Draupadi 'Vastraharan' did not happen! A case study: Part 4

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 02. 2024
  • What Sanjay says to Dhritarashtra, after Pandavas leave for Vanavas

Komentáře • 14

  • @VickyGYT
    @VickyGYT Před 18 dny

    One question: as you mentioned dyut was played twice. During first dyut when Duryodhan showed his thighs and Bhima makes a vow how come he knows that they would be going on 13 years Vanvas that time?

  • @rrr4597
    @rrr4597 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Recently saw an expert on Sangam channel refute your dating of 5000~ BCE for Mahabharatha. He claim that anything before 3000~ BCE is absolutely wrong as prr the data from other dynasties across time using interpolation of evidence.
    Looking forward to your rebuttal of his reasoning, pls take time out for it.
    Love your work and thankyou sir

    • @VolodymyrBoyka
      @VolodymyrBoyka Před 3 měsíci +8

      If I'm correct that guy's name is Raja Ram Mohan Roy. That guy is literally a McCaulay product. He keeps quoting the dates of English and American Historians who base their analysis on AIT. What more can I say!

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 3 měsíci +2

      Who is this individual? What specific date s/he is claiming for the year of the Mahabharat war?

    • @NileshOak
      @NileshOak  Před 3 měsíci +8

      I presume you understand the difference between ' attempting a refutation' and 'successfully refusing a claim' or 'making a jackass of oneself while claiming a refutation'

    • @ajaykatnauri9086
      @ajaykatnauri9086 Před 3 měsíci

      Very nice presentation sir.... waiting for your next part.
      czcams.com/video/W2YuGQRmZ9c/video.htmlsi=GTVziNSukoH4h64b
      Above is the link for Raja Ram Mohan Roy who is refuting your date of Mahabharata war.....plz check and share your opinion

  • @atharvshendage4705
    @atharvshendage4705 Před měsícem

    8:50 i can see the translation is correct , but how can bhima say "after 13 years" when there was no mention of such 13 years of vanvas in first game of dyuta but it came later in second game , is sanjay wrong in quoting bhima?

    • @dr.ravishankarpolisetty2820
      @dr.ravishankarpolisetty2820 Před měsícem

      The second game of dice occurred shortly after the first game, within a few hours, resulting in the '13 years' of time spent exile.

    • @VickyGYT
      @VickyGYT Před 18 dny

      I asked the same question. References by Sanjay seem incorrect.

  • @y_k3096
    @y_k3096 Před 3 měsíci +3

    Part 1 - czcams.com/video/BfpDcLPCJpc/video.html
    Part 2 - czcams.com/video/BZcAdSXmPZU/video.html
    Part 3 - czcams.com/video/x_BEBRieSiI/video.html

  • @damonp6366
    @damonp6366 Před měsícem

    "Promo sm" ✅

  • @anilvashist6758
    @anilvashist6758 Před měsícem

    Nilesh ji, if you want your own podcasts on your own channel to get high numbers of viewers (which because of your knowledge you deserve) then please take a few lessons on your content presentation and on your content delivery.

  • @parthapratimchowdhury6756
    @parthapratimchowdhury6756 Před měsícem +2

    Unnecessarily dragging the point in parts after parts and convincingly landing nowhere to prove the claim. It is obvious that the partiular incident would always be repeatatively referred in toto in other Parvas as well. Plz come to the point sharp & specific without wasting watch time of the people.