Israeli Settlers in the Occupied West Bank
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 05. 2018
- “Why would an Israeli Jew choose to live in the West Bank?”
That’s the question that motivates writer Wajahat Ali to travel to Israel in a new documentary from The Atlantic. Ali, who has been critical of Israel, embarks on a personal quest to understand the perspectives of some of the 400,000 Israeli Jews who live in the occupied territory in defiance of international law-and to hear from the Palestinians who oppose them.
In his travels through the West Bank, Ali visits the family of a Palestinian terrorist, ventures into the heart of one of the most radical settlements, and speaks to the leader of an NGO focused on creating a dialogue between Israelis and Palestinians.
Read Ali's article in the June 2018 issue of The Atlantic: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/...
Author: Daniel Lombroso
Support for this project has been provided by the Henry R. Luce Initiative on Religion and International Affairs of the Henry Luce Foundation.
Subscribe to The Atlantic on CZcams: bit.ly/subAtlanticYT - Krátké a kreslené filmy
The Atlantic Festival 2022 is here! Join the event on CZcams: czcams.com/users/AtlanticLIVEvideo
*in occupied Judea and Samaria
This is a well-known cheap propaganda in favor of the jews, zionists, occupation and the terror-state of Israel, mixed with a flavor of the sinister plan of establishing the modern world religion.
Also, go equate the victims and killers is very malicious.
@@djphlange One cannot be accused of being called an occupier of one's own country.
@@user-bo8nb2mi fair point lol
Reclaiming land has an expiration date !
Imagine a foreign family building their home in your backyard, knowing that this is illegal under international law, yet they're protected by the police, and the army even, while you can't say anything and if you did you get arrested.
They became refugees.
It happens everyday in Europe and the United States. Just accept diversity. It's a strength 😊
@@brent3086 not exactly. Immigrants on your examples are not killing local ppl to occupy space and are not been covered to do so. Disastrous comparison.
@@brent3086cry us a river, immigration is the only hope the West have of not shriveling up and dying of old age
@@GutoSantanaNo, it’s pretty much the exact same. But if you’re seen as “privileged”, then you cannot call it out.
Its wild we call them "settlers" instead of "terrorists"
do those Arabs that move to settle in Europe should be also called "terrorists"?
Well they are gently called settlers by neutral people sadly for most of the world they are called hero israeli citizen who live in fear caused by plaestinian terorists for no reason just because they ar jews. You can never hear from main stream US media calling them illegal settlers, Sadly the victims who's land, dream, futures are stolen are called terrorists. Sadly we live in a time propaganda is everything and you can turn a victim to a most despicable human being for everyone who just consumes mainstream meda.
and the resistors are called terrorists... lol
Thank you!!!
There are videos of "settlers" arriving - armed to the teeth, protected by the army, as they occupy land owned by peaceful, unarmed people. It's really something else to see.
Crazy how that guy spent the last 2000 years as a foreigner.. doesn't look quite that old.
😂 his DNA will prove he would be from Eastern Europe all along. Went there to grab lands for free
@@ElBarzawiDefensive wars? like the 6-day war? a pre-emotive strike…where the CIA even concluded that attack was not imminent and Egypt did not want war?
Didn’t Israel claim Egypt attacked first the later stated it attacked first.
Didn’t Israel attack USS Liberty and try blame Egypt so that US would also invade Egypt?
Israel loves false flags attacks
@@ElBarzawi its the same for palestinians, they stayed in canaan while the rest of ur grandfather runned away so yes jewisj n muslim habe the same tree
@@ElBarzawi Stop lie here
@@ElBarzawi United Nations and every other supra intergovernmental organisations doesn't recognise the land own by Israeli immigrants to middle east which were taken after burning hundreds of villages of Palestinians and fleeing seven hundred thousands Palestinians. UN still recognise those settlements illegal and that annexed land occupied. By definition Israel is a pariah state in civilised world of post WW2. It is also an Apartheid and Racist state by definition and by action with segregation laws. A state which doesn't allow return of seven hundred thousands of Palestinians to their rightful land and welcomes return of Jews who were never ever lived on the soil of Palestine. Maybe their ancestors were lived once 2000 years ago but that argument is absurd and have no moral and legal ground.
I’m from Tunisia, used to be Carthage about 2000 years ago, Carthage owned Algeria , Morocco, southern Spain and Sicily. I’m going to reclaim all this territory, because it belonged to us.
I love this argument.
So why do Palestinians want their land back then?
@@cotteneyebill74747because they are kicked out by occupiers....
Definitely they'll fight against oppression...
They're native of that land... Zoi*nists came from out side...
@@cotteneyebill74747 You misunderstood his point, he's saying that's what Israelis are doing
@@cotteneyebill74747 Couldn't imagine I would find a dumber argument that israelis argument, but then I read your comment!
Israeli Guy: "but we cant be equal"
Same Israeli Guy: "Hitler was evil and he did not treat equally"
Isnt the israeli guy right though. Jews and muslims would never treat each equally no matter who rules
@@fightclub1164 No actually, prior to Israel Jews lived in equality and co-existence with both Christianity and Islam.
@@fightclub1164 ignorants of history would say that, but truth be told it was Muslims who protected the jews in AlAndulus (now called spain) from the crusaders and thats by the testimony of a jewish historian not even a muslim person, so you can’t claim we are being biased 😂
also jews and christens and Muslims were living peacefully under islam in the holy land until the UK barged in to leave a parasite there
...conveniently forget Hitler is the most popular figure among all Arabs
@@hthrhthr not equal is not the same as different
Isreali Guy: "I dont deny democratic principles"
Also Same Israeli Guy: "but we cant be equal"
I have seen him in other CZcams videos he is by far the craziest.
Sounds like a nazi to me
So, democratically, can't you accept that there is someone against democracy? I thought you democratic fellows could be able to accept that.
And he is from America. He should come back here.
Honestly
75 years of tyranny and occupation .. The problem has never been Hamas , your tyranny is what made Hamas exist.
Correct. Try explaining that to people with no knowledge of the situation. They look at you like you have 2 heads.
I feel so alone as an American evangelical that is opposed to giving Israel a free hand with everything it does to the Palestinians. You can't even talk about it objectively without being called anti-Semitic. Very sad.
Tell them arabs are also semites
Don’t feel alone, we’re seeing so many posts all over social media of young Zionists, Jewish and evangelical, who are leaving such evil beliefs. Palestinian Christians and Orthodox Jews who follow the real Torah have both proven this entire claim to so-called Jewish land is false.
Crazy how you win an argument for life.
Yechezkel (Ezekiel) 37:
21And say to them, So says the Lord God: Behold I will take the children of Israel from among the nations where they have gone, and I will gather them from every side, and I will bring them to their land. כאוְדַבֵּ֣ר אֲלֵיהֶ֗ם כֹּֽה־אָמַר֘ אֲדֹנָ֣י יֱהֹוִה֒ הִנֵּ֨ה אֲנִ֚י לֹקֵ֙חַ֙ אֶת־בְּנֵ֣י יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל מִבֵּ֥ין הַגּוֹיִ֖ם אֲשֶׁ֣ר הָֽלְכוּ־שָׁ֑ם וְקִבַּצְתִּ֚י אֹתָם֙ מִסָּבִ֔יב וְהֵֽבֵאתִ֥י אוֹתָ֖ם אֶל־אַדְמָתָֽם:22And I will make them into one nation in the land upon the mountains of Israel, and one king shall be to them all as a king; and they shall no longer be two nations, neither shall they be divided into two kingdoms anymore. כבוְעָשִׂ֣יתִי אֹ֠תָם לְג֨וֹי אֶחָ֚ד בָּאָ֙רֶץ֙ בְּהָרֵ֣י יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל וּמֶ֧לֶךְ אֶחָ֛ד יִֽהְיֶ֥ה לְכֻלָּ֖ם לְמֶ֑לֶךְ וְלֹ֚א יִֽהְיוּ־ (כתיב יִֽהְיֻה) עוֹד֙ לִשְׁנֵ֣י גוֹיִ֔ם וְלֹ֨א יֵחָ֥צוּ ע֛וֹד לִשְׁתֵּ֥י מַמְלָכ֖וֹת עֽוֹד:23And they shall no longer defile themselves with their idols, with their detestable things, or with all their transgressions, and I will save them from all their habitations in which they have sinned, and I will purify them, and they shall be to Me as a people, and I will be to them as a God. כגוְלֹ֧א יִֽטַמְּא֣וּ ע֗וֹד בְּגִלּֽוּלֵיהֶם֙ וּבְשִׁקּ֣וּצֵיהֶ֔ם וּבְכֹ֖ל פִּשְׁעֵיהֶ֑ם וְהֽוֹשַׁעְתִּ֣י אֹתָ֗ם מִכֹּ֚ל מֽוֹשְׁבֹֽתֵיהֶם֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר חָֽטְא֣וּ בָהֶ֔ם וְטִֽהַרְתִּ֚י אוֹתָם֙ וְהָֽיוּ־לִ֣י לְעָ֔ם וַֽאֲנִ֕י אֶֽהְיֶ֥ה לָהֶ֖ם לֵֽאלֹהִֽים:24And My servant David shall be king over them, and one shepherd shall be for them all, and they shall walk in My ordinances and observe My statutes and perform them. כדוְעַבְדִּ֚י דָוִד֙ מֶ֣לֶךְ עֲלֵיהֶ֔ם וְרוֹעֶ֥ה אֶחָ֖ד יִהְיֶ֣ה לְכֻלָּ֑ם וּבְמִשְׁפָּטַ֣י יֵלֵ֔כוּ וְחֻקֹּתַ֥י יִשְׁמְר֖וּ וְעָשׂ֥וּ אוֹתָֽם:25 And they shall dwell on the land that I have given to My servant, to Jacob, wherein your forefathers lived; and they shall dwell upon it, they and their children and their children's children, forever; and My servant David shall be their prince forever. כהוְיָֽשְׁב֣וּ עַל־הָאָ֗רֶץ אֲשֶׁ֚ר נָתַ֙תִּי֙ לְעַבְדִּ֣י לְיַֽעֲקֹ֔ב אֲשֶׁ֥ר יָֽשְׁבוּ־בָ֖הּ אֲבֽוֹתֵיכֶ֑ם וְיָֽשְׁב֣וּ עָלֶ֡יהָ הֵ֠מָּה וּבְנֵיהֶ֞ם וּבְנֵ֚י בְנֵיהֶם֙ עַד־עוֹלָ֔ם וְדָוִ֣ד עַבְדִּ֔י נָשִׂ֥יא לָהֶ֖ם לְעוֹלָֽם: 26And I will form a covenant of peace for them, an everlasting covenant shall be with them; and I will establish them and I will multiply them, and I will place My Sanctuary in their midst forever. כווְכָרַתִּ֚י לָהֶם֙ בְּרִ֣ית שָׁל֔וֹם בְּרִ֥ית עוֹלָ֖ם יִֽהְיֶ֣ה אוֹתָ֑ם וּנְתַתִּים֙ וְהִרְבֵּיתִ֣י אוֹתָ֔ם וְנָֽתַתִּ֧י אֶת־מִקְדָּשִׁ֛י בְּתוֹכָ֖ם לְעוֹלָֽם:
27 And My dwelling place shall be over them, and I will be to them for a God, and they shall be to Me as a people. כזוְהָיָ֚ה מִשְׁכָּנִי֙ עֲלֵיהֶ֔ם וְהָיִ֥יתִי לָהֶ֖ם לֵֽאלֹהִ֑ים וְהֵ֖מָּה יִֽהְיוּ־לִ֥י לְעָֽם:
28 And the nations shall know that I am the Lord, Who sanctifies Israel, when My Sanctuary is in their midst forever." כחוְיָֽדְעוּ֙ הַגּוֹיִ֔ם כִּי אֲנִ֣י יְהֹוָ֔ה מְקַדֵּ֖שׁ אֶת־יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל בִּֽהְי֧וֹת מִקְדָּשִׁ֛י בְּתוֹכָ֖ם לְעוֹלָֽם:
A lot of churches in the world helped Israel to get more arrogant
Stop calling them "settlers". They're occupiers, plain and simple
Colonizer
Or better yet true and rightful owners of these lands.
@@whiteobama3032lmao
Well tell that to the native Americans in the USA, guess you think differently about them?@@whiteobama3032
@@whiteobama3032says who? That land and every other land has always been controlled by those strong enough to conquer and hold it honorably. The last group to do that are the Muslims. You want it back? Fight for it like the Christians and the Latin kings did. The last fight they had with the Muslims they lost and surrendered it honorably. The true native jews that have always lived there know and accept this because it's in their book to remain in exile. The new jews from Europe aka the Zionist are not real Jews and what they are doing is illegal and immoral.
It is sad that there wasn't any mention of any Palestinian Christians living in either historical Palestine or the West Bank. They have stories to share as well.
Jews and Christians love each other
They are brother of each other
❤
There's no such thing as Palestinian Christians. It's an invented term in the 1960s against Jews. They are Nazerites.
ScreamToASigh I know Palestinian christians why are you bullshitting
@@screamtoasigh9984 I'm a Palestinian Christian and you're full of it. I'll be there alongside my fellow kinsman on the day Zionists are forced out of every square inch of historic Palestine to celebrate to recovery of MY ancestral homeland.
@@mahirakhan3867 what about Muslim as you seems pakistani and your ancentor are converted Muslims from Hindu
So first think about yourself then teach to other
Still can't believe how can people go to another people's house and saying "this is my house, based on what I believe in history, theology, and prophecy. And for that, I will stay here, and you have to get out of here".
Have you seen the footage from the thefts of homes in Sheikh Jarrah? When a Palestinian lady tells the settle 'this is my house' he replies 'if I don't steal it someone else will'!!! It's like watching a dystopian movie - except its real life events in the 21st century!
Pretty much
🙍🏽♀️free America from those who have colonized and plundered the tax resources of American citizens
"Do you think building on their land is part of the problem?"
"No. They are the problem."
All of Israel is settlements in the Palestinian backyard. In 1880 there was a 3% Jewish population, and 95% Arab/Palestinian. Then the mass immigration of Jews came in. And now they control everything, how can anyone be sympathetic to Israelis when they invaded and have been committing genocide on the Palestinian people for over 100 years. But Israel has a killer Public Relations network, to obfuscate the ethnic cleansing they are perpetrating. They wanted these attacks to take place, so they have an excuse to wipe out more Palestinians and annex more land. Far easier to kill and take over, then try to force them out.
israel wont go anywhere
🙍🏼♀️free America from those who have colonized and plundered the tax resources of American citizens
@@amosamwig8394It will by your action. Proof ? Two temples of yours were destroyed twice in history. No Jews temple lasted more than 85 years. 🤥
Like most Americans, when the war started I was all for the support of Israel, but after dumping hours upon hours of research into this mess, my whole perspective has changed. You cant occupy and control people without harsh repercussions. I dont condone violence...but what did you expect?
except it was their land when they were hebrews. Which is the biblical term for the people of that land. The Palestinian people are converts to Islam when Mohammad came thru and conquered, they were originally called Canaan. The current Jews in Israel are mostly Ashkenazi Jews who are also converts and not the original shephardic jews.
@@ChicagoYoureOut No man, you can't just show up after 2000 years and claim a land. Fck off with that.
@@ChicagoYoureOut What right? Who gave you the right? Where were you for the 2000 years?
Same and for a lot of people. I suggest you watch Noam Chomsky his take on this matter. There's not more to be said by anyone regarding israel really.
@BabushkaBrigade the ignorance in these comments of yours is quite something, my man. As any ignorant pretending to be knowledgeable you come across as goofy
Israel has caused so much pain to these people WHY is the media not covering this?!
because they are hypocrites.
Because Hamas are snakes. They have dome worse. The media has no right dirtying the righteous side
The US media is mostly tilted towards white wealthy Protestant capitalists, and Israel is considered an outpost of the post, plus many very wealthy Jews, on top of the white Protestant support, use millions of dollars to fund the "right" candidates i.e. pro-Israeli, and their allies are influential in the media, so stories about settlers about Palestinians being abused, international law ignored isn't that important because Israelis are doing it. They are considered white Westerners tied to the white Protestant establishment. And at the same time, the system oppresses people of all races who aren't wealthy, but especially certain minorities like black people.
Because not everyone is like you and reads half a novel. Most people who have a dog in the fight have done the research and are AWARE of just how long Israel has belonged to the Jews. 5784 years maybe???
This guy is from Pakistan. Let me clarify the situation in Kashmir, which belongs to India, yet the government of Pakistan resorts to terrorism and the people of Kashmir cannot live peaceful lives. This guy is the pitiful of hypocrisy.
This was such an eye opening piece. I wish it was longer. He was the perfect guy to connect and speak with all those people. The last guy who said "you sometimes don't see it when it is in front of you".... well many of us are seeing and learning about it now, and a lot of us are horrified, and our hearts are breaking for the innocent, oppressed people of Palestine.
If anything this should open your eyes to how much propaganda this documentary entails there isn't a single palestinian who'd say that they want israel ruling them this is the biggest bs documentary i've ever seen
So let me understand, you think if someone came and took your land that gives you the green light to go rape and behead people and burn them alive? gotcha, great logic.
The thing is, the people behind this don't want to stop with just Israel, they intend to take over the world.
This is not a conspiracy theory anymore.
Do a little research.
🐇🕳️
please search for "the nakba documentary VOX" is soooooooo much better ! trust me
“Innocent and oppressed”. Uh huh. This video completely washes over any perspective other than it’s “stolen land”.
bro spent 2000 years as foreigner 🤣
The audacity of these people to occupy Palestinian land and talk like they are the victims.
Yea it’s really despicable
When was Palestine ever a country or nation?
@@andresrojas7924 several states recognize Palestine, except US and its allies. People need to spend time finding out the truth. Palestine belongs to the Palestinians not the Jews.
@@andresrojas7924 What? Palestine is a region. Herodotus, the ancient Greek philosopher mentions Palestine. It was a 4 State region where people of all types lived. Syrian Arabs, Greeks, Palestinians and others. Please for heaven's sake educate yourself instead of posting one liner to propagandize and spread lies.
@@e.t.ethics1771Do you know where the word Palestine comes from?
I know I have been terribly hard on the Palestinians but ater watching this documentary, I can understand their frustrations. I do believe the settlements/occupation is causing the problem. I don't condone killing innocents on either side, but I did not know there were SO MANY settlements THAT deep into Palestinian land. WOW! What an eye opener. This issue has to be seriously addressed by both sides. I love this documentary and I wish it were longer. It has pretty much cleared my confusion on this issue.
The Palestinians have had hell from these people for the past 75 years. Do your research and stay away from the big news channels.
I hope you share this new insight with your peers and entourage, it is incredibly disheartning for Palestinians to be painted as the bad guys by everyole while they are the victims. But I have hope. And thank you for opening your heart to a new perspective.
Thank you for your kind words. I have to say that the first step towards developing more peaceful relations between Palestinians and Israelis must start with Israel disbanding the settlements and allowing the Palestininan people to set up a formal government where they are in control of their own territory to the Palestinian people freedom of movement and dignity and to allow that government to promote job growth, education and further progress. There is no doubt in my that both sides CAN do it and that DEEP down inside BOTH sides really want to do it. It's such a shame that the Palestinian people suffer so much at the hands of so many. I recently spoke to a Palestinian man living here in the USA and he told me he nor his family actually likes Hamas buthe feels the rest of the world is not listening to Palestinian concerns about the occupation.Let's keep out fingers crossed.@@aminaassbayou85
@@aminaassbayou85
Palestinians are the bad guys if they support what Hamas did to the children.
You are confused there is no such country as Palestine. What we in the west call settlers were welcomed by the populace in the area at the time and sold their houses to the new Jewish incomers ,when they improved the area they wanted it back . if the Jews can hold on to the land it is theirs , That is the way it is after centuries of persecution the Jews deserve a home
The audacity of a foreigner , occupying the native peoples land, playing a didgeridoo- the instrument of the Australian Aboriginals!
Oh the irony!
Agree with you. He's
Trying to play a didgeridoo.... He is to far away of doing well. I'm Ozzy.
you can't claim ownership over land cause your ancestors lived there, can you imagine what that would mean for the entire world? it doesn't make sense
“For many settlers, the redemption of the land is the only way to make Israel’s soul whole and pure again. And yet the irony is, I believe that Israel is on the verge of losing its soul by redeeming the land, by expanding, by creating more settlements.” I think this is pretty obvious and neatly summarizes where this is going for Israelis.
Palestine have been freed once,it will be freed again.Israelis are trying to go against history
Fozia....... then you dont know what you are talking about. See the video Israel for a viable peace.
@@jilldent5514 You are here too? Still trying to spread your BS? Get a life.
@@AzizDoufikar2280 It is a fact that there was never a Palestinian state. The Jews cannot give their land to the Arabs without maintaining security over the skies of the Rift Valley and the main airport.
@@jilldent5514 BS as usual I see
"Everything belongs to us" is such a scary line to hear. It's the sentence of an invader.
They think they are the chosen ones, modern day nazis.
Yes, that is what the PLO extremists think and say.
It was said by a zionist who's settling. The arabs didn't say anything like that at all.
The arab settlers had no right to steal the Land from the indigenous Jews.
Time to expel these interlopers.
Sin D
actually israel was a jewish state back then
it was called judea
it was where king david ruled
Great work! I am a born Pakistani and never felt so proud about my people ever before than now watching this incredible documentary video by Pakistani journalist 👏
So Netanyahu funded hamas, ignored Egypt intel days before attack and even moved most security to the west bank to conveniently make it easier for hamas to carry their attack. Hamas couldn't have done it without Netanyahu...
Netanyahu wanted a license to massacre and he got it. Those "hostages" were never intended to be rescued, they are human sacrifices Netanyahu made.
Wonderful presentation. “Israel losing their soul trying to retain this land”. Incredible. I didn’t know anything in my 46 years n the attacks on Israel made me so angry. But i wanted to know why Arabs, Muslims were so angry. Watched enlightening documentaries. Then this one. My heart hurts so much right now. But I also feel closer to the Lord than i have in a while. God speed to all on both sides. Free Palestine
Hah.... Well said! I hardly ever care what Americans think. We are fed on 100% "GRADE A" CIA BULLSHIT from cradle to grave and it takes decades to recover from this propaganda assault. Let us not forget that we are the ones funding the Palestinian genocide, which is in our DNA. We think nothing of having virtually erased the indigenous peoples from the USA in our own land grab. ( Point in fact: The Cherokee Indians ... disliked by all other tribes.... were the wealthy plantation owners of the south until they were driven out. )
❤
This all started during WWI. The British were desperate against the Germans. The Zionist Jewish leadership (not all Jews) made a deal with the British that they would help bring America into the war and help fund the British war effort. In 1917, government official Arthur Balfour wrote a letter to Lord Rothschild, a Jewish lord, saying they would support a Jewish homeland in Palestine and to let the Zionist organization know that Britain would support it. Problem was at that time, the population was 92% Palestinian Arab. Of course, so many of the Arabs have been ethnic cleansed and kicked out.
Weird, I'm the same. I didn't know much about this mess before Hamas attacked Israel the other day.
And from what I've watched and researched, including this same video as you - I have concluded that freeing Palestine will involve deporting the Jews, and achieving a free and peaceful state of Israel will involve deporting the Muslims (a wonderful example of the failure that is multiculturalism, as the West is just beginning to feel: But that's another story...)
Anyway, I have concluded that Jews were there first thousands of years ago, and for the last 700-Years have suffered serious oppression (whether of not worse than current Palestinians are suffering is not my point) My point is Christians have the Vatican, Muslims have Mecca; is it so much to ask for Jews to have the Temple Mount?
As for Hamas + Gaza, I cannot invision any good or legitimate claims they can make following their actions.
But still, I have seen Muslim street parties + celebrations in London, Berlin, Brussels, Amsterdam, etc. - They aren't simply chanting 'Free Palestine' as you put it - If I even write what the Muslims chant I'll get banned for life.
Maybe your research can take you to "Raja Casablanca FC Fans singing about Palestine" - Then you may feel a tinge of symathy, understanding and even support for Israel's treatment of Palestinians + creation of Settlements. It doesn't make it the right thing to do, but it is understandable given the murderous hordes that will be on their doorstep, showing absolutely NO mercy given half a chance - As Hamas highlights in the extreme.
“I also feel closer to the Lord than I have in a while”. This Shows you have a good heart.
That last guy who said he heard the word occupation for the first time and changed his mind, really gives me hope.
And, it's that last guy on whose face and words you see humanity. He has the heart to feel what Palestinians feel.
No murder will enter
It's the Palestinians who are the occupiers... you obviously haven't read enough.
@@seanoleary1979 and where does your source of information come from?
@@10thjul You mean you didn't cover this stuff in undergrad studies in college? ...and now you're looking for ME to do YOUR research? Historically, archeologically, and theologically, all converge on the same plane. Jesus Christ... READ!!! Or at least make believe you attended a decent secular school that taught objectivity as opposed to religion-based schools who teach subjectivity for 'Christ's SAKE!'
2000 years ago🤦🏽♀️
Crazy they think it is their land
Loons!
The logic that a land is still yours after you haven't been there for over 2000 years is ridiculous.
With this logic Italy (the roman empire) could claim the entirety of europe and parts of africa as theirs.
In a way I do feel very sorry for these settlers - they’ve been brainwashed into beliefs that are so extreme that they’ve discarded their own humanity. they’re shameless.. and that’s a sad way to live.
The west actively supports this. These views are well represented in the israeli government.
How? Their history is quite documented. They all have lived there it's both their homes. The Israelites and the Philistines
@@stuartchilongozi2439 I mean just because they have ancestors that lived in the region doesn’t mean they get to displace the people currently living there. it would be fine if they just moved there and co-existed peacefully without stealing other people’s stuff but that’s not what the settlers are doing
@katoe908 I agree with you. They can both live in peace and harmony if both sides don't take the extreme route
@katoe908 yes this. What's baffling is that so many people still think it's ok to evict people from their homes because their ancestors once live in that land
“ I cannot see them as equals” that is not judaism. That is Iblissism . How can one have such an attitude of “I am better than you” and hope to last long on a land that isn’t his ?
he's saying the land of Israel, including JUDEA and SAMARIA belong to the Jewish People , going back to the BIble. IF you want to reject the"favoritism" of the Jews in the Bible, that's your choice. but then you should show scorn for the NewTestament which "favors" XIans and definitely for the Koran, which really looks down on non-moslems.
phillip baram we see also the curse for breaking covenant with God. And they were taken as an example for future generations where their bad actions have been corrected. We don’t see them as God elected in the sense you understand it. Like when you correct a pupil that has a bad behaviour, you give him a good correction to teach the rest a lesson. No one wants to be chosen that way , I am telling you. Understanding it your way is misunderstanding it altogether. The real favoured by God are those who are sincere and do good for the sake of God, that is the islamic understanding.
@@sanabougossa5470 Even the Quran says God gave the Holy Land to the Jewish people. The Most High has brought them back to their Land of Israel for they are favoured, sincere and do good for the sake of God.
Jonathan DeLeon the Quran says God gave the land to the children of Israel (so the followers of Jacob), whom are the Israelites. But the modern day descendants of these Israelites are the Palestinians ( as the historical research and archaeological excavations performed by Israeli historians such as Ben Schlomo Sand uncovered that the exile of Jews did not happen to all Jews and many remained in Palestine and continued to breed eventually forming current day Palestinians after the mixed with Arabs). Even Israeli prime ministers have admitted Palestinians are the modern day descendants of Israelites and so even by religious books the Palestinians have right to the land.
Faris Chowdhury: So where do we go from here? The Palestinians have the right to the land. All they need to do is take it away from the IDF. So what’s the problem?
This so frustrating. Washing this makes me se sad and sorry for every Palestinian who stepped in this land since 1948
How does a colonizer refer to Palestinians as the terrorist if the settlers didn’t even ask permission to settle in Palestinian territories and don’t want them there. It doesn’t make sense and it doesn’t seem as if Israel wants peace.
The saddest part is at 11:28, when he asks if Palestinians can be equal. If you look closely, the dude on the left is nodding his head; the animal on the right, knowing the position of the guy on the left, quickly silences him by stepping in and motioning for him to shut up, and proudly saying ”No!” It really speaks volumes.
loopje so true good spotting
Agreed. I highlighted that too in a comment. Though I already knew this is how many jewish people have felt in their heart of hearts for thousands of years. What sucks is many people that would be called as genetically or culturaly "jewish" are not of that kind of corrupt, racist mind. Plenty of good jewish people in the world, like many other peoples, but religion ( different from spirituality) is poisonous to all. T.T
Man in the middle seemed at bit uncomfortable.
Racist at its finest
@Tyrant Great way to deflect op's original comment
Breaking into some one house and calling the house as terrorist. What a civilised people
As civilised as Malappuram.
@Killikia Productions Gtfo youtube, educate yourself . Look at palestine before 1948 look at it now
@@Uzair823 yes because before british mandet palestine there was nothing... Maybe you should gtfo youtube and educate yourself...
@@Eran_L Before the western colonization there was neither lebanon nor jordan. Do you have the right to invade those countries and force their people out of their homes (as you did to the palestinians)?
@@alomariy1088 This is wrong on so many levels... I don't know what do begin with, so I won't, cause it doesn't worth my time. You are welcome to do a little research about what happen and how Israel was created, about the war after the declaration of independence of Israel, and what defensive war means...
BTW liking your own comment is pretty sad...
This was an absolutely beautiful piece. Thank you for sharing this.
There can be no lasting peace where there is injustice.
Imagine if people from America came back to Europe and claimed the right to start a new state because of their European ancestry.
Sure, if they have Italian or Greek origin and feels Italians or Greeks they can do it (and sometimes do it really). Of course they are not supposed to fight with locals or take lands by force. Also Zionist project of repatriating hundreds of thousands of Jews to create Jewish state on part of former Judea, had no intension to harm local Arabs in any way. Tiny 300K locals in the mid of 19 century (some of them converted jews by themselves) owning few % of the land privately, where no problem at all. They even could be great beneficiary of the project. There is no point for both sides to look for the justice in the past, but in the presence.
Greeks, Italians, Mexicans and some others have a right of return
@@ProtomanButCallMeBlues yes that means you can stay there, not that you can force the natives from their land
@@richardabrahams5184 If you look at the time line of the size of Palestine over the years it seems that it may not exist in the future.
@@asweeney101
No, doesn't actually work like that. It means you get granted citizenship. A lot of people that do, just do it to buy property in Mexico. I don't know much about Italy, Greece or some of the other one's. For example, with Spain, you just have to proof your ancestors were part of the former Spanish Empire so Latin American immigrants are not technically counted as Immigrants after 2 years.
The Palestinians were never Israeli Citizens, and they themselves weren't actually a native people of the area. They were Arabs that were brought in to displace the populations before them.
So that guy with the pony-tale lived 2,500 years as a refugee?
Lol, so right! I wished they asked him, how good are you?
talk about longevity.
carries his age well,must buy him a german sportscar for his next birthday
Lived as refugees for so long that they all look different
he did
That was an amazing video! Thanks for doing this and sharing!
You took their land and demolished their house and you still call them terrorist?
hey guys, I have an Arab ancestor from 15 generations ago, does that mean that I have a right to a Kuwaiti citizenship?
Why not? Most countries have a law of return. Italy for one has no limitations on generations to claim citizenship.
Moises Huerta I don’t know, my man. I don’t know how interested they are to give me citizenship when I’m a Persian Bahá’í.
@@YaverMemolibaba yes I'm positive
Divan Iseradom no because most arab countries dont grant citizenships even if u were born in their country they can still remove or deport u when u turned 18
If you manage to prove it that it is also from your father side then yes, as they follow father blood line.
" I haven't seen god anywhere"- what a powerful statement. So much hate on both sides, it will never end :(
Exactly
Yes, that really hit my heart too and the tragedy is, the journalist Wajahat Ali saw it with the intelligence of the heart and I have tears in my eyes too because that is the TRUTH.
The Jews have always had to fight for their land ,they fought the Romans in Judea at the time of Christ for over a hundred years . Good luck to them they the Jews are the lesser of 2 evils
That's because there is no such thing as god lol
When someone's land is stolen, you can't blame them for being hateful. Stop this stupid "both sides rhetoric"
This is fantastic reporting.... 5 years on and still so relevant
When I was a teen and young man I believed everything I saw on the news and what was taught in school. As a middle aged man I have learned that almost everything I ever knew about the world is either a lie, backwards, or only 1% of a bigger back story. For example Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, turns out they never did. In the 80s America made friends and allies with the Taliban to fight the evil empire of Russia in Afghanistan, turns out we funded, armed and trained Osama. There were just a few savage native indians in America when the colonist arrived so the land was open for the taking, turns out there were millions of natives in north america and they werent all savages who killed each other. The entire west coast natives were some of the most peaceful natives you could come across yet they were killed for their lands. Genocide was acceptable because of greed. And there is so much more...
I think I'll build my shed in someone else's garden. I'm sure they won't mind.
Well if someone builds a shed on your garden then you come in and say this shed is mine whose right?
@@shaboki802 the one that's still left breathing
@kb be The Palestinian dialect of Arabic is quite different from the standard Arabic.
@kb be and Israelis should go back to the Caucasus mountains with their Neanderthal ancestors
@kb be and Israelis should go back to Germany, Poland and UK
THANK YOU
that's great and brave work, i just wonder about the footages that you weren't allowed to include!
This is a great eye-opening clip showing both sides of the conflict. Both sides of the conflict see themselves as the victim. Wajahat, good interview. I love the phrase, "The closer you are, the less you see".
The forces are not equal to say the two sides, they are Zionists (settlers) occupying the land, who want to impose a fait accompli policy.
All of Israel is settlements in the Palestinian backyard. In 1880 there was a 3% Jewish population, and 95% Arab/Palestinian. Then the mass immigration of Jews came in. And now they control everything, how can anyone be sympathetic to Israelis when they invaded and have been committing genocide on the Palestinian people for over 100 years. But Israel has a killer Public Relations network, to obfuscate the ethnic cleansing they are perpetrating. They wanted these attacks to take place, so they have an excuse to wipe out more Palestinians and annex more land. Far easier to kill and take over, then try to force them out.
That long haired dude saying he spent more than 2000 years in exile is a Vampire y'all
Or he believes in incarnation 😂
Hahahaha
Lol
"I haven't seen God anywhere" powerful words!
God is everywhere remember this worldy life is just a trial
@@arifnoor100 special god as a realtor, to have real estate business
@@abrahammoses6369 Allah never said, stop lying by name of god, Moses was homeless and runaway from Egypt after 40 years of living, and find a nice land of other poor people who become greedy by Jashaw fighting those kind people who feed him and give him a safe place to sleep, also married one of them later find his people not an honest and run away from his people still no one knows where, and later Torah was changed and made story god wants us to steal others land, no god is a real state or and believe in stealing as thieves when Jews for thousand years lived in another side of the world, and today inside Israel, 3 Million Orthdux Jews have war with zionist Jews when showing them Moses never ask for a country,
@@abrahammoses6369 The book of the Quran wrote hundred years after Judaism and Christianity, so can not steal land from others, and those old Jews all died in the war with the Romans, these new Jews believers called Ashkenazi who are stealing the land of Palestinian, Sephardi Jews still live in Iran are the old one and never move out of Iran,
it's ironic, because he meant and they're talking the same omnipresent Abrahamic god..
Do they get paid by the state to set up shop?
According to B'Tselem, an Israeli human rights organization, they are financially subsidized when they move there yes
Settlers? What does that mean. Let us call a spade a spade. Invaders. Occupiers. Land grabbers. Agressors.
“As the world is burning, those two will be dancing together”
Beautifully said. I liked this report a lot, so many moments felt like poetry
What does that mean the dancing together comment? I didn't understand.
@@snakejuce My interpretation is that each party will hold out, dancing in their victory and ignoring each other's sufferings and the blood they have spilled with their anger of fire, the same blood which fuels the fire in the land and within the other.
Who was the first prime minister of PaLIEstine??🥵 and when was PaLIEstine declared a state for the first time??🥵 if you answer these questions then you will understand by yourself that there was never a state called PaLIEstine🥵
@@book.jupiter0719 Who they are??
@@book.jupiter0719 You Palestinians claim that there was once a country called Palestine, so why don't you have a history??🥵
My heart is with Palestine. I wish the Palestinians victory.
this "victory" you are talking about is something that arabs living in israel will never achieve
What does "victory" mean to you?
@@havibabi if anyone is hoping for these arab people of getting back "their" lands, it will never happen because israel is strong and supported by the USA, USA approves israel ownership of the land due to archeological evidences
@@MTC008Allah is stronger than all the West combined. Just wait and watch
Ameen dear
"I spent the last 2000 years outside Israel" Who is this guy? A vampire?
There is NO holy land where there is so much blood!
Settler is a euphemistic term for invaders, colonialists, thieves, and murderers.
people who were persecuted by someone else are taking out their anger on Palestinians
this does not make sense.
Its no logic
based gibson persecuted*
based gibson prosecution is in a law court, whilst persecution is when an authority unfairly treats a minority group 💁🏽♀️
Do you think we like to send our boys to war? We have no choice! Terrorists threaten our home! The only home the Jews have! All the wars of Israel, the Arab states began. There have been more than 11,000 terrorist attacks in all the years that Israel has existed.
So no, we don't enjoy this war
@@user-so8if7jk9i
your stolen home*
Britain gave them the land. It wasn't Britain's land to give away!
@AMERICA FIRST about 50% wasn't it? The land was given to them to keep. I think it's written in the Balfour treaty.
@Ret1173 Israel is the new Nazi nation.
Ret1173 simple fact, Jews want to claim a land they have no right to, just because you have ancestors there doesn’t mean you have the right to it. I have ancestors from Pakistan but I have a British passport, so I deserve full Pakistani citizenship, hell no! I was born in Britain simple as. I’m British. As much as I can want to be Pakistani I will never be. Same with the occupation. Jews had no legal right to move into the West Bank, FACT. They shouldn’t be there, they should at the very least move out of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Give Palestinians full control over those areas, recognise the Palestinian state, then work together to find peace.
Public Public don’t bother debating him, I’ve seen him on a pro Israel prager u video, he is a liar and just swears to make up for his insecurities
Problem with owing a lot of money to the Rothschilds. They get to decide policy.
So the israelis call the Palestinians terrorists, only because they want to defend their home and land...please, give me a break!
"When they're extinct, we'll feel bad about them, like animals." I heard it somewhere. I hope we don't get to that point.
Free Palestine!!!!!!!!
“The closer you are the less you see”. Wise words
Wrong words.
The closer you are the more you see.
I don't understand
@@rahmanreshad4909 it depends
@@akunformalitas what you dont understand please .
4:48 he looks pretty young for a 2000 year old person.
I think he's talking about jewish people as a whole
@@destinyneedle541 the guy is joking
Nah, not really. The more he talks, the worse he looks.
“Unfortunately the recent Israeli air campaign in Gaza has only worsened living conditions, inflicting $380 million in damage to the beleaguered Strip and necessitating $485 million in immediate humanitarian and reconstruction aid,” the letter highlighted.
The letter then called on Blinken to work with Israel and Egypt, clearly state which materials are allowed into the Gaza Strip, and review the efficacy of the so-called Gaza Reconstruction Mechanism agreement.
The US lawmakers said Israel “selectively bans materials that it considers having 'dual use' - any item it claims could have a military application.”
They also condemned Israel's restriction of Gaza's fishing zone as a form of collective punishment.
“Although the restriction was recently reversed, the decision to collectively punish the people of Gaza by unilaterally restricting its fishing zone remains extremely concerning,” said the letter, urging Blinken “to work with the Israeli regime to refrain from such harmful and illegal actions.”
he looks a scary villain from merican horror movie in the mid west
and today is getting worse and worse... please help them
Imagine the hatred Israel is building against itself among young people watching the current barbarism.
I'm an old man, most of my life I have admired the Jewish people and their struggle. No longer. The barbarism we see from Israel today is exactly the kind of fascism my father fought against in WW2. The victims have become the perpetrators.
Let's not confuse the Israeli government with the Jewish people. Not all Jews are Israeli, not even all Israelis are Jewish and certainly not all Jewish Israelis support the colonialist settler policy of the government and army.
Especially in times like this it is important that we are careful with our words.
Zionism does not stand for all Jews.
We in the West need to stop assuming we understand the entire situation. It's apparent by this video we don't. Thank you Wajahat Ali for not choosing sides, but letting each side speak for itself. We should follow your lead.
Not choosing side ? This man literally instinued that the Jewish man killed in terror attack was indirectly due to anger due to Israeli settler activities. The way Israel is treating hypocritical Muslims is a model that should be implemented in other countries to save us from islam
You won’t say that about the current situation between Russia and Ukraine now won’t you 🥱😒
Neutral/ impartial reporting is done to ensure that the viewers are allowed to make their own conclusions. Many people conclude that Israel is wrong.
It reminds me of cousins fighting.
They have much in common.
I don't think it will change.
@@rdred8693It’s more like a sibling that bullies the other sibling, and when the other finally stands up for themselves, the parents side with the sibling doing the bullying. The Palestinians have no rights under the Israelis, and the Israelis already have complete control over every aspect of their lives. There is no fair fight here.
By this logic then USA and Canada should give the land back to the native Americans who lived there milenia after milenia with all their sacred places, religion, culture and language!
Too late for that, native Americans are close to being extinct so… they don’t have the numbers anymore. It’s about the numbers. Things would be so much simpler if Palestinians were as small of a number as native Americans to begin with, you see?
@@luceafarul579 Otomans were big and defeated, saddly if USA decides arabia is more suitable because of oil then intentions can be flipped, it is not about who was where it is about control. One thing is for sure, superpowers last until thee day they don't. ;)
@@georginaporter4809 nope. They would still prefer settler colonialism if they are able.
@@luceafarul579 certainly, the will prefer a dirty, smelly, drunk settler over their sacred sites, knowledge of the skies, agriculture and sacred rituals ;)
Last part was the most important and beautiful. Take care.. we all are blessed to have a place, roof, food to eat, cloth to cover. We need to be thankful for the same
Now this is what is called next level propaganda. Trying to depict the occupier and the occupied as equal.
It’s so incredibly sad and angering. I really hope Palestinians get their land back. All of it. How can people just see those settlers and the genocide and not do anything against it? As a Ukrainian I deeply condemn those who look onto imperialist landgrabs and genocide without empathy or the drive to take action
You trivialize the word genocide by misusing it like that. As well as the word Imperialist.
I guess all the NATIVES should get their land back?
What do you define Palestinian land as?
Back to the USSR.
This aged like milk
To all Jews, I know the Jews have had it very hard for centuries, but that doesn't give u the right to take your anger out on other races, especially Palestinians. U don't need the West Bank. That is Palestinian land, and they NEED a nation. The Jews have a nation, now let the Palestinians have theirs.
Soon God's going to shake everything up and many people will be without
Exactly. A similar situation is the Romani people. Originally from India, persecuted in WW2, but no homeland. Time to integrate in the countries you live in. To take a land back from 2k years when a majority of your "people" have intermixed with others. Therefore, you don't have any reasonable right due to genetic lineage.
We have tried letting them have a nation in the West Bank. They said no. What more can we do?
@@EzraTheEpic When this happened, Jews were the minority. What would you do if someone came to Israel today and proved their civilization predated you and wanted land?
*zionists
If Israel wasn’t a settler colonial venture at first it is now
Israel always been that way. In Palestine, Jews, Christians and Muslims lived peacefully until in 1881 when the white Ashkenazi (central and eastern) European Zionists came from Europe with the idea to take the Palestinians lands without the Palestinians on it. Since then they bought some land, and killed and cleansed various parts of Palestine all the while lying about wanting a fair and equitable 2-state solution. So here we are...
Noam Cohen, the hippie settler, was especially creepy.
Weird how most of the people he interviewed were the same people interviewed in the 2016 Vox series.
Jewish run media!
I'm kidding. Actually I am surprised a conspira-tard has not said that yet.
@@minirock000 Yeah I wasn't insinuating anything like that, I'm sure it won't take long though! I wonder if he was either trying to reference that documentry, or more likely they use the same media contacts for finding willing interviewees.
@@minirock000 You are a fool.
@@enlightenednews5265 Please explain your conclusion. Provide evidence that helped you to acquire your opinion. I am not by any means denying that assertion but I am interested how an entity or group of 'enlightened' persons could reach that conclusion from one joke from me.
Your response is anticipated with much enthusiasm, I assure you.
EDIT: My apologies for the above assumptions that you are an organisation or group of people. It appears your channel is actually less than that of an actual person. I really do not anticipate a response with the exception of more low brow personal attacks. Do your guardians allow you to access the internet without supervision regularly?
@@enlightenednews5265 You are a dolt.
This is one of the most informative and useful documentaries I have seen on this burning topic. Many thanks Ali.
They say they wanna settle there and never get out, but most of these settlers have US income, EU income. It's really just a vacation home to them. The Israeli economy would be nothing without all the money they receive from the US. I say this because one of their arguments is that there was never a Palestinian state, and that Palestine never had its own currency/economy.
So much hate so much indoctrination, lack of humanity, lack of empathy, lack of love, lack of inclusion, kindness, lack of mercy. 😢
“For many settlers, the redemption of the land is the only way to make Israel’s soul whole and pure again. And yet, the irony is, I believe, that Israel is on the verge of losing its soul by redeeming the land, by expanding, by creating more settlements.” - Wajahat Ali
whos soul yours or the Jewish ones
*The ETERNAL GOD would do anything for you!!*
Even out of love for you he went to the cross as a human!!
Philippians 2:5-8
Do these guys worship God, or the land? If it's the land then they are guilty of idolatry.
@@andrewbeswick6495 "Most zionists don't believe that God exists, but they do believe he promised them Palestine" - Prof. Ilan Pappe
Blind, duped zionists deserve a special place in hell. Deranged narcissists that worship their own selves
israel is only temporary
Let me get this right...🤔 If my previous house owner comes back and says I consistently lived here for 35 years and you have only lived here for 5 years therefore the house is mine. Is that how he is justifying this? Referring to guy at 3:50
And that isn't even a good comparison.
@Aghilas lol well said
a house isn't comparable to a country
Its more than that it is prophecy and destiny
That is a slight misrepresentation...
Jews were always persecuted and had to flee and abandon their home...
Now I am a big believer in secularism, so I think neither side is correct in saying only people of a specific religion are supposed to live there...
I’ve been watching documentaries and reading books and articles looking for context to the horrendous events of Oct 7, 2023 and the aftermath. I’m so glad I found this. My only criticism is, it should be longer. C’mon, Atlantic! Surely you have the resources. This is a subject for an entire series.
That documentary should have been at least 40 minutes long. These conversations you were having with everyone were so interesting to watch!
The hirony of people escaping opression to become opressors is amazing
The Zionists came as terrorists and continue their barbarism against defenseless people. There were never differences between Jews, Christians and Muslims until the Zionists arrived.
The same irony can be said about Palestinians.
Same thing is happening in the Western World
It's happened a thousand times in history. Western liberals have a very naive view of human nature.
@Phillis "Dick" Black Palestinians oppress groups like the LGBT
The problem I see here's that both the parties are holding onto their past and wants to get back there. Some wants to go back 70 years and some wants to go back 2000 years ago. Neither of this going to work, you can't even get back to yesterday... So please accept the reality of today and keep your strong identity towards religion away and see this with humanity first approach. Then and only then things will change for better.
After so many years of fighting and bloodshed is not realistic to say that the two parties can live peacefully together. All that happened during these terrible years of living next to each other, created a big trauma. The political and economic propaganda plays also a big role This is a big dilemma and both sides have their rights. The problem is that as long they don't find a suitable solution for everybody, more and more people will be killed. That land is drained in blood even from ancient times!
Ironically, I'd say this is one of the places in which you're the farthest from God you can possibly be.
Wrong, liberal.
Can you explain why Josué is wrong, and why you just chose his political party for him?
Duck Because israel is the most sacred land, that is where you are closest to God. Second only a libtard would say that.
@@kollective3608 is there any need for the hate? Can't you just have a conversation without insulting others?
Katrina Hannan And you are as far from God as anyone could be especially because of your disrespectful and evil way of insulting others
It proves Judaism is not the same as Zionism. I love and respect honest Jews who work for peace and equality. God bless them all.
What a load of crap Alden...... Did you know that the zionists who created Israel weren't religious at all? They weren't Jews, they were business/political figures.... you want to learn more? Just ask
Alden, it's LIAR like you who make my blood boil, going on with the fabricated story about Jews being the INDIGENOUS PEOPLE OF PALESTINE..... yes Jews did & still do live in Palestine, but not in the descriptive way you've just spewed out... Jews,Muslims,Christians all lived together as ONE PALESTINIANS..... Alden, here's a suggestion, those who pray to the wailing wall shouldn't make contact with the stone structure, otherwise they may suffer injuries relating to falsehoods & exaggerated claims. OK
Much of what we now call Zionism stems from Judaism.
True Ronie, AND at the time of the great catastrophe in 1948, Jewish leaders wrote to their so called (fake) co religionists & demanded Palestine stay as it had for thousands of years..... Even earlier than that, during the Balfour declaration, many Jewish members of Parliament were against the creation of a loyal little Jewish ulster that would keep the region in check from the Arabs if they were to be brave enough to challenge British rule; the most notable was MP Montague who was a stern rod against the fake Jews (zionists)...... Israel was created after the agreed colonisation by the British imperialists AND THEN THAT COLONISATION MORPHED INTO THE FALSEHOOD THAT ISRAEL IS THE HOLY LAND
Who was the first prime minister of PaLIEstine??🥵 and when was PaLIEstine declared a state for the first time??🥵 if you answer these questions then you will understand by yourself that there was never a state called PaLIEstine🥵
4:09 In case anyone is wondering that's a Didgeridoo he is playing which originate from the indigenous people of Australia.
I don't understand why if he knows he's settling someone else's land and knows it's illegal he's still there.
Simply bc they can, and their government allow it and protect these colonizers in hopes that one day they can steal the whole land
Its the settlers who r trying to get what small area is left for Palestinians.
You don't have to be a Muslim to support Palestine, you just have be a human being ❤🇵🇸
Islam = hell
Do you condemn palestians settle in kurdish towns in occupied kurdistan by Syria its happening right now
false the correct one is racist = hell@@texasarknights5637
do you know the history about Hamas what is it and how it became that do you know Palestine do you know Israel why they fight and what to blame do you know history did you see crime after crime or you just follow the media i don't hate Israel people but i hate Israel as a Country for its crimes and i hate other countries for supporting crimes i don't hate America but that also has history of crimes but know to see that America support israel is heart breaking or ok let us forgot the past but what we see now is Hamas attacks first yes but Israel has to come with a smart solution that has not involved the innocent people we see Israel Boombing buildings and hospitals and their media was like Hamas killed thousands of Childs head off with zero proof the world only see one side they all share lies they also support Israel why because of religion racist@@texasarknights5637
😂😂Muslims have inflicted greatest pain on humanity because of their stupid book. Stand with Israel 250%
Imagine if native americans started occupying peoples homes in this country. This logic is as sick as it gets
Well done~!! I seem to always think of Palestinians and Israelis as two 'groups' with 'group think" yet there is so much diversity of views within each group. This video really shows this. In a lot of circumstances, family say, we find it hard to get even two or three members to agree on everything. How much harder for a situation like this when there are millions of viewpoints~? Wish we could all wake up oblivious to our 'identities' one day and just live our lives collectively. Basic structure of society is important it seems for things to work better for everyone, but politics is very damning. When will humans learn~? Edit: "There is no way to peace. Peace is the way." A.J. Muste.
they really missed the mark; arrogance, ego, racism, selfishness, and showing hate isn't relevant to those who claim any faith, or humanity
14:58 "The way that my people are settling Judea and Sumeria is unfortunately coming at the expense of the Palestinian people-I think that's a fact."
@@frostcupcake6564 eat crap
The Jewish Rabbi is smarter than all of the Zionist combined...
Frost Cupcake pretty sure Palestine existed and was recognized by Greeks and romans far before Islam became a thing,not even mentioning the fact that the semetic Arabian cannainits were the first to settle the region factually.
Alden Buyer pretty sure America/isreal would the one paying your kind considering they have a history of doing that.
what do you mean My people??
Brilliant documentary into the crazy but sad situation of the west Bank, thanks
How can a man from the Bronx claim that because some mysterious ancestry allegedly lived there he has more right than a man with a key to a house? (A house that Medad probably watched being demolished as a child)? [Hope I make sense].
There is a state called Israel you dope
The same way one idiot (prophet) flew on flying horse in it's dream.
David. Nonswnce stateof Isdaël is exluding the westbank and gaza. Judea and Samaria or on the westbank. So no jews should be there. who cares about an old story like the Thora or bibel or koran.
Or leave whoke Israël and take the westbank as jews but not all the land.
Wasn’t sure how this was going to be, but watched it anyway and glad that I did. Really enjoyed the narrator, he is able to see both sides and recognize the truth that people can absolutely destroy themselves if they get to lost in the extreme.
🙏🙏
''I am going to raise them a Muslim, it is up to them whether or not they want to be Muslim.
I dont want them to be animated and fueled either with a zealous love or a
hate inspired by buildings or land, like I see it happening heer. I hope they see beyond that.''
This goes to all religion
Funny thing is calling indigenous people “terrorist” and calling themselves “settlers”. Ive never heard someone to psychopathic like that.
Funny thing is calling natives "settlers" and preventing them from returning to their land. Israel will win.
This
I appreciate how impartial this documentary was. It presented the facts in a raw yet impartial way, that allows viewers to get an idea of what is happening in the region.
It's not impartial. Literally starts off by saying that Israel is a brutal, colonizing force. Did you even watch it?
@@ucrjedibecause it is. Wake up.
@@ucrjediLiterally started stating his background and the ideas that been taught to him hence why he started this journey to see both sides. Yet, you didn't like it because of what it shows. 14:40 "The closer you are the less you see" describes you well.