The Crusade That Could Have Destroyed the Ottomans
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 05. 2024
- In 1444 there was a clash at Varna that could have changed the course of European history. Might have saved an empire. Might have ruined another. Yet in our time it only solidified the Ottomans. What if it had gone another way?
Buckle up, because while the regular type of content will remain unchanged a new wave of content that we have tirelessly worked for is coming:
Altremer: A 10-episode alternative history narrative centered around the fourth crusade
Patreon: / altremer Exclusive access to numerous perks you will find nowhere else
Discord: A thriving community featuring contests, watch parties, quiz nights, alternative history roleplay, debate shows, writing contests and live shows!
Facebook and Instagram social media for funny memes and special interactions
Instagram ( / althisthub ) Facebook ( / alternatehistoryhub )
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
01:17 Altremer
04:25 The Ottomans In A Pickle
09:24 Europe Getting Stronger
13:45 A Stalemate
14:54 The Battle
17:27 What if It Went the Other Way?
Believe me when I say that Altremer is going to be something that you have never seen before. This is mostly due to the fact that the massive team behind it is full of talent and passion, both of which are fueled by the support of people who like to back projects like this. Those of you who decide to become the first patrons at www.patreon.com/Altremer and support the project will receive a special bonus, their names in the credits of the pilot episode and will be invited to a special watch party when the episode drops.
I hope you are as excited as I am!
This comment is too sus, lets fanum tax it
Love your videos!💚
Please do "What if humans had higher physical limits?". So essentially, as long as your training is intense enough, you can reach superhuman levels of strength, speed, durability, stamina etc, but a regular person would stay roughly the same.
Can you tell about possible crusade of 1622? That after Cossacks and Poles defeated Ottomans at Hotyn, French nobleman, Grandma of whom was from Palaelogos dynasty, organised "Order of Christian militia" with goal of restoring Byzantine empire under his rule.
Only thing that stopped him is 30 years war, when France confiscated his fleet, and death of Peter Konashevych, Cossack leader.
@@anteriax5175 true enough
This feels like a writer's attempt to create the most epic and convulated war narrative, only to end in a plot twist with the Ottomans winning. I love it
or one where Ottoman civilians rise up like the French and thus the Ottomans get a French revolution and resulting enlightenment era before Robespierre was born. Imagine Ataturk in the 15th century without the baggage of colonialism that led him to reforms which led to backlash from more orthodox Muslims.
DAMN I KNEW IT WAS A BAD IDEA TO LOOK DOWN AT THE COMMENT SECTION I DONT BLAME YOU BUT CRAAAAAP
It's called history my friend
Got to leave a cliffhanger for a sequel
Not even a plot twist, it’s a deus ex machina. Imagine the ending of Breaking Bad but Walt just keels over and dies in the cabin. That’s it, that’s the end. Everyone goes home and nothing is resolved.
Cody is making a show? Amazing! I can’t wait to see more!
Man's goin places.
A part 2 would be so interesting and captivating.
I would love to know what would happen next in this what if.
Agreed
Part 2 yes
Yes please
I feel like the turke are gonna return during the rise of thr safavids.
The Balkan wars would be fun to talk about in this AU
As a Pole it's weird seeing Władysław Warneńczyk having a role in AltHistory. Especialy since his younge Brother Kazimierz Jaggielończyk is seen as more active and competent then his brother as he focused on finnaly getting rid of Teutonic Problem.
every where I go homestuck finds me
I have to disagree. Kazimierz is more important for his domestic policy, than winning a war that was impossible to lose. One has to remember that the Thirteen Years' War was very much a sequel to the Great War (1409-1411). That war broke the Order, it was bankrupt, with massive manpower shortage, and ravaged contryside. Over the coming years succesive conflicts and diplomatic manoeuvring, while not accomplishing all of Polish goals, allowed Jagiełło to take back virtually all concessions that he made to the Order in Peace of Thorn.
On the other hand, the Order had to raise taxes, which led to resistance from the burghers. That would become the sign of things to come, as Prussian cities started to organise themselves in a leauge, aimed at curtailing the power of the Order. In fact, the Thirteen Years' War begin as a civil war in the State of the Teutonic Order. Poland-Lithuania only intervened when Prussian cities petitioned the Crown for incorporation, and provided massive monetary support for the war effort. They would come out as winners of the conflict, gaining not only autonomy under Polish rule, but aslo becoming only citites in Poland to elect representatives to Sejm, a sign of their importance.
The poor shape of the Order can be summaried in the "fall" of Malbork. The biggest castle in the world, unconquered throughout the Polish-Teutonic wars, finally came into Polish hands, because the mercenaries were given the castle in lieu of payment and, after negotiations, agreed to sell the castle to the Poles, for money which was given to the Crown as a loan by burghers of Gdańsk for war effort.
Casimir IV Jagiellon ruled Poland for 45 years, while he was extremely successful administrator just by sheer length of his rule he would have bigger impact on Poland and Lithuania. While Władysław III ruler Poland only for 10 year (while he was Supreme Duke of Lithuania, the effective rule of Lithuania was given to Casimir), he become King of Poland as 10 year old child (so in the beginning he has not have such active role) and aged 16, when he would usually real start to use his powers, he was elected king of Hungary (and also Bohemia, but Bohemia was in civil war) and spend rest of his short life outside of Poland, either trying to secure Bohemian crown or fighting the Ottomans. If Władysław III would win the Battle for Warna, and manage to create stable union of Poland, Lithuania, Bohemia, Hungary and Croatia, he would probably one of the most impactful kings in European history. He had all the pieces to create an European hegemon (assuming he would secure succession in all 5 states, even if the Union would be loose, but one supreme monarch responsible for the foreign affairs would be enough to create almost untouchable block; and winning a Crusade would give Władysław all the glory and prestige to pull if through).
@@Hadar1991 Oh, I don't disagree, just point out, that regardless of who would be the King, that war would be a victory. The difference between Kazimierz and Władysław would come to how they would carry out their respective domestic and foreign policies.
@@mateuszchoda5560 Actually Casimir tried to rebuild his brother empire with dynastic policy and I don't think they would differe very much in terms of policies. But Casimir seems more levelheaded than Władysław (although those were the times where the prestige and glory of the rulers was extremely important and if Władysław would win his the crusade he could probably force more reforms with his prestige alone than Casimir ever could with his levelheadness)
“If you are the Sultan, come here and lead your armies. If I am the Sultan, I hereby order you to come here and lead my armies.”
My man is 12 years old and talking to his dad like that. Badass.
AlternateHistory going from a month of no uploads to 2 uploads in 2 days is a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one
But what about the attack on the Wookiees?
Most unoriginal comment of all time goes to HeisenbergFam
@@balabanasireti Yeah, because it's probably a bot. I see this little bullsheisserin everywhere, and it never replies to replies or edits its' comments. I don't think it replicates other peoples' comments like most, but it's certainly not alive
@@FelidaeEnjoyerI don't think it's a bot, but more likely something where a bunch of people who spend way too much time on CZcams who use the same account and just say random somewhat related stuff to a bunch of videos for internet clout
Once the comment has been made it's just left there
@@IDKisReal2401 Possible, it'd just have to be a LOT of people involved considering they'd need to pay for the internet and food and such, either by having people near to them do it or every single one of them only spend like 4-6 hours on here
Footnote: The Hungarians and their allies quickly returned to the crusade after meeting all of the treaty's short-term stipulations. An army mostly consisting of regular Hungarian soldiers as well as men from Poland and Transylvania was assembled by King Władysław.
In the Nicopolis region, 4,000 Wallachians joined the 16,000-strong united army.
The two armies engaged in combat in the Battle of Varna on November 10, 1444, close to the Bulgarian Black Sea citadel of Varna.
And then europa universalis 4 was developed
@@rodolagoac238 Indeed
And also lost.
16:10 “He had the broken treaty nailed to the banners of his army”
Gigachad move
Not the first to do it though. I remember that a bulgarian tzar did it after the eastern roman empire attacked them. Can't remember who did it. (sorry if my English isn't perfect)
Advanced shaming, if I’ve ever heard of it.
I'd like to see a video on if Timur's ambitions for conquering China had been realised and the consequences of it, along with if Timur had not existed!
History altering stuff, indeed
@@DualArrow88 👍🏻
Wasn't Timur Ruling in Persia? How would he ever conquer China? There's a vast desert and a buttload of mountains in the way! Governing China from persia, let alone get a single army over, would be next to impossible, if not completely impossible!
@@wires-sl7gs Genghis Khan was able to do so a century or so back. It's not realistic, but it's interesting nonetheless.
Conversely the very same mountains and deserts make it hard for China to send troop to defend their west front
Two alternate history videos in a week? Christmas indeed came early.
Thanks Cody.
Satisfactory
Possible idea for a what if scenario: what if there was gold on the east coast of North America?
What I learned in my US History class was that Europeans originally came to North America for gold but they didn't find any, but what if there was?
The Spanish would have fought the English much harder to hold onto the area than they did.
interesting
The United States would be more like Latin America, as early discovery of gold would allow the colonial elites to disregard the desires of their colonial subjects
@@alehaim Sounds like a terrible time.
There actually was gold found on the Eastern Seaboard, but not until the early 1800s, and it was somewhat inland.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carolina_Gold_Rush
Funny enough, Brazilian Mapping made an entire series on what if this crusade succeeded.
its like 8 hours of content, its good tho
Omg it the guy from Vologda mapping and APOT
Certified J moment
@@zidium guh?
Ahhh yes. November 10, 1444... The day before EU4's start!
I learned more about the early modern period from looking up EU4 stuff than in school
Tbf school teaches jackshit about the early modern period
Today's Fact: In 2011, a man in California found a 5.75-carat diamond while digging for gold in a state park.
Damn bro is lucky
ok
Todays fact:
Every single day a different person will have the worlds largest
💩
Bro is luckier then the ones actually tryna find gold in California 2 centuries ago lol
The gold rush is real...
Absolutely a part 2 is warranted, especially considering the personalities involved.
+1
He's doing a vote for what video should get a part 2 rn.
One Immediate effect I can imagine is that the Church is United, under Rome.
Though I am 30 seconds in. I expect that it’s mentioned. Thanks for Atlantropa Articles Cody. Keep it up 👍
But maybe some Orthodox Patriarchs wouldn't accept the authority of Rome, creating many new autonomous churches (e.g. the church of Moscow, the church of Kyiv)
true, though they would be incredibly small, and *ever-dwindling*@@thenamesianna
2:50 that "For thr Republic" and "For the Empire" gave me some OG Battlefront 2 flashbacks. Feels like im back in the 501st
I really love how this videos switched up styles! Keep it up, Cody! (Also please make a part 2)
Yo Aurelian!
It sucks. Literally it’s way more confusing and the production quality is way worse and more like his really old videos
Sensational work team! I'm delighted to be working with you on this, and I'm really impressed at how it all came together.
this is truly a veritasetcaritas moment
Make sure Nubia and Ethiopia are well included in the series.
@@ikengaspirit3063 I just do the medieval European history. They have different script writers for different topics.
@@veritasetcaritas eh, okay. I guess they could always hit up the guy that does African History Extra for Nubian and Ethiopian relations with the Near East and Europe.
@@PakBallandSamiCringe
It's always a pleasure to see a what if" scenario where The Roman Empire survives longer.
Fun fact of the day: Finland got its independence on the same day that the Halifax explosion happened.
Going out with a bang
I was wondering why we got less videos lately and I’m so glad to see the altermer project. I can’t wait to watch
This video was AMAZING. Please make a part 2!
This is great! Would love to see this turned into a series, since this is my favorite period of history.
Actually, someone should make an EU4 mod with the scenario at the end of the video
Can’t wait to see your new show!
Altremer is such a hype name
Awesome start for team Altremer, Looking forward to more from you guys!
As a Bulgarian i would love if this scenario had happened in real life :) Some of the descendants of the last czars of Bulgaria had taken part in the 1444 crusade so if it was successful Bulgarian state could be restored. Part 2 sure will be interesting. If some of the Byzantine successor states like Trabizon and Morea continue to exist past the mid 15 century this will also have interesting consequences. Keep up the good work Cody! Greetings from Bulgaria!
Yeah but john hunyadi had already been promised the throne of Bulgaria
Please do a Part II. This whole situation is so, so cool and I’d love to hear more about it
Pleeeease go for the part two. I can't even imagine how fun would the continuation be!! great work as always
Awesome video! And can't wait to explore Altremer with everyone!
Oh gosh, I’m so hyped. Not only one of my favorite time periods being talked about in this video, but an actual series being made too? I’m so happy Cody, this is great! I’m looking forward to a part two and to Altremer!!!
Jesus Cody, the upload schedule is insane
This is the classic alternate history hub I remember! Lets go part 2! 🙏🏻
Part 2 sounds great to me, love you work :)
Please make a part 2, this scenario seems pretty interesting!
Agreed!
I’m very exited to see an alternate history show, especially on such an interesting topic.
I know that your more known for your what if history vids but I’m really liking these non speculative history videos. Keep ‘em coming 👍👍
Looking forward to Altremer! Seems like fun.
Another interesting video as always. Also, I absolutely love the trailer for your new series!
Until 1569 th Lublin Union I wouldn’t consider Poland and Lithuania the same state. Heck until 1430 the ruler of Lithuania was different from Polish king (he was king’s cousin and officially a vassal acting as king’s regent in the Grand Duchy, since personal union did exist) until his death in 1430.
And even after Lublin the GDL was as separate as Scotland inside the UK, hell, Lithuania had even more autonomy than modern day Scotland.
@@Vitalis94 Tiesą sakai (for english speakers: True)
@@xenamorphwinner7931 Cheers! (I really don't get why am mistaken from the Lithuanian all the time, must be the "is" ending in my nickname :P
I do learn Prussian at the moment, and do come from, let's say, historically Baltic area of Poland, so it's not like I don't adore my Lithuanian brothers. :D
@@Vitalis94 your username is an actual name in Lithuania, which is primarily prevalent among older people.
@@xenamorphwinner7931 Interesting. Must be a very old name, because I looked it up some time ago, and couldn't find anything but like 3 Lithuanian guys in Wikipedia. :P
Awesome video!!
Please do a part 2 it's vary interesting!
one of your best vids man look forward to the show!
A great introduction to the history of the region at the time, the crusade and the "what if". Thank you!
"They embarked on many crusades, some of which almost didn't fail."
Nice. Looking forward to a lot of alternate history.
Thanks you for making 2 videos so quickly
Part 3 is very welcome. Also that trailer gave me goose bumps
Altremer and this video is exactly what I’ve been looking for in alternate history! Amazing video! Please do a part two
Great video! I knew very little of these conflicts. Will need to catch up on history now and read a few books.
Excellent video. Waiting for part 2.....
This was an interesting video. And the trailer foe the series looked epic. K can't wait until it's released
Two alternate history hub videos in a week? It's a damn Christmas miracle!
I really hope you make this a series or that we at least get a part 2, this is very interesting
I love it, I hope you make a part 2
Please do a part two!
Also the context you gave was very good! (I am from Thessaloniki!)
Same
1:17, Idk why but at first I thought your trailer was some kind of EU4 ad! 😅
I don't know, I think just the aesthetics were very similar. But cool show nonetheless! Excited to see it when it comes out!
such an excellent video, very interesting, need more videos like this (especially in this period!)
That map at the end looks so cool honestly. Can't wait to see part 2.
Looking forward to seeing a sequel to this, so many ways it can go and so many ripples in history.
That trailer was amazing!!!
Now Cody, you're just teasing us. Eagerly awaiting part 2!
W on the series, looking forward to it
Holy SHIT! I am hype. I had chills all throughout that trailer! Bravo, sir, bravo!
I thought that whole trailer was a sponsor spot for a new Crusader's Kings like game.
You should definitely make a part 2 it would be interesting
Part two this. Really enjoyed it
A vid on if the Sino-Soviet split never happened or was patched up in the 70s would be so kino
Sup my man
@@sergioventura2595 as always
@@conserva-chan2735 How you’ve been?
@sergioventura2595 pretty good, I have a GF now
@@conserva-chan2735 Congrats!
yeah I wonder what would have happened
Blud thinks he can take my crown
Damnit Cody. Why do your videos always kick so much ass. Keep up the good work boss
Absolutely part 2! This is really interesting
That "FOR THE REPUBLIC!" got me.
What a fun and exciting video you made, Cody. I didn't know you made a show, and I can't wait to see it when it is released on December 8th. And I would love to see a part two where the Byzantines do a Reconquista on Antonilla and unify them under their banner. And maybe having Byzantines discover black powder and trade with China and India conquer Persia would be awesome to see for part two. Anyway, I can't see this show because I know it will be awesome!
You can't see the show because you know it will be awesome?
This looks amazing!
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
It’s often something I’ve noticed about medieval nobility especially Frankish nobility. They were often too brave and chivalrous, to a fault would be a fair way to describe their actions. Brave to a fault. All to often fighting when it’s was suicidal. Władysław III was the last in a long line of failed knightly charges (though not a frank).
Off the top of my head
Battle of Harran (1104)
Siege of Damascus (1148)
Battle of Hattin (1187)
Battle of Mansurah (1221)
All examples of battle that could have been victories but advice was ignored and they fought when they should have held their ground or withdrawn. Instead they charged and were all defeated. But that’s why we love knights. Brave to a fault. They needed a strong leader to stop them doing something stupid. Like King Richard I at the battle of Arsuf (1191).
The problem starts, when your king is more of a knight than any other present and wants to risk his life that way.
Looks like your maps got an upgrade, great work on the video, although you might have have used the wrong picture of Elizabeth (I think you're referring to Elizabeth of Luxembourg, daughter of king Sigismund and wife of Albert, who gave birth the the king that succeeded Wladyslaw, Ladislaus the Posthumous, but the image is that of her daughter Elizabeth, who married Wladyslaw's brother Casimir Jagiellon), can't wait for a Part 2 with all these gigachads of Hunyadi, Stephen, Constantine, Skanderbeg, and Vlad duking it out for the Balkans
Yes PLEASE part 2 I’m so excited
Right on another video from Cody of the Alternate History Hub
Is it just me or has the quality of these videos increased? I mean they were always good, but there seems to be a massive improvement here.
Please don't add mouths to the characters, it looks very cursed
Great introduction lol felt like the start of a walk polished peice 😊
PLEASE DO A PART 2!!!
CODY WHAT THE FUCK
THE ALTREMER TRAILER IS FUCKING KILLING ME I WAS LOSING MY MIND
Let's do a part 2
Love your work so much, dude.
My daughter is old enough now that I can explain 'history' vs History.
Your stuff is a great teaching aid.
Its pleasing to witness your growth as a person and content creator since the early days.
Your wacko hand wavy theories of what would happen to one part of the world if the other (west) did a or b, was maddening.
First a book, now you're making a fucking SHOW?! Cody, i'm so proud of you!
Part II please.
Holy fuck that trailer was rad as fuck
I extremely enjoyed this episode. I love it when you do these time periods. Maybe do one on the Baltic crusade and the rise of Prussia as a state. Or maybe do a video on the Iron Harvest game timeliness. I've been a long-time subscriber and fan of this channel. Love what you do.
im really looking forward to seeing that show it looks awesome
I would watch 6 seasons and a movie of this show
The show looks better and more interesting than a lot of professional movies
Not surprising, when most modern "history" movies and tv series are most focused on pushing political agenda and rewriting history.
It's made by people who actually love history
More accurate than Napoleon
Hollywood is woke this days.
Contents like this here have done their research.
Part 2? Let's F-ing GOOOOOOO!!!!
I was just going down a rabbit hole about this
So good shit cody
While you are doing medieval scenarios, I was wondering if I could suggest a scenario where the Angevin Empire never lost Normandy (i.e If Richard the Lionheart lived longer or one of his two older brothers (Henry or Geoffrey) became king).
I have reasons to believe Cody kidnapped a woman for the show…
Your community post popped up before the video!
I cant wait to watch the show!