@@LudiCrust. His trophy cabinet says different. You don't become the most successful captain at one of the biggest clubs in the world without leadership skills.
Keanes leadership was through fear whether his teammates want to admit it or not. That's not real leadership and is old hat now and wouldn't work in this era.
So apparently Roy Keane is a representative of a certain English culture? Nah mate, he's just a person that doesn't get carried away in sensationalism like most pundits do. You need someone like that to remind you of reality sometimes, sure it can be a bit negative, but I rather a guy like that on my team than a guy who praises you for getting a simple pass right.
It's called brutal honesty and it's in short supply nowaday's. It's refreshing to hear unfiltered honesty regardless of offending snowflakes in a world full of woke superficiality.
@@otey7326 when has he ever made that admission in his punditry? I'm sure terrible things were said many times in the tunnel, during games, during players careers but what you can't do is shame Roy for being a people pleaser or playing to the gallery. He knows what he thinks and says it and I respect that.
@@adamyeejy-sk9fh Hes never said it in his punditry obviously, why would he? Hes said it in his book though. I don't like people pleasers either and respect the honesty but he is now portrayed as this really laid back fella with a dry sense of humour. People have got short memories.
Jesse highlighted the main issue with football and the world in general now, he said thats not our truth, there is no our or their truth, the truth is the truth in football, the eyes don't lie and roy calls it as he see's it, if people can't handle being critiqued their in the wrong game
@mytmt1613 I don't think its keane. I'd say it's the soft new age players. He had 2 good years, but I agree that his punditry sets his management prospects back as he's too honest.
Excuses and blame he says. That's why you'll never a be a good manager. Go and tell alex ferguson that being honest and truthful doesn't win titles. What a muppet
I think he knows what nationality Roy Keane is, he’s simply making a point about English culture, cuz you know, Roy is a part of that culture. 🙄 If you actually bothered to watch the whole thing he actually comes off as one of the least arrogant people Simon’s had on there.
@@BourbonJRA If he knows what nationality Keane is, then maybe he'd get a clue that the cutting kind of punditry he's on about isn't uniquely English at all. If anything, Irish or Scottish pundits are much more that way inclined than the English. His bitterness is because US culture is so much the opposite. Maybe he's better off staying over there!
At no point does he say Roy Keane is English, he's on about the culture of English people who are watching him . Try paying attention before talking bollocks
Um I watched that game mate, he's right. Not his fault that the team couldn't kick the ball into the back of the net. I'm an Arsenal fan and Leeds should have won that game
@brianguthrie3196 no it's not his fault, but not putting blame where it lies is useless. I could manage a team better than him. How can you say unlucky to someone missing easy chances and getting paid thousands for it?
So if this guy was a school teacher, he'd give kids a medal for taking part? Nothing wrong with trying to improve or telling the players who were bad that they were bad. Good way to stay mediocre
I think that's good for their self esteem though. The chance of school kids becoming professional athletes is almost zero so why be negative? You're watching too.much CZcams where everyone is a star
I really like Roy Keane and he of course isn’t English but Jesse is right here in the difference of cultures. We’re always down on ourself whereas Americans back themselves.
What difference does it make? Roy’s apparent negativity brought him great success in the game whereas Marsch’s ability to “believe in himself” got him the sack at Leeds within 2 years
@Ooth9999 He wasn't negative as a player. Hated losing would do what it takes to win games. A bit negative as a coach, fell out with players, wasn't offered big jobs as a coach. Can't adapt to some of the 'modern' players and has my sympathy for that. Good pundit but a lot of Sky Sports and other sports commentary is clickbait negativity to increase their audience for advertisers.
@@Ooth9999Why do people act as though United won things due to Roy Keane? The team won more without him did it not. Admitting that you want to end someone's career is something that is admirable in your opinion? What is wrong with people.
@@otey7326 lmfao what? When did I say that United won trophies solely because of Keane?. I said that Keane had a lot of success in his career. Also when did I say that him saying he wanted to end someone’s career was admirable? Lmao what are you on
@@Ooth9999 Youre putting someone down by comparing JM's manegerial stint to Roy Keane winning trophies which were mainly won by Ferguson and the rest of the team. A fair comparison would be against Roy Keane's managerial career - we all know what happened there
It’s okay. I think Marsch is an asshole. At least Keane won something. Playing at Princeton when he did means Marsch could play on an average high school team today. His ego has no reality check.
Roy Keane is on these shows due to his humour and put downs, it's like a sitcom. If you actually listened to his punditry, its some of the worst i have ever heard. He literally knows nothing about the modern game but is TV gold.
Roy Keane ruled Man United dressing room by fear reason he couldn't make it in management times have changed. However as pundit find him one of the best & honest no b.s unlike a lot other pundits.
It’s funny but I actually agree with what he’s saying despite liking Roy Keanes punditry. I have a manger at work who blames everyone else for all his shortcomings and I realised he isn’t a leader and doesn’t get the best out of people.
@@sobbyhasselhoff what point did you prove? Not all of us want to be grouped with an overly sensitive guy who never amounted to much in his playing days and as a manager? Nope, you missed that as well; what you proved is a lack of intelligence, both of you might have more in common that we do.
Even as a United fan and I loved Roy but he is right about his being a asshole. To be honest most of these ex pros who are pundits are terrible and full of themselves.
If players are missing penalties and sitters, then coach them better or bring in a better quality of player. He brought some real dross into Leeds, thought he was being different and loyal by bringing in fellow Yanks. He's sounding like a really whiney, spoilt kid. 🥴🙄
Sometimes things you dont want to hear need to be said in order to enforce a winning mentality. His lack of understanding of this is why he wouldn't prosper in England. Stick to the cheerleaders and high fives.
Roy talks the talk, but the fact remains he’s only a football pundit because he can’t get a managerial job. He’s been out of management since 2011. If he was that knowledgeable there would be a line of chairmen trying to hire him for their club, but that hasn’t been the case which says it all really
Jeremy Kyle calling Keano an arsehole! I've seen it all now.
Hahaha
I suspect Keane might know a bit more about leadership than J-Dog.
Ehhhh not really. If he was even a decent leader most of the teammates he had wouldn’t dislike him…
@@LudiCrust. Doubt you're even old enough to comment.
@@LudiCrust. His trophy cabinet says different. You don't become the most successful captain at one of the biggest clubs in the world without leadership skills.
Keanes leadership was through fear whether his teammates want to admit it or not. That's not real leadership and is old hat now and wouldn't work in this era.
@@barryb90United were probably better when he left so how can it be due to his leadership?
So apparently Roy Keane is a representative of a certain English culture? Nah mate, he's just a person that doesn't get carried away in sensationalism like most pundits do. You need someone like that to remind you of reality sometimes, sure it can be a bit negative, but I rather a guy like that on my team than a guy who praises you for getting a simple pass right.
It's true though? We love brutal honesty and respect it in England. Which is one thing that I do admire about this country.
Generalising a whole nation based off football commentary from an Irishman. The American needs to get a grip
It's also his nature. We all know someone like Keane and someone like Marsh. If everyone was the same, the game would more boring than it already is.
It's called brutal honesty and it's in short supply nowaday's. It's refreshing to hear unfiltered honesty regardless of offending snowflakes in a world full of woke superficiality.
Roy's pretty 'woke' himself.
He was a thug who admitted to wanting to end peoples careers. If you think that is refreshing, your parents haven't taught you well.
@@otey7326 when has he ever made that admission in his punditry? I'm sure terrible things were said many times in the tunnel, during games, during players careers but what you can't do is shame Roy for being a people pleaser or playing to the gallery. He knows what he thinks and says it and I respect that.
@@adamyeejy-sk9fh Hes never said it in his punditry obviously, why would he? Hes said it in his book though. I don't like people pleasers either and respect the honesty but he is now portrayed as this really laid back fella with a dry sense of humour. People have got short memories.
This is not punditry
Jesse highlighted the main issue with football and the world in general now, he said thats not our truth, there is no our or their truth, the truth is the truth in football, the eyes don't lie and roy calls it as he see's it, if people can't handle being critiqued their in the wrong game
The things that make Keane a good pundit, in some peoples opinion, are the very things why he has not, and never will cut it as a manager.
@mytmt1613 I don't think its keane. I'd say it's the soft new age players. He had 2 good years, but I agree that his punditry sets his management prospects back as he's too honest.
@@chro1843I’m a Liverpool fan. The fact you said he had two good years really speaks volumes about how silly you are .
Agreed 😊@@razorramon2786
@@razorramon2786 is what I said a lie ? Silly man
Show us your medals Jesse...Roy...hold my beer😂
You realise someone can still have an opinion even if they don’t possess a premier league medal?
Winning through intimidation and being an all round thug doesnt make you successful imo
@@Ooth9999doesn’t mean quite as much though does it
@@otey7326🤣🤣🤣 clown
I like Roy Keane more than this 🔔 🔚
Did he just use the phrase ‘our truth’? Give me brutal honesty any day of the week rather than that rubbish
Roy is the man
Excuses and blame he says. That's why you'll never a be a good manager. Go and tell alex ferguson that being honest and truthful doesn't win titles. What a muppet
Someone tell him Keane isn't English
Guy comes across like an arrogant arse
I think he knows what nationality Roy Keane is, he’s simply making a point about English culture, cuz you know, Roy is a part of that culture. 🙄
If you actually bothered to watch the whole thing he actually comes off as one of the least arrogant people Simon’s had on there.
@@BourbonJRA If he knows what nationality Keane is, then maybe he'd get a clue that the cutting kind of punditry he's on about isn't uniquely English at all. If anything, Irish or Scottish pundits are much more that way inclined than the English. His bitterness is because US culture is so much the opposite. Maybe he's better off staying over there!
No-one's perfect.
Americans vs Geography 😂
At no point does he say Roy Keane is English, he's on about the culture of English people who are watching him . Try paying attention before talking bollocks
Its Keane's unfiltered honesty that people like. What Marsch said about the Arsenal match is completely untrue to the point that he is delusional
Um I watched that game mate, he's right. Not his fault that the team couldn't kick the ball into the back of the net. I'm an Arsenal fan and Leeds should have won that game
@brianguthrie3196 Um, there's a diffence between missing a peno and a couple of good chances than having 5 absolute sitters that anyone could score
@brianguthrie3196 no it's not his fault, but not putting blame where it lies is useless. I could manage a team better than him. How can you say unlucky to someone missing easy chances and getting paid thousands for it?
@@johnwedgbury6817 what good does it putting individuals on blast? Really works out for managers when they know they are getting sacked.
Alex Ferguson- hairdryer. Jesse Marsch - mr nice guy. Yeah but good point.
So if this guy was a school teacher, he'd give kids a medal for taking part? Nothing wrong with trying to improve or telling the players who were bad that they were bad. Good way to stay mediocre
I think that's good for their self esteem though. The chance of school kids becoming professional athletes is almost zero so why be negative? You're watching too.much CZcams where everyone is a star
Jesse who
This guy is a turkey
I really like Roy Keane and he of course isn’t English but Jesse is right here in the difference of cultures. We’re always down on ourself whereas Americans back themselves.
What difference does it make? Roy’s apparent negativity brought him great success in the game whereas Marsch’s ability to “believe in himself” got him the sack at Leeds within 2 years
@Ooth9999 He wasn't negative as a player. Hated losing would do what it takes to win games. A bit negative as a coach, fell out with players, wasn't offered big jobs as a coach. Can't adapt to some of the 'modern' players and has my sympathy for that. Good pundit but a lot of Sky Sports and other sports commentary is clickbait negativity to increase their audience for advertisers.
@@Ooth9999Why do people act as though United won things due to Roy Keane? The team won more without him did it not.
Admitting that you want to end someone's career is something that is admirable in your opinion? What is wrong with people.
@@otey7326 lmfao what? When did I say that United won trophies solely because of Keane?. I said that Keane had a lot of success in his career. Also when did I say that him saying he wanted to end someone’s career was admirable? Lmao what are you on
@@Ooth9999 Youre putting someone down by comparing JM's manegerial stint to Roy Keane winning trophies which were mainly won by Ferguson and the rest of the team. A fair comparison would be against Roy Keane's managerial career - we all know what happened there
Jesse is a clown
Americans vs Geography 😂😂😂
And history 😂😂😂
What a bell end
So glad he was given the boot at Leeds 😅
Apart from roys Irish 🤦♂️🤣🤣🤣
A man who has achieved nothing in comparison to Roy Keane saying this 🤡🤡🤡
It’s okay. I think Marsch is an asshole. At least Keane won something. Playing at Princeton when he did means Marsch could play on an average high school team today. His ego has no reality check.
I think it would always be hard for an American coach, all of there schtick just sounds cheesy to a Brit.
This bloke couldnt lace Roy Keanes boots. What an absolute helmet
Roy Keane is on these shows due to his humour and put downs, it's like a sitcom. If you actually listened to his punditry, its some of the worst i have ever heard. He literally knows nothing about the modern game but is TV gold.
@@otey7326 yea ok lol
Roy Keane ruled Man United dressing room by fear reason he couldn't make it in management times have changed. However as pundit find him one of the best & honest no b.s unlike a lot other pundits.
I still like to see what he could do as a manager.. time changes how you handle things... well, some people.
Two nations divided by humour
It’s funny but I actually agree with what he’s saying despite liking Roy Keanes punditry. I have a manger at work who blames everyone else for all his shortcomings and I realised he isn’t a leader and doesn’t get the best out of people.
Jesse crying about hurt feelings. How very American.
how about not grouping all of us with him
@@EL.JEFE1231 how about I do what I want and you do what you want? Thanks for proving my point.
@@sobbyhasselhoff what point did you prove? Not all of us want to be grouped with an overly sensitive guy who never amounted to much in his playing days and as a manager? Nope, you missed that as well; what you proved is a lack of intelligence, both of you might have more in common that we do.
And when its the other way round Jesse, and the opposition misses a load of chances, do you point that out?
Septic not got a clue! Football to them is throwing the ball and games last 4 days not 90+ mins
4 days?
D-reg motor, one previous owner who was a nun, nice little runner, yours for £25k
What a plum he really is ha ha
Im not a shite manager!!! Im..... Oh Roy is an asshole (take the heat away from me being crap)
Roy's based. He likes nerve. JM is vision over truth. And that BS will fly but not for long. 37 games was generous.
1. Keanes Irish
2. Yanks should stick to their own sports 😊
Even as a United fan and I loved Roy but he is right about his being a asshole. To be honest most of these ex pros who are pundits are terrible and full of themselves.
If players are missing penalties and sitters, then coach them better or bring in a better quality of player. He brought some real dross into Leeds, thought he was being different and loyal by bringing in fellow Yanks. He's sounding like a really whiney, spoilt kid. 🥴🙄
This guy is a snake oil salesmen through and through....Keano is a hothead but has more charisma in his left toe than this guy
Sometimes things you dont want to hear need to be said in order to enforce a winning mentality. His lack of understanding of this is why he wouldn't prosper in England. Stick to the cheerleaders and high fives.
Roy talks the talk, but the fact remains he’s only a football pundit because he can’t get a managerial job.
He’s been out of management since 2011. If he was that knowledgeable there would be a line of chairmen trying to hire him for their club, but that hasn’t been the case which says it all really
You’re supposed to tell the truth then encourage. If not you’re setting yourself up for zero success
Different approaches to success
@@user1517.and Marsch has had no success
@@bear1245Doesn’t mean someone else can’t succeed with that approach
@@user1517. we’re not talking about someone else we’re talking about his bull he’s talking
@@user1517. it’s ok if you got the tactics to back the waffle up too. Which he didn’t have. So he can’t handle the truth because he’s so deluded.
Bluffer
Americans and their feellings again
Easy now.. some of us like hearing what Roy says.
Jesse is spot on. About leadership, about Keane, about the yobbish culture celebrated in Britain. So glad I left and came to America
Jesse is right for once.
No he isn’t. Americas are insufferable arseholes. Trust me.
He's right about Keane. Keane is just a depressive liar who acts tough.