Meet the Israeli “traitors” standing against the war in Gaza

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 05. 2024
  • While opposition to Israel's conduct in Gaza is voiced around the world, in Israel support for the war is still strong, but we speak to one of only two people imprisoned for refusing to serve in the army. (Subscribe: bit.ly/C4_News_Subscribe)
    Meanwhile, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has told his fellow politicians they need to stand united against the United States, as it cautions against an offensive in Rafah.
    Mr Netanyahu has sent a delegation to the US to discuss Israel's planned military operation in Gaza's southern city, where more than a million Palestinians are sheltering.
    -----------------------
    Follow us:
    Facebook - / channel4news
    Twitter - / channel4news
    TikTok - / c4news
    Instagram - / channel4news

Komentáře • 2,3K

  • @jeanneparadise8200
    @jeanneparadise8200 Před měsícem +550

    Don't participate in the IDF abuse. She is not a traitor, she is so courageous .
    Decent people don't support the sadistic genocide.

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem +8

      why do you support hamas then?

    • @NazmusLabs
      @NazmusLabs Před měsícem +18

      @@user-sp3wd2nn3e because they fight for the freedom of the Palestinians. They are heroes. I’m not gonna apologize for that.

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +1

      @@NazmusLabs How will troiists ever be free?

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +3

      terr-o-riist soup porter.

    • @mintchocolatechip273
      @mintchocolatechip273 Před měsícem +4

      ​@@NazmusLabsFinally, someone with a spine.

  • @LukeMovement1
    @LukeMovement1 Před měsícem +600

    Jailed for not committing war crimes. The irony

    • @forjerusalemssakeiwillnotr5608
      @forjerusalemssakeiwillnotr5608 Před měsícem

      Why is protecting your country a war crime? Why do you all assume Its ok for the Palestinians to shoot rockets at israeli children, burn homes with people in them, kidnap children and elderly. And Israel is not allowed to respond and protect themselves or search for the kidnapped. Sorry for the Palestian children hurt by this, but their parents dint give Israel a choice.

    • @yasirkhan6455
      @yasirkhan6455 Před měsícem

      jews...

    • @HamzaGrygori
      @HamzaGrygori Před měsícem

      Its the I D F and D stands for Defense. Defense after Oct 7th f.i..

    • @LukeMovement1
      @LukeMovement1 Před měsícem +22

      @@HamzaGrygori occupation since 1948 👍 learn to educate yourself kiddo

    • @HamzaGrygori
      @HamzaGrygori Před měsícem +1

      @@LukeMovement1 Jewish state since 1948. What occupation? Pals always att first (since 1948) so educate yourself.

  • @Morbing_Time
    @Morbing_Time Před měsícem +564

    Imagine a government forcing you to kill civilians or be imprisoned. Fucking crazy

  • @RunPJs
    @RunPJs Před měsícem +492

    she has about 90% of the planet on her side - good for her

    • @t1m3l0rd
      @t1m3l0rd Před měsícem +27

      Lol no she doesn’t. You live in world of fantasy.

    • @RunPJs
      @RunPJs Před měsícem

      @t1m3l0rd are you saying that more than 10% of the worlds population are pathological genocidal supporting trash?

    • @user-mx2nh4pt9h
      @user-mx2nh4pt9h Před měsícem +9

      It is essential to recognize that the Arab aggression against Jews predates the modern state of Israel and is rooted in a complex historical context shaped by centuries of interaction and conflict between Arab and Jewish (The Children of Israel) populations. Understanding this historical backdrop is crucial for comprehending the complexities of the Arab-Israeli conflict and working towards lasting peace and reconciliation in the region.

    • @ShaySaysSo
      @ShaySaysSo Před měsícem

      ​@@user-mx2nh4pt9hmany arabs are Jewish! Stop spreading your made-up history!

    • @yosikful
      @yosikful Před měsícem

      @@user-mx2nh4pt9hThat is simply not true. Historically, Jews have been the safest is Muslim countries. Proof is when Andalisia was reconquered, Jews were welcomed with open arms into countries like Morocco and north Africa in general. Don’t twist narratives by inventing lies.

  • @jcpt8365
    @jcpt8365 Před měsícem +1027

    Finally, Sophia's story went mainstream! She is amazing and on the right side of history!

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem

      Wrong side of history. You want Is-rael to be weak. Can't fool us.

    • @falakeexdrolly3938
      @falakeexdrolly3938 Před měsícem +53

      The humane world loves you Sophia. God bless ❤ free Palestine 🇵🇸 🙏

    • @jh8914100
      @jh8914100 Před měsícem +1

      ​@elkobit7415 of course there's always one of you in the comment sections lol. I am sure you're in the Frontline killing women and children eh. Or you just another keyboard warrior?

    • @JuanAristi
      @JuanAristi Před měsícem +38

      @@elkobit7415She stood up against Israel’s plausible Genocide

    • @annamoris9753
      @annamoris9753 Před měsícem +18

      There is mandatory military service for women and men in the State of Israel. I think that refusing is wrong because it is clear that the country needs the army and without the army Israel will not survive here surrounded by Arab countries that are not satisfied with our existence as a Jewish state here. I refused to serve in the occupied territories and protect the setlements, but I did serve as a medic at the Gaza borde, and I am proud of it. my family now sending money to my family's friends in Deir al-Balah, they hate Hamas and hope that the war will end when Hamas no longer rules there. The war, even if it is difficult, is against Hamas and not against the Gazans.

  • @PatriciaClaireEdelstein
    @PatriciaClaireEdelstein Před měsícem +844

    Sophia I salute you. I wish there were more Israeli women like you.

    • @aiiscool6118
      @aiiscool6118 Před měsícem +22

      she was just too lazy to enlist the army💀

    • @andreskorge1828
      @andreskorge1828 Před měsícem

      @@aiiscool6118
      Idyit

    • @joselimjoco3367
      @joselimjoco3367 Před měsícem +27

      If she were one of the hodtages, she would feel and think a very different way!

    • @martinwhitney9343
      @martinwhitney9343 Před měsícem +33

      @@joselimjoco3367you dont know that

    • @MrBagpipes
      @MrBagpipes Před měsícem +29

      ​@@aiiscool6118 interesting how Orthodox Jews are exempted from national service but not pacifists. 🤔

  • @hmustafa6500
    @hmustafa6500 Před měsícem +103

    It's great to see young people who think for themselves and aren't influenced by patriotic propaganda.

    • @MsBhappy
      @MsBhappy Před měsícem

      Where are they in Gaza and the West Bank?

    • @vincentvangogh8092
      @vincentvangogh8092 Před měsícem +2

      people need to stop hating on the young who are brave and have principles having learnt their parents and grandparents lessons

    • @saikatkolay2255
      @saikatkolay2255 Před 27 dny

      but one specific religion teaches everyone to hate who are not from the same community, right?

    • @hmustafa6500
      @hmustafa6500 Před 27 dny

      @@saikatkolay2255 that's politics, all religion teaches peace

    • @larrybarnett5799
      @larrybarnett5799 Před 13 dny

      yawn...nothing wrong with patriotism..
      what a f-ing globalist comment. globalism fails every time. and i do not give a F, about your reply..

  • @Mrnobody957
    @Mrnobody957 Před měsícem +53

    Sofia : You are not a traitor. You are an Angel walking among us lost humans, bringing the heavenly words that we are all woven from the same thread of humanity and love, regardless of religion. Salute from the depths of my heart.

  • @shootingsportstransparency7461
    @shootingsportstransparency7461 Před měsícem +660

    Brave girl Sophia don't you worry history will judge. Never forget same thing happend in Nazi Germany with people who don't wanted to kill innocent civilians

    • @norman_5623
      @norman_5623 Před měsícem +5

      Sophie Scholl.

    • @Naruto-db8yg
      @Naruto-db8yg Před měsícem

      In Germany, there is still denial of genocide. It's amazing how Germany manages to be on wrong side the history every time.

    • @MrKnowItAll2024
      @MrKnowItAll2024 Před měsícem

      Hamas, Islamic Jihad and the Palestinian Authority share the same anti-Semitic Nazi ideology. Read their charter.
      🎗💔✡️

    • @cmciaranmasterson
      @cmciaranmasterson Před měsícem +14

      The difference is that, unlike Germans who opposed the Nazis, the Israeli woman who is refusing to serve in the military won't be executed. She is also not being tortured.

    • @shootingsportstransparency7461
      @shootingsportstransparency7461 Před měsícem +11

      @@cmciaranmasterson Thanks to Western civilized media

  • @Jordan77831
    @Jordan77831 Před měsícem +574

    As an anti-zionist Jew, I feel hope when I see brave young boys and girls like her. I already cut my ties with almost everyone I know from Israel, but as it turns out, not everyone is complicit with what is going on, just as not every Jew is a Zionist.

    • @user-ed7et3pb4o
      @user-ed7et3pb4o Před měsícem +61

      God bless you. One day in Palestine all the children will live amongst each other and play together again, and it will be because of brave and honest people like you.

    • @clintonisidore
      @clintonisidore Před měsícem

      ​@@user-ed7et3pb4owhich Palestine, keep dreaming

    • @clintonisidore
      @clintonisidore Před měsícem +25

      You might as well go live in Gaza

    • @hasanalhasani
      @hasanalhasani Před měsícem +1

      ​@@clintonisidoreI hope one day the world will be free of people with a mentally like yours. ❤

    • @gooner2047
      @gooner2047 Před měsícem +50

      ​@clintonisidore how about you go back and live in Poland or ukrain or Russia or Romania... maybe Armenia

  • @monas5054
    @monas5054 Před měsícem +9

    you can tell how proud and protective her parents are of her. They did an amazing job raising such a beautiful kind young woman.

  • @Laurence-dc2is
    @Laurence-dc2is Před měsícem +70

    I absolutely salute you, you brave, brave, honest young woman!!! The world is with you and on behalf of the world I wish you safety, strength and peace!!! The world will always remember your courage for doing what is right and your parents for their support of you. I salute the rest of your family too!!!

  • @lilvat262
    @lilvat262 Před měsícem +451

    She should be proud of herself for not being involved in this conflict

    • @ali-rikabrands8637
      @ali-rikabrands8637 Před měsícem

      Do you really think, Israel wanted the conflict. That the innocents wanted to be massacred

    • @abbeyroad9529
      @abbeyroad9529 Před měsícem +12

      she is inevitably involved in this conflict beacuse she lives there what

    • @santalofty4917
      @santalofty4917 Před měsícem

      @@abbeyroad9529 exactly ALL are settlers , colons ; squatters , thiefs ect ect

    • @HamzaGrygori
      @HamzaGrygori Před měsícem

      A proud trait-or.

  • @daniellekwant1425
    @daniellekwant1425 Před měsícem +315

    Youre not a traitor but a brave girl standing on the good side!

    • @zicokanoo5383
      @zicokanoo5383 Před měsícem +18

      Muhammad Ali also had moral courage like Sophia and many more. Peace to them all.

    • @kryogenica4759
      @kryogenica4759 Před měsícem +16

      And she very mentally strong to be emotionally abused by the military personnel and still not breaking away with her morals

    • @Ethanuk26
      @Ethanuk26 Před měsícem

      I wish you would say the same about russia.
      @@kryogenica4759

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +6

      Traitor.

    • @kryogenica4759
      @kryogenica4759 Před měsícem +17

      @elkobit7415 If standing for human rights, which the Palestinians are denied by the Israeli state, especially in the west Bank, is being a traitor, then so be it and proudly

  • @cheese_wrld
    @cheese_wrld Před měsícem +50

    The fact that they call Sophia's belief for human rights as being a "traitor" says a lot about that society.

  • @NaeemKhan-bk4mm
    @NaeemKhan-bk4mm Před měsícem +9

    I love each and every Israeli who wants peace to prevail in the land comprehensively, I will Insha Allaha meet those people from both the sides. We are human so I believe war hungry politicians and their ugly ambitions cannot bring harmony and Prosperity to the land.

  • @Rades1055
    @Rades1055 Před měsícem +42

    Just like not all Palestinians are Hamas, not all Jews are zionists.

    • @ivantibormate7086
      @ivantibormate7086 Před měsícem

      A non Zionist Jew is like a heterosexual lesbian. It's either, or.

    • @Igor-nn8tw
      @Igor-nn8tw Před měsícem

      Why, what is the difference?

  • @gkepxxx
    @gkepxxx Před měsícem +147

    Israel's destroyed 75% of Gaza, killing 32,000 Palistines, 69,000 are disabled, 1.9 million are displaced left to die from cold and starvation! Netanyahu's government must stand trial for these heinous crimes against humanity! Independence & Justice for Palestine!🇵🇸

    • @user-mx2nh4pt9h
      @user-mx2nh4pt9h Před měsícem +3

      It is essential to recognize that the Arab aggression against Jews predates the modern state of Israel and is rooted in a complex historical context shaped by centuries of interaction and conflict between Arab and Jewish (The Children of Israel) populations. Understanding this historical backdrop is crucial for comprehending the complexities of the Arab-Israeli conflict and working towards lasting peace and reconciliation in the region.

    • @lord_hellraiser254
      @lord_hellraiser254 Před měsícem

      @@user-mx2nh4pt9h Bot? Because you sound like Chatgpt

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      Lol you accept all those those nice round figures straight from pallywood, only minutes after its supposed to have ocurred. You are aware that these ludicrous numbers are unverifiable because no journalist would risk his life mingling with murderous muslim jihadis on the ground? And that in reality it takes weeks and months of careful investigation to arrive at true numbers for such events?

    • @apinbozzo3457
      @apinbozzo3457 Před měsícem

      They are not Israeli, they are germans colonized who colonized palestine.

    • @eyesonyou99
      @eyesonyou99 Před měsícem +1

      Whose numbers? You believe Hamas?

  • @mahbubsubhan2308
    @mahbubsubhan2308 Před měsícem +29

    They are not traitor, they are good human beings. They don't want to kill innocent people.

  • @michaelcuri9902
    @michaelcuri9902 Před měsícem +17

    What a brave young woman Sophia. I am surprised there are not more like her who believe every human being has rights.

    • @kriggo1
      @kriggo1 Před měsícem

      But Jews are the chosen people, we need to submit to their will

    • @user-mj3ju1mb5e
      @user-mj3ju1mb5e Před měsícem

      We are , every day we re more hope some day we will the majority ❤

  • @enzoeclipsed
    @enzoeclipsed Před měsícem +554

    Only two?! I thought there were more….this doesn’t bode well for that society

    • @DeniseWilliams-jr5xo
      @DeniseWilliams-jr5xo Před měsícem

      No there should be more. Of course Zionism is all about indoctrination. Indoctrinating their young people to hate Arabs.

    • @WanderingExistence
      @WanderingExistence Před měsícem

      Most of them are racists.

    • @IcarianX
      @IcarianX Před měsícem

      Israel is a very sick society... How could it not be, given their own foundation myths, institutional brainwashing and propaganda?

    • @kathleencove
      @kathleencove Před měsícem +91

      There are only two that refused to obey the initial draft altogether. Tal Mitnick (the other objector) has said to Amy Goodman from Democracy Now, that many deserters who leave once they see the battlefield, have also gone to jail. They just don’t realize that what they’ve been told is false until they see for themselves. Many of the soldiers know exactly what they’re doing, but some go in honestly thinking they’re the good guys until they see what their side is doing up close. Some of those people who wake up in the battlefield / military op rooms, and then desert, are in jail now. Meital Yaniv is one of the women who left after she served for a while and woke up to what is happening. She’s living in Los Angeles now to avoid being jailed in Israel, and she’s part of Jewish Voices foe Peace

    • @enzoeclipsed
      @enzoeclipsed Před měsícem +19

      @@kathleencove thanks for the info. I hope there is power to change from within their ranks as well as from the outside

  • @tethergobrrr
    @tethergobrrr Před měsícem +183

    Sophia has been very brave through this. Not just in refusing but in fronting up on global media at eighteen.

    • @DennisJack-we9sq
      @DennisJack-we9sq Před měsícem +4

      I’m proud of Israel. Arab government won’t keep this girl alive

  • @jaykay5688
    @jaykay5688 Před měsícem +13

    Good on her! If I was her parent I would be proud of her have such kind soul!! Sadly not many people think clearly with their heads..blurry moral standards is everywhere now..people keep choosing to do the wrong things…many innocent lives have lost….i truly hope the insanity will end soon🙏🏻

  • @camillaroest3768
    @camillaroest3768 Před měsícem +5

    The parents can be truly proud of their brave daughter. Thank you!!

  • @jujutrini8412
    @jujutrini8412 Před měsícem +244

    Well done to you Sophia. Standing up for your principles is to be admired.

    • @leroysimon5692
      @leroysimon5692 Před měsícem +1

      👏🏾👏🏾👍🏾

    • @user-mx2nh4pt9h
      @user-mx2nh4pt9h Před měsícem

      It is essential to recognize that the Arab aggression against Jews predates the modern state of Israel and is rooted in a complex historical context shaped by centuries of interaction and conflict between Arab and Jewish (The Children of Israel) populations. Understanding this historical backdrop is crucial for comprehending the complexities of the Arab-Israeli conflict and working towards lasting peace and reconciliation in the region.

  • @aboucard93
    @aboucard93 Před měsícem +173

    I wouldn't want to spend one day in prison. This woman and the young man. Are very brave. It's not easy to stand up for what is right and to go to jail for it. I hope she runs for political office.

  • @Sniptool
    @Sniptool Před měsícem +2

    Saying no in participating genocide is not called as traitor but human with sound heart. You are one of the very few in apartheid state to be called as hero.

  • @benjamindavey4782
    @benjamindavey4782 Před 29 dny +2

    One of my great-great grandparents, a Quaker, was jailed for refusing to fight in World War I. He and other conscientious objectors suffered in prison, under horrible conditions that would now be considered illegal under international law. I pass no judgement on those Israelis who feel it is their duty to protect their country at such terrible times in history (like one great-great uncle of mine, who died in a German gas attack in the trenches), but I also have great respect for those who refuse to participate in wars due to the honest and sincere dictates of their consciences. I hope this family are happy and feel safe again.

  • @moonbow867
    @moonbow867 Před měsícem +35

    Take pride in being called that. In a soulless society, it speaks of your humanity.

  • @Patrica84
    @Patrica84 Před měsícem +155

    She is a great human being 🕊️

    • @aiiscool6118
      @aiiscool6118 Před měsícem +4

      she was just too lazy to enlist the army💀

    • @insatsuki_no_koshou
      @insatsuki_no_koshou Před měsícem +26

      ​@@aiiscool6118Too lazy to participate in genocide.

    • @user-pp7gl4kc8s
      @user-pp7gl4kc8s Před měsícem

      no she is just very stupid..

    • @fuzielectron5172
      @fuzielectron5172 Před měsícem +4

      Lol alliscool and elkobit through the comments talking rubbish about a decent human being.

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +5

      @@fuzielectron5172 "Decent" because it fits your Arab narrat-!ve of a we-ak Is-rael.
      can't fool us.

  • @ashleighnikolarakos98
    @ashleighnikolarakos98 Před měsícem +49

    She isn’t a Traitor.. it’s called empathy

    • @juanpedrojosegaffneyr9064
      @juanpedrojosegaffneyr9064 Před měsícem +5

      It's also called honesty; justice; right-living.

    • @eagle-4-gaming814
      @eagle-4-gaming814 Před měsícem

      ​@@Christian_ZionistSo for you ,refusing to commit a genocide is called cowardice, you either a heartless Zionist or an average media consumer

    • @ashleighnikolarakos98
      @ashleighnikolarakos98 Před měsícem +1

      @@Christian_Zionist entitlement to stand up for innocent civilians getting slaughtered?

    • @ashleighnikolarakos98
      @ashleighnikolarakos98 Před měsícem

      @@Christian_Zionist your late to the party

    • @DeduDed-en3je
      @DeduDed-en3je Před měsícem +1

      It is also called bullshit

  • @olivetreelighthouse8659
    @olivetreelighthouse8659 Před měsícem +3

    Lovely young lady. I'm thinking of her parents. They've brought her up in this environment and still she kept a pure soul that rejects racism and seeks justice & equal rights for all human beings. They taught her well or at least supported her natural sense of empathy and justice. I hope she reads this one day. I hope she's able to stay true to her beautiful nature and I wish her everything good wherever she is.

  • @Tekkailz124
    @Tekkailz124 Před měsícem +178

    Brave young girl, if only people had that much courage. This is a true hero and an inspiration.

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +3

      Sure you want Is-rael to be weak. we get it.

    • @nest1363
      @nest1363 Před měsícem +17

      @@elkobit7415 Israhel is by far the weakest country in human history. The level of over the top emotional reacting from both government and population is unprecedented.

    • @SOPHISTICATED_VIBES
      @SOPHISTICATED_VIBES Před měsícem +9

      @@elkobit7415It is weak in deed more than what people think and it’s getting exposed more and more on a daily basis.

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +5

      @@nest1363 Winning all their w@rs is indeed very, very, very weak. Are you delusional?🤣🤣🤣

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +3

      @@SOPHISTICATED_VIBES Name one other country that won all its w@r and admit that Is-rael is the strongest country.

  • @layinlow77
    @layinlow77 Před měsícem +104

    Bless this girl. Kepp following your conscience, young lady.

  • @yakobadamovich1813
    @yakobadamovich1813 Před měsícem +5

    Wow this girl is a hero! her parents must be so proud

  • @Tangoman82
    @Tangoman82 Před měsícem +10

    Germans who resisted the Nazi regime were also considered traitors back then. History will do justice to this young Israeli lady.

  • @linvisible7782
    @linvisible7782 Před měsícem +185

    Well done those standing up for Palestine

    • @captainwin6333
      @captainwin6333 Před měsícem +5

      @@elkobit7415 They will.

    • @vaughancreighton9994
      @vaughancreighton9994 Před měsícem

      ​@elkobit7415 Think you're dreaming, They have had 75 years of Israel apartheid, So thinking of it's over,don't think so.

    • @MarianneExJohnson
      @MarianneExJohnson Před měsícem

      @@abdell75roussosIsrael is stealing Palestinian land, not the other way around, buddy.

    • @MarianneExJohnson
      @MarianneExJohnson Před měsícem +1

      @@abdell75roussosIsrael is st ea li ng Pal est ini an land, not the other way around.

    • @MarianneExJohnson
      @MarianneExJohnson Před měsícem

      @@abdell75roussosIs ra el is st ea li ng Pa le st in ia n la nd, no t th e ot he r wa y ar ou nd.

  • @christopherwayne2761
    @christopherwayne2761 Před měsícem +76

    One of few humanity left in the state.

  • @GVX817
    @GVX817 Před měsícem +3

    Yeah some war going on in Israel when people can just walk down the beach and have Starbucks

    • @Najda007
      @Najda007 Před měsícem

      It is not a war, it is just Israelis butch ering Gazans

    • @georgietully-watts2593
      @georgietully-watts2593 Před měsícem

      haha there are no Starbucks in Israel

  • @Happetybuppety
    @Happetybuppety Před 28 dny +2

    What a brave and courageous young lady. I cannot imagine how nasty they would've been to her and probably still are for not taking part in a genocide.

  • @heatherbrown384
    @heatherbrown384 Před měsícem +95

    GOD BLESS THEM! A testament to her parents and the way in which they brought up their child. Sadly, too, too few.

  • @richw9394
    @richw9394 Před měsícem +61

    She's a hero. It's sad they are so few loke her. Israelis have been groomed to hate the Palestinians from a young age. And then serving in the IDF makes them complicit in the oppression. Admitting that they have justified or took part in these atrocities would be too difficult. It's easier for them to deny and deflect. Few want to admit that they are on the wrong side of history.

    • @mz4kids
      @mz4kids Před měsícem +3

      she is not a hero . she refused national service she could complete her service working in a hospital or school not in the army. this is a publicity hound

    • @richw9394
      @richw9394 Před měsícem +8

      @@mz4kids I would disagree, we all have a duty not to participate in genocide. If there were more heroes like her making a stand and publicly announcing it, then Israel would not be able to commit the war crimes that it does. Never again means something to some of us.

    • @MrFernandesb
      @MrFernandesb Před měsícem

      The more I hear about Israel the more sick I get it appears that the Zionists hate Christians even more than they hate the Palestinians. The Irony is that the Muslims are close to Christians in what they believe.
      The Hindus and the Zionists are both evil as the both are extreme

    • @SloLee17
      @SloLee17 Před měsícem +1

      This is very wrong and misleading. I've met thousands of Jewish Israelis and NEVER heard anyone say they hate a Palestinian. That would be stupid because Palestinians (also known is Israeli Arabs) also live INSIDE Israel (not just West Bank and Gaza) and go to the same universities, shopping, live in the same buildings, etc. Inside Israel they are neighbors and coexist. They hang out together on weekends, and though less common, marry each other. Goodness gracious that could NEVER be accepted in an Arab ruled country. 20% of the Israeli citizens are Arabs and growing each year. These Arabs have family in the West Bank and Gaza.
      On the contrary, everyone I have met feels sorry for the Palestinians. They know that it is not a good life. But everyone knows why occupation and blockade are there I'm the first place...because every chance given Palestinians in West Bank and Gaza will kill Jews. They did this before Israel was created (when all Jews and Arabs in the area were considered "Palestinian"), they did this when borders were open, and they will do it if the blockade and occupation end. Everyone knows it, including Israeli Arabs. Israeli Arabs serve VOLUNTARILY in the IDF...and there are many. Israeli Arabs are politicians and judges. They go to the same schools. To say Israelis are "groomed" from a young age to hate Palestinians is a blatant lie. Go there and see for yourself. I am not Israeli. I'm not Jewish. But I have seen for myself that Israel is possibly the most diverse and possible tolerant country on the planet considering all of the extremist in the middle east. Truly a beautiful people, with no agenda, that other people hate and want to demonize just for being Jewish.
      That said, it is true that there are some extremist Jews in Israel usually from a minority of very religious background. But the people who are "fighting" those people are...fellow Israeli Jews. This is why you see Israeli JEWS in Israel publicly protesting settlements in the West Bank, and Israeli JEWS advocating for public transportation on Saturdays.
      Honestly, if you don't really know what's going on there...haven't lived there or even been there...don't spread lies about a country you clearly have only heard about from antisemites. Instead, if you want to spread information, start with an open mind and just go see for yourself.

    • @yosikful
      @yosikful Před měsícem

      @@SloLee17that is completely false. Jews always coexisted in peace with arabs! It’s only in Europe that they were prosecuted. And I need not mention the hate Israelis have for Palestinians as they demonstrate it themselves on social media. Funny you think people don’t have access to Data on the internet.

  • @Glastonbury1
    @Glastonbury1 Před měsícem

    Bravo Safia!!!! How strong and exceptional you are. Take heart that you are seen, you are heard and your stance, your not following along with the rest of Israel is so unbelieveably important. Thank you for your outstanding courage!!! NEVER change. Please hold your humanitarian balance. Best wishes to you!!

  • @ariffkome
    @ariffkome Před měsícem +8

    She has a heart of gold.. To fight againts your own country will be hard.. Be strong safiya..

  • @paladinbob1236
    @paladinbob1236 Před měsícem +16

    its takes a brave person to stand for peace...even more so , when your country is at war, and the otherhalf dont really want to know or care about it :(

  • @HontuZindabad
    @HontuZindabad Před měsícem +103

    Even Sophia herself might be unaware how much honor & reward is in store for her on the Day of Judgement. Bravo.

  • @Starlightbarking
    @Starlightbarking Před měsícem +14

    Wow only two objectors, that must be an international record low out of any conscription in history

    • @jmanakajosh9354
      @jmanakajosh9354 Před 26 dny

      There's a whole segregated part of that society who just want to read the Bible and won't fight but they'll never see prison.

  • @user-ke1xz7ct8k
    @user-ke1xz7ct8k Před měsícem +27

    Bravo - Some One With A Conscience And Values

  • @nonamefm23
    @nonamefm23 Před měsícem +5

    Salute to Sophia and all the peace activist israelis right there, very brave and shows humanity..meanwhile the rest of the story is sadly true, most israelis couldnt care less about whats happening in their neighbour..

  • @hmzgha6243
    @hmzgha6243 Před měsícem +2

    Never forget, Rachel Corrie
    🙏

  • @purekarate
    @purekarate Před měsícem +93

    This young lady is a hero, her parents should be proud of her.

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +3

      Proud of a traitor?

    • @yuisdtiraNome
      @yuisdtiraNome Před měsícem +7

      Proud to be a hero of humanity!
      Proud to represent the truth about dehumanization that still happen!

    • @elkobit7415
      @elkobit7415 Před měsícem +1

      @@yuisdtiraNome Proud to be a fool.

    • @yuisdtiraNome
      @yuisdtiraNome Před měsícem +6

      @@elkobit7415
      best than being a supporter of the hypocritical murderer!

    • @lord_hellraiser254
      @lord_hellraiser254 Před měsícem +3

      @@elkobit7415 with your logic every human that stood against oppression is a traitor? well in that case I'm a traitor as well.

  • @paulappleton5812
    @paulappleton5812 Před měsícem +28

    I hope her voice of resistance raises up other young brave voices for peace

  • @brightpage1020
    @brightpage1020 Před měsícem

    I love what the conscientious objector said in the beginning!
    Thank you for this perspective!

  • @moraisisabel6424
    @moraisisabel6424 Před měsícem +50

    Well done the Channel 4 is showing his side.

  • @majl7917
    @majl7917 Před měsícem +60

    Good reporting.

    • @thepanther8925
      @thepanther8925 Před měsícem

      the ending statement lost my respect, saying 7th october "overides anything else", clearly false.

  • @dianasher5510
    @dianasher5510 Před měsícem +18

    She is the hero, not the traitor. She dared to say No to Israel’s government

  • @ihtesham_emon
    @ihtesham_emon Před měsícem +1

    Jailed. For. Not. Commiting. War. Crimes.

  • @jaymfom6963
    @jaymfom6963 Před měsícem +92

    Not all heroes wear capes!

    • @WanderingExistence
      @WanderingExistence Před měsícem +7

      Some go to jail.
      "We know too well that our freedom is incomplete without the freedom of the Palestinians." - Nelson Mandela

    • @andypitt2848
      @andypitt2848 Před měsícem

  • @alingard1
    @alingard1 Před měsícem +87

    A true patriot is someone that criticises their country because they want to make it better. Same old tropes you get from extremist governments, traitors, will of the people etc etc...

  • @sbeast64
    @sbeast64 Před měsícem +1

    Also known as courageous people with a conscience.

  • @splash2976
    @splash2976 Před měsícem +8

    Netanyahu should be in Jail, Not Her.

  • @Seemidarling
    @Seemidarling Před měsícem +71

    Thank you for standing up against a violent regime.

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      and hamas isn't a violent regime to you? you need a lobotomy.

  • @salvadorpalma8173
    @salvadorpalma8173 Před měsícem +33

    Sofia Orr, you are a hero and a good person. We thank you and your parents.

    • @lilyayusupova2932
      @lilyayusupova2932 Před měsícem

      Oh, how it reminds me the situation in Russia🤕...
      After 02. 24.22( the day of Russian z-army invasion to Ukraine) a lot of Russians approved this criminal war against Ukraine and even there were real nazists among them, who wished Ukraine to be destroyed, or like "there is no nation like Ukranians, they are all Russians and we will conquer all Ukraine" And so on...
      And now 2 years later after being hit on a muzzle Russians wants the war to end. But, unfortunately we, Russians now are occupying ~20% pf Ukrainian territory. And all like me who are against this occupation of Ukraine and against war with Ukraininans - all we are called "traitors" by compatriots.
      So I really feel bad for Ukrainians and Palestinians. Cause they had to face the similar problem.🤕

  • @user-fn6oc2bi6u
    @user-fn6oc2bi6u Před měsícem +1

    When the older people rules the country ...

  • @igorkreep
    @igorkreep Před měsícem +2

    "Israel only talks about their hostages and losses and not the palestinian ones"😭
    Oh I must have missed all the coverage and compassion from the palestinian news about the israeli ones🤔

  • @pawelanglik5964
    @pawelanglik5964 Před měsícem +62

    What an amazing brave young woman!!

  • @NOTJustANomad
    @NOTJustANomad Před měsícem +75

    regardless of if you agree with her or not, you need to admit that it takes a ton of self-reflection and courage to overcome the indoctrination you've been receiving since childhood and reach a point to understand it, to stand up to it, and especially when knowing that the entire society will be against you.
    salute.

    • @Daniel-jv1ku
      @Daniel-jv1ku Před měsícem

      No. If she wasn't a hypocrite, she would leave Israel. I hope she does.
      Even the most far-left Jews in Israel are fighting in the IDF.
      The kinds that call Israel a "racist, terrorist, supremacist state". Even they fight, because they no what would happen without the army. A real genocide... against Jews. She should leave Israel NOW.

    • @les0218
      @les0218 Před měsícem

      Also this is Israel. Imagine if a woman does this in a muslim country. Every muslim using this against Israel are idiots.

    • @abbeyroad9529
      @abbeyroad9529 Před měsícem +9

      please don't forget there are also many Israelis that are supporting her

    • @abbeyroad9529
      @abbeyroad9529 Před měsícem +2

      ​@@thotslayer9914I don't really have anywhere else to go and I'm very young so no. But maybe I'll have to run away from here soon

    • @isabellac1117
      @isabellac1117 Před měsícem +2

      @@abbeyroad9529You ignore the these unnecessary questions. You are young, and I am not. I, too, can’t leave mine. And, I often see the signs to go…. Stay true to who you are!

  • @SH-lk8rh
    @SH-lk8rh Před měsícem +2

    Thank you Channel 4 for reporting this.

  • @thomasjosullivan9179
    @thomasjosullivan9179 Před měsícem +60

    Respect you so much Sophia

  • @karimaabdelmalki3601
    @karimaabdelmalki3601 Před měsícem +98

    Good for her!! She will be able to look at herself in the mirror

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      How do you though? when you support baby-killers and murderers.

  • @TrueNorthPatriot
    @TrueNorthPatriot Před měsícem +4

    What happens to conscientious objectors who grow up in Islamist families in Gaza or the West Banks? And what is the TV coverage like on Palestinian TV stations, you know, the free press there? Are they interviewing the family members of hostages or of those in Kibbutzim who managed not to be burned in ovens? Did they interview the Palestinian poet (before he was killed) about his ['With or without baking powder? tweet or did they ask Israelis how they felt about that tweet?
    If anyone has seen Channel 4 segments on this subject, please do be sure to share the URL below.

  • @mardasman428
    @mardasman428 Před měsícem +2

    A democratic society has the right to form its own opinions, even if Western audiences might not like it. I do think that Israelis are better informed about the situation around it than Western audiences who might just have a very naive or simplistic view of it.
    There is a reason why there are just two conscientious objectors: Because most Israelis are aware that they are under threat by Iran and antisemitic terrorist groups such as Hamas and that they have to protect themselves against it. Not all Israelis are in favor of the current conduct of the war however, there is a big divergence of opinion with regard to that.

  • @GiannisG3A3
    @GiannisG3A3 Před měsícem +4

    because its a democracy... in several muslim countries (if not all) they would just ...disappear...

  • @strungleforbetter4343
    @strungleforbetter4343 Před měsícem +20

    Beautiful young lady with a beautiful clean heart ........shalom

  • @RohitKumar-xz7un
    @RohitKumar-xz7un Před měsícem +1

    A traitor with a conscience. I love her!

  • @Davad-fd7ky
    @Davad-fd7ky Před měsícem +6

    If you're unwilling to defend your nation and its people against terrorists, that's your choice. However, the safety and freedom she enjoys are due to the sacrifices of soldiers who protect her and her family. How spoiled and comfortable must she be to not only decline military service (there are alternative roles like nursing or supporting in the kitchen) but also to criticise those who defend you and the very country you call home. Without an army, she would have been 6 feet under de ground by now or floating in the Mediterranean sea even before October the 7th.

    • @Prod.z3nzi
      @Prod.z3nzi Před měsícem

      Should Americans support the war of Afghanistan or Iraq which was proven to have been a lie by the US government? Just because people are fighting, does not mean you cannot oppose the cause, especially when it is a cause as sickening as the israeli genocide campaign to steal Palestinian land.
      Only a coward would follow orders of a genocidal maniac rather than stand up for what they believe in

  • @Weneedmoresalt
    @Weneedmoresalt Před měsícem +23

    What the world has seen since October 7th of this conflict is saturated Horror. The screaming of those people standing on the rubble of loved ones is absolutely heart wrenching.
    RIP to all those lives young and old.

  • @sheriarthur4789
    @sheriarthur4789 Před měsícem +27

    Thank you Tal and Sophia you two are truly brave and sticking to your principles. Much blessings to you 🙏🏽

  • @davidspira2358
    @davidspira2358 Před měsícem +2

    She has no understanding of what Hamas represents. She will understand better if Hamas is not defeated.

  • @karlscher5170
    @karlscher5170 Před měsícem +2

    Why don't they go to Gaza to appease Hamas?

  • @theeraphatsunthornwit6266
    @theeraphatsunthornwit6266 Před měsícem +40

    That is what dictator do, esp in wartime.

  • @squirrelandchick9484
    @squirrelandchick9484 Před měsícem +41

    A brave young woman. The world must take notice of those who call for peace.

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      that wouldn't include muslims obviously, who want to kill all non-muslims.

  • @user-sr5zv9bk4g
    @user-sr5zv9bk4g Před měsícem +2

    So proud of my country when, even in such horrific times, you hear multiple voices. The problem is that Channel 4, like many others, grabs on our oh-so-Jewish propensity for self-criticism to hammer us. Nothing is easier ah? No self criticism on the Palestinian side, though. They're spotless clean.

    • @sakha2349
      @sakha2349 Před měsícem +2

      You will agree that there is a difference - the Isr are the occupiers whereas the Pal are the occupied.

  • @vincentvangogh8092
    @vincentvangogh8092 Před měsícem +1

    much respect to this young lady

  • @Antrunu
    @Antrunu Před měsícem +34

    Only two conscientious objectors since the genocide began?!? [0:25] ...The hope that the Israelis will change their attitude on their own is minimal

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      Lol that's because 99.999999% of Israelis are sane and want to protect their lives from murderous muslim jihadis.

  • @anmarabdulaziz2419
    @anmarabdulaziz2419 Před měsícem +3

    Bless your heart sophia !

  • @3boys1family
    @3boys1family Před měsícem +1

    May God Almighty reward them and you and guide them, reveal all truth and make justice for the oppressed soon!!

  • @suhaill1890
    @suhaill1890 Před měsícem +2

    Jailed for not taking part in " Genocidee"

  • @digglerdudeuk
    @digglerdudeuk Před měsícem +40

    If only our political class had even a thousandth of the humanity and moral fortitude of Sophia.

  • @kublaikhan2020
    @kublaikhan2020 Před měsícem +44

    What a woman👏 her parents should be proud for raising such a compassionate human being.

    • @lilyayusupova2932
      @lilyayusupova2932 Před měsícem

      Oh, how it reminds me the situation in Russia🤕...
      After 02. 24.22( the day of Russian z-army invasion to Ukraine) a lot of Russians approved this criminal war against Ukraine and even there were real nazists among them, who wished Ukraine to be destroyed, or like "there is no nation like Ukranians, they are all Russians and we will conquer all Ukraine" And so on...
      And now 2 years later after being hit on a muzzle Russians wants the war to end. But, unfortunately we, Russians now are occupying ~20% pf Ukrainian territory. And all like me who are against this occupation of Ukraine and against war with Ukraininans - all we are called "traitors" by compatriots.
      So I really feel bad for Ukrainians and Palestinians. Cause they had to face the similar problem.🤕

    • @leroysimon5692
      @leroysimon5692 Před měsícem +2

      👏🏾👏🏾👍🏾

  • @faridjamali5928
    @faridjamali5928 Před 28 dny +1

    Jailed for not being part of a massacre

  • @titteryenot4524
    @titteryenot4524 Před měsícem +20

    It’s interesting that the strictest Orthodox Jews (15% of Israel’s population), who are Netanyahu’s most ardent supporters, don’t actually serve in the military, yet pacifists and those citizens who oppose his foreign policy must. Words are cheap when your own neck isn’t on the line.

    • @rhetorical1488
      @rhetorical1488 Před měsícem +4

      like the draft dodging bibis son hiding in miami

  • @TheDMG45
    @TheDMG45 Před měsícem +60

    What kind of a country sends their young *girls* to war ffs?

    • @joselimjoco3367
      @joselimjoco3367 Před měsícem +10

      Kurdistan women fight for their country!

    • @martinwhitney9343
      @martinwhitney9343 Před měsícem +7

      women have always been apart of the military. like many parts of the world.

    • @etheu9sby292
      @etheu9sby292 Před měsícem +4

      Um America

    • @lorenam8028
      @lorenam8028 Před měsícem +15

      I think you meant "their children".
      Regardless of gender.
      You shouldn't turn children into sociopathic killing machines

    • @TheDMG45
      @TheDMG45 Před měsícem

      @@lorenam8028 No, I meant girls. Soldiers are not sociopathic killing machines but soldiering is men's work and its wrong to put women and girls in that kind of danger.

  • @eliasahmed1339
    @eliasahmed1339 Před měsícem +1

    A brave sweet heart. Salute your courage.

  • @JBR868
    @JBR868 Před měsícem +2

    Bravo bravo young lady you are a role model for global peace

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      so... let the murderous muslims rampage free without opposition and the result will be peace? I think obamacare does a cheap lobotomy, you should look into it.

  • @davidladuke7039
    @davidladuke7039 Před měsícem +16

    Because fascism? Seems like it's because of fascism.

    • @RonaldReaganFan
      @RonaldReaganFan Před měsícem +2

      Conscription isn't fascism.

    • @iwatchwithnoads7480
      @iwatchwithnoads7480 Před měsícem +3

      ​@@RonaldReaganFanthis one is

    • @yosikful
      @yosikful Před měsícem

      @@RonaldReaganFanthat’s an argument that could have came in handy to a german soldier in 1945.

  • @YishEyeYo
    @YishEyeYo Před měsícem +42

    The psychological condition that created this psychotic society needs to be evaluated

    • @dannyv2468va2
      @dannyv2468va2 Před měsícem

      It is called defend your country or be massacred. She can always go live in England.

    • @blackbox9641
      @blackbox9641 Před měsícem

      it is easy: centuries of persecution + holocaust+75yrs of terrorist attacks by arabs = what you call psychotic society.

    • @ShaySaysSo
      @ShaySaysSo Před měsícem

      Same as in n∆zi Germany. They used the same playbook.

    • @user-sp3wd2nn3e
      @user-sp3wd2nn3e Před měsícem

      are you talking about palestine? yes the mental illness of islam needs to be eradicated.

  • @earthspirit516
    @earthspirit516 Před měsícem

    What a loving and courageous being! Her rewards will come in a different way because she is staying true to her heart, and not closing it down in fear and retaliation like her weaker fellow citizens.

  • @user-jh2jy5yb1n
    @user-jh2jy5yb1n Před měsícem +1

    A wonderful brave and honorable young lady, thinking of peace

  • @naymatunc-rc6vs
    @naymatunc-rc6vs Před měsícem +4

    I hope she and her family is save