a deep dive into one direction drama | aka my multiverse of madness

SdĂ­let
VloĆŸit
  • čas pƙidĂĄn 9. 03. 2023
  • Dipsea is offering an extended 30 day free trial when you go to DipseaStories.com/UNCARLEY
    đŸŒ· instagram đŸŒ·
    / carleythorne
    (@carleythorne)
    đŸ© tiktok đŸ©
    / carleythorne.jpg
    💕 storygraph (instead of goodreads) 💕
    app.thestorygraph.com/profile...
    want to work with me? email: uncarley@zigguratxyz.com
    intro music: Louie Zong - Cycad Conga
  • Komedie

Komentáƙe • 1,5K

  • @uncarley
    @uncarley  Pƙed rokem +1756

    xfactor BLOCKEd the video footage of one direction performing torn @ 4:27 but do yourself a favour and look it up after

    • @ellafriesz5717
      @ellafriesz5717 Pƙed rokem +90

      genuinely laughed so hard at the silence after “it’s bad”

    • @sadoffer4972
      @sadoffer4972 Pƙed rokem +38

      The audio is out of sync after that point jsyk! At least for me

    • @amanitamuscariatheshroom
      @amanitamuscariatheshroom Pƙed rokem +6

      @@sadoffer4972 just you

    • @samspud007
      @samspud007 Pƙed rokem

      @@sadoffer4972 same!! Hard to watch but I love the audio so I’m just looking away

    • @samspud007
      @samspud007 Pƙed rokem +9

      FYI I’ve restarted the app, closed and restarted video twice and it’s not fixed so no clue why it’s happening and not to amanita^? Weird who knows đŸ€·đŸŒâ€â™‚ïž

  • @emclaire7027
    @emclaire7027 Pƙed rokem +9287

    “Person with a string board explains something I have never previously heard or cared about” is my favorite genre of videos

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  Pƙed rokem +387

      hahaha YES

    • @Aelffwynn
      @Aelffwynn Pƙed rokem +223

      Same. It's how I discovered Vampire Diaries (Jenny Nicholson) and others. Idk why it's so fun but it is.

    • @heatherbocks
      @heatherbocks Pƙed rokem +60

      Hahaha right? I was 19 in 2011, I was too old for One Direction. Yet here I am.

    • @ashthebash7131
      @ashthebash7131 Pƙed rokem +69

      @@heatherbocks I was 5 in 2011, and had no idea what or who One Direction was. Yet here I am.

    • @patiencekillz
      @patiencekillz Pƙed rokem +169

      *mind immediately flashes to mike’s mic pretty little liars video

  • @EE-zw8iv
    @EE-zw8iv Pƙed rokem +6497

    we didn't even touch on Liam having a baby with the judge he met as a child ☠

    • @doiireann
      @doiireann Pƙed rokem +612

      omg i almost forgot about that😭 no honestly i feel like no one ever talked about how creepy that was :/

    • @Rebe8d89AH
      @Rebe8d89AH Pƙed rokem +356

      Yeah Cheryl is so creepy for that

    • @sarahdworak1260
      @sarahdworak1260 Pƙed rokem +100

      Im trying to ignore that Bc Cheryl is creepy in my opinion 😅

    • @Kas_Styles
      @Kas_Styles Pƙed rokem +18

      Oh ya, bear

    • @letstalkaboutit3195
      @letstalkaboutit3195 Pƙed rokem +26

      That was definitely something


  • @ossswin
    @ossswin Pƙed rokem +4162

    the fact that zayn's "remember when you had a life and stopped making bitchy comments about mine ?" tweet was not mentioned in the naughty boy feud era convo is wild. HISTORY WAS MADE

    • @bernadette6553
      @bernadette6553 Pƙed rokem +144

      History was made, and my Zouis heart broke 😔🙌

    • @jenmurphy7777
      @jenmurphy7777 Pƙed rokem +6

      @@bernadette6553 dis he say that to Louis? 😱

    • @EmmaRianne
      @EmmaRianne Pƙed rokem +56

      BC BITCHY WAS SUCH A CRAZY TERM TO PULL OUT

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  Pƙed rokem +319

      that message is burned into my retinas

    • @EnnAye
      @EnnAye Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +10

      @@uncarley Yet you failed to mention it in your video?

  • @cassyeager6164
    @cassyeager6164 Pƙed rokem +3727

    you can’t forget how delusional we all were on the 10 year anniversary and how we thought they were gonna magically come back

    • @thercheese
      @thercheese Pƙed rokem +147

      no bc i remember someone starting a rumour that they were gonna post the infinity music video on the anniversary 💀

    • @mansikkamaito
      @mansikkamaito Pƙed rokem +125

      tbh liam was totally feeding into that so i don't totally blame us

    • @ellaronci2703
      @ellaronci2703 Pƙed rokem +31

      and that was RECENT 😭😭

    • @Bexab53
      @Bexab53 Pƙed rokem +3

      Alright that’s a little hurtful.
      But it’s also true so. 😂

    • @L33NL33N
      @L33NL33N Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +3

      when i tell you i got no sleep that entire week

  • @aasthabisht3431
    @aasthabisht3431 Pƙed rokem +4042

    Girl you missed the Zayn and Perrie breakup I was passing out in school halls over it

    • @jimena.the.swiftie
      @jimena.the.swiftie Pƙed rokem +72

      LMFAO

    • @ia490
      @ia490 Pƙed rokem +144

      oh my god the drama surrounding their breakup!

    • @stuartblittley3531
      @stuartblittley3531 Pƙed rokem

      @@jimena.the.swiftieNOT THE PFP MATCHING HELPđŸ˜­â—ïž

    • @MISSMADISONMEDIA
      @MISSMADISONMEDIA Pƙed rokem +8

      Everyone was happy lol

    • @WeShouldStabCaesar
      @WeShouldStabCaesar Pƙed rokem +53

      Didn't Little Mix write a song about it? I have a distinct memory of a music video with a teddy bear??

  • @Smolkim20
    @Smolkim20 Pƙed rokem +4564

    I will never forget the delusion that Eleanor was not a real person and the lengths people would go to try to prove all photos of her and Louis were photoshopped 💀💀

    • @amanitamuscariatheshroom
      @amanitamuscariatheshroom Pƙed rokem +273

      The original AI

    • @julinjaz
      @julinjaz Pƙed rokem +529

      anything about eleanor is a drama. this girl was treated so bad by 1d fans for no reason.

    • @torileaann1314
      @torileaann1314 Pƙed rokem +547

      the rumor that she was a triplet and all three of them were pretending to be his girlfriend??? wild.

    • @botticellibarbie
      @botticellibarbie Pƙed rokem +303

      Not Eleanor Gretchen and Tina 😭😭😭

    • @PRM77
      @PRM77 Pƙed rokem +469

      @@julinjaz the brand of misogyny that directioners developed towards any breathing woman that approached those boys... incredible, should be taught in schools. They wouldn't just hate you and spew the worst fucking things you'll ever hear, they would go as far as denying your entire existence 💀

  • @theartiestofhoes64
    @theartiestofhoes64 Pƙed rokem +2192

    The way I had literally blacked out in my middle school cafeteria when Zayn had left the band will never be okay

    • @alexdavis360
      @alexdavis360 Pƙed rokem +90

      PLEASE-💀💀

    • @BlazeDupree1525
      @BlazeDupree1525 Pƙed rokem +196

      My school started finding out around our first period classes and by lunch every 1D fan in the school was having meltdowns and acting like the zombie apocalypse just got announced and that we would have to form a council to decide how we would live. đŸ˜­đŸ€Ł

    • @elizabethheyn5365
      @elizabethheyn5365 Pƙed rokem +69

      I will always remember the day Zayn left because it was my HS graduation day and the internet would not let me be happy about it 😆

    • @planetaryray7119
      @planetaryray7119 Pƙed rokem +1

      i was a senior in high school stoppppp

    • @naominnnnn
      @naominnnnn Pƙed rokem +34

      Girl when I tell you. My friends were waiting for me to arrive to school to give me the news bc we didn’t have wifi at home. I cried the whole day and anytime someone asked Id say „ you wouldn’t understand“

  • @summerwoodward8967
    @summerwoodward8967 Pƙed rokem +4544

    you can't forget the 2012 drama where everyone went feral over a photo of Liam w two fans and Niall in the corner starting the rumor that the fans had asked for Niall to not be in the picture. This spawned the most horrific traumatizing fanfic in existence where Niall k!lls himself in a hotel room cause "no one wanted him there" and countless hashtags in support of him....not k!lling himself?? tbh I still contemplate this time in my life sometimes

    • @toni3762
      @toni3762 Pƙed rokem +195

      NO THIS ONE. Still has me dyinggggg

    • @andre-cmyk
      @andre-cmyk Pƙed rokem +170

      WHAT THE FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK

    • @littlegirlblue6326
      @littlegirlblue6326 Pƙed rokem +252

      bro... the amount of black and white sad niall photos on tumblr that year

    • @antidave
      @antidave Pƙed rokem +40

      Stoooop this is too good 😭

    • @sophiew5117
      @sophiew5117 Pƙed rokem

      and circa Mr. X assassination plot, there were rumors that Mr. X had gotten footage of Niall either having sex or masturbating and that Mr. X was going to release it

  • @eilidhm
    @eilidhm Pƙed rokem +643

    Imagine Niall Horan crawling inside your ear. you tell him to stop but he is in there

    • @ziamfighter
      @ziamfighter Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci

      Imao what

    • @KittyCleary
      @KittyCleary Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +15

      STOP I REMEMBER THAT I COMPLETELY FORGOT THAT EXSISTED

    • @peachrie
      @peachrie Pƙed 8 měsĂ­ci +7

      THIS JUST UNLOCKED A MEMORY LMAOOOOO

    • @pennyforyourthoughts1
      @pennyforyourthoughts1 Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +3

      I LOVE YOU FOR THIS LMFAOOOOO

    • @emmalaughlin761
      @emmalaughlin761 Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +3

      This is such a deep cut

  • @michaelawoods9144
    @michaelawoods9144 Pƙed rokem +2408

    The year is 2013. You and your bestie make matching “she’s my Harry” and “she’s my Louis” crop tops to pair with suspenders and a mustache necklace for the “take me home” tour. You scream “I love you” during the moment of silence in “Moments” and Harry yells “I love you too” and TO THIS DAY you bring this up in the car while listening to Harry’s house with your partner

    • @amulyasubhash7764
      @amulyasubhash7764 Pƙed rokem +26

      đŸ„ș

    • @amairhapokala
      @amairhapokala Pƙed rokem +41

      Wholesome tbh!!

    • @BlazeDupree1525
      @BlazeDupree1525 Pƙed rokem +51

      This takes me back my crush and I had each other as Haz and Loubear in our contacts 😭

    • @floatwiththesticks
      @floatwiththesticks Pƙed rokem +22

      the moustache era omg I just had such a vivid flashback (i made me and my friends 1D primark converses and I defo drew moustaches on them😭)

    • @Link-1004
      @Link-1004 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +6

      Thank God I wasn't able to get tattoos during the mustache Era, I know I would be getting that on my index finger lmaooooo

  • @totoLP100
    @totoLP100 Pƙed rokem +2099

    Carly revealing that she's a Louis girl makes so much sense in a way but is also the most unhinged and unexpected piece of information she could've ever revealed

    • @toni3762
      @toni3762 Pƙed rokem +5

      So real

    • @maryseptihet
      @maryseptihet Pƙed rokem +146

      I have also never met a former Louis girl who isn’t bisexual which is so funny to me

    • @Dannalasapa
      @Dannalasapa Pƙed rokem

      As she should

    • @antidave
      @antidave Pƙed rokem +76

      ​@@maryseptihet true Louis fandom currently is really full of queer folks and large amount of them are lesbians đŸ€­

    • @Nicole-cb8bm
      @Nicole-cb8bm Pƙed rokem +11

      @@maryseptihet I didn’t expect this read to be so accurate rn I’m looking like 🙄

  • @marielmorenolarrinaga862
    @marielmorenolarrinaga862 Pƙed rokem +1465

    I’m a Mexican who lives in MĂ©xico, (we speak spanish) and I remember having to LEARN ENGLISH to try and understand some of this drama.

    • @ldipkin
      @ldipkin Pƙed rokem +90

      I think this might be the best comment I've read on any video ever

    • @olgam3365
      @olgam3365 Pƙed rokem +73

      Omg same, I'm from Poland and I remember trying so hard to understand what was happening on the 1d day and kinda failing but still enjoying the live

    • @sabrinebenamor9605
      @sabrinebenamor9605 Pƙed rokem +57

      I literally learnt English because the 12 yo me thought that one day I'll meet them lol

    • @EughhBrothereughh
      @EughhBrothereughh Pƙed rokem +44

      Nothing motivates to learn a foreign language more than hot tea đŸ€Ł

    • @strawberryyogurt7
      @strawberryyogurt7 Pƙed rokem +16

      literally same, one direction was the main reason why i started speaking english

  • @britnicox3929
    @britnicox3929 Pƙed rokem +869

    Honestly I don’t understand why people still ignore or undermine the power that women and girls can bring to a fandom because we will literally rewrite reality for an artist we care about

    • @Tusisvrivhing
      @Tusisvrivhing Pƙed rokem +3

      FR

    • @Hungarycloud
      @Hungarycloud Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +6

      I still remember when Voltron was cancelled because it had an unexpected number of female fans and they didn't perceive the buying power there for merchandise. Literally cancelled the show.

    • @TKDDLJ09
      @TKDDLJ09 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +9

      Right?
      Like these boys made millions upon millions. The Twilight movies made millions.
      Horses are also considered a "female" thing and horses are sold for millions as well.
      One young women had the buying power of a 1000 men. Like look at Taylor Swift, most of her audience is also female and she is making millions. đŸ€ŁđŸ€Ł
      Men must be just stupid to not realize that if you make a product that caters to young women, you will be set for life. Really sad men still run most countries.

    • @froggywithaheart
      @froggywithaheart Pƙed 8 měsĂ­ci +2

      ​@@Hungarycloudthis reminded of a video essay i watched on how shoujo genre is slowly disappearing...bc they are harder to merchandise and hence, dont make as much as shoujo.

  • @rea858
    @rea858 Pƙed rokem +359

    being a niall girl was and is so peaceful

  • @Karolina-dr8du
    @Karolina-dr8du Pƙed rokem +742

    Let’s pay homage to Mikes mic for starting this unhinged genre on yt because I really enjoy it

    • @serotoninseeker2411
      @serotoninseeker2411 Pƙed rokem +144

      Jenny Nicholson started it :)

    • @leilanyx
      @leilanyx Pƙed rokem +144

      @@serotoninseeker2411 jenny walked so mike's mic could run, and mike's mic ran so everyone else could sprint. jenny might have been the one to influence it, but mike definitely helped push it over the edge and create a whole new video genre.

    • @ellaronci2703
      @ellaronci2703 Pƙed rokem +5

      out king 🛐🛐🛐

    • @serotoninseeker2411
      @serotoninseeker2411 Pƙed rokem +6

      @@leilanyx that’s true! Hadn’t thought of it that way

    • @andreapt392
      @andreapt392 Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci

      @@serotoninseeker2411 this is a unexpected moment of wholesomeness 😂

  • @laylla7692
    @laylla7692 Pƙed rokem +376

    i remember VERY clearly one of them saying "our drummer has more followers than you" during the whole TW throw down and i don't understand why that stuck with me to this day

    • @toni3762
      @toni3762 Pƙed rokem +79

      i rememebr one of the wanted called Louis gay and Louis said he would buy tom’s mum a Jacuzzi because he couldn't

    • @angelamichelle6501
      @angelamichelle6501 Pƙed rokem +19

      I just remember that a little time after that the wanted split up and in some magazine they "said" as an excuse that "They can not compete with 1d"

    • @ziamfighter
      @ziamfighter Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +2

      @@toni3762gay is not an insult, gay is louis sexuality

    • @jadeshepherd8627
      @jadeshepherd8627 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci

      Thats what you think. Only he knows his sexuality. You've seen too many shipping videos@@ziamfighter

  • @rayana4941
    @rayana4941 Pƙed rokem +100

    Another Key moment in 2015 was Zayn VS Calvin Harris on twitter - and zayn tweeting “ so I suggest you calm your knickers, before them dentures fall out” in response to Calvin. 😭😭😭

  • @geekyglobal7542
    @geekyglobal7542 Pƙed rokem +467

    I genuinely believe that everyone with internet access who was 12-18 at the time can tell you exactly where they were when the news broke that zayn left 1D

    • @meghansullivan6812
      @meghansullivan6812 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +1

      HAHHAHA yes

    • @godisgreat10
      @godisgreat10 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +6

      I came back homefrom school, checked twitter and cried like the child I was 😂

    • @sof1675
      @sof1675 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +4

      I even remember what I ate while crying and scouring the internet for facts on my family’s desktop. I was on the phone with my best friend (at the time) and we were hysterical. Lmao, what a strange time, especially bc I wasn’t even *that* young.

    • @okay6353
      @okay6353 Pƙed 6 měsĂ­ci

      flashbulb memory fr lmao

    • @grinchizinhe
      @grinchizinhe Pƙed 3 měsĂ­ci

      yes and it was such a traumatic day

  • @Rosenrot0eme
    @Rosenrot0eme Pƙed rokem +1145

    The Larry thing was such an experience, I saw grown women who started out writing casual, fun little fanfics about everyone in the band consume one too many slowed down gif of Harry and Louis glancing in each other's general direction and they got sucked into this alternate reality with a force that I have only ever seen in right wing conspiracy theorists since.

    • @tenthousanddaysofgratitude
      @tenthousanddaysofgratitude Pƙed rokem

      It still happens to this day. I think older women might be less tech savvy and not know there is such a thing as fan FIC(tion) and believe the whole thing like it’s gospel! Try to convince them otherwise and you will be up against a militant Larry. 😂

    • @Rosenrot0eme
      @Rosenrot0eme Pƙed rokem +38

      @@tenthousanddaysofgratitude that happens too but I was thinking of people who were 20-30 and clearly had their wits about them 🙃
      And I'll never understand the urge to evangelize about these hidden queer relationships to nonbelievers. Cause I have heard (and seen) certain things as well, but I've made it a point to not talk about it on social media. If what they believe is true, aren't they just making this whole thing so much harder for their supposed idols?

    • @stuartblittley3531
      @stuartblittley3531 Pƙed rokem +94

      pls my GRANDMOTHER ships them 💀 she became a directioner in December i think and every time i think about it it deals me psychic damage because she’s just scrolling CZcams shorts and learning about 1D and shipping Larry watching those edits 😬

    • @alexrose20
      @alexrose20 Pƙed rokem +35

      ​@@stuartblittley3531 your grandmother is awesome

    • @kristen7687
      @kristen7687 Pƙed rokem +68

      someone could do an anthropological case study like the delusion was off the charts

  • @torileaann1314
    @torileaann1314 Pƙed rokem +381

    the whole “niall in japan” situation has lived in my brain every day since it’s occurred

  • @minztee0910
    @minztee0910 Pƙed rokem +1133

    It's carleys multiverse of madness and we're just living in it✹

  • @winterviveca5976
    @winterviveca5976 Pƙed rokem +595

    I was never a directioner but I read fanfiction about their struggle against alpowerful T H E M A N A G M E N T and this is how i wil imagine their beginnings forever

    • @BlazeDupree1525
      @BlazeDupree1525 Pƙed rokem +41

      Tbf their management team did suck. đŸ€·đŸ€Ł

    • @linasayshush
      @linasayshush Pƙed rokem +28

      It's concerning that I could immediately tell you weren't a fan because we never said "The" Management. It was only ever Management, and I have no idea why

    • @luzbecerra8280
      @luzbecerra8280 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +1

      @@linasayshush omg I never realized that was a thing we did!

  • @isabellazavala4424
    @isabellazavala4424 Pƙed rokem +320

    I was never a 1D fan but I will always be proud that the smoking weed incident was at my country, Peru. The iconic headline “GRINGOS FUMONES” is still as iconic as it was in 2014.

    • @MaGpeS
      @MaGpeS Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +8

      JAJAJA Gringos fumones. Me encantan la creatividad de las notas. ¥Viva Latinoamérica, carajo!

    • @TKDDLJ09
      @TKDDLJ09 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +5

      Omg, that is an amazing headline!!! đŸ€ŁđŸ€Ł

    • @audiomomento
      @audiomomento Pƙed měsĂ­cem

      PLEASE😭😭😭

  • @delaneygalvin4874
    @delaneygalvin4874 Pƙed rokem +302

    glad to know i wasn’t alone as a Louis girl
 my “not like other girls” syndrome started at an early age đŸ˜Ș

  • @-rianna
    @-rianna Pƙed rokem +664

    every time anybody brings up 1D my brain immediately goes


Niall’s crawling in your ear. you tell him to stop but he’s in there
    and that will forever be my villain origin story

  • @ladygaygay94
    @ladygaygay94 Pƙed rokem +840

    Carly we absolutely do not deserve to be fed this well on a Friday. Like thank you for the only homework I’ve ever wanted to do willingly

  • @malloryb21
    @malloryb21 Pƙed rokem +231

    i remember the day zayn left the band my whole 8th grade class found out at the end of the day me and the girlies were SOBBING like genuinely acting like a tragedy had happened

  • @malloryb21
    @malloryb21 Pƙed rokem +209

    the conchabar thing generally makes me laugh to the point of tears

    • @toni3762
      @toni3762 Pƙed rokem +1

      sameee

    • @gutierrezmaria77
      @gutierrezmaria77 Pƙed rokem +30

      She said they named him Connor. His name is Freddy Reign Tomlinson.

    • @artsyswarley
      @artsyswarley Pƙed rokem +3

      no but this part was sending me lmao

  • @hannahdigitals
    @hannahdigitals Pƙed rokem +432

    I remember watching all of this drama in real time on twitter, it feels like it was both yesterday and a lifetime ago

  • @Bubbline13
    @Bubbline13 Pƙed rokem +210

    As former Larrie, every single Larry theory, the sections of Larries, and the mental stability of Larries would make an extremely interesting video. Oh, and the fan fiction drama was insane

    • @rubykgarrett
      @rubykgarrett Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +19

      they concern me so bad. their behavior is 

. not natural

    • @Bubbline13
      @Bubbline13 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +27

      @@rubykgarrett Fr man, I remember people were loosing their shit over Louis wearing a shirt with an H💀 Not a single Larrie is mentally ok. It’s the way they treat them like characters in a TV show

    • @ziamfighter
      @ziamfighter Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +1

      @@rubykgarrett😂😂😂you’re in the wrong place then honey

    • @ziamfighter
      @ziamfighter Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +6

      @@Bubbline13imao but solo harries who sexualize Harry all the time are okay? They literally faint when they see him because they’re all in love with him and he’s there waving his pride flag but they choose to be blind 😂or solo louies who insult and trash everyone who is a larrie or a babygatler because they’re intolerant and immature 😂

    • @Bubbline13
      @Bubbline13 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +9

      @@ziamfighter never said they were never implode they were. A lot of the 1D fandom, solo or not, can be pretty toxic. Look at how many “divisions” that are fighting over who might be dating who, who’s the better split artists, who’s the best member, etc. All the disgusting signs, fan fictions, and actions of each group. That whole fandom needs to get its shit together. Nothing wrong with the artists, just the people who grovel at their feet and treat them toys

  • @enaidvalero
    @enaidvalero Pƙed rokem +557

    This was both wonderful and horrifying because i truly believe that all this mess shaped me but this has also Unlocked the memory of 17 year old harry dating a woman in her thirties 🙃

    • @winterviveca5976
      @winterviveca5976 Pƙed rokem +44

      Do I have some sort of fake memory or one of them has a baby with Cheryl Cole that was judge on the X factor?

    • @BlazeDupree1525
      @BlazeDupree1525 Pƙed rokem +43

      And then they wondered why we always thought his relationships were PR stunts đŸ€Ł

    • @ia490
      @ia490 Pƙed rokem +26

      @@winterviveca5976 that was Liam! /gen

    • @caraamethyst6956
      @caraamethyst6956 Pƙed rokem +27

      And then she went on to kill herself??? That was buckwild

    • @ziamfighter
      @ziamfighter Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +2

      Fake dating though

  • @blugreen123
    @blugreen123 Pƙed rokem +94

    The melodramatic reading of "Both Ways" had me DYING. 😂

  • @jerrika4America
    @jerrika4America Pƙed rokem +496

    Carley babe if we follow you we all were obsessed with one direction. It just goes hand in hand

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  Pƙed rokem +157

      the venn diagram of my followers and one direction fans is a circle

    • @Aelffwynn
      @Aelffwynn Pƙed rokem +23

      I was never a one direction fan. I just like random deep dives. I never watched Vampire Diaries but I've seen Jenny Nicholson's video about 50 times.

    • @_bebeboudeur_
      @_bebeboudeur_ Pƙed rokem +5

      I never cared for them but my sis did so I wanted to know what is was all about đŸ˜¶

  • @adrielkatz
    @adrielkatz Pƙed rokem +226

    i have absolutely no interest in One Direction whatsoever but i am clearing my schedule and making popcorn

  • @colourriot3520
    @colourriot3520 Pƙed rokem +96

    I was firmly in the CZcams crack and wattpad fanfic section of the fandom so I missed so much of the drama but I will forever remember 'Management' as a nebulous force for evil whose only job was to make 1D miserable

  • @maria-en2nc
    @maria-en2nc Pƙed rokem +76

    i had to get picked up from school when zayn left because i could NOT stop sobbing

  • @3bellam
    @3bellam Pƙed rokem +56

    love seeing the girlies come together in the comments to make sure ALL the drama is recognized

  • @optimistichaos9004
    @optimistichaos9004 Pƙed rokem +104

    Also the Euphoria drama! When they did an episode that featured a Larrie scene and Louis took it to Twitter.

    • @gabrielymatias3998
      @gabrielymatias3998 Pƙed rokem +17

      oh god that was so cringe... i feel sorry for louis for having to dealing with that weird rpf bullshit

    • @ellie5995
      @ellie5995 Pƙed rokem +4

      Omg genuinely wtf were they thinking with that scene

    • @lll.24601
      @lll.24601 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +3

      OH MY GOD I REMEMBER BEING SO PISSED OFF- this was when I regret shipping real life people

    • @RH-vd2uv
      @RH-vd2uv Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +1

      I cringed so bad that I just never got to watching that show lol it turned me off almost immediately

  • @highpalpss3708
    @highpalpss3708 Pƙed rokem +255

    The moment an uncarly and mikesmic collab happens is the moment the universe collapses.

    • @Onelsyd
      @Onelsyd Pƙed rokem +1

      How can we make this happen?
      I need this lol

  • @dakotamcgovern1617
    @dakotamcgovern1617 Pƙed rokem +130

    I was in so deep I wrote a poem about Zayn leaving One Direction.

    • @mofidakawam6016
      @mofidakawam6016 Pƙed rokem +2

      SAME😭

    • @mmaantj
      @mmaantj Pƙed rokem +14

      i need to read the poem for scientific purposes

    • @dianaromero9691
      @dianaromero9691 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +3

      Now that is deep !

    • @DarkUrgesandBlackRoses
      @DarkUrgesandBlackRoses Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +4

      Bruh I convinced my group of friends (who weren’t directioners) to wear black to school because I was in “mourning” & they all did without questioning it until our homeroom period that I broke the news I was mourning over Zayn leaving the band. They were all ready to kill me because they couldn’t change 💀

  • @sadem1045
    @sadem1045 Pƙed 8 měsĂ­ci +12

    Liam said that when he shared that he was in rehab, every member of One Direction reached out to him. I really admire people who are willing to show love to folks who have wronged them.

  • @ariadnekirigan9806
    @ariadnekirigan9806 Pƙed rokem +46

    Listen! I found out about the smoking weed thing from my dad on the drive home from school. The way this man was acting you would swear that Louis and Zayn were friends of mine who'd been caught doing this 😂😂. He hated that I was a directioner so for him this was vindication like "see, those boys are bad news" 💀

  • @mariahdavey8821
    @mariahdavey8821 Pƙed rokem +51

    Haylor vehicular manslaughter has always been my favourite piece of 1D lore it makes me lose my mind a little bit every time I remember it... also your dramatic rendition of that liam song belongs in a museum frankly

  • @amulyasubhash7764
    @amulyasubhash7764 Pƙed rokem +209

    I'm from India, neither white nor affluent and yet my world shattered when Zayn left. I participated in flash mob in a mall circa 2013 before midnight memories released organised by directioners in my city. This video was equally nostalgic and comedy gold

  • @graciea71
    @graciea71 Pƙed rokem +356

    CARLEY! video idea: reading men’s GQ book they can’t live without! explanation: yk how like when guys go on the “10 things they can’t live without” they suddenly all randomly read. i wanna see you struggle to read those books to see if they’re genuinely good or just for show!

  • @linn6701
    @linn6701 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +10

    Louis' response on the Zack Sang show about logan paul exploiting Liam was pretty hilarious. Louis went on to say that Liam was likely not in the right headspace and then Louis said that he hates the Paul Brothers. Iconic.

  • @vikkisgrotto
    @vikkisgrotto Pƙed rokem +261

    I know it's not really drama and the guys had nothing to do with these videos, but someone please tell me I'm not the only one who still has nightmares about the Adventurous Adventures of One Direction videos. Also what on earth was going on in the X Factor video diaries??

    • @emmyrose233
      @emmyrose233 Pƙed rokem +28

      You just unlocked a memory from the deepest, darkest depths of my mind

    • @BlazeDupree1525
      @BlazeDupree1525 Pƙed rokem +21

      Nightmares bro they came up in my yt recommend feed recently and I binged the whole series 😘👌 they are so stupid but they get better and better with age đŸ€Ł

    • @Hippolyta.
      @Hippolyta. Pƙed rokem +14

      I used to go around saying "pussy magnet" and writing it on my school folders because of AAoOO, blissfully unaware of the double entendre

    • @anninaninana1070
      @anninaninana1070 Pƙed rokem +8

      OH MY GOD MY FRIENDS AND I HAD WATCH PARTIES FOR THOSE VIDEOS 😭 we would have sleepovers, whip out the snacks and power on the projecter to watch it on the big screen alskdjg

    • @Bexab53
      @Bexab53 Pƙed rokem +1

      I HAVE LITERAL NIGHTMARES

  • @andreaferreyra1760
    @andreaferreyra1760 Pƙed rokem +49

    LETS NOT FORGET HOW HALSEY LITERALLY WAS BORN BC SHE WAS BORN IN THE HAYLOR ERA AND WROTE THE ANTI HAYLOR ANTHEM

  • @veraluta
    @veraluta Pƙed rokem +93

    we can not forget the 10 year reunion delusion. truly a scary time

    • @zbun8067
      @zbun8067 Pƙed rokem +3

      Bro we just needed to grasp onto something😭😭😭

    • @confusiyeon
      @confusiyeon Pƙed 2 měsĂ­ci

      and all we got was a website LMAO

  • @jennawos7320
    @jennawos7320 Pƙed rokem +55

    When I found out Zayn quit the band I was at a Noodles and Company and I couldn’t stop crying and now I can never eat there again

  • @evelynnsometimes2
    @evelynnsometimes2 Pƙed rokem +35

    the one direction to kpop stan pipeline is so real. whenever people talk about larry i cannot help but think of vkook who many bts fans ALSO think (or thought idk what the fandom is up to anymore) were dating and that management was keeping it secret. like the PARALLELS BBY. THE PARALLELS. history 👏 repeats 👏 itself 👏

    • @ccland844
      @ccland844 Pƙed rokem

      BTS shippers live in a very specific universe that overlaps with fans of the band but is also separate because they are usually just fetishizing and don't actually follow the band's music. So I would say there are still people who firmly believe that vkook are dating but 99.9% of the fans think that's nonsense.

    • @themagicspoon1379
      @themagicspoon1379 Pƙed rokem +4

      OMG Vkook/Taekook fans are so fucking unhinged at this point. But atleast we don't have to worry about fake dolls and fake baby rumours because there is NO WAY IN HELL that any member of BTS is going to announce a relationship or marriage/pregnancy.

  • @actuallyrubyleaf
    @actuallyrubyleaf Pƙed rokem +103

    So all of this just supports my theory that no one should become super famous below, like, at least age 20. Blowing up at a younger age just rots your brain in a very special way.

  • @my_cha
    @my_cha Pƙed rokem +235

    Oof. This was my WORLD in middle/high school. everytime there was drama it was earth shattering, its crazy how much we cared lmao. I think you've reached the height of journalism with this video, carly

  • @abigailmorgan8273
    @abigailmorgan8273 Pƙed rokem +205

    Best class I've ever attended. thank you, Ms. Carley.đŸ‘©â€đŸ«

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  Pƙed rokem +27

      anytime my faithful students

  • @dawnelle
    @dawnelle Pƙed rokem +49

    I have a vivid memory of my best friend breaking down in gym class over Zayn leaving
 and also of me trying to reassure her they’d get back together and better than before after the hiatus and my dad just completely shutting us down with “Nope, groups always say that and then never do” 😭

    • @minirth.maggie
      @minirth.maggie Pƙed 7 měsĂ­ci +1

      Dying laughing at your harsh af dad!

  • @annasutton4029
    @annasutton4029 Pƙed rokem +147

    Please do more dramatic readings of song lyrics, now THAT was art 😂

  • @anaclarasebben
    @anaclarasebben Pƙed rokem +230

    Something you didn't mentioned, the rainbow bears account (they had names but I forgot) and people speculated that it was Harry and Louis way to talk about larry because the account used to post photos with the bears using things related to the lgbt community.
    If someone remembers anything else about this, please tell me or I will think I went crazy and made this up

    • @onyxophelia3915
      @onyxophelia3915 Pƙed rokem +38

      Oh yeah that happened. It was just a tech guy who had fun taking pictures of the bears on the stages he worked on.

    • @ashleighgordon5832
      @ashleighgordon5832 Pƙed rokem +50

      not rainbow bondage bear. the trauma

    • @jimena.the.swiftie
      @jimena.the.swiftie Pƙed rokem +12

      YES. fr a lot of that still doesnt make sense to this day

    • @arisingh4747
      @arisingh4747 Pƙed rokem +4

      omfg u just unlocked a memory

    • @heartlknj
      @heartlknj Pƙed rokem +15

      the bears has a phone number that still takes voicemails to this day which is wild

  • @clairegopaul4977
    @clairegopaul4977 Pƙed rokem +65

    carley how did you know I just made a playlist this week with all of my favourite one direction songs called “I should have been taken to a specialist when I was 12”

  • @whoo227
    @whoo227 Pƙed rokem +14

    Will never forget when Liam posted that photo of him standing on the ledge of their hotel window and the fandom collectively freaked out, begging him not to jump, bc they thought it was a sign of suicidal tendencies 😭

  • @toni3762
    @toni3762 Pƙed rokem +19

    ACTUALLY THE SMKING WEED VIDEO IS THE MOST ICONIC THING THAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE 1D FANDOM IT WAS WAR!

  • @minjgoto
    @minjgoto Pƙed rokem +52

    so hard to separate the drama from wild theories but harry having six toes has a special place in my heart

  • @lila3618
    @lila3618 Pƙed rokem +60

    Carley do you remember/know about the Eleanor twin theory? I remember Louis was dating this girl Eleanor Calder and fans were speculating that she has a twin or triplets and they occasionally swap places when going on a date with Louis.

    • @doiireann
      @doiireann Pƙed rokem +8

      THIS OMG i remember there were triplets: gretchen, tina & eleanor 😭 it just sounds so silly looking back

    • @hskingdommm2597
      @hskingdommm2597 Pƙed rokem +13

      that’s definitely one of the craziest theories out there!!according to it, Eleanor had two twins: Tina and Gretchen and they all were paid by modest management to pretend to date Louis. the proof was that her hairline and nose on different photos looked differently lol.
      btw, Louis and Eleanor broke up only several months ago so she’s really been through it all with this fandom

    • @colt9836
      @colt9836 Pƙed rokem +1

      ​@@hskingdommm2597 I wonder how much hate the gfs got was internalized misogyny that the fans were projecting.
      I don't blame the fans because most of them were actual children but at some point you gotta be like, bossbabe, I don't think this is about shipping and dating anymore.

    • @hskingdommm2597
      @hskingdommm2597 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +3

      @@colt9836 yes, exactly. I don’t think you can say any of the vile things larries say about gfs without having some portion of internalized misogyny. Like what’s the deal with them calling women by animal names (elk, camel, octopus) or ascribing them other offensive titles (dogsitter, terrible mother, p*do). Interesting how most of the larries are women and (at least claim to be) queer, i.e most likely to be attracted to women, and yet, they apply any sexist stereotype to Louis’ or Harry’s girlfriends while fantasizing about their faves publicly humiliating those women. I remember how last year a larrie’s tweet which went like "if Louis punches Olivia in the face, it will be justifiable and I’ll thank him" for over 20000 likes.)

  • @anninaninana1070
    @anninaninana1070 Pƙed rokem +20

    I showed their x factor performances to my father thinking those were the best covers ive ever heard 💀 i had converted the yt videos to mp3 in horrid quality and they were part of my music library on my phone. I listened to those x factor performances every day for a couple of years

    • @sabrinebenamor9605
      @sabrinebenamor9605 Pƙed rokem +10

      I did worse: I had a Niall Horan laughing compilation as my alam ringtone in Middle school. No shame.

    • @anninaninana1070
      @anninaninana1070 Pƙed rokem +3

      @@sabrinebenamor9605 💀 oh yeah, thats tragic aldkfj i feel for you

  • @cynicalcenobia
    @cynicalcenobia Pƙed rokem +51

    Me: *Never followed 1D or actively listened to their music.*
    Also me: *Watches this video 'til the end with undivided attention.*

  • @alexdavis360
    @alexdavis360 Pƙed rokem +33

    I love how the real villain of the 1-d saga was Liam all along

  • @mathildegbaatz
    @mathildegbaatz Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +31

    i can't explain how happy i got when Liam and Zayn spoke to each other publicly a few days ago. Glad they are on good terms again.

  • @3bellam
    @3bellam Pƙed rokem +33

    Bestie, I wish I had seen four One Direction concerts. MY cross to bear is waking up knowing that I NEVER saw them in concert and NEVER will 😭😭😭

  • @honorluca
    @honorluca Pƙed rokem +23

    This was amazing! Just adding my two cents here, can we all take a moment for when 5SOS wrote 'English Love Affair' (allegedly) about Ashton's affair with Harry's sister???

  • @thejuliateresa
    @thejuliateresa Pƙed rokem +78

    I completely forgot how feral I was about One Direction. Thank you for this lesson.

  • @idabergh-smith179
    @idabergh-smith179 Pƙed rokem +99

    Was never into One Direction myself, but my best friend was a huge fan of Justin Bieber, and I remember she would just talk so much shit about One Direction because they kinda rose to fame as Justin was doing
 well, not especially great. There was like, a full-out war between the girls in my class who were Bieber-fans, and some of the younger classes that were 1D fans, it was insane

    • @someplaceovertherainbow523
      @someplaceovertherainbow523 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +3

      At my school in 2012-2015, you were either a die hard Directioner or a die hard Belieber. You could not be a fan of anyone else or like both Justin and 1D without being seen as weird 😭

    • @kelseylandon1224
      @kelseylandon1224 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +2

      For me it was kpop
      like right after Zayn left 1D so many girls switched to kpop but it was so different i could never get into it but BTS fans and 1d hated eachother for a bit
      Also i remember the JB vs 5sos fight too lol

  • @izotovuse
    @izotovuse Pƙed rokem +15

    i remember feeling so guilty that i would listen to like 2 the wanted songs bc i was a directioner, i never told anyone. it was my deepest darkest secret at the time kdksksj

  • @miko__1003
    @miko__1003 Pƙed rokem +96

    "i was a louis girl" louis girls always at the scene of the crime we love to see it đŸ” (i was a louis girl too omg)

  • @colourmeblur5569
    @colourmeblur5569 Pƙed rokem +70

    this is kinda necessary to the world as a society

  • @lianunez415
    @lianunez415 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +7

    one of the craziest things about the whole zayn & louis smoking weed thing was that a group of catholic bishops in the philippines threatened to ban one direction from touring there because they feared this would "poison the country's youth" 😭

  • @edtheturtle
    @edtheturtle Pƙed rokem +65

    I had a friend who was majorly into One Direction. When Zayne left, she took his poster off the wall and told us to use it as a doormat. I knew nothing about one direction, I'm not sure if I did what she said or not

  • @ReaganAlexis112
    @ReaganAlexis112 Pƙed 9 měsĂ­ci +4

    I think such an important moment within the haylor pr relationship drama was the NYE kiss, like girlies were truly watching that kiss video frame by frame trying to prove they were pr kissing. I remember that being such an unhinged time

  • @CheesePoutine
    @CheesePoutine Pƙed rokem +27

    I remember all of this being waaaaay more intense when it was happening ... now I'm laughing at it all

  • @witchesgetstitches9900
    @witchesgetstitches9900 Pƙed rokem +42

    One smal correction: Louis sons name is Freddie and he had it with a one night stand, I think. I also HATE that I know all this.

  • @fallisdying2077
    @fallisdying2077 Pƙed rokem +15

    "we need to save my precious baby boy from that witch" will forever be iconic

  • @evenif7431
    @evenif7431 Pƙed rokem +31

    Niall actually responded to the mic turning down rumor and laughed at the fans spreading it in 2020!

  • @willowwickertop7152
    @willowwickertop7152 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +5

    11:46 love the concept that Taylor swift would reference this horrible crime she was a part of in a fairly lighthearted song.

  • @abrielle13
    @abrielle13 Pƙed rokem +9

    I wasn't a directioner, but I remember The Great Fandom War around 2014 between swifties and directioners because one direction fans were so mad that Taylor dated Harry. Other fandoms were picking sides, too. It was wild.

  • @davidhenry7536
    @davidhenry7536 Pƙed rokem +7

    I remember the exact moment I learned Zayn left One Direction. I was in english class having just came back from Lunch (At my school if you had B lunch you would take lunch in the middle of class). And this girl got in front of the room to tell everyone "I know what just happened is difficult and effects everyone differently. I know things are going to be tough going forward. But now more than ever, we need to stick together and support each other." I thought someone had died.

  • @danid2387
    @danid2387 Pƙed rokem +9

    I’ll never forget nor will I get over that video of zayn and his two friends dancing to that usher song “that’s what it’s made for” I went feral for that as a young teen

  • @marianasaude9125
    @marianasaude9125 Pƙed rokem +18

    I loved when there was this video of Niall and Louis making a weird face while drinking from their "water bottles" on stage and Niall tweeting "Ah now I get why people are saying it ! Hahah! Me and Louis do that every night! Pretend there is something in the water bottles."

  • @danielacortes98
    @danielacortes98 Pƙed rokem +16

    I was traumatized when the documentary premiered and it was revealed to the world that Zayn and Perrie were engaged. I remember reading fanfics about Zayn leaving her for y/n, because I cried my eyes out that day and Zayn wasn't even my favorite

  • @editingfrenzy9642
    @editingfrenzy9642 Pƙed rokem +8

    girl PLEASE- 😭 the background music and rainy window while reading Liams nasty ass lyrics has me in tears đŸ˜­đŸ€Łâ˜ ïž

  • @philosofay
    @philosofay Pƙed rokem +15

    *TRIGGER WARNING* don't forget when a bunch of fans threaten to sh both when zayn smoked weed and when he left the band... I have an image of someone literally having "Zayn" cut into their arm when he left literally burnt into my brain,
    its so sad

  • @katsala918
    @katsala918 Pƙed rokem +10

    “He said *nothing* about Niall.” I died.

  • @oneofeverything9820
    @oneofeverything9820 Pƙed rokem +21

    The fact that both you and Casey Aonso put out 1D videos back to back, BLESSED 🙏

    • @samandsophia5632
      @samandsophia5632 Pƙed 23 dny

      "untapped chlamydia boy lore" is a sentence I'll never be able to wipe off my head

  • @graciousmarwisa9496
    @graciousmarwisa9496 Pƙed rokem +13

    Now it makes sense how a lot of directioners are now K-pop stand because this is the level of mess we see everyday in the K-pop world 😭😭

  • @marialuisaoliveira3002
    @marialuisaoliveira3002 Pƙed rokem +10

    GIRL MR X WAS WILDDDD I remember being on twitter and people would post stuff like “THEY FOUND A GUY WITH A GUN ON MSG” but nobody had a source or a pic or anything. This was one of the only moments when beliebers and directioners got together because Mr X was threatening Justin Bieber too?????

  • @hannahrg06
    @hannahrg06 Pƙed 10 měsĂ­ci +6

    Just to point out, Louis' mum passed away in 2016, not in 2019 as implied here which I think might have been confused with his sister's death in 2019 ❀

  • @UntilTheStarsBurnOut
    @UntilTheStarsBurnOut Pƙed rokem +73

    Maaan this unlocked some memories I forgot I had LOL
    I remember Harry dated the host of xfactor, Caroline Flack, and most ppl (rightfully) thought it was pretty creepy bc he was still a teenager and she was in her 30s?? That was some more 2011 drama
    I also remember part of the fandom getting mad (also rightfully) at Niall bc he liked a tweet that was lowkey racist against Zayn. The whole thing really highlighted how few ppl cared how much racism Zayn experienced at the time :(
    Another one was that Niall called some fans a ‘shower of cunts’ and like half the fandom was trying hard to make it seem cute bc ‘he’s Irish and that’s just what they say’ looool :’)

    • @thedarkjotun
      @thedarkjotun Pƙed rokem +5

      I literally just randomly remembered Niall calling fans that yesterday and was like omg was this for real 😂

  • @fann458
    @fann458 Pƙed rokem +5

    when zayn left one direction I was 17, I remember all this people who I've never talked to on my high school hugging me like a family member died and I remember me crying 😭

  • @Rachel-sv9pq
    @Rachel-sv9pq Pƙed rokem +76

    I followed a self-help author on twitter hoping for a little inspiration and IMAGINE MY SURPRISE when she turned out to be a vocal and active Larry. In the year 2023. Honestly I was shook. I had to block her.

    • @lulaa123
      @lulaa123 Pƙed 11 měsĂ­ci +5

      I got into Harry’s fandom more over the last year and there are SO many still active larries (also haylors, zarries and ziams, but way less). It’s infuriating.

  • @512dancergrl
    @512dancergrl Pƙed rokem +8

    You and Casey Aonso posting 1D drama videos, what a joyous occasion

  • @javabeanstudio
    @javabeanstudio Pƙed rokem +11

    I know that I am in fact a millenial, and an old one at that (33), but I didn't know that as an adult you would so actively see yourself getting old. You reading out that emoji as "millenial laughing" about crushed my soul today lmao. Just going right for the throat.

    • @lizklein2926
      @lizklein2926 Pƙed 16 dny

      Right??? Lmao im spent the rest of the vid thinking "so what do they use instead???😭😂 (and imma keep using it too lmao!!)

  • @samikshagarglove1D
    @samikshagarglove1D Pƙed 4 měsĂ­ci +2

    i cant BELIEVE you didn't mention the rainbow teddy and how much of an IMPACT it had on larries 😭😭😭😭😭