Top 20 Roblox Train Simulators
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- Choo Choo! 🚂
-
Do you guys agree with me?
What do guys think should be higher/lower?
Let me know in the comments below :-)
-
Lots of honourable mentions this year that were super close but just didn’t make it for one way or the other:
- Mind the Gap
- Steam Era
- Romney, Hythe and Dymchurch Railway
- Trains: Canyon
- Trains: Island
- Hyperloop Simulator
- Tateland Railway
- SRI Terminal
- Just a Train Track Test because I like Trains
Super close competition and I can’t wait to see how things look next year!
-
0:00 Intro
Rails Unlimited
PTA Subway: Callaghan & Madison
Sodor Simulator
Somewhere, Wales
Rails of D.G County
Snow Hill Lines
Metra Train Sim
Train Sim
DJMN Lines
Whitecoast City Railway
Terminal Railways
MBTA Providence Line Train Simulator
Itty Bitty Railway
Rail Sim Universe Pre-Release
Trainware
Grand Continental Railways
Steam & Steel
Stepford County Railway
Streamlined
British Railway
Outro
-
Join my Discord here:
/ discord
Or my Roblox Fan group here:
www.roblox.com/groups/9650560... - Hry
There is one thing that makes Rails Unlimited stand out from the rest: derailments. This game has a heavier focus on derailing your train, with dedicated sounds and effects and your train not glitching through the floor when falling over (except for old yard). Although it is very difficult to derail your train because you have to either go through a very tight curve at a very high speed or switch a junction while your train is on it.
Very cool!
Hey, thanks for playing RU! We definitely do need to focus a lot on the points you've noted. We're working on more replayability and other general improvements.
Yo, coaster was up. It's me mr noob, glad your game is getting recognition
Sounds good!
That would be amazing! I remember the currency system, as well as the customization of consists, being teased a good while ago, yet both of them have yet to even be mentioned again. I would absolutely _love_ for both to be in the game, as they actually looked great!
Thanks for playing Rail Sim Universe! We have made a TON of new updates and changes since this was filmed, and have a very rapid update schedule. We would love to see your thoughts on the latest changes we have made.
I would also like to address the 500 robux price, it's intended to be a limited time novelty purchase to help us fund development. Players receive several special trains (for free) with every route expansion we add in the future. The game will be 100% free to play when we complete it.
i love rsu
RSU is EASILY a top 3 train game on roblox for me
Ong
@@traindude432 same
The real RES 😮
The reason I like Stepford and British Railway is because trains can not drive through each other. There’s a whole system that prevents trains from crashing into each other and users ending up on the same tracks driving through each other, and I hope other games adopt this system.
I believe WCR also has such a system. The BR one is the best in my opinion though, because of the ghost feature. Makes it hard or even impossible to purposefully block the signals because you'll just get ghosted if you try.
It's called signals
“Trains cannot drive through each other”
Leaton Depot:
@@Foxy_AR Oh god oh no not that bug
I remember playing that Hyperloop game tons years ago... Bit of a throwback seeing that
As a DJMM member, I can explain why the game is so broken. Since Roblox started to update their software, DJMM also tried to keep up. Unfortunately, they mostly put effort into new features instead of fixing the game to the new Roblox software which resulted in your part loss for example, or tracks could be missing which can make you derail and so I could go on and on. People where also mad at the management for promising things like the Metropolitan and Northern line, but they only added half-made lines which where only accessible with gamepass trains. And they where also mad at them for the state of the game, which resulted in the owner of the game robbing the group of its funds and flee. The game is now transforming into a brand new community, called All Change community. We are hoping that this time the direction won’t disappoint us.
i am a DJMM member too, i can remember the strikes and everything.. the game was in a horrible state and i honestly have not played it in a while
be honest
@@S.11Ayers730 what?
@@masonsmainlineroblox the applesville stuff he means
Omg thanks for putting BR in first place, it deserves it compared to SCR about a lot of things like physics, consistency of electric trains (with pantographes) and diesel trains and even the AI passengers features imo
Snow hills lines... I remember that people called it "The NEW SCR" cause it was realistic at the time and has custom train option, but is now forgotten cause of the physics and the just lack of updates :/
Just found out about the video. Thanks for playing Terminal Railways!
I agree with the points you said and we are currently working on improving them.
We are also releasing freight with jobs and contracts soon so that should make the game a bit more interesting + many optimizations and map upgrades :)
As someone who also plays train games beside flight sims on roblox, im very excited for this video
I approve this list, but I personally miss ro-scale sandbox, where you can build your own railway, not play on a prebuilt map, and sure, it doesn't really fall into the train sim category, but in my opinion, it would deserve a honorable mention.
I agree, i miss SRI Terminal, Northeast Corridor Train Sim, Empire Corridor Train Sim and Southline District in this video
Definitely a good shout, Itty Bitty Railway was on the list so I don’t see why RSS couldn’t be! I just missed it when compiling a list to review lists
@@PatronRBLXI’m an admin for Ro Scale Sandbox. We have the largest community of Live Steam Enthusiasts on Roblox, players who build more realistic full size models than most games listed, life-like model layouts and frequent updates. Itty Bitty Railway is a crappy cash grab compared to RSS.
@@spencercohen2673 which one? (this is plimbo)
@@PatronRBLX hello, administrator Mr_signals of Ro scale sandbox here.i'd like to say that we got one of the largest communities among live steam enthusiasts on roblox. and no offense but they're building much better full size models than most of the games upon this list. the game wasn't meant for that purpose but some people wanna be creative which is a great thing. and looking at itty bitty railway. ro scale sandbox has a lot more options upon sceneries and creativity.
I'm so glad streamlined was mentioned! Such a great video ty
14:00 A proper tutorial rework has been in the works for a while.
the current tutorial was kind of just... jammed in when I very unexpectedly had some youtubers play the game and needed to throw something together in about a day.
Definitely glad to see you've been enjoying the game so much!
Cheers!
-GregTame
It’s currently one of my favourite games on the platform! Keep up the amazing work!
Great video! Thanks for using clip of Western Railway! (Steam & Steel)
The reason for Snow Hill Line's lack of updates is that it was discontinued years ago and now is unsupported entirely. The studio behind it however, Centro, are working on a very impressive looking tube game simulating the Victoria Line. It's probably the most innovative in years on the basis of UI, sounds, models, etc etc, so I do suggest you give it a try when it releases hopefully sometime in the remaining portion of the year.
i used to LOVE snow hill lines until it went downhil.
@@NecromaninticdinosFr, when it released, it was arguably top 5 beat train games in roblox and competing with scr and gcr for most players
Fourth Rail's Northern line will be a fierce competitor
@@spottymaxy1628 that didn’t age well
@@Foxy_AR 🤯
Rail Sim Universe has changed very much since patron took those clips. I'm not sure how many trains there are but it's definitely more then 3 or 5. However you still made a great video!
yea Rail Sim Universe needs another look imo
There are about a dozen or so, but we have over 60 unique pieces of rolling stock ready to be inserted as soon as are core is ready!
Awesome to hear!
Glad to see Streamlined in second place! We'll see what we can do with your suggested improvements :)
I am glad to! Love streamlined fr
nice video! as someone who's a fan of railway games but sadly hasn't been able to find many outside the mainstream ones this is much appreciated!
Thank you very much! Remember to check out some of the honourable mentions in the comments too!
Very good video but i do believe that other games such as OIR, Northeast Corridor and Trainways should have been on this list, however at the end of the day finding room for everything is not simple so i understand why you may have missed some
Thank you for playing RSU! Since your last visit, we have done many updates and plan to have more out soon. We hope you can come back and make another video on RSU!
Sincerely,
Matt
Support Representative/Game Tester
Can't wait to see where the game goes next!
@@PatronRBLXcan you make another video of rail sim universe?
Trainways is a very underrated sim set in Sydney. it is by far my favorite but is missing a signaling system. i would definitely give it a try!
Please consider trying out the Northeast Corridor Train Simulator! It contains the full route between NYC and Philadelphia and has more advanced current systems but similar to the MBTA game.
omg its BIT
You should try playing RSU again, they have added approximately 5 new stations and multiple more locomotives and trains since you last played, that I think you would enjoy.
Fr he needs to play rsu again
Awesome video! I'm currently a dev for Rail Sim Universe, The price tag will be eliminated upon final release, and we have much more features on the way!
awesome! I'm gonna wait a bit before buying, just to see what other content gets added.
Hi there, stranger!
@@RailwayEngineeringStudios first lol
Yea but won’t that take like a year or two?
@@Adumzzinthehouse no it says early-mid 2024 so like 6 months at most
The roscale games are modeled off of real train lines in America and is basically a small recreation. You can go on google maps and compare.
Stream lined also gets constant updates like new/updated model, events with limited timed engines and wagons, and while it currently is in Alpha, and will probably stay there for a while, once it's in Beta, it'll be free with private servers also free
Really interesting video with lots of good points made - I developed the games in the Trains series (the latest, Express, released two months ago) and would love to hear any feedback you’ve got!
6:00, the flowers and other foliage are clipping thru the tracks because they haven't been handled very well, which is realistic for Eastern Europe. I live in eastern europe and it's very common
Finally a good best train video
PTFS got some crazy training updates
As of today rail sim universe as progressed a lot more stations and trains have been added. It has a lot of potential.
Thank you for this, it was really helpful.
Glad it was helpful!
I edge to this
Hahahhahahhaha so funny
Uuh what
But sir you are a train
Wat
What the br class 73 doin
Rail Sim Universe has a crap ton of new updates since this was filmed
"Top 20 roblox train simulators"
Dovedale railway: Am i a joke to you?
this is a very nice video!
now that you've done plane and train, can you do busses next?
Maybe!
Brotish Railway also offers interactable cab controls for a more emersive experience too!
Are you an IGN presenter, cause this is what you sound like lol. A really good video
Ro scale sandbox is a lot better than itty bitty railway and doesn't suffer from major gameplay mechanics behind gamepasses.. and its free :D
Anyone who is interested in building your own railway should definitely try it out.
Hello there, i'm Jhota, a Trained Driver Instructor at WCR. We thank you for your feedback, and that you still enjoyed the game. Hope to see you again soon ingame, or in a training!
Thank you too!
For people who don't know about rail sim universe: its a game based in South Florida (west palm beach to Miami) and the commuter train tri-rail its getting updated over the months and seemed to release probably in 2025 what I saw and its worth the robux
My suggestion Northeast Corridor train simulator, it’s basically MBTA but it has tons of more content and much more built out.
SRI Terminal & Southline District too
When I saw Metra, I thought northeast corridor would be on here, because in my opinion it is much better
@@captaincactus5247 Yep
Thanks for playing Train Sim, i'm Contributor for this game :)
I didn’t expect for you to play or featured a Thomas game in this video, I thought Steam Age/Era was going to take the 18th spot. But anyways, This “Top 20 Roblox Train Simulators” video is pretty good, your opinion of the train sims in this top 20 is kinda similar to mine actually. Btw if you want a free Roblox Thomas game, I would highly recommend Blue Train With Friends or Sodor Online Jobs A Plenty (although as for today, December 3rd, 2023, the “Jobs A Plenty” part is replaced with “Snow Time To Lose”)
SCR is very good, but you can't stay in schedule if driving somewhat normally. Also you need too much grind to progress in routes/trains imo
5:00 it is based off the NNSF Metra racetrack between Chicago and Aurora
According to this list, good video.
In Spain we have the C5 Cercanias Madrid, L8 of FGC and L2 of the Barcelona metro.
The rest of the simulators still need to polish many things.
Hello Patron! I was the ATC from aeronautica!
wow, RSU changed so much in these 3 months. Cant believe this is what it used to look like, its so different now lol
Thank you, as a mobile player this is super helpful 👍.
Glad it helped!
that's a funny looking plane simulator
Ikr
Fr
Thanks for checking out D.G. County!
Any time!
These are my favorites
SRI. DG county.
Logging through the great depression. Strasburg last golden Spike. Somewhere in Wales.
Also, in your review DG county is the older version There’s a newer version.
The style of the PTA System map mirrors the one the New York MTA uses. They in fact do not use a diagram-style map and settle on a geographically realistic map.
The new Rails of D.G County is a whole lot better than the old one. Better map for navigation, amazing UI, and it’s a lot more immersive since you have to manually fill your locomotives with water as well as filling gondolas with coal
I'll check it out!
I am disappointed that Trainways didn't get a mention (basically because I am Australian) but this was a very enjoyable video to watch.
I didnt think streamlined and itty bitty railway would rank so high! But yea this list is very relatable
Bit disappointed i didn't see finish rails but thanks for making this new video that I happily edged to.
I’ve never played it! I tried to research as many games as possible but it looks like I missed a few!
happy edging!
there is zero context here and i hate it
I suggest if you do another same video to put Generation Trains in the video😁
Hey there! Well Train Sim (czech and Slovak game P13) doesnt feature four models. It is way more, but at the start you have four FREE trains, the rest needs to be bought by in-game credits or robux. Just for info :)
Mind The Gap is one of my personal favorites, and it feels like its been here for years. Give it a try!
My favourite train simulator is Finnish railway. It's, as the title suggests, a Finnish train simulator. There is a mediocre variety of trains and LOTS of carriages. It's about as realistic as Train Sim where if you power up certain trains too quickly, they stall out and do not move.
I’ve never heard of this one! Will have to check it out!
The few problems I had with the game (despite buying all but two gamepasses):
- Performance
- Scenery
- The models are alright but again, very laggy.
@@ArCKonan The performance is probably more to do with the device you are using rather than the game itself. I run it quite smoothly since I have a very strong computer.
@@benukasrYT Lots of parts- I do get 20fps or so, which is playable, but it definitely doesn't feel as smooth as other titles.
I've personally played a lot of these, but I personally recommend taleland railway. Extremely detailed, and a lot of engines to choose, standard and narrow.
Dude whos that hot fv107 guy at the end holy moly
RSU has more than 3 trains, decent replayablility, same map, but fun
I used to be a dev for Romney, nice to see it mentioned here
one thing i don’t like about itty bitty railway is the fact that you can’t really build with your friends on one plot
I almost Play RSU everyday, it’s the best
train sim now had alot of updates from the time you played.. now it has more than 20 trains, controls arent as confusing and some bugs are fixed.. though it still lags a lot
interesting how DJMN in it's current state made it onto this list. aside from all the stuff related the group itself, the game now has been highly neglected since most of the former developers (understandably) archived all of their meshes that have been used (this includes the train exterior, as well as ticket barriers and some other misc like decals)
(one more thing is how badly they were replaced, like the mesh ticket barriers that have been replaced with a wide 2d decal)
update wise:
-there was meant to be a whole new revamped map which had better stations, tracks, trains etc
-they tried to merge it with the current map, which was a bad choice considering the current map had 0 quality control (it was made by 50 different developers so scenery, quality and detail became heavily inconsistent)
-it was never finished
and i havent even mentioned the DLR, metropolitan and northern lines all of which were only partially finished and never released
i was a dev there during the 2021-2022 period which i'd say was when the game peaked before all of the stuff happened
As an MBTA Railfan from Rhode Island, I approve this video
4:41 fun fact the game is based off a real life train line in Chicago Illinois
Given the Ro-Scale usage, Im super surprised that Northeast Corridor Line isn't on here which gives a very accurate, Semi straight line scale of the NJ Transit and Septa section of the Northeast Corridor.
Exist too the "Northeast Corridor Train Sim" its so realistic with great models
btw metra train sim is based off the racetrack and is a real route, it’s the bnsf line
there were to many that were not put in here but i wont complaine btw RSU has gotten many updates need to do a recap on that cause the more people that know the better it will be
Snow Hill Lines' standalone feature is that it's set in Birmingham with all the same scenery as the real world
I am proud to be a Train Sim contributor
Pov: Half of them are not suitable for mobile. (Somewhere wales used to be, but new updates made it too much)
I hear there's a newer train game with some of the RU devs, its called Generation Trains. check it out sometime
5:52 no way bro just said that
You should have added Northeast corridor train simulator, Its a game similar to the Providence and Metra game you included in the video. The game is based on the Northeast corridor located on the East coast of the USA, The game stretch's from NYC-Philly.
Hey patronimo! Did you consider the game "Northeast Corridor Train Simulator" by American Rail Studio? They have a realistic map that's true to life, between the cities of Philadelphia and New York City. I'm curious to know whether you simply didn't hear of this game, or decided to not include it in the list for other reasons.
I actually live along a section of the map, and I can confirm it is very realistic and nearly looks the same as in real life. Every single building along the tracks are modelled just as they are in real life.
I did not! When making the list for this video I spent hours asking as many people for as many train games as possible, there is just so many train games and unfortunately it looks like a few good ones.
Oh yes NECTS is amazing.
As a developer for ARS was very sad to not see our game featured and yet see our sister games there that we actually brought about(we donated a lot of systems to MBTA and Metra)😢. Glad to know it was simply you missing the game.
you can go 1000 mph if you alter the speed of the trains
There's also cool Philippine railway games, an example would be Daang Bakal of Ablaze
Train sim has lots more trains but you have to pay for them (by in game money you earn from driving)
Thank you for great review of Train Sim!
There is much more trains to buy in the game shop for the earned money.
Anyway, we already saved all important bugs and confusing things you talked about in the video and we will look into that!
Train Sim development team
Thanks for that!
Devy_y's yt channel spotted
congrats on winning the korn landing comp
You should check out metro mania, its a game about the bucharest metro. While it may not sound very intriguing, it has 5 lines built in the game, as well as 3 drivable metro trains.
Rail Sim Universe has added new trains and they are working on making new maps soon.
PTA is fun but they are so harsh in discord crazy stuff lmao and the fact that NEC Simulator isn’t on here is crazy
RSU has changed quite a lot since😂
For tycoon style game, you can try roscale sandbox
a creepy fact about somewhere wales is that if you go down in the mines you could hear a scream
Wow trainware has barely changed in 4-5 years - crazy how far ahead of its time it once was though
RSU will be free by 2024 it is still inder development.
Try RSU again, it's much improved from last time with an absolutely massive map.
Although sodor sim is good, it is very buggy like I used to have 27 locations unlocked and then I lost them and I was back to 25 locations, I also couldn’t teleport to the places I lost
I think that Northeast Corridor train sim should have had a spot
I’ve never played it! I tried to research as many games as possible but it looks like I missed a few!
i mostly agree whit everything in your list execpt for scr being number 3 sure it may be large but its super strict for how easy it is thats juts my opion btw
Honestly I agree for the most part