I Compared 25 Engine Sounds! | Forza Motorsport VS Gran Turismo 7
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Hey guys! Today we will be looking at the engine sounds of cars included in Forza Motorsport and seeing how their sounds compare to Gran Turismo 7. We will also compare tracks as I tried to set each one in the same location and during the same time of day. All cars are 100% stock. 25 different cars are included here with timestamps down below. Thanks for watching, remember to like and subscribe!
Timestamps:
00:00 - Aston Martin Valkyrie
00:23 - Bugatti Chiron
00:43 - Dodge Super Bee
01:03 - Dodge Viper GTS
01:23 - Dodge Demon
01:43 - Ferrari Enzo
02:03 - Ferrari 458
02:23 - Ferrari LaFerrari
02:43 - Ford GT '05
03:03 - Ford Shelby GT-350R
03:23 - Ford GT '17
03:43 - Honda Civic Type R
04:03 - Lamborghini Aventador SV
04:22 - Lexus LFA
04:42 - McLaren MP4/4
05:02 - McLaren 787B
05:22 - Mazda RX-7 Spirit R
05:42 - Nissan Skyline GT-R R34
06:02 - Nissan GT-R LM
06:22 - Nissan GT-R R35
06:42 - Nissan Z
07:02 - Porsche 911 RSR
07:22 - Subaru WRX STi
07:42 - Toyota Supra RZ
08:02 - Toyota GR Supra
-DON'T CLICK THIS: bit.ly/2WI3A3J
-Watch my most recent video:
• 3 Reasons Why Forza Ho...
-Check out all the drag race battles: • Drag Races FH4
-Follow me on Instagram: / correa.cars
Music:
Lakey Inspired: Blue Boi
@LAKEYINSPIRED
#forzamotorsport #nfs #bestsoundingcar - Hry
Timestamps:
00:00 - Aston Martin Valkyrie
00:23 - Bugatti Chiron
00:43 - Dodge Super Bee
01:03 - Dodge Viper GTS
01:23 - Dodge Demon
01:43 - Ferrari Enzo
02:03 - Ferrari 458
02:23 - Ferrari LaFerrari
02:43 - Ford GT '05
03:03 - Ford Shelby GT-350R
03:23 - Ford GT '17
03:43 - Honda Civic Type R
04:03 - Lamborghini Aventador SV
04:22 - Lexus LFA
04:42 - McLaren MP4/4
05:02 - McLaren 787B
05:22 - Mazda RX-7 Spirit R
05:42 - Nissan Skyline GT-R R34
06:02 - Nissan GT-R LM
06:22 - Nissan GT-R R35
06:42 - Nissan Z
07:02 - Porsche 911 RSR
07:22 - Subaru WRX STi
07:42 - Toyota Supra RZ
08:02 - Toyota GR Supra
really mclaren 787b
@@tenyalida6124isn’t that Mazda?
gt7 is so much better
As a person who has heard every single one of these vehicles multiple times in person, I can say without a doubt the sounds itself are much better represented with Forza’s showcase even though majority of the sounds are over exaggerated, especially with exshaust notes.
Gran Turismo I’m not sure what exactly how they differ from Turn 10 in terms of recording set up, but the Dodge Viper GTS really stood out as appalling in terms of how they represented that vehicles sound. It sounded as if it was recorded from 200 foot away upwind. I have sneaking suspicion gran Turismo doesn’t even record majority of the actual vehicles like turn 10 studios does, this would explain the stark disparity and why almost nothing in GT sounds natural.
Fun fact the vehicles neither game actually records is the Aston martin Valkyrie, Enzo Ferrari.
@@known3617 plus gt7 needs better cars
Fun fact. Cars in GT7 are recorded on a dyno, scanned by hand every inch with hand-held lasers, and exported at 8k to future-proof them. This takes roughly 270 days PER CAR.
The interior cam always sounds slightly muffled in GT7 due to them recreating how it sounds in a helmet, using binaural audio.
In my opinion, ALL SOUNDS in FH4/FM7 were better than the new FM8. Side note, when you change exhaust in GT7 the sounds change along with the style of exhaust, 100% unique to each car. So yes, these stock exhausts in GT7 obviously are quiet. Put the racing exhaust on with headers and anti-lag (yes GT has that) and some sound absolutely nuts.
Fh4 is a bit of an exaggeration
Why do they sound so muffled though? I don't understand. And the audio between shifting sucks
@@azi9_itycan you give any example of when or what gave you the opinion on sounds between shifts? They all sound pretty similar to me if not better in gt7 because the sound of the increasing load being represented. As for the "muffled" sound, the original comment pretty much already summed that up. Forza uses a more exaggerated sound for stock road cars to make them artificially louder/ more exciting sounding. You can achieve a similar effect by changing the exhaust system on your car in GT. As you could probably tell especially on the older race cars, GT has loud cars but they don't make road cars louder than they are in stock form.
@@azi9_ity Because they also recorded it in a studio and leave out a lot of the noise. road, chassis, how the sound bounces around
No, it takes them 270 man-days which for many workers drastically reduces the number. Each employee puts in x amount of hours, which multiplied by the amount of employees makes it 270 days. Otherwise they wouldn't make more than a few cars each year
This comment section shows the biggest problem in gaming community, most people think loud = better, its clear that they have no clue how car sound recording works
anyone who has heard engine notes of these cars in real world videos or real life knows GT7 is way more realistic in terms of the camera distance from the car while FM is just faking the loudness like it's being recorded from a mobile phone, not to forget completely wrong engine sounds in most of the cars especially at higher RPMs
Yeah, gt7 sounded infinitely better then Forza, the different between the lfa and the r35 gtr was insane. It didn't sound even close in Forza, but it got it pretty much dead right.
This is true for chase cam but in cocpit it sounds better in forza. The high pitch sound gets muffled and the in between gears is more realistic sounding in Forza.
Forza should reduce the higher pitch just a bit.
I like how you talking like you're the camera in the distance and you know how a car would sound according to how far a camera is to it in gt7 all the cars are quiet an Aston Martin valkrie doesn't sound as soft in real life and you can still hear it from a distance same with most of the cars in the vid except the dodge viper and I also like how you talking like you've been in all the cars in the video to know exactly how they sound for you to conclude yourself by saying gt7 sounds way more realistic...Playstation fanboys do anything to protect their games...who said softer is more realistic
@@nicog4638 I haven't driven any of the cars in this specific video, but I have driven several supercars IRL which are in both games, and GT7 blows FM out of the water. Forza sounds are horribly overexaggerated, they have way too much mechanical noise and other crap masking the actual exhaust note of the car, and they're often so loud it sounds like the audio is peaking, like they were recorded at too high of a sensitivity. A lot of cars are nowhere near as violent sounding or as loud in stock form as FM pretends they are. The smoothness and "softness" of GT7's audio is wholly realistic for most of these cars.
Oh, and FM also does a horrible job depicting the shifts in automatic cars such as the Chiron, Demon, Supra etc; the shifting is slow and they sound almost like manuals instead of the near-instant shifts that GT7 accurately depicts.
Yeah but gt7 sounds like the car is inside a tunel
one of the biggest crimes here is how slow every cars shift is regardless of how fast the transmission every is. forza has never and will never understand that it is possible for factory transmissions to shift fast without a clutch.
I was looking back at the civic gear change and it wasn't fast
god finally someone mentioned it. the chiron, 458, anything with a dual clutch... you can watch the nose dip between shifts. ive driven cars like that. those cars absolutely do not do that in real life lol
Prbaly would help if he changed in the power band...
It’s because they’re playing with clutch shifting. You can change it to sequential no problem and the shift times are normal.
@@Bowseefuss101 Nope, it doesn't have to do with this. You can even change to automatic and all the DSG/DCT cars will still shift as if they had a manual transmission
i love the fact that in 3:54 you can hear vtec kick-in , such a small details which i love GT7 for
Forza has vtec transitions too, but it doesn't always happen, seems to happen more in about 2 or 3 gear
@@coreyscolaro288 Cause 4th and 5th gears are shorter, they already are in the VTEC rev range.
@sharper9164 that doesn't make any sense. I'm talking about keeping in gear, go down to 3k rpm and floor it to redline. 4 and 5 are longer than 2 and 3
More like in 5th gear,@@coreyscolaro288
@@sharper9164even gear shift sounds in NFS II PS1 is infinitely better than FM8.
OMG the LFA in GT7 is heaven😭
Yea boi 👍😎
Chisato Nishikigi when driving the LFA in GT7: SUPAKAAAAA~
Doesn't sound as good as in forza tbh
@@capitalmammalyou must be joking at this point, lfa in forza sounds like aventador.
@@capitalmammal man, is ur ear okay?
I can't believe Forza somehow managed to get the most generic car sound (R35 GT-R) so wrong 😂
LOL hear a real r35 compared to GT7 they are way off forza is more closer
@@sensimit6559 I've heard plenty of them irl already. Forza sounded like a VQ
@@TurboAlice exactly what i thought, I was like wtf sounds like a vq
@@sensimit6559it’s the opposite, gt7 has much better sounds
@@TurboAlice67.98 percent of 600 cars in FM8 sounded like Ferrari vacuum cleaner 2014.😅
GT7 is the first game to get the LFA sounds spot on
gt7 sounds more realistic in terms of mixing, believe it or not. They add a lot of low frequencies so that the car can feel heavy like irl. Which means you gotta turn up your volume to really make it feel more realistic. Forza instead has a neutral mixing most times so everything feels like its syntetized and fake, literally when cruising around in forza it feels like ur driving a mosquito, while in gt7 it feels like an actual car. But yes ofc some car sounds might sound a bit dead compared to irl, even tho its way better than the annoying light sound of Forza. Forza focuses on first impact, making the game boring; while gt focuses on long term experience, making it more enjoyable to drive a car.
I appreciate you being able to put that into words alot of people who simp over Forza say "Forza sounds better" when they mean louder I try to tell them what you said but couldn't put it into words.
GT7 uses real engine car sounds, like they have a studio to record cars
And this video never showed the interior sounds or from a audience point of view and Gran Turismo made that damn near perfect especially with good headphones. And something A LOT of people that obviously never has been close to these cars don't know in real life is the shifting from the gearbox and that's a huge factor for me and Forza absolutely failed at that where every single car shifts the exact same slow almost manual like speed. This is a part of where GT is leaps and bounds ahead of Forza. Like you can hear in this video a LFA has that kinda slowlike shift but then a more advanced modern DCT like in the GTR R35 has that awesome banging in gears and also they nailed the Porsche PDK perfectly.
@@ProGen6 Ugh, that's one of my biggest gripes. You'd imagine FM would have figured that out by now, but I HATE how basically every car shifts like a manual. Doesn't matter if it's equipped with a lightning fast auto IRL, it's gonna shift roughly and slowly.
Spoken like a Sony drone fanboy
It's cool to see how both games go about the sounds side by side, great vid!
Thanks man, happy to hear that!
@@CorreaCarseven engine notes in GT5 is way better than FM8.
I’ve been fortunate to be around and driven some of the newer super cars in this video and GT7 is close or pretty spot on. Forza is great, but they add a wierd amplification to the sound that I can’t quite identify that makes it sound “synthetic”. Almost like they are giving it there own spin to the sound. For those who have been and driven some of these cars you’ll agree👍🏼🤷🏻♂️
I’ve driven some of them. The lambo and the 458 in forza are absolutely wrong, in particular the Ferrari has the wrong pitch, and the gearbox is nothing like that, it looks like an old f1 gearbox from the old 360 (I drove that too in real life). In gt7 the gearbox is quite wrong too for the 458, but the sound is nicer thus not perfect. In both games it looks they forgot that the 458 is a dual clutch transmission with practically seamless gear changes.
I have a Jaguar XK-R, and the closest game I've heard to getting the sound of the AJ V8 right is FM4. The worst is FM7. I barely even drive my car in 7 because the sound is so off and weird; it sounds like a blender (I do like the XK-R racecar though, that one sounds much better). FM4 does V8's in particular better than pretty much any other game in either series in my opinion. Even 13 years after its release, I still melt when I play FM4 and hear the V8-powered cars rumbling and screaming around the track. The sound work in FM4 always keeps me coming back for more.
See me comment bro 👍😎
@@marcods5232the 458 Italia 2009 in GT5 sounds like true 458 whilst in FM8 it sounded like Formula 3 2019 car.😂
@@Kryptic1046the XJ220 Race Car 2001 in GT5 > XK-R in FM8.
I would also like to point out gt7 has race exhaust that changes the sound completely it makes it deeper, louder and adds pops crackles and shoots flames often times. Best one is the c6 zr1 sounds insane with race exhaust
U heard the Cobra Daytona in stock trim - headfones on and up LOUD - that’s insane engine noise 👍😎
@@stevolarry420stevenslozz3Shelby Cobra in GT5 to 7 are equally impressive.
@@stevolarry420stevenslozz3 no because no one can afford the daytona cobra in GT7 LOL
@@HugoStiglitz88 check the license test in the special ones, it’s at Watkins Glen 👍😎
Forza does the same...........
Forza - still using synthesized exhaust sounds where you can hear an echo towards the top end of the RPM. They also tend to crank the exhaust volume up higher to make it more pronounced, but less realistic. Third, how did they get the LFA engine note completely wrong? It doesn’t sound like an LFA, which you’d think would be an easy sound to acquire.
Gran Turismo - the use of synthesized sounds are present, but much less pronounced. They add in other sounds to help combat this issue, like when shifting. Notice how the Hellcat has a pronounced supercharger whine (same as the Ford GT, but much less pronounced like the real thing) but Forza does not. Why? Why doesn’t Forza add the coolest part of the Hellcat to the game?
Forza used to have amazing exhaust sounds. Horizon 1 and 2 showed this and so did FM4 and FM5. What happened?
I bet all my money Turn10 got hacked and someone deleted the entire game, while i have enjoyed the game, it feels like a game they made in 1 year not 6 years. "built from the ground up" my ass. Shame all AAA racing games are going to hell nowadays.
I also don’t understand how they can get good sounds in some games and then become completely trash in the next 😂 like why cant they just reuse sounds that were good before
@@SAMOSTWANTED I guess it makes more sense to reuse models from over a decade ago instead of sounds, right? 🤣
The weird thing is that FH5 has some really decent sounds, dare I say, some of the best, specially considering its vehicle count
@@taquito1561 difference is. Playground games actually cares about the players and genuinely tries to make games. With this Turn10 has showed they don't care about the player.
I know its a small detail but it really bugs me that dual clutch and other faster automatics shift like manuals with the time it takes in forza. I could complain about a few things when it comes to GT7, but i'm amazed how it feels like each car was cared for when being created.
The same also as in Forza Motorsport 2.
I feel like GT7 is the only game to get the sound of the 2017 Ford GT right every other game it just doesnt sound right i heard one in person and it runined every car game i played featuring after, until i played GT7
Totally agree, gt7 did great on the GT, in fact, on all cars...
También Lexus LFA, amigo.
@@yg.mathieuthe X2019 and MP4/4 in GT7 also sounded very close to their real life counterparts as well.
@@purwantiallan5089 uhhh lol the x2019 isn't a real life car though LOL
All cars in forza sound like they're in a tunnel. And already have 'modified' sounds. To make the comparison closer, put racing exhausts on all the cars.
For one, the STI. The forza exhaust sound you can hear an external wastegate at certain rpm. Show me a stock sti that sounds like that. Most of the forza cars do not sound like that in real life in stock form, so people who dont know automatically think it sounds better.
I clicked on the video to hear the LFA, and I wasn't disappointed because of GT7🔥🔥
Setsuna Yuki also love the car sounds in GT7 like the 2020 GR SUPRA RZ, LFA, Zonda R, and her fan favourite, Senna's MP4/4.
What is that Mazda 787B sound on Forza? Seems like a hybrid car sound
Gt7 is on another level.. use headphones then you can hear how clean and realistig car sounds in gt7 are
You're joking fm8 sounds way more realistic and dynamic
@@alexb2004_ Not in a month of Sundays mate
Bro never approached a car@@alexb2004_
@@alexb2004_how old are you?
@@alexb2004_Bro thinks louder=better💀
I think that Dodge Demon is the most telling. You can barely make out the supercharger whine on Forza, but it is distinct and audible in GT7. It's not even close
If the camera were in the cabin or hood views, I'd agree, but from behind the car, you'd barely hear the supercharger at all--just glorious thick American V8 noises. Unfortunately, neither of these games capture it well. Also, can't speak for GT, but FM unfortunately fails to capture how powerful and deep they sound at idle (true for a lot of loud-from-factory cars).
That’s down to the use of multiple microphones and 270 days to record and 3D sound. PD don’t fuck about yo 👍😎
Oh the harmonic scream of the LFA in GT7, beautiful👌
FM has slightly less better engine sounds than FH5, the LFA in FH5 was unholy, it has more scream than FM.
the srt demon sounded great on gt7 and you can hear the supercharger whine real good even turbo cars you can hear the spool real good
What I don't understand is that Turn 10 doesn't acknowledge the existence of an automatic or DCT.
Polyphony for a long time had a problem acknowledging the existence of a single clutch or manual and had some of the worst sounds imaginable. Nowadays, things have gotten so much better. The exhaust is spot on and shifting is just short of perfect. The manual physics without a wheel and shifter could use some work.
I think the problem with forza motorsport's sounds is that there is so much echo which feels unrealistic, also gran turismo feels a bit muffled but i think gran turismo is more realistic overall
That's how it is irl there's echoes that go around the track it's not just a clean engine sound
@@nicog4638 i thought trees would decrease the echo and this sounds like they recorded it in an empty room but as i havent heard of the pure sound of those cars, i can't be sure
Both are a bit of a mixed bag, some cars have improved and some haven’t. GT7 has come a long way, Forza was always the leader previously. Its car to car, clearly some cars are still synthesized. One thing that hasn’t been properly represented is the true difference in sheer volume, everything it leveled out.
A GT3 cup car in real life is deafening and has a distinct vibratory harmonic that you feel in your head. A 7B7 can be heard on the other side of the track and completely wipes out the sound of everything around it.
Gt7 takes the cake here for almost every sound. They are just much more realistic
Gt7 sounds are better
Specially that LFA part sounds like RL 🔥
Are you high?
Ford gt in gt7 sounds so bad
@@sgulley6655Clearly you are
@@K.O.B.R.A makes sense
The one gripe I have about Gran Turismo is that the shifting is super quick. In GT4 shifting was slower and more realistic, it was either 5 or 6 that made shifting almost instant since then. Gear changes simply don't sound very satisfying whatsoever.
It also kinda bothers me too how slow the actual gear shift animation is in Sport and 7. The driver looks like he's taking his sweet time to shift and it doesn't match everything else that's going on. Reminds me of that one bus driver video where he's being all dainty with his shifts.
At the same rate, this video showcased a few modern vehicles with dct or pdk type automatics that shift entirely too slow in forza.
But, u can get the real shift with a manual shifter, sounds crazy at that point
@@ahamdache2010 Yeah but auto or manual sequential should sound good too.
Gran Tourismo did it a lot better. There sounds are way more realistic, and they actually recorded the cars actual sound of the cars.
GT7's sounds are clearly the best because they are very accurate and you can hear the tone of each engine and distinguish it, while Forza only has superiority in the loudness of the sound, but this is of no use when the engine loses its tone, which the player enjoys. Only a few cars in the clip were better with Forza, such as the Dodge Viper.
They somehow sound like they were made on a computer like ps2 days
I love this so much
Switched this year from xbox to ps5, i have played forza since 3, switched after hearing jist how realistic the gt7 sojnds are and how amazing the racing is.
Welcome to the club
Gt7 = Realistic
FM = excitement
2 different approaches.
Sums up the style of both teams, Turn10 wants to appeal to the gamer, while Poly wants to appeal to the Car people.
and even then GT7 still sounds robotic
@@Mr.Goldbarthis ngga 💀
@@Mr.Goldbar ofc you would say that
@@Mr.Goldbarlmao you’re so biased, an example is the lfa in forza that doesn’t sound anything remotely close to real life🤦♂️
I've noticed FM has a distinct "fizz" and "static" noise to their exhaust notes.
Since the first version of the PSX, in basically everything, graphics, animations and sound, Gran Turismo has always had a sense of refinement that Forza never managed to achieve. I don't even play racing simulators anymore, but this smoothness and beauty of GT always impresses me.
Gt7 does a soooo good impression in tuning, I love the oldschool big Turbo Tuning on some modern cars especially MK5 and honestly, this is just stock sound I mean as well for forts but I think you ain’t get the pinchi high not like in gt7.
Every GT7 player should experience a:
1. full racing exhaust nsx ( I choose 2002 because you get it easy with a bit of money)
2. Full Racing exhaust 964 911
3. an 8k rpm R35
4. and classic big Turbo Tuning with a supra (MK5/4 I liked them both)
And an stock F12 Ferrari because even stock is that car an absolute sound beast.
Just a quick reminder, it’s a personal opinion and I’m not here to argue with anyone, I just like to share the passion with everybody else that’s in to the same thing. And even for me a s a GT boy, I’m still jealous about FH even tho ppl say FH5 is a flop, I just miss a openworld racer for PS
LFA with full exhaust and high life cam sounds good to screamsss
Do the same, but, for interior view as well. IMO GT7 just has better across the board sounds as a general majority, however...FM8 just has better "shifting" feel so it can be a tough one!
I think you should also compare how they sound from the interior and also how they sound under braking and turning because that rsr's transmission would have sounded much better under turning
4:04 that almost sounds like a v6 what
They’ve had the almost perfect sound for years (albeit overused) and they used that
Still alive man
@@DarkKnight2845 ello
Yes, GT7 gets four cars best, LFA, 787B, Aventador, R35.
The other 21 cars sound dramatically better in Forza.
nah
@@budthecyborg4575no way lmao
FM rew sounds are much clearer, maybe not realistic but for game purposes its easier to shift without looking at counter
Did anyone notice the difference in how most cars are shifting at different RPMs from 1 game to the next? I wonder which is right.
Well you can see GT7 he's using manual so it might be he's just shifting at different spots
RX-7's rear light glow in Forza reminds me of those from the Big Rig Over the Road racing
I have always been a fan of forza but I think GT7 wins this one. I don't really like the shifting in GT7 and the sounds are a bit muffled but it's still better than FM.
Gran Turismo actually record their engine sounds from the real cars
czcams.com/video/Yqsrizplujs/video.html
lol
Forza live audio recording session: czcams.com/video/Yqsrizplujs/video.html
You're so dumb 😂😂😂
Forza do that since Forza 1. Sorry, GT is still a piece of crap sound. Better than ALL the previous versions, but still a pos
I noticed shifting in forza is a lot slower and clunkier vs gt. It makes it seem as if all of the cars are manual lmao
About 55% done with GT7 using a G923 and I’ve had the best experience ever. Really considering GT6 next lol, I have Assetto Corsa and CarX Drift on ps4 but they just don’t really catch my attention as much as GT does! Really Fantastic Game
Can you do a comparison on which game have the best physics for ramming
Nice video but please sync volume next time.
You should compare GT7 and The Crew Motorfest sounds next
The Lamborghinis in gt7 , in first person, are a symphony for me ☝🏻
I feel like all Gran Turismo engine sounds have that similar grain tone, it's hard to describe. And they also sound like they were recorded only in the inside of the car.
Although gt is more realistic, at high reving cars, gt sounds way better and more refined
FM8 - Louder engine / exhaust volume, sounds okay, exciting
GT7 - Sounds much quieter compared to FM8, realistic approach, detailed
I don't get it how FM8 can get LFA engine sound wrong? just watch some videos on LFA engine sound, come back to this video and compare FM8 and GT7 again, you'll see how different FM8 sounds compared to real life and its rival GT7. GT7 also does have room for improvement but damn it does sound very close to real life. If they can get LFA engine sounds wrong, what about the other cars.
I love the fact in GT7, other than the engine sound, things like turbos, super chargers, v-tec and all the other major components that makes noise is enhanced, you can hear more of it like the v-tec 3:54 and the high pitch turbo spooling up from the Chiron 0:33
The gritty sound of Forza makes almost all of the cars sound way better.
Gran Turismo 7 gets the LFA and 787B dramatically better, and the Aventador and R35 are more exciting in GT7.
Everything else I give it to Forza hands down.
Both sounds definitely have their ups and downs, however what I wanna know is why motorsport doesn’t use the frankly decent sounds from horizon 5 instead of whatever these are
apparently they're incompatibile with each other
Because it's "Built from the ground-up" (lmao)
@@LoogiBalloogi that’s actually why the game’s lacking in so many aspects, they genuinely did need to rebuild the game
Granted they had 6 years to do this
Yeah, FH5 has some really cool sounds, the GMA T50 for example, sounds exactly like the actual car than FM does
Different companies
So basically GT7 wins in every instance here
You should try comparing FH5 to GT7, some of the car sounds are different to FM
4:53 you could literally feel the car gaining power from turbo lag by just hearing it
So good to finally see GT producing good engine sounds after so many years. GT7 is miles ahead of FM
Gran turismo All day babyyy
I think GT7 sounds more realistic but over reverbered, sounds like was recorded in a empty hangar
GT7 sounds like the factory speakers brand new, Forza sounds like them when they blow out while driving with the windows down.
Never had the opportunity to play GT7. But my question is this. How can you get a sound comparison when the cars have differences? i.e. the 2020 Supra has 335hp and weights 3397 lbs on FM but on GT7 has 382hp and weights 3373 lbs. Valkyrie on FM has 1140hp and weights 2271 lbs while on GT7 has 1139hp and weights 2800 lbs.
O som da faixa de rotação do motor do gran turismo é mais fiel
Only games I know that had almost accurate car sounds - "nfs Most Wanted 05, MW 2012, nfs Pro street, Driveclub" these latest car games can't beat the old ones
I find it kind of funny that the LaFerrari and most Ferrari engines sounds most accurate in NFS Games like Rivals
Louder noise doesn’t mean better representation,, gt goes so much further to give you a true experience. I’ve exclusively used my xbox one for the last 2 yrs and i now have a ps5 sitting in the box rite in front of me with robocop rogue city and gt7 so my xbox one is retiring tonight, all ps gt editions have nailed the sound but I expect on the ps5 it’ll be even better.🤙
Love reading comments on videos like this, it’s a game guys 😂 you all take it far too serious. If you have a PlayStation you get GT, if you have an Xbox you get FM, it’s that simple.
I don't like the sound of Ferrari Enzo Ferrari in FM (2023)
Still prefer more FM4 but nice video
Appreciate it bro👍
Both in title is good. But about car sound NFS still No.1 in class
When ur playing gt7 , w a headset and a tv w good graphics, it sucks you in . I still play gt7 to just hear the soundtrack of the car the revs, the turbo the supercharger noise i could go on , good amazing game 🎮 ps exclusive
as always I been said gran turismo has the most realistic engine sounds no doubt
Goat Tourismo 7
fr
Both have reverb like they're driving in a cathedral lol
Gran turismo is definitely more intake based but listening in, you can really hear what is going on in your car. Forza puts something loud in your ear and calls it a day
I'm camp Xbox since 2013 and I have to admit from FM 5 onwards I never really warmed up to the engine sounds ... GT7 does quite a lot of things right when it comes to that. However I have to admit that I absolutely do not like how every car in GT7 sounds like it's running on a DCT or something. GT7 lacks that brief period of decreasing revolutions especially in manual gearbox cars. It's REV REV REV SHIFT REV REV REV whereas in FM the engine sounds more realistic it's REV REV REV CLUTCH SHIFT SMOOTH REV DECREASE REVS CLIMBING AGAIN
I hope everyone gets my point even though I explained it pretty poorly.
Polyphony since GT5 has had that problem with manual cars. Seriously, you should've been there back in GT5 and GT6 days. Classic Ferraris and Lamborghinis always had dual clutch physics and in reality take a long time to shift. What they have now is a drastic upgrade in realism. If you use a wheel with a clutch and gearshift, it's spot on.
Forza does the opposite. Dual clutches and automatics feel like single clutches or manuals. Everyone has been getting it down for years while Forza refuses to acknowledge the existence of autos and DCTs
istg the engine notes form FH5 is way better then FM. Funny considering that FM is supposed to be the more realistic one
Lexus LFA! Oohhh! Lovely better in GT.
Which has better model for the cars?
The Bugatti Chiron's engine in GT kind of sounds like the BMW M3 GT2 ALMS from Real Racing 3.. weird.
There was a time when GT cars sounded like vacuum cleaners, now they sound better than forza’s lackluster vehicles
In FM cars sound like you put you head in to exhaust
Je préfère entendre le son du moteur étouffé dans GT7 qui est réel , que entendre les sons du moteur qui gueule dans FM8 qui est pas réel .
Both are good
4:32 🤤🎧
Im here for the v8 noises.... and both these games fail to capture it. Grid 2 has amazing car noises btw, not sure why we are going backwards
Gran Turismo 7 records and uses actual sounds, but there's actually something even more amazing than that.
That is, "A completely natural engine sound can be heard even in the rotation range above the original rotation speed."
According to the development team, it seems that the engine sound above the original speed is reproduced using AI, allowing us to hear the best sound at impossible speeds.
Didnt know 458 comes with manual transmission lmao, iykyk 2:07
gran turismo such a masterpiece, timeless game
The fact that we waited 7 years for a new forza Motorsport and it was such a let down is so sad
If GT7 exterior is better, now imagine interior.
4:32 Of course the LFA is the one car where GT has dramatically better engine sound.
GT also wins on the MAZDA 787B and R53, and a slight edge on the Aventador SV.
Specifically note the Aventador SV on Forza sounds too gritty, where it's clean and higher pitch on GT.
Having not heard these cars in person I can't say if either is objectively better but I much prefer the art direction of Forza in the engine audio department. It almost sounds like Forza is giving us the engine sounds with the hood up and mic inside the engine bay, where GT sounds more like recordings of the car from 20 feet away.
Across the entire roster I give it 21:4 in favor of the unfiltered feeling exhaust notes in Forza.
remember that most road car in gt7 is a stock car that obviously not loud as tuned car thats why the "stock" sound more low than forza
Outside sounds like inside sounds
The shifting sounds in FM are horrible.
Easily the worst shifting in any racing game ive ever played. All cars shift the same like what the hell? A DCT shifts the same speed as a 80s 4-speed converter Auto 😂
Yea gt7 sounds better because all the cars shift like they have straight cut gears lol..forza goes for a realistic shift sound hence why when you shift in a manual car it takes time because like in real life you have to press the clutch and change the gear but in gt7 the gear shifts are like the guy has super speed and all cars just go to the next gear like they aren't manual
@@nicog4638 No, according to Forza logic a manual Honda Civic shifts through gears just as fast as a Ferrari LaFerrari with a DCT.
@mathorsky where's your proof of that I play the game a Ferrari with pedal shifters shifts way faster than a honda with a Manual shifter don't talk about shit you don't know because it makes you look dumb
The shifting in fm is bad its way to slow and its almost the same for every car, gt7 has much better shifting and sound
GT7 every car has realistic sound and has its own flavor like real life cars
Damn, I love seeing GT and Forza fanboys arguing in the comment section as if their lives depend on it
This "war" between GT and FM is pretty childish and silly
Do a comparison video with Assetto Corsa Competizione :)
With road cars?? As far as I know there’s no road cars in ACC. Also gt7 doesn’t have the same gt3 cars as acc. It has gte and super gt cars not gt3 ones
CorreaCars: the Sam Sulek of FH.
Forza is much more syntetized, louder, but GT 7 has more precise sounds. Clear and pure engine sound second thing is when you put racing exhaust system on your cars sound is incredible. And this is not working in forza
O mazda 787B e o Lexus LFA no Gt7 tem o som mais próximo do real