Author Vikram Sampath on Savarkar, RSS, Cow Worship, Meat Eating, Hindutva then & now | Barkha Dutt
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 07. 2021
- Historian and writer Vikram Sampath is back with the second edition of his volume on Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, one that details his contested legacy. Join Barkha Dutt as she discusses the historiography with the Bangalore based author.
#VeerSavarkar #VikramSampath #Indianhistory - Zábava
News to you Barkah , Hindus do have Muslim role model = APJ Abdul Kalam!
Wonderful.
and many many more..but a bigoted news trader like burkha wont see it.
Spot on. Indian across all religions have role models we look up to that belong to different religions. APJ Abdul Kalaam is one of the many role models that followed Islam.
However the so called liberal media which pretends to care about muslims by calling them minority. It is an insult to muslims and other religions. If it was not for the vote bank media will not even concern and there will not be any appeasement politics.
Buddhists, Jains SIkhs Jews others are far less but no one from thos communities every uses the minority flag.
Strength of India is in our diversity and respect for all citizens that follow the rule of law and put the country before religion. Religious freedom will only exist if country is secure.
KK Muhammed too he deserves so much respect from hindus.
Prodigal son will always be remembered as a britisher bootlicker so is the RSS...
Kudos to Vikram for sticking to his views and rightly so, especially in the beginning despite incessant efforts filled with wokeism made by the anchor to sway him. Talking about the Hindu refugees he said, "Where else will they go." It requires amazing amount of conviction to tell the truth on the face.
I agree with u totally
Kuddos to anchor for back slap on 2nd view of this genius writer of World on Kashmir. Nicely given back Barkha...Good job !!
She didn't answer to that question😂😂😂😂😂 and there she got her own answer
Vikram Sampath did an awesome job responding to BD’s questions. Love this author.
Barkha - Q1
Vikram - Answers
Barkha - Okay, now time for whataboutery!
😂😂😂true
This is what annoys me. I respect her for what she believes but her arguments are complete bs sometimes.
burqa is blind by her arabic burqa....
@@adityajoies What she indulges is defined as "Chala" in Nyaya (or vaisheshika) shastra. I.e. speak something that appears to be related at the outset, but is not. The goal of "chala" tactics is to disrupt the train of thought of the opponent, or to disrupt the attention people listening to your opponent have. So she is willing to appear as an idiot propounding BS, if the end result is dilution of her opponent (i.e. anyone not buying into a Nehruvian view)
@@adityajoies j
Burqa came prepared after watching his interview with Shekar Gupta (Print) but her lack of knowledge is still evident by her questions.
Typical Darbari patrakaar lot of words no real knowledge
The interview was excellent. Vikram was cool and his replies were too good. Barkha as usual had great tinges of bias against the present ruling dispensation in India, and one could see it from her questions. Cannot blame her, for she had to appease her masters. She was alert at times not to go wayward in her bias, for she was aware that she was interviewing a highly knowledgeable person who had authentic researched matter up his sleeves. Barkha couldn't get any gun powder to blow her trumpet to substantiate her bias views against hindutva and hindu rashtra, for Vikram was forthright and destroyed her questions by very factual and convincing answers.
Wonderful views Sir!
Very well expressed. Just like how I felt too.
Excellent observation
Even I felt the same...very well said
I don't why your commentary is more on Barkha and less on Samapt who actually was being interviewed. is it your own bias
To be completely frank...being a Maharashtrian we always had respect for Vinayak Damodar Savarkar from our school times. But for past ~10 years, I was little confused after seeing opposition to him from the other political side. Vikram's interview with Shekhar brought me back from my confused state of mind to again worship Veer Savarkar. I still remember 'Sagara Pran Talamalala' a marathi poem written by him when he was jailed in Andaman jail....I still remember the most of the poem, that we sung when we were in school. This is beautifully sung by Lata Mangeshkar....
czcams.com/video/I4pJ0aD5RtA/video.html
dave buddhibhrast kartil, apan adun rahayche...
Unfortunately his caste is his undoing as Meem Bheem, Christian politics demonised him though it's he was jailed for 27 years. His caste lost political relevance hence he as well. Under congress written history all Hindu Mahasabha, RSS etc leaders not only sidelined but also demonized. Syam Prasad Mukherjee presence in the first cabinet, Savarkar before independence itself shows their prominence in national movement but completely ignored by Nehru deliberately. It's all about himself and Gandhi.
@@SR-fs2fd what was he doing in Europe bro? Why would he go there for honeymoon?
your mind was manipulated with to deliberate be confused with.
And indira gandhi had Hridaynath Mangeshkar summarily removed from All India Radio for singing that song. Anyone saying anything positive about Savarkar or RSS were punished openly. And the press did not even cover such stories. That's how Freedom of Expression came alive and democracy was born under 70 years of congress rule.
Came here for entertainment esp how vikram destroys burkha's claims😂😂😂
This is what happens when an intellectual who is trying to be objective meets someone who is trying to spin a biased narrative.
Who's who do you mean!? This statement applies equally to both of them.
@@Skywalker-zs9tf it is the person who is asking the same questions that she also asked in her previous interview just to pander to her following
@@Skywalker-zs9tf How and from when does the word intellectual apply to Barkha? She still believes that the Kashmiri Pandits were driven out because they were exploiting the poor and hapless Kashmiri Muslims. Not to mention, her highly "intellectual" and detailed reporting of the Kargil war divulging IND's positions, and she still continues the same, reporting from cremation grounds, while being so aware and vocal about her own rights and freedom.
@@Skywalker-zs9tf she has her pockets filled with narrative.
@@Skywalker-zs9tf why wasta time here if you see both as biased?
The amount of research done and clarity on the subject has no match. Vikram you are mindblowing!!
Why you are watching this anti india and anti hindu channel pls watch jaipur diloge
@@adityatripathi3107
Jaipur dialogue is actually anti India
This lady is devious to say the least..very opportunistic interventions throughout the discussion..when it's not fitting her intended narrative..
Devil dutta
This is a subtle debate masquerading as an interview. Vikram is a scholar who cites evidence and the counter to it from the "debater" is rhetoric. She allows her ideological preferences to rise to the occasion, which gets reflected in her impatience.
It is Barkha who brought this Sanghi man to track from Hindu -Muslim ideological blabbering and asked him to stick to Sawarkar.
Any well read man can be a scholar.But that does not wash his prejudices and ideological fixations.
Vikram is an apology for scholarship like all right wingers are
@@gangadharhiremath7306 any well read man can be a scholar right. Similarly any well read woman could be an anchor. And that’s what Barkha is , just a left inclined news presenter.
@@sivaramanmudaliar9728 seriously?
True, very biased n no substance from the interviewer. Her focus on mercy petition was jarring for me.. the battle continues.
More I listen about Veer Savarkar more I admire him. You will live in our heart. He stand on his ground despite the torture and trauma he received for the same.
Pls watch jaipur diloge
The author of this book is a good scholar.. Request him to write a book on Aurangzeb
He is right now researching about Tipu Sultan
All round study ! Great no doubt !mr vikram samptji 👍👍!
Jadunath Sarkar has written a fantastic book on Aurangzeb . You can refer that
Fatva a aalmgiri from jypur dylog 👍👍!
All hail hyder Ali... But why he attacked RANI CHENNAMMA?
Barkha is looking so uncomfortable...... 😂😂
The way the so called ‘liberal’ channels are promoting Vikram Sampat’s books on Veer Savarkar indicates two things: first, serious scholarship cannot be wished away easily; the second that times are a changing in so much that Savarkar cannot be bad-labelled and pushed under the carpet. A lesson for right wing scholars is to take their work very very seriously. Like Dr B R Ambedkar he will rise like a Phoenix.
Riddles of Hinduism will be condemned by the Brahminical mindset society who are cowards like Savarkar.
@@kevincastelino3209 @Kevin Alex is this comment of yours some kind of cryptic clue we are suppose to unravel?
@@kevincastelino3209 ur totally off tangent like the host who's paid to drum up a wrongful narratives which has been totally demolished hearing this discussion.... grow up Alex the culture in this country is beyond narrow ideological mooring as my way is the highway....
@@kevincastelino3209 that's my fear for Hinduism that even we don't get abrahamised with sanskrit names that we get so blindly opinionated that we shut all shutters of our mind and talk like you . I am sure you also call people "bhakt" , consume news as per your own bias and believe in Aryan invasion theory which now became Aryan migration theory and soon to be Aryan tourism theory 😂
@bharat pandit I think it's lil bit of first one but dominanted by market and marketing . Good marketing by Vikram that he could outshine taboos (to far left) through brand Vikram and far left will become irrelevant if they don't serve the center left ( majority in india / bjp voters) hence marketing . Ultimately champagne socialites have to make enough to get their champagne 🥂
Barkha is facing the uncomfortable truth ! LOL maza aa gaya
Haha.... her heart is churning like hungry stomach
Amazing Vikram Sampath u stuck to truth no matter how hard she tried to steer you away to her biass
I like the way vikram answered the most expected, stereotyped Marxist centric questions. Well done Virkram!
Undoubtely , veer Savarkar was the greatest thinker, social reformer , freedom fighter and greatest of all his contemporaries !
Many congratulations and gratitude to vikram for presenting the historical facts in such a brave and articulate way !
Salute to him !
Yet another brilliant, scholarly and composed replies by Vikram to provocative questions. Hats off to Mr. Sampath's knowledge based on deep and wide research and ability to present in such logical and lucid ways.
Thanks Barkha for bringing up a subject that many people shy away from.
Thanks Vikram for standing your ground despite the many deviations when your points validated the right.
@Goblin and when will our left guys understand this?
@Goblin people actually think that donkey cares for India. Idiotic. First I thought he was a good critic, turned out to be an idiotic leftist.
Vikram Sampath was just brilliant
Mard / himmat vala hi veer savrkar pr likh bol sakta hai !
Ramachandra Guha can learn a few historic lessons from this young pleasant intelligent young man! JN U is the last place to learn history!
Can you really blame them? Entire careers were made out of selective retelling of national history and continually-divisive victim narratives by leftists and Islamists.. Going as far back as the now-disproved "Aryan Invasion/Migration theory". Those ultra-erudite souls don't have any choice but to stand by their theories and publications, even in the face of undeniable facts, truths and new discoveries/proofs to the contrary. Pathetic.
Every one knows everything about Sawarkar.It is what we pick,what we highlight and what we ignore that makes us whether we accept or reject that person.
Vikram Sampat does not know any thing extra.From the very out set,he is a lover of Hindutwa and hence tries to justify everything about Sawarkar.
Therefore it is more important to discuss the ideology of that person than the personality.
*Sawarkar was a dark intriguing secretive personality and his ideology for India was supremacist,divisive and not acceptable.*
Rest all is beating around the bush
@@gangadharhiremath7306 please provide us with verifiable evidence of this. Not anecdotal evidence or personal opinions.
@@suen3634 Dark: Involvement in Gandhi assassination(Kapoor committee report 1968).
Secretive:His refusal to even make eye contact with Nathuram Ghodse,let alone speak,during the trial of Gandhi's assassination.Numarous accounts and book on this hugely public event of Indian History are testimony to this.
It is said that the Harsh years in cellular Jail,enduring torture,insult and seclusion for almost 14 years,made him bitter,
paranoid,suspicious as well as bigoted.
For the confirmation of above statement
you may have to read beyond hero worshippers like Vikram Sampat.I can't provide you an immediate list of books.
Please search.
Divisive:His Hindutwa ideology which is in the public domain is an open proof of that.
@@suen3634 Your demand is funny.How can I provide "verifiable evidence" without relying on the accounts of some ppl who wrote about him?What if you call them as mere hostile observations?
Today we see the top two leaders.
Both are secretive and dark for me.
How can I provide verifiable evidence
without relying on other's accounts?
Guys this is not about right or left. Its about the truth. The truth is all of us need completion and healing from our past.
I wish Burkha Rest In Peace ☮️
🤣🤣
@@sid2173 😂😂😂
haha jon snow ? arya here
@@aryastark879 Oh my Sister 😭😭😭
@@aryastark879 are you still playing with needle ?
Vikram is simply great. I really appreciate his his response to many provocative questions of Barkha. Especially murder of Gandhiji by Godse.
For lack of evidence Savarkar escaped
@@nonvinkeregopalakrishna2363 or may be just a false accusation in the first place..I think people like you who have least bothered to read the man simply want to manufacture evidence to support your terribly biased view of him😏which has unfortunately been internalised by many due to mainstream media and political speeches
@@nonvinkeregopalakrishna2363 no evidence idiot
You can see restlessness brewing inside Barkha's soul throughout the interview.
😂🤣😂
Vikram’s interview on The Print with Shekhar Gupta is much better and descriptive ,
Here Barkha seems to be more interested to pin present Govt for example she gave long monologue on beef politics of today
Shows how being first badass journalist as she has marketed herself, doesn't help here.
If you think a close-minded SheGu was descriptive, imagine how horrible Burkha is.
Watch his interview at Carvak Podcast, that one is the best
Totally agree with you....it's always the same with her. Kudos to Vikram for his calm level headed answers. I'm sure he wishes he could stuff a plate of beef down her throat😂 Poor guy just wants to talk about his effing book for goodness sake.
Agreed
First this lady needs to be taught correct history... Also journalisim
Amazing.
Barkha left speechless so many times .
Baktiapur station .history is interim
Amazing intellect. And without the pompousness of romila thapar
Barkha comes across as phony.
Which she is of course .
I wonder if the Thapars, Guhas or Habibs could have ever survived if not for the Congress govt's patronage
@@avishekbhattacharjee812 no chance. They were leeches who had a Faustian pact
Mercy petition is similar to "Ganima Kaava" tactics of Shivaji Maharaaj
Karma Ayurveda
*SURELY*.
Vikram is right, we have to heal ourselves
Nice for a Muslim to say that I feel sir! The buried debris of the past becomes an obstacle to love in the present.
Healing can’t be done when you keep on scratching the wounds
@@zeenatahmed990 lol, how can you scratch the wounds when leftists are hiding the wounds.
@@zeenatahmed990 secularism is greater than religion and anyone who disagrees with this is the reason for the wounds
Hats off to Vikram Sampath! Barkha Dutt tried her best to interrupt Vikram when he was talking about stuff that she didn't like (32.5 min marker, for example).
Wish we had a 100 Savarkars
At least 30-40 are now operating in the country. We might only see about a dozen of them on the front, but more are there, and more are in the making! We must do our part I feel to empower our poor in the meantime, and enable more strength and confidence for the poor.
All sanghis r sawarkar
Asking apology is the common fact of all sanghis
@@ameenameen4833 Don't downgrade Savarkar by comparing him with a sanghi, It's like saying Mohammad is same as any other Muslim😉😉
@@dengxaoping5031
Ok sorry but sawarkar was a head sanghi who started era for asking apologies so many times written letters to British government for release him frm prison , that following now also by his followers.
Am not mind watever u r saying abt our lovely prophet
He is the best and greatest of human history
Check - THE HUNDRED
@@ameenameen4833 I didn't say anything on Prophet , I was just giving an analogy.
And I'd encourage you to see on CZcams what VIKRAM SAMPATH (the guy in this video) has said about the "apologies" written by Savarkar. It would be best if you read the biography itself.
You should see the videos of Vikaram on Savarkar with an open mind, I bet you'd change your stance on the current politics.
The amenities that Nehru had during his jail term and the treatment that Savarkar got at the hands of the British even after he got out shows who's the stooge.
So what do you want? Make a new hero out of Savarkar?
@@sarbajitghosh5244 new hero, Sawarkar was and shall always remain a Hero.
Even if nin compoops like u think otherwise
@@stack7340 What makes you so apprehensive about whether someone thinks otherwise about your hero? Actually I am not intetested in a larger than life picture of either Gandhi or Savarkar. Nor am I interested in pitting one against the other. What provoked me to write the initial comment was the remark on 'Abrahamic' and 'Indic'worldview. First of all, it is an altogether wrong way of thinking-- highly tentative speculation. Secondly no civilization in any of the continents could remain totally insulated from other civilization. As if we haven't been enriched at all by the Mughals or the Pathans!
Savarkar's Portrait is there in Parliament Central Hall now. In the new Parliament Building, there shall be a STATUE.
@@sarbajitghosh5244 Savarkar's Portrait is there in Parliament Central Hall now. In the new Parliament Building, there shall be a STATUE.
Vikram has been really brilliant here while Barkha quite predictable on her baiting points. Like described in other comments she has made it more as a debate than discussion. But the discussion remained civil. Vikram should be a spokesman for the Right
Well articulated analysis Sir! But you are bang on when you say that he should be a speaker for the right! He expresses so fluidly, so well, and without malice and anger :)
I am happy that Barkha has been able to bring about facts of The daredevil and visionary freedom fighter Vinayak Damaodar Savarkar.Hope her political favourites like rahul gandhi, kamalnath and likes and will rethink and amend their comments and say sorry to their conscience minds.
Vikram out-awed his host by miles.
How many times must barkhaji ask about mercy petitions and cow slaughter? All these questions were asked in the first interview. Lazy interviewing.
Thousand times.
Yes,that needs to be asked thousand times to those ideological stooges of Sawarkar.
Lazy?
For her age, you can't do one hundredth of what Barkha is doing.
True. Same questions. I was expecting something new apart from this political jabs.
@@singhnaveen5694For those who are a bit more than average readers,not much can be gained from these so called scholars.
Five letters of Sawarkar pleading mercy are in the public domain.His role in the killing of Mahatma is in public domain.
His silence against British after release from prison till 1947 is known to every one.All his stories big and small,pre and post Andaman are known to us.
No doubt Sawarkar is an enigmatic personality but nothing new is brought out by the admirer "scholar".
Mr.Sampat is simply soft peddling the personality of a dark person whose ideology he is subscribing to.
@@gangadharhiremath7306 Gangadhar, clearly you are one of those who wants the 1950s, 60s and 70s version of history to be frozen in stone.
An actual structure built in stone was brought down; so, you better understand and appreciate the mood of the nation - I can't say if we want reconciliation, but we definitely want the truth.
Vikram Sampath's book is a great service in the cause of looking for and finding the truth.
The Truth shall Triumph.
It always does.
@@sukhbirnaidu4360 You are asking me to decide about the TRUTH based on the present Modi controlled mood.
Thank you for your suggestion.
Barkha whenever question arises about Liaqat pact she immediately gives her opinion of what should be done almost nullifying the pact. We all know Hindus and Muslims have to live together and we know country was divided on religious lines.
It's called indoctrination. She has to defend her "faith" at every turn.
@@marshallmendonza partition was the best thing happened ( excluding all the pain and suffering) for india
@@marshallmendonza Did Savarkar also do Khilafat movement where Muslims showed they cared more about Turkey than their own supposed country? GIve me a break.
@@Dariusdagr8 Please understand what the topic is all about. Then comment.
@@marshallmendonza Fact is that Gandhi/Nehru agreed to partition while Savarkar opposed it. That's the reality you have to live with.
29:04, Vikram Sampathji nailed it. We will definitely not oppose naming of a street as Kalam Street or Bismillah Khan Street or Azim Premji street.
We need to put our complete/intense effort in in educating our younger generations about Veer Savarkar and let them decide who the real father of the nation is Jai Hind !!!
Revisionism happens even in science ...... Newton's laws underwent revision post Einstein. THe geocentric view of the world was replaced by the heliocentric view of the world. Satyameva Jayate. How silly is Barkha ... But hers is the view of the Abrahamic religion ... One book uttered once.
Does " revisionism'" happen in science? I thought it was always used in the pejorative science for ideologies and in this case for history. I note that a number of analysts in other academic disciplines, are beginning to use the historical. At the moment, Law rules ok,? Economics has had its day. Historians are taking on the mantle, to find a corner in which to park themselves as futurologists and capture the limelight.
Was the interviewer playing the devil's advocate,as one would expect her to do so? I hope interviewers do not become publicity agents. They are here to probe and enlighten. Seeking the truth? Every historian has a bias. This author and the subject he writes about, could only gain all this publicity, as it has a friendly political persuasion.
.
,
She exposes herself with such interviews 😂😂😂
This very conversation is happening because of BJP victory in 2014. An alternate version of Indian History to the unchallenged version has a voice. Fascinating!
this is an effort to rewrite the history devoid of facts anbd contexts. Just as bhakts do. Bhakti is necessarily faith based and not reason based.
@@1ahmed2 he is not writing books out of thin air . He is giving reference and sources. Try to accept alternate thought as well you may or may not like.
Yes. True. Let’s not loose this voice. We have acquired this after nearly 900 years of suppression.
@@wingsoffreedom4292 alternate thought is not something a person would even listen as the guy listens to a 1400 year old book every day.
@@1ahmed2 like your quran?? Which faith based with zero facts
Vikram Sampath nailed it
Agree with the view stated by a majority that BD tried very hard to bait VS. But he held his own.
The right needs more Vikram Sampaths and less of Sambit Patras if a change has to come.
The right has a point and strong ones, but they cant articulate it well.
Barkhs Visa-versa, or a subtle attempt at whata-bout-ism, was hilarious to watch.
Exactly. Anand Ranganathan is often a better articulator than all of BJP's spokespersons combined.
@Jitendra Singh Except that 'Patra' is hardly to be pitied. He's a shameless, failed doctor who knows his importance is only because he's chanting Modi's name all the time, and he's been rewarded for that sycophancy. He's the BJP's equivalent of the darbaari of the Congress.
I am not fan of Patra bt Still we definitely need sambit patras ,coz different people need different language
The right needs a Sambit Patra to counter a Rajdeep and a Vikram Sampath to counter a Batkha
@@atul1024 He's a good man. Heart and soul definitely in the right place. Let's acknowledge that.
She very cleverly brings her own narrative on issues other than the topic of discussion but leaves no space to counter them by Mr. Sampat by saying "if you will discuss this there will be no time left for the topic of the day" 😂
True..:) She thinks she is too smart and nobody would notice this :)
Exactly, wish Vikram had responded. "BARKHA , there is your truth and then there is actually what happened..."😀
@@THIAGARAJAN1965 😂
If she wanted to do that with the ruthlessness you've imagine about her, she wouldn't have him in the show at all.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 how else would she be able to claim to be neutral.
Barkha is rattled😂😂
Tailored history did real harm. What we really needed was bare history.
Just the facts and related context.
Bold of you Barkha to invite Vikram sir for one to one. You tried to maintain your calm but your restlessness is pretty obvious.
Vikram Sampath is a knowledgeable man. He is a researcher historian. Salute to you sir. We need many more VS. Great to see you back in good health. Rightly said you had to live to tell the history. 🙏🏻
Vikram sampat
Salutes
Salutes
Salutes
Sakutes
We all 👍👍!
Barkha was just speechless in front of Vikram
History textbooks have already been rewritten in peoples minds Barkha.....
Her version of history is true... You can omit other history. She doesn't care. Her ego is so huge...her forehead melts in it
We need more people like Vikram to shed light on our true past, and drive away the darkness, misinformation spread by people like Burkha!!!!
i have heard Vikramji many times. But thoroughly enjoyed this one by watching BD's expression after every reply of Mr Sampath.
May be just a thought - Cong. leaders actually may be british stooge as none of them went to Kala pani ... and which histroy books states them to be more troublesome than Savarkar?
It's not thought, it's reality. Congress was created by Britishers to avoide violent backlash and end of British rule sooner than later by these revolutionaries. Congress put Ghandi as a shield to blunt the wrath of revolution to save their skin. And ultimately it was fear of being butchered by INA of SC Bose that promoted them to leave India.
@@ganeshuniyal7367 So r u implying that Gandhi and the non violence was an idea to blunt the revolutionaries and fool the people to say we will achieve independence one day... just like what political parties say " garibi hataoo" --> they want poor people so that they can be in power for perpetuity.
Also think of this.
In fact Vikram ji talked about this in his talk at Carvak Podcast.
Congress called themselves as moderates and others as Extremists. If we use a different nomenclature. And say Congress were loyalists while others like Savarkar, Bahgat Singh, Sachindranath Sanyal, Bose were Nationalists.
@@mrityunjay1055 can't equate Bhagat Singh's nationalism with Savarak's
@@srikk9 Well depends. I have used two broad classifications. Moderates & Extremists. (I am not going into nuances)
Anyone who was talking with Britishers over the table, forming governments, briningin reforms, forming pacts,etc were moderates.
And those who supported armed revolution, wanted to instigate mutiny within the British Army were extremists.
Based on these definition, I can club Savarkar & Bhagat SIng together.
Vikram Sampat, all questions well handled!!
Savarkar ko sach me samjhenge to jhuth bolne ki likhne ki jaruri hi nahi kabhi !
Host says dt we should accept all refugees irrespective of religion.
Then tell us what was partition for?
Why Muslims divide this land? & will we be getting a proportionate land too in return?
I would say we should have a total ban on citizenship for all Muslims from Pak/BD, including cases like Adnan Sami.
2nd, does India have resources for an open ended refugees policy? We already have such a massive population.
Maybe she can keep them at her home!!
@@yahiyafirdous Have you read the history properly ? It was Muslims who said identity of Muslim will be in danger and that is why they need to form a country. Read when and why Pakistan resolution was passed by Muslim League. What was Iqbal's role ? What was Jinnah's role? Why Direct Action DAY was called on 16th August 1946?
@@yahiyafirdous ak Pakistan mila tha na name of a religion..see Pakistan is now Terroristan instead of Jannat..Islam is not a religion of peace😅 at least Soudi Law granted women new freedoms now..
@@yahiyafirdous madrasa jana band karo or actual Universities jana chalu karo
barkha got really uncomfortable with bakhtiar khilji lol
Yes. I too observed.
She changed the topic
Lol, she started claiming he wants Allahabad to be changed which he never claimed.
Barkha trying to guide interview to familiar grounds of BJP bashing while Vikram trying to bring back conversation to Savarkar...
Both Savarkar and BJP are douchebags
Bjp did harm to the image of Hindus. Today to outsiders Hindu - means cow worship, riots, mobs etc. Not much different from Taliban.
@@uncleputin6219 Kuch to log kahenge - logon ka kaam hai kehna - what did these outsiders do for Hindus ?
@@Suresh_Kamath Yet people like you go and watch videos on Savarkar and put trolling comments - have a life loser!
@@MandarJoshi I didn't watch this video as Savarkar is a douchebag. Just like I do not need to watch any video to call Hitler evil. I subscribe to MOJO stories for other interviews not for repulsive creatures like Savarkar.
The interviewer, in typical fashion of her core character,glosses,cuts short answers not as per her script.
Barkha we idolise APJ but definitely do not idolise Monghuls
Great to listen Vikram..! Loved to hear another side of narrative.
This learned gentleman Vikram Sampath, has a good knowledge and i am happy with his points and facts ! Hats of to Vikram !
The lady tries desperately to extract an antiestablishment comment by making unnecessary pointed questions which were answered clearly by Vikram emphatically bringing out the reality which was twisted to suit the subjective narrative..... hearing this discussion one gets a feeling that it's grossly shameful to articulate a wrongful narratives of a progressive patriotic individual who is not a comunal or anti Minority ....
Vikram Sampath, you nailed it. As usual.
Although we have heard Burkha a lot and agree with many of her views in an altruistic context , not much has she opined about the approach of Abrahamic faiths towards Non Abrahamic faiths .
She needs to remove her kid gloves while dealing with them , the Abrahmic faithfuls and call spade a spade as she generally does otherwise ! 😎
Barkha, like all libtards, calls spade a spade only when the spade is lying on the neighbours backyard. Not calling spade a spade isn't her problem, or the problem of her entire cabal. Inconsistency, double-standards, cherry-picking, dishonesty are the main diseases they are infected with.
I want to see where burrqa will go if she becomes a refugee?
Cheap Journalist ----> cheap journalism, Barkha never disappoints
It's a business adjustment between 2.
It clearly comes out from the interview that Barkha desperately wants the nation to be stuck in the false narratives created by the invaders, colonial masters, and the Leftists and tried her best to nudge and push Dr Vikram Sampath to endorse her position! The good thing is, unwittingly, she facilitated Vikram to clarify much better on the controversial points and the false narratives created by the Left!!!😁 Kudos to Dr Vikram Sampath, his scholarly work, and bold position based on research and documented facts.👌🙏
it was an amazing interview... got to know a lot about Savarkar and all these stuff.. really it was great.. interviews should be like this..
Vikram Sampath is one of my favourite Historians.
Gandhi was probably not a champion of an Indic world view as opposed to an Abrahamic world view, in a simple minded way. Gandhi's interactions with CF Andrews and to a certain extent with Rabindranath Tagore would qualify him as a politician with much more complex and eclectic ideas. I am not championing Gandhi's politics. But I have an intuition that nothing is more 'non-indic' than the Gandhi phenomenon in Indian politics. Ascribing an essentially Indian or Indic quality to Gandhi's politics of non violence and non-cooperation is a Western invention.
Infact his much talked about 7 social sins that appeared in Young India were of a Christian priest Frederick Lewis Donaldson. His views of morality came from an Abrahamic lense and not Indic one.
I tend to agree. He dis short term good but long term damage to India and Indians. He twisted the thought process of a whole generation of educated and uneducated Indians and we are still paying for that. West deified him to suit its own purpose. A billion strong pacifist nation professing Ghanaian ways suited its colonial and neo-colonial agenda.
@@bharatpandit4796 what was the damage again?
Long Live "Vikram Sambath" with full Health and Wealth. You are simply rocking without any hesitation
Whatever you say about Barkha, she is still a jewel in the Indian media crown! Very good questioning and a very decent disposition!
She abstains from saying “Veer Savarkar”
That's the Savarkar effect. Savarkar be like, "I'mma pissing liberals even after 75 years😎"
@@acharya8959 Exactly!
Nice dialogues indeed. Except when madam mentioned that Azad should be a role model. He is definitely not qualified...
Very few Muslims go beyond religion to nation and nation alone. Like Dr. Kalam.
What part was ommited at 21:37?
An excellent research work by Vikram Sampath.
Hahaha.. BD in her usual elements.. trying to justify khilafat movement by giving completely out-of-context example of today’s citizenship amendment.. no wonder she is often shut up by the likes of Hirsi Ali et al for drawing wrong parallels. Pathetic. Vikram Sampath was brilliant in his articulation👏👏
If this was a discussion about the Book, I guess Barkha should have focussed on it alone. She trying to get contemporary politics, discussions questioning Vikram for his opinion was slightly out of context. Was expecting better interview. Disappointed
Our eminent pre independence leaders learnt liberal view of religion and politics from the west during British Raj. Veer Savarkar's stature is tall amoungst our revolutionary visionaries and leaders.
She always abuses Gaurakshaks but does not talk about the cattle thief’s and. Smugglers who kill and butcher
At least they don't kill humans... what kind of logic or religion is this that you kill a human being for an animal.
@Chota Pandit Exactly! Nobody likes them.
@Shubham Upadhyay Why eating beef is wrong? The whole world eat it.
@Chota Pandit What you said is fake news. Even for argument sake it is accepted that cows were being smuggled, one cannot justify killing a human being for smuggling cows. Are there no laws in India that deal with smuggling or theft. The bigger question, why Hindus impose their beliefs on others. Why should others not eat beef if (some) Hindus want to worship the silly cows?
@Chota Pandit That is a total whitewash and a blatant lie to say it was poor people to lynched cattle traders.
My friend there are organized Gau Rakshak vigilante groups roaming streets in north India. There are all kinds of intimidation, extortion, and killing of innocent cattle traders.
Modi himself is on record talking about such gangs. He blames these vigilantes and you are blaming him.
There is a lot of issues in what you say, if it really are poor who are lynching, then in other words you are saying India has no rule of law.
There no slaughter houses where cows are slaughtered. Its only buffalos. Lol, the ancient craze of Indians with fair skin extends even to animals too. That is why they could not bring themselves to worship buffalos for its black skin. You see the depiction of horses in Hindu mythological paintings, you will never see a black horse. Anyways, that's beside the point.
And you did not answer why others should be stopped from eating beef. You talked about ISIS and Taliban in your previous post. Tell me how is it different when Taliban forced people to keep beard and wear hijab in Afghanistan and Hindu extremists forced people to not eat beef. How is it different when Taliban blow away the status of Buddah and Hindu extremists demolished Babri Masjid. There are clear parallels. Extremists of every religion are different sides of the same coin.
Great points VS 👍👍
There is no comparison in the type of imprisonments between congress leaders and Savarkar. The former were in first class luxury jails whereas the latter was incarcerated in the torture jails of kaalapani in Andaman inside a small cell with regular whippings from afghan prison guards who hated Hindus.
Came here for Vikram Sampath ..
Vikram is very eloquent, he makes you think , which very few public figures are able to do today
🙏 Vikram Sampath 🙏
How many would like Rajdeep taking interview of Vikram 😂
Bruh literally ur wish become a real event on india today conclave..😂😂
I think there is an India Today conclave discussion where Rajdeep (host) constantly interrupts Vikram and Shashi (guests) with his ramblings and biases. You can check that out.
Awesome listening to Vikram Sampath jee🙏
VS: Brilliant & scholarly. Love to read his books!
Well said Sampath
Barka don’t be anti Hindu. Learn from him. Even so called celebrated historian mr Guha should learn. These are the people who criticise hindutva for their selfishness and fame.
Great you always play to the gallery none of your questions and your stand had a neutral agenda... if u feel that your ground of a Hindu vs Muslim policy will work for a long time , Apologies you will be out of business very soon
Very nice conversation .jai hind jai maharashtra
Great, Vikram Sampath responds in an excellent manner to all the questions, much as he was cornered to the questions related to hindusim and hindutva, he was genuine and true to his thoughts and writings. Not many people would know that Mahatma Gandhi also used similar addressing pattern as Savarakar did with British, Savarkar is quoted out of context these days I guess
We ought to be grateful to Vikram for bringing out the 'real' Savarkar, something no one could do so far in a well documented, factual manner and at one place. There were many facets to his personality but political vilification by Congress clouded everything else. As it now turns out, he is actually the father of our country for he defined in precise terms, what Hindustan should be. A completely unknown and ignored fact is that the Hindu Mahasabha had penned India's Constitution in 1944 with ideas such as fundamental rights, secular governance etc.
Vikram should continue to write more and more. We need a historian like him to counter likes of Ramachandra Guha or other left historians.
Finally, he deserves Padmashree immediately for his monumental work on Savarkar, even if Bharat Ratna for Savarkar has to wait till the right political moment!!
Barkha, appreciate your patience and open mindedness, to listen to EXCELLENT CLARITY given by Vikram Sampath, for enlightening us on attrocities of Evil rulers came to rule and worked against humanity and looted us
Vikram , Excellent work by you. Keep it up
Barkha: What makes you feel uncomfortable Hinduism & Hindutva as practiced today? How devious & Mischievous is this lady?
Haha... True Shankarji! She is quite something
Soft conversation is required
Ultimately Sanatan dharma need its deserved place across complete Middle East ..