Which Custom Shop is a Better investment? Murphy or Masterbuilt
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 12. 2021
- As many guitars are going up in value, Baxter and Jonathan discuss what custom shop guitar has the highest possibility of gaining a return on your investment. Murphy Lab from the Gibson Custom Shop or a Fender Custom Shop Masterbuilt Guitar?
Just bought #20 of the Rick Nielsen historic LP. Loving it.
If the goal is return on investment, then I would choose a Murphy Lab extra light relic '59 Les Paul. Not because Fender's Custom Shop guitars are lesser instruments, but because those that are willing to pay through the nose are more likely to buy a Les Paul.
If it were a guitar to actually play, then it would be an Anderson, Suhr or PRS Private Stock.
Nooooooooooo!!!!! PRS is for dentists :)
Gotta love when a video comes out before Christmas 😃
Would love to be able to afford either one
Agree
I'm a guitar player...not an investor. So I am never considering any of these things when buying a guitar. Although, it is nice to know that good instruments will hold their value over time :)
I will say this. When I buy my first Masterbuilt Jazzmaster, I am building it for me. I don’t have that urge to sell ever. I’m a hoarder of guitar and equipment. Oh lord. I have a problem lol
@rb240tuner me too. I wonder if there is a 12 step program I can attend…then again, maybe not….:0
My experience for what it’s worth. Did the Masterbuilt thing. Waited 18 months and got a guitar that was beautiful - but never bonded with it and sold it about a year later. Go with a MB or a Murphy Lab - just make sure you can play it before you buy it.
Awesome guys Merry Christmas!
Happy Holidays to everyone at Casino Guitars and all the viewers... one of my fave channels/communities in 2021. LOL at "perception" opening of this vid. To quote Greg Koch, Jonathan is a mansquatch !
I had a John Cruz MVP strat with Abby pickups…. And sold it for 2700…. Kicking myself in the ass profit wise…But I never connected with it and am really glad it went to someone that is playing it on stage now. It deserves to be seen and heard. With that money I went and bought a shell pink American original 60’s strat and a couple of awesome pedals. I get more juice from the squeeze with that set-up.
I’d pick a Murphy Lab instrument over a Fender Masterbuilt. Just my preference of Gibson over Fender.
Me, too. Because Fenders will always be more "assembled" than built. I don't see anyone setting LP style necks bought from Warmoth in there garages.
I have Josafina pickups in my Wildwood 10 61 Strat and they sound amazing!
Gibson Custom Shop. Signature models are also great. Right now I'd love a Slim Harpo ES-330. My crown jewel currently is a #30 Gibson Southern Rock Tribute (SRT) from the Custom Shop. Basically an R9..love it!!
The first 5 seconds of this video reaffirmed my decision to work with you guys. Funny dudes.
Been playing and buying guitars for almost 50 years. Never, ever bought one as an investment and I've had some nice ones throughout the years. That being said, I've owned a Mark Kendrick built Strat for 20 years. Best Strat I've ever owned or played. Basic mid 50's style two sunburst Strat. I'll be playing that one until I die.
I just bought a Gibson Les Paul special flame custom shop, killer guitar!
When you buy anything, including guitars, based upon its potential investment value you are, in essence, allowing others to control your purchases. Beats me why anyone would do that but it takes all kinds to make a world, I guess.
Personally I would go PRS wood library or private stock. Not sure about the resale but probably the most beautiful guitar you’d ever own.
I would love to own a Light Murphy ES
Gibson custom just my opinion....Great show as always Merry Christmas!!
I’d probably grab a Murphy Lab R9, light aged as an investment. They’re new-ish, and represent the beginning of Gibson’s non-razor blade era. I can see those increasing in value.
Bought a Gilmour fender CS NOS in 2016 for $3K on reverb they’ve been selling for upwards of $10K
I'm going with series EE savings bonds. It's a sure thing, baby.
Silver Sky! Jonathan I thought was Bigfoot for a second he was so close. Just kidding and I appreciate both of you guys. Just off today and enjoying casino guitar and coffee again this morning. Keep videos coming. When will Cruz start having things available? I probably can’t afford one but I’d like to see his stuff.
Fender all the way. Merry Christmas guys!
If you can afford it, go to your most high end guitar store and play through all the best guitars and choose the best one. I’ve been able to sell things overpriced just because it sounds phenomenal when people try it out. Don’t get a Gibson or a fender cs that’s generic. Get one that screams and sings.
My Fender 63 Custom Shop that was built in 2014, was purchased for a little less than 3K in 2017. If I wanted to sell it now, I could make some money. I could probably sell it for 4K or so. They are going for $5600 now new. Good musical gear usually holds its value or grows in value. Same with quality firearms.
Gibson. My first guitar as a new student was a Gibson Les Paul studio. Yes I’m that guy. I just knew that they were highly collectible. If I don’t like it I knew I could sell it and get my money out of it. When it comes to investing there is this golden aura around Gibson.
Two videos In one day it's like we just got married!
I own an FCS stratocaster from you all and I still would say if investment was what I was looking at or even just holds value, I would go with the Murphy Lab Gibson. Maybe next you can do an accompanying video of custom shop guitars that tank in value, my G&L Legacy is a great example of that.
I think I’d find something else to invest in . JMO ! Merry Christmas 🎄
Merry Christmas 🎄🎄🎄 everyone
I'm fortunate enough to own one of each. I've got a limited edition 1 of 10 Gibson Historic Custom Shop 58 plain top LP Burst with a base ball bat neck hand relic-ed by Tom Murphy ' which is by far my best sounding guitar (I believe it's 2002). I've had it about 10 years and bought it from a good friend of mine. I play it regularly at home and once in a great while I take it on a gig simply because it sounds so cool. And in 2011 I got a Master Built Strat built by Dennis Galuszka and it is the coolest one of a kind axe I've owned. But I play it maybe once a year because it has increased in value so much I don't want to screw it up. It's the only guitar I own that doesn't have a single nick or scratch on it. I've got a bunch of swell guitars but those 2 are far superior as far as feel, weight, tone and playability than any of my other guitars. As far as an investment, I never thought of them as that when I bought them but I'm certainly glad I got them when I did as I definitely couldn't afford them now.
Merry Christmas Guys! Hope everyone their has their Nut n’Bag ready for the holiday!
I know we were supposed to do this from an investment standpoint but for me it would be Fender custom shop. I will probably never be able to purchase a masterbuilt but if somehow that happened I really would call you guys and trust your judgment as to the Best builder available at Fender. I have the specs in my mind just in case.
I’ve always wanted a Gibson version of an Epiphone Scroll. Not sure if that is even something you could get done at the custom shop.
With all of this excitement about Relic (aged) guitars,. we had no idea that the tools we had would gain such value! If I still had my 1961 Les Paul Jr., any of my Rickenbackers, like my 1964 330 from Rose Morris, my older Teles, like my 1967 Custom. I would never have to worry about money again! But in those days, it just wasn't a thing!
I think these relic'd guitars will lose value over time.
I’ve owned several second hand custom shop guitars. IMO, it’s the way to go. If you search you can find people trying to make a quick sell and get one for an excellent price. (I paid 3k for my mint r8 on Craigslist). These are EXCELLENT investments. I could fetch over 4k for it now easy and the value just keep going up. Just do you research and be informed on what your buying :)
Fender CS. No sour grapes about Murphy Lab pricing, but as a practical matter they seem have looked at Fender CS prices and said, "Hold my beer..."
I did my own custom strat via warmoth so I'd go gibson because I can't easily make a Les Paul. A place like Warmoth allows you to have just about any neck shape you want or a vintage strat body with the shallow pickup routes. Plus you get to paint, solder and assemble it yourself if you do choose. There are lp style kits but you won't get gibson quality where as warmoth you do get fender quality or maybe even better. Arm wrestle
100% cant ever see paying that much money for a bolt on neck guitar. You get into that 2k+ range and it better be a set neck or neckthru..
@@seanbrooks2583 when it was all said and done I had $1400 in my strat. Olympic white with mint green pickguard and gold hardware.
Yup my strat and tele are both Warmoth builds...and they definietly hit the spot. I sold all my Fender CS guitars and replaced them with 2 Warmoths. I only discovered them 2 years ago and I love them! CS quality....and you can get the specs you want. My strat had an Ebony neck AND a Ebony FB, Alder body...sounds and feels sooo good. My tele roasted swamp ash and roasted maple neck..perfect for me. Other players who come in the studio love them too!
2 videos in one day?
christmas came early
I would love to own/play a CS Strat. For a Les Paul, I'd buy a PRS.
😎 Thanks Casino ⚓️
I know this needs to be on the other video for entry for the guitar, but it fits this video too. Baxter could win the arm wrestling if Jonathan was as small as Baxter was at the start today. Jonathan looked like Gandalf. 😂
Imho vintage only for investment
Not that I could ever afford a custom shop for investment I would have to go with the Gibson the seem to gain value and hold it better from what I have seen.
I'm always a fender 1st guy except when I'm not. JS lol
If finish is still delaminating from the Murphy Lab guitars, I’d say Masterbuilt is a better bet. Has Gibson fixed the finish reactivity issue with the analine dye yet? Or is it still being swept under the rug and blamed on the customer?
I need to make a choice? Dang. Umm ok… let me think… 🤔 Murphy Lab or Master Built? Such a difficult choice. Well actually no it’s not… Fender Master Built is the clear winner. For many reasons!
Don’t get me wrong, Murphy Lab guitars are really nice guitars, but I can’t wait to get going on my Fender Master Built.
I love your show/content etc...But I'm far too along in the guitar world not to negate the Fender Japan Custom Shop offerings or The J-Craft editions not to mention The Ishibashi Music limited editions all of which will run circles on many Masterbuilds and Team builds I will testify under oath and guarantee that these esoteric guitars are far and away in 90% of the cases better guitars. Do your research and have your minds blown HAPPY HOLIDAYS GENTS FROM Newport Beach, CA.
If I had that kinda money, I’d invest in that Cherry Red ES-355 on the wall. Got one in ‘76 and sold it in the early 90’s. Bad decision.
Why not do a full shop tour showing all the brands that you sell? Happy Christmas to you all.
so my very first impression is that I would want a Fender just because I can get in at a lower price and it has more room to grow
Can someone please leave a link where I can check out the casino guitars podcast 🙏
For an investment, 8k would buy a great Fender offset, or an Epiphone Casino. Why spend money on a beat up new guitar when the same money buys you what they are trying to achieve?
For the Murphy money I’m buying two regular used Gibson customs or a player grade vintage
Check-out the new Heritage Custom Core H150s. I'm interested in your review.
For investment purposes, I'd go for one of the Collector's Choice Murphy Aged examples, not Murphy Labs which I feel has lost some of that master craftmanship value. Either that or a really limited Masterbuilt Fender like Yuriy Shishkov's Violinmaster. At that level though, I might as well go for a true vintage 60s strat! The only trouble is...geewhiz...I'm dreamin' my life away!! 😴
Probably the Murphy but I like custom shops more
Both
I think next year with everything going up in price, the secondhand market is going to increase as well. Now might be the time to sell.
Hope so. But where do we sell it because reverb and eBay are going to require a 1099 starting next year 2023 and you will be paying at least 28% tax they have a video here if you haven’t seen it. So it’s been taxed if it’s used when you sell it how many times 500?
I would more likely go for a specific limited color on a contentious s style guitar, if only one was being given away hhmmm
Wow-a guitar as an investment! I find it hard to wrap my head around that. Here's my question: If you buy an master built guitar by either Fender or Gibson, and you actually play it, or even perform with it, does it still maintain (or improve) it's value? See you all next week! Merry Christmas!
That is one of the advantages of the relic and aged finishes. They come with play wear from new...so if you gig it and take reasonable care of it you won't lose value.
@@ehiracheta Thanks that makes sense. I might be able to (someday) afford a masterbuilt guitar, but I'd have a hard time justifying it if it just sat in a display case.
Gibson 54 goldtop would be my choice
From an investment only. I choose Gibson. Gibson devotees are fierce in their zeal to grab whatever model is their dream. This cuts across all models the Fender people tend to be narrower in their echelon of valued guitars.
Fender CS Tele please!
I'm just a dumb guitar player not a collector. Gibson is the only 1 of the 2 that talks about wood. From what I've heard the custom shop sources their own, plus they inspect everything that comes into the plant, and use all the very best wood for CS guitars. I've never heard Fender even mention wood, except maybe 1/4 sawn for necks. I believe wood matters, a lot. Even the CS line built are a better value for that reason. Years ago I missed buying one made by an independent builder, and from wood left at Parsons Street thought to be from the same lot as the 1959 Bursts were made from. They wanted $20k for it, and had a lot of documentation. The guitar was a very high quality build, and it looked and sounded right. $20k was a lot though, and I balked. I still think about it. --gary
Wow a late night video!
A guitar would be a terrible investment for me... I would play it all the time and never sell it!
A Christmas Eve video where your choice of perspective makes Jonathan look like a Rock n Roll Santa and Baxter his gear making elf! Really wish the Josefinas weren't Masterbuilt only option. I'd love to get a single coil P with one of her winds. Whether it's for a working instrument or as only an investment I'd honestly recommend buying any Fender Custom Shop used. You let the original owner take the immediate hit and it'll start climbing in value right away. Can't go wrong with a FCS.
Fender custom shop Stratocaster!
Investment or not, that git-box is gonna get played….
I couldn't approach it from the investment position. There are better things to invest in. However, if I could afford the custom world, I would go Luxxtone. A lightly relic'd Choppa S, no Floyd, 12" radius, jumbo stainless frets and an HSS loadout. *Drool
Fender Custom Shop Relic Masterbuilt Stratocaster Magenta Sparkle by VVT🥰🥰🥰
You lost me at investment 🙂,but I want to just like you guys when I grow up🤓…merry Christmas 🎅 eve !everyone!!
B
That is hilarious. Letting Jonathan be the bigger man!
Guys who can take you seriously? 😄 Have a Merry Christmas to the whole crew!
Gibson and Fender will always have their die hard fans, so similar demand. I feel the future price will be affected by rarity, determined by quantities produced and the actual builder who makes them. Fender might have some real hits with some individual masters builders in their team gaining fame after they retire kind of like famous painters. Gibson don't have that, it seems more like a collaborative effort under the supervision of Murphy.
Having a custom built guitar comes with maintenance costs that aren't factored in. You're gonna want a top of the line luthier to maintain your instrument. So if you're spending 8-10k on one of these instruments, you need to factor in the Ongoing maintenance and set-up that such an instrument regularly requires.
Better investment? Bitcoin for sure.
My first gibson , a used les paul traditional, was bought with a price equivalent to 4,5 btc.
Today I can buy 15 brand new PRS private stock with 4,5 btc.
Fender !
Was that a stitch imitation from lilo and stich baxter?
I be should have bought that cunetto nocaster….
I had this dilemma few months back. I learned that high end gibsons are better investments but, there are going to be a lot of faults which you will only notice when it's too late. Fenders are better built, they're safer buying second hand.
Was that elf Baxter or giant Jonathan?
LOL the intro . . . I'm more of a player, even if its several K . . . I dunno, for investments, there are better returns than on guitars, although Jonathan is right on the GIbson having more spending power . . . no relic. let time and hands do their thing . . .
If I was an apprentice, I’d buy everything I ever built as an investment just in case I’d ever make something of myself after the apprenticeship is all done. Then I’d be rich . . . hopefully, lol.
Check your recording levels guys. This one wasn't as hot as they usually are.
I would go Gibson custom shop but I would never pay that kinda money for a guitar. I've played a few $5-$6000 les pauls and wasn't blown away enough to spend that kind of coin. My 61 junior will be worth more than I paid for it. Hell it already is
Well... that 2015 strat comment may not be totally accurate. Inflation has made it so nothing is the same price as it was in 2015 🤣 I bought my strat in 79 and still use it. Loaded it with stainless steel frets and cs69 pickups. Still got all the original gear and case. I think I made a return on investment. But guitars are spiritual. Not just investments. Ask CBS.
Damn, you’re right with the inflation bit:)! Good call. And we of course agree, as we said in this video and tons other, we never really buy for investments, just for the love…thank goodness my wife is very patient with me:)
One day, I shall have a Fender Masterbuilt Stratocaster.
Guess I will continue to love my Mexican Tele!
When it comes to big money things, the in-family joke has been "We'll just take it out of petty cash... "
Growing up working middle-class, there was never petty cash...
Much like Baxter, I'm not looking to invest. I want to play with my toys.
100% more fun to play than invest. Plus: as an investment, it's crazy to try and predict this domain. Buy stock in something safe like utility companies
The problem with Fender Custom Shop stuff is not the quality of the guitars but the fact that the Fender name is on everything from all over the globe. Gibson keeps the Gibson name on only American made models. So the Gibson logo is associated with a higher end built guitar, even if it really isn't.
My humble opinion is don’t buy guitars as an “investment,” the market is too volatile and the market is very small. Rare exceptions are original guitars and some particular models/years (mostly non-custom shops). Collectors are an interesting bunch and it’s a small market.
I buy/sell many guitars (mostly fender custom shops) and I’ve found a stable way to keep my hobby going (both as a player and collector). I have a specific list of guitars that I want to own or try out, I never (not ever) buy new, I negotiate the best deals for guitars kept in the best condition (and let go of deals that are too expensive), and have a one-in-one out policy. Sometimes (but rarely) I find an amazing deal and can sell the guitar for more money to buy one I really want to own. Mostly, I try to break even when I sell them or make a couple hundred bucks here and there but that’s only bc I buy used.
Gibson custom shops are way overpriced in my opinion and the quality is hit or miss. Fender is quite reliable and the used market is quite better than Gibson. Early Murphy lab guitars aged my Murphy himself might fetch a premium overtime but that market if potential buyers is small (all you need is one). My final thoughts: play because you love it and enjoy the hobby and it’s financially “sustainable.” Invest elsewhere
How about DIY.
That's, literally, what the custom shop builders are doing. Doing it themselves. It's not real, as far as the aging. And, a guitar is either assembled properly or not. You can do the same.
These new prices are too close the the price of a good vintage guitar...Vintage for me please!
Easy ML.
Private Stock
That PRS tho
Personally I would buy a Fender Masterbuild and live in the knowledge the Gibson will always gain more value :-/
Wait... all this talk of Custom Shop and Murphy Lab.. are you infering that the Epiphone I bought 2 years ago was maybe not the most promising of investments?
I like some Epis. The Sheraton and Casino.
Gibson has problems but I would love to have a 1979 les paul with a Floyd rose and a sustain in it.