Paul Muad'dib Atreides - False Prophet | DUNE
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 04. 2024
- "Long live the fighters."
Trully a captivating performance. Wanted to show the tragedy of the story in this video, hope you enjoy.
Music: Twelve Titans Music - Azimuth
Link: • Twelve Titans Music - ...
A tribute-edit-trailer to Paul Muad'dib Atreides, The Lisan al Gaib, Mahdi, played played by Timothée Chalamet in Dune Part 2.
#Dune #PaulAtreides
Dune 2 Atreides Speech Fremen Best Scenes - Zábava
I also do freelance work for video editing, you can contact me here: panosdks22@gmail.com
Gurney Halleck looks like a proud dad when Paul started talking about leto during his speech to the fremen
Gurney technically becomes Paul's step dad after Paul gives him rulership of caladan and Jessica joins him there and he becomes her lover
@@achillesrodriguezxx3958 😂that's so wierd( her becoming Gurney's lover )but okay lady Jessica 😂😂😂
Im sure that's not gonna happen in the movie lol @@_dreamy.light_
3hours that felt like 20 minutes. I left wanting more and imagining what a director's cut would be like.
I will happily purchase an extended version if they bless us with one.
While I agree with you, Denis Villeneuve already stated that he won’t release any extended cut because „what’s out is out“ for the sake of consistency in storytelling. Dune has incredible pacing, no scene feels wasted or boring. Extraordinary filmmaking at every level
I remember trying to explain to my friend why my favorite part of the first movie is Paul spending his last evening on Caladin walking the beach. It’s a moment that captures Pauls last day before he touches Arrakeen sand and sets the universe on fire.
“The danger with people like him…is that we put them on pedestals. They become symbols. Icons. *And then we start to forget about their flaws”* -Baron Zemo, MCU
#Mao #KanyeWest #JohnnyDepp
I am sure that you and this channel are different, very speacial moral noble HOLIER THAN THOU folk.
@@SenatePalpatinetroller?
@@SenatePalpatinetroller time for your medications
No think the same with the Harkonnens chasing you 😛
"Lead them to paradise..."
He looked so sad when he said that, but he knew he had to. A subtle reminder that this was the only path he saw for humanity to survive and he didn't want to go down it.
@@LeppalimesIts tragic. "Lead them to paradise" is basically, _lead them to "heaven"_ And he knows it. Thats why he fought so hard against it, but he sees literally no other way 🤷🏽♀️
Bro i dont think anyone realized it, he no longer does the fremen walk to avoid the sand worms, bro casually walking through the desert.
because only LISAN AL GAIB can do that
He probably knows he won't be killed by a worm so it doesn't really matter
@@stanpines9011 it is, he knows when a worm comes
One of the best sci-fi movies I have seen
One of the best period
There isn’t much science involved. It more of a fantasy genre like Lord of the Rings.
@@thisismyname007LOL. That’s why the genre is called science FICTION. 🤡
@@thisismyname007is there science in alien, blade runner etc, and they are the goats of sci-fi. Don’t be sayin that bro
@@thisismyname007 It's a fictional story with technology and animals/religion we haven't and will probably never see. It's sci-fi
This side of paul is what makes his character so interesting. Wanting to do good but w partially selfish intentions and manipulation from his mothers doing.
i mean who doesnt want to be a king? in pauls case he gets to be the emperor of the known universe.
After he drank the water he doesn’t care about doing good anymore he’s intentionally manipulating the firemen and everyone else around him to get what he wants. He wanted to do good, now he’s fully delved into being a dictator like villain.
@souvikmondal6161 the main motivation is revenge for his father and house
It's a matter of survival for him. If he doesn't do this, Arakkis would fall with all the Fremen. It's only a matter of time.
@@Despotic_Waffle i dont think so. If paul wanted solely revenge he would have killed the emperor and irulan and be done with it. But he drank the water of life. Becoming the emperor was the only way , paul could ensure his mother and his sister to be born will be safe. In the opening minutes of the movie , he is clearly worrying about he is gonna fix things before his sister’s arrival.
He’s not a false prophet. He’s exactly who they were waiting for.
But they were waiting for him becouse brainwashed from the bene gesserit, the same one who were creating him
In such a short clip you encapsulated the essence of Dune Part 2.
Well done.
Thank you!
absolutely amazing bro
Thanks boy🫡
That's high praise from the Lisan al Gaib of editing!
For all those who want more, read or listen to the audiobooks by Frank Herbert. DUNE truly is excellent. You'll be able to better see what Denis Villeneuve was aiming for, and appreciate all the subtle details he imbued in this visual Masterclass.
My favorite book I’ve ever read
Where can I find audio books of dune, please?
Visions of the future, surviving the water of life and male bene gesserit. As close to a messiah as you can get.
All fabricated and weaponised by the Bene Gesserit missionaries and breeding program.
That’s what I’m saying. Like…he kinda IS the Mahdi
@@colefriel3171it just so happens that the Lisan Al Gaib itself was not the best prophecy lmao.
But he was literally bred to do this, would jesus be that special if you could put him in a test tube and clone him? That's what Paul is a test-tube messiah who manipulated a population with social engineering into committing mass murder and genocide. Closer to a science experiment gone wrong than a messiah.
I still dont understand why the movie doesnt show us the visions Paul has during the last scenes. Having read the books, I know during the duel with Fayd-Rautha Paul has visions showing him that the outcome of the duel doesnt matter; the Holy war will happen no matter what. When Paul says his last line (send them to paradise) it's not clear what is the future he sees that compels him to say that.
One of the best Cinematic expieriences ever, very Epic Edit, great Job🔥
Thanks friend!
literally best edit ive seen
Perfect compliment friend🙌
You deserve it 😁 you did a very good job @@panosdks
@@panosdksPaul's lines during the war council scene are really powerful.
Warner Bros can’t stop all these fire edits 😎🔥
The scene shot from above as Paul moves through the huge crowd of Freman is a visual reference to him being the Kwisatz Haderach. In Dune part 1 Mohiam says "Like sifting sand through a screen we sift people". The scene from above resembles grains of sand with Paul sifting through them but being separate because he is the Kwisatz Haderach that the Bene Gesserit have been working towards all those years.
I just saw this again yesterday and watching this is making me want to watch it all over 🔥🔥
Best edit yet for dune 2
absolutely brilliant man
Thanks!
Actually he is the Kwisatz Haderach and has total prescience. He can see all past and future and has supernatural powers. So no, he is not a false prophet. He was pursuing what Herbert called the terrible purpose in his books. It meant that war was the only way for human race to survive through the scattering of genes. Also Paul had to follow the Golden Path, but he recoiled from it and let the responsibilty fall on his son's shoulders. I regret that Denis Villeneuve's movie is giving way to a myriad of videos from people who did not read the books and misinterpret what is going on.
He does become egotistical and he does let the power corrupt him tho
I agree. These movies dropped the most interesting parts of the book and replaced it with the generic and banal.
I'd add one thing though: Paul didn't want the jihad to happen, but knew that there was no way of stopping it, even if he sacrificed himself.
@@Trebor6127 because the message that Herbert intended got lost in the first book.
It’s unfortunate that you read the book and still don’t seem to understand Herbert’s main thesis - that charismatic, messianic figures are tyrants in disguise and that people should be wary of a Paul Atreides in the first place, or that blind faith in such people can and will lead to mass death. In this case, more than 60 billion of them.
My guy Herbert had to make it known to his audience that paul isnt the good guy because there are readers who still taught that he was the good guy after reading dune
61 billion dead
In his name
He was the only thing his father ever needed him to be
And the one thing his father never wanted anyone to be
great edit and music too
Glad you enjoyed it
This is beyond incredible as always, my friend!!
Thanks bro
I don’t care what you believe! I believe!
45 years ago before any of the movies we used to call Dune "Star Wars for adults".
Yup!
Crazy edit
Glad you enjoyed it
Keep up the hope people...
"I AM PAUL MUAD DIB ATREIDES. DUKE OF ARRAKIS." man, that line gives me chills every time! Excellent video.
Thank you!
absolute banger wow
Thank you!
As someone who's only seen the movies, it's fascinating seeing his conviction as he says the word paradise, when we've seen nothing but destruction within his visions. Maybe they didn't show some revelation when he drank the water of life, but from what they've shown us he's falsely claiming something he's not seen once.
He did see that. The failure is not on him and his action individually, but on the idea of him, the idea of needing to create a "messiah". The breeding program created him as the messiah, yet the power and ability he possesses could never lead to the promising future that the bene gesserit envision. It's doomed to fail and could only fail bc an omnipotent prophet and prescience would only be an obstacle to the advancement of humanity
Dune is EPIC
Nice one.
he sounds like Eren Yeager
Paul atreides is based 🔥💯
y’all have to understand I am not a false Prophet It’s deeper than that
I loved the first movie but the second one was a masterpiece
✨ Green Paradise ✨💕💖
This video should have this huge "SPOILER WARNING" banner at the start. 😂😂😂
Wow
The thing is: He is a tragic fate. He never wanted to be a prophet or messiah yet the circumstances of the war, the lies, the deception, the assassination attempts and then finally the prophecy of the Fremen and the madness like pushing of some of its believers almost left no other path open for him than to accept this future and finally embrace it. Deep down he never wanted it but honor and heritage are giving him no other choice so he chose to embrace and fully live it in the end.
I can't wait to see this movie bruh
It’s the best I’ve ever seen in theaters.
Paul: Ire Iduna Isa Nadi Ni Lisan Al Gaib
Aruh An Ni Pira Alo Ashidi!
Fremen : LISAN AL GAIB!!!
where did you get this clear version of the movie?
I want to rewatch it again but it's not in my city no more.
The difference between prophecy and truth is will. Just because you said a thing would happen does it become less true if you make it happen? Paul made a choice, and his son did everything he was still too sentimental to do. Paul chose to die rather than walk the Golden Path himself.
So from my perspective, dune emperor is so weak. Because he cannot eliminate his enemy fully and lost his throne. But emperor palpatine of star wars played 4d chess play both sides and killed his enemy (the jedi order) and ruled the galaxy for almost 23 years. So Dune emperor must learn from palpatine (Darth sidious )
I want dune to continue as a tv show until we get Leto II Atreides. Shit will literally bamboozle people
Lisan Al Gaib!
He didn’t want any of this.
Ten thousand years and still the same old shit!
Courtesy of centuries of oppression. Long live the fremen 💚
Thing is he made Arrakis green so to them he was the prophet they were right to be loyal to, as that is what they wanted.
His son pretty much tore down the system and manipulated people to stop believing/dependant and go spread out to the stars following their own way which included Arrakis becoming a sand dune again while he technically spends the rest of his life enjoying being without responsibilities as a sand worm.
Hand of God be My Witness…
The thing about this is...he is not a false prophet, he literally is the prophet, he sees the future.
But he's not a prophet by the traditional sense. He isn't divine, he isn't sent by God. He is a product of engineering and planning that spans centuries. The myths that support his coming are made up by the Bene Gesserit, and his birth and training are also made by them (well, his mother mostly) to fulfill said "prophecy".
But does he still work? Well, yea. In the end he does have prescience and he does predict the future of humanity. He finds the one path to survive extinction and he does lead the Fremen and Atreides to rule the universe.
He's not a prophet, but he might as well be.
@@zathary564the divine prophet sent by God is part of that engineering, it is the marketing of it. The Bene Gesserite are in real life the Jew, and Fremen are the Sunni the Jew created to destroy Christianity which is Rome turned into a Religion following their destruction of the 2nd Temple.
@@zathary564anti-religion is an overarching theme of the book. The author doesn't believe in the promise of an omnipotent prophet. Paul is as close to that as possible but he is doomed to bring disaster, not because he is bad or not powerful enough, but precisely because of the power and ability he possesses
The amount of people misunderstanding Paul’s being a false prophet in the comments is wild…
Wait he really did turn arrakis into a water planet he did everything he said he would do. The universe suffered but the fremen got their paradise
the universe suffered. a "hero" wouldnt let that happen.
@@dosomestuff1949 everyone suffers. 1st noble truth
@@DriveandThrive prove it
Mahdi
J.L. Borges says in his book Oral:
"Literature is an extension of memory and imagination."
When you think you are going to see the image that the Director and his team are developing, you have to interact with the reaction of those who are witnessing the scene. Villeneuve gives us the opportunity and invites us to participate, create, imagine, build in our minds... a universe of infinite possibilities. He is a Whisperer of Worlds!
As written
Is it a false profit who delivers on the prophecy? Or just a manufactured one.
What???? The movie follows books layout? Does movie change fact Paul. Is good/bad?
Well no Paul is suppose to be an anti hero in the books and movies but people keep saying hes the bad guy and the villain and that is getting really annoying
He actually has vision ofvthe way.
Except Chani doesn't buy into everything she saw with her own eyes!!
What is this heresy, to call our savior a false prophet, not knowing what he will sacrifice for us...
Denis needs to do a zack snyders directors cut of this lol
Unfortunately he has already said that there would be no “Director’s Cut” 🥲
Paul was a False Messiah yet he acted like a True Messiah while his son Leto II was the True Messiah by acting as a False Messiah.
He is the prophetiest prophet that ever prophesied. Given what he actually accomplished, what more do you want?
I think the point is the breeding program created an actual prophet, as real as it could be, but it still leads to devastating consequence, even worse outcome actually. Hence the author invalidates the promise of a prophet and messiah. Prescience is an obstacle to the advancement of humanity and free will
The story of Paul is complicated. He is not a "false" Prophet. He is a "manufactured" Prophet. The Bene Gesserit planted the idea of a "messiah" or Prophet on Arakis. So again, Paul filled the role. Did it better than they expected. And did "free" the Fremen. So not really false. Just different than anyone expected. Thanks for the great video. The other comments are right. Excellent work.
Appreciate it. Very correct take in my opinion
IMO he became a self fulfilling prophecy. The Lisan Al Gaib may have been a manufactured story in service to the Bene Gesserit but Paul was the Kwisatz Haderach and ultimately did fulfil what the prophecy said the prophet would do. So then you can argue that the prophecy was actually real all along and the Bene Gesserit had unwittingly unleashed it because they though they had final control over all things.
@@JayPotton Yes. The Prophecy was fulfilled. The mechanism it was setup for was triggered by the arrival of Paul and Jessica to Arakis. You bring up a good point. Paul was also the Kwisatz Haderach. That was not part of the Prophecy. That and the Lisan Al Gaib served separate purposes. The Bene Gesserit did not expect or want those two entities to be the same person. They lost control of both.
So somebody who saves people from their suppressors in a false prophet? Wake up
Maybe so - if the "savior" is someone who also oppresses them, uses them to slaughter billions in the name of revenge, destroys their culture, and then walks away leaving them to be utterly dominated for thousands of years by his son...
But yes, he was a Mesiah because they wanted to have forests and more water, he did it so he was a Mesiah for them. And i personally think Kwizatz Haderach was the same as Lisan al Gaib, because the Benegesserit created the prophecy for them to think that tgeir Kwizatz Haderach is their Mesiah (Lisan al Gaib).
Isn't he actually the chosen one? He died and was brought back to life by the prophecy.
not a messiah, he havea power beyond compreension.
How can the fremen speak english ? Or are they speaking their own language but the directors translates it to english for us ?
But... is he false?
He fulfilled the prophecy, threw off their oppressors and was beginning to turn Arakis green.
He is a Fallen hero. Not entirely good, not entirely bad. Flawed. Human.
He is, a vilain, in some ways, he “Paul” is trying to do good, doing bad things, he is, a unique character, Writer of dune, wanted to make the point be to not blindly follow charasmatic leaders like paul, and this is based off largely ww2. Paul completed a jihad, yes his kids control the universe but he is evil, im not sure how to explain it further.
The prophecy was fabricated by the Bene Gesserit. They wanted to use it to control the fremen and in the end Paul uses it.
That's what blurs the lines.
He seems to be a Messiah cause it's all falling into place, but everything that's allowed him to accomplish what he's accomplished can be explained with reason, not divine force.
He's been a victim of circumstance that is garnering blind faith, and he's gaining ultimate power in the process.
I personally don't think that Paul is a false prophet. I don't know how to explain it, but he's planned and unplanned at the same time. 🤷♀️
Dune is for science fiction what Lord of the Rings is for fantasy
1:37 who tf edited out his voice
I noticed that as well when putting the video together, it’s still there it’s just the music that covers it
False prophet but truest messiah
He isn't the false prophet..things he do were true all long..started becoming true as he waked the path he was meant for..just like in real world prophecy..few people believed and few people ignored yet those prophecy came true...
Actually a true prophet
But is he a false prophet if he fulfils all the conditions of a true prophet?
He is because it’s not he who brings true salvation to all of Humanity…but his son, Leto the Second…The God Emperor! 😊
OMG !! JUST LIKE MUHAMMAD !!
In the book Paul asks his mother to negotiate the terms for peace and asks her to take Chani with her because the Fremen are good negotiators. Paul isn't evil. Paul's character has been rewritten by the script writers who produced a different story for Hollywood. On a personal note, I don't believe revenge is evil. I believe it's necessary to keep the bullies under control.
Paul was "rewritten"? In what way? What Villeneuve depicts of Paul is actually very very close to the books, almost precisely the same. Yes, the storyline is altered for cinematic storytelling reasons, but that's not the same thing as saying that his character has been altered.
I think it's a misinterpretation of Villeneuve words about following charismatic leaders to blindly People hear that and see Paul use the Fremen i say use and not manipulation because it was not him who created the prophecy and even when he refused it they still believed he was the one he only took on the role as the messiah when he saw the destruction to his family and the fremen. People are saying he is a villain and not a good guy from those words Villeneuve said but he himself has said Paul is an Anti hero someone who has to do bad things for good
False prohet really? He is the voice from another world that is going to lead Fremen to paradise
No, hes much worse. You all don't seem to understand the source material just like Dennis. He ACTUALLY became a prophet, chose to take on the responsibility of becoming their demi-god and actually succeeded in changing the literal landscape of his mind and body to become a cross sectional living history of the fremen and rest of humanity, essentially, and used all that to guide humanity through endless war and suffering deliberately because he could see the real threat to humanity would be from without, one day. He is awful BECAUSE he will MAKE humanity do the right thing for the future survival of the species AT ANY COST. Even the damn director and son of Frank Herbert missed this point completely, and its the direct result of all the things that WEREN'T said. The absence of the thing creates the thing. Thats how the desert works. Its the absence of the water that drives the entire ecosystem, so its reall all about the water. Its the ability to destroy a thing that controls a thing in the spice. Its all the same lesson. Its the Tao. Its a guide book for self actualization and mindfulness. I personally think he wrote it to teach people what it means to become a true human being, and not just an animal. Probably for his kids/future generations to understand how even if you succeded in becoming a perfect all seeing god, you still wouldn't get it all right all the time and even if you did, it would end up horrible for humanity. Sometimes though, thats the narrow way through.
i like the old movie better, with a chani that knows her place and a Paul Muadib that has powers to crush the corpse of the defeated Feyd Rautha Harkonnen just with his voice! There is no doubt left he is the Mahdi in the previous one. It will make u a believer.
Paul was not able to crush people by voice in the book. You all are Lynch fans, not Herbert fans that’s why you are not like more complicated Paul who is not just another hero.
@@zzz7103 what about the weirding way you weirdo
What are the flaws of the True Mahdi Jesus Yeshua Emanuel Christ?
He is the real prophet....
You wanna know about the fake one, talk to a Muslim
How is he a false prophet lol
Check out Revelation 13 and Daniel 11. Don't be surprised when a person like the king of the north, as in Daniel 11, suddenly rises up, calls everyone to take chips and signs to buy or sell things, else you'll be k+lled. False prophets do exist, and the last one of them will be the worst.
Get peace with JesusChrist, the only True One.
Music is not epic enough.
It’s good. Maybe a bit trailer like but it definitely works with the lines of the characters in this edit.
Every prophet is a false prophet
So the bald albino guy is the actual hero of the story but he didn’t succeed in killing this crazy fluffy haired guy who was on a mission from “god.” 😢😢😢
No.
Lol