Let's Talk Movies | Thugs Of Hindostan, Tumbbad | Anupama Chopra, Rahul Desai, Sucharita Tyagi
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- Our in house critics Anupama Chopra, Rahul Desai and Sucharita Tyagi discuss recent releases #ThugsOfHindostan, #Tumbbad and #BadhaaiHo.
Have you subscribed to Film Companion yet? Join us here -
bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Visit us at filmcompanion.in
Do Like, Share, Comment & Subscribe to our channel.
Subscribe: bit.ly/FCsubscribe
Follow Us On:
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
/ filmcompanion
The Film Companion is a web channel intended to promote Indian cinema through films review, interviews, discussions, video essays and analytical compilations. It is intended primarily for the purpose of encouraging informed discussions, criticism and review of cinema and towards such purpose the programs use short extracts of cinematograph films, sounds recording and photographic works. These clips and extracts are of a minimal nature and the use is not intended to interfere in any manner with their commercial exploitation of the compete work by the owners of the copyright. The use of works are in compliance with the fair dealing exception provided under Sec. 52 of the Copyright Act, and we asset our use of the works under the exception provided for criticism and review.
When rahul said “I always have expectations whenever a new movie comes up, except salman khan”, I was like you are my bro
Sucharita you watched Thugs Of Hindostan, and you say you dont watch horror movie!!
Savage dude
🤣🤣🤣
It's only you dear
It was not horror. I am offended. You people don't know what hard work goes into making such huge level shit film. It is sci-fi fused with thriller and neo-noir.
That's not a horror movie it's horrible
20:27 Tumbbad
Thanks
🖕🖕🖕🖕
Thanks bro
Thank you ♥️
Thanks
C'mon guys! Age of superstars will not be over unless people like you, who are supposed to understand the films, will dedicate more time to discussion on movies like Tumbbad. Out of 26 minutes, for about 20 minutes, you talked about TOH and Amir Khan. Then 3 min on Tumbbad and again answered questions regarding TOH and Amir Khan. You could have discussed achievements and shortcomings of Tumbbad, but you chose to discuss a bad film like TOH. Disappointed!
Well said .👍👍👍👍👍
exactly i don't know why anupama was defending aamir khan's character which was utter bullshit in the entire film
These are Bollywood people... They've been paid massively to not talk bad things about a shitty film... Putting a name of good film in title and talking about it for just a less than a min is the way of saying "tumbbad marketing team has not paid us enought"... It's all about the nepotism and superstars... Because these guys are also working in show business for years...
Very well said, why they talk toh more, despite it being such a crap
EXACTLY!!....I WAS EXPECTING critics to b appreciating #TUMBBAD ....but these guys r constantly discussing TOH .....
This video is injustice to Tumbbad.
So true, I just kept on seeking and found no mentions, except a 1-2 min at the last. And Rahul saying he missed something in Tumbbad, dude, please. You are just biased. Appreciate that the horror it created in the first half, and the surprise it pulls off in the climax is the best in horror/thriller/surprise genre in Bollywood for a long time. Comparing a movie like Tumbbad with international cinema is gross injustice solely because of the reason that it's been made in Bollywood with so many production issues and a low budget. The vfx monster and his den gave me more chills than any Bollywood film and some Hollywood movies too.
The fact why the monster in Tumbbad keeps us scary is because of the unpredictability. Usually, in horror movies we expect the monster to overpower humans always. Here, that element was changed to unpredictable. You get to see a man tease the monster and getting away with it as if nothing happened yet succumbing to it when we feel nothing will happen.
Amen.
More than the unpredictability of the film, it created a finished narrative unlike Pari and gave us the all the answers one could think of at the end. This genre based segregation of movies is killing their penchant for critique.
@@Rakz4u8 I will even say this storyline and the concept based horror is better written than majority of Hollywood horrors. Only films Shining, Witch, Get Out, etc are comparable. Maybe East Asian horror movies and anime can be compared.
Shit man 20 Min for THUGS and everything else is damn 5 mins.
Really absurd
Failures are as fascinating as success, as Anupama rightly said
Tumbbad was hypnotic. The cinematography, sound design, score and art design was at a level i've not seen in Hindi cinema before. Psychological/atmospheric horror done very very well.
I rarely see it in foreign films too.
Finally u talked about Tumbbad for 120seconds and BadhaiHo in approx 100seconds..🙄
wow they spoke so much about tumbbad.... heard so little about TOH. :/ (*sarcastic *) Bullshit!!!! at least give equal time to the movies you're talking about... came here to hear about TUMBBAD
TUMBBAD SHOULD GET OSCAR NOMINATION
@@Palashvadnere trueeee...for production design and maybe for Cinematography!
And thugs for 20 mins that too a good review(paid)...We're here for tumbbad!!!
@@shreyanksurve8100 true😂
I feel yrf has some magic to convince superstars n make shit films
Not some magic.,handsome money
Dahi and shakkar for you ❤️
@Shashank Reddy.... especially Vijay Krishnan Acharya!! I Would never be able to understand why YRF backing such director.
That magic is called money in our world
Agreed bro
And in the last five minutes, they finally talk about Badhai Ho and Tumbbad.
#PaidPeople
Actually tumbbad needed more time to be spoken upon !! Masterpiece!! Sadly a crap like Thugs gets more time in the video !
We can never hear the questions! Pls give the poor guy a mic! :)
I feel it's wrong when people say that title of TOH is not justified as there are no thugs...can't u see they have looted the audience
YRF's best movie featuring Aamir has been _Fanaa_ by a long, long shot.
Absolutely agree
absolutely agree
7 Cr question on KBC
“Name one movie which Rahul Desai liked??”
Badhaai ho
Sairat
The guy has sobered down now
i want to know your thoughts on ZERO? don’t you think it is like every other srk’s romantic movie except that srk is playing a vertically challenged person with the help of vfx. Srk’s mannerism is same the usual srk, dialogue deliveries, the way he walks, shouldn’t he at least try to study how the movements of vertically challenged people differs from regular person, i know it for the fact because one of my friends is vertically challanged and he feels that the movie is mocking people like him instead of celebrating them.
Brother I felt same. Not a srk fan but anand fan indeed. When anand said in one interview that he is not mocking anyone instead movie celebrates the incompleteness. I got sold on it.
Let's wait. I have faith in Anand. He will not let down.
Watch KGF instead
It's an escapist cinema..logic aur justice k chakkar me nahi pad sakte .waise ye film hai apne aap me risk..thodi bhi achhi hogi toh bahot achhi lagegi..Anushka ke liye I am concerned because the boat already has sailed for her.lets see.we need good films and we have hope for that
you know what the first thing that crossed my mind after watching the Zero trailer - the french movie called Intouchables...from what is shown so far, they just replaced the physically challenged old frenchman with Anushka, and the black guy with SRK - and as always Bollywood needs a love triangle hence Kat
I really hope I'm wrong cause I have too much faith in Himanshu's writing ability
It's only me or everyone think about jab Tak hai Jaan just after watching zero trailer ?
Even though Tumbbard was released long back, you should still give it a proper review guys out respect for such a phenomenal story, cinematography, screenplay, direction, performances....And yes age of Superstars will end eventually and gradually because audiences are getting more evolved day by day.
They have given a detailed review( both Rahul desai and Anupama Chopra)
And they do discuss, they discussed mard ko dard, Sonchiriya in great detail
I was eagerly waiting for sucharita's take on Tumbbad...it less scary but more spine chilling kinda film...like IT(clown vaala) was.
When Aamir does a bad film..everybody gets shocked that how did this story appeal to Aamir. That my love is the trust ppl have on aamir
There are various other factors also. The fact that this film had the biggest budget in bollywood and they hyped it as India's first fantasy film. Also the star cast.
True that. But to say the truth, the trailer in itself was unappealing and not promising. Had decided to not watch it the moment I saw the trailer.
@@asianetsurya me too, it was like bunch of people fighting in a swimming pool.
Aamir on kbc said that this is the first movie since long that he chose on character .
Why would you get shocked?
He has done so many horrible films.
He made this image and people blindly follow that.
He has always done commercial masala films.
HAHA YAYYY!
Ur video was more precise n better..
Why don't you make video on 5 worst and best comments of yours on film companion. 😂
😬
Why dont u join them....
@@rajdeepchadha4155 *MATLAB KUCH BHI!*
You should watch 'NAAL' Marathi movie
Fanah was the worst film of Amir's career? What is this guy saying? Thugs is a bad film but if this guy didn't like Fanah then he is not the kind of guy whose review I would care for about a main stream hindi movie.
These people Doesn't Know About Film And Film Making.
@@mushtaq_shaikh sure, and you do.
Arunima Tiwari LOL.. Good one..
Arunima Tiwari Yes I Do ☺
@@mushtaq_shaikh so you claim to know more about film and filmmaking than three legitimate film critics who get paid for their knowledge and expertise in film??? interesting
Golden words spoken by Anupama - “masala is so hard to do!” Waaah
What a point ....I too felt that....eklavya bodyguard hahahhaah
Stree movie to dekha tha su4ita ne.. jhoothi.. 😅😆
22:24
Shekhar Singh hehe i commented before reaching 22:24
#desperationlevel
Akshay Joshi 😂😂😂😂
Usne bola tha baad mei yaar
She said she watched. Atleast wait like 5 minutes before putting a comment 😆
Sorry but the main and only think i like about movie is katrina kaif she acted well, she dances well, when she come its a delight for movie, its fun to watch her
True
K.G.F Review pleaseeeeeeeee
Lmao, the Eklavya comment
Objectivity in a world of defensivess..... muahhh
hindi me samjha sakta h kya bhai ?
Sachi Rout anupama ko laga ke amitabh ka kirdaar, thugs of hindustan mein, unke pati ke picture eklavya se liya gaya, bus thoda budha gaya. Aur maine likha ki anupama ko iss baat ki daad deni chahiye ki filmy duniya mein jaha pe sab log bahut jazbaati ho jaate hai apne kaam ko lekar, unke paas ye kabiliyat hai ki woh apne pati jaise kareebi insaan ke kaam ko halke aur zameen pe dimagh rakh kar dekh sakti hain.
Level headedness aur easy ka translation mereko pata nahi tha iss liye halka aur zameen pe dimagh
@@A_free_n1 haha samjh gaya tha ...eklavya film was completely out of my mind..
Don't mean to be rude but Desai's tone is so tiresome
I genuinely don't understand why people are soo obsessed with watching films in the first three days.
If you really give a shit about saving money why not wait till Monday to get the word of mouth and read critics reviews.
This is the reason why theaters charge you soo much money and get away with it
Yes you are correct i always do that but with TOH i don't know what happened to me i booked for 1st day and had to pay 350 for 2 tickets( not a very good theatre)
Yup becoz they are idiots ,agar itna he roote ho paise ke liye toa review pad lo but critizim is read film is bad, the fans will definitely be upset everyone expects this stature film to be good, the film you genuinely like from trailer, you definitely watch
Because we watch movies as a form of hero worship. If we thought about the experience, the story, we would wait for sometime.
Because it will be spoiled by Monday. Also most people are fee on weekend. No job /schools. Also reviews and word of mouth is out by Saturday.
I think it's only because of their job. Since they review movies, guess they need to watch it early on
What I feel is even though Katrina has the least role in this film ...actually she is the one who has done her job perfectly in this film
😂
Yes atleast she knows her limitations as an actor and works aacordingly
you are joking , right? i am asking because didn't see bazinga in the end.
Ritu Bala
I am not joking ......she had to look beautiful and show us great dance moves which she did perfectly as there was not much for her to do in this film
@@consdrireu2102 Katrina and Jacqueline dance very well but only on songs with modern feel.. And it's not a bad thing... They have great core strength... But a character like this which you felt was small also could be played far better by someone who knew what adaayin is and what the character demands...Rekha in mukaddar ka sikandar, GAUHAR in ISHQZAADE did great job because they know how much is too much when it comes to Indian dancing.... Aishwarya in kajraare... Indian dancing requires perfect flowing moves and not perfect Pilates moves... It's different... It requires riyaz... Watch vaijyanti mala in amarpali... If you offer an argument that she practices a lot, then please see the making of the video and compare Kat with the dance assistant ... Kat puts just too much effort and kill the essence... Sometimes an artist should know how much is enough even if they can jump ten feet and the requirement is for only five then they should stick to just five... No need to do what you can do, do what character can...
Please do this more often
I really look forward to these discussions
another over-hyped film is on its way
2.0
it looks terrible from trailers
Bhai shankar director hai
It’s like I can guess the story
The dark knight (2008) is the gold standard !!
@@shera281 bhai ashutosh gawarikar ne bhi mohenjo daro banai hai.. don't go by names, go by the content which is out there on display and the teaser and trailer have fallen flat is the truth.
2.0 looks very derived . at anypoint, you can name 5 Hollywood films it is inspired by. Liked the technical touch but the trailer lacked heart. it will not make any difference whatever we discuss here. it will rule the roost in South India. As Film Companion just said. Superstar culture in India is not going anywhere
SUCHARITA U R SO ANIMATED.......U MAKE THE EPISODE VERY ENTERTAINING............ANU ...U KNOW...U R A SUPERSTAR....U ALL CREATE GOOD CONTENT BUT THE WAY THIS CONTENT IS PRESENTED TO US NEEDS ALSO TO BE ENTERTAINING AND ENGAGING..................THNX TO ALL OF U TO KEEP US ENGAGED......I LOOK FORWARD TO ALL YOUR INTERVIEWS...REVIEWS AND MOVIE TALKS.........LOVED THE SEGMENT OF "BENEATH THE SURFACE - KJO N PRIYANKA''...SHOT ON THE STREETS OF AMSTERDAM (I GUESS...SOME EUROPEAN STREET...MAYBE)...............PLZ BRING US MORE SUCH SEGMENTS.................LOTS OF LOVE AND A TRUE ADMIRER.........NAVJOT :)
Fanaa was a good movie Rahul. Come on man
Yaa i agree.. I don't know what does he like... Even someone inhale.. He would say it was the worst thing i have seen
That littlie shit doesn’t like any hindi movies at all..
fanna was not a good movie...crap presented in a fancy way...
Fannah is beautiful drama film.
Guys...one whole video dedicated to THUGS!! Salute to FC.
it seems you went through the comments and then discussed tumbad ..thank you..:)
whole video they were just talking about Thugs and then Finally main part came at 20:27 for which i was waiting for
Yrf produces mostly mediocre films.... Thugs, ek tha tiger, tiger zinda hai, jab tak hai jaan, dhoom3, qaidi band, jhoom barabar jhoom, tara rum pum, thoda pyar thoda magic... List goes on
Thoda pyaar thoda magic,Tara rum were so bad..yuck..May be married Aditya's love for Rani..Dono pati patni Yash Raj ka Naam duba rahe he.
You are so right
Yet you keep watching!
@@fatyfarrell Nopes. I didn't watch Thugs of hindostan, Tashan, jhoom barabar jhoom, thoda pyar thoda magic, tara rum pum, laga chunri mai daag not even on television.
@@meenaverma1870 Who the fuck came up with those titles, Im not indian so i don't even knows what they means let alone pay to watch them.
Hey! Whats wrong with Fanaa??
What is right about it?
It was a pretty mediocre movie. Extremely dated for starters.
@@onibon1990 I watched it back when it released as a kid. I remember liking it. Maybe you are right. But to say it was one of his worst three films, I think is a stretch. Fanaa was better than 85% of Bollywood movies that were releasing at that point of time.
I think they meant aamir khan movies only. And that too 2000 onwards. Considering his other movies this one was probably not one of his best works, not the worst either. Im guessing thugs and dhoom 3 take the cake.
haha..i liked it too!
3 of my favorite Indian film critics. Good work guys! ❤️
Does this guy ever like anything.....!!!!!!
Good movies
😂😂😂
He does. Good movies. For example last week's discussion he said he liked "Andhadun" and "Badhai Ho"
@Krishna Chaitanya 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ranveer singh as khilji ..I still remember this😁😁😁
next time either give a mic for those questions or at least put them on subtitles
Mam, Let's talk movies or just a panel with Bharadwaj rangan sir ,it's almost the end of the year , please make this dream panel come true
Would love to know what were your issues with Tumbbad ?
when aliens find earth and want to learn about human emotions they'll take rahul desai to learn about sadness
Why you people don't talk about directors at all ... Your whole conversation was around Amir .. I personally feel you were just talking about something but it didn't add up to anything
@Filmcompanion team, many thanks for the episode. Also, I really appreciate the way you are establishing a genuine two-way relationship with your viewers. Keep up the momentum of film appreciation and criticism in India. Way to go!
I love it when the coffee comes each time. Feels cosy for some reason 🍵
Brings me so much joy watching your discussions. Thank you for your content. Lots of love from Vietnam.
This Rahul seems to be very unhappy n pessimist person as he mentions negative points with so much zeal n positive ones with so much apathy nd the way he says Okay Fine Aamir has Done good work but not that great....Dude come on even i am not a Aamir Fan but Hands down that Man is a Great Actor.
Sandeep Mehta chutiya sandeep srk bot everywhere abusing every aamir fan u r jobless n sooo insecure jist like srk!!
His voice and thick accent is painful to ears.
How could so many wise men go so wrong? The answer is simple - when you're ideologically wrong shit falls apart no matter how much money and big names you put in!
7:56 save your ears
Fanaa was a good film. I liked it. 😬
Compared to any 80s-90s movie, sure, it fit right it. Not compared to films in the 2000s. Most films are judged basis the time they came out in, and how it took cinema to the next level. This was regression at its best. Corny throughout
@@onibon1990 regardless of time, I enjoyed the movie and its story throughout. ✌️
That's fair and completely personal. I guess I was giving a critics POV more than a standalone viewers.
Imdb 7.2
Rotten Tomatoes 100%
Google users 89%
Don't know about critics
1:15 , Sucharita , i haven't seen it , i'm avoiding a migraine, saving money and a lot more. i realised the value of time and money this year after Race 3 :p
Also, i'm enjoying all the bashing of this movie and that's why i'm here.
Katrina can do so much action and stunts due to her physicality, this director just wasted her potential.
Rahul Desai always looks so sad. He didn't even wish happy Diwali.
KGF ki baat karo yaar... Trailer review ya kuch
KGF- Khoob Gaan Faadu Movie Hogi
It is not at all a bad movie..you can watch it one time...
We do have disastrous brainless movies collected well at box office
Who are these people to judge movie. How much experience they have of film making. Its easy to give shitty comments on what u dnt see. Audience didnt like the story n tats it. Aajkal koi bhi uthke review daal deta hai youtube pe. Pseudo intellectuals.
Didn't talk about tumbbad at all ....full boring review..do not watch
Zero vs KGF .I am kannadiga and srk fan but when people talk about KGF vs zero really I am in heaven as kannada film in the pivotal place please give a thought on this. Please support KGF film in your channel
it was one time watch, not as bad as the reviews suggested
That might be the best review about the film
It was cringe to watch it
You dont understand it is not about one time watchable movies but rejecting mediocrity in indian cinema which is passed by the audience due to hero worship. I love the fact that this movie flopped and i hope bollywood changes for the better
Rahul Itna depression main q hai
Look at Rahul Desai speaking so frankly, politely and truthfully ladies... Learn something from him
How could you talk so much about Thugs but only gave Tumbbad, which is the finest fantasy film from all aspects from bollywood, only 2-3 minutes... You could have just given atleast half the time to Tumbbad, it has set a bar for fantasy and horror in India.
Rahul seems pseudo intellectual...😃
What's you guys have thoughts of about KGF plz share
KGF- Khhob Gaan Faadu Movie rahegi
Maaaaan, I wish I was at this table!
1 day..... maybe. Live in hope!
I always know a fashion trend is passé when I see Indians wearing it. So it’s obviously clear that torn jeans are now finished !
Rahul says "THIS" country??? Wow man.
Granted he can sap the party mood, but don't make a mountain out of a molehill. The emphasis is completely yours and 'this' is a demonstrative pronoun commonly used, this place, this house, this state bol sakte hai toh this country mein kya kharabi hai?
Dont let Rahul review any comedy movies.. He dont like humour at all..
A warm hello to sucharita,Rahul and anupama from Melbourne
My gripes (spoilers):
Impressive opening act. Sets up a grand, nation sweeping saga. Then goes all downhill from there.
1. Amitabh's character was a bad ass of no background. Not even a throwaway line about his back story, or motivation. He is called Azaad. And that is supposedly meant to also be a metaphor for his moral stance - fight the British. Freedom for Indians. That stuff. But throughout the movie he isn't fighting for freedom. He's fighting for revenge. He's not fighting the British. He's fighting one man-Clive. It becomes a petty revenge movie instead of a grand period film about Thugs fighting the British. Wasted opportunity.
2. Fatima's character also, like you guys said, completely one-note. Look angry (your parents were killed), fight. That's it.
3. Amir's best friend in the movie? Completely useless! Grandly introduced as a man who spoke the language of the thugs and could live amongst them as one of their own, he turned out to be nothing but! Only there as a comedic relief and for Amir's verbose character to act against. Why wasn't he just introduced as a mere friend instead of all that mighty introduction?
1-3: If they mean to film a sequel, then they should've done better with the world-building and characters.
4. After the British sail into a trap and the thugs leave one man alive to pass on a message, the thugs make no plans to change their hide-out nor put sentries out there. What kind of outfit are they? The plot-convenient kind?
5. That dance/attempted assassination of Clive? That scene was put there only so that Katrina's character would have something to do. Remove her, write up an interesting (and plausible, or too much to ask?) assassination attempt.
Because of that scene, we had another one of those many, many twists, which by that time came off more as a shock factor. Not that a shock factor isn't any good, but by this time i felt it was stale. Instead they could've focused on an equally lengthy, smart and decisive finale.
6. Katrina's character? She was in the movie? LoL
The other inconsistencies regarding the action sequences, I'd just be nitpicking.
Edit: Whoa! That felt good. Writing it all down. Cathartic!
whole reason is due to director vijya krishna acharya who doesn't know even the abc of direction
Sahrukh Khan does his movies just to earn money.He isnt there for the craft.Be it Zero one or Infinity he plays the same cliched lovable character with good heart.Even if he breaks his usual character and goes for a new one like in Don it is usually like all charming things and stuffs.Once in a while he does films like My Name is Khan Chak De.The rest ninety percent its just typical flowery bollywood bullshit
Watch fan. His character of Aryan and Gaurav both are different.
Sucharita is all of us when we go back for diwali and come back chubbier :P
dear filmcompanion thank you for the very toucheable thought and heart behind every video . i enjoy most of them
i have a request can you translate in english whenever u speak in english because u alot of international viewrs who r not indian .
The movie has crashed ..... On boxoffice after record first Day
I can't see Sanju movie Review in this channel? Any body knows the reason ??😕
OK, it's unethical for the channel to review it because Vidhu Vinod Chopra, the producer is Anupama's husband.
Praveen Gupta it was vidhu vinod chopra production , husband of anupama chopra so no reviews .
@@nehashukla5480 Neha ....yes...it was sarcastic comment ....but not ethical by Anu to not review that movie.Sad though
Actually They Don't Reviews Good Films, They Review Only Bad Films To Get More Attention.
@@mushtaq_shaikh Are u saying Sanju is the only good movie this year? They reviewed Street, Andhadun,bhadhi ho etc.
watched thugs, definitely not a masterpiece but still a entertaining one time watch but it was sad to see how the movie was rampaged by critics and media , these ultra intellectuals just hate if a commercial mainstream movie comes but on rottentomatoes it got good review from hollywood critics , after panning it received i dont think conventional bollywood wud even attempt such adventure movie kindly do not turn hindi mainstream cinema into a art cinema meant only for multiplex audience
Its just 18% on RT
www.rottentomatoes.com/m/thugs_of_hindostan
And yes its bad, watch tumbaad if you want indian cinema to grow.
But it wasn't just critics and intellectuals who hated it--it was the common people on the street who cared enough to put their hard earned money in for the tickets and came back disappointed. Finally, we are recognizing that we are consumers and we deserve to receive value for our money. Why should audience support substandard cinema because it wants to promote non-conventional film-making? Sorry making and promoting good cinema is the producers' responsibility, not the audience. Would you accept sub-standard food, education, roads? No, you would not because you should value your money. In fact, you are valued only because of your money.
@@mehul5387 i said hollywood critics it got 2 positive out of 3
But on rotten tomatoes it got good reviews those are your words.
@@mehul5387 i said "but on rottentomatoes it got good review from hollywood critics" most critics there are indian only , just 3 are from hollywood
In South top heroes have 5.30 am show and it's house full everytime.
"Aamir trying reallyyyy hard to pull it together but the rest " true that ...firangi was simply on fire 🔥
Aamir was great in the movie, good to see him in a different role. The film's screenplay and direction was weak.
Different role? He's been approcahing comic roles with the same manner from decades. Nothing new there
Suyash Awasthi this is for sandeep mehta srk pr agent.... Sandeep Mehta srk is the shittiest actor hamming it up as if he is perennially constipated in all emotional scenes and when it comes to comedy it was funny u said subtle look at his pathetic attempts at comedy in chennai express or hny or any non romantic film if he has any.... his overacting in the interval scene of kalhonaaho makes me cringe till date i cant watch it!! Critics analysts n fellow actors have all rated aamir as the best actor of his generation!! U conveniently talk of aamirs early 90s films like aatank hi aatank or daulat ki jung but how about his versatility in different genres be it lagaan sarfarosh rangeela rangdebasanti andazapnaapna ghulam dilchahtahai talaash taarezameenpar ghajini 3 idiots pk jojeetawohisikandar dangal etc!! Insecure srk fans plz try to be objective for once....
even zero is nothing but srk playing himself in a romantic film with the vertically challenged man as a gimmick hopefully anandrai who writes small town humour very well may save the film like he did with tanuwedsmanu series or ranjhana..,
n real life too srk is a master manipulator and a pompous full of himself philosophy spouting pretentious ass!!
@Sandeep Mehta Just watch 3 idiots and rate the comedy.
Watch dil chahta hai and rate the comedy.
And watch ghajni first half and rate the comedy.
After all this, I hope you stop writing such long comments with agenda visible all over it.
Every actor has bad films and thug is one of them. Move on.
@@suyashawasthi1 You did not like 3 idioits? You did not like rang de basanti?
Now thats a first!
@@rp1443 Just because he is srk pr agent.. u do not need to be one for aamir.
Both are legends of Indian cinema with good body of work. Stop belittling a person just because you do not like them.
Victor Acharya knows something about Aamir that Aamir does not want anyone to know. How else can he keep convincing him to star in the movies. Definitely not by showing Tashan
Sunil m.s .... comment of the century
I agree. For someone like Aamir who I find him quite intelligent but to work with this director twice....eh? And to approve Dhoom 3 which is a RIP OFF from The Prestige... a RIP OFF! Surely for someone who is passionate about his work would not approve plagiarism. I donno man... and Thug...ughh
Barely spoke about quality movies like Tumbbad. Tumbbad deserves a seperate video of its own, infact you could have discussed elaborately about the change in horror genre in Bollywood since movies like Pari, Tumbbad and Stree. But you guys won't do it. Blabbering for 20+ about Thugs of Hindostan. Why Film Companion why?
Moreee discussions like this plehz. Absolutely love critics critically discussing movies 😍
KGF trailer review Pleeez
Film companion does not review trailers.
@@bikashkumarswain6911 thye reviewed zero just last week.
Please see naal marathi movie नागराज manjule in it
This is the reason the whole world don't take bollywood seriously .After Dhomm3 , it took me Amir's 3 good movies to like him back again😠😢
tumbbad should get national award.
Sucharita ne diwali me kya khaya?
Torn Jeans pant
Lund
*It was a disaster of gigantic proportions from the last 5-7 years. TOH is an example of how you can make a mess of this size despite having a ton of money for the budget. Victor has proved the 3rd time that his big ambitions don't translate into better execution. No studio or producer should spend their money on his movies anymore. He is good for nothing type of director.*
I think victor should now experiment and do low budget movies and if that works then make big budget movies
@Jeevan M R I took my girlfriend to watch Dhoom 3 because I am a huge AK fan. Half way into the movie and I was snoring. That was the first for me. I had never fallen asleep in the theater. My girlfriend was mad that I pushed her to watch a Bollywood movie and I praised a lot about AK before the movie.
d3 was plagiarized, and writing not as good as d2. but sparing dat it was a good action thriller of indian standard.
Victor Should quit Direction not only that he should be forbidden to hold even a Camera
When does the discussion for Tumbbad start? 🤔
21 : 00
How can you say that it's not a good movie, you guys are having fun while reviewing it, I will surely watch it on digital app, may be on Amazon.
Thugs wasn’t bad, I went in with lowered expectations and I liked the film. It had flaws but they weren’t big enough for the hate the movie is getting. It was meant to be a pure commercial entertainer like Aamir had said and it did that to a good extent. Film deserved more positivity.
Fuck off..
Shut up
💯 sure tune free me dekha hoga
@@ulfathsadia6115 I actually watched it twice and the ticket cost $23 which equals to 1,203 rupees and times that by two = 2,406 rupees. So I actually paid more than you for it :)
Mahir Aryan I paid $14 😂😂😂
I admire Rahul's reviews. It is always honest and unaffected by popular opinion.
I am glad u understood what he said. I didnt. If someone trolls me and calls me a moron for not understanding rahul's train of thought i plead guilty but his train of thought has too many tracks and the train gets derails. Thats why may be he's a DEEEEEP thinker.
Hi Sucharita! Namaste namaste. Loved your honest review and ya dude 'jaan' nahi thi movie mein. Anu I m so glad u exist ❤️...I could listen forever. It is sad that such accomplished actors expect so little from their audience to actually believe that making such a movie will satisfy the audience. Of course EXPECT MORE! It's rediculous otherwise. This is picture art in motion and the art comes alive when the motion captures the life in the eyes of the human actors. - okay got carried away at the end there. I wonder if they had flipped the script, keep women the main thugs and actually make them fkin badass white walker killing thugs!!!! - yup got carried away again
The reason I put a thumbs down on this video because Mr. Desai called ‘Fanaa’ one of the worst films in Aamir’s career. Has he gone completely mad?
I love sucharita
Same here. Sucharita is the best thing on film companion followed by anupama.
One time watch .....-nice way to say movie is garbage😂
Sucharita looks totally different. I couldn't recognize her. I like her hair not bounded
If you feel there is something missing in Tumbadd then you may as well stop watching movies.