Real vs Fake Piano - Can Pianists Tell? (w/ Daniel Thrasher, Marcus Veltri, Joe Jenkins)
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 10. 2020
- Can YOU tell which are real and fake?
Remember to subscribe to @Marcus Veltri, @Joe Jenkins and @Daniel Thrasher !
Check out the original performances used in this video:
0:44 - Peter Bence: • Pirates of the Caribbe...
3:58 - Francesco Parrino: • Havana - Camila Cabell...
4:57 - Beegie Adair Trio: • Beegie Adair Trio - Au...
6:51 - Marnie Laird: • Mozart - Rondo Alla Tu...
7:49 - Tiffany Poon: • Tiffany Poon (2018) - ...
8:59 - Riyandi Kusuma: • Taylor Swift - Love St...
9:35 - Gamazda: • Linkin Park - In The E...
10:48 - Pascal Rogé: • Pascal Rogé - “Gymnopé...
12:47 - Peter Vamos: • DESPACITO - Beautiful ...
14:27 - Joep Beving: • Joep Beving - Sleeping...
15:26 - Vinheteiro: • Top 10 Most Difficult ...
Discord server: / discord
/ roomieofficial
Merch: bit.ly/2SiCqDz
Reddit: / roomieofficial
Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/3ti6K...
My & video & music gear: kit.co/RoomieOfficial
/ roomieofficial
Business contact (Sponsorships etc): roomiebusiness@gmail.com
Edited by Rikard Tholén - Zábava
Links to all the piano clips used are in the description if you want to listen more!
thank you:)
13:36 pls
11:58? Does anyone know what piece this is?
We’re no strangers to love
@@cranjismcbasketball615 you know the rules and so do i
Some random person; *plays piano*
Audience; “great job”
Daniel;
“IS THAT A YAMAHA YGP-535 88 KEY PORTABLE DELUXE KEYBOARD???!!!”
So many talented yt pianists here omg
Can't wait to see you get your verification tick
Aaayyyhh is you the guy
@blv nah, it's stupid, wtf are u even doing here
Love seeing Kestrel popup in the comments :)
THIS PIANO IS DIGITAL BECAUSE IT’S A THURSDAY AND THE WIND IS BREEZING DELICATELY TO THE EAST
Lol
I am laughing so hard rn
Nah it’s because the wind is sharp and cold and fake
I know you
Lol😂😂😂😂
Daniel giving an answer: "it was played on a 2005 Yamaha, it was a sunny day, partly cloudy, the pianist was drinking a diet coke. Out of a can, not bottle. He had visited the bathroom exactly 16 minutes and 37 seconds before playing this piece"
Yes
You forgot the “lol” after everything
Sunny day and partly cloudy? Interesting
Needs more detail
@@hazmat664 lol
hearing daniel talk like a normal human being and not being his weird, funny self just ain't familiah
The thing that makes me the most happy about this comment is that you obviously do not only have a great taste in CZcamsr's, but also in music in general, my fren! 😁💛||-//
@@musicaddict1046 :O you like tøp as well?
oh wait you saw from my profile pic lol
you know what this is getting confusing forget i said anything
@@Name-co5qi
😂💛 Alright! 👍
Stay alive! ||-//
to summarize: acoustic pianos good, electric pianos bad
Well said
Such a powerful statement
yes
Agreed
Can only afford electric one ;_;
Marcus: fake
Joel: real
Joe: real
Daniel: I actually built this piano so it’s fake
I laughed so hard I don't even know why
Joel: sorry to tell you Joe but ur wrong cause I guessed the same thing
I like imagining that roomie specifically told everyone before they started recording that everyone needed to have a piano in frame
Hahaha
That might be true
i was thiinking the same thing
Lmao
SAME
I love how getting all of them wrong is not holding back Daniel in the slightest to come up with another detailed explanation each time, with a straight face - until he finally gets one right.
Props to Daniel for literally guessing the exact preset of one of the samples, was a pleasure competing against you legends!!
So humble lmao. You smashed this!!
Wait a minute
I know you
Do more collabs like this
@@RoomieOfficial yep, great job man
I've been subscribed to Marcus, Daniel and Joel for a long time! And I knew Joe from some videos, so it was so awesome to see you all together! Like a dream come true 😄 and of course Marcus won with his perfect pitch and amazing talent and hard work 🙃
It warms the heart to see Daniel talking with someone that isn't himself
Loll
It ain't familliah.... 🤔
i wanted to comment this lmao
I wish I could do the same...
Oooo 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Daniel: *names exact piano* I helped engineer this piano in Germany
Joe: Gut
Daniel was definitely the kid in school who would give random, unnecessary pieces of info about the school unit to the class every time he answered a question from the teacher
I am adopting that style from now on.
"Did you accept my merge request yet?" - "Yeah, you had exactly 33 changes. Did you know that 87% of edits with 33 changes end up breaking in production? At least back in my day when I was wearing an onion on my belt, which BTW was totally the custom at the time."
Joel is the DJ Khaled of this video: he brought the right people together, occasionally says something semi-relevant or his own name. And then he gets the money
@NEHEMIAH RALFORD I mean Daniel IS being the definition of third impostor
@NEHEMIAH RALFORD I think he's cool too😅 being a comedian makes him being wrong about stuff less uncool somehow, bc it's funny
@NEHEMIAH RALFORD hahah thanks😅🥰 🤗
LOL
I'm glad I'm not in this video so I look like I still know what I'm talking about when it comes to sample pianos in the future 😂
F
F
F
F
F
I feel like Daniel was originally sincere with the specifics, but eventually was just doing it to meme
Marcus: Constantly second-guessing himself and changing his answers
Daniel: Making weirdly specific guesses that are only accurate once in a blue moon
Joe: “Just going with his gut”
Roomie: Just trying to keep up
You got that right!
I feel like Daniel is 'perfect pitching' with the detail of his answers.
"How does this sound?"
"Like a Yamaha GB1K acoustic grand."
Its kind of funny because marcus is the one with perfect pitch and he's the opposite of that.
@@enchiladas1875 Does Joe have it too?
@@cadenpadua idk, havent seen all his videos or recall a video where he talked about it.
@@enchiladas1875 In his video about Davie504, he was copying what Davie played on his bass, on the piano. He might have it.
@@cadenpadua he could possibly have or the other possibility is good relative pitch, Im not jumping to conclusions because I thought "the doo" had perfect pitch but then it turned out he just had really good relative pitch.
Acoustic pianos sound so awesome! Sometimes digital pianos just sound too perfect to be sounding less real.
Here before 1K likes. Much love btw
Jesus you as well my guy
Amosdoll thankyou for all your tutorials dude you've taught me so many songs I love !
Appreciate your content!!! It really helped motivate me to play the piano.
Man you're one of my favourite Pianist if not the most favourite on CZcams. Wish you were part of the video too
Daniel has officially mastered the dad laugh combined with the clap
Everybody: Real
Daniel: This piano is real because when you listen carefully, you can hear the bird in the background singing looking west and his little bird friends are so happy.
New skit idea for Daniel; “When you’re not specific enough”
HAH DANIEL NEEDS TO SEE THIS
"The preset and sample aren't enough, no, no. You didn't even mention the reverb plugin. Nor the fact that it was detuned by 2 cents. Or that the first equalization band was made silent and placed at exactly 72Hz. You are a disgrace."
When your TOO specific
He better lol. I’ll be waiting to see this.
Get this man pinned now ive been waiting a month
I was expecting something like:
"This piano is real because you can kinda hear the pedal noise in the background moving the dampeners as well as the hammer action and the way the strings vibrate"
But instead, This is what I heard:
"It's digital because I was at their HQ in Germany and they have a clavinova there..."
The good VSTs all fake those things. That’s why it’s so hard to tell.
@@FlorianRachor1 Even Korg Kronos simulates it. With Physical Modeling every instrument is replicable
Right??? Not only that, one of the samples everyone knew it was real because it sounded _worse_ than the digital tools.
Technology is here boys
ngl that was how my brain was thinking for some of these samples
To summarize:
- Daniel went to Germany once
- Joel played in a jazz band
- Joel doesnt know anything about jazz bands
- Daniel is loud when he’s right
- Marcus is the *supreme piano pianist*
This is the first time I've seen Daniel talk with sum1 else other than himself
True
😂😂i was thinking the same too
Daniel be like: this piano was made in 1999 the wood is from a maple tree that was 45ft tall and the tree was planted by my great grand father George Johnsons' boss Mr. Steve Piper
Edit: Thank for the...…. JK
...then the answer reveal: It was free VSTi plugin put together with twigs and berries in like five minutes.
Who knew pianos were like HP wands 🤣
I laugh so hard with every statement😆
Jorge Joestar
JK
Everyones talking about how oddly specific daniel is BUT watch his videos, he IS oddly specific on almost *everything*
I know right. He's very oddly specific. I like it, it makes him unique in his own way
Yesss he’s very detailed. I adore that about him! Detailed eccentricity is awesome.
It's a charming little quirk of his.
Someone: **plays a fart sound on their keyboard.**
Daniel: "heyo was that a G major on the Roland E-A7 ? Cause if u listen carefully, u can hear the melodious change in the notes, which you'll find only on a Roland."
Daniel is that type guy in classroom who gives correct answer with whole explanation to how he got that answer
I love this combination of people! More vids like this! :D
More collabs with them pls
YES!
agreed
I know
that's a sneaky way to have a collaboration with him 😏
100% yes
Everyone: Amber upright, (and other specific piano stuff) and nords
Joel: yeah
Ok, that "everyone" was probably Daniel
I did, but I don't like that it's mostly giving me hate videos bc of the tumbnail
Daniel is the kind of person who would say "its a digital piano because I could feel the electricity running through the wire moving at 69km/hr."
Hoodie Guy would probably be able to tell, seeing as he has perfect pitch and can hear radio waves before they reach people's devices...
Daniel took "the show your work in school rule seriously"
no one:
daniel: this is either a real piano or a yamaha 50021439 made in 2009 by john white who came to work late on a tuesday and was born at 90:91 pm on the fifth friday of the year
also daniel: gets it wrong
90:91 pm how does that work
@@nolt1738 alternate universe military time?
He could make a skit out of this o.O
@@bigblue3936 it just does
Daniels specific guesses: *confidence*
Joe advocating for acoustic instruments: *faith*
Marcus winning: *humility*
Joel trying to fake upgrade his score: *comedy*
no no its
kOmEDi
@@ZappyRXQ no its Co.Me.Dy
AAHHH KOMEDI I CAHDT SSPJEEL OCRREETDCTLEAE
jk i know its comedy i was trying to recreate the meme man meme
@@ZappyRXQme too man jk.....why u take so serious man
I love how daniel kept giving answers like "Oh, this one's fake. It's the Nord Grand Upright, I was there on the cold, autumn night when this instrument with this exact serial number was first played"
Daniel: talks to someone who isnt himself
fans: *it ain't F A M I L I A H*
Joel: so who wants to guess!
Also Joel: *not me*
Roomie: Daniel cant go first again because he knows weirdly accurate stuff thats been wrong so far.
Daniel: 😂(😭)
"Today we have three successful musicians and Roomie here"
Yayyy someone else remembers that video!
ah the making music without sound video
Marcus: *visible confusion*
Joe: "I'm going with my gut feeling here."
Daniel: "I think it's from a Flowey tutorial, which I know is on a Clavinova because I've been to their headquarters in Germany."
Joel: *completely guessing*
Joel: was it the challenge tough?
Marcus: it was tough
Joe: it was tough
Daniel: *german*
i swear i was crying laughing at that and thats how i know that my humour has gone to shit HAHA
Hart wie Kruppstahl! 💪🏻
Is that what he said? I couldn’t make it out. And I’m German!
*Intense discussion going on*
Joel: I agree with u.
Stella Look at my covers please!!! If you like them then subscribe!!! 😂 Joel is like that
Daniel: thinks he knows everything
Joe: sooooo clueless
Roomie: hyped for the vid
Marcus: chill asf
its good to see daniel interacting with people other than hoodie guy
Dang some of these had me completely fooled. Shows how far recording technology and VST’s have come.
Pleasant surprise seeing you here good sir
Sup ek
how to win the challenge:
( ) be a pianist
(x) wait for Joel's reply and say the opposite
love you, Joel 😝
@blv why do people spam this
@@sigmathletics its just him
@@agencer50 ikr
@@agencer50 maybe it’s his alt
🤣🤣
I like how they are all flexing their pianos in the back lol
This collaboration is one of the best ones I have seen so far in music, so much talent here in one video
Daniel guessing everything specific makes me so much sadder when he gets it wrong 🤣
Edit: it also makes it funny
For me, it makes it a lot funnier 🤣
I don't know... I really don't know how to feel about daniel getting things wrong...
IT AIN'T FAMILIAR
@@nerpiiisbored1472 *FAMILIAH
@@GraciesMelodies um.. the word is familiar..but thanks anyways
Nvm what I said, thanks
*Daniel with other people? IT AIN'T FAMILLIAH!*
Ayo get this man to 10k likes
@@curiousgeorge5311 it ain’t familiah comments are getting old
It is what it is
Loved it ! Can't wait for episode 2 !!!
Hoodie Guy shoulda guessed for Daniel, he's got perfect pitch doesn't he?
What does perfect pitch have to do with this?
@@ggdk2865 It’s one of Daniel’s videos.
Marcus has perfect pitch but it didn't help him any. Digital pianos are in tune so it wouldn't help
*I love Dan’s insistance on it being called digital instead of fake* lol
Roomie: So Daniel I’ll put you down for Fake, Real, Fake?
Daniel: Yeah Digital, Real, Digital
I agree with him.
My florist friends are insistent on saying silk flowers rather than fake flowers. The word fake just takes away from the art when the creation is just as good, if not better, depending on the skills of the artist.
@@thecountrychemist2561 I absolutely agrre
@@thecountrychemist2561 i know nothing about this topic specifically, but i totally agree the word fake adds a negative connotation to it
@@hannalowercase5928 this is odd. I just saw this video recommended to me again yesterday so I rewatched it last night. And then I get a notification from your comment. That sounds suspiciously coincidental. Curious if the algorithm takes into account when commenters last saw a video for how relevant their comments are.
I love how they all just casually have pianos in their shots, even Joel, the non-pianist. He's just sitting there, pretending to be a pianist 😂
He plays quite well, tbh, even if it isn’t his main musical talent. But he’s multitalented, really.
That was a lot of fun to watch! And it shows how incredibly good the digital / sampled piano's are.
daniel at 7:50: what did i get myself into
joel: it aint familiar.
THE COLLAB WE NEVER THOUGHT WE NEEDED
period!
Daniel every time: "That was a Nord Grand and it was uploaded to CZcams on the 28th of June 2019 and has 1,435,677 views; and put on Spotify on the 18th of October 2019 and currently has 980,298 plays."
That was enjoyable just to hear these musical wonders add their precise thoughts... Joel, this video edit was epic! The blurred captioning timing was killer! Instant subscribe!
8:26 "Daniel, your answers aren't specific enough" had me laughing so hard, lmao.
Everyone's thoughts:
Joe: "I have a gut feeling" + "you will never hear the end of acoustic pianos"
Daniel: "My answers must be specific which is why I SUMMON THE DIGITAL NORTH WHITE GRAND"
Marcus: "I'm using complicated words so I must be right, RIGHT? Even tho I actually have no clue"
Joel: "I have no Idea but I want to catch up so I will give the exact opposite answer of the other 3"
*Nord White Grand*
@@crimsnblade8555 WOW, took a while for anyone to notice but I know how to write it, it's just that the way Daniel said it was funny😂
this is so true
joel: "that is really funny"
also joel: *looks sad*
Ha lol I'm just glad I'm not in this compitation
@@_itz_anyusha_shrestha_9937 I would cry 30 seconds in
happy on the inside but dead on the outside ;(
@@azramishal9938 11:23
joel is sad
I love how Daniel doesn't stop being specific even though he almost gets them wrong 😂
I love thid video. Really good concept and talking about something you are not as familiar / an expert in brings variety. Also your choice of guests was spot on.
[2:47] Daniel: I don't like the word "fake", I like the word "digital"!
[4:12]
Everyone: it's digital
Also Daniel: I think it's not real
Since there are no comments i shall comment
atleast he didn't say fake🧘♀️
I mean to be fair, I think you put those 4 people in a room, and someone plays on different types of piano behind a curtain or something and I'm pretty sure they would be spot on. The conversion to a digital file, the type of microphones and the headphones must have a massive impact.
Good point. I listened on my iPad Pro Tablet’s speakers.
As much as I love Joel's solo videos... This energy and back and forth between all of them is just awesome.
Also kinda proud of myself on how many I got right (including #8 HAH!) considering my last piano lessons were 18 years ago.
“Infinity war was the most ambitious crossover even in history”
Me:
I admittedly cackled when it was a “NORD WHITE GRAND.”
The NORD VPN THE SPONSOR FOR TODAYS VIDEO AND BY THE TIME I HAVE TOLD YOU ABOUT NORD VPN I WILL OF MADE A BALLOON
@@AEXU_ so there are people that watch the second half end of his videos 😂
Love watching all of you together.. Hopefully more to come 🔥♥
When you watch all four of them and they do a collab: 😳
This was such a great video! Love all their channels and guessing along with the video was a lot tougher than I thought.
It's a surprise seeing you here,the first musical youtuber i have ever watched.
Keep doing the great job man.
Wait a minute
I know you
Love your vr vids😁
Oh hey :0
A pleasant surprise, but a welcome one
Heyyy sqwizzy, sup with the 2015 cod 2 zombies track?
* Roomie Talks
Daniel: Oh that thing, I have been to their factory
More of this! Epic!
I love all of the people in this video. I didn't know I needed this but I did
Daniel's teachers always tortured him for not being specific....
I appreciate they all took the time to put their pianos in the shots. TV has conditioned me to assume authenticity because of set choices, & I'm ok with that.
Id love to see more of you guys together :D so good
I love the way daniel laugh as he heard marcus opinion,its hilarious 😂
Daniel be like: this is the acoustic piano made in 2009 the wood is from a pine tree I witness being cut that fell in the west while the wind blew east on a cool wednesday.
No one:
Daniel: It was uploaded to Spotify 130 days ago with an ISRC code of 37492
I have never heard of this channel but this video features three of my favorite youtubers so yeah, i'm definitely watching it.
We need more of these people collaborating
Joel finally got a taste of how it feels like to be Jonas in a competition
That is a real OG intro
“Real? Fake? Real?”
Definitely do more of this
It’s really cool when a bunch of you tubers get together to do something like this
Me during the whole video: That's a piano.
Teacher: What is 2+2
Daniel: I was there with the first people that found math, so I would like to say that the answer is 5 and the government is trying to make us think that it's 4, I've been there no way Im wrong!
Teacher: Wrong!
No way!!! I watch you all then I happen to find a video with all of you in just one video?!? This is amazing. Part 2?
The best pianists CZcams reunited in one video. Perfect.
I love how Marcus was the least confident in his answers and then he won. Humble legend
.
.
.
.
.
Also yes I'm basically spamming comments at this point, I had a lot to say about this video I'm sorry
"he got us in the first half not gonna lie..."
Best crossover you gotta love this
Yes i agree with daniel they should so this again
Totally
this video was so much fun, keep em coming!
Thank you! so many new musicians! love it!
When Daniel is giving REALLY specific answers, it kinda reminds me of his video "When You Have Perfect Pitch"
The music community on youtube should be much bigger then others like gaming or vlogging.
I agree
im pretty sure the music community is bigger than those communities already
I just like it when multiple pianists come together and laugh and talk about pianos.
this is the collaboration everyone needed