unit. After teaching that unit, I loved the song even more than when it first aired on my local radio station in 1971.

    • @mariaelenacruzflores5920
      @mariaelenacruzflores5920 Před 4 lety +1

      Yes of course

  • @user-ri7nl9xb5b
    @user-ri7nl9xb5b Před 8 lety +3614

    it's not pronounced Van "go" or "goff" it's pronounced Van GOCHKHFGSKSFJSVS *chokes*

    • @maxg4962
      @maxg4962 Před 8 lety +35

      +boo rants I loled to hard at this

    • @Pentenemy
      @Pentenemy Před 8 lety +75

      +The Beatbox god you laughed out louded to hard at this?

    • @maxg4962
      @maxg4962 Před 8 lety +5

      Amookoo Hykera fuckin oath mate

    • @AngieGandalf6
      @AngieGandalf6 Před 8 lety +50

      +boo rants People in Holland laughted at me when I tried to pronouce Van Gogh...

    • @SingaporeSkaterSam
      @SingaporeSkaterSam Před 8 lety +10

      +boo rants I've had the exact same lecture from some mad Dutch woman I've not seen since. I still go with Goff...

  • @lambadajewo.4143
    @lambadajewo.4143 Před rokem +12

    I know that this is old, but I realized - for some reason, Van Gogh's art helps me clear my mind when my mental health is really poor. It's strange, considering his tragic story. But for a reason I do not comprehend, it soothes me.

    • @AlexR333
      @AlexR333 Před 9 měsíci +1

      Not strange. Van Gogh may have actually seen things more clearly, and beyond the surfaces, than many realized (according to the video Physicist, among others).
      Clarity is a relief, in a world of confusing noise; just another wonderul ripple effect of his genius.
      I find his nighttime paintings particularly calming.

    • @jeannemurray1046
      @jeannemurray1046 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Yes, I'm drawn to it in my way also

  • @robertschlesinger1342
    @robertschlesinger1342 Před 5 lety +29

    Interesting that during van Gogh's periods of so-called psychosis, he also apparently had lucid insights into certain aspects of nature. This sort of deep insight during a psychological episode may be much more common than commonly thought. I can think of such examples from music, literature, poetry, art, and even mathematics. It has been said (by an ex-Harvard psychologist from the mid-60s) that to learn how to use your mind, you must first go out of your mind!

  • @JS-vp6wg
    @JS-vp6wg Před 7 lety +18

    When I was doing van gogh for my artist research I hated his style because it took so long to do but it really helped me to get top marks with only an a4 piece and now I'm coming to realise why his work is so great and I even somewhat still use his style because it's amazing

  • @sandrabuck-camp6521
    @sandrabuck-camp6521 Před 3 lety +6

    Van Gogh was epileptic. Treatment for epilepsy in his time was digitalis. His 'hallucinations", "episodes of 'mania'", were directly attributed to digitalis overdosing! I am so very saddened for him and his family, especially Theo, his brother, who basically supported him and appreciated his art. Van Gogh produced well in excess of 3,000 drawings and works of art! Most, paintings are priceless works of true art. I was blessed to view in person "Starry Night" when it was on display at "MOMA' in NYC July, 2017. During July, 2018, my pleasure was a trip to The Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam, Netherlands which houses many of his more famous pieces of art. I was and continue to be amazed that the masterpieces are not well protected from visitors -- only a thin rope 18 to 24 inches high two feet from each wall on which the masterpieces hang separate the art from visitors. I noticed the museum guards were not very attentive to the possibilities of visitors reaching out to touch the paintings themselves ... No matter, I enjoyed the visits to MOMA as well as The Van Gogh Museum itself.

    • @judyhermes6256
      @judyhermes6256 Před 10 měsíci +1

      Where to start. Van Gogh was not epileptic (Google it...) but was given digitalis to address what were psychiatric issues that were thought to be epilepsy. He suffered from a number of psychiatric issues. His brother Theo, an art dealer in Paris,, completely (not "basically") supported Vincent during the 10 years that he was painting. Van Gogh produced nearly 1000 works of art - about one every 3 days (not 3000 paintings, which would have been about one a day!) .....the name of the painting is THE Starry Night not just Starry NIght and it is owned and permanently on display at MOMA (unless MOMA takes it down for some reason). Sorry to be a schoolmarm here, but...facts are facts and the mis-statements about Van Gogh are everywhere, and, here, too many to ignore..

  • @dvd11811
    @dvd11811 Před 5 lety +5

    Van Gogh is my favorite artist ... his paintings not only captured the time and space of the eternal moment, but the energy as well ... this is most apparent in The Starry Night ... and is what gives life and meaning to his beautiful works ... Thank you Vincent !!!

  • @maitranthanh
    @maitranthanh Před 9 lety +270

    Craziness is not as crazy as it seems. It's genius!

    • @gustavle6613
      @gustavle6613 Před 7 lety +4

      oui

    • @gustavle6613
      @gustavle6613 Před 7 lety +4

      yes

    • @pratikshyamohapatra
      @pratikshyamohapatra Před 4 lety +1

      Comment of the century....

    • @ivanbrkan8611
      @ivanbrkan8611 Před 4 lety +1

      Yea that murderer that went crazy? NAHHHH hes just genius

    • @Chirp-chirp
      @Chirp-chirp Před 3 lety

      @Rs Ok i agree with the first bit but bro. Some people like psychopaths and sociopaths and the like are born that way. Some people with mental illnesses made themselves that way. I hate how people think like you. 😐

  • @riverfare2847
    @riverfare2847 Před 7 lety +379

    It's 9am and I'm crying.

    • @c0smogon
      @c0smogon Před 7 lety +38

      I thought i was the only one who cried watching it. High five ✋ 😊

    • @13222222221
      @13222222221 Před 7 lety +5

      +Catarina Xavier I cried too..is so beautiful

    • @melozanob
      @melozanob Před 6 lety +4

      i cried too

    • @shanisarathchndra5284
      @shanisarathchndra5284 Před 5 lety +1

      it is 3 pm and I know the pain

    • @justanotherbohemian3827
      @justanotherbohemian3827 Před 5 lety +3

      Awww...I'll come and hug you....wait, this was two years ago...probably this hug will be useless now....

  • @housephone8646
    @housephone8646 Před 8 lety +476

    His minds eye must of saw a lot of weird shit

  • @trinityfrank2526
    @trinityfrank2526 Před 8 lety +53

    The real truth: Van Gogh just suffered from migraines, which made him dizzy.

    • @richardsun6435
      @richardsun6435 Před 8 lety +2

      +Trinity Frank probably the most likely conclusion

    • @spookyboi6219
      @spookyboi6219 Před 8 lety +1

      +Trinity Frank he also had constant beating noises going off like a bell in his head , how do you explain that, HUH?!

  • @caffeinatedinsomniac9298
    @caffeinatedinsomniac9298 Před 3 lety +18

    This video gave me goosebumps. Van Gogh was a genius and the way he was treated by society for being so ahead of his time is saddening. Van Gogh was according to me one of the most beautiful souls to ever have lived and he deserved so much better than what he got.

  • @martinamancuso2274
    @martinamancuso2274 Před 8 lety +6

    I think in this video there's the sadness and the beautifull story about an artist. Thank u so much.

  • @cardinalhamneggs5253
    @cardinalhamneggs5253 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Van Gogh is one of my favorite artists, and _Starry Night_ is one of my favorite paintings. Seeing him in _Doctor Who_ and playing as him in _Cube Escape: Arles_ just solidifies that fact for me.

  • @janmaaso
    @janmaaso Před 3 lety +4

    One small point: Munch did not depict movement at all in "Skrik", he quite accurately depicted standing lenticular clouds lit up by a setting sun. I used to watch this phenomenon from my kitchen window in Oslo, not far from where the scene was painted. It is actually a very realistic depiction of how it can look at times, which is to say that it does not look real at all.

  • @CiliophoraEuplotes
    @CiliophoraEuplotes Před 9 lety +48

    Interesting content but I don't really like the flickering images, it felt like the video was forcing me to accept that the images should feel dynamical to the eyes without giving me a chance to judge myself. Specially the paintings which are supposed to feel dynamical by themselves.
    That aside, the connections between the concepts presented are beautiful.

  • @kaykap7
    @kaykap7 Před 9 lety +8

    I just keep on falling in love with Van Gogh's art, stories and even wretchednesses!

  • @juanli4153
    @juanli4153 Před rokem +3

    The narration for this though, the descriptions are beautiful.

  • @augustvalek
    @augustvalek Před 5 lety

    I always find myself amazed at the end of your videos, well done TED, well done

  • @gina2he
    @gina2he Před 7 lety +60

    Van Goth was treated for epilepsy with digitalis which can cause a yellow green tint in vision and yellow spots surrounded by coronas. This may have been why he made Starry night, because that's how he saw the sky on medication. Well that's the theory anyways.

    • @v3le
      @v3le Před 4 lety +1

      Dr Gachet probably gave him some macrodoses of psilocybin

  • @yurisucupira
    @yurisucupira Před 9 lety +11

    [português / portuguese]
    Agora o meu pintor favorito é ainda mais favorito!
    [english / inglês]
    Now my favourite painter is even more my favourite painter!

  • @Meow_yj
    @Meow_yj Před 3 lety +2

    Animation and everything is so beautiful in this !♡

  • @kendrabrecka279
    @kendrabrecka279 Před 8 lety +21

    I firmly believe that what was depicted in the Doctor Who episode "Vincent and the Doctor" was true and is a legitimate portrayal of reality. That's all.

  • @craiginzana
    @craiginzana Před 9 lety +12

    Anyone else think this is proof that certain artists see the world in a way that we do not? Maybe perceive things that the normal mind blocks out? Perhaps he didn't understand the concept of turbulence, but was able to paint it so articulately because he just saw it all around him.

  • @ACkive
    @ACkive Před 4 lety +9

    Indeed like the song suggest:
    "This world was never meant for one as beautiful as you"

  • @PotaytoDestroyer
    @PotaytoDestroyer Před 4 lety +1

    all of these videos leave me with a warm and fuzzy feeling inside and a much sharper brain ..... thanks for making these ... i love you guys ...

  • @hannahmichaels9992
    @hannahmichaels9992 Před 7 lety +5

    combining art and science. two of my favorite things.

  • @blanchekonieczka9935
    @blanchekonieczka9935 Před 5 lety +64

    Amazing how a turbulent mind was able to translate turbulence onto a canvas.

    • @prakhargupta3949
      @prakhargupta3949 Před rokem +2

      He did the impossible even after so much of torment. Such a great soul he had.

  • @kiron84
    @kiron84 Před 4 lety +3

    Beautifully animated, Avi! 🙂 👍🏻

  • @AdnanAli-iz8ln
    @AdnanAli-iz8ln Před 4 lety +8

    Van gogh: draws the perfect turbulence patterns during his moment of genius
    Animator: does it for a TED-ED video

  • @jennazhang4927
    @jennazhang4927 Před 8 lety +2

    I am always in love with the painting "starry night ".

  • @carriepearson6643
    @carriepearson6643 Před 9 měsíci +4

    I believe Vincent van Gogh saw things differently than other people. He was so profoundly different that it cost him his sanity. Starry Night has long been and will always be my favorite paining. VVG is my 2nd favorite artist. God is my favorite artist. He gives us daily masterpieces to look at. How fortunate we are to seem them, feel them, hear them and know them.

  • @MidnightSt
    @MidnightSt Před 9 lety +30

    I understand the point in making the video's images "flicker", and it's interesting, but DAMN, is it hard at the eyes after the first two minutes!

  • @mmmk1616
    @mmmk1616 Před 5 lety

    The concept of turbulence, this way, had never been explained to me like this, I just came from their new video "Turbulence: one of the great unsolved mysteries of physics" posted on April 15, 2019. Excellent videos! Thank you!

  • @davidkennedy6022
    @davidkennedy6022 Před 4 lety +2

    This is my favorite painting I painted a nice one in 1st grade art class . Wish I still had it !

  • @drew2pac
    @drew2pac Před 9 lety +7

    This was honestly fascinating..... Really really awesome!

  • @ujjwalsevra2249
    @ujjwalsevra2249 Před 4 lety +10

    "Math is always unexpected." ~ Some great person

  • @dylanbrusstar6646
    @dylanbrusstar6646 Před 5 lety

    Having delt w mental episodes, I can completely understand the contrast in his works. The brain is on another level in a manic episode, it’s a trip, I wish I had time to put it into words.

  • @isabellafelipedeoliveiraca6698

    The Starry Night is gorgeous, but have you stopped to appreciate his 1887 Self-Portrait (the one that is in the Art Institute of Chicago)? It's a perfect painting!

  • @mrwhitemantv
    @mrwhitemantv Před 7 lety +23

    Van Gogh reminds me of Thom Yorke

  • @literatureandlife
    @literatureandlife Před 2 lety +3

    Whoever animated these concepts is really a great animator!!

  • @nathanyleal
    @nathanyleal Před 4 lety

    Thanks for this beautiful video and animation!

  • @alzofonphysics3834
    @alzofonphysics3834 Před 6 lety +1

    My late father, Dr. Frederick Alzofon, was fascinated by the mathematics of turbulence. He published an original solution to the exact problem discussed here in 1996 (in a refereed journal). He was retired at the time and not connected with a university, so his solution didn't attract as much notice as it might have otherwise, but it IS a complete solution, nonetheless. Bibliographic reference: “The Transition to Turbulent Fluid Flow,” Journal of Wave-Material Interaction, 11 (1996) 234-244. In principle it is not difficult to understand, but the math gets a bit tricky after that. If you are a physicist, you might find it interesting.

  • @michaeldedios7866
    @michaeldedios7866 Před 7 lety +133

    who else almost had a seizure throughout the entire video.

  • @TheKrensada
    @TheKrensada Před 8 lety +4431

    Never has a video said so much while saying absolutely nothing at all.

    • @whirlpool4
      @whirlpool4 Před 7 lety +329

      watch anything Trump has said...

    • @boxmike2003
      @boxmike2003 Před 7 lety +27

      +whirlpool4 lol agree bout trump

    • @spacecorpse3212
      @spacecorpse3212 Před 7 lety +5

      the idependent party sound pritty good right now

    • @Chew1964
      @Chew1964 Před 7 lety +61

      This video is what happens when liberal arts majors are allowed to believe they are smart.

    • @danhatman3538
      @danhatman3538 Před 7 lety +18

      Any Arts Major*

  • @davidgreen5994
    @davidgreen5994 Před 6 lety +1

    Van Gogh was always one of my favorite artists, ut now after this I am seeig him in a totally different light.... thank you.

  • @andriasovstore
    @andriasovstore Před 5 lety

    An incredible effect of the circular wind, combined with the general ascension from lower left to right, makes this a geometrical masterpiece.

  • @henrysheerwater9024
    @henrysheerwater9024 Před 2 lety +3

    My old Dad was an engineer, but actually more interested in pure maths. In his last years, he was interested in the maths of another manifestation of turbulence: the formation of mackerel sky clouds. He told me that he "got a result". I think this means that he felt he came closer describing the mathematical relationship between mackerel skies and the cold front which comes after them.

  • @thazerozero4063
    @thazerozero4063 Před 7 lety +13

    This video reminded me of the Doctor Who episode with van Gogh, and that makes me sad

  • @Redorgreenful
    @Redorgreenful Před 7 lety +1

    Mental illness is terrible to go through. Especially mania & hallucinations. This man, like other great artists, never lived to see their genius being recognized. I hope he's in a better place now. RIP

  • @kitcoffey7194
    @kitcoffey7194 Před 2 lety

    This animation is simply stunning!

  • @AtlasInTheWest
    @AtlasInTheWest Před 8 lety +37

    He actually only lost his earlobe in a sword fight, and swore his friend to secrecy.

    • @devinobrien9241
      @devinobrien9241 Před 8 lety +3

      I was just about to write that.

    • @TheOrderOfThePurple
      @TheOrderOfThePurple Před 7 lety +4

      Actually, newly discovered historical evidence (a letter from a worker at the place where he admitted himself) shows exactly where he cut his ear off - and its all of it.

    • @gondametzger6146
      @gondametzger6146 Před 7 lety

      Devin O'Brien same

    • @AtlasInTheWest
      @AtlasInTheWest Před 7 lety

      ThePurple
      huh...

    • @Crgb777
      @Crgb777 Před 7 lety

      real Van Gogh fans stand up 🙌🙌

  • @UATU.
    @UATU. Před 5 lety +17

    I have visual impairments that cause me to see flowing type of kaleidoscopes similar to Van Gogh’s swirls. I wish I could paint them like he did. I wonder if he could have had a bit of neural path damage along with psychiatric symptoms.

    • @alicedoors4826
      @alicedoors4826 Před 4 lety +2

      Found this comment so I think you may be onto something:
      Georgina Tuohy
      "Van Goth was treated for epilepsy with digitalis which can cause a yellow green tint in vision and yellow spots surrounded by coronas. This may have been why he made Starry night, because that's how he saw the sky on medication. Well that's the theory anyways."
      Thanks for sharing!

  • @florenciagaita2959
    @florenciagaita2959 Před 3 lety +1

    this video is so visually pleasing

  • @tubermind
    @tubermind Před 5 měsíci

    Great job, Addison!!

  • @delta3352
    @delta3352 Před 4 lety +68

    Off topic:
    As a Dutch person it kind of annoys me how English people pronounce van Gogh 😂

    • @esmeeteeuw1264
      @esmeeteeuw1264 Před 4 lety +3

      Same! En dan gaan andere Engels talige mensen zeggen dat het "van Goff" is, denkend dat ze slim zijn en het goed hebben. Hoe moeilijk is het om gewoon op te zoeken hoe het in het Nederlands klinkt

    • @TheCamillo4ka
      @TheCamillo4ka Před 4 lety +6

      And what's the right way, please? Can you make a transcription?

    • @shamimamiri9513
      @shamimamiri9513 Před 4 lety +3

      TheCamillo4ka paste his name (van Gogh) in google translate(Dutch) and listen to it.

    • @TheCamillo4ka
      @TheCamillo4ka Před 4 lety +2

      The google translator says [hoh]. Correct pronounciation? In Russian we say smth between [gok] and [gog] :-)

    • @shamimamiri9513
      @shamimamiri9513 Před 4 lety

      TheCamillo4ka yeah but it’s not correct. Change the language to Dutch and then listen to it. Hope you find it :)

  • @Aantara.
    @Aantara. Před rokem +3

    It's wonderful that the animation is inspired by Van Gogh's art 💫

  • @9647245626
    @9647245626 Před 4 lety

    The more I watch this channel & more I learn that I have learnt nothing. Loved your work.

  • @antonio_universenergy
    @antonio_universenergy Před 2 lety

    Espetacular!!! Muitíssimo obrigado por este belo conteúdo!!! =D

  • @almostThere_xx
    @almostThere_xx Před 3 lety +19

    Sushant had this van gogh painting on his twiiter cover, both of men died mysteriously and painfully.

  • @LaurenBasamot
    @LaurenBasamot Před 7 lety +5

    Interesting ! 😊🎨

  • @milenaoliveira1492
    @milenaoliveira1492 Před 6 lety +2

    Wow, que vídeo lindo! Tanto pela parte física, quanto criativa e empatica ♡ Contemplando um ótimo dia na minha vida!

  • @shauna-mariehenry9448
    @shauna-mariehenry9448 Před 6 lety

    This makes me so emotional. It's beauty is undeniable.

  • @DavidGarcia-nw3xu
    @DavidGarcia-nw3xu Před 7 lety +4

    Watch this video with your phone on your lap. Now shake your leg left to right and be amazed.

  • @TheAssassin409
    @TheAssassin409 Před 8 lety +7

    this video feels like that time when my high school English teacher tried explaining to me what the author meant through his symbolism and motifs. maybe you're just looking into it too far. i doubt van gogh sat and though... ill make a painting based around the equations of turbulence that havnt been discovered yet!

    • @kylemiller2414
      @kylemiller2414 Před 3 lety +1

      To know what a man knows you must be that man. Some ppl truly need inspiration to create. Maybe rudimentary math was a talent he possessed.

  • @petermcmurray2807
    @petermcmurray2807 Před rokem

    This makes the most sense I have ever come across. It fits perfectly with Music that is simply the turbulence of air and responds most strongly with the 5:3 ratio.

  • @thymotube
    @thymotube Před 7 lety +2

    great video. really interesting.

  • @whatsupdonkey
    @whatsupdonkey Před 7 lety +64

    did van gogh mean to make his painting this mathematical?

    • @jasmineevans5686
      @jasmineevans5686 Před 7 lety +6

      Derpy Waffle I would believe he did, as he was a very very intelligent man.

    • @Xplorer228
      @Xplorer228 Před 7 lety +26

      No. Most certainly not. Jasmine Evans doesn't know what she's talking about.

    • @solitaryreaper4592
      @solitaryreaper4592 Před 7 lety +5

      It doesn't matter really.

    • @jasmineevans5686
      @jasmineevans5686 Před 7 lety +6

      mossy1 no one knows, but you would assume so seeing he was very smart? But there's no point arguing seeing he's dead and we will never know

    • @Xplorer228
      @Xplorer228 Před 7 lety +8

      Jasmine Evans My nephew draws light in almost the same exact way. Plenty of kids do. There's only a couple of ways to illustrate radiating light and this is one of them. Van Gogh wasn't a mathematician.
      And there's a saying about those who make assumptions..

  • @dard1515
    @dard1515 Před 7 lety +32

    An episode of Doctor Who also explains this, though not as explicitly.

  • @tdgtwo850
    @tdgtwo850 Před rokem

    I first seen this painting in a restaurant and actually made me fascinated by visual art

  • @clover5923
    @clover5923 Před 7 lety

    it's 3:18am and I'm binge watching Ted-ed because I can't sleep. Maybe this is why the first time I saw Van Gogh's Starry Night, I was so attracted to it because it explains something in my brain that I can't seem to explain. I've always looked at the world like Van Gogh's paintings.

  • @brandondriver1377
    @brandondriver1377 Před 8 lety +4

    The Psychotic reaction of a lover scorn results in creation of a legendary painting that unknowingly visualizes a complex process in mathematics.
    Thanks Ted!

  • @robinboyle5786
    @robinboyle5786 Před 3 lety +4

    The other thing I notice about Van Gogh's paintings is the play of light off objects. I'm lucky enough to have lived in Paris for a year, I spent every day in the art museums looking at his work. I was able to walk right up to canvasses and could have touched them (I didn't). Heart droppingly incredible brush strokes, light, color. I want to know where he found a gun in the asylum dammit. 😣

  • @brissaayala107
    @brissaayala107 Před 6 lety

    This is one of the most amazing paintings i have ever seen

  • @gandalvar
    @gandalvar Před 2 lety

    Great video!

  • @Wholelotta..
    @Wholelotta.. Před 4 lety +4

    artist: imma color this with love and color and a sprinkle of compassion
    math teachers:but wait its not just a painting

  • @nemoexperiences1734
    @nemoexperiences1734 Před 7 lety +4

    Holy fuckers watching TedX video's high IS THE SHIIIIT

  • @kirokuan1525
    @kirokuan1525 Před 2 lety +1

    Van Gogh is quite productive artist. Starry star is like other subject, sunflowers or himself he drew it repeatedly. Although he can't draw it at night, he still memorize the scene and then apply turbulence so precisely.

  • @glencram
    @glencram Před 5 lety

    Very cool and interesting video!

  • @thedarknight5714
    @thedarknight5714 Před 9 lety +6

    0:58 That is incorrect he lost his ear in a sword fight...

  • @rchelitk8447
    @rchelitk8447 Před 6 lety +8

    Crazy people have pure hearts

  • @bunbury4620
    @bunbury4620 Před 5 lety

    Beautifully written!

  • @salvadoriilegaspi7649
    @salvadoriilegaspi7649 Před 4 lety

    i like ted ed i learned a lot because of the animation the good visual , thnks