Viewer Request: Sig Sauer MCX Rattler V. Q Honeybadger
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 12. 2017
- Website
www.anrdesignkydexholster.com
CZcams
/ alexandryandesignllc
Facebook
/ aandrdesign
Instagram
@anrdesignllc
Instagram Backup
@anrdesign_backstage
Twitter
@anrdesignllc
Holster - Best Seller
www.anrdesignkydexholster.com... - Sport
Love this video. Points out the glaring flaws of the QHB2.0.
The MCX price is painful but from a engineering aspect they nailed it.
That was my thoughts after watching this video. The reassembly was huge turn off…..
5 years later and I STILL couldn't decide... so I got both.
Yas
haha wasn’t expecting to see you here. love your content and message
Merica!
You are a lucky men ‼️
Both are great
LOL! Best post here, says everything!
Great video! I was really excited about the Honey Badger and the video was eye opening. I'll probably still pick one up, but looks like it won't become my go to SHTF rifle. It's a shame but i guess they had to make some compromises to get the weight down. Anyway great vide thanks for making it very informative.
+Alabama Arsenal it's a fun gun. Great, lightweight range gun. Great lightweight hunting rifle.
+Alabama Arsenal what would be your SHTF rifle?
💯💯
Excellent vid! Takedown and re-assembly of Honeybadger made a big impression. THANK YOU.
SIG just has a design advantage especially the Rattler. Brilliant design and look, its just a great firearm which can even be more compact than the badger. And you get a integrated barrel for it. As usual you get what you pay for with todays compact weapon systems.
good to see a video from someone who's actually used one of these!
Thanks for the honest review. The sig now comes with a folding brace option which brings it to 5.1 lbs vs the hb at 4.5 lbs. So we are talking a little more than half a pound difference. For the added "sturdiness" of the sig I'll take the extra weight.
Especially, since it will be closer to my body with the shorter extended length and the way shorter folded length. I've never owned either brand and this would be my first 300blk gun so this has helped a lot in my research.
I was going to get the honey badger. That take down ... game changer! Great review
Thank you for your honest review and opinion. I have some reservations about the Honey Badger now. I am thinking about going with the Noveske Ghetto Blaster instead (N4 Gen 4 PWS).
Thanks for the honest review comparison. Think I’m going to go with the short barrel 300blk Sig MCX Virtus upper whenever they do release them.
+Yuanmei 10" in the 6.75 in model upper. It's unbelievably quiet
Glad you did this. Always wondered what the differences were.
Thanks for the honest review. Most reviews worship the Honey Badger but this gives an honest breakdown of the gun and it's very difficult to reassemble. I might hold off on that Honey Badger paint scheme now.
Secound owner i have seen questioning reliability.... f*** that , when things hit the fan you want to be able to pick up something and you know its gonna work.
"smush watermelons" was top on my checklist, believe it or not.
+JT Burg lol.
“SIGnificanly heavier” I like what you did there
yess Dad puns
Got the HB in jail. Saving up for the Sig. Thank for the video. Perfect comparsion for me!.
I’ve had baffle strike on an x95 using the 556ti-qd can not tightly mounted, FWIW. (Luckily I have a bunch of cans so I just sent that one in to Sig)
Excellent comparison!
Been super curious about both guns... Always wanted to try out a 300 Blackout rifle in a compact size as the Rattler, but it seems a bit steep for me. The honey badger is really cool too, but that disassembly is kind of a pain. I guess I'll wait a bit more and see what else gets developed...
The GQ Paladin is an excellent contender to these. Has the engineering of the SIG Rattler, but has the gucci aesthetics of the HB. Comes in at $2700 so middle of the road pricing between the three of these options. Takes down just like an AR.
never seen one.
They're bad ass!!! love the gold
It’s more like the HB than the Rattler. It’s just a really Gucci 7” AR. I have both but the rattler is more it’s own thing entirely .
Great video, thanks! Guess tjhe Honey Badger is more design/beauty than function... room to improve! Super cool info, keep up the good work
Thanks for the honest review.
Watching this again and handling a MPX SBR at the local shop the other night I would almost say to either keep the brace (it is almost the same as the stock but actually more comfortable) and keep it a pistol. A pistol would be 50 state legal if they pass the 50 state CCW or if you are otherwise eligible for 50 state carry (not to mention all of the states where you can possess a pistol otherwise.) My opinion the second option if you go the SBR is to go with the new small sig adjustable folder that is currently on the vertus series.
+K0gashuk0 this brace blows. Chews you up after a day in class
I think what the poster is trying to tell us about is, “the honey badger is for a rich ne’er-do-well who is seeking a status symbol versus a functional weapon“.
Sir, Thank you so much for posting this video, the honey badger is off my list and I will happily stick with my Sig MCX in 300 blackout.
The whole vibe of Q is “I’m a hood rat in a gated community”
A full length handguard over a suppressor also prevents barrel flex when mounting on barricades. It allows for a mounting point so you aren't getting the suppressor causing accuracy issues.
That's why the MCX Tacops is awesome. 6.75" barrel with a 10" handguard, I believe.
Depends on where the weight is distributed. If it's toward the back more then it's more tolerable and easier to manage shooting. Personal preference.
Awesome comparison thank you! For me a better comparison would be the galil ace pistol. Seems like they are going after the same market pretty much. Any chance of that happening?
Great comparison!
Thanks man. Funny watching the industry try to appease customers who MUST Not abandon the AR history of worth. A gun that is a -fiddle fart- to assemble because of the design manipulation to cram a 10 pound design into a 5 pound bucket. Vs a design that removes the buffer tube, and keeps the AR ergonomics.
Nice comparison, just subbed
Thank you for the honest review.
+Nick Brungard try our best
ANR Design LLC question at the end of this review is would you buy this gun again if you lost it?
The question relates to where to spend my 💰 ... but thanks for the comparison 👍
Everyone should keep in mind a few things. The honey badger is not a replacement for your ar15 or you 300 blk hunting rifle or your home defense rifle. It was specifically designed to replace the mp5 sd. That’s it. It isn’t meant for bashing skulls or laying down suppressive fire or for accuracy. It is meant for vbss and low profile ops. It is mission specific and frankly does a good job at its mission but not much more and q and Kevin are fine with that because they don’t deny it.
Did you just say this gun isn't designed for accuracy? Lol. You should probably clarify that it's not designed for precision shooting. But it's certainly a very accurate firearm. I'm just expressing that it is not a hard used gun. The mp5sd is a pretty hard use gun.
ANR Design LLC yeah my bad. Precision is definitely a better word. The mp5sd is hard use no doubt but you aren’t bashing skulls in with the stock like you were talking about. That stock seemed to have a good bit of wobble but it’s not like mp5 skeleton stocks are reinforced rebar.
Well, if the Honey Badger was designed to replace the MP5 SD, it's doing a terrible job. The MP5 was a tank, much easier to disassemble and maintain, and certainly didn't have magazine or feeding issues. Whatever the original Honey Badger was, the current production version is a civilian toy. Definitely a cool looking gun, and probably great for plinking or hunting, but not a hard use duty weapon
The funny thing about your explanation of the Honey Badger is that it wasn't selected as the replacement for the MP5SD. Q built it for that reason as you said, but it didn't make the cut.
The rattler did make the cut though.
Love my Rattler!!! ❤️❤️❤️
4:24 SIGnificantly heavier ;)
Gas and Di is also a weight difference, but like you said this really not a good comparison, me personally I would prefer the rattler and the weight would not be a problem, I would think it can handle the recoil better.
I'm not seeing any Virtus vs Rattler videos. Is there much of a difference?
My Honey Badger runs 20 round Lancers just fine. That is what I use for Backpack carry.
Honey badgers had issues off the first production run. It is a known issue and it has been fixed since then
I love the aesthetics of the Honey Badger, but I would trust my life with THE MCX.
agreed
The problem with the full mags on the honey badger is because they drastically changed the physics of the weapon to fit the design. With the MCX they changed the design to meet the needs of the weapon system. IE you cant have the entire system rely on that one tiny little spring that gets jacked up when you put it back together.. That is one of the reasons the MCX has 2. That and they almost completely eliminate the evil piston carrier tilt. Remember the difference between subsonic and supersonic is drastic. It takes a pretty good gas system to get that right. You cant just lower the spring weight and continue to drop all the burnt powder in.
+K0gashuk0 great comment!
K0gashuk0 good point. And to be honest, from what I've seen with the one I have, the MCX doesn't have any carrier tilt at all. Unlike a short stroke AR, it's not really possible for the BCG to rotate inside the receiver. The whole piston system on the MCX is very well designed ( well, at least after the hiccups of the Gen 1 version)
So which would You Get? Obviously there is some novelty to the honey badger that the sig just doesn’t have as there’s hundreds of thousands of them out there or at least I would assume as most distributors have hundreds in stock compared to zero Homer’s badgers...
Excellent video.
Glad you liked it!
I've had horrible experiences with sig rifles but I like this rattler a lot and will be getting one to try out
American Defense ALG, although they should have put a geiselle or hiperfire in there... it’s weird you can’t pull one pin and open it like a typical AR. Is the Noveske Ghetto Blaster identical in terms of takedown? Or easier?
So with the new ATF proposed rule changes this would be a SBR, 6-12 months in NFA JAIL, pay $200 tax stamp, registration of you & this firearm and all the interstate regulations that go with it.
These are rules not laws, don’t let an executive branch of government that is supposed to enforce current law be allowed to arbitrarily change definitions and create confusing, subjective and complicated rules leading to ambiguity, these rules are an attempt to circumvent legislation and through executive action effectively ban all braced pistols. This is a clear overstep of ATF authority and purview.
SCOTUS has previously stated that laws must be clear and simple.
“Clear" means easy to understand or intelligible. It also means unequivocal or unambiguous. For a document to be described as clear, it must not only be easy for its audience to understand but also convey the same message to those who read it.
The ATF rule change is intentionally extremely subjective in wording and provides a back door to ultimately determine a braced pistol to be a NFA item upon their final opinion and position despite otherwise passing their arbitrary scoring system.
Ultimately, the Constitution is clear, under the 2A: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed. It does not say government has the ability to determine what is an acceptable form of arms for the people to bear. It says shall not be infringed. The people have a right to own, carry, transport, manufacture, or modify arms as necessary to maintain a well regulated body capable of defense of self or nation, period.
Please, contact your local, state, and federal representatives and congressman. Let them know we the people will not relinquish our freedoms and rights, given by God and enumerated in our Constitution. We will not allow subjugation of the People and tyranny by our governments an opportunity to take root. Then go to the ATF website and make a stand and let our voices be heard, provide a comment on this rule change as well as the other proposed regulations that infringe upon our Constitutional rights.
If we don’t let our voices be heard then we allow our rights to be taken!
Easy with the goods man! Haha great video
+Gianna Corpuz slamming them around?
You can put a 6.75” barrel on the rattler. Actually you can put any barrel from the MCX line on the rattler.
If using a virtus barrel on a rattler upper you have to use a virtus Op Rod/Recoil Assembly since the rattler has a shorter op rod that will not be long enough to reach the piston on a virtus barrel
I forgot to ask.... you prefer the 10” can on the mcx for 300blk? You referring to the 338ti-qd? Why that over the 762ti-qd?
Does you stock lock up tight on the HB? Does the chamber side stock rail have a large gouge in it where the locking block engages?
Yes
Good review
id be happy with either but goddamn my dads honey badger shoots the nuts. super fun gun
The last suppressed MPX I fired was gassy as hell... still the case? How does it compare to the Q?
William Woods if the MPX was gassy, I can’t imagine the Q would be better since it’s DI vs Piston.
The reassembly of the honey badger looks painful. I love the sig Sauer gas piston and ease of assembly are the selling point for me. I'm going to get me one. I really don't care about the weight.
I've been eyeing these thinking how much better they'd be than my 8 inch. It gives me solace that their proprietary systems aren't any better.
Exactly as described
thanks
Ya if im clearing houses in a war zone sure Il take the sig, here in America where I'm shooting for fun where I want something that's super light and looks badass- honey badger all day
They weigh exactly the same in the SBR configuration.
Mpx, Mcx, getto blaster, mp5, Scorpion (Honey Badger don’t care!)
How does the charging handle aid in destroying an over gassed gun?
Rattler all day! Because I own one and love it. My homeboy wants the Honey Badger and I’m encouraging him to make that his Christmas gift to himself! Shared the video with him today as well.
Great video btw
How is this not a fair comparison.... They have to exact same intended use, exact same setup, same caliber. They're practically the same gun, different color haha
Sounds like the rattler is much better, just a little heavier.
Would you recommend the Thunder Chicken or the Trash Panda for the 7” (non 2 stamp) honey badger with the short handrail?
Trash panda & cherry bomb
ANR Design LLC right on thanks.
ANR Design LLC I have been noticing some of the Honey Badgers have the Geissele flat triggers instead of the AR Gold. Do you know why that might be?
One is gonna be a safe queen.. and the other is going places
What's your Fav 300ACC Cann ? And 556 Cann?
That HB take down is brutal ... for someone wanting a PDW that breakdown is just not practical. Not to mention the mag issues. Thanks for the review.
Lightweight*durable*affordable - when it comes to firearms you can find all those attributes, but only two/three at a time.
+SpartanB88 true story
The honey badger also has an adjustable gas block
yup, sucks to access
Wow! Given the amount of shit the guys at Q talk... man what a load of horse shit! The mag issue alone seems like a deal breaker, but the takedown looks like a giant pain in the ass and the stock and hand guards have their own issues... whatever Q😒... Sig wins
ShooterSD72 fwiw I dont think @lonestarboars has had issues with his mags. Excited to see"normal" people get theirs and what issues they have or don't have.
I say your the only one that took the long to resemble a honey badger than anyone else I have seen..
I had a stroke trying to read this
Well damn.. Your still able to type but yeah.. you can thank me for that..
Your comment is lame
Thinking of picking up a rattler this week. Thanks for the video. Didn't know you were local! Good to know.
Eric Couture Please let me shoot it, I'll buy ammo! Lol
Tre' Roney I'm in NH. I'm down.
+Eric Couture manchvegas!
Rattler is on order... I'll let you know when I get it!
I have the rattler pistol now... waiting for the sbr paperwork I submitted in September
I wanted a honey badger.
I researched more. This video helped a ton.
I don't want a honey badger anymore.
Don't get me wrong it looks like a really fun range gun. Like you're going to take this out and have a good time with it with some buddies. But I'm not at a stage to really be buying range toys. Maybe one day I could get one. But for what I'm focused on, it doesn't really seem like something that will fit my needs.
Thanks for making this!
no problem
@@ANRDesignLLC Glad I found this video before I spent $3000 and paid $200 to file a form 4.
DI vs Piston? Less gas in face for DI with suppression?
no
I would go with the Sig.
I have a sig MPX 9mm and its my favorite gun.
I hear Socom is interested in the MCX Rattler.
Probably the only force in the world who can afford them
Looks like lots of other people here in the comment section have the same opinion as me about the Honey Badger. It's too bad that a gun that gets really dirty, really quickly is such a pain to service.
The guys at Q have come up with a expedited way to assemble and disassemble the system. I believe they will be rewriting the literature on how to assemble it more efficiently
For a gun lauded to be superior to the original design and everything the MCX couldn't be, it really looks like a major pain in the ass
I know this is an older video, but thoughts on .300blk in terms of DBs at the shooters ear given varying platforms and options on the market?
depends on the gun, the subs, and the can. Some yes, some no. Some, the gun mechanics cycling are NOT hearing safe via bone conduction in the jaw with a cheek weld.
@@ANRDesignLLC ya I figured like grandma's underwear that it just dependz (duh dun tsh)
from your experience with the MCX in terms of 5.5", 6.75" and 9" .300blk. Is one more "hearing safe"-ish?
5.5. 9 is loudest
@@ANRDesignLLC sorry so is 6.75" the quietist?
5.5
Wow what a “smart” on the honey badger. Glad I didn’t buy one after watching this video. They need to figure a way to make a captured spring for that recoil spring.
50MT4 I have both of these pistols and I suggest you try to get your hands on the honeyb first before writing it off. It’s hard to explain about the honeyb but you just gotta try it. Shooting the Sig I feel like it’s just another highly modified ar pistol. This is only my $.02
Dainty. Not a word I want to hear when I'm talking about self defense.
Lol
Great video, personally I’m Not a huge fan of the 2 inch barrel on the sig rattler.
its 5.5"
Oh noooos I will not be getting a 🍯 honey badger..sig rattler it is
Noveske Ghetto blaster please do another honest review with all 3.
Sure buy me a ghetto blaster and I will totally do a video of all three
Is the Rattler compatible with standard AR lowers?
Found the answer to my question if anyone was curious. czcams.com/video/ShZf87R9H4s/video.html
build your own!
or this
Honey badger has an adjustable gas block
sure does. not easily adjustable thought
Great video. I love Q but Kevin gave up too many of secrets at sig. Their suppressers he designed are amazing, the taper mounts, and the mcx were all great ideas. I want to like q but there’s nothing q does better then sig other than maybe marketing and the erector. The Rattler is better then the honey badger, the sig QD is better then Q’s, sig makes inconel and TI cans opposed to Q’s ti only Rifle cans, and their direct thread cans are neck and neck. The Q erector is a game changer though, can’t wait for the 45 cal can.
😂😂😂
i need the blast
Isn’t the honey badger a DI gun and the Rattler is GP gun?
Everyone always puts the honey badger back together the hard way. It takes 20 seconds to put it back together.
yes, sling shotting it is easier and a now known method. This was the Q instructed way when they first released.
Hey bro any links were i can pick a honey badger up at
ask Q
Can you order the stock instead of the brace after your file for your SBR or can you not get the part from Q?
Great question. I am wondering the same for the Honey Badger. Did you find out?
How much $$$$ for rattler?
I got into firearms too late. The MCX is 500 cheaper than the HB.
That's good if you're buying MCX tho...I'm still looing at both
Good vs
how can a charging handle destroy an upper?
+EvendimataE over gassed, jumps off the latch catch on the upper, gauling the aluminum.
ANR Design LLC cool thanks, I learned something new every video!
"Q-ty" marks? 'Sig'nificantly heavier? lol
+Aries144 punsssss
The biggest criticism I've heard of the Rattler is shooting suppressed it's so gassy you can only get 10 rounds or so off before your eyes are watering, almost a fatal flaw. Any idea if the Honeybadger has the same problem?
No cause HB was designed to be suppressed. Rattler wasnt
@@ANRDesignLLC for a gun that wasn’t meant to be suppressed, they definitely made the canebrake to be suppressed. They are the same gun just with different handguards
So there isnt any option anymore to use these on full-auto ? Not eaven in a diffrent state ?
What's up with people and wanting to commit felonies
How can they not be compared lol, they are designed to do the same thing...
You sound like Joe Rogan
So Q managed to make an AR that is:
Magazine sensitive
A pain to disassemble/reassemble
Has useless mlok rail up front
Poor execution of sling swivel
Less than 100% reliable
Only costs $3000 with tax stamps!
Meh
even the makers of the Honey Badger admitted that Sig made a much better product.
Pricing. It is OVERALL more affordable and much lighter. But it's not a hard use gun imho
I like the honey badger but why is it 4 different colors?
Florin Toader the guy who made the honey badger made the mcx and mpx and sing silencers then made the honey badger 2.0 which is what you see here
The honeybadger has just as much usable mlok as the sig.
The HB looks like a mediocre toy compared to a highly engineered professional cq weapon system - and that takedown and reassembly with the HB - not impressive